arxiv: v1 [cs.it] 16 Nov 2017

Transcription

1 Sptio-Temporl Motifs for Optimize Vehile-to-Vehile (V2V) Communitions Tenghn Zeng, Omi Semiri, n Wli S Wireless@VT, Brley Deprtment of Eletril n Computer Engineering, Virgini Teh, Blksurg, VA, USA Emils:{tenghn, wlis}@vt.eu Deprtment of Eletril Engineering, Georgi Southern University, Sttesoro, GA, USA Emil: osemiri@georgisouthern.eu rxiv:7.030v [s.it] Nov 207 Astrt Ching populr ontents in vehile-to-vehile (V2V) ommunition networks is expete to ply n importnt role in ro trffi mngement, the reliztion of intelligent trnsporttion systems (ITSs), n the elivery of multimei ontent ross vehiles. However, for effetive hing, the network must ynmilly hoose the optiml set of rs tht will he populr ontent n isseminte it in the entire network. However, most of the existing prior rt on V2V hing is restrite to he plement tht is solely se on lotion n user emns n oes not ount for the lrge-sle sptio-temporl vritions in V2V ommunition networks. In ontrst, in this pper, novel sptio-temporl hing strtegy is propose se on the notion of temporl grph motifs tht n pture sptio-temporl ommunition ptterns in V2V networks. It is shown tht, y ientifying suh V2V motifs, the network n fin su-optiml ontent plement strtegies for effetive ontent issemintion ross vehiulr network. Simultion results using rel tres from the ity of Cologne show tht the propose pproh n inrese the verge t rte y 5% for ifferent network senrios. I. INTRODUCTION Vehile-to-vehile (V2V) ommunition is seen s one of enling tehnologies for intelligent trnsporttion systems n key enler for mny smrt ro n trffi mngement systems [], s it llows ritil informtion issemintion. Moreover, spurre y the vilility of in-vehile infotinment (IVI) systems isseminting entertinment n informtion ontent to pssengers [2], there is strong nee for high-spee n stle elivery of lrge multimei files, suh s vieos, photos n songs, to the vrious rs within vehiulr network. For effetive issemintion of suh iverse ontent ross vehiulr networks, there is nee for effetive ontent plement strtegies to mximize the throughput of the system [3]. Moreover, to rep the enefits of V2V ontent issemintion, we must ress ifferent hllenges inluing optiml he plement n resoure llotion []. Che plement in V2V networks hs reently ttrte signifint ttention suh s in [5]-[8]. In suh works, the populr ontents re offloe to the storge of numer of well-hosen rs n evies t off-pek hours in orer to serve requests uring pek trffi hours. In these senrios, rs n evies tht o not hve the he ontent will not hve to ownlo the ontent from wireless se sttions (BSs). Inste, they n request the ontent iretly from other rs hving he t whih n eventully le to reution in the trffi lo t the BSs. Menwhile, hing using lol storge n reue lteny ue to shorter ommunition istne. However, the enefits of hing re highly epenent on the set of rs n evies hosen for hing the populr ontents [7]. This reserh ws supporte y the U.S. Ntionl Siene Fountion uner Grnts CNS-5397 n IIS In [5], the uthors use vehile moility t for ontent issemintion n omine the ie of opportunisti forwring, trjetory se forwring n geogrphil forwring to evelop moility-entri lgorithm to ple ontent in vehiulr networks. Menwhile, the work in [] pplies ville users moility ptterns to evelop polynomil-time solution to mximize the sve ost y hing ontents in lol storge. Moreover, in [7], the uthors use lotion informtion n susription-se informtion to ivie vehiles into ifferent groups n, then, esign sptio-temporl multist routing protool to onstrut n optimize issemintion mesh network. The work in [8] presents n optiml hing poliy y using oth moility informtion n users emns n proposes