Cost Effective VCOs Replace Power Hungry YIGs

Transcription

1 Cost Effective VCOs Replace Power Hungry YIGs By: Ulrich L. Rohde, K. Juergen Schoepf, Ajay Kumar Poddar These innovative voltage controlled oscillators make the most of multi coupled slow wave planar resonators to achieve low phase noise performance at a fraction of the size and power of YIGs. Phase noise is the curse of many a communications system, and one of the key performance parameters that most oscillators strive to minimize. System designers have long recognized the yttrium iron garnet (YIG) oscillator for its broadband, lownoise, high frequency capabilities. But YIG sources are also power hungry and physically large. The mechanical design, with a YIG sphere mounted in the air gap of an electromagnet, is not conducive to integrated circuit (IC) integration. And the sphere placement and tolerances required do not lend to high volume production. The size of the sphere and the windings used for the electromagnetic field become prohibitive at resonance frequencies below about 2 GHz. In addition, YIG oscillators are sensitive to thermal drift, vibration, lighting, electromagnetic interference (EMI), microphonics, phase hits, and frequency modulation, all of which have a detrimental effect in designing modern communication systems. Fortunately, there is now an alternative source for tunable high frequency signals with low phase noise: the distributed coupled YIG replacement oscillator or DCYR series from Synergy Microwave Corp. (Paterson, NJ). The new patent pending voltage controlled oscillators (VCOs) are currently available for frequencies from 250 to 6000 MHz with typical measured phase noise of 132 dbc/hz offset 100 khz from carriers 250 to 1000 MHz. In spite of their low phase noise levels, it is a YIG oscillator's sensitivity to drift, vibration, and other negative factors that can diminish a microwave radio's bit error rate (BER) performance YIG oscillators are also limited in tuning speed in the range of millisecond frequency switching speed. For point to point and point to multi point radio designers, the microsecond switching speed of a VCO supports frequency agile solutions, although the phase noise of source agile sources has traditionally been limited. With the new DCYR sources, the phase noise performance is comparable to the best YIG sources over wideband tuning ranges, but at a fraction of the size and power consumption, and with considerably faster tuning speed than YIG oscillators. YIG oscillators require a significant amount of power (typically 200 ma at 12 V or more) in order to power the heater that stabilizes the internal temperature of the YIG sphere and its supporting electronics. Dissipating this heat often becomes a problem, especially when protecting the surrounding circuitry of a microwave radio. Even with the integrated heater, the operating temperature range of most YIG oscillators is limited to about 0 to +60 C and not suitable for all wireless systems. The design of one YIG oscillator is not readily scalable to a nonstandard package or frequency range, so custom YIG sources generally require additional non recurring engineering (NRE) costs along with the costs of the products. Another limitation of the YIG oscillator is the nature of its tuning, by means of an applied magnetic field. Instantaneous changes to that field are difficult to control, and creating the structure to generate such a field is not readily compatible with low cost monolithic microwave integrated circuit (MMIC) fabrication techniques. A YIG oscillator is essentially a YIG sphere with high unloaded quality factor (Q) set in a resonant cavity. The resonant frequency is tuned according to the magnetic field applied by a main coil. A second magnetic field, applied from a second coil, provides modulation when necessary. And a heating element is often added to stabilize the frequency of the YIG sphere and resonant structure over wide temperature ranges. The traditional design of a YIG sphere and resonant cavity becomes significantly larger as wavelengths become larger, typically at frequencies below 2 GHz. Few advances have been made in this basic proportionality rule, resulting in few commercial YIG sources for frequency ranges below 2 GHz. Due to demand for low phase noise sources, and knowing the limitations of YIG oscillators, the design engineers of Synergy Microwave developed a novel patent pending oscillator topology based on multi coupled slow wave (MCSW) planar resonators. The approach supports multi octave tuning in a small package, and is compatible with IC fabrication processes. 1 3 The novel topology allows for a substantial reduction in phase noise by dynamically optimizing impedance transfer function and coupling factor across the guided distributed medium of the planar multicoupled network. 2 9 An MCSW VCO is planar and broadband in nature, therefore well suited for cost effective, monolithic microwave integratedcircuit (MMIC) fabrication. With the potential to enable wide operational bandwidths, eliminate discrete resonators (such as a YIG sphere), and produce high quality factor (high Q) planar resonators for low noise VCOs by means of a planar fabrication process compatible with existing IC and MMIC processes, the MCSW VCO is a promising technology for present and future broadband communications requirements. The MCSW, for example, is well suited for use in microwave communications systems, test equipment, radar, local multipoint distribution systems (LMDS), and multichannel multipoint distribution systems (MMDS).

