PLANNING DEPARTMENT. Executive Summary. Conditional Use HEARING DATE: MAY 13, 2010

Transcription

1 SAN FRANCISCO PLANNING DEPARTMENT Date: Case No.: Project Address: Zonng: Block/Lot: Project Sponsors: Staff Contact: Recommendaton: Executve Summary Condtonal Use HEARING DATE: MAY 13, 2010 May 6, C 200 FILLMORE STREET NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct 40-X Heght and Bulk Dstrct 0859/020 Bl Maher (agent) 433 Waller Street San Francsco, CA Mustapha Hakkou (applcant) 2445 Flmore Street San Francsco, CA Sharon M. Young - (415) sharon.m. young@sfgov.org Approval wth Condtons 1650 Msson S1. Sute 400 San Francsco. CA Recepton: Fax: L : Plannng Informaton: PROJECT DESCRIPTION The proposal s a request for Condtonal Use authorzaton under Sectons , 303, and 186.1(b)(1) of the Plannng Code to allow an "other entertanment" use wthn an exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant dba Café Du Solel located on the ground floor of the two-story resdental and commercal buldng wthn an NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct and a 40-X Heght and Bulk Dstrct. The proposal wl nvolve addng the performance of nonamplfed muscal entertanment (jazz) and poetry readng to the exstng restaurant between the hours of 6 p.m. and 10 p.m. Thursday through Saturday and between the hours of 12 p.m. and 9 p.m. on Sunday. (The applcant's orgnal proposal for "other entertanment" use on the premses was between the hours of 6 p.m. and 11 p.m. on Frday and Saturday.) There wl be no tenant mprovements made wthn the exstng commercal space or any changes made to the exstng buldng envelope. SITE DESCRIPTION AND PRESENT USE The Project Ste at 200 Flmore Street s located on the northeast comer of Flmore and Waller Streets; Assessor's Block 0859; Lot 020. It s located n an NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct and a 40-X Heght and Bulk Dstrct. The subject lot s 3,114 square-feet (35.59 feet wde by feet deep) n sze and s occuped by a two-story resdental and commercal buldng bult crca The exstng buldng s lsted n the Plannng Department's 1976 Archtectural Survey as havng archtectural sgnfcance and s ncluded wthn the Halley Valley Survey area. The exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant (dba Café Du Solel) occupes commercal tenant space on the ground floor of the buldng. ww.sfplannìng.org

2 Executve Summary Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street SURROUNDING PROPERTIES & NEIGHBORHOOD The surroundng development conssts of a varety of mxed-use buldngs featurng resdental uses above ground-floor commercal establshments. The scale of development n the area conssts prmarly of lowrse buldngs (prmarly two- to three-story strctures wth a few one and four story structures), some of whch were bult n the early 1900s. Generally, the commercal establshments characterzng ths porton of Flmore Street nclude a mxture of restaurants, specalty shops, and a general merchandse/drug store. Some of the exstng commercal establshments nclude Health Wse For Pets, Thep Phanom, Indan Oven, Squat & Gobble, Zp Zap Har, Upper Playground Flowers on Flmore, Estela's Sandwches, and Ffty 24 SF Gallery. The surroundng zonng s NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct, NC-2 (Small- Scale Neghborhood Commercal) Dstrct, RH-3 (Resdental, House, Three-Famly) Dstrct. The block of Haght Street, whch has a number of commercal establshments, s located one block north of the Project Ste. L : ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW The proposed project was determned by the San Francsco Plannng Department to be categorcally exempt from envronmental revew, under Class l(a) of the State CEQA Gudelnes, Secton 15301, pursuant to Ttle 14 of the Calforna Admnstratve Code. HEARING NOTIFICATION TYPE REQUIRED REQUIRED ACTUAL ACTUAL PERIOD NOTICE DATE NOTICE DATE PERIOD Classfed News Ad 20 days Aprl 23, 2010 Aprl 23, days Posted Notce 20 days Aprl 23, 2010 Aprl 23, days Maled Notce 20 days Aprl 23, 2010 Aprl 23, days PUBLIC COMMENT. As of May 6, 2010, the Department has receved one phone call (Valle Brown) expressng concerns regardng the proposed hours of operaton and ts potental nose mpacts to the resdents wthn the surroundng neghborhood. The project applcant's agent has snce contacted Ms. Brown wth regard to her concerns. In response to these concerns, the project applcant's agent has ndcated that the applcant would lke to modfy the proposed hours of operaton on Frday and Saturday from 6 p.m. to 11 p.m. to 6 p.m. to 10 p.m. The Department has also receved two letters n opposton to the proposal from adjacent resdents (Phl Horowtz and Jmmy Terrell) concerned about the nose that may emt from the proposed entertanment use snce there are no nteror modfcatons to nclude acoustcal soundproofng n the proposal. The project applcant's agent has contacted the San Francsco Polce Department (Northern Staton) wth regard to the proposal and has submtted a petton wth over 600 sgnatures from customers of the restaurant (whch ncludes approxmately 500 sgnatures from neghbors) who ndcated ther support for addng entertanment (.e. jazz and poetry readngs) to the premses. SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPARMEN 2

3 Executve Summary Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street ISSUES AND OTHER CONSIDERATIONS The exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant dba Café Du Sole, whch was establshed snce 2006, s ndependently owned and s not consdered a formula retal use under Secton of the Plannng Code.. The project applcant's agent has ndcated that the restaurant (café) has been open for several years and has the support of nnumerable neghbors (over 500 sgnatures on the petton). The café has had sdewalk tables and chars for the last few years wth no apparent problems. Accordng to the project applcant's agent, the proposed "other entertanment" use wl provde for a more "lad back" alternatve venue than the many venues for late nght drnkng and entertanment exstng on Haght Street, located approxmately one block from the Project Ste. : The project applcant's agent has ndcated that the proposed project wl nvolve no physcal remodelng of the premses and requres nothng more than movng a few tables durng the weekends. The restaurant currently has tables and seats nsde to accommodate 60 people wth permtted sdewalk café tables and seats for approxmately 20 more people. No permanent stage or structure wl be requred. The project applcant's agent has ndcated that the exstng restaurant s well establshed n the communty n whch the majorty of the clentele are local resdents who walk or bke to the establshment and a small number take publc transt from the adjacent Hayes Valley and Castro neghborhoods. In addton, some of the clentele are toursts (prmarly European vstors to the Cty). REQUIRED COMMISSION ACTION Ths proposal requres Condtonal Use authorzaton pursuant to Sectons , 303, and 186.1(b)(1) of the Plannng Code to allow an "other entertanment" use wthn an exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant dba Café Du Solel located on the ground floor of the two-story resdental and commercal buldng wthn an NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct and a 40-X Heght and Bulk Dstrct. BASIS FOR RECOMMENDATION The proposed project would further enhance an exstng ndependently-owned, neghborhood servng restaurant and would help further ensure the restaurant's success at ts current locaton by attractng customers seekng an entertanment venue for poetry readng and nonamplfed muscal entertanment. The proposed project meets all applcable requrements of the Plannng Code. The Department beleves that ths project s necessary and/or desrable for the followng reasons: a) The proposed project wl enhance the economc dversty of the neghborhood by allowng the establshment of a new entertanment use n the area. b) The proposed project s a neghborhood-servng use whch local resdents can access by walkng or takng publc transt. SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPARMEN 3

4 Executve Summary Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street c) The proposed project s consstent wth the mxed commercal-resdental character of ths porton of the NC-1 Dstrct. RECOMMENDA non: A roval wth Condtons Attachments: Zonng Dstrct Map Parcel Map Sanborn Map Aeral Photographs Ste and Context Photographs Reduced Plans õ- ;. E Attachment Checklst Executve Summary ~ Project sponsor submttal ~ Draft Moton Drawngs: Exstng Condtons D Envronmental Determnaton ~ Check for legblty ~ Zonng Dstrct Map Drawngs: Proposed Project D Heght & Bulk Map D Check for legblty ~ Parcel Map ~ Project sponsor's petton ~ Sanborn ~ Aeral Photo D ~ Context Photos D ~ Ste Photos D Map D Exhbts above marked wth an "X" are ncluded n ths packet PI~~lta, SMY: C:1200 Flmore St- summary-smy.doc SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPARTENT 4

5 SAN FRANCISCO PLANNING DEPARTMENT Subject to: (Select only f applcable) D Inclusonary Housng (Sec. 315) D Jobs Housng Lnkage Program (Sec. 313) D Downtown Park Fee (Sec. 139) Date: Case No.: D Frst Source Hrng (Admn. Code) D Chld Care Requrement (Sec. 314) D Other Plannng Commsson Moton No. HEARING DATE: MAY 13, 2010 Project Address: Zonng: Block/Lot: Project Sponsors: Staff Contact: May 6, C 200 FILLMORE STREET NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct 40-X Heght and Bulk Dstrct 0859/020 Bl Maher (agent) 433 Waller Street San Francsco, CA Mustapha Hakkou (applcant) 2445 Flmore Street San Francsco, CA Sharon M. Young - (415) sharon.m.young@sfgov.org 1650 Msson SI. Sute 400 San Francsco. CA Recepton: Fax: t= = Plannng Informaton: ADOPTING FINDINGS RELATED TO THE APPROVAL OF A CONDITIONAL USE AUTHORIZATION UNDER PLANNING CODE SECTIONS , 303, AND 186.1(b)(1) OF THE PLANNING CODE TO ALLOW AN "OTHER ENTERTAINMENT" USE WITHIN AN EXISTING LEGAL NONCONFORMING LARGE FAST FOOD RESTAURANT DBA CAFÉ DU SOLEIL AT 200 FILLMORE STREET WITHIN AN NC-l (NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL CLUSTER) DISTRICT AND 40-X HEIGHT AND BULK DISTRICT. PREAMBLE On February 9, 2010, Bl Maher actng agent on behalf of Mustapha Hakkou (herenafter "Project Sponsor") made an applcaton for Condtonal Use authorzaton for the property at 200 Flmore Street, Lot 020 n Assessor's Block 0859 (herenafter "Subject Property") to allow an "other entertanment" use wthn an exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant wth approxmately 1,200 square feet of floor area dba Café Du Solel, located on the ground floor of the two-story resdental and commercal buldng wthn an NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct and a 40-X Heght and Bulk Dstrct, n general conformty wth plans dated February 26, 2010 and labeled "Exhbt B" (herenafter "Project"). ww.sfplannng.org

6 Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street On May 13, 2010, the San Francsco Plannng Commsson (herenafter "Commsson") conducted a duly notced publc hearng at a regularly scheduled meetng on Condtonal Use Applcaton No C. Under Sectons , 303, and 186.1(b)(1) of the Plannng Code, Condtonal Use authorzaton s requred to allow an "other entertanment' use wthn an exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant dba Café Du Solel wthn an NC-1 Dstrct. The proposal wl nvolve addng muscal entertanment and poetry readng to the exstng restaurant between the hours of 6 p.m. and 10 p.m. Thursday through Saturday and between the hours of 12 p.m. and 9 p.m. on Sunday. Pursuant to the Gudelnes of the State Secretary of Resources for the mplementaton of the Calforna Envronmental Qualty Act (herenafter "CEQA"), the Plannng Department of the Cty and County of San Francsco (herenafter "Department") determned that the proposed Condtonal Use Applcaton was categorcally exempt from the envronmental revew process under Class l(a) of the State CEQA Gudelnes, Secton 15301, pursuant to Ttle 14 of the Calforna Admnstratve Code. The Commsson has revewed and concurs wth sad determnaton. L: E The Commsson has heard and consdered the testmony presented to t at the publc hearng and has further consdered wrtten materals and oral testmony presented on behalf of the applcant, Department staff, and other nterested partes. MOVED, that the Commsson hereby authorzes the Condtonal Use requested n Applcaton No C, subject to the condtons contaned n "EXHIBIT A" of ths moton, based on the followng fndngs: FINDINGS Havng revewed the materals dentfed n the rectals above, and havng heard all testmony and arguments, ths Commsson fnds, concludes, and determnes as follows: 1. The above rectals are accurate and consttute fndngs of ths Commsson. 2. Ste Descrpton and Present Use. The Project Ste at 200 Flmore Street s located on the northeast comer of Flmore and Waller Streets; Assessor's Block 0859; Lot 020. It s located n an NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct and a 40-X Heght and Bulk Dstrct. The subject lot s 3,114 square-feet (35.59 feet wde by feet deep) n sze and s occuped by a two-story resdental and commercal buldng bult crca The exstng buldng s lsted n the Plannng Departments 1976 Archtectural Survey as havng archtectural sgnfcance and s ncluded wthn the Halley Valley Survey area. The exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant (dba Café Du Solel) occupes commercal tenant space on the ground floor of the buldng. 3. Surroundng Propertes and Neghborhood. The surroundng development conssts of a varety of mxed-use buldngs featurng resdental uses above ground-floor commercal establshments. The scale of development n the area conssts prmarly of low-rse buldngs (prmarly two- to three-story structures wth a few one and four story structures), some of whch were bult n the SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPAREN 2

7 Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street early 1900s. Generally, the commercal establshments characterzng ths porton of Flmore Street nclude a mxture of restaurants, specalty shops, and a general merchandse/drug store. Some of the exstng commercal establshments nclude Health Wse For Pets, Thep Phanom, Indan Oven, Squat & Gobble, Zp Zap Har, Upper Playground Flowers on Flmore, Estela's Sandwches, and Ffty 24 SF Gallery. The surroundng zonng s NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct, NC-2 (Small-Scale Neghborhood Commercal) Dstrct, RH-3 (Resdental, House, Three-Famly) Dstrct. The block of Haght Street, whch has a number of commercal establshments, s located one block north of the Project Ste. = 4. Project Descrpton. The proposal s a request for Condtonal Use authorzaton under Sectons , 303, and 186.1(b)(1) of the Plannng Code to allow an "other entertanment" use wthn an exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant dba Café Du Solellocated on the ground floor of the two-story resdental and commercal buldng wthn an NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct and a 40-X Heght and Bulk Dstrct. The proposal wl nvolve addng the performance of nonamplfed muscal entertanment Gazz) and poetry readng to the exstng restaurant between the hours of 6 p.m. and 10 p.m. Thursday through Saturday and between the hours of 12 p.m. and 9 p.m. on Sunday. (The applcants orgnal proposal for "other entertanment' use on the premses was between the hours of 6 p.m. and 11 p.m. on Frday and Saturday.) There wl be no tenant mprovements made wthn the exstng commercal space or any changes made to the exstng buldng envelope. 5. Issues and Other Consderatons. The exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant dba Café Du Solel, whch was establshed snce 2006, s ndependently owned and s not consdered a formula retal use under Secton of the Plannng Code. The project applcants agent has ndcated that the restaurant (café) has been open for several years and has the support of nnumerable neghbors (over 500 sgnatures on the petton). The café has had sdewalk tables and chars for the last few years wth no apparent problems. Accordng to the project applcants agent, the proposed "other entertanment" use wl provde for a more "lad back" alternatve venue than the many venues for late nght drnkng and entertanment exstng on Haght Street, located approxmately one block from the Project Ste. The project applcants agent has ndcated that the proposed project wl nvolve no physcal remodelng of the premses and requres nothng more than movng a few tables durng the weekends. The restaurant currently has tables and seats nsde to accommodate 60 people wth permtted sdewalk café tables and seats for approxmately 20 more people. No permanent stage or structure wl be requred. The project applcants agent has ndcated that the exstng restaurant s well establshed n the communty n whch the majorty of the clentele are local resdents who walk or SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPARMEN 3

8 Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street bke to the establshment and a small number take publc transt from the adjacent Hayes Valley and Castro neghborhoods. In addton, some of the clentele are toursts (prmarly European vstors to the Cty). 6. Publc Comment. As of May 6, 2010, the Department has receved one phone call (Valle Brown) expressng concerns regardng the proposed hours of operaton and ts potental nose mpacts to the resdents wthn the surroundng neghborhood. The project applcants agent has snce contacted Ms. Brown wth regard to her concerns. In response to these concerns, the project applcants agent has ndcated that the applcant would lke to modfy the proposed hours of operaton on Frday and Saturday from 6 p.m. to 11 p.m. to 6 p.m. to 10 p.m. The Department has also receved two letters n opposton to the proposal from adjacent resdents (Phl Horowtz and Jmmy Terrell) concerned about the nose that may emt from the proposed entertanment use snce there are no nteror modfcatons to nclude acoustcal soundproofng n the proposal. The project applcants agent has contacted the San Francsco Polce Department (Northern Staton) wth regard to the proposal and has submtted a petton wth over 600 sgnatures from customers of the restaurant (whch ncludes approxmately 500 sgnatures from neghbors) who ndcated ther support for addng entertanment (.e. jazz and poetry readngs) to the premses. t: = 7. Use Dstrct. For the purposes of ths acton, the project ste s wthn the NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Zonng Dstrct. The NC-1 Zonng Dstrct s located on Flmore Street on the northeast comer of Flmore and Waller Streets n the Western Addton Neghborhood. NC-1 Zonng Dstrcts are characterzed by ther locaton n resdental neghborhoods, often n outlyng areas of the Cty. The commercal ntensty of these dstrcts vares. Many of these dstrcts have the lowest ntensty of development n the Cty, generally consstng of small clusters wth three or more commercal establshments, commonly grouped around a comer; and n some cases short lnear commercal strps wth low-scale, nterspersed mxed (resdentalcommercal) development. 8. Plannng Code Complance: The Commsson fnds that the Project s consstent wth the relevant provsons of the Plannng Code n the followng manner: A. Secton 101.1(b) establshes eght prorty plannng polces and requres the revew of permts that authorze changes of use for consstency wth sad polces: (1) That exstng neghborhood-servng retal uses be preserved and enhanced and future opportuntes for resdent employment n and ownershp of such busnesses enhanced. The proposed Project would provde a local, small busness owner an opportunty to enhance an exstng busness that currently provdes job opportuntes to the Cty. (2) That exstng housng and neghborhood character be conserved and protected n order to preserve the cultural and economc dversty of our neghborhoods. The proposed Project wl preserve and enhance the cultural and economc dversty of the neghborhood by helpng to retan an exstng busness n the area. Exstng housng wl not be affected by the proposed Project. SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPARMEN 4

9 Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street (3) That the Ctys supply of affordable housng be preserved and enhanced. The proposed Project wll not dsplace any affordable housng. (4) That commuter traffc not mpede MUNI transt servce or overburden our streets or neghborhood parkng. The proposed Project would not sgnfcantly ncrease the automoble traffc congeston and parkng problems n the neghborhood. The proposal s a neghborhood-serng use whch resdents can access by walkng or takng publc transt. t= = (5) That a dverse economc base be mantaned by protectng our ndustral and servce sectors from dsplacement due to commercal offce development, and that future opportuntes for resdent employment and ownershp n these sectors be enhanced. There s no commercal offce development assocated wth the proposed Project and there would be no dsplacement of any exstng ndustral or serce busnesses n the area. (6) That the Cty acheves the greatest possble preparedness to protect aganst njury and loss of lfe n an earthquake. The proposed Project wl comply wth all applcable earthquake safety standards and bult to the current standards of the Calforna Buldng Code. (7) That landmark and hstorc buldngs be preserved. The proposed Project wl not affect any landmarks or hstorc buldngs. (8) That our parks and open space and ther access to sunlght and vstas be protected from development. The proposed Project wl not affect any cty-owned park or open space B. Secton 186.1(b)(1) allows a nonconformng use to be sgnfcantly altered, enlarged or ntensfed except upon approval of a condtonal use applcaton. The proposed Project requres Condtonal Use authorzaton to allow the ntensfcaton of an exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant by allowng "other entertanment" use on the premses. C. Secton 303(c) establshes crtera for the Plannng Commsson to consder when revewng applcatons for Condtonal Use approval. On balance, the project does comply wth sad crtera n that: (1) The proposed new uses and buldng, at the sze and ntensty contemplated and at the proposed locaton, wl provde a development that s necessary or desrable, and compatble wth, the neghborhood or the communty. The proposed Project wl allow for "other entertanment" use (.e. acoustc musc and poetry readng) n the restaurant. The project sponsor has submtted a petton wth over 600 sgnatures from patrons of the restaurant whch demonstrates that there s a desre SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPAREN 5

10 Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street for the entertanment use on the premses. There wl be no tenant mprovements made to the exstng commercal tenant space or changes made to the exstng buldng envelope wth ths proposal. (2) The proposed project wl not be detrmental to the health, safety, convenence or general welfare of persons resdng or workng n the vcnty. There are no features of the project that could be detrmental to the health, safety or convenence of those resdng or workng the area, n that: (A) Nature of proposed ste, ncludng ts sze and shape, and the proposed sze, shape and arrangement of structures; t: : The sze and shape of the ste and the sze, and the arrangement of the structures on the ste are adequate for the proposed Project. There wl be no physcal expanson of the exstng buldng. (B) The accessblty and traffc patterns for persons and vehcles, the type and volume of such traffc, and the adequacy of proposed off-street parkng and loadng; Exstng traffc patterns wll not be sgnfcantly affected by the proposed Project. Publc transt that s n close proxmty to the restaurant ncludes Mun Lne 22 wthn walkng dstance of the Project Ste. There s on-street parkng n front of the subject property and n the surroundng neghborhood. (C) The safeguards afforded to prevent noxous or offensve emssons such as nose, glare, dust and odor; The Condtons of Approval, attached as Exhbt A, wll requre the applcant to ensure that nose and odors are contaned wthn the premses so as not to be a nusance to nearby busnesses or resdents. (D) Treatment gven, as approprate, to such aspects as landscapng, screenng, open spaces, parkng and loadng areas, servce areas, lghtng and sgns; Snce the proposed Project does not propose the physcal expanson of the exstng restaurant, no addtonal landscapng wl need to be provded. There wll be no addton of parkng spaces, loadng facltes, open space or servce areas. All Project sgnage and projectons wll be consstent wth the controls of the Plannng Code. (3) That the use as proposed wl comply wth the applcable provsons of the Plannng Code and wl not adversely affect the General Plan. ~~':~~I~C~ DEPARENT 6

11 Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street The proposed Project comples wth all relevant requrements and standards of the Plannng Code and s consstent wth objectves and polces of the General Plan as detaled below. (4) That the use as proposed would provde development that s n conformty wth the purpose of the applcable Neghborhood Commercal Dstrct. The proposed Project s consstent wth the stated purpose of the NC-l Dstrct n that the ntended use s a neghborhood-serng busness. t= : D. Secton sets forth provsons applcable n the NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Zonng Dstrct. The NC-1 Zonng Dstrct controls are ntended to serve as local neghborhood shoppng dstrcts, provdng convenence retal goods and servces for the mmedately surroundng neghborhoods prmarly durng daytme hours. Buldng Controls or the NC-1 Zonng Dstrct promote low-ntensty development whch s compatble wth the exstng scale and character of these neghborhood areas. Commercal development s lmted to one-story. NC-1 commercal use provsons encourage the full range of neghborhood-servng convenence retal sales and servces at the frst story provded that the use sze generally s lmted to 3,000 square feet. However, commercal uses and features whch could mpact resdental lvablty are prohbted, such as auto uses, fnancal servces, general advertsng sgns, drve-up facltes, hotels, and late-nght actvty; eatng and drnkng establshments are restrcted, dependng upon the ntensty of such uses n nearby commercal dstrcts. Housng development n new buldngs s encouraged above the ground story n most dstrcts. Exstng resdental unts are protected by prohbtons of conversons above the ground story and lmtatons on demoltons. E. Secton allows hours of operaton from 6 a.m. untl 11 p.m. as of rght and requres Condtonal Use authorzaton to operate between the hours of 11 p.m. and 2 a.m. The proposal s to add nonamplfed muscal entertanment (jazz) and poetry readng to the exstng restaurant between the hours of 6 p.m. and 10 p.m. Thursday through Saturday and between the hours of12 p.m. and 9 p.m. on Sunday. F. Secton defnes "other entertanment' as a retal use, other than adult entertanment, whch provdes lve entertanment, ncludng dramatc and muscal performances, and/or operates as a dance hall whch provdes amplfed taped musc for dancng on the premses, ncludng but lmted to those defned n Secton 1060 of the Polce Code, and whch s adequately soundproofed or nsulated so as to confne ncdental nose to the premses. Other entertanment also ncludes a bowlng alley, blard parlor, shootng gallery, skatng rnk and other commercal recreatonal actvty, but t excludes amusement game arcades. G. Secton requres Condtonal Use authorzaton to allow an "other entertanment' use at the frst (ground) floor wthn the NC-1 Dstrct. SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPAREN 7