greey hing lgorithm with polynomil orer omplexity to otin ouns of the hing poliy whose omplexity grows exponentilly with the numer of users. However, existing works, inluing [5]-[8], o not tke into ount the temporl ynmis of V2V ommunition networks, suh s the frequeny of ourrene of ifferent V2V links, whih n e key metri for ontent plement. For exmple, using only lotion informtion to selet the set of rs tht will he the ontent n le to hoosing rs whih re unle to ommunite with eh other or with other rs, effetively limiting the enefits of hing. The min ontriution of this pper is novel frmework for sptio-temporl hing in vehiulr networks tht is ogniznt of intrinsi sptil n temporl ptterns in V2V ommunitions. In prtiulr, using the tools of temporl network nlysis [9], we ientify temporl motifs in the V2V network s key ommunition ptterns oserve mong vehiles tht pper more frequently ompre with wht is expete in seline, rnomize referene system. After ientifying the sptil-temporl motifs, the propose pproh then fins the est nite rs for ontent plement. To our est knowlege, this is the first work tht exploits sptil-temporl motifs for optimizing ontent issemintion in vehiulr networks. Simultion results using rel tres from the ity of Cologne, Germny, show tht the propose motif-se pproh yiels signifint performne gins in terms of the verge t rte, ompre to onventionl lotion-se sheme. The rest of the pper is orgnize s follows. Setion II presents the system moel n prolem formultion. In Setion III, we present the propose motif-se pproh. Setion IV provies the simultion results. Conlusions re rwn in Setion V. II. SYSTEM MODEL AND PROBLEM FORMULATION Consier vehiulr network in n urn environment, ompose of set N of N vehiles. In prtiulr, s shown in Fig., we onsier tht nery BS provies wireless overge to the

2 Link etween BS n rs V2V ommunition Songs j SINR t the reeiving r j from the trnsmitting r i exees trget threshol for V2V ommunition, otherwise, L i,j = 0. Aoringly, the hievle t rte for the V2V link etween the serving r n non-serving r is i R, = ω log 2 ( + γ, ), (3) Work zones Vieos Cr ients Fig.. V2V ommunition networks n its mrosopi ommunition grph. rs in N. The BS frequently uses eon signls to keep trk of the vehiles positions y using the reeive signl-strength mesurements in [0], n ollets the V2V ommunition t when exhnging informtion with the ommunition fility within the vehiles s propose in []. In our system, the BS seeks to see multimei files n trffi t in the storge unit of set C N of C rs to provie the pssengers in neighoring rs with streming servies or to isseminte ely-sensitive informtion, suh s upoming ro inients to help rivers eie on their routes. Using this mehnism, the seee rs, referee to hereinfter s serving rs, n isseminte the he ontent to nery rs vi V2V links. Consequently, the BS n reue its trffi lo, s it no longer nees to trnsmit the sme ontent to multiple rs. Fig. shows se in whih the BS hes ontent t r. Here, n ritrry r N\{} sens request for ontent m to the BS. If the ontent is lrey he t r, the BS woul inform the requesting r to use V2V ommunition to otin the ontent from. Otherwise, the BS hs to iretly trnsmit the requeste ontent to, whih inreses its lo. Hereinfter, we refer to rs tht o not hve the he ontent s non-serving rs. To inrese the spetrum effiieny, we ssume tht V2V links reuse the spetrl resoures of the ellulr network s in [2]. A. Prolem formultion The signl-to-interferene-plus-noise rtio (SINR) of V2V ommunition link etween serving r n non-serving r will e: P, g, γ, = I, + I + σ 2, () where P, is the trnsmission power from to, n σ 2 is the vrine of the Gussin noise t the reeiver. In ition, g, represents the hnnel gin