RF PROPAGATION INVESTIGATIONS AT 915/2400 MHz IN INDOOR CORRIDOR ENVIRONMENTS FOR WIRE- LESS SENSOR COMMUNICATIONS

Transcription

1 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, , 2013 RF PROPAGATION INVESTIGATIONS AT 915/2400 MHz IN INDOOR CORRIDOR ENVIRONMENTS FOR WIRE- LESS SENSOR COMMUNICATIONS Thipparaju Rama Rao * and Dhanavanthan Balachander RADMIC, Department of Telecommunication Engineering, University, Kattankulathur, Tamilnadu, India SRM Abstract Propagation of Radio Frequency (RF) waves in indoor corridors is very complex and diverse as the propagation effects in the indoor scenarios are those that change over fractions of wavelength. Therefore, understanding of RF propagation characteristics is vital for the design of air interface and estimation of propagation losses is very much needed especially for wireless networks such as randomly deplorable Wireless Sensor Communications. In this research work, short-range, near floor/ground RF propagation path loss measurements at low antenna heights of 2 cm and 50 cm from the floor were made in typical narrow and wide straight indoor corridors at 915/2400 MHz in a modern multi-storied building utilizing RF equipment. Comparisons between measured and simulated path loss values were made utilizing Matlab simulations of Ray-tracing technique, free space and ITU-R models. Mean path loss exponent values were deduced from the measured data. The research work reported in this paper is predominately geared towards characterizing radio link for Wireless Sensor Communications/Networks in typical indoor corridor environments. 1. INTRODUCTION In recent years, the world has witnessed the emergence of Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) in various fields ranging from health care, military surveillance to indoor navigation and home automation [1 3]. WSNs have emerged as a significant technology and have the potential to revolutionize the harnessing of data from the physical Received 29 October 2012, Accepted 5 January 2013, Scheduled 11 January 2013 * Corresponding author: Thipparaju Rama Rao (ramarao@ieee.org).

2 360 Rama Rao and Balachander world, enabling applications that previously were not practical and are attracting increased interest for applications in a variety of fields. Measuring, monitoring and controlling nearly any process has become feasible with the current generation of wireless sensors. The work reported in this paper is part of a larger effort to model the WSN radio link in a range of settings within the Indian sub-continent. Some amount of work has been performed to characterize the WSN radio link in other countries [4 8], no results have been reported for WSN scenarios in India. The differences in building materials and construction practices in India when compared to the other countries in which WSN radio-link studies have been performed suggest that indoor propagation might also be different [9]. Radio propagation measurements have been performed and models developed for cellular frequencies ( MHz) [10 13] and propagation path loss measurements have been performed in the VHF/UHF bands [14 18]. However, those measurements are not directly applicable to WSNs scenario because the sensor node antennas are likely to lie on or near the ground/floor (0 to 30 cm height) as opposed to a person holding a mobile phone ( 1.5 m off the ground) and the environments in which wireless sensor nodes deployed are typically different from the cellular network scenarios. Around 11 db decrease in signal strength was observed when a cellular phone user lowers from a standing position to a lying position by Welch et al. [4]. Abiola and Jeff [19] presented near-ground propagation models at 915 MHz based on field measurement data for open fields, woods and wooded hill environments. The effects of these environments on coverage area are explored for various power transmission levels. Channel propagation measurements at MHz were performed with ground-lying antennas by Sohrabi et al. [5]. The range of path loss exponent and shadowing variance for indoor and outdoor environments were determined. Foran et al. [6] analyzed the effects associated with placing a man-portable radio transceiver very near the ground (3 28 cm) using a 2-Ray model. A significant decrease in signal strength of 16.8 db was observed at 915 MHz when a soldier drops from the crouched position to the prone position. Also, an additional set of channel measurements was performed to study the effect of rain on near-ground propagation at 1900 MHz in a forest environment. Wyne et al. [20] proposed a statistical model for indoor office wireless sensor channels and presented in-depth analysis of the propagation channels of typical sensor node locations in office environments utilizing ricean factor. Willis and Kikkert [21] described the development of a suitable long-range ad-hoc propagation model to predict the signal-tonoise ratio (SNR) for radio links over irregular terrain. Narrowband