12 Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street The proposal s to allow an "other entertanment" use wthn the exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant on the Project Ste. 9. General Plan Complance. The Project s consstent wth the Objectves and Polces of the General Plan n that: COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY ELEMENT!: = NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCE Objectves and Polces OBJECTIVE 6: MAINTAIN AND STRENGTHEN VIABLE NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL AREAS EASILY ACCESSIBLE TO CITY RESIDENTS. Polcy 1: Ensure and encourage the retenton and provson of neghborhood-servng goods and servces n the ctys neghborhood commercal dstrcts, whle recognzng and encouragng dversty among the dstrcts. The approval of the proposed project to allow an "other entertanment" use wthn the restaurant wl enhance an exstng neghborhood-serng use. Polcy 2: Promote economcally vtal neghborhood commercal dstrcts whch foster small busness enterprses and entrepreneurshp and whch are responsve to economc and technologcal nnovaton n the marketplace and socety. A local, ndependent entrepreneur s sponsorng the proposal for the restaurant, whch s not consdered Formula Retal Use. Polcy 9: Regulate uses so that traffc mpacts and parkng problems are mnmzed. The proposed Project does not adversely mpact publc transt or place a burden on the exstng supply of parkng n the neghborhood. Many patrons are able to walk from ther resdences or places of employment, and the project s well served by publc transportaton. There s on-street parkng n front of the subject property and n the surroundng neghborhood. 10. The Project s consstent wth and would promote the general and specfc purposes of the Code provded under Secton 101.1(b) n that, as desgned, the Project would contrbute to the character and stablty of the neghborhood and would consttute a benefcal development. SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPARMEN 8

13 Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street 11. The Commsson hereby fnds that approval of the Condtonal Use authorzaton would promote the health, safety and welfare of the Cty. DECISION That based upon the Record, the submssons by the Applcant, the staff of the Department and other nterested partes, the oral testmony presented to ths Commsson at the publc hearngs, and all other wrtten materals submtted by all partes, the Commsson hereby APPROVES Condtonal Use Applcaton No C subject to the followng condtons attached hereto as "EXHIBIT A" whch s ncorporated heren by reference as though fully set forth. = APPEAL AND EFFECTIVE DATE OF MOTION: Any aggreved person may appeal ths Condtonal Use Authorzaton to the Board of Supervsors wthn thrt (30) days after the date of ths Moton No. The effectve date of ths Moton shall be the date of ths Moton f not appealed (After the 30-day perod has expred) OR the date of the decson of the Board of Supervsors f appealed to the Board of Supervsors. For further nformaton, please contact the Board of Supervsors at (415) , Cty Hall, Room 244, 1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place, San Francsco, CA I hereby certfy that the Plannng Commsson ADOPTD the foregong Moton on May 13, Lnda Avery Commsson Secretary AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: ADOPTED: SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPAREN 9

14 Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street Exhbt A Condtons of Approval 1. Pursuant to Sectons , 303, and 186.1(b)(1) to allow an "other entertanment" use wthn an exstng legal nonconformng large fast food restaurant wth approxmately 1,200 square feet of floor area dba Café Du Solel, located on the ground floor of the two-story resdental and commercal buldng wthn an NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct and a 40-X Heght and Bulk Dstrct n general conformty wth Plans on fe wth the Department n the docket for Case No C (labeled EXHIBIT B), revewed and approved by the Commsson on May 13, 2010 under Moton No. L E 2. The proposal wl nvolve addng nonamplfed muscal entertanment and poetr readng to the exstng restaurant between the hours of 6 p.m. and 10 p.m. Thursday through Saturday and between the hours of 12 p.m. and 9 p.m. on Sunday. 3. The establshment shall be adequately soundproofed or nsulated for nose so that sound from lve entertanment shall not be audble from outsde the premses nor nsde any of the resdental unts located above the restaurant. All doors and wndows shall be kept closed durng all entertanment. The Project Sponsor shall obtan all necessary permts from the Entertanment Commsson pror to commencement of the entertanment use. In addton, the Project Sponsor shall comply wth any requrements mposed by the Entertanment Commsson and/or Polce Department pror to the commencement of the authorzed entertanment. 4. If the Project requres montorng of the condtons of approval n ths Moton, the Project Sponsor or the subsequent responsble partes for the Project shall pay a fee of $1,080.00, as an ntal fee plus tme and materals as set forth n Secton 350(c), as establshed under Plannng Code Secton 351(e)(1) and work wth the Plannng Department to ensure complance. 5. The Project Sponsor shall mantan the man entrance to the buldng and all sdewalks abuttng the Subject Property n a clean condton. Such mantenance shall nclude, at a mnmum, daly ltter pckup and dsposal, and washng or steam cleanng or the man entrance and abuttng sdewalks at least once each week. 6. New sgns and exteror lghtng for the busness shall be revewed and approved by the Plannng Department before they are nstalled. 7. The Project Sponsor shall mantan an attractve storefront provdng vsblty of the restaurant nteror through the storefront wndows. 8. VALIDITY, EXPIRATION, AND EXTENSION Ths Condtonal Use approval s vald for three years from the effectve date of the Moton No. authorzng the proposed "other entertanment" use and shall automatcally expre on. Ths authorzaton s just an approval of the proposed use and s NOT a permt to mplement the approved use. Ths authorzaton and rght vested by vrtue of ths acton shall be SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPARENT 10

15 Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street deemed vod and cancelled f a Buldng Permt from the Department of Buldng Inspecton to mplement the approved use has not been obtaned pror to the expraton of ths Condtonal Use approval. The valdty of ths Condtonal Use approval may be extended at the dscreton of the Zonng Admnstrator only f the falure to ssue a Buldng Permt by the Department of Buldng Inspecton s delayed by the cty, state, or federal agency or by appeal of the ssuance of such Buldng Permt. However, the extenson must be requested pror to the expraton of ths Condtonal Use approval. 9. MAJOR AND MINOR CHANGES AND MODIFICATIONS OF CONDITIONS Mnor changes to the approved plans may be approved admnstratvely by the Zonng Admnstrator. Major changes and modfcatons of condtons shall be subject to revew and approval by the Plannng Commsson requrng a new Condtonal Use approval or amendment to ths Condtonal Use approval as determned by the Zonng Admnstrator. Such changes must be requested pror to the expraton of ths Condtonal Use approval. t: E 10. RECORDING OF CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL Pror to the ssuance of a Buldng Permt Applcaton for the proposed "other entertanment' use, the project sponsor or the responsble party shall record a Notce of Specal Restrctons as approved by the Zonng Admnstrator n the Offcal Records of the Recorder of Cty and County of San Francsco for the premses (Assessor's 0859, Lot 020), whch notce shall state that the proposed use has been authorzed by Moton No. and s subject to the condtons of approval of ths Moton. 11. BUILDING PERMIT TO IMPLEMENT THE APPROVED PROJECT A Buldng Permt from the Department of Buldng Inspecton must be obtaned to mplement the approved use wthn three years from the effectve date of Moton No. approvng the proposed "other entertanment" use. The Buldng Permt Applcaton shall nclude plans n conformance wth the plans on fe wth the Department n the docket for C (labeled EXHIBIT B), revewed and approved by the Plannng Commsson on May 13, 2010 under the Moton No.. The plans are requred to record the approved use of the premses even f there s no new constructon or mnor nteror changes. The condtons of approval shall be reproduced on the Index Sheet of the plans submtted wth the Buldng Permt Applcaton. The Index Sheet of the plans shall reference to ths Condtonal Use Authorzaton and any subsequent amendments or modfcatons. The project shall also comply wth all other applcable cty codes as requred by other cty departments. Addtonally, no change n the character of occupancy or change to a dfferent group of occupancy as descrbed under the Buldng Code shall be made wthout frst obtanng a Certfcate of Occupancy from the Department of Buldng Inspecton and approval from Plannng and other cty departments as necessary. 12. COMPLETION OF BUILDING PERMIT If the Buldng Permt s allowed to expre for more than one year, the renewal of such Buldng Permt thereafter wl be subject to revew by the Plannng Department. Pror to flng of a renewal SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPARENT 11

16 Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street of the expred permt, the project sponsor or the responsble party shall notfy the Plannng Department. 13. REPORTING The Project Sponsor or the subsequent responsble party for the project shall submt to the Zonng Admnstrator two copes of a wrtten report descrbng the status of complance wth the condtons of approval contaned wthn the Moton No. wthn sx months from the date of mplementaton of the proposed use. Thereafter, the submttal of the report shall be on an annual bass. Ths requrement shall lapse when the Zonng Admnstrator determnes that all the condtons of approval have been satsfed or that the report s no longer requred for other reasons. t. = 14. REVOCATION Durng the Buldng Permt Applcaton process phase of the project, the Zonng Admnstrator may place an order to stop work, suspend, or revoke a Buldng Permt f the proposal carred out on the ste s not n conformance wth the plans approved under ths Condtonal Use approval and subsequent Buldng Permt. The Zonng Admnstrator may also recommend the Plannng Commsson to consder revocaton of ths Condtonal Use approval n a publc hearng for noncomplance wth any of the condtons of approval. 15. ENFORCEMENT After commencement of the approved use, volaton of any of the plannng condtons of approval contaned n the Moton No. or of any other provsons of Plannng Code applcable to ths project shall be subject to the enforcement procedures and admnstratve penaltes set forth under Plannng Code Secton 176 or Secton 176.1, whchever applcable for each day a volaton contnues or s allowed to contnue. The Plannng Department may also refer the volaton complants to other cty departments and agences for approprate enforcement acton under ther jursdcton. 16. MONITORING If the project requres montorng of the condtons of approval contaned n Exhbt A of Moton No. the project sponsor or the subsequent responsble partes for the project shall pay fees as establshed under Plannng Code Secton 351(e)(1) and work wth the Plannng Department to ensure complance. 17. NEIGHBORHOOD CONCERNS The Project Sponsor shall appont a Communty Lason Offcer to address ssues of concern to neghbors related to the operaton of ths Project. The Project Sponsor shall report the name and telephone number of ths Offcer to the Zonng Admnstrator and the neghborhood for reference. The Project Sponsor shall keep the above partes apprsed should a dfferent staff lason be desgnated. SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPAREN 12

17 t: = Moton No. Hearng Date: May 13, 2010 CASE NO C 200 Flmore Street 18. SEVERABILITY If any clause, sentence, secton, or any part of these condtons of approval s for any reason held to be nvald, such nvaldty shall not affect or mpar other of the remanng provsons, clauses, sentences, or sectons of these condtons. It s hereby declared to be the ntent of the Plannng Commsson that these condtons of approval would have been adopted had such nvald sentence, clause, or secton or part thereof not been ncluded heren. SAN FRANCISCO PLANING DEPARMEN 13

18 Zonng Map IE n: ~nr~ SAN FRANCISCO PLANNING DEPARMENT e Condtonal Use Hearng Case Number C 200 Flmore Street DBA Café Du Solel

19 Parcel Map La Haght St ~ '3 o ro r \ \ 029 \ 039 \ \ \\ \ \ 038 NC~~ \ I 0288\ \ 40~)(. \ \ I \ Haght lalcohoi Restr,ct \ SUO: ;wer I \ \ \ \ \""1 \ \ \ \ \ I \ \\\ \1 \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \\ \ I \ I z_---- _-C,"I 021 )(.. ~ oj \ \\ íj \ \121oUlL_-- \ -- \ 014 1\ I \ \ 011 \ \ \012A\\ \ \ I 1\ \ \ \ R~;3 40~X \ \ \ \ \ \ \ I \ \ \ I \ \ \ \ \ ~~ \ \ 031 \ \ \ 001 \ \ :05 \ ---- r~--- \ I \ _---- \ \ I I 009 \ \ waerst --- SAN FRANCISCO PLANNING DEPARTMENT e Condtonal Use Hearng Case Number C 200 Flmore Street DBA Café Du Solel

20 Sanborn Map* ". r :;; '" 518 s~ron~ JR HAIGHT lf ~ "T rr ~ 0-, ~~. ;0 '~ J1 ~ : ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~=~~u_~,~:: ". U~_-..-,Q:I!.t,.:,.fÆ!!t: ~'l.!. CB'9"wlt/e 1IlI4~."f~~~l T! ~ ~ r. :~ :;,~, ~. to,..-..""k.".l5"w/~ r~~~ -'J - ór;.r' ''' :~...,'" t.~,-. :, L! :l I: :l ~~E" ~." úfohs - - "J I : L '0 :~! ~_ ~: c t)l.~. _...!l ll æ. ~.. "'- ~~~ j;~!.~ 4J6-oU 4~8J6 ~, ~"1~-'.~~!......,,. 'The Sanborn Maps n San Francsco have not been updated snce 1998, and ths map may not accurately reflect exstng condtons. SAN FRANCISCO PLANNING DEPARTMENT e Condtonal Use Hearng Case Number C 200 Flmore Street DBA Café Du Solel

21 Aeral Photo* ~.' ~e1f~.-'~' II... l ~... ~lr ~)1S1 -. ~ j ~-.( t ~_.\-..~ 'l~jo~ _..,.-...,':.. & ~ -'.' ~~:,.J: SUBJECT PROPERTY 'The Aeral Maps reflect exstng condton s ' In March 2009, SAN FRANCISCO PLANNING DEPARTMENT e Condtonal Use H. Case earng 200.Number Fllmore C Street DBA Café Du Solel

22 Aeral Photo* 'The Aeral Maps reflect exstng condtons n March SUBJECT PROPERTY SAN FRANCISCO PLANNING DEPARMENT CD Condtonal Use Hearng Case Number C 200 Flmore Street DBA Café Du Solel

23 Ste Photo SUBJECT PROPERTY ON THE CORNER OF FILLMORE AND WALLER STREETS / // /" LJ" SUBJECT PROPERTY SAN FRANCISCO PLANNING DEPARMENT Condtonal Use Hearng Case Number C 200 Flmore Street DBA Café Du Solel

24 Ste Photo SUBJECT PROPERTY ON WALLER STREET I CA94117, USA (approx).!,.1 'I SUBJECT PROPERTY SAN FRANCISCO PLANNING DEPARMENT Condtonal Use Hearng Case Number C 200 Flmore Street DBA Café Du Solel

25 Ste Photo SUBJECT BLOCK ON FILLMORE STREET ~ / IQJ rq, òo1mfm. SAN FRANCISCO PLANNING DEPARMENT Condtonal Use Hearng Case Number C 200 Flmore Street DBA Café Du Solel

26 Ste Photo OPPOSITE BLOCK ON FILLMORE STREET '.." ' '" ~.~ IwwJ SAN FRANCISCO PLANNING DEPARTMENT Condtonal Use Hearng Case Number C 200 Flmore Street DBA Café Du Solel

27 Pctures of Cafe du Sole and my Phone numbep Page of3 /lflø/p/x L From: Arne Lazarus -:arnelazarus@comcast.net:- To: blmaher@aol.com Subject: Pctures of Cafe du Sole Date: Mon, Sep 28, :45 pm and my Phone numbep Attchments: Cafe_du_SoleU4).jpg (175K), Cafe_du_SoleU5).jpg (218K), Cafe_du_SoleU6).jpg (139K), Cafe_du_SoleU7).jpg (164K), Cafe_du_SoleU8).jpg (150K), Cafe_du_SoleU9).jpg (154K), Cafe_du_SoleU10).jpg (521 K) I hope these are satsfactory. If not, I wll shoot them agan. Arne P.S. My phone number s Attached Images tj O.0083 C /aol/ en-us/mal/prntmessage.aspx 9/30/2009

28 Pctures of Cafe du Solel and my Phone numbep Page 2 of3 ~~, L -- ~ ~ ~~ r~m aol/ en-us/mal/prntmessage.aspx /30/2009

29 Pctures of Cafe du Solel and my Phone numbep Page 3 of3..~~jøl '- en-us/mal/prntmessage.aspx C 9/30/2009

30 BILL MAHER 433 WAllER STRET SAN FRANCISCO CA (415) /fffç"1j Px ;2 Captan Croce Cascato Northem Staton 1125 Flmore Street San Francsco, Ca 9417 October 4, 2009 Dear Captan: Thank you for takng the tme to meet wth me the other day, t was very gracous of you. As we dscussed the Café du Sole I on the corner of Waller and Flmore Streets wl be askng the San Francsco Plannng Commsson for permsson to play Acoustc Jazz only, on the earler part of Thursday through Saturday and earler on Sunday. Specfcally we are requestng Plannng Commsson approval of non amplfed musc and poetry readngs from: 1. 6 PM untl10 PM on Thursday nghts PM untl 11 PM on Frday and Saturday nghts 3. 2 PM untl 8 PM on Sunday nghts The Café has been open for several years and wth the support of nnumerable neghbors (over 500 on the petton) they have had sdewalk tables and chars for the last few years. Unlke ts predecessor, the Mouvda Lounge, there has not been a sngle run to the premses snce t opened several years ago. The present applcaton has the support of over 600 sgnatures from customers supportng the dea of evenng acoustc Jazz and Poetry. As you are well aware one block up on Heght there are many venues for late nght drnkng and entertanment. I wl be good for those of us n the neghborhood who no longer wsh to Part Heart untl 2 AM to have an altemate more lad back alternatve venue. We wnl request that a condton be placed that the sale to any new owner wl requre an opportunty for publc testmony and revew be the Plannng Commsson to further protect the area. Agan, I apprecate your takng the tme to dscuss the proposal and your supportve comments. Ths s a good proposal, supported by the communty. It wl enhance the neghborhood and reduce rather than ncrease the demands on your offcers. We apprecate your support of the proposal. I look forward to contnung to work wth you and Offcer Gallagher and f I can provde you wth any more nformaton please let me know. 7~ Bll Maher Bl Maher 433 Waller Street, San Francsco CA 91117, blmaher@aol.com (415) C

31 /ffpelp/x 3 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here 1. ~~ :~'l ~@Tne 2. J:d~=L.: J; a~ NCdfgdØWl Ýútl 3. 4.!v l z--: C. '2 \lhte ( HA C, t. "fcv loñ zutf, YaJ,o.(Qr ~ 5. LWVvJ v.vtn. C'" v ~"'\' e V' \ \.lew' L-.. f 6. p 7. ~(. T~,-W,. ~(J.vl b c az1j0 )o.g0at!.ll1 -t _~"d (!~lrl ls tk~i.(/0j,., ~ca... v lkt ~-ào\\'6 ttï~ 06\l:ç\- ~~\lòf(15tö~(ov 11. ãja,.: ~e c. â n-l1v en" ':b å. meh,eo' j"l,1 Con ",q k~ 12. p"*/,,,1' H..."'~ p..... d.j..k '.J 4. 'on "",Ike) 13 ~ß~ Gmt 'oøafp~j\i.cn f. G 14. ~~.% :q5 S-rJm "'') (Z~ N&.w", t:1î e.er~ tk ~~.. ~.- 16.,v?f:J1l ~b#!'yk''''", vju1~

32 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone ~ ~5J J ' beccaln ~~Et~ c:!-t'n: q era ~ e.t,~l- How dd you get here 10. l~ ??AUL \ra~ 1$' ç:llve Al,B 1Y\'\~fß"3\SæédfJ'r.~ 13. (7\rìC\ nt\"chael qoc PJ\cñG ltvenye grn\ohctt?~ L.Cl 14.:;;; &0 ûh 1\ '3~ I D-a'f Sk \",ul'ed.ìaè\."~oo COM 15. t So,dc 5& 3 W.ler 5 1C,_ l 'ls 2~~ 332"Z w 1 k. Il 16. ßÐy ~l=c ~ l /ltmj1j1ff. 'ft;/z -del ~

33 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name 3. ~~y~ ttlv\0v n 1 (I Address E-mal or phone 4. \ ~k Ä\\t/ ù~ LAoo çî.~ 5.,. t. h.~ ;,.,'. ' C9(~ ). \.ll J' J ) Y I l/vtltf j 't g'74 - (J(P How dd you get here \ I''l e. OJ ô ûrj 6c\~ts?? ~ f.ho\q-,.uro f~ th LOH~.',;\/t d'()!ni"' VV,'ch lie I b Jh~IY"'1 J ~ r ~ ~ 't 1 6. s~?7l2av~vvvv \1\ WL~sk(' MsrB5eyoJo./' / Y?s Ç;IL.~ 7. l.; l;t ì~-'l b,. t~_, (c-(. 8. ~J. ~ fl'r :, t u/al '.. \. J. 1ft tlc"'c j \~ ( \ 9. _tl I:J;UlÁ p. '" If"' a",bocd\ ve km ì ~.cd- t.c. CóÝI l.,e~bll s a "'(J 10. Q,r\lll\ \rt1l\ Tì~ \\\If/?l, bk'~(l'1 HJe- htf~ 11. ßREN COU6/1lf1,J; 1-50 Scaf sr. J/Ct"J"'(a.e!/leteRcolV l~j 12. 'f4'?jf2et:eorj :?Jc 1) -F)LlNrìl2 JT f)l? (ÇjllAtl\, /117., j, /Ó' 13. fa II L "r q, ') 11 Fì lly QtU' b~l t ýt,,, ~(j,"~i \ r-\l 14. C û n~~ 4e 'tì\~ 1 (\ GIrrq.L... J (6 k",~~ 5J '~:ll( 0 V" 15. ÁrN~(~ 16. "y. G ~ U.r,.", ~-, ~'1 1tS 0\ Y1 H W\LV-- Il'1 II vrañed CtJ/ly(-? (2- 'f j \ 1M,uP I;H (,;~ I-Çl q ~I V1 ~

34 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here 1. ~Lan~(~ (?;;;-~; - UJt1-2. ~Ìd-~ ~l(a ~:3J; -JÆ- ~.c. ~ J If \ Lc d 3. A"J,,(~ \\eaes s 3 S 'tcäq\e STlt S Q\e~\ \c\ 0f o.v 00 CV 4. J ~. J'.1~ CJ 21 --~pd ll. v-t -. Ç,f Wplf\ IS - ~(2. - A. \ ~O + r) fl. lj;; b.'jj~t 5. YoM akmsv 133 ch-ej-r Q;ø,) ýo@l, ecl-t ~.. -'t ep 7 COl. ~ a'v,-,j!lç C! I)~ :;.(, vv J; I k.~ l ~~ v I 6. C/~ :tb\o~ 1~?J Sço~ l:yca LdøJkeJ ç+ #,/7 S" \r: $), ~ V\0/~ \ JC1 L \~ f:: D /' " t / "? '. c.~. ì.",;:'ll.-" 12. e-ett II L-,...:v\ :l".el (0 ~ 2. ß Hú\:t-.~ l:l, fm~ Ao Jr$ ö?~'ie-\$"te.i'\+l ~ /17../" lo;.1 r;k~, 1/ Î /?,. It C-l /' J~c-:. '" /1. VA-, c..- ~.,1-13.! f"ë/ oj, t. c...a:/t/'y( ~ I v Tv _J -- CVN'L'-~ 14..'0 Z- J1c. jj~ t;' l1. ~ #- Jfy.;t:tf', 15. førlru. It:k!1 Ie c1 7Î( uttul-l 73 J)u /tçc;tø'v~ 16. Saùf)\Ó\X QrroO S9DS-j\æ,st'3 L\)C\\I't1fee