etween n n n expresse s g, =η α,, where η is the fing gin,, is the istne, n α is the pth loss exponent. We onsier tht the ellulr links n the V2V links will experiene Ryleigh fing s one in [3]. I, n I pture, respetively, the interferene generte y the links etween the BS n other vehiles n y other V2V ommunition links. These interferene terms re given y, I, = (L, )P, g,, I = (L, )P, g, N \, N \ where L i,j is inry vrile tht ptures the fesiility of ommunition link etween i n j. In ft, L i,j = if the (2) where ω is the nwith. The orresponing SINR γ, n the hievle rte R, etween the BS n non-serving r, re: γ, = P,g, I + σ 2, R, = ω log 2 ( + γ, ). () We onsier set M of M populr ontents with the sme size, sorte from high to low populrity. Due to the limite storge, the serving noes will hoose to he limite numer of ontents. Therefore, to inrese the possiility of meeting the requirements from non-serving noes, the serving rs will he F M most populr files, uner the pity onstrints. Therefore, when non-serving noe requests one file out of the F files, the noe n quire it vi V2V link s long s there exists one serving noe within its ommunition rnge. To leverge V2V ommunitions for isseminting he ontent, the network must etermine whih vehiles t s serving noes so s to mximize the verge t rte hieve y non-serving rs. To this en, we efine the inry vrile x i for eh r i, where x i = if r i is selete s serving noe, otherwise x i =0, n set C ontins C= N i x i serving noes. Therefore, we n formulte the prolem s follows: ( F mx Pr (m) ) M β, R, + Pr (m)r, C N(N C) N \C m= C m=f + (5) s.t. P, P mx, () γ γ,, (7) where Pr (m) is the proility mss funtion (pmf) of the request for file m y r. This istriution n e moele y the Zipf istriution with pmf Pr (m) = m / M θr x= x, θr where θ r is the Zipf exponent tht etermines the skewness of the istriution []. The initor vrile β, is suh tht β, = if the serving r is the nerest r to the requester in the serving set C; β, =0, otherwise. β, ensures tht non-serving r will lwys hoose the losest serving r with the requeste file. Constrint () gurntees tht the trnsmission power of vehiles will not surpss the mximum power level P mx, n onstrint (7) ensures tht SINR of the V2V links is ove threshol, γ. B. V2V mrosopi ommunition grphs As long s we fin the optiml set of serving vehiles, we n ssign non-serving noes to serving noes oring to the sptil istne, n solve the prolem given y (5)-(7). However, fining the optiml set C is 0- integer progrmming where etermining whether eh iniviul noe in the set N shoul e onsiere s either serving or non-serving noe. In ft, the prolem is one of Krp s 2 NP-omplete prolems [5], whih is hr to solve iretly. Alterntively, we n fin su-optiml solution to the optimiztion prolem y using the informtion within the vehiulr

3 network. In prtiulr, in ition to the the position n emn of eh vehile, we n lso leverge the temporl omin informtion. This is euse V2V networks re nturlly ynmi n exhiit the temporl fetures. For exmple, the numer of ommunition links etween two ritrry rs my vry with time. Suh temporl informtion on the frequeny of ommunition is vlule to etermine whih rs re more likely to etter isseminte the ontent. Therefore, time omin informtion is lso importnt to hoose the optiml set C for he plement n solve the prolem (5)-(7). To pture the ynmis in the time omin, we propose to use ollete V2V ommunitions t n moel the system s irete temporl grph G=(N, E), whose verties re the rs in N n whose temporl eges, in set E, enote the timestmpe ommunition events mong vehiles. We represent wireless ommunition link etween two ifferent rs s 3- tuple ege lele s i, e i =< i, i, t i >, where i n i enote the serving r