3 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, and wideband channel measurement results at 300 and 1900 MHz were presented for near-ground propagation, characterizing the effect of antenna heights, radiation patterns and foliage environments by Joshi et al. [7]. Molina et al. [8] performed channel measurement campaigns in open quasi-ideal area, a university yard and a park at 868 MHz for WSNs. Yarkoni and Blaunstein did a semi empirical approach and the analytical model on how to predict the total path loss in various indoor communication links. Also done path loss experiments in indoor corridor environments utilizing laptop LAN cards [9]. Taha-Ahmed et al. [22] performed short-range propagation loss measurements in indoor corridors at 5.6 GHz band. It has been noted that the multipath induced fading tends to have Normal Distribution at low distance between the transmitting and the reception antennas. Also the human being obstruction causes an extra propagation loss of 2 to 10 db. Given the sensitive dependence of WSN performance on the radio link, any differences that exist should be understood before deploying WSNs. Robust communications is essential in the overall performance of sensor networks, as sensor measurements and control commands are transmitted over wireless links connecting the nodes. The major factors to be considered in the WSNs are the propagation losses and antenna placement. Wireless sensor transceiver systems typically have their antenna elements (transmitter and receiver) located at or near ground/floor. In most of the scenarios antenna in a WSN node is placed very close to the ground. Antenna impedance and field pattern fluctuate with varying height above the ground plane [23, 24] regardless of the antenna orientation especially with omni-directional antennas [23]. Furthermore non-uniform ground dielectric properties can also affect the path loss and finite conductivity of the ground cannot be ignored in the near-ground radiation problem [24, 25]. Precise estimation of propagation losses offers proper selection of transmitter locations and hence the radio link characteristics near the ground should be properly understood especially for WSNs. Further, equipped with the strides in indoor localization technologies, the focus is now on applications that will change our day to day life such as indoor navigation with the aid of maps, object tracking, surveillance and location information. To understand the possible unique nature of WSN radio-link propagation in indoor corridors, near floor RF propagation measurements and simulations were made at 915/2400 MHz utilizing RF equipment and Matlab simulations. The next section provides experimental details followed by comparison of measured/modeled observations with conclusions.

4 362 Rama Rao and Balachander 2. EXPERIMENTAL DETAILS 2.1. Measurement Details Measurements were made in Narrow Straight Corridor (NSC) and Wide Straight Corridor (WSC) in a modern multi-storied building, which is made-up of concrete and steel. The corridors are situated in Tech Park building at SRM University, Chennai, India (GPS Coordinates: N and E). The transmitterreceiver separation distance was 10 m in NSC and 8 m in WSC. The receiver was kept stationary and the transmitter is placed at each distance, i.e., (1 m, 2 m, 3 m, 4 m,..., 10 m) to get the received power values. Repeated measurements were performed at each distance on the same day in an interval of minutes to obtain the necessary received power values and an average of received power was taken to compute the path loss. Figure 1 illustrates the measurement set-up Figure 1. Measurement set-up. Table 1. Summary of parameters and equipments used in measurement. Parameters/Equipment Values/Description Transmitter Agilent Signal Generator (N5182A) Receiver Agilent Signal Analyzer (N9010A) Frequency 915/2400 MHz Antenna Gain 915 MHz with 0 dbi 2400 MHz with 0 dbi/4 dbi Modulation BPSK Filter Gaussian, Filter-roll-off factor = 0.5 Transmitted Power Level 10 dbm (power at antenna input)

