Bowen High School. Definitions EXTERIOR E 89th St Chicago, IL Co-locating on This Campus: Bowen HS and Noble St Chtr-Orange

Transcription

1 Facility Assessment Summary This report summarizes the findings of a facility assessment completed on the date noted in the document footer below. Assessors rate each facility feature and system by visual observation only; they do not test operability or perform destructive testing inside walls, ceilings or floors. The rankings below reflect the assessors visual evaluations of the property condition as of that date. For additional information, you may review the detailed assessment report linked on this school s profile page and visit the Facilities Standards webpage under CPS Policies and Guidelines at Condition ings and Descriptions 7: The item/system is new or in good condition and no work is required. : The item/system requires general cleaning and/or routine maintenance. : The item/system requires repairs and has not reached the end of its serviceable life. : The item/system has reached its expected useful life, but is still fully operational. CPS will maintain until replacement occurs. : The item/system has surpassed its expected useful life and has limited operability. CPS will maintain until replacement occurs. : The item/system has surpassed its expected useful life and has low operability. CPS will maintain until replacement occurs. 1: The item s/system s failure leads to an immediate life safety condition for occupants or to the potential of an uninhabitable facility.¹ Definitions means, for each item, the total number (or amount) of that item that exists and was evaluated. Within that, different portions may have different rankings. means the generally accepted standard unit of measure for each item. Some items, like doors, are measured individually and use the unit of measurement EA for each. Other items, like chimneys, are measured in terms of linear feet ( LF ). Still other items, like flooring, are generally measured in square feet ( SF ). means a basic estimate for each item needing some level of repair or replacement. does not include all expenses that would be necessary to complete a repair or replacement project. This is because, depending on the item and on the overall scope of a construction project, repair/replacement projects can include additional costs such as destructive testing, environmental needs, discovered conditions, and additional work triggered by building codes. For the same reason, the Campus Need listed at the end of this report reflects only a portion of what it would actually cost to repair/replace all of the listed features. Campus Need also does not reflect features that do not yet exist at a particular facility, such as: programmatic improvements, school-wide ADA compliance, air conditioning, space reconfiguration, or construction to alleviate overcrowding; these are viewed as separate capital needs. EXTERIOR CHIMNEY Brick Chimney - Concrete/ Mortar Liner Metal Flue GRE LF 53 LF CORNICE Cornice - Terra Cotta 1 7, ,421 LF $30,766 $30,766 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 1 of 20

2 DOORS Exterior Steel Door Exterior Wood Door Overhead Rolling / Garage Door Transom Lite 1 7 GRE GRE GRE $10,240 3 $8,022 $1, EA $65,405 $84,695 ENTRANCE Concrete Exterior Stairs Concrete Ramp Entrance Controls - Audio Power Door Operator and Controls Ramp Handrails 1 GRE GRE GRE 7 2 BLU LF $57, LF $5,089 2 EA 60 LF $396 $63,079 FIRE ESCAPE Fire Escapes 1 7 GRE LF $5,097 $5,097 FOUNDATION Concrete Foundation Masonry Foundation 1 7,710,185 1,710 LF 1,185 SF LIGHTING Exterior Lights - Parapet or Roof Mounted Exterior Lights - Wall Mounted 1 0 GRE EA $5, EA $19,305 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 2 of 20

3 $24,310 LINTELS Lintels - Brick Lintels - Steel Lintels - Terra Cotta 1 7 GRE GRE 6 2, LF 142 LF $5,021 2,060 LF $5,021 PARAPET Coping - Metal Coping - Stone Coping - Terra Cotta Parapet < 16" Height Parapet > 30" Height Parapet 16" to 30" Height ,302 GRE ,058 BLU ,320 LF $ LF 1,058 LF 70 LF $16, LF 1,165 LF $37,790 $55,141 ROOF SYSTEM Asphalt Gravel Ballast Roof Asphalt Shingle Roof Exterior Downspouts Interior Downspouts Metal Roof Modified Bitumen Roof Roof Structure: Steel with Clay Tile Arch Roof Structure: Steel/Metal Deck/Concrete Topping 1 GRE ,353 BLU 5 21,364 7 GRE GRE GRE ,200 6,485 GRE GRE 7 82,542 GRE 7 50,837 97,553 SF $623,446 21,364 SF $141, LF $11, LF 9,760 SF $25, SF $2,301 82,542 SF 50,837 SF $804,383 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 3 of 20