35 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. How dd E-mal or phone you get here J. 4IQsJ-NlfS l~æ 2. ~B4a X~~~.Q1e: ~ljliul- 3. CQRev NEaLA"\eN S61f';\\~1e-Çl"fl4Û\ Çtf ~~ '0 _ ( ~ 5. ~9Y CyVVer/fS ß"fía.-lpcl"S 15 Cl, eæ. U,,,,, ~J-~_1t11) l)-t) er'~ 4..ILe. (D Iv1 è r (e \1 Y I, 1= '8 ( cß~ a- '5+ 5 F r- \W4 l J 6. f~wl Zìl/ I?db k~ 'læø.ø WJl/ 7.,J05b'-(A P'\f Oq /-1)'/'''))+ s.f 5 k 8. 0lT4 t:x b 11oÇ-~L- &T Sf 1)(Uf: 9. Ckv/~Le /~ ICps-vJcr Jt~ ~v- -t~ 10. -ß ~~j"''t Me \ ÌC. Jo. 9~\\. (.om v.j~ \ k. 11. J t ~-- r\ Z \ V VJ ') Iv.)')e' S l ~t VJ ~ \ l: 12. J~ ~ 'P Cl M=p~;' ~~~I.ý vr 13 ~\- ~~ ~ J j ' Jm lw~ Çf6lÝ., rag e. Lj 1.;!I?,l) - 10 D wf.( (,(1 w 15. -t'or' N çcåvv( al 4Ay f A \~ ~7.'" 1:=-Q- \\~\~ 16. Kelt' \)6 w' Afl k \t"mtj 9t~~4)rJA~v Q"~H11 \Nlr\k~u I.. k ~ "' :.,v (r

36 .. We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café.. ' How dd you get here.- OLtS w"lket dfl 8. \)A LK- ~vt 1 w~\lj ). \ kj 0 \ \L. v Wf/~. Wlæd./ wr,lkj

37 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café/s presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. 1. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here C,f D 16. dr\v&li\\t\\.'d~s

38 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone 2.~d~ 1. S tj Sf e j (1) 111 Çd~ 'l ') I~ lu d'jlers/- '&~.,, 3.~t 4. DO A6:=:t\S s.~1l\~ 6. Ae\fk rt Lf-wn,~ 7. 1./ HI(L 8. / "~' Z4= (~) 3q Çt.Ql N: 1-'2~ l\\\taort 3I, ßOO vj~ \\0 r,j~ u6tp..q 't~.çj~ y)d -lsõwlet Sf Ø v.., K%:ít CU\ L 1 ßdÛttt/ Sf. 9. () 'ft\~-\ ~~\ \~ê tj~er \DCa (\ ",)~\1'b\Ú s t -+ 1/ 12. c.:\):-,.\ E.et (~Q \. ' f-c "2 ~ L L c' S) ~ '\ 10. ftfl f/ndf/(lsc)fj Z 1"1 vjttè)t' 1r 11. Îlt!l~ WMJKt \:/ ;t( (&V)~, /5/ú'bû How dd you get here (j..~) '- C'J. ~dø 3SB p. WAt.12 S'" 13. fftk IvJA t Nrf 1lJ1 ffr"(a.t 5~ CA~Jl/Ç 231S JUßA\. Sf. :H\Î.'/ 14. Sf-/\;t(Z,-. / ~í (0,-,.. ' 1. s~ If~ J1 15. Nft L. s-!\ -í P $l\ H J CA$1& t1 '-tl ~ ~' lul V,(.~+t, I..yJ l N1 '3JJ 'rcaq,//r7 16. ~l. ~~ ~. -I ucjked vj~t-led \N~~ Lv. "f O J:. lu: (. WPt\.kJ Lt /I II r-(j ljjjj(/~ \,\. ~laltj vy\ '-cl'l_ k"'r'lh.~ DOK. 1\\ -JUPf'll hot"", 1. COt'" snu ' ~ F WfnlZbj \vla~

39 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone 1. //hr4ael Cßtfsff'("t How dd you get here 415~ E.-(ù:...wdbP~ /1081 YÇtlv:. ~of(",~:i.-j~(iç,7"'~ ~CI Ur(/("h 2p ( t. 4/1 U ~r c \. (J L tj (1"- II + ß((( 11.~e j)qllceí '2Ll~PlfRC 5I- Cf4 12. ro\0~ ~ ~ l 1ú WfA\ 13. L: (c. ji~ 1/é/ ~ W/!!/? rad R~lcl Q :1M ~ ~ \ l\~ Zh. VY1,:b1 jrv!k Sl S'FCA qlf/(r ~ 16. (=:z,d/;4 l/z FUlmON sl 1IÌ LJqlg

40 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. 1. Name C "-". (~o. LvJ Address lj'í1 ~ lclt'çl How dd E-mal or phone you get here ( I v w c't 4 1)0 CJ.G. Ú~\ VVL-\t 2. ll\ \.lt 4 Plr'l \.~ ~ ~ t P6:t: - ~~ ' 3. Cl; ~ (6C~V U S L-,k1 c: ) _ 4. (,v-;'-\l\ß ý l.~\\ -lj"\ \,-\.\s4 \ Lt.V." o.'ttl~y9'~-\ t? l)'m~ I t~,j lr c\l. C CA\..- t( S-4:c, \t (...- C- \ w~k.. 1/ 7 c~ S,'-1 r v/x 3/l ~L,C:~'r' Ul: 5. ~Jc/ ~ - '.fr.//. ';,'CVDc c. 6. M.(AU /',j MlCu 1 1~o \ tvi \" 110"1 " ') J'lLZ \ -0lll; 1 Vlt&@fjul,.... awl waak 7. l/h~a,w\ (j 1\.VJ1)A '''10 Vb'0~( \ìj"nd-\ii1~,.;)hv'h\'v- \,kj~ '". I jl/l(,j / J!. rt /) 1 L.,,- 8. fr Y," ~ S ",l '1-)1\,., oj Vt\ (. b( 1(. j1 So 7. OJ!~ ~ ~- 9.~ ' (LJA T.13:)1 A 73, 4 ~~ (110\.ç\LJ.ý )(V~Q(LkWfÆ, 'flu 10. qr(~ clj QI,e- J (6 c\o,\j-l (1Ær;Cß- Sozc: 11. L":on JhM ~1( /f"'o:jlr rl (5U2) Zt-l'(lJ 01./I~ 1/ ~./llk- "N/\ (1'- 12. \r.::,i.a. l.'-l\, 'JL.. \. (ovv ""c.~ \: 13. L1 /"11 f) 'atf 11/\ 7l&.e- ~ 14. f) ~ l' N (, :-1 \I (l A" );. 16 ~.tm,). / t-~ I '",'I ",e- )~Ç hll/d6 Of, /J )L ;k l.j '1 / y: /!:= 21 ø' :1tu'\ \ (), n ) n-. e "'~ov' -~ /'rý ~. f)'"t!q~/jí!og 7,JL

41 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. ~~E ~ How dd Name Address E-mal or phone you get here 1. O(.tì-L'T J ~y 12c At'!\1~T6;"èÇL cfî;lf( Q@h+m4J LQt' (Oft b/~1t!j~) 2. S (öfrgtll'2(f/ft.l\ ~JI'(J Hll ~1t'~ 5t ~F-(/1 S!". tt~-+rtl '~1(?"' r1' w~ t-er:(... 1~'''1l l(j ~(l rjá.ltj 3. -Javì tf '1lA~c:(Aln. CJG r1or;svm 51' ~ 1/25 ftw/a:le.c1f1l! ~~kùù 4.~CaCV /,9.#4 tjsr S (A.9//4 -Jb,1 t7...,a'. 5. "VOl!!.,-. "V )$ t,~ ' "('''. ' t e l ~2l\,~ 7;0' rf\l. S Q41l.a~ Qøk Sb b.)v\ù - &;\1 c,.. ~=y(j,q? 8. 3t. ljq:1 Ie"\ 141/1: b ttlå h f rr l _!C"L \.Lu.~l ~AQ~~ t,nq ~ vvv-(~~~ ~ l.,3öb8 ~ \ A.tK-LL 14. \û "1( "ll Ò 9-\' "l.trv t?e~dr V~ f~ \\utl wcjæj lh,/ L~ I (7'(' '" e'l,sf. II e.uj A\~ èr'l-7. ì ~~ ól\ v.- 0\

42 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. How dd E-mal or phone you get here '- Ir: 3Î"D.(/;Sq C::r ( ìr!~á! 7 Lj)4.J!@(Ý,:I1L C'Q~ ~ 6. l\ ft ~J r'oja: ))Q LL la t ~t, 7. )(;.1\/\ ' "d 8. Q '0 \r,\iw 6S ---\1 s\- r' :; ( 10. :: (W ') hv. ~ 10 lb bv(er b 6~Ó -:t '" J' 9. \~ \ ~(lr'0 0(o'~ S ~ *\\) L.\\Š 1'1~':5)r ~\. 11. CL()\ ~. J ~ r. 'M,II' (\ ' ;))11~! L (~(l~\7./z'ç,cj JJ l.l\?~s,,~s ;4h t\\lu k '- \S~TIb~'\ \ ""\L ~)"'erýb'.\ ~J'~ 13.~\L"'''~~~'' 3"l1 S~~~l-s-- - 'C';':MyQ1:-; 14.1t r;df'je 677 at!6-(/! IWn-tW /J!." 16. ì t -. r.- :;111 () /\ ~ :J \ r/tyli,i'm,'/j) 'tt l, t./, r~\ rol.:' 15.,4:&; Ak,'""", fls J tf:j,t (f- ob Jd d 1= ~,,,jk,,(1,-!' ñl r I'.!. J I.~ A

43 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. How dd E-.mal or phone you get her~ 1. -&vrbtl,~j/ bm"~('/ rj'~ 2. Name Address J:o.,,/.t\cM1f 3'7lDef,,kJ fcölk(,'d',cr ~~ 1/ fa.. V r;;. fn!e.s'r, 3. ~ At-A.. vvllkln1 GRcJ~; l~ CoVl. -.JA' 4hJ ~ /"I(J Í-K 4. (V~I2.1 D yvr-j1z f 'A/-t. IltJ 11 ~ f f ' ll-t,m.lrt r ø Y d 'Ol ì (r Õ W' 5. (o"wt."'). nc (,f "".J Z l, l t?owt&!,l,o.j ~ mje I.! M' l-.ccù.rc... ",. w Q.-t 6. L 2.~:: ~ 1/.' -,~ 0, 7. )'~~. \0"1 A (l~lll1/~tj' & ~'I) '((l( 1; \ q 8. Dll\l: d S'JL\ ~.\or\f.\,. l.~ '\ L.l\)rJ~.1 6 t 1 f,frul Î,1'j f k "" (r6 t e h(?aj I.~ "Vt 1"- o ' -, ~ r \'If' f\?,'v\,\ '- I ' G.? ~, C ~. (., t7 C'C. C P' (.. u.l J\ f' ß J( / ~66 t,lcé' & í l S/ ' (4 VV.l 12.1Ø~ \k~ 111 ÝVhh M f CjclO ~bs \. (' J, (JA M \ (. (. ). (., ( Cr ' I~\ ~ \ ~~ \. ) Q 13.~vt~ llj-,nr~ 1,11.) t I,q, ".,-~~, (,CV"-- 14.~ "' (\'løæ.cj '1 -lu dol: S+ "' (,/lc..~ lvg~,\(.f?, \" Sv) ß! tt ~" -Sf\Qæ@o.e () rn W,; I~ CA;. l,\i ~ Ç. ~ (."-"' \ L.. ( 1::1 '" (j.. "" \-'1.). ( \À"L ~l ~í Q41-r

44 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here 1. Jmbt\N? SPICUYI QsP t0pwjè~m'\'r.gù'y \)~; 2. ~. dj~ ~\ kloç,\t"oj~5~\.~ r C'.. \)G\ \ \ltv\. 3. ~a; I: ~c.),\ tvct 43(" \\\0 MlesöV\~ç@eQ.oU~.vU 4. "-,/)/;1,""", ~n;4 S Y-v 6Á// V )J'I í- AI 5.~ U;~37C~ NJ fj*-l 6. "ú (j 7. 5~ß t\jè- \k-!. c!.ie 8. "3 '1 t. V.~ I! c- / l/, c. I,.. Nrl.)./lc, e c;:.y 11 ~êjv ~)) U J1 GlI, (C~.Î 9. lola Qvo1Serv Sf ~tdji/;g S,!lA// (2 \ Or. 4 It," t S. 10. ídoja Dhyn ~20\'C~JOetat d ttkvlgm Ntl/L 11. ~ø- ~ N S "r 1 ~ a ~l~~~~~~ 0: l\) olll \0 ~c C \ V\Ao ltv 0 V)~ r r ce. ~"L (~\.,j-..~ - O,))T I 13. l-o~ 'J -:, ~~,hl-tjlr 51 C'~"'~c..~ ~ ~ -'- Ie:- 14 1)ehrf ro~ I ùq'l- ~ermt\\~ St dl' ~~.(ø.", wj ("II ~("",S;'rÍ'?W tj...f 15. Or"~ \ 'J ß OJ-\ 1'1 o' 1\.1 f ~ Î" ~ y S"l 'J V'vl. 16.,\t2S6\. ~elw\aa 1113 f~ \\\(w..e.s( JE'~ì! Freewt4o (,JS/'\cc 'r 1, ('('~ WC-L\ L

45 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here 1. t14.j90 + Sbm.b "3 'Îa I"n -cs- r.-,ev 0.1"",0, L~ 2. ~'YA\)L JA\\OUMrßÎKON~ 3. ~(CA Cò -e'b~ I 27;7 4. (''(s AJQt"s r/6 f(l'-'t ~'\. 5. (J.AIA:b jltfmmw 1m R~(tST l) j... \\ Q\~.Q K\ìvO&\ (OStA ~òr. 751 faöe "n\(r_~a\ìlool? ).((j\lv\\l- (ü!j I Ul'.~!) IlUf,~ I v-4 \ k: ed -; la e bst Sc / C '3 ers te l e 9 MCÚ \. c c' II CIHdfl-t,,:J' Jk rj~.' "..." lcot J +. s.. fa I b I '- '" fv f C '",,. '.f ",01 '" "" So e. j.. 4; Lt,.,,, l(pl/~ejt. 0õ, Icc. IV; ;,. r tyl II " dv\ VÍJ.. P ta. / l, v0. 1, C.AJ ~:.t( /-,,._... - " 5 'l~, 1. tl/'(l 11ìá vc/,/"ú4 lac..l,//5acjz...t,tæ,!,~,'ø-vj.,-( ~, ' '~ v S:7, k eyn) 1 r í1 00. k ýt'uv b.x! trtj erl, ',).1) -LJe I l-r 11.. S V t ~J r: l ~'w~ ' ß:J J. -r CJ5 \\W I' \-J$k (". b\ J I 'tt'(,ivj,"@~~' 'r' L ~ (c),,,.~.- l~, ' -.c; ~' t;ß,l.ì= L.of l 15. ~I SA COl/IV' f 16. é r ; L V' e (fl c: Y ~.~ '101 J.( 0"1!Va,': (r í?'b 11ILl.:EJ sr 1AR(á&lTA LeR e Y4HCO, ll~t\~awl' Co~ - c. /,. " ~ 'f ~.1 l" I, I ~ (r ~.:;C( (\/l. ')"""'1 IV-/V c,l. Z5~,LIOl~o.n'" Sf Qr:lL5l8J'Jet:/.~'"

46 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. l e IPd.J r Name I Address E-mal or phone \l t A " L.-,/ (( r I- 1. j.rl,,/ t'vn''' ~OG' 'Nø. Lr.;. 2. ~ Ûl/\)c'4 ~1(C:-r ~ ~Lgr) 3. lúc& J-Sl -:cw It 5t. l 3 Cc1..J 4.OAlBA(L UA MMt:~,ò q q~ I-1A It; /l lf óù 9'f J1 t' VI ~f- 5. ~~~ wcd(~t ~ C\( 6. ú- How dd you get here 1JALf3 V!/ le; N ~~ e.ll -'î '" ' () 11. A~ A 12 /0 fob D\,poU' Ave. 111~ SI~ M5ú:utt- 3S CAllu Sr. Sf e '-JOL LJJ2Kt 13. J4~r~.( aj ~ '* 5YU t Vù~ 14. fv~ ~~rl Lf1 W",\\tW :.II1" ~l\~jç)j..c"". 15.la'e 12Cdlì0us m SltìMt ('#:3:f,ç~5' wecl/( (, 16. _Ko~ 1 12(f tl% dl(0ú 4í("11,)~ß Ircl4À

47 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name 1. MfrL STYltw Address 727 h. td:àllf E-mal or phone How dd you get here 2., \~e\5t 4..t1t\ ~Dr t ytv 0 j\ 5. A f'ú. WI P vrc.e 6. len j \l l eo 96'1l:al5\tt'Sf7- o g 5 Fed I Sf: VV(A rj n' e. ~tf Lòl- 2 s"3 Sfu'j/ r J JakJ tv l' lo 2~ La V-rU'. ßut eau tteu Î.( ov ()c 7. 3e~eQ, Aeo,r. 530 'SSg, 'JLl.. 8 ~ "" 11t5c 1((, ço - ÇJol :l.gjjxa-j~ éj sh ~ /!MR./J(~ 1/2. d'dk s+ JV~ 10. lê-4úxl ~ ~B~k.s~~\. ~MA.Z-~~e~~'L\\,~f' 11. ~ ( (l ('! h Q Q.? 6r- flo (N~ v S r~ pi Q M S ~ryr7.r _fì I' cv'@ 3 M CArl. r. 12~(9 M6,J~~ "!~ jo(dw:@jvv,..,d.~ It",l~ 13. ("00 z /L C AN\POS.2s4 t \LLJl\t a.4.. 5f ~tllî ~,ctv\sre1r,,~ ~I. T~? ( ~ ') C( t=~' ( (la(~ st~- c' Lt I ( -7 L,- rt -(~ t 14. '- ~_. L... Ll:'., ll l.l\' LjUl-.flt\Hf.sí Sf lt q ll v\ l\~ 16.1\ m v ~t Y\G\t f; l 116 L~'O() SIS r ~. (1 y) z z

48 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here 1. Sara \2fBQ 3Z ' \.\\e(st VI Co rf on e~) 2. 0lLJ3rJr- 'OOltKt:C So T F f'(ti'vehnorlo/o' ()./)f(j/( 3..Dú\\Ií~1 I.e ~l g3~ ttl-loub/ çt olvl kjol,dec? Wvt(aOO,LDtv vv Ll1~ I 4. cji;" jol.../j.. 9 C!:c.ýUff k~krt-t~. ''' vv+i(.. 5. ~c. 6 ÚJr, C '1 ~ ;/ -., fn /',r ' wa.7 et(~ 6. ~Ol"t 'LíÜSyy(LO to 13 fflls ~nrlld1-3(aòl(ôm 7. ~e- c;l go r:/fmre- co-l~(j9/,,' L L ÚN 8, LçlAtxOcÀ - tq GCfrY;O- s1 - Gs"-bea.Gh I@Gmll\.mY/IA,.1c 9. 1)O(\Y\AWll~ n~ T"S' 4wlV"ArAA'l.u d. 10..\Mwt lù2'1~ltl \l \\\l""- t. o~~b- ~ DPØÝ et. ~@ow~'í 1-1 Uk. IÍ' / Jt '".t ~Ù~ vvj t.f \ f't4 P G-~ 'L..cuv 13. ~ llosß~pck- (Q1 W~rt S 1" ~\?."Wt~~e'l~' t.1l Le ko",~- ~ j,drej 16.

49 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Address E-mal or phone,! 1./;. 1. / G..;+rn (1. P I /t/e dc-. c. C~-'1 WJ~V/~ 2. 'J;.t.o ':&ro 01 4c~ 0/1'" ~ l-v IV,rL@';'-_W'... p ):.. 3. ~p~ L.\~' ~sjt\ ~-Wk\~@~L ~CrjL-.T5 ~7M f?r: t ; #1 rjld;v1l\/b.,t*íe-7d(~--c~ ~ 5. _dw thjloj 1 \ os fb Y l~ \-Øl yxcc? c~ wnl- \_ßV'~ 6 -m.tl E G~V ;11 I-Il ~ SF C, Clr/è'Z lv/lk 7. / ) ~A~ ~ -:K)::F;::Jl\P :a '\"J _t 'd'" ~\: r I. y 15"\2.,ö all U vvl~ 1 L.ç 'Su,-fSldL :Jc:,k, Cf"W 2-9. R..\?~ e.g LL 13 ( (" : O?LJ- ~., L- 1",1.4 "1 '( IN ( ("r..' J fla l, 10. :;t Co,hC- ~Itc.~v' _. : \.! f-) 11. ~YttSSk'lM-.l'L~t1~:t. #l~ ~lçt, SF, CA 12. Ç6\4,,j),\ Il %LeI~l~ S+, Q/DL~\ve~t\l\&ç. 13. ~"- ~.hc;h. I ;'ì j 14. r hrktepllè I' (t law" 15.,\í) k.jq II. 16. \~R L\e..~;A: ~ 70 jl,b1 &( $'0 /-do H:r ('ld? () ;2 tl 6U2 M A"J (I) ;7 C. \) How dd you get here, /l1w1, ~~ " n 0 Mt.!'~ \.\YJLLQ\ WL\kJ, f\ j; v- (u,) W:~~

50 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone 1. ~"\ ~ ~~o W 4w\'\. S\ 2. r\~ ~ &bs=.~ rv~v- 3. _~?1~ t LL dd you get here How INX~ 4...~ l~ t.t~wv' Sr- ~~.!2-') ~gk~ r1j- I. Lø Mks Q1D v ~Vttlr lofu.vt')c~3l1f~- ~ L- 0 ~ L)/ S L q~ I r') UJ et 1I7I'7t\ ~ìß,@(oma'" W~~""\?~ 8. -;!\N\, \\-\J1o 11'07, ~c,\. wf ~~í( 'I 9. Sc-.!L :1\) Ll2b. Ypt tj W,(L\ l~ 10. C:?fUL-tG.M ".Z-1 L;Jy~ lû4-k:k. 11. ~ts\~ Lf22Vv~ '5, L 12. -t \ \f\ \) ( \1 \d! '(\.nth C \~ 1- ~L ~ \l L- \ç. ' \"1/,- (. t; 13 h-e Ie (' t6 yl 103 b"la v d s1 14. Nt1l /"T~.f+) '?~2s f \\ ~ t. st- -*~,... \ \ '.,. \. / L- \\"\'.. r t,j", ~..,j ~. ~. A ~.. V D'\.. (L~. ~~'1W\ wall k t Ik _ e'(r6( (J hol(yúì\ ( IV 16.~4 Ca~ ;flofí/n ')#3 VÎJ,tsl ~L'\1MA1 \ la) ( (~ l/j(jjt. wu1"f \JCv\ \"' JdLe

51 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone 1. ~ J~~ 3.c1!~ç r: 2. ~;O~ n'fç' r-t d 3. -tòc&!-\u ~Jp. ltr Jt 4. ';s~ k.l"t,,v~ '6~3 lfal~5kt sj', 5. ~nty-lk;( (,lbtk, tel hl/.8/ )Lf~.~ )51-/Af~f5) 7.,~c-~ r-/6 lttf~ /' 8..,/,,/-:./.~ t , E...nv;',,..ld'L; r. ' 3a 7h5 ft st 14. N (te vj C.VlClV 9J qlv1dale Sf ì Sf (A 15. \V ~ : )) c.. \k G-.. 16"~WU~ -I- (.)j'\ ~ vj) J.1 v-1 )t(ú1 hsa DDLjJáS~ St. How dd you get here 0Jd2 \;Á/lR. t;cv\ ~ w 4.l Ke.cL l t/uc--k, tvtl lil rk 1 : lav Jl ~ ~W ~ ljj,ja t~ j W.dk.J fro." f~ìe""(i; f'f~'t 1)/1 U,Ie. t t. 0~/L dylvû

52 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café.. w~ ~ \ù J).; c;( ý\jj,'j. ~~. ~~ vfv-.~d. 't l '-6",. y. "- r-- L \l0 rr \ How DD.. dd Î). '(\o ~vjj' "7' Name ~ '\G A ress dde-mal or phone you get here ~ ~ lw-t~75 ttt!rft!f.(au@~(ðjl ~ --,/ 17 ~(:~~ ( / ~~ ~454 IS -S~-...tßd~~ ~ ß",-u: " ) r' (1 Cct.5",.r.lSAJ.S.,-4-.lhvrft~'C"'/~èY~,()"--~t '*,. 8. e ls(vi (fa It" r ~ 1# h OO~ Ct~/y.-I \ \.Cl\L J,. lm ( ICl!. (~'" 0. ( 'c Ce o~? v- 9. " \ \ 10., r \.l" ~ l~.u h')0 11 L ~~ -.- ::: ~ ;; 13. S - 2- vcú+ 14. &'Y\& t: l h.. \ It. " " I \..J g'3 d J\~J\ 1cv( "S 11 \. I"" C.ì"r- (Ðda L. 't.')), ~,) r? ScJIJl" ç/tr( s; LJa)J ec JJ:ú::c.j ~~.1. ce..-i '

53 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here 15Jù Fé~' 5..~~ :'.~~j~=~ 8. 6L'lN~Ve"~ 9. C. tau C\t. \\L (S'jo.,l f\ 10. ';VCf Md: f) 0 CAu fg? Uc0t ~ j 400J S(Ov!.(r 14. '3 d C\. :\~ (J \ LDlp 15. /.jl'vn ltx * l~ll~~o.~~ Irv/~..) L w; ~ UQlk lj4l laa..\ \ç ew~~'nqì I. ca Lo a1 ~ al do ì Jçc1 e.ho/n/a)! CDrl o W~ vja. ~è/\ll ().)q( 1:.- c (L\.\

54 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here 1. ~Á(k ~us13" tt~ ~Al l"e- 46'~lJl-8053 Wjrq(f;b 2. ß tj"uii aud ~ S r' 0 Sl~:IL 1 L :u- W.r- w'/1ll / 3. r\) ~ Ie,. Ih 07 l ll'e. '$ ""L" t~y..uv wil Kt( 4. Lb\'"" ~Sl1' 'L\"L J~~L~ S~, t\b "l\ò \'1ò'3 II vv(z~w e. ~A~ l.~ ÇÇ l:""~'uj s. \, A. ~ c;ør \ ß~ g Ø(f"tJ \p. ~ f'y1rj'i 9 p:,tp. \ 'ô ~ c,-ø (ZA rj~ '7-1?1,..,L- e. L-'ìf' (2. CotV v--.&j 7. CbìÙ a ~ AD S, htlxby st. 6 It ì a.b15'@.ltì vtt ~.. 2-3BA h((~~...m 9. Â\ LLØ'tf' (' Sf fu(;r t~l\~ fll. C; ~ 1.; ç",a,~ VI ç.\ A l 8. K vv '\ Lø'A 1 r n ~ -w ( l/. (e' Lt \ C/l '" s- L.. ::: ~t=5 11, tlr: sf 'l11g= ~~7~1- ~;J 12. ~5~~&vattl w):. ll""d!e dl S' 1'11'1 whl j(.~ Jle,'!O' OJM ~rt 4t;o. ( t, 7F0r- a 1- W ( wat( \' ' 'LL./ pde'ro- ~ r c s.e 0./\ "e (? /1. /,:Jù!/lC~,,.t!.ç- ~\Mb (f qn Lvtt J.