5 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, used in our experiments. Table 1 provides equipment and parameters used in our experiments. The measurement signal from the Signal Generator at 915 and 2400 MHz is a BPSK modulated signal and the received signal is demodulated using Agilent s Vector Signal Analyzer software tool through Signal Analyzer equipment via omnidirectional antennas as shown in the Figures 1, 2 and 3. In Agilent Vector Signal Analyzer software, by placing the marker at peak position in Spectrum channel, we can get the received power values in dbm. Then using Equation (1), measured path loss (L p ) can be computed. P r = P t + G t + G r L s L p (1) where P r = Average received power (dbm), P t = Transmitted power (dbm), G t = Transmitter gain (dbi), G r = Receiver gain (dbi), L s = System loss factor, L p = path loss (db). Considering Equation (1), for example if, P r = 45 dbm, P t = 10 dbm, G t = 0 dbi, G r = 0 dbi and L s = 0, then the measured path loss (L p ) will be 55 db Environment Description Narrow Straight Corridor: RF propagation measurements are made in a Narrow Straight Corridor (NSC) of 14.0 m length, 1.83 m wide and 2.52 m height. The left and right walls of the NSC are made of concrete (relative permittivity [11, 25 28] ε r = 7.0) with glass windows (ε r = 4.0). Concrete ceiling is covered with gypsum board (ε r = 3.0). Case A: The floor of the corridor is covered with porcelain tiles (ε r = 6.0). Case B: Plywood (ε r = 2.0) were placed on the floor covering the measurement space. The lights and the AC were switched ON during the measurement in both cases. Figure 2 depicts measurement environment in Narrow Straight Corridor. Wide Straight Corridor: Measurements are made in a Wide Straight Corridor (WSC) of 10.0 m length, 2.82 m wide and 3.1 m Case A Case B Case A Case B Figure 2. Narrow straight corridor. Wide straight corri- Figure 3. dor.

6 364 Rama Rao and Balachander height. The left and right walls of the WSC are made of concrete (ε r = 7.0) with iron grilled glass windows. The ceiling is also made of concrete. Case A: The floor is filled with Green Granite (ε r = 7.75). Case B: Plywood (ε r = 2.0) were placed on the floor covering the measurement space. Figure 3 depicts measurement environment in Wide Straight Corridor. 3. SIMULATIONS AND THEORETICAL BACKGROUND DETAILS Matlab simulations were executed utilizing a deterministic approach of a simple 2-D Ray-tracing technique based on classical geometrical optics and image method [11, 13] to account for the direct ray and reflected rays from wall, floor and ceiling, respectively. The Ray-tracing and ITU-R model considered here are for indoor environments. The Ray-tracing method is among the available methods for the relatively accurate estimation of field strengths to deal with the type of complex layouts in indoor environments. The 2-Ray model [11] can be a helpful tool in predicting the received power (R R ). It can further serve in the development of multi rays (Ray-tracing) model. It considers the direct ray and the ground reflected ray where the received power is given by Equation (2). R R = T R ( λ 4π ) 2 a t a r e jkd 1 d 1 + R (θ) e jkd2 d 2 where λ is the wavelength, k the wave number, d 1 the length of the direct path, d 2 the length of the ground reflected path, a t and a r the directional functions of transmitter and receiver, R(θ) the reflection coefficient of the reflected ray on the reflecting surface, and T R the transmitted power. The modeled received power using Matlab simulations is converted into path loss [11, 13] using the Equation (3). PL (db) = 10 log 10 T R R R (d) where PL (db) is the path loss in db, T R transmitted power, and R R (d) the received power at distance d [11]. Further, for comparison/evaluation purpose, Matlab simulation of ITU-R sitegeneral model [29] was performed as well. The site-general model of ITU-R requires little path or site information. The indoor radio path loss is characterized by both an average path loss and its associated shadow fading statistics. The distance power loss coefficients include an implicit allowance for transmission through walls and through obstacles, and for other loss mechanisms likely to be encountered 2 (2) (3)

7 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, within a single floor of a building and the model propagation loss is represented as Equation (4). PL total (db) = 20 log 10 (f) + Nlog 10 (d) + L f (n) 28 (4) where N is the distance power loss coefficient, f the frequency (MHz), d the separation distance between transmitter and receiver (m), L f the floor penetration loss factor (db), and n the number of floors between transmitter and receiver (n 1). To perform simulations, N = 33, L f = 0, n = 1, T R = 10 dbm, d = 1 m to 10 m for NSC and 1 m to 8 m for WSC, λ = 0.33 for 915 MHz and λ = for 2400 MHz, k = 2π/λ = for 915 MHz and k = 2π/λ = for 2400 MHz have been considered. In addition, the height and width of the corridor, height of transmitter and receiver antenna, relative permittivity of ground, wall and ceiling have also been taken into account. 4. OBSERVATIONS/RESULTS The following figures and tables provide measured and simulated/modeled Path Loss (PL) values obtained in our near ground/floor RF propagation measurements/simulations in indoor corridors at 915/2400 MHz Narrow Straight Corridor Measurement Results Figures 4, 5, 6 and 7 show 915 MHz simulation and measurement results in NSC for all cases. From the figures it is observed that Figure 4. and simulated path loss for Case A at 2 cm height. Figure 5. and simulated path loss for Case A at 50 cm height.