4 SUPERSTRUCTURE Slab on Grade Steel Steel with Clay Tile Arch 1 7 GRE 7 4,238 GRE 7 92,966 99,237 4,238 SF 92,966 SF 199,237 SF WALLS Brick Prefabricated Metal Panel Wall Stone - Cast 1 7 GRE 6 29,209 95,223 GRE GRE 6 5, ,432 SF $192, SF $3,669 5,099 SF $72,916 $269,557 WINDOWS Curtain wall - Glazed Single Pane Curtain wall - Insulated panel Curtain wall - Louver Skylite - Glass Single-Pane Skylite - Lexan Window - Guards perforated Windows - Casement Aluminum Windows - Decorative Windows - Sash Aluminum Windows - Sash Aluminum Double-pane EXTERIOR 1 YEL 4 5,632 BLU 5 2,920 7 GRE BLU 5 1,316 YEL 4 4,649 GRE 7 6,342 GRE GRE 7 400,480 6,840 5,632 SF $956,787 2,920 SF $110, SF 1,316 SF $79,491 4,649 SF $991,626 6,342 SF 702 SF 400 SF 1,480 SF 16,840 SF $2,138,139 $3,480,187 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 4 of 20

5 ELECTRICAL EMERGENCY SYSTEM Automatic Transfer switch Emergency A/C power - Auditorium and aisle lighting Emergency A/C power - Corridors and Stairs Emergency A/C power - Gym and Lunch rooms Emergency A/C power - Students Toilets Emergency Battery Packs - Corridors and Stairs Emergency Battery Packs - Lunchroom and Gym Emergency generator 100 to 150 KW diesel - Outdoor Exit Signs - Auditorium Exit Signs - Corridors and Stairs Exit Signs - Lunchroom - Gym - multipurpose rooms Independent Electrical Service for emergency power Public Announcement System Security System - CCTV Security System - Intrusion detection 1 7 GRE 7 2 GRE 7 5,938 17,088 GRE 7 24,609 GRE 7 2,779 7 GRE GRE GRE 7 2 YEL 4 296,441 82,150 GRE 7 296,441 GRE 7 82,150 2 EA 5,938 SF 117,088 SF 24,609 SF 2,779 SF 17 EA 2 EA 12 EA 84 EA 19 EA 2 EA 378,591 SF $1,100, ,441 SF 82,150 SF $1,100,638 MAIN SERVICE Main Electrical service - Live Front A 120/208/3PH Main Electrical service 2000 A 120/208/3PH Main Electrical service 2000 to 3000 A 120/208/3PH 1 7 POWER DISTRIBUTION Lighting and power panels Main distribution panels amp Main distribution panels above 600 amp GRE EA $70,642 2 EA Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 5 of 20

6 Main distribution panels less than 400 amp ELECTRICAL 1 2 EA $6,578 $77,220 $1,177,858 FIRE PROTECTION FIRE ALARM Fire Alarm Strobe Lights Fire Alarm System FIRE PROTECTION 1 7 GRE 7 296,441 22, ,441 SF 122,842 SF MECHANICAL AIR CONDITIONING Chillers - Air Cooled - Rotary/Screw type - Ground Mounted 100 to 200 tons Condensing - Ground Mounted less than 5 tons Condensing - Roof Mounted 5 to 10 tons Window A/C AIR HANDLING SYSTEMS Air Handling Package - Multi Zone - Hot Water 15,001-20,000 cfm Air Handling Package - Single Zone - Electric 12,001 to 20,000 cfm Air Intake - Built Up Air Handling Air intake for all Air Handling s except built up AHU Make Up Air - Roof Mounted - Gas-Heating less than 6,000 cfm Multi Zone Built Up Air Handling - Steam above 35,000 cfm Multi Zone Built Up Air Handling Auxiliaries - Steam above 35,000 cfm Reheat Boxes With Steam Coils 1 GRE 6 4 GRE GRE 6 2 YEL 4 2 YEL GRE 6 4 YEL 4 3 YEL 4 3 GRE $25,597 $715 4 EA $9,152 7 EA $1,502 $36,966 2 EA $18,590 2 EA $148,720 3 EA $68,354 4 EA $5,720 $2,860 3 EA $493,350 3 EA $132,990 2 EA $2,088 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 6 of 20