55 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. How dd Address E-mal or phone you get here 1. 4&~hUK u~1rctd'~ ~L- 2. )T t: LJoh fl 3. I?D sed- 5r: ()tll p/)~ 4. Jx (/ Ut DJø~~ S 51 0.%~,j2L b h. tú 5. ;Y\~~ tbk( d- 7 So F ~:h 530-e.J"'zrlf CQ,V 6. ~ ~l lwd)?:~~ai 'D"V (~_ ~\~ L- 1/::A I j ~ 2-1. F7/nøu. 7. fu r Whyf "ull 2 '1/1.,l.((~:t"j-.7~L ~ ~ 8. -l1t\\\~e-\b &u~ b~i1;jî~ t1mt. 9. ~~erlv5~ 1~~( ~ d e g vll VI ~ )L l1'--~~;,~~ M 13. v, )7) '(10 (oj( 9?jc!ó~~ 12. _btl b J=~;::n 3Vf~DlVl ~~ ff~ q 0/ co n VJbL~

56 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name, \f\, ~ 1. \ '" \ '\..~ \ \J 4'1\ 2. ~~ 7. Hm. How dd you get here., ~l' l0 K It::lQ 6J l?l\ v(rv~ff~' L~"1 3. ",J ()~\t ~~(ja kjlt7 P4e ~t, tt \ 4. \f (,\ 1';\ t~l; \ )1 CÅ~~ L L\V 5. SDVrt\S"\ l C~L~L\j(A.À-5 ('f,h ~$f111. ~+~..\. CO v- \ Ñ ejk, r' \ 11\ r ; \~. ;;1....:1' 111/1'1,1 YI,v'lvIVL': ' T Î L'.\.~l \ \ ',\ l-l rrd'ê 7 L- 0 '1' 7Y j ~\ b,-- \c' =CÐ\ a \ I.:Q 1 E 1é': f, í... ) a~) ri' (~V û..' kv, ft G~ ~ j ('Q1/'.,v\JI \ 4( 1 '1 ì \.~. ~ /r (' '\.. ;"' (" \ V.\. :).'..,~..:; \.... ".. " \A ".. \'\. 8.. ;-bæø1/j ~ d;sf'lll'tj:wl SFC tf/o? W*(~ :~.l:~ b2~~fl~ 11., r /L77; ~ ~qc D,I r"loe:~r: Ndz~ Ô.. (,/ /'..A r &7-/.gh~ 5//VR?4,NCt'Cd 12.,ýfM ~ /2 G,ll'1veSF 9lf((7 Wd k Sf c- q If- lùú.lk è; ljr;c J' :,..r) t-.l + fr 17..t f 15. (0 U d. 0. ß 4: S-- 0 ~ lc J çç q'- L ( D 1jf2ru\; ~13~ J (;HQOQ~ q~h \ L&\U WA1JL uje;\ \.

57 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. 2. Name Address E-mal or phone 3. '''a nj &e 11&"- 4. \7íl\ fu-r ut 'LO wtta~ 5. ~(~ V-Lf 6. ~Gd LýLl) / 7. \)ttv- b":"n ~\) 8. l),r (tur 9. Yæ\\e\\o~ \ 10. FeJ 7 Ú~! De../) 1&:1&1~ 11. ll / /)31--6 t...v' í(: 12.llkt ~ crv ; v,4 13. ~ ()\z L.., 1.o '" \ \ \ \'''r0'~. S:f (.:", t l-i P 1_.'",. '\/1,/ ' ~~+ ":'1,'/. (1ft DC;I,\\\ ~\ '-INO~L; S C"-- q / IT How dd you get here etov~ \ ~: ~. (o~ d fv o/t- / tv tdcp \ '?\ W"dtked v1q ß v~~vtl'c1r\lj.~~~yl k'.' J ~(;l\ 1. Ltç"L2S1 ~~UL.eD /J -:3 Æ l?1cs :1 Dr j I ~ q~q. ~-= I. O? J UCllféG~ :ss;s:(cl2\4~ \ L 3760:: r-ìc-j\/0jccc COOC( CAcA \'8"\ -7 7/. l 1-..,.,1 'J / ) I LJLAÆt.f -ãr ~J#3 ( (. P ~ 14.

58 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone \ 1. ~ S'l'h t G.~cA o~l-yb\" (Nj~(tA How dd you get here \ L k 2. 1ex esker... L 4'1 *-~f\d ~cl~\:t:6), I 3. --~ß"t ~S -U 8 ;)f' í \ Loh ~~\ ~.. ~ V01 \. M;r.~\ tòvv-l~"5 4.,'\cJa(.\" S ~r-c,~ '33 t\ cs vjôu.~~ C..oH'C"~ S f: \M:~c.. c.ofv b1j.kv.f1~ ó Clnd \N.~ \. \L..a 5. \Klca qafwrvr ~ ~J7Jl- v - ~o.~ ~/~ ~/I' \ /SL ì. t~.. ~1l:..c? '/ j - (J 6./fC//4vtt~ W lfl 1'(11 ý~l,bl1!4(! (JfY7 ~ law(t:~ 7.M,'yu~. ~ ~. 8. \. e'b (.fñ\~ll S1 rj PA(T~r 4f6 M ' M-CHq,k: ê)ljv"l (011 Q. je-?@ ~~a.. C.fr 0~ ( lj \, vl. :V t1. l le- 9. (ì 11. l(j e CO 'SÆ '5 4SY'V3'l3 Idao.'1~~ 12 T?:...,Ol' tñ'9' fl ~ 'j?,j;ad'" Sf. r'rtæw?!,de lf;1 rm L eat &~~ Q ~ tllu \MW\\L.&* ~~~U() &b.vn~~~ Q ~l_l9 14..r1L j\j/ 1.(. OìvI7..A, Jj- 12('UJM~b;/ól..I...,'jr 0A"tJ _ -=d ste/rbu,cad~@~/.c~ 15DehoYt Sléìnher 1-l/ û; Ie Sf L m u n ì 16. Lv Lll"l.f\ 77/ ( Ie Sf,f C~v~ 1't~~/.cvV NUN, /

59 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. 1. Name Address E-mal or phone Du D0)( 600 OAj 4f trs :s How dd you get here v"! L C?-!J r\ -7cr15Jtk ~&v 6J u.a.". 1y;J.f- to al V Cr c.\o\t 7 ó ßlL\erO st ed~. (/~ B ~1 fa ) e/k. 5. ~l ~e.~\.c,,, ~D 'S de'ls ~~\)M,vs 6. ~ J'p.Y\,3D"2,'5#'VJ f)lttk?,~ 7. ~tl'.f'ual ;S 5() 3 ~ eo \ r-e' \CA) Cu''', \ ro~ 8. D~\1 ~ cl Ne W d'la. 1 :;0 "2) jl e r~ 1.Q J 9. S v Ck1UQ ~ l\ ;jk. st sc.v;e(o@~f~)qwvv 10.~ek. (;a/l I-,~'" Q - f... tt ((:/5 S'f c' t.c.. t ) f"j. f 11. ~1J'l (AY 65~ ~L. ~, PJt\03 Je-tJ.\ f/~l%%.:"; 12. tv&.s q:;s *, '-\ "1'2 feet c,..-it.e.\.r~~.,.t.co,, 13. C \ c, \. ß R~'1 f1 \ l \ ~% V,$ \-AvL~ L ~ ~ k. 4-1 S ' 4- ~ ),008 ct WKt~ 14. LCUl2l A Vro Tõ;"j)E; 2S1 ~ JÒ'S~ t'f 1l ~ ;/òr Lx ) teowíy1v\ J 5\ M 114 ~I~ v (~ t 1I (I (Ih W Ct I ~ 16. Ate-X ~QUd ~OO ~\(2/ Sl LO~u~clC6~~\\\.t.lv,-

60 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. How Na~e. ~ddre5.5. E-malO;QO~ 1. ~~~d SB C qðæe ~ (1~S t- ~ 2. At' C::?5 ~vj O~\r~ W~.-d:'tf yl, J 3. A S/, Q l."t I'alz BH/t g- 4-1!1J."_ rr :r. r'ûh,.1. Ç0 IJ~ tw CIØ ;1'\ W'l5l ~rv\ 72-1 (Jak. 5-1 SF fi 9'W 'f 'ì,n.&lark- dd J (W4levs-\. r- çsj---= 'Co U\\ X. 9. :3uLt-,UL 1~~ 10. JAIM\S fvôty rv.c,\.u. I ' CA~ 14. EWIlL M~ \.\ 15._~l 16. \wml\r ( L!:J &It. _. lv\lvc.'1e ~ 2- F ( I Wl 15 &l '(t:~'f " G7U. ~V\t. It-l'f\~,t lzq Ogk. ~t' &:~fr"'ì1.lo( _C~ UJu/l( ~lk ~ ~1 \\1öj g. C\C\ \~ "J ojt \; P\ Ik., ~. ~

61 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here 1. &to 2. ()eu ß'S Gà~be"5 " 3. ~. 1/ alk 11"j ftlìle n v IJ~Ò~ tv: I.( om r e(~ftj te J 4. ff f a Ì)1 VJq (kj 5. ~ _ ~(. ~; t:r:t IP' gë7f?r4i3l. 'C'/M ;; o4e c.y,n ~ 6. ~ok f. Øt I) cat ;)ta! Sf '2~6cd-~. 7. jevil) Oot h Yrw./I:" L.kxU 8. ~M -S-;) LvA-~ LJ/l/C- 9. N WALL 10. F.R.e l IJE JlA4: 73 oa K. U'''l.lt~IC.' CQ ~.-, r( (Xv' \t \ o't) \ ~ _ J 11. mvv,1y?'~ Al l'\'! h 1 \W\CJ-t et~; I, \J (Å \ p ' (tv 1\ h I/I,, báu y S~yø'' ldß.l!lj f4b D ( ) j!w 13. ~~.. \r~1\ \ /,yi\('ríf 'lllh ~ t 14. 5~"'b J ì' J CIA M u- R t 0. \ 00, CòV 15.~løv NJ' V1t1A 84/ Log~ 16.~ \005 LÀ\flYtWfu h\\0e~ful5 Gl ';õ Q;)~.. Uù~\

62 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone you get here. Q n. IAJ tj)_e 1. bßnn(l. 6nd q lkwl(áun c\~ (lótföod (~\I1(Ar((H~~ C.Olr 2. RükRft 1-l..Q ì, ()JOJJL :: ~J~~ ~;~~~:~::~~1 :~~WAL~ 5. è\v ngue-v'(vo.l.lj ~~' A~ A\\JV\Qý1r;y!!; 6. ' :5 tv'oá J \- - Sf c A 1 \~ II' S tv.'-d~-.-.. J" y-/,jj. c~_ ~ ì _. I "" ~!\l\ ~ ~~(.kfl o 10. \: l\(v~ r' ~L q(q \NA\l-r ~ 13. ::, '\ "014wV 'Dr W~ 14. ~~ 'ßS wje.s \ 15. 2\40& ßkYl t1; w.l~/ì :r~ ~~~Q.y\~ qloö OA- \ ~ -----_._-,..," How dd ' I / ~-" ~~LK Nw L ()~ ~/J9 ~;! C- WC\\k: L-~ ~ ~L- I1I tvjlca J ~ u. c

63 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. v ~~4 Name Address E-mal or phone you get here 1. :/t'ej tdjlø ~ /AJ!Rc!f/IWfb-g/pft,ft: 2. MIl/ (L tylkm C:~( el ll)'l~(4 qà),e Wr~ Q 'f.. ftn- ~ How dd J II "JL I~ 3..5f~løJ li :laø'" 3"~ 41k'/fA. S"""" e ~ /J!(ßA. ~ 4. et (th~ (f ~ ~ -- c.k ~ 5. ~. 'lcf kl hllulsm~p()~' CL 6. ~. L.",r\o"V~\:@~~\...to" 7. 0:' V 01" 0V ~ 8. ~At-LI D I\J1lu- Cc 9. '3~'1~NtS=cs fð. ~ø~ \CoÇfet c:.f~ 10. ~ -r~ 78'v~ ka;~.t'"e.?,i'go'" ~! 11. ~ a rí~ A kl/ ú ms 01 L.. 4;' e ty tl t; ç,. ( Iv t.b /Y 01.. a /Y h,, K It'A (1.;1 &.t fs lay. l e 4\. \ r "E4,0, &~Q. ) 13. Gk& CA5~ "If 9 :ïdfe"ß, s-r :t(l &0.,, ~._,. 14. El"I.-~ ~AR.Ld\Nt- 410 bæj.n6r 'ST. ~u-61r1..g 15. J?N Aù(t\)rU5 ß~ ss+ ì 6S ~ CL"l\OM,J~ ~.cæyv 16. ß /2, A IV Ltv F G hf r 'f'j1?11 re L f. (; 7 1'" \ c Oè J. Ay c~

64 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. How dd 1. ~. tt u~ e. A. ddres5 E-mal t ö or phone ~.. Vll~ yo:;et here 2. --æ~,s1 61.c CL:.%g", \'t~ 3. -:~"\ - ~ 3"31-lVbs-Ú~ :3 lj f\ - :~.sg. ì J'ì2 (trj 4. Y.fs Q"oll Vcß I) 45b S. \ Col res:: 4 î -7"14-1 CJ q (j)(sl' lr ) 5. tjwch, ~s. L ~ 3 v.~ st. 11') "'f1. C; (, q'b -, ( LJle) 6. ~f6 ~~ \ )LB-I5I~öRt. 7. ß.tt 1J ù\, u-l b'- S n \\ "" ( S \ ù) "l'ò"ì - \0 \0 l' K"" \.\) 8. ~ 11&v-U /"lw1"vrt5l. Åfr(f1A ~.t.ji U@7 ~~t 9. Ac't~ a, f?;t l0faf/,.c:l",!r /-" e 1""'". dj". 10. V,q"N V".- f7l #S;-c, ",c 2 /"@/64,o.c'A 11. j~ úm 1k~.41 vje.bç ~CY ch~ u- 12. G~ r 1 fzl-h- _ 3~q 0'trC0 rz roj+er.~~)mct/ I o~ S+ VI \ Y' X. S J 'P 0- vn u. Zùe.s-\"v t., "" \ LO,,,JCÅ1 L \ ~ 8 efc ~. w- ',,õ:n"67f' ~ " "7 r ~~ 15. \.\.~JCA flr:/.zi Scal D. /)pmhh@ twlm CO.J-1'~ 16.-C~1 '--, \\g S"'-='t~ Ca~.~Q/@~~Q-

65 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. L ~ Name Address E-mal or phone 2. ~ I~ ss'l- o3ç-s- 3. ~"t) Yo 3 Wa Ie 4. J?t,J\ ~ú /Ø' (n"'/ Oc, lv~l. o n ~ 5. ll~ C\ Sj G.(M S 1 t ~.\ "". ~ \1 j(h ". ~ ó W' W~ 1I "' 6. l,wul C (J 1% 111\ VW (t/çt' 1;:~'J Cro@F (.(() ~L 7.!111 ~. u-b wa(igral. I How you get dd oajk,p!a1&."", ""."J. 8. ~ll. D\ 01 es -V I vl m (f5k-ft.\ IA v. yf ftl ;~ es 4.\V,- n encu, lgvt' 9. W--. N Aíh ~ os Sc.. $; "t~()""9s "14;15 e)"".c.~j\ 10. a~j,l~ ~ ~'D-\. ~~.~ wj 11..-vl Beav- Z~3 MYL:\: ~:\'M ~t'a~c 21~~()?tLtoo 'p: \ ~ t) ;3 q ""911 :, \-', s GQ\) \).6) jmc:~' C '" ' o~ 13. 0uk-~~~~ W w~d-~ c:bj~rg l1r1,(),~~ 14. Y ø. J? E e b -0 r;(/", cr t 5 f Yb- Ie e 0. fj' ~ j It 1\,/. C o/v w (ll K S,Sf BlSßA \1M 6~ fa. be. -:Q:~.sßAut\@G.HA IL \.AL/( 16. ~1. ~ì4's Jd.r PÙ~KLc~.t ~~0tA~~~.~ here

66 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Sole! fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here 1. (I. rjlt'tw~fc ~37 tb54t MMdtÌ1 ~. Q..41~ 2. -.,tbì&" 4-S thahl- 8'~é?r:Y;Çf, ~/t- 3. ~p~/ 170~ JvAT~l#~~ttY~.~ ~ :: 4., ~ \ 3? ìjo IV V A- 9s 1 f t,j Ifa- 5. ~D ~/N5lø 253 ujml b2g:t68 6. S l1,. (0W\v) 5 YA- s-tt "" '1/ J. 52-7/6 2 W~ 7.15~c' de. G-o./~ /7 LtL-(7Sc ualler -ìucj(~ 8. ).), '..L 0 c...,,,-'10 F l l'of 9. ~IOO I ~ (Sr J:36620 vvcjh 10.!@tm Møìc dq~ "315-lí:%Y ItAtK 11. _~ r e 1/~ f\ e4l~ ""5 ().:5 Sh ~ I\e Lfl í - t.z- L'l9tl -a /It 12. ~h( ~ 'tc\ ~1t Sf q-(c; ß/'r Zaog lí1t 13. '6tRd~vJ 1fVAJ ac(. 9~/v"v 4r)- çnal,.~s u/mc 14. çl ~l4 ljo; ~ - Sf. ~15-f(?-"3~\ 15. \f1f\ ~ 'ra 41-, t 1\ & h + djlfjr"lin1ê.jic ltcj ' e~\' 16. ',)' VlbIßI :prrn,qn t7rh~l+ ~Il'" hd

67 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Cf~ How Name Address E-mal or phone dd you get here hOv~~~n~ 2=S~~:: ~~PU':"S,.~ 12. ~~ '1\l Uß~I:=;~;'Í/í(~. :: í 13. l VlQ. S 0fRI'~\c"' L..ß 9l \ ~,:: vj aalu. 14. b~~ Jv\ 'ç\ ~q S -\\ \ \VVA..~ l"tj \ k f Ló1V1J LÆ(~ ~L(o rlljjufl w~ 16.tboílL ~\\e.t.dul- 110 ~tø\ út 1f6 ~lj;. torr ~\~d~

68 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here ìf-vo.(1 6 ~ Ltf\ -. 'r: ~ ~ I (t:- \~5\ 5Uv~ y-\. )1- :2410~~ 'S ~J úvc h_iý~~s. ì )' r= cj I( c - ( S \ ~S.r!~bK0l. ;CVG J." *WÀl-~tf 5"1 4:sí-21:l; W ~í) ;/'o'%lw'j\ç /~/~-1)~'/lr" /,lj.?j (. /J q /oy 9.,I Utl0 ~ 10. Î/ ('1 '0 :$-1K. /h S f 9lt l/, ú,1.'( Q ry, ~a.l\~-:f ( n\jo lO'(;...." Q. \ f ( ~ lú1~pm.. ~,jyl~c9~ 4 UM ù 1;tSlI;st. sý '1LtltJ lo-(~~~~ ~..~ f ~ Ç;\:. b\= a. elu wcv'. II.r (J u ~ k )LeIh!S/7, 16.