8 366 Rama Rao and Balachander Figure 6. and simulated path loss for Case B at 2 cm height. Figure 7. and simulated path loss for Case B at 50 cm height. the Ray-tracing and 2-Ray simulation are in close agreement to the measured PL values at 2 cm antenna height. However at 50 cm antenna height there is a large variation between the measured and Ray-tracing simulations PL values. The ITU-R model varies largely with the measured PL values in all cases. Also it is noticed that ITU-R model predicts less PL than the measured PL values in all cases. This could be due to close proximity of the antenna to the ground in our measurement setup which could result in RSS degradation. It is observed that the measured values differ from free space PL values by 20 db to 30 db on average. Further it is noticed that there is RSS degradation at around 5 to 6 m. This could be due to propagation through the very fine glass door and diffraction from the edge of the glass window at 5 m. Table 2 shows the maximum, minimum and mean PL values for all cases at 915 MHz. It is observed from measurements that there is better RSS in Case B than in Case A. This could be due to the low relative permittivity of plywood as compared to porcelain tiles. Also it is noticed that this is more so in the case of 50 cm antenna height than that of 2 cm antenna height. Further, it is observed that the RSS is better at 50 cm antenna height than at 2 cm antenna height in all cases, because of degradation of RSS as antenna height approaches the ground [24]. In Case A it is observed that there is attenuation of almost 7 db when the antenna height is decreased from 50 cm to 2 cm from the ground. Also in Case B it is observed that there is attenuation of almost 12 db when the antenna height is decreased from 50 cm to 2 cm from the ground. Figures 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 show 2400 MHz simulation and

9 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, Table MHz. Summary of PL values in a narrow straight corridor at All Values in db Maximum Minimum Mean Free Space Loss ITU-R Model Case A/Ant. Ht. 2 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna Case A/Ant. Ht. 50 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna Case B/Ant. Ht. 2 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna Case B/Ant. Ht. 50 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna measurement results in NSC for all cases. From the figures it is observed that the Ray-tracing and 2-Ray simulations are in close agreement to the measured PL values at 2 cm antenna height. The ITU-R model varies largely with the measured PL values in all cases. Also it is noticed that ITU-R model predicts less PL than the measured PL values in all cases. It is observed that the measured values differ from free space PL values by 16 db to 30 db on average. It is noticed that the RSS degradation occurs around 5 m to 6 m due to the presence of glass door which could be because of the difference in relative permittivity of glass and concrete. However it is not as prominent as in the case of 915 MHz.

10 368 Rama Rao and Balachander Figure 8. and simulated path loss for Case A at 2 cm height. Figure 9. and simulated path loss for Case A at 50 cm height. Figure 10. and simulated path loss for Case B at 2 cm height. Figure 11. and simulated path loss for Case B at 50 cm height. Table 3 shows the maximum, minimum and mean PL values for all cases at 2400 MHz. It is observed from measurements that there is better RSS in Case B than in Case A. This could be due to the low relative permittivity of plywood as compared to porcelain tiles. Also, the same is observed to be more prominent with 50 cm antenna height than with 2 cm antenna height in all cases. Further in Case A it is observed that there is attenuation of almost 9 db when the antenna height is decreased from 50 cm to 2 cm from the ground. However in Case B it is observed that there is attenuation of almost 5 db when the antenna height is decreased from 50 cm to 2 cm from the ground.