7 Return Duct Work - Indoor - Vertical Shaft and Ducts Return Duct Work - Masonry and Ducts - Existing or Missing Exterior Shaft Return Fans - Indoor 10,001 to 20,000 CFM GRE YEL GRE LF 300 LF $793,650 4 EA $9,724 $1,676,046 BOILER SYSTEMS Boiler Assembly - Non-Condensing Scotch Marine Hot Water Boiler greater than 4,000 MBH Boiler Assembly - Steam - Low Pressure Scotch Marine Boiler greater than 200 HP Boiler Auxiliary - Steam Boiler greater than 200 HP Boiler Auxiliary Non-Condensing Hot Water Boiler greater than 4,000MBH Chemical Feed System (Steam Boilers) Chemical Pot Feeder - Hot Water Combustion Dampers Feed Water Pumps and Tank - Steam Boilers Glycol Feed System 1 BLU 5 1 BLU 5 2 GRE 6 2 BLU GRE BLU 5 1 $155,155 2 EA $200,200 2 EA $6,578 $32,890 $2,145 2 EA $1,502 5 EA $572 $19,305 $1,087 $419,433 HEATING DEVICES Fin Tube Hot Water Radiators - Hot Water Radiators - Steam Heater - Hot Water MECHANICAL PLUMBING Condensate Assembly - Pumps and Tank Piping - Condensate - Steel or Galvanized Piping - Hydronic Supply and Return - Steel or Galvanized Piping - Steam - Steel or Galvanized Pumps - Chilled Water less than 10 HP 1 GRE GRE 6 5 GRE 6 35 GRE YEL 4 2 ORA BLU BLU GRE LF $3,432 5 EA $ EA $4,905 8 EA $11,440 $20,406 2 EA $57, LF $68, LF $24, LF $34,635 2 EA $4,004 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 7 of 20

8 Pumps - Hot Water 5 to 10 HP GRE EA $4,004 $193,150 TEMPERATURE CONTROL Pneumatic System Thermostats - Pneumatic Zone Dampers UNIT VENTILATION Ventilators - Hot Water and Chilled Water VENTILATION 1 BLU 5 214,291 82,150 BLU YEL GRE ,441 SF $1,561, EA $59, EA $90,576 $1,711,470 3 $53,196 $53,196 Exhaust Fans - Roof Mounted 1,501 to 8,000 cfm Exhaust Fans - Roof Mounted 500 to 1,500 cfm Exhaust Fans - Roof mounted less than 500 CFM Lab Exhaust Hood Type I Exhaust Hood - Kitchen or Culinary Arts MECHANICAL BLU GRE 6 2 GRE 6 6 ORA EA $4,290 5 EA $5,034 2 EA $315 6 EA $19,734 $26,884 $56,256 $4,166,923 PLUMBING HOT WATER Hot Water Heater - Gas 150, ,000 BTU/HR Hot Water Heater - Gas more than 300,000 BTU/HR Storage Tank less than 500 gallons 1 GRE 6 2 GRE EA $8,294 2 EA $13,442 $21,736 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 8 of 20