n the non-serving r, respetively. t i is the time of inititing the trnsmission from i to i. Here, we ssume tht, t ny time, r nnot ommunite with more thn one r simultneously. In this se, there re no two eges with the ommon vehile element initite t the sme time. To otin the set of rs tht re more tive n more likely to prtiipte in the V2V ommunition in perio of time, we introue the time onstrint T n evie the grph G=(N, E) into multiple mrosopi ommunition grphs, where we n hnge the vlue of T to filter outte V2V links. Tht is, for ny ege e i in these mrosopi grphs, there lwys exists t lest one other ege e j, i j, in the sme grph, tht meets the following requirements: Two eges shre t lest one noe, ( i, i ) ( j, j ) ; If wireless onnetion i ours efore nother onnetion j, 0 t j t i T ; If wireless onnetion j ours efore nother onnetion i, 0 t i t j T. Given these efinitions, using the grph-theoreti frmework of temporl networks nlysis, next, we present novel grphtheoreti su-optiml solution to the originl prolem in (5)-(7). III. PROPOSED STRATEGY BASED ON SPATIO-TEMPORAL MOTIFS To fin su-optiml solution to (5)-(7), we nee to evelop n lgorithm to etet motifs in V2V ommunition mrosopi grphs. To this en, we follow three steps. The first step is serhing mirosopi sugrphs efine s si ommunition units with typil sizes (numer of eges) in mrosopi ommunition grphs. The seon step is olleting mirosopi sugrphs with similr isomorphi struture. The thir step is etermining the frequently ourring motifs fter ompring eh sugrph s frequeny f of ourrene with its ounterprt f in seline rnomize V2V ommunition network. In prtiulr, we use the notion of Z-sore, expresse s Z = f f, (8) σ m where σ m ptures the stnr evition of the orresponing sugrph in the referene system. If Z>Z th, where Z th is given threshol, we n lssify the sugrph s motif []. Finlly, Algorithm Mirosopi Sugrphs Serhing Algorithm Input: A V2V mrosopi ommunition grph G = (N, E ), n trget sugrph size k. Output: The set of mirosopi sugrph V with size k. : V = 2: for ritrry ege e i E o 3: V {e i } : for ege e j E e i o 5: if { i, i } { j, j } = n j > i : V 2 {e j } 7: en 8: en 9: ll EDGEEXTENSION(V, V 2, k) 0: return V : funtion EDGEEXTENSION(E su, V 3, k) 2: If E su = k then output G[E su ] n return 3: while V 3 o : for ritrry ege e x V 3 o 5: Remove e x from V 3 : for ege e y V 3 e x o 7: if { x, x} { y, y} = n y > x 8: V {e y} 9: en 20: en 2: V 3 = V 3 V 22: ll EDGEEXTENSION(E su {e x}, V 3, k) 23: en 2: return given the etete motifs, our sptio-temporl hing strtegy n selet C, C N, to solve the optimiztion prolem in (5)-(7). A. Serhing for V2V mirosopi sugrphs To effetively etet existing motifs in V2V ommunition networks, we first eompose V2V mrosopi ommunition grphs into mirosopi sugrphs with the sme size. The lgorithm use for fining V2V mirosopi sugrphs with trget size k in mrosopi grph G =(N, E ) is shown in Algorithm. Given set of lele rs n lele onnetion eges, there re two wys to otin mirosopi sugrphs from the mrosopi grph. One pproh is to onsier the noes onnete y eges, n nother pproh is to onsier the set of eges in whih n ritrry ege n fin nother ege shring the ommon noe. In ontrst to the work in [7], the propose lgorithm is se on the seon pproh. As shown in Fig. 2, from the mrosopi grph, we n otin pir of ege sets, V n V 2, where the first set ontins only one ege e i, lele s i, n the seon set hs e i s ll neighoring eges with greter lels. The mehnism will first n ritrry ege e j, lele s j, from the seon set to the first set n upte the first set. By lling EDGEEXTENSION(E SUB, V 3, k), the seon set oul e extene y first merging the set of eges, whih re neighor to the newly e eges e j n with greter lels in the mrosopi grph, n then removing ege e j n other eges with smller lels ompre with j. Next, we repet the forementione steps for the first set with the e ege n the new seon set until we otin the mirosopi sugrphs meeting the size requirement, i.e., k. Exmple: When the two sets of eges from the mrosopi grph re {} n {2,3,,}, s shown in Fig. 2, the lgorithm first s ege 2 to the first set {} n otins the first upte set {,2}. Then, it uptes the seon set s {3,,5,} y first merging the neighoring set with greter lels, i.e., {3,5,} with