69 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. 1. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here W:lkJ (4 'c êl:plt. R. 'ktf 4. E~ ~L btl\lw\\j 511 W"'\~~ S-t. L,ó\ 5. \.ø Q" 2'61 \.owb", ~. ~",\\ì M G '1 pi'?/ /3 ltú,ic'",; í. :;S~~SA; Tt -#,,or ~ 10. ~. Jß ú ClCo.~ 11 (Iemmt f~~ ~Sq \. VJfAl~ l~.fdt ;t?i:t~ ~st 13~u\7. rs.f1ki.-j' e Ö:t1 am,. '4 I ~ 14. ~Sll A'fL'9 AfolkJ 15. Se.",,, K o,, 15/ 5L,,: 55 /fir B \~ J _ /\ /~ ~ w- S. V ~.~ I\e)~ld-~ 16. l' L oo~ 120 0' ~lq to/'òx.f brnù

70 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. How dd you get here 1. ellt~qßj 1-Ltl~ vcäls) 2. BoLA :W;Sc t,q-) Bel. ~. l,1;~ t (~ W'~ \~~ r \' 3. ~~~ L.(Y c,ó CO ~d\\~ 'S ~ YJ~\ ~ Co 4. ~1L~ ~1 Î-1~ W~~ ~ ' VA \~,v"9 5. $ooe ÅVaC'OO y3qy 11'KS-/. sr c4: cftj?rct to~ ) 6. fu~ e. Pps 055 \1r~.,M-llE: S'l \.çt l.es.m: l'cu\ IAf\~ t :... ~. ~ Name Address E-mal or phone. r J~~\,'ù 14. C;COk~:yv Y lj 'l~5. (!; ('I4 (Z.-d-,,,J:IA l\l~' \t 16. (Al. Cé 1? ~~ ta ~'t r I(

71 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. How dd Name Address E-mal or phone you get here 1. N e.'r C-Ðpe'f4Itl 4tr"DO..~e... $5-11"-1$3 LlUúI K 2. S y O~ H-v"6lL h (tw t (;1$ A --f '(0 (0.---~ ~-.J.n 3. ~~L ~Kl \., 74 q ~z.:rl' '- \. 4. ~ bv&r ~Db~ ;l. ~C; D~bltel,dk 5. Ce: ~ô:. 1O(n:'fV~J ''lfp?;-1lf79 IAI k- ::~~~?'~~~r ~ '..~ 6. ~v 1,L"A OIJ/,1 (Jl.p t!(q - (( /" wjj \ ' Q" ì \.q ì c( 3 lac. \ CJ 10. f\. A.._ -J 2 Wt.hsJ. 'f.. 11A#" ~rv.. e (f.../. ~ " LL 11. ~Q ~ì:,~. 52q tk~ t~dtfí~,k N:\ ~~") rucq ÆJ--, I Co/J a.d \Wlr t111\g\ \Jh Ttl Wí Lv g \t'vtvl@r~ levdlø 9. :;. '1: C\ V\ n lq Ç;XlN '.t YlìSSk~l(j J ãrncd L l..j CÆ \ ~ 14. J t h 1\ n y &%6 J~ r, ì' Y)II \ tvfl l. \ligi( t: \. 15. Rc~ -ç,vy- rohf~rø7@;~a-l::,~()mj,letl 16. Út-;;r; Q f'li(\el JtfletG l\(. ~ ~

72 vve ne UJlUt:l ~1t:1 n::u ~,;IU~. n.~...'"..._...._ the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. How dd ~/JJ N~me Address. E-mal or phone, you get here vl') 1. \\M ~~\\L ~lçly~6jyv 2.IA~fV f' í \p~ r I ~-'-- 1" l ~'. U/ - 'w~ I~ r, ~(Â~ ~~ ~(M ;f.(~ \1. b -1 q; b~ (/J?T. gf#/-fý,;. j~ v" A' t' ß ;~ ' \1~v Sf "'U\L!,..eA.",vt":'" v. :: ~ d Lotet~~. 11. C/" nu' s íß,,~ 3~'6 j %,ÌI - 'f,~ " 2 q~ sx p" ójolrr "" n 4l \.,.II'5)~4\n5f U. Thhl \ or~ 4/2 ~3t ~~(~ -~Qn 1qÇ-L ~ (~",,I,t'J ~) 13. J~ tl~ LOO OVßQtR fh/ 211 Sl, u~ qy 117- IA)útl'-tcl 1J.,Ã1/ C I- n. L4 et t! l? 6-e)T I!"l 1' " ~ 4EL...o EfFU'1l flfj "Iv,A 15. A-"( (jw "13 Al:rN VW (@ ~~.Rlr.."",1f/( 16.=: í)ovvs ~ \,w\j %tß~

73 We the undersgned resdents and customers of the Café du Solel fnd the Café's presence to be an asset to the communty and support the proposal to allow evenng jazz and poetry readngs at the Café. Name Address E-mal or phone How dd you get here 1. t~\e&f\, O~I\ 7jq wøjlú Ulvl?) C2D"1 -gq) (p. 3 0r-Jte-. ~~,II LfC(. 1'rJk ~\ C o\.e(~~e vntnotúa 2. JltYt) ~ 12-1~:t ft. Cl:J~) -sß-lscce 4. J1l Kr1~L M t v\t-rl-f'/ ttl(,-v4vc( 5. Shar (Y ßpv./en J:l,)A /-r/~y 6. ' ' tc-lg C\1IV\.. ~. Co

74 Jmmy Terrell 149 Fllmore Street San Francsco, CA RECEIVED MAY May 3,2010 CITY & COUNTY OF S.F. PLANNING DEPARTMENT RECEPTON DESK Subject: OPPOSITION TO - Case No C Fllmore St (CU appl) Ms. Sharon M. Young The Plannng Department 1650 Msson Street Sute 400 San Francsco, CA Ths letter s to OPPOSE the request for a permt to allow acoustc musc at ths locaton. The precedng busness n ths locaton was an establshment called Movda. Ths establshment contnued for a number of years to have DJs and bands n ths locaton wthout a permt, and very loud musc. Even after numerous meetngs wth the owners of Movda and the then Polce Captan of the Northern Polce Staton, Kevn Dllon, the owners contnued to volate the law and dsturb the neghbors, ncludng neghbors who sgned the petton to allow ths actvty at Café du Sole!. Hereafter the Northern Polce Staton wll be referred to NPS. After numerous calls to the polce, neghbors' opposton to lve musc at the 200 Fllmore Street locaton, whch lead to the owners of Movda's nablty to obtan an entertanment permt, they closed the Movda establshment. Shortly thereafter, we were nformed that Café du Sole was openng n ths locaton. We met wth Mr. Mustapha Hakkou and hs busness partner at the home of Phlp Sarrs located at 129 Fllmore to dscuss the use at the locaton, and was assured by both owners there was NO INTENTION to ever have lve musc there. Mr. Hakkou and hs busness partner both stated ths would be a famly envronment café, and a totally dfferent venue. They even brought samples of some of the food they would be servng, once opened. In attendance at ths meetng were Phlp Sarrs, Valle Brown, Cedrc Holley, Gregory Bartnng, and a host of other neghbors who had endured the nghtmare of Movda. Only after we were assured by Mr. Hakkou and hs busness partner, that there would be NO LIVE musc at ths locaton, dd we all feel comfortable wth Café du Solel openng. All was good for a number of years. Approxmately 3 years ago, Mr. Hakkou had lve jazz at Café du Solel to celebrate hs brthday. My partner, Phl Horowtz spoke wth Mr. Hakkou regardng the lve jazz, as we could hear t nsde our home. Mr. Hakkou stated t was smply for hs brthday celebraton. Wthn 3 weeks, Mr. Hakkou was havng lve acoustc jazz (wthout a lcense) at Café du Solel every Sunday. Ths s to reference the pont n the letter dated October 4, 2009 by Mr. Bll Maher wrtten to NPS Captan Croce Cascato that "there has not been a sngle run to the premses snce t opened several years ago", (Attachment 1). Ths unfortunately, s a false statement because durng the tme that Mr. Hakkou was havng lve jazz on Sunday, we were placng nose complants wth the NPS. One partcular Sunday, durng a lve jazz performance (stll wthout permt) at Café du Solel, Phl Horowtz went to Café du Solel and nvted Mr. Hakkou to come to our house so that he could hear what we hear. Mr. Hakkou agreed wth us that the lve jazz could be heard clearly nsde our house wth our wndows closed and the doors at Café du Solel closed, and assured us that he would not have lve musc agan,

75 and the lve jazz performances would stop. Of course, ths was also after numerous nose complants reported to the NSP. One problem wth ths locaton havng lve musc s that t sts dagonally to our house. The property at Fllmore sts out a lttle further than our property. There s a walkway between the two propertes. Ths s where the sound echoes and bounces back and forth between the two propertes. Our 3 year old son's bedroom s at the end of ths walkway, and we could hear the lve jazz n hs bedroom, whch dsturbed hs nap tme. Our son's bedtme s 8:00 PM, so the proposed lve musc would nterfere wth hs sleepng at nght. San Francsco, Calforna Plannng Code, Artcle 7 - Neghborhood Commercal Dstrcts, Secton Entertanment, Other clearly states: (Attachment 2) A retal use, other than adult entertanment, as defned n Secton of ths code, whch provdes lve entertanment, ncludng dramatc and muscal performances, and/or operates as a dance hall whch provdes amplfed taped musc for dancng on the premses, ncludng but not lmted to those defned n Secton 1060 of the Polce Code, and whch s adequately soundproofed or nsulated so as to confne ncdental nose to the premses, etc. Acoustc jazz s loud. Instruments normally nclude drums, and often wnd nstruments such as trumpets, saxophones, and the lke. Ths faclty s NOT soundproofed n any fashon, as we have experenced, and anyone can see by lookng at t. The door entrance to Café du Solel faces our house, and when the doors are opened and closed, the musc was even louder n our home and our son's bedroom. Even when Café du Solel's doors were closed and our wndows were closed, the acoustc jazz could stll be heard clearly nsde our house. Durng the sunny days, Café du Solel has a habt of openng the entrance doors because there s no ar condtonng n ths faclty. The photo of Café du Solel wth doors open was taken on Saturday, May 1, 2010 (Attachment 3). Ths s a frequent occurrence. If you notce, Mr. Hakkou s n the pcture, and s aware that hs doors are open, and on most occasons, all day. cannot agree under any crcumstances to have lve musc at ths locaton unless all soundproofng requrements have been completed pror, as clearly defned by the San Francsco Plannng Codes. That would nclude: 1) nstall sound proof nsulated double doors at the entrance to contan nose nsde, 2) construct an entry vestbule wth a second set of sound proof nsulated doors, and have someone statoned at those doors durng lve performances to ensure both set of doors are not opened at the same tme, 3) the nstallaton of double paned nsulated wndows. Presently, the majorty exteror at ths locaton s sngle paned glass, 4) Install ar condtonng so that doors wll not be opened durng the warm days, and 5) a sound check from our home at 149 Fllmore be conducted so nothng can be heard nsde our house wth the wndows closed. As needed, determne what nstruments are so loud they can be heard nsde our house despte soundproofng and prohbt them from beng used. 'ì -- chme (1) Copy of Bll Maher's letter dated October 4, 2009 (2) San Francsco, Calforna Plannng Code (3) Photograph of doors open at Café du Solel taken Saturday, May 1, 2010.

76 I SAN FRANCIS1 0 PLANNI G DEPARTMENT SAN FRANCISCO LANNING COMMISSION NOTICE OF HEARING Notce s hereby gven to the ge ral publc that an applcaton nvolvng the property descrbed below has been fled wth the PIa ng Department for revew as set forth n the Plannng Code. The Plannng Commsson wll hold a l BUC HEARING on ths tem and on other matters on Thursday, MAY 13, 2010, at 1:30 P.M. or later please cal on Monday, MAY 10,2010 or thereafter for a recorded message gvng a more p ecse hour that the hearng for ths specfc matter wl begn), n Cty Hall, 1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodley Place, Room 400. CASE NO C: 200 FILLMpRE STREET, northeast corner of Flmore and Waller Streets; Lot 020 n Assessor's Block 0859: Request for Condtonal Use authorzaton under Sectons 'ãñd 303'-of the Plannrg Code t allow an "oler entért.nnt"-ušé'wtln'an exstng legãl-- nonconformng large fast food rest urant dba Café Du Solel located.on the ground floor of the twostory resdental and commercal uldng wthn an NC-1 (Neghborhood Commercal Cluster) Dstrct and a 40-X Heght and Bul Dstrct Msson Sl. Sute 400 San Frncsco, CA Recepton: Fax: Plannng Informaton: The proposal wl nvolve addng coustcal muscal entertanment (.e. jazz) and poetr readng to the exstng restaurant between th hours of 6 p.m. to 10 p.m. on Thursday, 6 p.m. to 11 p.m. on Frday and Saturday, and 12 p.m. t 9 p.m. on Sunday. There wl be no tenant mprovements made wthn the exstng commercal spa or changes made to the exstng buldng envelope. For furter nformaton, call Sh on M. Young at (415) and ask about Case Number C. You are recevng ths notce becau e you ether own property wthn a t radus of the subject property. If you are nterested n vewng the plans, please call the planer whose name s stated below. Please call one day n a vance so that the plans can be ready for you at the Planng Department's "Pck Up" box on the urth (4th) floor at 1650 Msson Street. Persons who are unable to attend e scheduled Planng Commsson hearng may submt wrtten comments regardng ths case to S aron M. Young at the Planng Departent, 1650 Msson Street, Sute 400, San Francsco, CA Comments receved by 11:00 a.m. the day of the hearng wl be made a pa: of the offcal record and wl be brought to the attenton of the Plannng Commsson. Comments whch cannot be delver d to the Planng Commsson by noon on the day of the hearng may be taken drectly to the hearn at the locaton lsted above. Comments receved at 1650 Msson Street after the noon deadlnes wl e placed n the project fe, but probably canot be brought to the attenton of the Planng Commss n at the publc hearng. Pursuant to Governent Code 65 09, f you challenge, n court, the approval of a condtonal use, you may be lmted to rasng onl those ssues you or someone else rased at the publc hearng descrbed n ths notce, or n wr en correspondence delvered to the Planng Commsson at, or pror to, the publc hearng. Lawrence B. Badner Zonng Admnstrator

77 I I I BILL MAHER '133 WAU mm SAN FRNCISCO CA (1-15) 606,522 ßIIMDAOLCOM! '. I! ;, Ca C roce C. as~ I Nortem Staon ; 1125 Flmore Stret San Francsco, Ca I I Ocer ftf l/ I? "I P Ix : f\*,l~v\ w; Y J- 4, 2009 Der Captan: I Thank you for ~l9ng th tme to meet wt me the other day, t was very graous of you. As we dscss the ~f6 du Sollel on the comer of Walle and Flmore Stts whl be askng the San Francs pannn. tf.' ommlsson for pennlsson to play Acstc Jaz only, on the earle part of Thursay through S turday and earler on Sunday.. Specally werre requestng Plannng Commsson approval of non amplfed musc and potr redngs frm:! I PM untl10 PM orl Thursay nghts PM untl 11 PM o~ Frday and sarday nghts 3. 2 PM untl 8 PM on~: da nghts The Ca has en opn for seral years and wt the suppo of Innumerable neghbors (over 50 on the pett ) ~ey have had sdlk tables and chars fo the last fe years. Unlke t prr, the M. da Lounge, ther has not ben a sngle run to the premss snce It opned severl years apo. j The prent ap Ilclon has the supprt of over 600 sgnatures fr customers supprtng the dea of 'nng acust Jaz and Poetr. As you are wed awre one bloc up on Heght thre are many &hues fo late nght drnkng and entertnmet. I wll be go for th of us n the neghborh wh no longer wsh to Pa Hear untl 2 AM to have an altmat mor lad ba altm e venue. We wl reuest tht a codt be plac that the sale to any new ower wll reure n!opportnt fo publc testmony and ree be th PIaMng Commss to furter ec th area. Agan, I appref. your takng th tme to dsss the proposal and your suppoe commets. ths s a g. propol, support by th comunt. It wlll enhance th neghbo and reu : rather than Increse the demands on yor of. We appreate your support of th pr al. I look forwrd to contnung to worj wth yo and Ofr Gallaher and If I can provde you tmh any more Innnatn please let me know. ~~ Bl Maher al Maher 433 Waller Stt, San Francsco CA 91117, blmaher@aolcqrn (415) C

78 Muncode Page of6 1\ LV ~ ~ \, r' -t 1... _'.'~'''~'.''_'.~ ~_. ' "".'A ~~~ '_""'_'A, ~~~.~n~ ~.~",._._...'~'~=-"' San Francsco, Calforna, Plannng Code ;:;: ARTICLE 7: - NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL DISTRICTS :::: SEC NC-1 - NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL CLUSTER QISTRICT.;::: SEC NG-1- NEIGHBORHOOI;LGOMMERCIAL CL,U.sTER DSTRICT. NC-1 Dstrcts are ntended to serve as local neghborhood shoppng dstrcts, provdng convenence retal goods and servces for the mmedately surroundng neghborhoods prmarly durng daytme hours. These NC-1 Dstrcts are characterze~ by ther locaton n resdental neghborhoods, often n outlyng areas of the Cty. The commercal ntensty of these dstrcts vares.~many of these dstrcts have the lowest ntensty of commercal development n the Cty, generally consstng of small clusters wth three or more commercal establshments, commonly grouped around a corner; and n some cases short lnear commercal strps wth low-scale, nterspersed mxed-use (resdental-commercal) development. Buldng controls for the NC-1 Dstrct promote low-ntensty development whch s compatble wth the exstng scale and character of these neghborhood areas. Commercal development s lmted to one story. Rear yard requrements at all levels preserve exstng backyard space.. NC-1 commercal use provsons encolrage the full range of neghborhood-servng convenence retal sales and servces at the frst story provded that the use sze generally s lmted to 3,000 square feet. However, commercal uses and features whch could mpact resdental lvablty are prohbted, such as auto uses, fnancal servces, general advertsng sgns, drve-up facltes, hotels, and late-nght actvty; eatng and drnkng establshments are restrcted, dependng upon the ntensty of such uses n nearby commercal dstrcts. Housng development n new buldngs s encouraged above the ground story n most dstrcts. Exstng resdental unts are protected by prohbtons of conversons above the ground story and lmtatons on demoltons. SEC NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL CLUSTER DISTRICT NC-1 ZONING CONTROL TABLE NC-1 No. IZonna Cateaorv 1& References Controls BUILDING STANDARDS, ' Heght and Bulk Lmt l ,105,106, ,260, Vares , 271 See Zonng Map Addtonal 5 feet for NC-1 parcels wth a commercal use on the ground floor wthn the boundares of Sargent Street to Orzaba Avenue to Lobos Street to Plymouth Avenue to Farellones Street to San Jose Avenue to Alemany Boulevard to 19th Avenue to Randolph Street to Montcello Street and back to Sargent Street. see Lot Sze , P up to 4,999 sq. ft.; Per Development) C 5,000 sq. ft. & above Rear Yard 130, 134, Requred at grade level and above (al (el Street Frontaae Requred Awnng P 136.1(a) CanoDv ~ Marauee I Street Trees 1 Requred, 143 COMMERCIAL AND INSTITUTIONAL STANDARDS AND USES Floor Area Rato 102.9,102.11, to 1 124(a) (b) &HTMRequest=http%3a%2fO/Ó2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/2010

79 Mun~.;ode Page 2 of Use Sze P up to 2,999 sq. ft.; Non-Resdental) C 3,000 sq. ft. & above Off-Street Parkng, 150, , Generally, none requred f occuped Commercalll nsttutonal ,204.5 floor area s less than 5,000 sq. ft. ~~ 151, 16Ho) Off-Street Freght Loadng 150, , Generally, none requred f gross floor area s less than 10,000 sq. ft. I Hb) Outdoor Actvty Area P f located n front; C f located elsewhere j 145.2(a) f10.25 Drve-Up Faclty I I P f recessed 3 ft.; IWalk-Up Faclty C f not recessed, 145.2(b) rt10.27 Hours of Operaton P 6 a.m.-11 p.m.; T C 11 p.m.-2 a.m , General Advertsng Sgn 262, , J 608, Busness Sgn 262, , P I 608, Hf) Other Sgns 262, , P ; 608, (c) (d) (a), No. Zonng References NC-1 Category I Controls bv StOry st 2nd I 3rd Resdental P Converson rt10.39 Resdental P C Demolton F Retal Sales and Servces Other Retal 790.1a2 P# Sales and Servces Not Lsted Belowl Bar ~ P# Full-Servce P# Restaurant Large Fast Food Restaurant ~mall Self ' C# ~ervce Restaurant Lauor Store P Move Theater Adult Entertanment Other C Entertanment Fnancal Servce, Lmted a P Fnancal Iservce ' Medcal!l P Iservce &HTMRequest=http%3a%2flIo2f1brar.mUncod... 4/29/2010

80 lvíun..ode Page 1 of5 San Francsco, Calforna, Plannng Cod,e ;;;; ARTIG.L_U; - NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL DISTRICTS ;;;; SEC USES PERMITTED IN NElGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL DISTRICTS. ;:;: SEC USES PERMITT,;J:;U~ NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL DISTRICTS. A use the specfc purpose for whc~ a propert or buldng s used, occuped, mantaned, or leased. Whether or not a use s permtted n a specfc dstrct s set forth or summarzed and cross-referenced n Sectons through of ths Code for each dstrct class.. (a) Use Categores. The uses, functons, or actvtes, whch are permtted n each Neghborhood Commercal Dstrct class nclude those lsted below by zonng control category and number and cross-referenced to the Code Secton contalnlnq.. h t d e f e nton.. I ecton I onng ControlNumber "ateaoresof Use I No. Ifor UsesDefnton I.24 Outdoor Actvty Area Drve-Up Faclty Walk-Up Faclty.27 Hours of Operaton.38 Resdental Converson I Resdental Demolton.40 Other Retal Sales and Servces.41 Bar.42 Full-Servce Restaurant.43 Large Fast-Food Restaurant ~ Small Self-Servce Restaurant ~ Lquor Store.46 Move Theater "dult Entertanment Other Entertanment.49 Fnancal Servce.50 Lmted Fnancal Servce.51 Medcal Servce.52 Personal Servce Busness or Professonal Servce ~ Massage Establshment &HTMRequest=http%3a%2fUI2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/2010

81 Muncode.82 Other Insttutons, Small.83 Publc Use Page 4 of Medcal Cannabs Dspensary, Resdental Use Communty Resdental Parkng (b) Use da~. Lmtatons. The uses pjrmtted n Neghborhood Commercal Dstrcts are ether prncpal, condtonal, accessory, or temporary uses as stated n ths Secton, and nclude those uses set forth or summarzed and cross-referenced n the zonng control categores as lsted n Paragraph (a) n Sectons through of ths Code for each dstrct (1) Permtted Uses. All p~rmtted uses shall be conducted wthn an enclosed buldng n Neghborhood Commercal Dstrcts, uhless otherwse specfcally allowed n ths Code. Exceptons from ths requrement are: uses whch, when located outsde of a buldng, qualfy as an outdoor actvty area, as defned n Secton of ths Code; adcessory off-street parkng and loadng and other uses lsted below whch functon prmarly as open-ar uses, or whch may be approprate f located on an open lot, outsde a buldng, or wthn a I d h. f h' C d oartallv enclosed buld no, subect to other lmtatons of ths Artcle 7 an ot er sectons 0 t s o e. No. Zonna Control Caterorv.56 utomoble Parkna I.57 utomotve Gas Staton.58 utomotve Servce :Staton.60 utomotve Wash I.61 Automoble Sale or Rental.81 Other Insttutons, LarQe (selected).83 Publc Use (selected).95 Communty Resdental Parkng No. onna Control CateQorv.56 utomoble Parknu.57..utomotve Gas Staton.58 utomotve Servce: Staton.60 utomotve Wash.61 utomoble Sale or;rental.81 ther Insttutons. L!aroe (selected).83 Publc Use (selected).95 Communty Resdental Parkna If there are two or more uses n a structure and none s classfed below under Secton 703.2(b)(1 )(C) of ths Code as accessory, then each of these uses wll be consdered separately as ndependent prncpal, condtonal or temporary uses. (A) Prncpal Uses. Prncpal uses are permtted as of rght n a Neghborhood Commercal Dstrct, when so ndcated n Sectons through of ths Code for each dstrct class. (8) Condtonal Uses. Condtonal uses are permtted n a Neghborhood Commercal Dstrct when authorzed by the Plannng Commsson; whether a use s condtonal n a gven dstrct s ndcated n Sectons through Condtonal uses are subject to the provsons set forth n Sectons 178, 179, 303, and 316 through of ths Code. () An establshment whch sells beer or wne wth motor vehcle fuel s a condtonal use, and shall be governed by Secton 229. () Notwthstandng any other provson of ths Artcle. a change n use or demolton of a move theater use, as set forth n Secton , shall requre condtonal use authorzaton. Ths Subsecton shall not authorze a change n use f the new use or uses are otherwse prohbted. () Notwthstandng any other provson of ths Artde, a change n use or demolton of a general grocery store use, as defned n Secton (a), whch use exceeds 5,000 gross square feet shall requre condtonal use authorzaton. Ths Subsecton shall not authorze a change n use f the new use or uses are otherwse prohbted. (C) Accessory Uses. Except as prohbted n Secton 728 and subject to the lmtatons set forth below and n Sectons (Accessory Uses for Dwellng Unts n Rand NC Dstrcts), (Dwellng Unts Accessory to Other Uses), and (Parkng and Loadng as Accessory Uses) of ths Code, a related mnor use whch s ether necessary to the &HTMRequest=http%3a%2fUIo2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/201 (