9 PIPING Domestic Piping - Cold Water from Risers to Fixtures Domestic Piping - Cold Water Risers Domestic Piping - Hot Water from Riser to fixtures Domestic Piping - Hot Water Return Risers Domestic Piping - Hot Water Risers Domestic Piping Cold Water Horizontal lines Domestic Piping Hot Water Horizontal lines Domestic Piping Hot Water Return Lines Sanitary Piping Storm Piping Vent Piping 1 7 GRE 6 82, ,237 YEL 4 199,237 82,150 GRE 6 82, ,237 YEL 4 199,237 82,150 YEL 4 199,237 82,150 GRE 6 4,238 10,816 82, ,237 GRE 6 4,238 10,816 82, ,237 BLU 5 169,361 82,150 40,692 99,237 82,150 99,237 82,150 99,237 82, ,387 SF $14, ,387 SF $155, ,387 SF $93, ,387 SF $108, ,387 SF $129, ,441 SF $108, ,441 SF $73, ,203 SF $238, ,387 SF $122, ,387 SF $94, ,387 SF $71,227 $1,209,613 POOL SYSTEMS 1 7 Pool Drain Piping YEL LF $25,740 Pool Filtration System YEL 4 1 $217,360 Pool Hot Water Heater - Steam Heat Exchanger YEL 4 1 $13,013 Pool Supply and Return Piping YEL LF $23,595 $279,708 PUMPS Domestic Booster Pump duplex Ejector Pump Sump Pump PLUMBING 1 BLU 5 1 YEL YEL $15,730 2 EA $33,033 $11,869 $60,632 $1,571,689 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 9 of 20

10 INTERIOR ADMINISTRATIVE SUITES Ceiling - Lay-In Ceiling - Plaster/Drywall Flooring - Carpet Flooring - Concrete Flooring - Terrazzo Flooring - Tile/Sheet Flooring - Wood Lighting - Lay-In Lighting - Pendant/Surface Walls - Concrete Block Walls - Plaster/Drywall Walls - Structural Glazed Tile 1 7 GRE 6 9,167 3,008,143,688 GRE 6 83 GRE GRE 6 8,329 2,488 GRE BLU BLU GRE 6 5,195 1,988 GRE ,056 7,303 GRE ,175 SF $19,663 1,143 SF $3,236 1,688 SF $2, SF $ SF 10,817 SF $11, SF $2, SF $ SF $59 7,183 SF $14,858 14,319 SF $18, SF $4,633 $79,106 AUDITORIUM - DEDICATED Balcony Seating Main Floor Seating Sound System Stage Curtains Stage Lighting System 1 GRE 6 60 GRE EA $2, EA $20, EA $23,116 CHORAL ROOM Risers 1 7 GRE LF $515 $515 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 10 of 20

11 CLASSROOMS Work Sink 1 BLU $1,931 $1,931 CORRIDOR Student Lockers DOORS 1 GRE EA $2,860 $2,860 Interior Steel Doors incl hw Interior Wood Doors incl hw Side-lite Transom Window 1 7 GRE GRE EA $10, EA $62, SF $1, SF $2,621 $77,156 DRINKING FOUNTAINS Single Fountain 1 7 GRE EA $1,544 $1,544 GYMNASIUM / AUDITORIUM Bleacher Seating Ceiling - Exposed Ceiling - Plaster/Drywall Flooring - Wood Lighting - Metal Halide/Sodium Vapor Scoreboards Sound System 1 GRE GRE 6 8,021 GRE 6 3,007 5,661 7 GRE 6 5,661 11,028 GRE 7 79 GRE 7 2 GRE EA $10,633 8,021 SF $61,021 8,668 SF $78,510 16,689 SF $42, EA 2 EA 2 EA Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 11 of 20

12 Walls - Concrete Block Walls - Structural Glazed Tile GRE 7 8,487 BLU 5 6,785 4,805 8,487 SF 11,590 SF $354,540 $547,446 KITCHEN Ceiling - Plaster/Drywall Flooring - Concrete Lighting - Pendant/Surface Wall - Plaster/Drywall 1 GRE GRE GRE 7 20, SF $3, SF 20 SF 1,222 SF $3,209 LIBRARY Casework Flooring Tile/ Sheet Lighting - Lay-In LOCKER/SHOWER ROOM 1 GRE GRE 6 2,370 YEL LF $11,042 2,370 SF $3, SF $279 $14,710 Benches Lockers Showers GRE LF $ EA $10, EA $3,160 $14,717 LUNCHROOM Ceiling - Lay-In Flooring - Tile/Sheet Lighting - Lay-In Lighting - Pendant/Surface Serving Line 1 7 GRE 6 7, GRE ,086 YEL ,920 SF $15,199 7,920 SF $1, SF $ SF 168 LF Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 12 of 20