4 3 5 Root 2 ({},{2,3,,}) ({2},{3,5,}) ({3},{,5,}) ({},{5,}) ({5},{ø}) ({},{ø}) ({,2},{3,,5,}) ({,3},{,5,}) ({,},{5,}) ({,},{ø}) ({3,},{5,}) ({3,5},{ø}) ({3,},{ø}) ({,5},{}) ({,},{ø}) Fig. 2. Consiering grph with noes n eges in the orner, we n otin ll mirosopi sugrphs with size s 3 fter following Algorithm Fig. 3. Exmples on the nonil leling of mirosopi sugrph n other mirosopi sugrphs shring the sme nonil leling. {2,3,,} n then eleting the ege 2. Repetely, the lgorithm follows the sme proesses for the upte set {,2} n the ege set {3,,5,}, n we n otin the mirosopi sugrphs {,2,3} n {,2,}, if k = 3. As shown in Fig. 2, y using this lgorithm for ny one ege set n the set of its surrouning eges with greter lels, we n finlly ollet ll V2V mirosopi sugrphs with the require size in mrosopi grph. To otin the whole set of mirosopi sugrphs existing in the V2V network, we n use this lgorithm for ifferent mrosopi grphs. Although the omplexity of the lgorithm will inrese with the inrement of the vehiles, we n pply the lgorithm in senrios with pity limittions, like intersetions, prking lots, n prts of the highwy, or suset of the network, thus reuing the omplexity n the proessing time. B. Clssifying V2V mirosopi sugrphs To sort V2V mirosopi sugrphs with the sme isomorphi struture, i.e., to fin mirosopi sugrphs whih ontin the sme numer of rs onnete in the sme wy, we exploit the notion of nonil leling. By permuting the elements in the jeny mtries otine from mirosopi sugrph, we oul onstrut mny lists of integers. By viewing eh list of integers s string of s n 0s, we sort them se on lexiogrphi orering to otin nonil leling efine s the string with the minimum vlue. Due to the ft tht the nonil leling of two sugrphs will e ientil s long s they hve the similr isomorphi struture [8], the prolem of etermining isomorphi strutures mong sugrphs is equivlent to eiing whether given mirosopi sugrphs hve the sme nonil leling or not. For exmple, s shown in Fig. 3, y ontenting rows or olumns one fter the other in the permute jeny mtries of the first mirosopi extrte from Fig. 2, we n fin two strings 5 Assume W motifs, lulte the orresponing weight vlues n etermine the influentil noe in eh motif Use funtion (9) n otin the sum frequeny f(j) of eing the influentil r i=i+ no i= i>n Output: serving r set n non-serving r set yes Sort the sum frequeny set from the iggest vlue to the smllest vlue Choose the first C elements s the serving rs Assign eh non-serving r to the optiml serving r se on sptil informtion Fig.. Flow ht of the propose sptio-temporl hing strtegy. of s n 0s. Aoring to lexiogrphi orering, we notie the string orresponing to the seon mtrix is smller thn its ounterprt in the first mtrix, i.e., < 0000, n 0000 n e hosen s the nonil leling for the first mirosopi sugrph ompre with other permuttions. Similrly, we n oserve the seon mirosopi sugrph shres the sme nonil leling with the first sugrph, n, thus, these two sugrphs hve the sme isomorphi struture. Aoringly, we re ple of ompleting struture lssifition for ll the mirosopi sugrphs in the V2V ommunition network, n then, we n lulte the ourrene frequeny f of mirosopi sugrphs