Project QC Consultation on Proposed Reliability Standards and Supporting Documents. Information session for registered entities

Transcription

1 Prject QC Cnsultatin n Prpsed Reliability Standards and Supprting Dcuments Infrmatin sessin fr registered entities Nvember 26, 2015

2 Presentatin Overview 1. Meeting bjectives 2. Webinar instructins 3. Regulatry framewrk in Québec 4. Cnsultatin prcess 5. Prject QC Next steps 7. Questin perid and discussin 8. Régie decisins (R ) D , D and D

3 1. Meeting Objectives Prvide an update n reliability standards in Québec Present the prpsed standards and supprting dcuments Give infrmatin n the cnsultatin prcess Answer yur questins Present the next steps 3

4 2. Webinar instructins Phne set t Mute Chat buttn fr questins Presentatin QC is available n the Reliability Crdinatr site (in French and English) 4

5 3. Regulatry Framewrk in Québec The Régie de l énergie s respnsibilities are t: Designate the Reliability Crdinatr fr Québec. Adpt the reliability standards filed by the Reliability Crdinatr, as well as their attachments. Apprve the Register f Entities Subject t Reliability Standards. Mnitr cmpliance with reliability standards. 5

6 4. Cnsultatin Prcess Cnsultatin ntice sent Prpsed standards and supprting dcuments psted Infrmatin sessin Feedback perid Feedback n the standards and dcuments Evaluatin f the financial impact f the standards prpsed Respnse t feedback Other feedback cycles, if needed Filed with Régie de l énergie 6

7 Prject QC New r Updated Standards and Supprting Dcuments Prpsed 7

8 Reliability Standards Prpsed Eight new standards BAL CIP COM COM FAC FAC PRC PRC Real Pwer Balancing Cntrl Perfrmance Physical Security Cmmunicatins Operating Persnnel Cmmunicatins Prtcls Facility Intercnnectin Requirements Facility Intercnnectin Studies Disturbance Mnitring and Reprting Requirements Autmatic Underfrequency Lad Shedding 8

9 BAL Real Pwer Balancing Cntrl Perfrmance Summary Real pwer balancing cntrl perfrmance Equatins mved t attachment Varius cmpnents f BAL a defined ( lad management and intercnnectin frequency ) ACE limit intrduced, taking int accunt the frequency (Hz) f each intercnnectin Changes t ther standards r t glssary Retirement f BAL a when BAL adpted Three new terms t be added t glssary: Regulatin reserve sharing grup Regulatin reserve sharing grup reprting ACE Reprting ACE 9

10 BAL (cnt.) Applicability: Balancing Authrity (BA) Prpsed effective date in Québec: July 1, 2016 (same as in U.S.) Preliminary evaluatin f impact Lw 10

11 CIP Physical Security Summary Identifies critical transmissin facilities based n specific criteria Specific criteria are assessed by an independent third party Implements security measure designed t t deter, detect, delay, assess and cmmunicate threats and physical vulnerabilities Applicability: Transmissin wners with a transmissin substatin that meets the criteria in sectins t f CIP Transmissin peratr 11

12 CIP (cnt.) Prpsed effective date Standard Effective date in U.S. Prpsed effective date in Québec CIP Octber 2, 2015 First day f first calendar quarter 6 mnths after Régie adpts standard Preliminary evaluatin f impact Mderate 12

13 COM Cmmunicatins COM Operating Persnnel Cmmunicatins Prtcls Summary Redundancy and ambiguity eliminated Predefined cmmunicatin prtcls adpted Adherence t these prtcls assessed annually Training t be given n the use f the prtcls Use f cmmunicatins in three parts Applicability t distributin prviders and generatr peratrs Ambiguities eliminated in standards nw in effect Three new terms added t glssary Interpersnal Cmmunicatin Alternative Interpersnal Cmmunicatin Operating Instructin 13

14 COM and COM (cnt.) Changes t ther standards r t glssary Retirement f COM and COM Applicability: Transmissin Operatr (TOP) Balancing Authrity (BA) Reliability Crdinatr (RC) Distributin Prvider (DP) Generatr Operatr (GOP) 14