13 Wall - Plaster/Drywall Wall - Structural Glazed Tile GRE 6 5,236 GRE 7 4,304 5,236 SF $12,354 4,304 SF $29,081 MDF/IDF Finishes Ventilation and Cooling 1 BLU SF $3,083 $3,083 MECHANICAL/SERVICE ROOMS Air Handling/ Mechanical Room Air Intake Plenums Boiler Room Janitor's Closet Mechanical/Service Rooms Storage Room Vaults 1 GRE BLU ,985 GRE GRE 6 3,429 5,195 GRE 6 2,071 7,905 1,372 GRE SF $3, SF $10,193 1,985 SF 6 SF $9 8,624 SF $16,181 11,348 SF $60, SF $458 $91,376 PHYSICAL EDUCATION ROOMS Weight/ Fitness Room Floor Matting STAFF RESTROOM 1,400 2, ,665 SF $28,589 $28,589 Accessories Ceiling - Lay-In Ceiling - Plaster/Drywall Floor Drain Flooring - Concrete 1 7 GRE 6 9,206 2, GRE 6 3,029 5,143 GRE 7 39 GRE 6 6,657 11,729 SF $71, SF $236 8,172 SF $8, EA 6,657 SF $31,414 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 13 of 20

14 Flooring - Tile Ceramic/Porcelain Flooring - Tile/Sheet Hand Dryer Lavatory Lighting - Lay-In Lighting - Pendant/ Surface Partitions Urinals Wall - Concrete Block Wall - Plaster/Drywall Wall - Structural Glazed Tile Wall - Tile Ceramic/ Porcelain Water Closet,473 3,598 GRE 6 62 GRE 7 22 GRE YEL 4 18 GRE GRE ,858 6,422 GRE ,004 1,538 GRE 6 2,351 5,425 BLU ,071 SF $3, SF $89 22 EA 52 EA $5, SF $ SF $ EA $9, EA $3,718 9,460 SF $9,533 2,904 SF $4,077 7,776 SF $16, SF $2, EA $1,859 $169,133 SWIMMING POOL Accessories Bleacher Seating/Plank seating Lighting - Pendant/ Surface Pool Basin Pool Deck Pool deck drains Splined Ceiling including access Structural Glazed Tile 1 GRE GRE 7 48 GRE 6 72 BLU 5 1,538,800 0 GRE 6 3,094 GRE 6 4,256 4 SF $31 48 EA 72 SF $77 1,538 SF $145,156 1,800 SF 10 EA 3,094 SF $33,183 4,256 SF $30,430 $208,878 THEATER Ceiling - Plaster/Drywall Flooring - Carpet Flooring - Concrete Lighting - Pendant/ Surface 1 7 GRE 7 5,938 GRE 6 2,969 GRE 7 2,969 GRE 7 8 5,938 SF 2,969 SF $4,246 2,969 SF 8 SF Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 14 of 20

15 Stage Stage Platform Wall - Plaster/Drywall Wall - Structural Glazed Tile,207 GRE GRE 7 5,968 GRE 7 5,968 1,207 SF 288 SF $1,223 5,968 SF 5,968 SF $5,469 VERTICAL CONVEYANCE Elevator - Roped Holeless Hydraulic Stage Lift 1 7 VOCATIONAL SHOP Work Sink INTERIOR 1 7 GRE EA $4,247 $4,247 $1,306,165 ROOM CASEWORK Casework 1 7 GRE ,771 LF $68,962 $68,962 CEILING Ceiling Exposed Ceiling Lay-In/Drop Plaster/Drywall Splined Ceiling 1 GRE GRE GRE ,169 3,350 GRE 6 7,045 6, BLU 5 1, SF $2, SF $727 73,411 SF $153,419 14,616 SF $58,797 1,565 SF $8,862 $224,339 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 15 of 20