hving similr isomorphi struture. Moreover, we lso repet the sme steps for rnomize V2V ommunition network so s to otin the men frequeny f n the stnr evition σ m of the orresponing sugrph. We n use (8) to etermine whether the sugrph is motif or not. C. Propose sptio-temporl hing strtegy To otin the su-optiml solution for the optimiztion prolem (5)-(7), s shown in Fig., the BS will first selet the serving rs in the set C se on the motifs etete from the V2V ommunition grph. In prtiulr, we ssume there re W motifs n the Z-sore of motif i is Z i. Note tht for ny i {,..., W }, Z i > Z th. By oserving the motif struture, we n etermine the outegree of eh r, whih is efine s the numer of outgoing eges emnting from the r. For exmple, for the first mirosopi sugrph in Fig. 3, the outegrees of,, re, 2, n 0. Then, we hoose the influentil r s the noe with the mximum outegree in the orresponing motif,

5 TABLE I SIMULATION PARAMETERS. Prmeter Mening Vlue w l With of eh lne 3.5 m P,n Trnsmission power of se sttion 20 W P mx Trnsmission power of V2V links 20 Bm α Pth loss exponent 3 γ SINR threshol 0 B σ 2 Power of noise 9 Bm ω Bnwith of the system 75 MHz θ r Zipf exponent 2 M Totl numer of files in the network 0 F The mximum numer of files the r n he 3 Approximte istne from BS to freewy 0.0 km T Time onstrint 00 s sine the onnetions tht originte from this r n reh more reipients ompre with other rs, leing to more effetive ontent issemintion. Next, we n sttistilly quire the frequeny of r j s eing the influentil r in the i th motif s f ij, j N. Bse on tht, s shown in Fig., we n otin the sum frequeny of eing the influentil r in the motifs for r j s, W f(j) = w i f ij, (9) i= where w i ptures the weight vlue of motif i, expresse s Z w i = W i. After lulting the sum frequeny of eh r, j=0 Zj we sort noes from the r with the highest frequeny to the one with the lowest frequeny. Finlly, the hoie of est C nites to he will e the first C elements in the rry. After hoosing the serving rs, the next step is to ssign eh reeiving r to its optiml serving r. In prtiulr, if the BS reeives the request from one reeiving r, the BS woul inform the r the nerest serving r with require ontent se on the ollete lotion informtion. To solve (5)-(7), we eompose it into two prolems. One is etermining the optiml set of serving rs, whih is solve y exploiting the temporl motifs. The other is ompleting the est ssignments etween the serving rs n the non-serving rs using the sptil knowlege. IV. SIMULATION RESULTS For our simultions, we use the vehiulr moility tset within the ity of Cologne, Germny, whih is ollete y the TAPASCologne projet [9]. The tset ontins informtion out ros n vehiles s well s the trip informtion for eh iniviul r in one y. In prtiulr, we tke into ount 5 km-length freewy (Autohn in Cologne) with three lnes in eh iretion n the nerest BS is olonius fernsehturm. We ollet the lotion informtion of network of 53 vehiles tht oexist on the freewy from the t. All simultion prmeters re summrize in Tle. I. Sine the Poisson istriution n e use to pture the numer of events ourring within fixe intervl [20], we ssume tht the numer of wireless ommunition links etween two ritrry rs i n j tht in proximity of one nother, in given perio of time, follows Poisson istriution with prmeter λ i,j. To etter simulte rel-time t, we ssume tht λ i,j is inversely proportionl to the istne etween i n j. This is euse loser istne les to etter ommunition environment, resulting in higher proility to uil Fig. 5. Motifs foun in the first senrio. () 3 rs () 39 n rs () 33, 35, n 37 rs () 3, 5, 7, 9, 5 n 53 rs Fig.. Motifs foun in the seon senrio with ifferent numer of rs. ommunition links. Then, we