Project Affordable Housing Design Rubric

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Project Affordable Housing Design Rubric"

Lynette Jacobs
5 years ago
Views:

1 Project Affordable Housing Design Rubric Elements Weight 5 Points 4 Points 3 Points 2 Points 1 0 Points Title Page Table of Contents Project Description Bubble Diagrams Design Sketches The title page includes all Excellent Neat and easy to read. includes all necessary information. Excellent Neat and easy to read. Page numbers are included and correspond to page numbers within Excellent description of the site and the proposed project. Includes all key elements of project. A thorough list of criteria and constraints is d. Client survey is completed and additional notes included. Interior and site bubble diagrams d. Spaces and their relationship are well defined and clearly labeled. Bubble sizes are proportional. Traffic flow indicated within the structure. Site orientation considerations indicated with arrows and notes. Sketches are included and all elements of the design are included. Sketches are well crafted and The title page includes most of the necessary information. Good includes most of the Good Page numbers are included but may not consistently correspond to page numbers within the Good description of the site and the proposed project. An acceptable list of criteria and constraints is d. Client survey is completed but lacking explanatory notes. Spaces are labeled and have some relationship to each other. There is some evidence of planning but bubbles are not proportional and the sizes are not clearly evident. Traffic flow is poor or not addressed. Some site considerations indicated. Sketches are included, but one or two elements of the design are Sketches are fairly well The title page includes some of the necessary information. Acceptable includes some of the Acceptable Page numbers are not included or do not correspond to page numbers within the No page numbers within the Project description missing key features. Several important criteria or constraints are Minimal documentation on client survey. Diagram(s) are confusing. Spaces are not labeled. Proportionality and layout are not correct. No attempt at sizing has been made. Traffic flow is haphazard. Minimal site orientation considerations noted. Either interior or Site bubble diagram Sketches are included, but more than three elements of the design are Sketches are A title page exists but most necessary information is Poor A table of contents exists but most necessary information is Poor Project description exists but is lacking. Client survey not included. The relationship between bubble sizes and the spaces they represent are not detailed. There is no clear indication of traffic flow. No site orientation considerations noted. Sketches are incomplete. Some sketches are title page. table of content. an acceptable project description or client survey. bubble diagrams. Total Civil Engineering and Architecture Activity Affordable Housing Design Rubric Page 1

2 Code Considerations Habitat for Humanity Requirements proportional, and include annotations where necessary to support the design. All sketches are initialed, dated and signed by the client. Meets applicable code considerations, including o Bathroom glazing/vent o Habitable room glazing area o Minimum room areas o Minimum room dimensions o Bathroom clearances o Emergency escape in sleeping rooms o Means of egress o Egress door size o Stairway requirements o Landing requirements o Thermal envelope Meets applicable Habitat for Humanity requirements, including o Square footage o Type of o Kitchen windows o No. of baths o Exterior doors o Attic access o Windows meet requirements o Linen closet o Heat pump o Water heater o Washer and dryer hookup o Hose bibs o Light fixtures crafted and proportional. Annotations are limited. Sketches are not initialed, dated, or signed by the client. Minor code violations exist. One or two code requirements not One or two Habitat for Humanity requirements not sloppy and not proportional. Minimal annotations. Three or four code requirements not Three or four Habitat for Humanity requirements not Annotations are Major code violations. More than four code requirements not Five or six Habitat for Humanity requirements not sketches. indication of compliance with building codes. evidence of compliance with Habitat for Humanity Civil Engineering and Architecture Activity Affordable Housing Design Rubric Page 2