82 Muncode Page 5 of 5 operaton or enjoyment of a lawful prncpal use or condtonal use, or s approprate, ncdental and subordnate to any such use, shall be permtted as an accessory use when located on the same lot. Any use whch does not qualfy as an acæssory use shall be classfed as a prncpal or condtonal use, unless t qualfes as a temporary use under Sectons 205 through of ths Code. No use wll be consdered accessory to a permtted prncpal or condtonal use whch nvolves or requres any of the followng: I () The use of more than 1/3 of the total floor area occuped by such use and the prncpal or condtonal use to whch t s acæssory, except n the case of accessory off-street parkng and loadng; () Any bar, restaurant, other entertanment,, or any retal establshment whch serves lquor for consumpton on-ste; () Any take-out food use, as defred n Secton , except for a take-out food use whch occupes 100 square feet or less (ncludng the area devoted to food preparaton and servce and excludng storage and watng areas) n a general grocery or specalty grocery store;, (v) Any take-out food use, as defned n Secton , except for a take-out food use operatng as a mnor and ncdental use wthn a full-servce restaurant; (v) The wholesalng, manufactur~g or processng of foods, goods, or commodtes on the premses of an establshment whch does not also use or provde for prmarly retal sale of such foods, goods or commodtes at the same locaton where such wholesalng, manufacturng or processng takes place. lquor sales, as defrled n Secton , except for beer, wne, and/or lquor sales for the consumpton off the premses wth a State of celforna Alcoholc Beverage Control ("ABC") Board Lcense type (off-sale beer and wne) or type 21 (off-sale general) whch occupy less that 15% of the gross square footage of the establshment (ncludng all areas devoted to the dsplay and sale of alcoholc beverages) n a general grocery store, specalty grocery store, or self-servce specalty food use'. (v) Any retal The foregong rules shall not prohbt take-out food actvty whch operates n conjuncton wth a fast-food restaurant or a selfservce restaurant. A fast-food restaurant or a :self-servce restaurant, by defnton, ncludes take-out food as an accessory and neæssary part of ts operaton. (D) Temporary Uses. TempOrary! uses are permtted uses, subject to the provsons set forth n Secton 205 of ths Code. (2) Not Permtted Uses. (A) Uses whch are not spjcfcay lsted n ths Artcle are not permtted unless they qualfy as a nonconformng use pursuant to Sectons 180 through of ths Code or are determned by the Zonng Admnstrator to be permtted uses n accordance wth Secton 307(a) of ths Code. (B) No use, even though lsted as a permtted use, shall be permtted n a Neghborhood Commercal Dstrct whch, by reason of ts nature or manner of operaton, creates condtons that are hazardous, noxous, or offensve through the emsson of odor, fumes, smoke, cnders, dust, gas, vbraton, glare, refuse, water-carred waste, or excessve nose. (C) The establshment of a use that sells alcoholc beverages, other than beer and wne, concurrent wth motor vehcle fuel s prohbted, and shall be governed by Secton 229. Except n the SoMa NCT, where these uses are permtted acæssory uses. (Added by Ord , App. 3/13/87; amended by Ord , App. 11/12/87; Ord , App. 11fl/97; Ord , App. 12/4/98; Ord , Fle No , App. 5/ ; Ord , Fle No , App. 11/ ; Ord , Fle No , App. 11/912004; Ord , Fle No , App. 12/12/2006; Ord , Fle No , App ; Ord , Fle No ; Ord , Fle No , App. 12/ ) &HTMRequest=http%3a%2f%2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/201 (

83 .1uncode Page 1 of 1 San Francsco, Calforna, Plannng Code ;.;. A~TICLE_I; - NEIGHBORHQOD COMMERCIAL DISTRICTS ;.;: SEC ENTERTAINMENT" QIHER. :-:- ~EÇ ß~NTERIAINMEf\TI_OTHER. ~ I A retal use, other than adut entertanment, as defned n Secton of ths Code, whch provdes lve entertanment, ncludng dramatc and muscal performances, and/or operates as a dance hall whch provdes amplfed taped musc for dancng on the premses, ncludng but not lmted to those defned n Secton 1060 of the Polce Code, and whch s adequately soundproofed or nsulated so as to confne ncdental nose to the premses. Other entertanment also ncludes a bowlng alley, blard parlor, shootng gallery, skatng rnk and other commercal recreatonal actvty, but t excludes amusement game arcades, as defned n Secton of ths Code and regulated n Secton 1036 of the Polce Code. (Added by Ord , App. 3/13/87) ~_~... _..'._,_'...._._~_'",_ø~.._._'..._~,._."a"'~"'._' ""_',.,~_~."~~.A"'.~.~~ #_...._,._v &HTMRequest=http%3a%2fUIo2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/2010

84 Muncùde Page 1 of?.....,, San Francsco, Calforna, Plannng Code ~~ ARTICL.E 3: - ZONING PROCEDURES ~~ SEC CONDITIONAL llses. ~~ SEC CONDITIONAL USES. (a) (b) (c) General. The Cty Plannng commbson shall hear and make determnatons regardng applcatons for the authorzaton of condtonal uses n the specfc stuatons n whch such authorzaton s provded for elsewhere n ths Code. The procedures for condtonal uses shall be as specfed n ths Secton and n Sectons 306 through 306.6, except that Planned Unt Developments shall ~ addton be subject to Secton 304, medcal nsttutons and post-secondary educatonal nsttutons shall n addton be subject to the nsttutonal master plan requrements of Secton 304.5, and condtonal use and Planned Unt Development applcatons fled pursuant to Artcle 7, or otherwse requred by ths Code for uses or features n Neghborhodd Commercal Dstrcts, and condtonal use applcatons wthn South those of Market provded Dstrcts, shall be subject to the proysons set forth n Sectons 316 through of ths Code, n leu of for n Sectons and of ths Code, wth respect to schedulng and notce of hearngs, and n addton to those provded for n Sectons and of ths Code, wth respect to conduct of hearngs and reconsderaton. Intaton. A condtonal use acton 'may be ntated by applcaton of the owner, or authorzed agent for the owner, of the property for whch the condtonal u.se s sought. For a condtonal use applcaton to relocate a general advertsng sgn under subsecton () below, applcaton shall be made by a general advertsng sgn company that has fed a Relocaton Agreement applcaton and all requred nformaton wth the Plannng Department pursuant to Secton 2.21 of the San Francsco Admnstratve Code. Determnaton. After ts hearng on the applcaton, or upon the recommendaton of the Drector of Plannng f the ths Code and no hearng s requred, the Cty Plannng applcaton s fled pursuant to Sectons 316 through of Commsson shall approve the applcaton and authorze a condtonal use f the facts presented are such to establsh: (1) That the proposed use or fe~ture, at the sze and ntensty contemplated and at the proposed locaton, wll provde a development that Is necessary or desrable for, and compatble wth, the neghborhood or the communty: (A) In Neghborhood Corlmercal Dstrcts, f the proposed use s to be located at a locaton n whch the square footage exceeds the lmtatons found n Plannng Code 121.2(a) or 121.2(b), the followng shall be consdered: () The ntensty of actvty n the dstrct s not such that allowng the larger use wll be lkely to foreclose the locaton of other needed neghborhood-servcng uses n the area; and () The proposed use wll serve the neghborhood, n whole or n sgnfcant part, and the nature of the use requres a larger sze n order to functon; and () The buldng n whch the use s to be located s desgned n dscrete elements whch respect the scale of development n the dstrct; and (2) That such use or feature as proposed wll not be detrmental to the health, safety, convenence or general welfare of persons resdng or workng n the vcnty, or njurous to property, mprovements or potental development n the vcnty, wth respect to aspects ncludng but not lmted to the followng: (A) The nature of the proposed ste, ncludng ts sze and shape, and the proposed sze, shape and arrangement of structures; (8) The accessblty and traffc pattems for persons and vehcles, the type and volume of such traffc, and the adequacy of proposed off-street parkng and loadng and of proposed alternatves to off-street parkng, ncludng provsons of car-share parkng spaces, as defned n Secton 166 of ths Code. (C) The safeguards afforded to prevent noxous or offensve emssons such as nose, glare, dust and odor; (D) Treatment gven, as approprate, to such aspects as landscapng, screenng, open spaces, parkng and loadng areas, servce areas, lghtng and sgns; and (3) That such use or feature as proposed wl comply wth the applcable provsons of ths Code and wl not adversely affect the Master Plan; and (4) Wth respect to applcatons fled pursuant to Artcle 7 of ths Code, that such use or feature as proposed wl provde development that s n conformty wth the stated purpose of the applcable Neghborhood Commercal Dstrct, as set forth n zonng control category.1 of Sectons 710 through 729 of ths Code; and &HTMRequest=http%3a%2f%2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/2010

85 Munícode Page 2 of7 (5) (A) Wth respect to applcatons fed pursuant to Artcle 7, Secton 703.2(a), zonng categores.46,.47, and.48, n addton to the crtera set forth above n Secton 303(c)(1-4), that such use or feature wl: () Not be located wthn 1,000 feet of another such use, f the proposed use or feature s ncluded n zonng category.47, as defned by Secton of ths Code; and/or () Not be open betweep two a.m. and sx a.m.; and () Not use electronc arhplfcaton between mdnght and sx a.m.; and (v) Be adequately soundproofed or nsulated for nose and operated so that ncdental nose shall not be audble beyond the premses or n other sectons of the buldng and fxed-source equpment nose shall not exceed the decbel levels specfed n the San Francsco Nose Control Ordnance. (B) Notwthstandng the ~bove, the Cty Plannng Commsson may authorze a condtonal use whch does not satsfy the crtera set forth n (5)(A)() and/or (5)(A)() above, f facts presented are such to establsh that the use wll be operated n such a way as to mnmze dsrupton to resdences n and around the dstrct wth respect to nose and crowd control.! (C) The acton of the Plahnng Commsson approvng a condtonal use does not take effect untl the appeal perod s over or whle the approval s under appeal. (6) Wth respect to applcatonsfor lve/work unts n RH, RM and RTO Dstrcts fled pursuant to Secton 209.9(f) or 209.9(h) of ths Code, that: (A) Each lve/work unt s! wthn a buldng envelope n exstence on the effectve date of Ordnance No (effectve Octoberl1 0, 1988) and also wthn a porton of the buldng whch lawfully contans at the tme of applcaton a nonconformng, nonresdental use; (B) There shall be no more than one Ivelwork unt for each 1,000 gross square feet of floor area devoted to lvelwork unts wthn the subject structure; and (C) The project sponsor wll provde any off-street parkng, n addton to that otherwse requred by ths Code, needed to satsfy the reasonably antcpated auto usage by resdents of and vstors to the project. Such acton of the Cty Plannng Com'msson, n ether approvng or dsapprovng the applcaton, shall be fnal except upon the fng of a vald appeal to the Board of Supervsors as provded n Secton (d) Condtons. When consderng an applcaton for a condtonal use as provded heren wth respect to applcatons for development of "dwellngs" as defned n Chapter 87 of the San Francsco Admnstratve Code, the Commsson shall comply wth that Chapter whch requres, among other thngs, that the Commsson not base any decson regardng the development of "dwellngs" n whch "protected class" members are lkely to resde on nformaton whch may be dscrmnatory to any member of a "protected class" (as all such terms are defned n Chapter 87 of the San Francsco Admnstratve Code). In addton, when authorzng a condtonal use as provded heren, the Cty Plannng Commsson, or the Board of Supervsors on appeal, shall prescrbe such addtonal condtons, beyond those specfed n ths Code, as are n ts opnon necessary to secure the objectves of the Code. Once any porton of the condtonal use authorzaton s utlzed, all such condtons pertanng to such authorzaton shall become mmedately operatve. The volaton of any condton so mposed shall consttute a volaton of ths Code and may consttute grounds for revocaton of the condtonal use authorzaton. Such condtons may nclude tme lmts for exercse of the condtonal use authorzaton; otherwse, any exercse of such authorzaton must commence wthn a reasonable tme. (e) (f) Modfcaton of Condtons. Authorzaton of a change n any condton prevously mposed n the authorzaton of a condtonal use shall be subject to the same procedures as a new condtonal use. Such procedures shall also apply to applcatons for modfcaton or waver of condtons set forth n pror stpulatons and covenants relatve thereto contnued n effect by the provsons of Secto~ 174 of ths Code. Condtonal Use Abatement. The Plannng Commsson may consder the possble revocaton of a condtonal use or the possble modfcaton of or placement of addtonal condtons on a condtonal use when the Plannng Commsson determnes, based upon substantal evdence, that the applcant for the condtonal use had submtted false or msleadng nformaton n the applcaton process that could have reasonably had a substantal effect upon the decson of the Commsson or the condtonal use s not n complance wth a condton of approval, s n volaton of law f the volaton s wthn the subject matter jursdcton of the Plannng Commsson or operates n such a manner as to create hazardous, noxous or offensve condtons enumerated n Secton 202(c) f the volaton s wthn the subject matter jursdcton of the Plannng Commsson and these crcumstances have not been abated through admnstratve acton of the Drector, the Zonng Admnstrator or other Cty authorty. Such consderaton shall be the subject of a publc hearng before the Plannng Commsson but no fee shall be requred of the applcant or the subject condtonal use operator. (1) The Drector of Plannng or the Plannng Commsson may seek a publc hearng on condtonal use abatement when the Drector or Commsson has substantal evdence submtted wthn one year of the effectve date of the Condtonal Use authorzaton' that the applcant for the condtonal use had submtted false or msleadng nformaton n the applcaton process that could have reasonably had a substantal effect upon the decson of the Commsson or substantal evdence of a volaton of condtons of approval, a volaton of law, or operaton whch creates hazardous, noxous or offensve condtons enumerated n Secton 202(c) &HTMRequest=http%3a%2t'1Ó2f1brar.muncod... 4/29/2010

86 Muncode Page 1 of 1 San Francsco, Calforna, Plannng Code ;:;: ARTICL.!;_ 3: - ZONING PROCEDURES :;;: SEC CONDUCT OF HEARLNGS. ;:;: SEC CONDUCT OF HEARINGS. (a) (b) (c) (d) Report and Recommendatons. In all actons for amendments to the Plannng Code or General Plan or condtonal uses, the Zonng Admnstrator or'he Plannng Department shall make necessary nvestgatons and studes and submt the fndngs to the Drector of Plannng pror to the hearng of the Plannng Commsson, or n actons on condtonal use applcatons n NC Dstrcts, pror to the consent calendar or publc hearng of the Commsson. The report and recommendaton of the Drector of Plannng shall be submtted at least one week pror to the hearng. Record. A record shall be kept of the pertnent nformaton presented at the hearng on any acton for an amendment, condtonal use or varance, and such record shall be mantaned as a part of the permanent publc records of the Plannng Department. A verbatm!record may be made f permtted or ordered by the Plannng Commsson n the case of actons for amendments or condtonal uses, and by the Zonng Admnstrator n the case of varance actons. Contnuatons. The Plannng Commsson n the case of actons for amendments or condtonal uses, and the Zonng Admnstrator n the case of varance actons, shall determne the nstances n whch cases scheduled for hearng may be contnued or taken under advsement. In such cases, new notce need not be gven of the further hearng date, provded such date s announced at the sc~eduled hearng. Decson. The decson of the Plannng Commsson or the Zonng Admnstrator shall be n accordance wth the provsons for each type of case n Sectons 302 through 305 and 340. (1) In the case of varances, the decson of the Zonng Admnstrator shall, unless deferred upon the request or consent of the applcant, be rendered wthn 60 days from the date of concluson of the hearng or, where no hearng s nvolved, wthn 60 days from the date of fng; falure of the Zonng Admnstrator to act wthn the prescrbed tme shall enttle the applcant to cause the matter to be placed before the Plannng Commsson for decson at ts next followng regular meetng. (2) In the case of actons for amendments to the Plannng Code or condtonal uses, the decson of the Plannng Commsson shall be rendered wthn 90 days from the date of concluson of the hearng; falure of the Commsson to act wthn the prescrbed tme shall be deemed to consttute dsapproval. (3) In the case of proposed amendments to the Plannng Code ntated by the Board of Supervsors under Secton 302(b), or modfcatons to proposed amendments made by the Board under Secton 302(d) of ths Code, the decson of the Plannng Commsson shall be rendered wthn 90 days from the date of referral of the proposed amendment or modfcaton by the Board to the Commsson. Falure of the Commsson to act wthn the prescrbed tme shall be deemed to consttute dsapproval, except that the Board may, by resoluton, extend the prescrbed tme wthn whch the Commsson s to render ts decson. (Amended by O,d , App. 5/8181; O,d , App. 3/13187; O,d , App. 8/8/96) &HTMRequest=http%3a%2fOIo2f1brar.muncod... 4/29/20 0

87 Muncode Page 1 of 4 San Francsco, Calforna, Plannng Coèle ~~ ARTICLE 3,_SL:.fEE_S ~;; SEC COMMISSION AND ZONING ADMINISTRATOR HEARING APPLICATIONS. ~~ SEC COMMISSION AND ZONING ADMINISTRATOR HEARING APPLICATIONS, a) Condtonal Use (Secton 303), Planned Unt Development (Secton 304), Estmated Intal Fee ~onstructon Cost No $ constructon cost, excludng extenson of hours No : 1, constructon cost, extenson of hours Estmated Intal Fee Constructon,ost 1.00 to $1, , , to $1, plus 0.557% of cost over $10, , ,000, $6, plus 0.664% of cost over $1,000, $4 999, $5,000, $33, plus 0.557% of cost over $5,000, ~9,999, ~1 0,000, $61, plus 0.290% of cost over $10,000, ~19, $20,000, $90, or more Estmated Intal Fee Constructon Cost No $ "onstructon cost, ~xcludng extenson of hours No 1$1, constructon r-ost, extenson of hours Estmated Intal Fee Constructon,ost 1.00 to ~1, , I I I I I 39&HTMRequest=http%3a%2f%2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/20 0

88 MuIcode Page 4 of 4 (I) Amendments to Text of the Plannng Code: $13, as an ntal fee, plus tme and materals f the cost exceeds the ntal fee as set forth n Secton 350(c). (m) Zonng Admnstrator Converson Determnatons Related to Servce Staton Conversons: $2, as an ntal fee, plus tme and materals f the cost exceeds the ntal fee. (Secton 228.4). (n) Condtonal Use Appeals to the Board of Supervsors: (1 ) $500,00 for the appellant of a condtonal used authorzaton decson to the Board of Supervsors; provded, however, that the fee shall be waved f the appeal s fed by a neghborhood organzaton that: (1) has been n exstence for 24 months pror to the appeal flng date, (2) s on the Plannng Department's neghborhood organzaton notfcaton lst, and (3) can demonstrate to the Plannng Drector or hs/her desgnee that the organzaton s substantally affected by the proposed project. ' (2) Such fees shall be used to defray the cost of an appeal to the Plannng Department. At the tme of flng an appeal, the Clerk of the Board of Supervsors shall collect such fee and forward the fee amount to the Plannng Department. (Added by Ord , App. 5/25/93; amended by Ord , App. 6/2/4; Ord , App. 6/25; Ord , App. 11/15/95; Ord , App. 7125/6; Ord , App. 5/21/98; Ord , Fle No , App ; Ord , Fle No , App ; Ord , Fle No , App ; Ord , Fle No , App. 7/21/2006; Ord , Fle No , App. 9/14/2006; Ord , Fle No , App ; Ord , Fle No , App ; Ord , Fle No , App. 8/6/2009) &HTMRequest=http%3a%2fUIÓ2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/2010

89 Muncode Page 1. ot 1.1. (c) (d) (e) "Busness." The enterprse for whch a permt s sought or has been ssued under ths Artcle, whether operated on a for-prof or not-for-prof bass. "Conduct that Consttutes a Nusance." Any conduct that would consttute a volaton of the followng laws: assault and battery (CaL. Penal Code 240, 242, 245); sexual battery (CaL. Penal Code 243.4); dschargng frearm (CaL. Penal Code 246,246.3); unlawful weapons (CaL. Penal Code 12020; S.F. Polce Code 1291); dsturbng the peace (CaL. Penal Code 415, 416, 417); unlawful threats (CaL. Penal Code 422); obstructon of pedestran or vehcle rght-of-way (CaL. Penal Code 370); gamblng (CaL. Penal Code 330, 337a); rape (CaL. Penal Code 261); statutory rape (CaL. Penal Code 261.5); prosttuton and related offenses (CaL. Penal Code 266, 266a, 266e, 266h, 266, 315, 316, 647(b)); sex crmes for whch regstraton s requred under the Sex Offender Regstraton Act (CaL. Penal Code 290); felony sexual assault loterng for lewd or lascvous purposes (CaL. Penal Code 647 (d)); loterng on prvate property wthout lawful busness (CaL. Penal Code 647(h); dentfy theft (CaL. Penal Code 530.5); a ~olent felony warrantng enhancement of a prson term (CaL. Penal Code 667.5); crmnal gang actvty (CaL. Penal Code ); drug offenses (CaL. Health & Safety Code laws (CaL , Busness 11352, & 11359, 11360, 11378, , ); volaton of Alcohol Beverage Control Professons Code 23300, 25602, 25631,25657,25658); publc urnaton or defecaton (San Francsco Polce Code 153); accumulaton of flth (CaL. Health & Safety Code ); or excessve nose emssons (San Francsco Polce Code Secton 49 or Artcle 29). "Correctve Acton." Acton whch ncludes, but s not lmted to, the followng: I (1) Requestng assstance from the local law enforcement agency n a tmely manner regardng the conduct. I (2) Requestng those ndvduals engagng n Conduct that Consttutes a Nusance to cease the conduct, or ejectng those Persons from the premses. (3) Revsng the Securty Plan, subject to approval by the Entertanment Commsson or the Drector as provded under ths Artcle. (f) (g) "Drector." The Executve Drector of the Entertanment Commsson or ndvdual desgnated by the Drector to act on hs or her behalf. "Entertanment." Any of the followng, except when conducted n a prvate resdence: (1 ) (2) Any act, play, revew,' pantomme, scene, song, dance act, song and dance act, or poetry rectaton, conducted n or uponany premses to whch patrons or members are admtted. The playng or use of any nstrument capable of producng or used to produce muscal or percusson sounds, ncludng but not lmted to, reed, brass, percusson, or strng-lke nstruments, or karaoke, or recorded musc presented by a lve dsc jockey on the premses. (3) (4) A fashon or style show. The act of any female entertaner, whle vsble to any customer, who exposes the breast or employs any devce or coverng whch s ntended to smulate the breast, or wears any type of clothng so that the breast may be observed. (h) "Manager." The ndvdual authorzed by the Permttee to exercse dscretonary power to organze, drect, carry out or control the operatons of the Busness. () "Permttee." The Person to whom a permt has been ssued under ths Artcle. G) "Person." Any person, ndvdual, frm, partnershp, jont venture, assocaton, socal club, fraternal organzaton, jont stock company, corporaton, estate, trust, busness trust, recever, trustee, syndcate, or any other group or combnaton actng as a unt exceptng the Unted States of Amerca, the State of Calforna, and any poltcal subdvson of ether. (k) "Polce of EntertanmenL." Every premses to whch patrons or members are admtted whch serves food, beverages, or food and beverages, ncludng but not lmted to alcoholc beverages, for consumpton on the premses and wheren Entertanment as defned n Subsecton (g) s furnshed or occurs upon the premses. () "Sale of the Busness" or "Sell the Busness." The sale or other transfer of the ownershp nterest n a Busness that result n a Person (who dd not already have such a percentage nterest) ownng 50% or more of the Busness, regardless of the form of ownershp. (m) "Securty Guard." A person who has a vald Propretary Prvate Securty Offcer regstraton document ssued by the Calforna Department of Consumer Affars; or a person who s a Patrol Specal Polce Offcer apponted by the Polce Commsson or an assstant to a Patrol Specal Polce Offcer and s operatng n accordance wth rules of the Polce Commsson governng Patrol Specal Polce Offcers and assstants to Patrol Specal Polce Offcers. (n) "Securty Plan." A plan that adequately addresses the safety of persons and property by () provdng a rato of one Securty Guard to a specfc number of ndvduals as descrbed n the paragraph mmedately below () securng the sdewalk for a 1 DO-foot radus n all drectons around the premses of the Busness to prevent njury to persons and/or damage to property, and () provdng for the orderly dspersal of ndvduals and traffc from the premses of &HTMRequest=http%3a%2t'12f1brar.muncod (