16 CHALK BOARD Chalk Board CLASSROOM 1 YEL 4 1,381 Bowen High School 7 1,381 LF $167,861 $167,861 Eye Wash Station Laptop Charging Station Science Lab Elements Science Lab Shower 1 7 GRE 7 2 GRE 7 6 GRE ,009 GRE EA 6 EA 1,866 SF $40,442 2 EA $40,442 CORRIDORS Concrete Block Drop/Lay-In Lay-In Pendant/Surface Plaster/Drywall Single Water Cooler Stair Handrails Student Lockers Terrazzo Tile/Sheet Flooring 1 7 GRE 7 24,306 GRE 6 51,620 YEL YEL 4 2,512 GRE 6 58,222 GRE 6 4,144,575 GRE 7 2,901 GRE 6 48,881 24,306 SF 51,620 SF $110, EA $1,264 2,512 EA $24,427 58,222 SF $137,375 4 EA $2,460 1,144 LF 1,575 EA $225,225 2,901 SF 48,881 SF $69,900 $571,375 FLOOR Concrete Tile/Sheet Wood 1 BLU 5 2,545 7,695 49,647 5,223 GRE 6 32,047 2,545 SF $12,010 56,565 SF $80,594 32,047 SF $241,968 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 16 of 20

17 $334,571 LIBRARY_CEILING Drop/Lay-In LIBRARY_WALL Concrete Block Mansory LIGHTING 1 GRE 6 2,370 1,350 GRE ,370 SF $5,084 $5,084 1,350 SF $3, SF $10,682 $14,543 Lay-In Pendant/Surface 1 7 YEL 4 1, YEL ,187 EA $429, EA $109,717 $538,774 MARKER BOARD Marker Board 1 7,928 1,928 LF RESTROOM_CEILING Restroom Ceiling 1 7 GRE 7 3,508 3,508 SF STAIRS Terrazzo 1 7 GRE SF Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 17 of 20

18 WALL Concrete Block Masonry Metal/Folding Panel Plaster/Drywall ROOM 1 7 GRE 6 28,125 5,610 BLU 5 7,495 1, GRE ,538 51,333 6,532 33,735 SF $80,438 9,435 SF $302, SF $1,581 68,403 SF $170,849 $555,124 $2,521,073 SITE CIVIL/DRAINAGE Catch Basin Site Manhole GRE EA 24 EA FENCING Chain Link Ornamental Iron 1 GRE , LF $3,213 1,463 LF $4,710 $7,922 LANDSCAPE Benches Grass Parkway trees Planting Beds/ Areas Retaining Wall - Concrete Retaining Wall - Masonry Trash Receptacles 1 7 GRE 7 46 GRE ,001 GRE 7 55 GRE 6 23,501 GRE GRE EA 87,601 SF $ EA 23,501 SF 48 SF $1, SF $2,124 5 EA Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 18 of 20

19 $4,037 PARKING LOT Asphalt Concrete Curbs Lights, Pole Mounted Parking lot interior plantings Trash Compactor Vehicular Screening 1 GRE 6 97,613,254 BLU 5 6 GRE GRE ,613 SF $83,752 1,254 LF $7,567 6 EA $24, LF $3, LF $118,918 PLAYGROUND Playground Equipment - Pre-K 3-5 Playground Surfacing - Poured Surface Playground Surfacing - Wood Chips GRE YEL 4 1,115 4 EA 404 SF 1,115 SF $7,175 $7,175 SIDEWALKS Internal Walks Perimeter Sidewalks 1 7 GRE GRE 6 8,281 22,442 1,202 LF $9,325 30,723 SF $15,631 $24,956 SIGNAGE Flag Pole Marquee - Free Standing Back Lighted w/ LED SITE 1 BLU $16,517 $16,517 $179,525 Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 19 of 20

20 Campus Need ² ³ $14,403,420 ¹ It is very rare for an assessor to find a feature in this condition. If they do, they are required to report it immediately to CPS, and CPS addresses it immediately. Thus, no features will be ranked 1 in summary reports; by the time the report is compiled, they have been resolved. ² As stated above, Assessed Campus Need does not include the addition of features not already in a particular facility, such as programmatic improvements, school-wide ADA compliance, air conditioning, space reconfiguration or construction to alleviate overcrowding; these items are treated as separate capital needs. The Assessed Campus Need includes current deficiencies and is based on current unit cost estimates; it does not reflect a complete project cost. ³ The overall condition of different items can change after an assessment date due to many variables, including newly occurring deficiencies, renovation or repairs and cost changes. These dollar figures in this report are estimates only and are based solely on the data that was collected as of the assessment date in the footer below. Assessment Date: 11/28/2012 Page 20 of 20