11 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, Table 3. Summary of PL values in a narrow straight corridor at 2400 MHz. All Values in db Maximum Minimum Mean Free Space Loss ITU-R Model Case A/Ant. Ht. 2 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna (0 dbi) Case A/Ant. Ht. 50 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna (0 dbi) Omni-Dir. Antenna (4 dbi) Case B/Ant. Ht. 2 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna Case B/Ant. Ht. 50 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna (0 dbi) Omni-Dir. Antenna (4 dbi) Also, in Case A the use of 4 dbi antenna resulted in decrement of mean PL by around 4 db while in Case B the decrement is observed to be around 6 db. Table 4 shows the standard deviation of errors in narrow straight corridor. The error is calculated by determining the difference between the observed PL mean value and the calculated PL mean value. It

12 370 Rama Rao and Balachander provides an insight to the suitability of the simulated and modeled methods with measured PL values in our study. It is noticed that in both cases, at 2 cm antenna height the Ray-tracing and 2-Ray models predict less error varying from 1.28 to 9.63 at 2400 MHz and from 4.86 to 6.66 at 915 MHz. The 2-Ray model at 2400 MHz in Case B at 2 cm antenna height predicts the least error of 1.28 whereas the ITU-R model predicts error of This could be due to the placement of antenna very near the ground in our measurement, and ITU-R model does not consider antenna height. However, it should be noted that at 50 cm antenna height, ITU-R model predicts lesser error than Raytracing simulations. Figure 12. path loss in Case A with 4 dbi at 50 cm height. Figure 13. path loss in Case B with 4 dbi at 50 cm height. Figure 14. and simulated path loss for Case A at 2 cm height. Figure 15. and simulated path loss for Case A at 50 cm height.

13 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, Table 4. Standard deviation of model errors in narrow straight corridor at 915/2400 MHz. Models 915 MHz 2400 MHz Case A/Ant. Ht. 2 cm/0 dbi Free Space Loss Ray-tracing Model Ray Model ITU-R Model Case A/Ant. Ht. 50 cm/0 dbi Free Space Loss Ray-tracing Model Ray Model ITU-R Model Case B/Ant. Ht. 2 cm/0 dbi Free Space Loss Ray-tracing Model Ray Model ITU-R Model Case B/Ant. Ht. 50 cm/0 dbi Free Space Loss Ray-tracing Model Ray Model ITU-R Model Wide Straight Corridor Measurement Results Figures 14, 15, 16 and 17 show simulation and measurement results at 915 MHz in WSC for all cases. From the figures it is observed that the Ray-tracing and 2-Ray simulations are in close agreement with the measured PL values at 2 cm antenna height. However, at 50 cm antenna height there is a large variation between the measured and Ray-tracing simulation PL values. The ITU-R model varies largely with the measured PL values in all cases. Also it is noticed that ITU- R model predicts less PL than the measured PL values in all cases. This could be due to close proximity of the antenna to the ground in our measurement setup which could result in RSS degradation. It is observed that the measured values differ from free space PL values

14 372 Rama Rao and Balachander Figure 16. and simulated path loss for Case B at 2 cm height. Figure 17. and simulated path loss for Case B at 50 cm height. Figure 18. and simulated path loss for Case A at 2 cm height. Figure 19. and simulated path loss for Case A at 50 cm height. by 19 db to 31 db on average. Further, it is noticed that there is RSS degradation at around 5 m to 7 m in the measurement. This is probably due to variance in the wall s architecture and transmission loss through iron grilled glass window at 6 m. Table 5 shows the maximum, minimum and mean PL values for all cases at 915 MHz. It is observed from measurements that there is better RSS in Case B than Case A. This could be due to the low relative permittivity of plywood as compared to green granite. Also it is noticed that this is more so in the case of 50 cm antenna height than that of 2 cm antenna height. Further, it is observed that the RSS

15 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, Table MHz. Summary of PL values in a wide straight corridor at All Values in db Maximum Minimum Mean Free Space Loss ITU-R Model Case A/Ant. Ht. 2 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna Case A/Ant. Ht. 50 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna Case B/Ant. Ht. 2 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna Case B/Ant. Ht. 50 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna is better at 50 cm antenna height than at 2 cm antenna height in all cases. In Case A, it is observed that there is attenuation of almost 8 db when the antenna height is decreased from 50 cm to 2 cm. Also in Case B, it is observed that there is attenuation of almost 10 db when the antenna height is decreased from 50 cm to 2 cm from the ground. Figures 18, 19, 20, 21, 22 and 23 show 2400 MHz simulation and measurement results in WSC for all cases. From the figures it is observed that the Ray-tracing and 2-Ray simulations are in close agreement to the measured PL values at 2 cm antenna height. The ITU-R model varies largely with the measured PL values in all cases. Also it is noticed that ITU-R model predicts less PL than the measured