3 Floor Plan Universal Design Features Elevations Wall Section The floor plan is successfully designed for traffic flow. All minimum space/size requirements are Windows and doors are in suitable locations and are properly sized. Exterior symmetry of windows and doors has been considered. Interior plumbing fixtures, appliances, and cabinets for human needs are detailed properly. Storage is d. Dimensions are modular and are properly placed. The Elements of a Good Floor Plan (as described in the handout) are incorporated into the design All required universal design features shown and annotated, including o Accessible entrance o Door and passage width o Open kitchen o Accessible bath All elevations included, properly labeled, and aligned correctly. Windows and doors are arranged with harmony (both aesthetically and proportionally). Exterior finishes are shown, labeled, and consistent. Roof slope is indicated. Levels are indicated with correct elevations. Building section properly shown. The internal as well as external structure of the wall is evident and properly labeled. Wall section indicates compliance with o Crawl space The floor plan is laid out for traffic flow. Most windows and doors are in suitable locations and are properly sized. Interior plumbing fixtures, appliances, and cabinets for human needs are not fully detailed. Dimensions are modular and are mostly placed correctly. Some Elements of a Good Floor Plan (as described in the handout) are violated. One required universal design feature not shown and annotated. All elevations included but incorrectly labeled or incorrectly aligned. Window and door locations not aesthetically pleasing or not proportional. Minor errors in exterior finish details. Roof slope is not indicated. Levels are not indicated or incorrect elevations shown. Building section properly shown. Eighty percent of components are properly represented and labeled. Wall section indicates compliance with most The floor plan is not laid out well with respect to traffic flow. Windows and doors are haphazardly placed and are not properly sized. Interior plumbing fixtures and cabinets for human needs are missing or improper. Dimensions are not modular and are placed in an inconsistent manner. Many Elements of a Good Floor Plan are violated Two required universal design features not shown and annotated. One elevation Elevations do not match expected views. Most annotations Building section shown. Fifty percent of components are properly represented and labeled. Wall section indicates compliance with some The floor plan is drawn but no consideration has been given to the placement of windows, doors, storage, traffic flow, and interior aspects, such as plumbing fixtures, cabinets, and dimensions. Most Elements of a Good Floor Plan are violated. Three universal design features not shown and annotated. More than one elevation No annotations. Building section shown however, more than fifty percent of the components are not properly represented or labeled. Wall create a wellplanned and efficient design. include universal design features. Minimal attempt. create wall section. Civil Engineering and Architecture Activity Affordable Housing Design Rubric Page 3

4 Schedules Site Plan o Drainage o Correct 2 x 6 wall, if used o Correct roof o Correct floor o Correct foundation o Roof pitch o Proper insulation per code and vapor barrier Door, window, and room schedules are included. The floor plan includes tags that correctly correspond to scheduled doors, windows, and rooms. Schedules correctly identify size and family of all doors and windows to be installed to the extent that heat transmission loads can be determined. Room areas and total area are given. Site Plan includes all required elements including o Use 1 = 30 scale o Legal description o North arrow o Property lines (by sketching over existing lines) and tags o Setbacks o Water (W) and Sanitary Sewer (SS) mains along the streets. Note that the SS lines should pass through the manholes. o House pad with appropriate dimensions and finished floor elevation o Driveway, walks, decks and patios Door, window, and roof schedules are included. The floor plan includes tags, but tags do not correctly correspond to scheduled doors, windows and/or rooms. Schedules correctly identify size and family of at least ninety percent of doors and windows to be installed to the extent that heat transmission loads can be determined. Rooms are incorrectly labeled and or improperly separated. One or two site plan elements are One of schedules is The floor plan does not include tags. Schedules identify inappropriate sizes and/or types of doors and windows to be installed or show less than fifty percent of windows, doors and rooms. Three to five site plan elements are section indicates noncompliance with most Two of three schedules are Six to nine site plan elements are include schedules. add required elements to site plan or site plan is Civil Engineering and Architecture Activity Affordable Housing Design Rubric Page 4

5 Green, Sustainable and LEED Features o Water service line (W) to the house o Sanitary sewer service line (SS) to the house o Landscaping -At least four green or sustainable design features are described and, when feasible, indicated on drawings. -Comply with all categories LEED -At least three green or sustainable design features are described and, when feasible, indicated on drawings. - Comply with 80% of categories LEED At least two green or sustainable design features are described and, when feasible, indicated on drawings. - Comply with 75% categories LEED At least one green or sustainable design feature is described and, when feasible, indicated on drawings. - Comply with 50%categories LEED No green or sustainable features are described. - Comply with less than 50% categories LEED Civil Engineering and Architecture Activity Affordable Housing Design Rubric Page 5

Project Affordable Housing Design Rubric

Project Affordable Housing Design Rubric Project 2.3.1 Affordable Housing Design Rubric Elements Weight 5 Points 4 Points 3 Points 2 Points 1 0 Points Title Page Table of Contents Project Description Bubble Diagrams The title page includes all