2 Figure 1 shows a block diagram of a DCYR series MCSW VCO. The DCYR series is currently available at frequencies from 250 to 6000 MHz (various tuning ranges); all models are capable of providing stable performance over wide operating temperature ranges of 40 to +85 C. The tiny low noise oscillators are housed in surface mount packages measuring either in. or in. (Fig. 2). These miniature sources are a fraction of the size of the smallest YIG oscillators, which are housed in metal cubes measuring either 1 in. or 1.25 in. on a side. As depicted in Fig.1, the active impedance created by the three terminal active device (a field effect transistor or bipolar transistor) in a MCSW oscillator has a negative real part with a real magnitude and an imaginary part with an imaginary magnitude. The real magnitude is a function of the imaginary magnitude. The imaginary magnitude is selected such that the real magnitude compensates for the loss of the MCSW resonator. The selection of the imaginary magnitude should also coincide with the maximum slope inflection point of the oscillator's phase characteristic curve, in order to optimize group delay performance. The mode coupling approach also includes a methodology for optimum dynamic coupling. Optimum coupling enhances the dynamic loaded Q, reduces or eliminates phase hits, diminishes susceptibility to microphonics (to an extremely low level), and minimizes phase noise while achieving a broadband linear tuning range. 4 9

3 The multi mode coupled resonator network shown in Fig. 1 is capacitively coupled across the base and collector terminal of the three terminal (bipolar or FET) active device. This arrangement can be characterized as a high Q multiplier based on evanescent mode progressive delay that eventually improves the time average loaded Q of the planar resonator over its multioctave operating band. A slow wave and a progressive wave coupled resonator (coupled through hybrid resonance mode convergence effect) connected through phase compensating network across collector and base of the three terminal (bipolar or FET) active device, which supports self injection locking mechanism over multioctave band. In addition to this, a phase compensating network (capacitively coupled between the base terminal and the slow wave and progressive wave coupled resonators) also optimizes group delay dynamically for uniform and minimum phase noise performance over the band. An RF output signal is coupled through a distributed coupled medium, which is coupled across the slowwave and progressive wave resonator networks, therefore, uniform output power and improved higher order harmonic rejection through out the operating frequency band How well does this arrangement perform in terms of phase noise? As a reference point, the typical phase noise of a commercial YIG tuned oscillator is 95 dbc/hz offset 100 khz from carriers spanning 2 to 6 GHz. In recent years, commercial YIG oscillators have been developed with frequency coverage as low as 500 MHz in multi octave 1 in. units, although maintaining a miniature package style at lower frequencies becomes difficult. In spite of the small size, the power consumption for these units, with the combined oscillator circuit and YIG heater requirements, can exceed 200 ma on surges and 100 ma in steadystate operation. In comparison, Fig. 3 shows the phase noise plot of a 250 to 1000 MHz model DCYR oscillator. The typical measured phase noise is 130 dbc/hz at offset 100 khz from the carrier. The oscillator is smaller than the tiniest YIG source, at in., and requires only 35 ma current at +5 VDC, with a tuning voltage range of 0 to 28 V. The buffered output power is more than +3 dbm across the full 750 MHz bandwidth (4 octave), with harmonic levels of better than 20 dbc across the full band. In contrast, wideband YIG oscillators can provide more output power, at levels of +10 dbm or more at even higher frequencies but at the cost of high power consumption and harmonic levels tend to be in the range or 10 dbc or worse. A variation, model DCYR , at 0.75 X 0.75 X 0.16 in, 35 ma current at +12 VDC, with a tuning voltage range of 0 to 28 V offers typical measured phase noise 134 dbc/hz at offset 100 khz from the carrier. Figures 4, 5, and 6 show the plot of phase noise, frequency tuning, output power, second harmonic rejection for model DCYR