rnomly ssign time stmp to eh V2V ommunition links. In seline rnomize V2V ommunition network, the ommunition instnes re rnomly generte n given time stmp. One the temporl grph t is generte, the motifs n e etete se on the pproh in Setion III. In our nlysis, struture is ientifie s motif, when the Z-ore of the struture is t lest 2. For omprison, we use lotion-se hing strtegy. In this strtegy, the si priniple is tht the BS woul lwys selet set of rs tht n relize the lest summtion of istne etween remining rs n the orresponing losest rs the in the selete set. We onsier two simultion senrios. In the first senrio, we onsier totl numer of 53 rs (serving n non-serving). As we hnge the numer of serving rs, the numer of non-serving rs will e moifie oringly. In the seon senrio, we first rnomly hoose severl r sets with ifferent totl numer of rs. Then, se on the propose strtegy n the lotion-se strtegy, we hoose fixe numer of non-serving rs hosen out of the selete sets. In prtiulr, we selet twelve r sets hving totl numer of rs rnging from 3 to 53 with step of 2, n we fix the numer of reeiving rs to 30. Aoring to the propose metho, we n etet ifferent motifs in oth senrios, sorte from the highest to the lowest in terms of Z-sore, from the rel tre t n generte wireless ommunition t, s shown in Fig. 5 n Fig.. Bse on these strutures, we n oserve the outegree of eh noe. Then, using the propose lgorithm in Setion III, we n etermine the set of rs use for hing. Fig. 7 shows the verge trnsmission rte hieve y nonserving rs uner the lotion-se hing strtegy n the propose pproh, with the totl numer of rs fixe t 53 (first senrio). From Fig. 7, we oserve tht the sptio-temporl hing strtegy yiels etter performne ompre with the lotion-se he strtegy in terms of verge te rte per non-serving r. In prtiulr, the performne vntge rehes up to 5% when the numer of serving r is 20. Furthermore, s the numer of serving rs inreses, the numer of non-serving rs will erese. In prtiulr, when the numer of serving rs goes to 50, there re only 3 rs requesting for ontent, leing to reue interferene n n inrese in the verge t rte, s lso seen in Fig. 7. Fig. 8 shows the verge t rte for 30 non-serving rs

6 CDF Averge t rte per non-serving r (Mps) Averge t rte per non-serving r (Mps) Propose hing strtegy Lotion-se hing strtegy Numer of serving rs Fig. 7. Averge t rte for non-serving rs where the numer of rs is Propose hing strtegy Lotion-se hing strtegy Numer of serving rs Fig. 8. Averge t rte for non-serving rs where the numer of non-serving rs is Lotion-se hing strtegy, 5 rs Lotion-se hing strtegy, rs Lotion-se hing strtegy, 5 rs Lotion-se hing strtegy, 2 rs Propose hing strtegy, 5 rs Propose hing strtegy, rs Propose hing strtegy, 5 rs Propose hing strtegy, 2 rs Dt trnsmission rte (Gps) Fig. 9. CDFs for the t rte of non-serving rs where the numer of serving rs re 5,, 5, 2. s we vry the numer of serving rs. We n oserve tht the propose strtegy outperforms lotion-se hing strtegy up to 5% when there re rs ting s serving noes. Further, the verge t rte for oth strtegies will not inrese ll the time. This is ue to the ft tht n inrese in the numer of serving rs will rise the interferene over the V2V links. When the impt of interferene nnot e ompenste y the gin from V2V ommunition, the verge t rte for V2V links will erese, s seen in Fig. 8. Moreover, Fig. 9 shows the umultive istriution funtions (CDFs) of the t rte of non-serving rs for 5,, 5, n 2 serving rs. Compre with the t rte resulting from lotion-se strtegy, the nonserving rs re more likely to hieve higher t rte when employing the propose hing strtegy. Fig. 9 lso shows uner oth hing strtegies, the proility of hieving higher t rte for 5 