16 374 Rama Rao and Balachander Figure 20. and simulated path loss for Case B at 2 cm height. Figure 21. and simulated path loss for Case B at 50 cm height. Figure 22. path loss in Case A with 4 dbi at 50 cm height. Figure 23. path loss in Case B with 4 dbi at 50 cm height. PL values in all cases. It is observed that the measured values differ from free space PL values by 17 db to 31 db on average. It is noticed that the RSS degradation occurs around 5 m to 7 m due to the presence of wooden door. However it is not as prominent as in the case of 915 MHz. Table 6 shows the maximum, minimum and mean PL values for all cases at 2400 MHz. It is observed from measurements that there is better RSS in Case B than that in Case A. This could be due to the low relative permittivity of plywood as compared to green granite. Also, the same is observed to be more prominent with 50 cm antenna

17 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, Table 6. Summary of PL values in a wide straight corridor at 2400 MHz. All Values in db Maximum Minimum Mean Free Space Loss ITU-R Model Case A/Ant. Ht. 2 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna (0 dbi) Case A/Ant. Ht. 50 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna (0 dbi) Omni-Dir. Antenna (4 dbi) Case B/Ant. Ht. 2 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna Case B/Ant. Ht. 50 cm Ray-tracing Model Ray Model Omni-Dir. Antenna (0 dbi) Omni-Dir. Antenna (4 dbi) height than with 2 cm antenna height in all cases. Further in Case A it is observed that there is attenuation of almost 9 db when the antenna height is decreased from 50 cm to 2 cm from the ground. However in Case B it is observed that there is attenuation of almost 5 db when the antenna height is decreased from 50 cm to 2 cm from the ground. Also, in Case A using 4 dbi antenna decreased the mean PL by around 4 db while in Case B the decrement is observed to be around 8 db. Further it is observed that mean PL increased with increasing frequency in both NSC and WSC. Also, at 915 MHz mean PL decreased in WSC as

18 376 Rama Rao and Balachander Table 7. Standard deviation of model errors in wide straight corridor at 915/2400 MHz. Models 915 MHz 2400 MHz Case A/Ant. Ht. 2 cm/0 dbi Free Space Loss Ray-tracing Model Ray Model ITU-R Model Case A/Ant. Ht. 50 cm/0 dbi Free Space Loss Ray-tracing Model Ray Model ITU-R Model Case B/Ant. Ht. 2 cm/0 dbi Free Space Loss Ray-tracing Model Ray Model ITU-R Model Case B/Ant. Ht. 50 cm/0 dbi Free Space Loss Ray-tracing Model Ray Model ITU-R Model compared to NSC. However at 2400 MHz mean PL increased in WSC as compared to NSC. Table 7 shows the standard deviation of errors in wide straight corridor. It is noticed that in both cases at 2 cm antenna height the Ray-tracing and 2-Ray models predict less error which varies from 4.51 to 5.77 at 915 MHz and from 4.89 to 9.55 at 2400 MHz. The 2- Ray model at 2400 MHz in Case B predicts the least error of However, it should be noted that at 50 cm antenna height the ITU-R model predicts less error than the Ray-tracing and 2-Ray models. Furthermore, we have derived PL exponents [11] values from our field strength experiments in indoor corridors utilizing linear regression analysis. The average path loss between the transmitter and receiver is expressed by a function of distance using a path loss exponent, n, as follows: PL(d) = PL(d 0 ) + 10n log(d/d 0 ) + S (5)

19 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, where n is the path loss exponent which indicates the rate of increment of path loss with respect to distance, PL(d 0 ) the reference path loss at the reference distance d 0, PL(d) the measured path loss at the distance d, and S for shadow fading. We have taken the reference distance d 0 to be 1 m. For free space propagation the PL exponent [11] is equal to 2. This PL exponents value changes with respect to the changes in multipath propagation and obstruction between transmitter and receiver. The PL and PL exponents information is vital for the coverage of transmitter and optimization in planning and deployment Table 8. Path loss exponents. 915 MHz 2400 MHz NSC Case A/Ant. Ht. 2 cm/0 dbi Case A/Ant. Ht. 50 cm/0 dbi Case A/Ant. Ht. 50 cm/4 dbi Case B/Ant. Ht. 2 cm/0 dbi Case B/Ant. Ht. 50 cm/0 dbi Case B/50 cm/4 dbi WSC Case A/Ant. Ht. 2 cm/0 dbi Case A/Ant. Ht. 50 cm/0 dbi Case A/Ant. Ht. 50 cm/4 dbi Case B/Ant. Ht. 2 cm/0 dbi Case B/Ant. Ht. 50 cm/0 dbi Case B/Ant. Ht. 50 cm/4 dbi