90 Muncode the Busness and wthn 100 feet of any door that patrons use to enter or ext the premses. The phrase "100 feet" n () of ths Subsecton (n) means 100 feet from the door n both drectons on the same sde of the street as the premses of the Busness. The plan shall nclude suffcent staff wth the requste experence to mplement the plan. Page 3 of'l'l The Securty Plan must provde at least one Securty Guard for every 100 ndvduals antcpated to be present at anyone tme durng Entertanment events on the premses of the Busness, wth the followng two qualfcatons. There must always be at least one Securty Guard for every 100 ndvduals actually present at anyone tme durng Entertanment events on the premses of the Busness. Further, n those areas of the Cty where a condtonal use authorzaton s requred for a late nght use, on Thursdays, Frdays, Saturdays, and Sundays from 9:00 p.m. untl closng (ncludng early mornng hours Frday, Saturday, Sunday, and Monday) the Securty Plan must provde at least one S,ecurty Guard for every 100 ndvduals authorzed by the Occupancy Permt durng Entertanment events on the premses of the Busness. I The defnton of Securty Plan n ths Subsecton 1060(n) does not lmt the dscreton of the Entertanment Commsson and Drector as specfed n ths Artcle to mpose more strngent requrements for a Securty Plan as crcumstances warrant. (0) ''Tax Collector." Tax Collector of the Cty and County of San Francsco. (p) "Professonal Entertaner." A!person who s compensated for hs or her penormance. Ths defnton does not restrct the defnton of "Entertanment" n Subsecton (g) and s relevant only to the extent the term "professonal entertanet' s used n ths Artcle. (Amended by Ord , App. 2/4/83; Ord , App. 9/4/91; Orc , App. 5/28/93; Ord , Fle No , App. 11/41004; Ord , Fle No , App. 11/20/2009) I SEC PERMIT REQUIRED. (a) It shall be unlawful for any Person to own, conduct, operate, or mantan, or to cause or permt to be conducted, operated, or mantaned, any Place of Entertanment or One Tme Event n the Cty and County of San Francsco wthout frst havng obtaned the requred permt from the Drector or Entertanment Commsson. (b) (c) (d) It shall be unlawful for any Person to conduct, operate or mantan, or cause or permt to be conducted, operated, or mantaned, a Place of Entertanment or One Tme Event for whch a permt has been granted (1) after the permt has been revoked or s otherwse nval~ or (2) for any perod of tme durng whch the permt has been suspended. It shall be unlawful for any Person ~ho s requred to surrender a permt upon the sale of a Busness as requred under Secton (b) to fal to do so. Any place or premses where a Place of Entertanment Permt or One Tme Event Permt s sought must conform to all exstng health, safety, zonng, and fre ordnances of the Cty and County of San Francsco, and must have a vald permt to operate (formerly referenced n ths Artcle as a publc eatng place permt) from the Department of Publc Health. The Entertanment Commsson, ncludng the Drector n the case of a One Tme Event Permt, may ssue a permt under ths Artcle condtonal upon the applcant recevng the other requred permts. (Added by Ord , Fle No , App. 7/29/2005; Orc , Fle No , App. 11/20/2009) I SEC FILING APPLICATION, NOTICE TO OTHER CITY DEPARTMENTS, AND DEPARTMENTAL REPORTS. (a) Every Person seekng a Place of Entertanment permt or an amendment to a permt shall fle an applcaton wth the Entertanment Commsson upon a form provded by the Entertanment Commsson and shall pay a flng fee as provded n Secton 2.26 of ths Code. (b) The Drector shall send the applcaton to the San Francsco Polce Department, Fre Department, Department of Buldng Inspecton, Department of Publc Health, and Plannng Department. Those departments shall complete all necessary nspectons and report ther determnatons to the Entertanment Commsson wthn 20 Cty busness days of recevng the applcaton. (Amended by Ord , App. 11/12/81; Ord , Fle No , App. 7/26/2002; Ord , Fle No , App. 11/20/2009) I SEC APPLICATION FORM. Except as otherwse provded heren, an applcaton for a permt pursuant to the provsons of ths Artcle shall specfy the followng and be sgned under penalty of perjury: (a) The name and street address of the Busness for whch the permt s sought &HTMRequest=http%3a%2f%2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/201 (

91 Muncode Page 4 of22 (b) The name and address of the applcant as follows: (1) If the applcant s a corporaton, the name of the corporaton exactly as shown n ts artcles of ncorporaton; the date and place of ncorporaton; and the name and address of each offcer and drector. (2) If the applcant s a Pe'rson other than a publcly traded company, the name and address of every Person that drectly or ndrectly owns or controls 10% or more of the assets, ownershp nterests or votng nterests n that persol' (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) () 0) (k) (I) (m) The name of and contact nformaton for the Manager who shall drectly, or through desgnees, be on the premses durng all hours of operaton. I The name and address of ejch Person who appears on the busness regstraton certfcate for the Busness for whch a permt s sought. The name and address of ejch Person to whom the Department of Alcoholc Beverage Control has ssued ~ lcense for the Busness for whch a permt s sought. The names and addresses of the Persons who have or wl have authorty or control over the Busness and a bref statement of the nature and extent of such authorty and control, f the applcant has not otherwse provded ths nformaton n the applcaton. The name and address of thl Person authorzed to accept servce of process. I A plan for the Busness to operate as a Place of Entertanment, specfyng the days and hours of operaton, the number of employees and ther dutes, the number of patrons, a statement certfyng that the Busness shall comply wth the maxmum occupancy load for the space as establshed under the San Francsco Buldng and Fre Codes, the types or classes of entertanment (n terms of the types of nstruments, numbers of performers, and sound levels) to be provded, and the amount of parkng, both on and off-ste, to be provded. If sound amplfcaton s to be used, the plan shall also nclude a specfc descrpton of the amplfcaton system. A proposed Securty Plan as defned n Secton 1060(n). I For the Persons(s) whose dsclosure s requred under Subsectons (b), (c), (e) and (f), all crmnal charges, complants or ndctments n' the precedng ten years whch resulted n a convcton or a plea of gulty or no contest for the followng laws: assault and battery (CaL. Penal Code 240, 242, 245); felony sexual assault; sexual battery (CaL. Penal Code 243.4); rape (CaL. Penal Code 261); statutory rape (CaL. Penal Code 261.5); dschargng frearm (CaL. Penal Code 246, 246.3); unlawful weapons (CaL. Penal Code 12020; S.F. Polce Code 1291); dsturbng the peace (CaL. Penal Code 415,416,417); unlawful threats (CaL. Penal Code 422); obstructon of pedestran or vehcle rght-of-way (CaL. Penal Code 370); gamblng (CaL. Penal Code 330, 337a); prosttuton and related offenses (CaL. Renal Code 266, 266a, 266e, 266h, 266, 315, 316, 647(b)); sex crmes for whch regstraton s requred under the Sex Offender Regstraton Act (CaL. Penal Code 290); loterng for lewd or lascvous purposes (CaL. PEmal Code 647(d), 647(h)); dentfy theft (CaL. Penal Code 530.5); a volent felony warrantng enhancement ofa prson term (CaL. Penal Code 667.5); crmnal gang actvty (CaL. Penal Code ); drug offenses (Cal~ Health & Safety Code 11351, 11352, 11359, 11360, 11378, 11379, , laws (CaL. Busness & Professons Code 23300, 25602, 25631, ); volaton of Alcohol Beverage Control 25657,25658); or for conduct n another jursdcton whch f carred out n Calforna would consttute an offense under one of the laws set forth n ths Subsecton 0). All crmnal charges, complants or ndctments n the precedng ten years whch resulted n a convcton for the Person(s) whose dsclosure s requred under Subsectons (b), (c), (e) and (f), for any other offense whch s a felony or msdemeanor un~er the laws of ths state, or for conduct n another jursdcton whch f carred out n Calforna would consttute a felony or msdemeanor under the laws of ths state, provded that ths Subsecton (k) apples only to offenses arsng out of the operaton of a nghtclub, dance hall, cabaret, Place of Entertanment or an establshment that serves food or beverages. For the nformaton requred by Subsectons (j) and (k), a statement settng forth for each Person all charges under whch convctons or pleas of gulty or no contest were obtaned, any sentence mposed, and for each matter the date, name and locaton ofthe court; and f the Person was granted parole or probaton, whether the Person successfully completed parole or probaton. Such further nformaton as the Entertanment Commsson requres regardng fnancal and lease arrangements and management, authorty, and operatonal control of the Busness or ts premses when the nformaton wll assst the Commsson n ts determnaton whether to grant or deny the permt. (Added by Ord , App. 4128flO; amended Ord , App. 9/4/91; Ord , Fle No , App. 7/26/2002; Ord , Fle No , App.11120/2009) I SEC NOTICE REQUIREMENTS AND CONTACT INFORMATION. (a) Unless otherwse provded n ths Artcle, the followng defntons apply &HTMRequest=http%3a%2f%2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/201 (

92 Muncode Page 5 of22 () To provde notce "electroncally" means to send wrtten notce by emal, facsmle or n any other manner that the Drector desgnates as approprate to transmt wrtten nformaton other than by mal or personal delvery. () To "mal" notce or gve notce "by mal" means depostng the notce n a sealed envelope or package, clearly labeled to dentfy the ndvdual to whom t s sent, n a post offce, malbox, or other faclty regularly mantaned by the Unted States Postal Servce, by Frst Class Mal, wth postage prepad. The requrement that notce be maled wthn a specfed perod of tme means that the notce s deposted n the mal wthn that perod of tme. () "Personally delver" or "persjnal delvery" means delverng notce or causng notce to be delvered n person. (v) "Notce" means notce of a hlarng, decson, acton requred of an applcant for a permt or a Permttee, or any other nformaton that ths Artcle requres to be gven or whch the Entertanment Commsson or the Drector fnd approprate n mplementng the provsons of ths Artcle. (b) (c) (d) (e) Applcants for a permt and permttjes shall provde nformaton necessary to enable the Entertanment Commsson and the Drector to gve notce under ths Artcle. Applcants and Permttees shall provde the Drector n wrtng wth a street address where the applcant and Permttee receve mal from the Unted States Postal Servce, and wth any emal address, facsmle number or other Informaton necessary to enable notce to be sent to the applcant and Permttee electroncally. The applcant and P~rmttee shall keep the nformaton requred by ths Secton current by nformng the Drector n wrtng of any change. When the Commsson or Drector mals or personally delvers notce or sends notce electroncally to the applcant or Permttee n accordance wth the nformaton most recently provded n wrtng by that Person, such acton shall satsfy the requrements of ths Artcle wth respect to how notce s gven. In some crcumstances, ths Artcle!reqUreS notce to the Manager. The Permttee shall provde a telephone and/or cell phone number and a facsmle number or emal address for the transmsson of notce to the Manager. The Permttee shall keep current the contact nformaton for the Manager and shall notfy the Drector n wrtng of any change n ths nformaton. The Manager may desgnate other ndvduals to whom notce s to be gven for any perods of the Manager's absence or unavalablty by provdng ths nformaton n wrtng to the Drector. When the Commsson or Drector mals or personally delvers notce or sends!notce electroncally to the Manager, or to any ndvdual desgnated by the Manager to receve notce n place of the Manager, n accordance wth the nformaton most recently provded n wrtng by the Permttee for the Manager, or by tle Manager for hs or her desgnee, such acton shall satsfy the requrements of ths Artcle that notce be gven to the Manager. The Drector may requre applcants, Permttees and Managers to provde dfferent or addtonal contact nformaton for recept of notce as communcaton: technologes change. A Permttee may change the nam~ and/or address of the ndvdual provded by the Permttee n the permt applcaton to accept servce of process by provdng wrtten notce to the Drector. (Added by Ord , App. 4I2SflO; Ord , Fle No. OS0323, App ) I SEC.1060.S.. DETERMINATION OF APPLICATION FOR A PLACE OF ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT. 1 (a) The applcant shall fle the applcaton for a Place of Entertanment Permt wth the Drector. The Drector may requre that the applcant or the applcant's agent fle the applcaton n person. Upon determnng that an applcaton s complete, the Drector shall accept and fle t and shall schedule a publc hearng before the Entertanment Commsson to determne whether the permt should be granted. The Drector shall provde wrtten notce of the hearng to the applcant by mal or to the applcant's agent by personal delvery at least 30 days before the date of the hearng. The Drector shall promptly notfy the Chef of Polce or the Chefs desgnee n wrtng of the applcaton and the hearng date and shall promptly transmt a copy of the applcaton, ncludng a copy of the securty plan, to the Chef or the Chefs desgnee. For purposes of ths Subsecton (a), the Captan, for the dstrct where the Place of Entertanment would be located, or the Captan's desgnee, s deemed the Chefs desgnee unless the Chef of Polce drects otherwse. Any Person may submt a wrtten request to the Drector to receve notce of the hearng on a permt applcaton. (b) (1) The applcant shall cause a notce of the hearng to be conspcuously and contnuously posted for at least 30 days before the scheduled hearng date on the premses of the Busness. Where the Busness s located n a neghborhoodcommercal or mxed resdental dstrct, as defned n Artcle 7 and 8 of the San Francsco Plannng Code, the applcant shall also make a good fath effort to dstrbute leaflets at each resdence located wthn 150 feet of the Busness, unless the Entertanment Commsson fnds that a Busness located n a dstrct s not lkely to sgnfcantly generate nghttme nose and traffc to the detrment Of resdences located n that mmedate area. Applcants subject to the requrement of dstrbutng leaflets shall do so at least 30 days before the scheduled hearng date and the dstrbuton shall be done n complance wth the provsons of Artcle 57 (begnnng wth Secton ) of the San Francsco Publc Works Code. The Drector shall provde notce of the hearng at least 30 days before the hearng to any Person who has fled a wrtten request for such notce, whch notce may be gven electroncally f the Person has provded electronc contact nformaton, or by mal. (2) In the event of a contnued hearng, the applcant shall cause notce of the contnued hearng to be conspcuously and contnuously posted on the premses of the Busness for at least 10 days before the date of the contnued hearng. The Drector shall provde notce of the hearng electroncally or by mal at least 10 days before the hearng to any Person who has fled a wrtten request for such notce &HTMRequest=http%3a%2f%2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/201 (

93 Muncode (c) (d) (e) (3) The falure of the Drector to provde the notce of the hearng to any Person who fled a wrtten request as provded n Subsectons (b)(1) and (2) of ths Secton shall not consttute grounds for nvaldaton of the actons of the Commsson taken at the hearng. Page 6 ot22 At the hearng on the applcaton, the applcant and any other nterested party, ncludng the Polce Department or any other publc agency, may ntroduce evdence and present argument relatng to the standards for revew under Subsecton (f) of ths Secton. (1) The Entertanment Commsson.shall hold a hearng and determne whether to grant or deny the permt wthn 45 Cty busness days of the date that the a~plcant has submtted a complete applcaton under Secton (a), except that ths 45 day perod shall be extended for such perod or perods of tme that apply under the followng crcumstances:! () If the Entertanment Comms~on fnds that an extenson of tme s necessary to obtan addtonal nformaton for ts revew of the applcaton uhder the standards set forth n Subsecton (f) of ths Secton, the tme perod shall be extended for an addtonal amount of tme as the Commsson determnes approprate, up to 15 addtonal days; and I () Upon the applcant's request, the Entertanment Commsson shall contnue the hearng for an addtonal perod jan opportunty to comply wth the requrements of ths Artcle, n whch case the of tme to allow the applcant tme perod s extended for that addtonal perod; and () If the applcant fals to post o~ mantan notce of the hearng, or make a good fath effort to dstrbute leaflets to resdences, as requred by Subsecton (b) of ths Secton, the Drector shall have the hearng before the Entertanment Commsson contnued for such perod or perods of tme that the Drector determnes necessary for the applcant to comply wth the postng requrement, n whch case the tme perod s extended for that addtonal perod or perods of tme; and (v) If the Drector fnds that the Commsson s unable to meet durng the 45 day tme perod or any permtted tme extenson due to exgent crcumstances, the tme perod shall be extended untl the Commsson s able to meet; the Commsson shall consder the matter at the frst meetng that t conducts followng such crcumstances. I (1) If the permt applcant has not obtaned all permts requred for the Busness from other Cty departments by the date of the hearng on the applcaton, the Entertanment Commsson may grant a condtonal permt pendng the ssuance of the other requred Cty permts; provded, however, the Commsson shall take ths acton only f suffcent nformaton has been provded to allow for adequate evaluaton of the applcaton and f grounds for denal, as set forth n Subsecton (f), are not present. Any permt condtonally granted by the Entertanment Commsson under ths Subsecton(e)(1) may be appealed to the Board of Appeals. Any such appeal shall be fled wthn 10 days of the decson of the Entertanment Commsson's condtonally grantng the permt. No Person may operate a Busness for whch a permt has been condtonally granted unless and untl the Person has obtaned all permts and authorzatons requred from other Cty departments. (2) If the Entertanment Commsson does not grant, condtonally grant or deny the permt for a Place of Entertanment wthn the tme requred by Subsecton (d)(1) of ths Secton, ncludng any extensons of tme provded for n Subsecton (Ø)(1), the permt sought by the applcant shall be deemed granted, condtoned on the requrements that the Permtee obtan all requred permts from other Cty departments wthn nne months and comply wth all the requrements of ths Artcle. The tme by whch the Entertanment Commsson must act commences on the date th:t the applcant has fled a completed applcaton under Secton (a). (f) The Entertanment Commsson shall grant or condtonally grant a permt for a Place of Entertanment pursuant to ths Artcle unless t fnds that: (1 ) The premses or the propo~ed operaton of the Busness does not comply wth the health, zonng, fre and safety requrements of the laws of!the State of Calforna or ordnances of the Cty and County of San Francsco applcable to the Busness; or (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) Notwthstandng the mtgaton provded under the Securty Plan submtted by the applcant, the buldng, structure, equpment or locaton of the proposed Busness cannot adequately accommodate the type and volume of vehcle and pedestran traffc antcpated; or The premses or the proposed operaton of the Busness lacks adequate safeguards to prevent emssons of nose, glare, dust and odor that would substantally ntenere wth the publc health, safety and welfare or the peaceful enjoyment of neghborng property; or The permt applcant has not provded a Securty Plan that adequately addresses the safety of persons and property and provdes for the orderly dspersal of ndvduals and traffc. If there s an unresolved ctaton applcable to the premses that has been ssued by a Cty department, the Entertanment Commsson shall not grant the permt wthout documented authorzaton from the department that ssued the ctaton. If the Chef of Polce or the Chefs desgnee, n person at the Entertanment Commsson hearng on the permt applcaton or n wrtng pror to the hearng, objects to the grantng of the permt on the bass that the Commsson should make one or more of the fndngs stated n Subsectons (f)(1 )-(4) above, the Commsson 4/29/201 C

94 Muncode may not ssue the permt wthout specfcally addressng the objecton n wrtng or on the record, at a Commsson meetng, and explanng specfcally why the objecton does not warrant the fndng. Ths explanaton requrement apples but s not lmted to objectons rased by the Chef or Chefs desgnee to the adequacy of a proposed securty plan. For purposes of ths Subsecton (f)(6), the Captan for the dstrct where the Place of Entertanment would be located, or the Captan's desgnee, s deemed the Chefs desgnee unless the Chef of Polce drects otherwse. Page 7 of22 (7) The explanaton requrement1stated n Subsecton (f)(6) above also apples to objectons rased by other Cty departments; provded, however, that ths Subsecton (f)(7) does not dmnsh the power of other Cty departments to ssue permts' or other authorzaton requred for a Busness to operate, and does not empower the Entertanment Commsson to overrde a decson by another Cty department regardng the ssuance of a permt or other authorzaton requred for a Busness to operate. I (g) (h) (8) When grantng a permt, the Commsson shall explan n wrtng or on the record, at a Commsson meetng, why t has not made any of the fndngs stated n Subsectons (f)(1 )-(4) above. 1 (9) In consderng whether to make any of the fndngs stated n Subsectons (f)(1)-(4) above, the Commsson shall consder where relevant the crcumstances surroundng any prevous denal of a permt applcaton or prevous suspenson or revocaton of a permt, under ths Artcle or Artcle 15.2, for the same permt applcant or Permttee.. When the Commsson grants or cohdtonally grants a permt, t shall requre the applcant as a condton of the permt to comply wth the Securty Plan that has been approved as provded under ths Artcle. The Commsson may mpose addtonal reasonable tme, place and manner condtons on the permt. In consderng whether to mpose sad condtons, the Commsson shall consder where relevant the crcumstances surroundng any prevous denal of a permt applcaton or prevous suspenson or revocaton of a permt, under ths Artcle or Artcle 15.2, for the same permt applcant or Permttee. 1 If a Permttee has been condtonally granted a permt but has not obtaned all of the permts requred from other Cty departments wthn nne months fron the date that the Entertanment Commsson condtonally granted the permt, the condtonally granted permt shall e~pre by operaton of law and be vod. (Added by Ord , App. 4128flO; amended by Ord , App. 9/4/91; Ord , Fle No , App ; Ord , Fle No , App. 11/112002; Ord , Fle No , App. 11/4/2004; Ord , Fle No , App ) I I SEC PRIVATE CLUB. No establshment ssued a permt pur,suant to ths Artcle may allow the premses to be used solely for the purpose of conductng a prvate club between the hours of 2:00 a.m. and 6:00 a.m. (Added by Ord , App. 4128flO) I SEC SOLICITATION OF DRINKS OR MERCHANDISE. No operator of a place of entertanment shall employ or permt any hostess, entertaner or person to solct any patron or customer of or vstor n sad place of entertanment to purchase any beverage or merchandse for the one solctng or for any other person. (Added by Ord , App. 8/6fl3) I SEC , - LIGHTING. Every establshment whch has receved a permt pursuant to ths Artcle shall be lghted throughout to an ntensty of not less than 12 foot candles durng all hours of operaton except whle the floor show s n progress. (Added by Ord , App. 4/28flO) SEC MISCELLANEOUS RULES. No professonal entertaner or employee may dance wth any customer on the premses n any place of entertanment. (Added by Ord , App. 4128flO) &HTMRequest=http%3a%2f'%2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/2010

95 Muncode SEC REQUIREMENT FOR STAGE. Page 8 01'22 Entertaners whose breasts are exposed to vew shall perform only upon a stage at least 18 nches above the mmedate floor level and removed at least 6 feet from the nearest patron. (Added by Ord , App. 7/6n3) I I I SEC BOOTHS. I It shall be unlawful for any person ope~6tng a place of entertanment under the provsons of ths Artcle n the Cty and County of San Francsco, or any agent, emplgyee or representatve thereof, to erect, construct, mantan, or cause or permt to be erected, constructed or mantaned, wthn su:c place of entertanment any prvate rooms, booths, enclosures or compartments, or any closed stalls, or any alcoves of any natur,,e, so arranged that the Inner porton of the same shall not at all tmes be vsble from any pont n the place of entertanment whera Isuch rooms, booths, enclosures, compartments, stalls or alcoves should be reasonably wthn vew. : I II ;1 (Added by Ord , App. 4I2SnO) I : ~ ~. SEC. '.1 I POLICE-INSPECTION.! The Polce Department, n addton to ssued a permt pursuant to ths Artcle. I ther several other dutes, shall nspect any and all establshments whch have been (Added by Ord , App. 41SflO),, I SEC NOISE ABATEMÄNT. l 'Menever, upon due notce and hearng, t shall be determned that nose from any establshment whch has been ssued a permt pursuant to ths Artcle nterfered wth the rght of persons dwellng n the vcnty of such establshment to the peaceful and quet use and enjoyment of ther property, the Entertanment Commsson may requre that the premses be soundproofed n a manner that n the judgment of the Entertarment Commsson wll be effectve to elmnate the nose or reduce t to a reasonable level. In takng any acton under ths Secto", 'the Entertanment Commsson must balance all of the nterests of the respectve partes, as well as the hardshp whch wll result from any order. If the Entertanment Commsson fnds that the nose complaned of s of a mnmum or nconsequental degree, no acton shall be taken under ths Artcle. If a permttee fals, wthn a reasonable tme and n no event more than 60 days after havhg been ordered to do so pursuant to ths Artcle, to abate any nose, hs permt shall be suspended after a second hearng, due notpe of whch s gven, untl such tme as he comples wth the order. (Added by Ord , App. 4I2SflO; emended, by Ord , Fle No , App ) I SEC MINORS. No person under 21 years of age shsll enter, be, or reman n or on any premses on or n whch any exhbton of the human body, as defned n Secton 1 060(f), s presented and permttee shall not permt such a person to enter, be, or reman n or on any such premses. (Added by Ord , App. 4I2SflO) SEC REGULATION OF SIGNS. No sgn or sgns, pantngs, photogr~phs, pctoral representatons, or any other vsual means shall be mantaned, erected, used or placed upon or adjacent to the outsde of any buldng, or n connecton wth any premses theren, whch has receved a permt pursuant to ths Artcle, f t shows, rèveals or depcts, n whole or n part, the followng: (1) The performance of acts, 9r smulated acts, of sexual ntercourse, masturbaton, sodomy, bestalty, copulaton (oral, anal or vagnal), f1ag~li,aton or any sexual acts whch are prohbted by law; (2) The actual or smulated caressng or fondlng by one adult human beng of the breast, buttocks, anus or gentals of another adult human ben~; (3) The actual or smulated d$playng of the pubc har, anus, vagna, pens, vulva, buttocks, or any other external gentala of the human body; &HTMRequest=http%3a%2fOA2flbrar.muncod... 4/29/201 (

96 ." ~ 'V ~~ ~\) ~6 a rl o-t' Mu~~~"-r3 -f~ ~,'- ~ tn U ~ (l~.

