Municipal Analytics 01/31/2017

Transcription

1 MUSKEGON COUNTY PROPOSAL SUMMARY Page 1 of 5 **MITN Solicitation Statistics** Commodity Number: 94611,94631,94648,94677 Vendors Received Notice: 158 Proposal: RFP Department: Finance and Management Services Release Date: 12/12/2016 Proposals Received: 5 Vendor Name & Address Proposal Received Scoring Pricing Comments Conway MacKenzie Yes 55.8% $340, SOld Woodward Ave Ste 340 Ernst & Young LLP Yes 51.3% $300, Detroit Ml Munetrix Municipal Metrics Yes 75.0% $40, First Year Price: $40, 860 Second Year Price add: $12, Auburn Hills Ml Third Year Price add: $12, Municipal Analytics Yes 98.0% $26, Ann Arbor Ml48103 Plante Moran Yes 79.8% $14, Northwestern Highway Department Recommendation: Municipal Analytics Name of Buyer: Jamie Burmeister Director of Finance/Assistant County Administrator's Name: Beth Dick Signature: Municipal Analytics 01/31/2017 Vendor Awarded: Board Approval Date: Board Motion Number

2 Page 2 of5 -MITN Solicitation Statistics- Commodity Number: 94611, 94631, 94648, Vendors Received Notice: 158 Proposal: RFP Department: Finance and Management Services Release Date: 12112/2016 Proposals Received: 5 Rates by Supervisory and Staff Level Times Hours Anticipated for Each : Vendor Name & Address Officer Director Managing Consultant Hrly Rate Est. Hrs Total Hrly Rate Est. Hrs Total Hrly Rate Est. Hrs Total... Conway MacKenzie $ $0.00 $ $84, $ $168, I 401 S Old Woodward Ave Ste 340 Binmingham Ml I.... Ernst & Young LLP No Bid No Bid No Bid Detroit Ml Munetrix Municipal Metrics $ $15, $ $7, $ $3, Auburn Hills Ml Municipal Analytics No Bid No Bid $ $20, Ann Arbor Ml Plante Moran $ $3, No Bid $ $4, Northwestern Highway..... :. ) ;i~f:''; I, ~.: \;( > : ;.....'. t ''J ~. ~;.~;..,:~f<!; "~ L~~~;;~ '..h..... <.

3 Page 3 of 5 -MITN Solicitation Statistics- Commodity Number: 94611' 94631' 94648, Vendors Received Notice: 158 Proposal: RFP Department: Finance and Management Services Release Date: 12/12/2016 Proposals Received: 5 Rates by Supervisory and Staff Level Times Hours Anticipated for Each Vendor Name & Address Senior Consultant Consultant Technical Specialist/Support ' Hrly Rate Est. Hrs Total Hrly Rate Est. Hrs Total Hrly Rate Est. Hrs Total Conway MacKenzie $ $88, $ $0.00 $0.00 $ $ S Old Woodward Ave Ste 340 Ernst & Young LLP $ $78, No Bid $ $48, Detroit Ml Munetrix Municipal Metrics $ $0.00 $ $0.00 $0.00 $ $9, Auburn Hills Ml Municipal Analytics $ $4, No Bid No Bid Ann Arbor Ml Plante Moran No Bid $ $60.00 $6, No Bid Northwestern Highway ;

4 Page 4 of 5 ~MITN Solicitation Statistics~ Commodity Number: 94611, 94631, 94648, Vendors Received Notice: 158 Proposal: RFP Department: Finance and Management Services Release Date: 12/12/2016 Proposals Received: 5 Product I Service: Professional Services for a Five Year Financial Forecast Opening Date: 01/06/2016 No-Proposal Fonm Received: 1 Rates by Supervisory and Staff Level Times Hours Anticipated for Each Vendor Name & Address Partner Manager Senior Staff Hrly Rate Est. Hrs Total Hrly Rate Est. Hrs Total Hrly Rate Est. Hrs Total Conway MacKenzie No Bid No Bid No Bid 401 S Old Woodward Ave Ste 340 Ernst & Young LLP $ $16, $ $155, $ $96, ~... Detroit Ml48226 Munetrix Municipal Metrics No Bid No Bid No Bid :....,.. : ~;{,... ~..,:<.... \t ".. Auburn Hills Ml >.\. \ \ <'.. :.\ Municipal Analytics No Bid No Bid No Bid.,:;, : Ann Arbor Ml ,. Plante Moran No Bid No Bid No Bid : ; Northwestern Highway : '~.,....~.,'j<~:'~~;~..':; ~ /.:.....:.

5 Page 5 of5 -MITN Solicitation Statistics- Commodity Number: 94611, 94631, 94648, Vendors Received Notice: 158 Proposal: RFP Department: Finance and Management Services Release Date: 12/12/2016 Proposals Received: 5 Travel Adjustment Vendor Name & Address Lodging Mileage Meals General to Cap Fees Facilitator Conway MacKenzie No Bid No Bid No Bid No Bid ($1,017.50) No Bid 401 S Old Woodward Ave Ste 340 Ernst & Young LLP $6, $2, $1, No Bid ($1 03,700.00) No Bid Detroit Ml Munetrix Municipal Metrics No Bid No Bid No Bid $2, No Bid $3, Auburn Hills Ml Municipal Analytics No Bid No Bid No Bid $1, No Bid No Bid Ann Arbor Ml Plante Moran No Bid No Bid No Bid No Bid No Bid No Bid Northwestern Highway.

6