20 378 Rama Rao and Balachander issues of wireless networks. Table 8 shows the PL exponents observed at 915/2400 MHz for the NSC and WSC. The PL exponents values are observed to be ranging from 1.01 to 2.06, and in accordance with similar results [11, 30 32] which could be attributed to the evidence of waveguide effects [30 33] due to architectural and structural dimensions, type of construction material and type of interiors of the indoor corridors. 5. CONCLUSIONS To understand the possible unique nature of WSN radio-link propagation in indoor corridors, comparisons of RF propagation field strength measurements and Matlab simulations at 915/2400 MHz for short-range wireless sensor communication/networks in narrow and wide straight corridors with 2 cm and 50 cm antenna heights is presented in this research work. It is observed that the measured PL values using RF equipment and simulated Ray-tracing and 2-Ray models are in close agreement in all cases at 2 cm antenna height. In our indoor corridors, it is noticed that 2-Ray model predicts lower standard deviation of error values at 2 cm antenna height than other models. It is noted that the PL values given by ITU-R model varies largely with the measured values in all cases. It may be due to the antenna placement near the ground where the RF propagation is more prone to degradation and omni-directional transmission patterns. Also it is observed that the attenuation shows increasing trend with the increase in frequency. The PL exponents values observed in the present study ranges from 1.01 to The measured PL exponents being less than free space PL exponents can be attributed to the waveguide effect and construction architectural issues that prevail in indoor corridors. From our measurement campaign it is noticed that there is lower mean PL in Case B (plywood) than in Case A (porcelain tiles/green granite) and the rate of attenuation with increasing distance is also low. This could be due to the low relative permittivity of plywood than other materials. It can be concluded from the results that the building materials and furnishings can affect indoor propagation. Indoor localization technologies are moving forward with the aid of mapping and object tracking where the available RSS plays a vital role. Thus in this respect as observed from our measurements, the flooring/walls material in indoor environment should be made of low relative permittivity such as plywood which allows better RSS. The value of this present work is that it demonstrates the variation between several measurement approaches and highlights the differences between commonly used modeling techniques. Our efforts in this work

21 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, towards understanding propagation losses in indoor environments will be very supportive to wireless network planners and for indoor location technologies which are expected to proliferate across very wide variety of consumer devices over the next years. ACKNOWLEDGMENT Authors are very much grateful to the Department of Science and Technology (DST), Government of India for providing financial assistance in executing this research work. Also, appreciate very much the help given by Mr. Nishesh Tiwari, Research Scholar for doing measurements and simulations. REFERENCES 1. Akyildiz, I. F. and M. C. Vuran, Wireless Sensor Networks, John Wiley and Sons Ltd, New Jersey, Zheng, J. and A. Jamalipour, Wireless Sensor Networks A Networking Perspective, John Wiley and Sons Ltd, New Jersey, Callaway, Jr., E. H., Wireless Sensor Networks: Architectures and Protocols, Auerbach Publications, Boca Raton, Welch, T. B., J. R. Wood, R. W. McParlin, L. K. Schulze, T. P. Flaherty, S. G. Carlone Hanson, R. J. Cahill, and R. A. Foran, Very near ground RF propagation measurements for wireless systems, Proc. IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference, , Tokyo, Sohrabi, K., B. Manriquez, and G. J. Pottie, Near ground wideband channel measurements in MHz, Proc. IEEE 49th Vehicular Technology Conference, , Houston, Foran, R. A., T. B. Welch, and M. J. Walker, Very near ground radio frequency propagation measurements and analysis for military applications, Proc. IEEE Military Communications Conference, , New Jersey, Joshi, G. G., C. B. Dietrich, Jr., C. R. Anderson, W. G. Newhall, W. A. Davis, J. Isaacs, and G. Barnett, Near-ground channel measurements over line-of-sight and forested paths, IEEE Proceedings Microwaves, Antennas and Propagation, , Molina Garcia Pardo, J. M., A. Martinez Sala, M. V. Bueno Delgado, E. Egea Lopez, L. Juan Llacer, and J. García Haro, Channel model at 868 MHz for wireless sensor networks in