97 PHIL HOH.OWI'I'Z 149 FILL:\10RE S'I'RE '~T SAN I'--RANCISCO. CA TELEPHONE: (415) FACSIMILE: (415) PHIL@CREATIVE.NET May 5, 2010 HAND DELIVERED Sharon M. Young San Francsco Plannng Department 1650 Msson Street, Sute 400 San Francsco, CA RECEIVED MAY CITY & COUNTY OF S.F. PLANNING DEPARTMENT RECEPTION DESK Re: Case No C: 200 Fllmore Street Dear Ms. Young: I am wrtng to oppose the request for a condtonal use authorzaton to allow an "other entertanment" use at 200 Fllmore Street. The request to allow lve entertanment at that locaton would negatvely affect me and my famly (we lve ktty corner from that locaton) and the neghborhood. The proposed lve entertanment would be heard loudly wthn my home. I know that because the current owner of the fast food restaurant has n the past unlawfully had lve entertanment n that locaton, repeatedly. I talked wth the busness owner, Mustapha Hakkou, told hm I could hear the lve acoustc jazz loudly nsde my home, and asked hm to please stop havng lve musc. I even nvted hm nto my home, where he admtted that the musc could be hear very well even wth my wndows closed. I remnded Mr. Hakkou that when he opened hs restaurant he met wth the neghborhood group and promsed he would never have any lve musc. Ths was an ssue of concern because a pror busness at the same locaton also had lve musc that created a nusance for our generally quet neghborhood. I enclose an e-mal I sent Mr. Hakkou to try to convnce hm to stop.

98 Sharon M. Young San Francsco Plannng Department May 5, 2010 Page 2 When Mr. Hakkou refused to stop havng lve musc, even after I explaned to hm that he dd not have the necessary permt, I reported the problem to the San Francsco Polce Department. I then made a complant wth the Department of Alcoholc Beverage Control. I enclose a copy of the complant. Mr. Hakkou later told me the complant resulted n a large fne, told me that he wanted to get along, and promsed me he would not try to have lve musc agan. The effect of the proposed lve entertanment would be even worse for me and my famly now, because we have two young chldren. One s not yet 2 years old. The other s almost 4 years old. Ther bed tme s 8 p.m. The proposal would nterfere the ablty of my chldren to sleep. The ground floor of 200 Fllmore Street s an napproprate locaton for lve entertanment for a number of reasons. Frst, lve entertanment s not approprate n an NC-1 Neghborhood Commercal Cluster Dstrct. NC-1 Dstrcts are the lowest ntensty commercal areas n San Francsco, "wth low-scale, nterspersed mxed use (resdental-commercal) development." San Francsco Plannng Code That s not a good place for lve entertanment, especally snce there are so many other approprate locatons n San Francsco (ncludng a couple of blocks away on Market Street). Second, lve entertanment n the evenng s partcularly napproprate n an NC-1 Neghborhood Commercal Cluster Dstrct. "NC-1 Dstrcts are ntended to serve as local neghborhood shoppng dstrcts, provdng convenence retal goods and servces for the mmedately surroundng neghborhood, prmarly durng daytme hours." San Francsco Plannng Code San Francsco s strugglng to keep and attract famles wth chldren. Allowng lve entertanment n the evenngs n the lowest scale neghborhood cluster dstrcts wll drve away famles wth chldren.

99 Sharon M. Young San Francsco Plannng Department May 5, 2010 Page 3 Thrd, the ground floor of 200 Fllmore Street does not come even close to meetng the requrements for lve entertanment n neghborhood commercal dstrcts. San Francsco Plannng Code allows lve entertanment n neghborhood commercal dstrcts only f the locaton "s adequately soundproofed or nsulated so as to confne ncdental nose to the premses." The locaton proposed for lve entertanment has no soundproofng at all. The exteror walls are almost entrely glass wndows. They are not double pane wndows, so sound travels very freely through them. When the double doors are open sound travels perfectly freely because there s no vestbule wth a second door. The doors are often left open, partcularly snce the locaton s not ar condtoned. If flled to ts capacty of about 60 people, wth lve entertanment, the locaton would get qute warm nsde except n wnter and the doors would be left open most of the tme. Even f the doors were closed, they would be opened much of the tme by customers comng and gong, ncludng gong outsde to smoke at the sdewalk table and chars. The nsde of the locaton s also desgned n a way that magnfes the projecton of sound. The floor s wood, wthout carpetng. The nsde walls are hard surfaces, as s the celng, wth no acoustcal tle or other steps taken to dampen the transmsson of sound. It would be hard to magne a locaton that was less soundproofed or less nsulated unless t had no walls at all. The notce of hearng states that "There wll be no tenant mprovements made wthn the exstng commercal space or changes to the exstng buldng envelope." That means there wll be no soundproofng and no nsulaton at all. No condtonal permt should be ssued.

100 Sharon M. Young San Francsco Plannng Department May 5, 2010 Page 4 If the applcant should wsh to alter the premses, wth buldng permts, another condtonal permt applcaton could then be consdered at that tme. In those crcumstances, the soundproofng and nsulaton could be tested to make sure that they "confne ncdental nose to the premses," as requred by San Francsco Plannng Code (as well as by San Francsco Plannng Code 303( c)(2) and 303( c)(2)(c)). The applcant has submtted a petton sgned almost entrely by people who do not lve close enough to hear the proposed lve entertanment n ther homes. The petton also does not dentfy where the sgners lve, so some busness owners have lsted ther busness addresses on the petton even though they do not lve there. Of course, nothng n the petton says that anyone who sgned t supports lve entertanment even f t wll be heard nsde other people's house, or even f wll keep other people's chldren awake at nght. Understandably, the applcant was not motvated to nclude anythng n the petton that presented the bggest problem wth the applcaton: nose nsde other people's homes. That s despte the fact that the applcant s well aware of that problem. Lve acoustc jazz s almost nvarable qute loud. It almost always ncludes drums. Wnd nstruments, such as trumpets, saxophones and trombones are common. Wthout soundproofng, lve acoustc jazz can easly be heard a block away. Lve jazz most certanly has a place n San Francsco. That place s not n a buldng n an NC-1 dstrct that has no soundproofng or nsulaton whatsoever. A fourth reason why the condtonal use applcaton should be dened s because, as far as s known to the undersgned, the "necessary nvestgatons and studes" requred by San Francsco Plannng Code 306,4 have not been done. Necessary nvestgatons and studes would nclude acoustcal studes showng how the sound of lve acoustc jazz would travel.

101 Sharon M. Young San Francsco Plannng Department May 5, 2010 Page 5 A ffth reason why the condtonal use applcaton should be dened s that allowng lve entertanment would lead to a large amount of outdoor nose generated from people sttng and drnkng alcoholc beverages at the outsde tables and chars, and from people mllng about the outsde of the establshment after the lve entertanment ended at 10 p.m. or 11 p.m. A sxth reason why the condtonal use applcaton should be dened s that t lacks a securty plan, as requred by San Francsco Polce Code 1060, ncludng at least one securty guard at all tmes. A seventh reason why the condtonal use applcaton should be dened s because the busness owner has not ever compled wth, or even reasonably attempted to comply wth, hs exstng condtonal use permt for sdewalk tables and chars. There s no reason to beleve he would do anythng dfferent wth respect to a second condtonal use permt. Whle that permt allows for use of a narrow stretch of the sdewalk durng certan hours, much more of the sdewalk's narrow wdth s used, often blockng so much of the sdewalk that people n wheelchars cannot pass by and two people cannot pass each other walkng on the sdewalk. At tmes, even one pedestran cannot walk by and must nstead walk on the street. Sample photos are attached. The busness owners's volatons of the exstng condtonal use permt for sdewalk chars and tables begns wth the setup n the mornng. The tables are set up so that they take at least one or two feet more of the sdewalk's wdth than permtted. Chars are then scattered wder and wder on the sdewalk as the day goes by, most days wthout the slghtest attempt by the busness to move them back n. The volatons contnue all nght, as the applcant does not remove the planter boxes from the sdewalk at nght as requred by the permt. Tables and chars have also been left out at tmes untl 11 p.m. and later, wth patrons at tmes talkng bosterously.

102 Sharon M. Young San Francsco Plannng Department May 5, 2010 Page 6 These problems have been brought repeatedly to the busness owner's attenton. The busness owner's response has been to say that even though the tables and chars are set up outsde the permtted area, there s usually stll room to get by, and he s not there often enough to make sure the chars are not scattered and the sdewalk blocked, he does not have enough staff to do that, and hs staff are n any event uncomfortable askng customers not to block the sdewalk. The problem wll get much worse f lve entertanment s allowed. The sdewalk wll become mpassble. Please do not allow lve entertanment, ncludng lve musc, at 200 Fllmore Street. The corner of Fllmore and Waller s generally quet and peaceful durng the days and n the evenngs; t s not at all lke Haght Street between Stener and Webster Streets. There are many places n San Francsco well suted for lve entertanment. Ths s not one of them. Please respect the rght of those who lve nearby to have peace and quet nsde ther homes. Please respect the rght of chldren to sleep nsde ther own homes. Very ~~ truly yours, Phl Horowtz Encls.

103 Unlawful Lve Musc and Broken Promse Subject: Unlawful Lve Musc and Broken Promse Date: Sun, 14 May :34: From: Phl To: Dear Moustafa; As unlawful. allowed to lcense. you know, the lve musc you have been havng on Sunday evenngs s You have no permt for lve entertanment. You are also not have lve entertanment under the terms of your alcohol My concern about your unlawful lve musc s that I can hear t my house. I can hear t now as I wrte ths e-mal. When you frst opened your busness and came to a communty meetng, you were told that a pror busness n your locaton had unlawful lve entertanment. You sad that ths was terrble and assured us that you would do no such thng. You broke that promse. When you and I talked a few weeks ago, I told you that one of my add tonal concerns about your unlawful lve musc was that when t was hot, you mght leave the door to your busness open, makng your unlawful lve musc even louder n my home. You promsed me that you would keep the door closed. You broke that promse also. Please call me Monday mornng to dj,',cuss ths. If we do not reach agreement that you wll stop lve entertanment n your busness, I wll contact Alcohol Beverage Control to fle a formal complant aganst your busness, n addton to pursung other legal acton. The unlawful rude conduct I have descrbed above s n addton to your unlawful conduct of blockng the sdewalk, ncludng makng t mpassble for people n wheelchars. I have photos showng that ths s stll occurrng, even n the last few days. You dd not call me, as I requested n my earler e-malstoyou.sot appears that you have no nterest n reachng agreement and prefer that we resolve your unlawful blockng of the sdewalk n court and through other legal procedures. If I do not receve a calion Monday from you, I wll assume that you also have no nterest n reachng agreement about your unlawful lve entertanment, and prefer that we also resolve that ssue n court and through other legal procedures. Is s really too much for me to ask your busness to follow the law when ths s necessary to show respect for others? Very truly yours, Phl Horowtz (415) (work) phl@creatve. net of I 5/14/20068:35 Pt-I

104 SEP : 18 ALCOHOL t. IS - J5~ - (.SbO Slale of Calforna COMPLAINT AGAINST LICENSEE ICBEVERAGECoNTRoL P.01/01 Department of Alcoholc Beerage Contro 1.-_êeNSEt NÄMF. f.. ÇAft: DU ~ O~.~.L~_.. J DONG BUSINESS AS (DBA) PREMISES INVOLVED._._._~._._ _-_ _...~- 12' LICENSE..~.. 1'PE AND NUMBER. _ çe.eé J) l! r_~~~:. ~ 4 PREMISES ADDRESS (Saa, num~a' am n8me, c,y_ sae. p cooo) OC E(LL-_~_Q1J S.1 /S' r. 5. r.onditidnal LICENSE (II y.a, atlac~. copy'" ne cendlono) IjYes UNO q IrZ....,'...,_...,.._.._.._.._-_.._....._-_..._"..._..... COMPLAINANT INFORMATION 8. COMPLAINAN:(Ä-."E , --., , "'--, ~ME PH-OÑËr'-UMBER-',_",_J!.,H. ( c, Ho (Zl)t~/ _'dlç. _...,, L1! ~.f: ~.t 2_?/!. B_ 110ME ADDRESS (S".e number om neme, oly, ".'0, tp ocdo) ~4;(- '/1'), ) f- Of 23 '" _ f.~tq_.. EU; '=_!~_~?/.(.t SHL... 9_ WORK AODRESS (Slroot nuiob., end Mm., cly,.oa, zp oo~.).. b.tl~!!1.l!ç_ E" , RELATIONSHIP TO rremise~ ÆIJí!4!I e Ac'lfÙ j.j S7t=r 13 CHEëK ÄlL1HÃT'ÄPF'LY ,- UMnors r~jafter Hours - --' " ' '--Ö:"-WORK PHONE NUMIlER NATURE OF COMPLAINT MNoìse,'/ ( I-I Drnk Solctaton --,-----,-,,----1 (! 1:;-. JqL_:_r?.!!.I.._._, ItJ~;~DENIAL kjno U Lewd Conduct l-j Gamblng!- False Owner j I Drunks/Obvously Intoxcated l -'Tobacco Sales to Mnors l-j Dsorderly House 1,_Drugs I Other r-- Prosttuton?''Volaton of Condtons DETAILS OF COMPLAINT -14,"OEs-cRp"õ-Ñ-ÖF PREMISES LOCATlë)N..(W:.;h~~-;~~~.h&;;-:.;'ý:-õ hõw,...,.....~.m.m.., M._.._..'.._._.-.,. T A IJLEJ._~_,_ÇJ!luf.), 0 J S I )tfwllj./c-.::::::--k.v.!.t:i,.. 1$~7 '1t.,.L" /~t..q#_,"'-" Je' JAL tl.41.,---0 ut S- f ó ~ /Ju:::---.:7l-1 ), j'7n,jp ùl ç--"-,---ajol,~-.,:--~ Mus.(.---f-t/-?,.---'/".)()r ~nj. J/ ;y'--- -/7(7:7- '-----'I.._ouïY, YVÒT~-H''''--:::--:;=~-~ H--è-':;"T---: '-''''-UIVI.....H 'H _.. _,_. u-----' 7// _-'------' u.!;_,~ Jl(;.c_G ìj T y'_ ~.- f.._.._5u N l)j1 V... --f, '''c fl/1:---'' , ,----, ,-,-.,---,.,,, , ,-.--,--- -,.--.,.-.,.-..,,--,-----,--,----- IIIYes l_no xlves No '5 CÒM 'Ü: W:NTHAs-E)I'HACrED THE aus'ness-öwn~-:lr(;gardingcõmp :ÃNT "6. COMPLAìÑÃÑrwsHü-Tc"BE NOTIFE"õfTHE RESULTS OF1HGïNvElTGÃTïõÑ , -CcM ;llíñänthasiled A COMP.ÄIf.TïN' :ÄNör.,ËllÀwï"ÑF"O-R"ëMENr AGENCY '"!es )(No tjoo,uù-il UII '1 pctt.-r ',-g-cõ-mp-wnt RÈCÈIVEO llv k!rz/j mot I Nt '22'" -Ù :ËRVISOR' R'EVIE\.~ff ,,-..-.". Í'ï~yä N"ME Of LAW'ENFORëË~ËNT-ÃGÊÑëyjï~=-''' ;'' (: J Ýo S-'--. NOltfOtÇX v "::-~~?/;-?'47"( ".J or;'~(t'-:ì',f VOQ ÕATE-RËëEve '2'-: MËREëEIVE 0 H t -,_?:~- Qb 73 ABC-61 ACTION! (r l) f _ ~~~.~~.~ \11~~1 TOTAL P, 01

105 . J'":. r.i I ~

106 :~: ::':: :~,.,: (. ~;;: :(' :.,.. '.. :;:: 1,:, C', f.. c: (T'..to -r:~ '-_. r.:' ",,:r~,..'t:" I, 0) ~ ~/- )7-;--0 C (.' r T /.--h-. - c: e, (( ~-- J çf' û I@ ~ J -ll-cd: ( J-.' Y J f?v C..,((-t.- J í-yd ~ U\ r- JI r-, - "'..(.. f -J r- r- "' w J a- c '- c. ~,. '" '\ -. ~ '; ~ \l ~ ~."; ":,:.,.,j.7 -:' ':'.--- :: :~ =2 ;:~.- " ",.";.' :;; î~ '. -:... ~:,;;: '-- ::~,..;:..-.,:, -- '.

107 N ~Q.. (J '---.,- lz 7-GJ ~ J ro o ;0-0 ç Z 8z -- t (J ~ --.. rr z ~ -- ~ç Z 8z FILLMORE ST.,,""... ~ " _. w _ _ c , C ~ËB ~E8 ~ PRPE UNE ~ JT :: (J ;- - :. ~ - ~. ~~ : :. : - :. : :.:.:.: '~ ::::::: :~ 6'-5" r ~ w a 0"' OJ,,0 0 ): lou1no o - U1 0" rr ~ -- ): Z 0 ): 7" N:: r 00 N '- (X AJ - 0 (J n ): F c 0 z~ (X o 0 (J 0J 0 U1 AJ 0 o r o rr (J - 0 ~r ): I l -- ): å ~r - " W ~B 29'-61' :' : ',1". Y',..;,I.!,.1. o. ~.:P;. ; "',.,.'~. r~i\ge ~:,.C'. '3~nr~~"~' ~;;, 'I~~',~~, ~:r~'-"~ d" "'L,',." ';.; l q' -I :. 11 'j "..r-.'.,'to" ;' J~J; ~L. I: -. xl t '*.~.; 't.'_~t ~ -, ':.,.-::_~~~ ~.\ r-... L.,.'._:c _...."';. ~1~.J '~",.' 1-..','Jl :~h'_:''. ~---:" ;;; "';...:-..;:.LJ: I,...~~: ~':..'; --..". ". ~~~O' 'j:ij:("',,:;.ll-'. ~-.":''\,1;' -w.. ~~'~,. )1. -t' f-'l"l,"-,".'rw 'j" l '''I.-,~-'f.;''''''.'~.. I 1.., ~'. (.,'...:;-,'I: l. : ~ 't-_., LI.J..;1 'I: r l.. 11 ;:.. ~l"'~ t ))., l' ~ :"'I~''''V'';: /ï'" t/,v~::'3 ~'~~...'..- ~ ~, ".. ~ ~.;~'l~t~'.,,; ~jq.~~;~ ~~/.;; l, ~~-.-~~~; ~.j ","..,L..~.._,.:(,..-:... (~ ==.,. HAtGtl..: -- ~~~$~, ~~~:~f~~.#j~ '~t~,!'v~~v~~~~f~~~~: I',;'.,.";":,~ ~à=;;-'~r,~~jl~'-1j;lf 'h(~j.:;" :'.:r'" '1''1' : \, 1: 'k,. U'USS\T ';'tn&:~~~;r~;f 'J e'. ~::. :'~l" l;!~ J~'r." --J.7 çr 'l' ~r- ~'$:J:~';: ~~~~~p.~j$%.\~~-;:' ~;; ~-t':~~~:~: '~l':...ø~.":~'='"'._. 'NA I.L'ER r,.r'~'~"~,1'..~,~\ 'f': l'~ C~ (Jl t--j í. _..."....~~.J_.. "~.~~ 'í.!.,. d; ~' 1~ Ị." = r ~ "' :..:"..._... C' : cjl,., I ~L_.- \,.,~,;.'--.r".'z.."ø-'...;.~.:j..._.._ t2ö(r~'~:-ltm'i~rit?;l.:~..:.r~:,~,:: r. f -- ;1.'. ~I ;.-. ' I L,.. 1 J...,"~',..1; ",; ",'j ::~.-,.;-:~' l~: ;.1,,_.j " 1.1 ~.J,. r r,.',,;, ;r,,..._, -t - - ~ '\1 -J :. r.. r:,e~l~jj~.. \ ~; L - '-" ''''', ~.. I'" ff~.. " _. I, JG rc:.i;=-',;,,:~:; ~. tæ'..~~~'.t~ 'j~ r-'jt\:i"õ 'rr _',3! :~.\; rji~~":(1~!~ltr,,.l~~~\tj.~,l_..,._l~~.. ò!~."'f\"a\ì~!".._...~.j rrt!~,,.,h :'~F.;.. ~, ((;)'3;:,.,,';~;0Tr:"~ 1:::;tt:: ~ î " \~...'~,r~l-,7jr~t-,~: "'!j.~1j..,'., j. 'I J." r I:.',-.II;;,,,) r :.. '='.~~;~~ ~, \..,.~. I ' (-,) O. t".'.._~.,_. CT1. 'f';)'" ; " ',' '''~~', frf~-:--~~r!'" I,,~"úf.,! ~"L.; ~..~~,J,.~ ; t-_ :L~"9', ---'1 ~"~ "-""l"~.-r I' r-r',- ~~;~~:J :~~.~~è\~' :'~~f;~l';i-~'-=3/'~ '1'--',;. ~.r-", rl I -: '. 1';-... ',,',,'~~~r:;j,l~!ja~1,j '~,S-,. ",":;f::)~ ::, ' ~:'!~"e~_._ v..'l.!er 4,.,',.'". ';,. (E~ l- ~, n ~ OWNER: l G ; l' ~ I ~!! MR. MUSTAPHA HAKKOU 2445 FILLMORE ST. SAN FRANCISCO CA (415) PROJECT: CAFE DU SOLE \ L 200 FILLMORE ST. SAN FRANCISCO CA ARCHITECT: ASHTON RICHARDS MCALLISTER ST. SAN FRANCISCO CA (415) ;!f,