serving rs is greter thn the ounterprts for 5,, n 2 serving rs. In prtiulr, when the numer of serving rs is 5 n the proility is 0.8, the propose hing strtegy improves the t rte of out 20% ompre to the lotionse strtegy. V. CONCLUSIONS In this pper, we hve propose novel sptio-temporl hing poliy in vehiulr networks. In ontrst to tritionl lotionse hing strtegies, we hve leverge temporl grph motifs, whih represent sugrphs with high frequeny of ourrene in the V2V ommunition grph, to etermine r nites to he populr ontent. We hve evelope n pproh to etet the motifs n, then, hve use the results to etermine the preferre set of rs for populr ontent plement. Simultion results using rel r lotion tres hve shown tht the propose sptio-temporl hing strtegy n yiel signifint gins in terms of the verge t rte per r for two prtil senrios. REFERENCES [] K. Zheng, Q. Zheng, P. Chtzimisios, W. Xing, n Y. Zhou, Heterogeneous Vehiulr Networking: A Survey on Arhiteture, Chllenges, n Solutions, IEEE Commun. Surveys Tuts., vol. 7, no., pp , Fourthqurter, 205. [2] Y. Wu, W. Putnm, J. Wng, n Z. Cheng, A wireless peer-to-peer rost moel for emergeny vehiles using utomotive networking, in Pro. of IEEE Symposium Series on Computtionl Intelligene (SSCI), Athens, Greee, De. 20. [3] D. Ryhuhuri n N. B. Mnym, Frontiers of wireless n moile ommunitions, Pro. IEEE, vol. 00, no., pp , Apr [] IEEE, IEEE tril-use stnr for wireless ess in vehiulr environments (WAVE) - seurity servies for pplitions n mngement messges, in IEEE St , e, 200. [5] H. Wu, R. Fujimoto, R. Guensler, n M. Hunter, MDDV: A moilityentri t issemintion lgorithm for vehiule network, in Prof. of ACM Interntionl Workshop on VehiulAr Inter-NETworking (VANET), Philelphi, PA, USA, Ot [] Y. Gun, Y. Xio, H. Feng, C. Shen, n L. Cimini, MoiCher: Moilitywre ontent hing in smll-ell networks, in Pro. of IEEE Glol Communitions Conferene (GLOBECOM), Austin, TX, USA, De. 20. [7] S. Shivshkr n A. Jmlipour, Sptio-temporl multist grouping for ontent-se routing in vehiulr networks: A istriute pproh, J. Netw. Comput. Appl., vol. 39, pp , Mr. 20. [8] S. Hosny, A. Eryilmz, A. Aouzei, n H. Gml, "Moility-wre entrlize D2D hing networks," in Pro. of Annul Allerton Conferene, Urn-Chmpign, IL, USA, Sept. 20. [9] U. Alon, Network motifs: Theory n experimentl pprohes, Nture Rev. Genet., vol. 8, pp. 50, Jun [0] M. Hellernt, R. Mthr, n M. Sheienogen, Estimting position n veloity of moiles in ellulr rio network. IEEE Trns. Veh. Tehnol., vol., no., pp. 5-7, Fe [] J. Huux, S. Cpkun, n J. Luo, The seurity n privy of smrt vehiles. IEEE Seurity Privy vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 9-55, My-June 200. [2] C. Yu, K. Doppler, C. Roeiro, n O. Tirkkonen, Resoure shring optimiztion for evie-to-evie ommunition unerlying ellulr networks. IEEE Trns. Wireless Commun., vol. 0, no. 8, pp , Aug. 20. [3] F. Liu, Z. Chen, n B. Xi, Dt issemintion with network oing in two-wy vehile-to-vehile networks. IEEE Trns. Veh. Tehnol., vol. 5, no., pp , Apr. 20. [] D. Mlk, M. Al-Shlsh, n J. Anrews, Optimizing the sptil ontent hing istriution for evie-to-evie ommunitions, in Pro. of 20 IEEE Interntionl Symposium on Informtion Theory (ISIT), Brelon, Spin, July 20. [5] R. Krp, Complexity of omputer omputtions, New York, USA: Springer Press, 972. [] P. Holme n J. Srmki, Temporl network, Phys. Rep., vol. 59, no. 3, pp , Ot [7] S. Wernike, Effiient etetion of network motifs, IEEE/ACM Trns. Comput. Biol. Bioinf., vol. 3. no., pp , Ot [8] R. Re n D. Corneil. The grph isomorph isese, Journl of Grph Theory, vol., pp , De [9] Dt/Senrios/TAPASCologne, ville on: Senrios/TAPASCologne. [20] J. Kingmn, Poisson proesses, Oxfor, UK: Oxfor University Press, 993.