15 COM and COM (cnt.) Prpsed effective dates Standard Effective dates in U.S. Prpsed effective dates in Québec COM Octber 1, 2015 First day f first calendar quarter 3 mnths after Régie adpts standard COM July 1, 2016 First day f first calendar quarter 12 mnths after Régie adpts standard Preliminary evaluatin f impact Lw 15

16 FAC Facility Intercnnectin Requirements FAC Facility Intercnnectin Studies Summary Peridic five-year review Remve requirements if n impact n transmissin system reliability Eliminate redundancy between certain requirements Clearly establish requirements fr each entity cvered by the standards Make certain requirements less stringent based n type f facility Clarify criteria t assess fr system impact when cnnecting lads in line with NERC guidelines. 16

17 FAC and FAC (cnt.) Changes t ther standards r t glssary Retirement f FAC and FAC Applicability: FAC-001-2: TO and applicable GO FAC-002-2: PC, TP, TO, DP, LSE and applicable GO Prpsed effective date Standard Effective dates in U.S. Prpsed effective date in Québec FAC FAC January 1, 2016 First day f first calendar quarter 1 year after Régie adpts standard Assessment f impact Lw 17

18 PRC Disturbance Mnitring Summary New standard with 12 requirements Establishes system peratin parameters that must be measured Specifies technical requirements fr recrding characteristics Determines preferred lcatin f dynamic disturbance recrders Evaluates minimum characteristics t mnitr Describes criteria related t disturbance data transmissin 18

19 PRC (cnt.) Applicability: Reliability Crdinatr r Planning Crdinatr (RC/PC) Generatr Owner (GO) Transmissin Owner (TO) Prpsed effective dates Standard PRC R1 and R5 R12 R2, R3, R4, R6, R7, R8, R9, R10 and R11 Assessment f impact Prpsed effective dates in Québec First day f first calendar quarter 3 mnths after Régie adpts standard First day f first calendar quarter 6 mnths after Régie adpts standard First day f first calendar quarter 3 years after Régie adpts standard in rder t achieve 50% cmpliance First day f the first calendar quarter 5 years after Régie adpts standard and its attachment Implementatin f the standard Enfrcement f the standard Cmpliance mnitring Lw Mderate High X X X 19

20 PRC Autmatic Underfrequency Lad Shedding Summary Establishes design and dcumentatin requirements fr underfrequency lad shedding (UFLS) prgrams Designed t arrest rapidly declining frequency Designed t assist recvery f frequency Prvides last resrt measures fr generatin-transmissin system preservatin and integrity Applicability: PC UFLS entity TO 20

21 PRC (cnt.) Prpsed effective dates Requirement Prpsed effective dates in Québec R1 and R2, D.A.3 and D.A.4.3, R5 t R15 First day f first calendar quarter 6 mnths after Régie adpts standard. D.A.4.1 and D.A.4.2 (Reginal variance fr the Québec Intercnnectin) First day f first calendar quarter 1 year after trip settings prvided by generatr wners in Québec are available, in accrdance with PRC and its attachment. 21

22 Feedback Tw frms are available: Standards and supplementary dcuments Evaluatin f the impacts f prpsed standards It is imprtant t specify clearly the fllwing: Name f the persn submitting the feedback Name f the entity represented Dcument and sectin t which the feedback applies Impact the prpsed standard will have n the entity (human, material and financial resurces) being as specific as pssible Send feedback t: fiabilite@hydr.qc.ca 22

23 Next Steps Study feedback Pst respnse t feedback Hld technical meeting (if needed) Incrprate selected feedback int standards and supprting dcuments Cmpile evaluatins f the mnetary impact f the standards File case with the Régie de l énergie fr adptin f the standards 23

24 Régie Decisins D D D

25 Decisin D Rendered n May 4, 2015 (R Phase I) 14 standards and attachments adpted Applicable risk factr adpted 8 standards and attachments rejected Amendment f 16 standards requested Filing again requested fr adptin f new register f entities and glssary Repening f enquiry n industrial generatrs (PVIs) requested 25

26 Decisin D Rendered n June 23, 2015 (R Phase I) 3 standards adpted: BAL-004-1, CIP and EOP Register f entities apprved Glssary adpted 26

27 Decisin D Rendered n Octber 7, 2015 (R Phase II) 16 standards t take effect January 1, existing standards suspended 2 pending standards (remval f PSE and IA functins) frm R

28 Questin perid and discussin 28

29