22 380 Rama Rao and Balachander outdoor scenarios, Proc. International Workshop on Wireless AD-HOC Networks, 23 26, London, Yarkoni, N. and N. Blaunstein, Prediction of propagation characteristics in indoor radio communication environments, Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 59, , Lee, W. C. Y., Wireless and Cellular Telecommunications, McGraw Hill, Columbus, Rappaport, T. S., Wireless Communications: Principles and Practice, Prentice Hall PTR, New Jersey, Parsons, J. D., Mobile Radio Propagation Channel, John Wiley and Sons Ltd, New Jersey, Bertoni, H. L., Radio Propagation for Modern Wireless Systems, Prentice Hall PTR, New Jersey, Rao, T. R., S. V. B. Rao, M. V. S. N. Prasad, S. Mangal, A. Iqbal, and D. R. Lakshmi, Mobile radio propagation path loss studies at VHF/UHF bands in Southern India, IEEE Trans. Broadcasting, Vol. 46, No. 2, , Rao, T. R., S. V. B. Rao, M. V. S. N. Prasad, and S. K. Sarkar, Single Knife edge diffraction propagation studies over a hilly terrain, IEEE Trans. Broadcasting, Vol. 45, No. 1, 20 29, Prasad, M. V. S. N. and I. Ahmed, Comparison of some path loss prediction methods with VHF/UHF measurements, IEEE Trans. Broadcasting, Vol. 43, No. 4, , Jakes, W. C., Microwave Mobile Communication, IEEE Press, New Jersey, Collins, R. E. and F. J. Zucker, Antenna Theory Part 2, McGraw-Hill, Columbus, Abiola, F. and F. Jeff, Effects of natural propagation environments on wireless sensor network coverage area, Proc. 35th Southeastern Symposium on System Theory, 16 20, Wyne, S., A. P. Singh, F. Tufvesson, and A. F. Molisch, A statistical model for indoor office wireless sensor channels, IEEE Trans. on Wireless Communications, Vol. 8, No. 8, , Willis, S. L. and C. J. Kikkert, Radio propagation model for long-range AD HOC wireless sensor network, Proc. IEEE International Conference on Wireless Networks, Communications and Mobile Computing, , Taha-Ahmed, B., J. L. Masa-Campos, and D. F. Campillo, Propagation loss measurement due to miscellaneous phenomenon at 5.6 GHz band, Progress In Electromagnetics Research C,

23 Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, Vol. 47, Vol. 32, , Janek, J. and J. Evans, Predicting ground effects of omnidirectional antennas in wireless sensor networks, Wireless Sensor Networks, Vol. 2, No. 12, , Seybold, J. S., Introduction to RF Propagation, John Wiley and Sons Ltd, New Jersey, Tranter, W. H., et al., Wireless Personal Communications Channel Modelling and System Engineering, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Massachusetts, ITU-R, Recommendation, P , Electrical characteristics of the surface of the earth, Balanis, C. A., Antenna Theory, John Wiley and Sons Ltd, New Jersey, Kraus, J. D., Antennas for All Applications, McGraw Hill, Columbus, ITU-R, Recommendation, P , Propagation data and prediction methods for the planning of indoor radio communication systems and radio local area networks in the frequency range 900 MHz to 100 GHz, Qaraqe, Q. A., et al., Statistical wireless channel propagation characteristics in underground mines at 900 MHz: A comparative analysis with indoor channels, Ad Hoc Networks, 2011, doi: /j.adhoc Pahlavan, K. and R. Ganesh, Statistical characterization of a partitioned indoor radio channel, Proc. IEEE International Conference on Communications, Vol. 3, , Chicago, Alexander, S. E., Radio propagation within buildings at 900 MHz, Electronics Letters, Vol. 18, No. 21, , Aleksandar, N., N. Natasa, and P. George, Modern approaches in modeling of mobile radio systems propagation environment, IEEE Communication Surveys and Tutorials, Vol. 3, No. 3, 2 12, 2000.