4

5 The DCYR series is based on fundamental oscillation not on doubling or multiplication, which can result in phase, jitter, and phase hits. The oscillator series is easily configurable and can be extended to other frequency bands. Additional models are available and some that are under development include the following: Model DCYR , covers the octave band from 1000 to 2000 MHz with better than 128 dbc/hz offset 100 khz from the carrier. It is supplied in a surface mount package measuring 0.75 X 0.75 in. It exhibits second harmonics of better than 10 dbc. The sources consume 35 ma at +12 VDC and output power is better than +3 dbm across the full tuning band. A variation, model DCYS , measures in. Model DCYS tunes from 1200 to 2000 MHz with typical phase noise of 125 dbc/hz offset 100 khz from the carrier. It is supplied in a package measuring 0.5 X 0.5 in. Second harmonics are better than 10 dbc across the band; the output power is better than +3 dbm across the full tuning band. The source draws 35 ma current from a +12 VDC supply, and is also available in a 0.75 X 0.75 in. package as model DCYR Model DCYR covers 3000 to 6000 MHz with a tuning voltage range of 0 to 25 V and power supply of 45 ma and +5 VDC. It measures 0.75 X 0.75 and exhibits phase noise of 105 dbc/z offset 100 khz from the carrier. Second harmonics are 10 dbc or better. The 0.5 X 0.5 in. version is model DCYS Model DCYS covers the octave band from 2000 to 4000 MHz in a 0.5 X 0.5 in. package. The typical phase noise is 113 dbc/hz offset 100 khz from the carrier with second harmonic levels of 10 dbc or better. The buffered output power is +3 dbm or more across the full band and excellent linearity (typically 1:2). Power requirements are 45 ma at +5 VDC, with tuning voltages of 0 to 15 V. Model DCYS tunes over the octave band of 2500 to 5000 MHz in a package measuring 0.5 X 0.5 in. Its typical phase noise is 105 dbc/hz offset 100 khz from the carrier with second harmonics of 10 dbc or better across the full band. The oscillator requires tuning voltages of 0 to 20 V and consumes 45 ma at +5 VDC. It delivers better than +3 dbm buffered output power across the full tuning range. Finally, model DCYS tunes from 3000 to 6000 MHz with typical phase noise of 102 dbc/hz offset 100 khz from the carrier and harmonics of better than 10 dbc across the full band. The oscillator measures 0.5 X 0.5 in., has a tuning voltage range of 0 to 25 V, and draws 45 ma current from a +5 VDC supply. It offers better than +3 dbm buffered output power across the full tuning range. Obviously, for microwave frequencies, YIG oscillators still provide the best combination of multi octave tuning range and phase noise, albeit requiring moderate to high power levels to handle tuning and YIG heater elements. For frequencies as low as 250 MHz and as high as 6000 MHz, however, the new DCYR oscillators offer a low phase noise alternative to YIGs and other sources at these lower frequencies, with less susceptibility to vibration and microphonics, less power consumption, and smaller size. And for applications requiring agile frequency switching speeds, the new oscillators offer the potential of microsecond switching speed for ultrawideband (UWB) and other emerging wireless applications. Synergy Microwave Corp., 201 Mclean Blvd., Paterson, NJ 07504; (973) , FAX: (973) , Internet: REFERENCES 1. A.K. Poddar, "A Novel Approach for Designing Integrated Ultra Low Noise Microwave Wideband Voltage Controlled Oscillators," Dr. Ing. Dissertation (Ph.D. thesis) TU Berlin, 14 December 2004, Germany. 2. U.L. Rohde, A.K. Poddar, J. Schoepf, R. Rebel, and P. Patel, "Low Noise Low Cost Ultra Wideband N Push VCO," IEEE MTTS, 2005, USA. 3. A.K. Poddar and K.N. Pandey, "Microwave Switch using MEMS technology," High Performance Electron Devices for Microwave and Optoelectronic Application, 8th IEEE International Symposium, pp , Nov. 2000, UK. 4. U.L. Rohde, A.K. Poddar, and Juergen Schoepf, "A Unifying Theory and Characterization of Microwave Oscillators/VCOs," 18th IEEE CCECE05, May 2005, Canada. 5. U.L. Rohde, K.J. Schoepf, and A.K. Poddar, "Low Noise VCOs Conquer Wide Bands," Microwaves & RF, pp , June A.K. Poddar, S.K. Koul and Bharthi Bhat, "Millimeter Wave Evanescent Mode Gunn Diode Oscillator in Suspended Stripline Configuration," IR &MM Wave, 22nd International Conference, pp , July 1997, USA. 7. U.L. Rohde, A.K. Poddar, and G. Boeck, Modern Microwave Oscillators for Wireless Applications: Theory and Optimization, Wiley, New York, A.K. Poddar, J.K. Bansal, and K.N. Pandey, "Millimeter Wave Evanescent Mode Power Combiner Gunn Oscillator in Suspended Stripline Configuration," Mathematical Methods in Electromagnetic Theory, IEEE MMET'98 International Conference, pp , June U.L. Rohde and A.K. Poddar, "Reconfigurable Wideband VCOs," IEEE, PIMRC2005, September 11 14, 2005, Germany. 10. U.L. Rohde and A.K. Poddar, "Distributed Coupled Resonator (DCR) Oscillator/VCO Limit Phase Noise and Phase Hits," IEEE Radio and Wireless Systems Symposium, January 17 19, 2006, USA. 11. U.L. Rohde and A.K. Poddar, "UWB Configurable YRO," IEEE Sarnoff Symposium, Princeton, March 27 28, 2006, NJ, USA. 12. U.L. Rohde, and A.K. Poddar, "Cost Effective, Power Efficient and Configurable YIG Replacement Signal Source," German Microwave Conference GeMiC 2006, March 2006, Germany.