ERAWATCH COUNTRY REPORTS 2010: Canada

Transcription

1 ERAWATCH COUNTRY REPORTS 2010: Canada ERAWATCH Network George Teather

2 Acknowledgements and further information: This analytical country report is one of a series of annual ERAWATCH reports which cover the EU Member States, Countries Associated to the EU Seventh Research Framework Programme (FP7) and, since 2011, selected third countries (ERAWATCH International). ERAWATCH is a joint initiative of the European Commission's Directorate General for Research and Innovation and Joint Research Centre - Institute for Prospective Technological Studies (JRC-IPTS). The reports are produced, under contract, by the ERAWATCH Network. The analytical framework and the structure of the reports have been developed by the Institute for Prospective Technological Studies of the Joint Research Centre (JRC-IPTS) with contributions from Directorate General for Research and Innovation and the ERAWATCH Network. The report is only published in electronic format and is available on the ERAWATCH website ( Comments on this report are welcome and should be addressed to jrc-ipts-erawatchhelpdesk@ec.europa.eu. The opinions expressed are those of the authors only and should not be considered as representative of the European Commission s official position. Page 2 of 42

3 Executive Summary Canada is an economically advanced country, with the ninth largest economy in the world. Canada s natural resources sectors (oil and gas, agriculture, forestry, mining) are important contributors to the economy. International trade, especially exports of natural resources, makes up an important part of Canada s economy, and as a result, Canada is reliant on imports of Canadian goods by other countries. The population in 2010 was 34.3m and the GDP was 1.185tr (CAD$1.6tr). Canada is a federation with a federal government responsible for security, international relationships, trade and telecommunications. The ten provinces have primary responsibility for natural resources, education and health within their geographical area. In practice the federal government is responsible for setting and implementing research policy at the national level, even in areas of provincial jurisdiction. The provinces and territories focus on implementing research policies and delivering research programmes customised to their specific requirements. Canada s gross domestic spending on R&D (GERD) has declined in recent years, falling from 2.1% in 2001 to 1.85% in 2008, and has declined even further during the economic crisis as business expenditures on R&D have declined. In Canada, the higher education sector performs about twice as much R&D as the OECD average (35% compared to 17%), and the business sector less (55% compared to 70%). The Canadian resource sectors (oil and gas, agriculture, forestry and mining), all major exporters, perform relatively little R&D. In 2007, the government introduced an integrated set of policies that link research policies directly with higher level national economic, environmental and social objectives. These policies and programmes support the development of research capacity, creation of knowledge and the translation of research knowledge and technological developments into economic, environmental and social applications that contribute to Canada s competitiveness and quality of life. Knowledge Triangle The effectiveness of knowledge triangle policies needs to be understood in the context of the Canadian political system and economic drivers. Canada is unusual among advanced economies in terms of the importance of exports, particularly of resources such as oil and gas, agriculture and forestry products and minerals. Sales of these products are driven by world demand, especially from the U.S., by far Canada s largest trading partner. Exports are affected by demand in importing countries and by alternative sources. Quality and price are important factors. Traditionally, these exporting sectors carry out little R&D, measured as a percentage of revenues. Canada is among the leading countries in terms of spending per capita on higher education and has a high percentage of population with post secondary education. However, Canada has had relatively little success in translating knowledge into economic, environmental and social applications. Page 3 of 42

4 The policy document Advantage Canada, produced in 2007, provided a clear linkage between research policy and the higher level economic and social objectives of the government. This linkage was articulated in the policy document Mobilizing Science and Technology in Canada s Advantage, which provided a clear description of the contribution of the three elements of the knowledge triangle policies to the achievement of Canada s long term objectives. The Table below provides a description of the specific contribution of the three elements to the achievement of Canada s long-term success. Policy Recent policy changes Assessment of strengths and weaknesses Research policy Innovation policy Education policy Other policies Through 2007 government economic policy Advantage Canada, research policy is linked to the development of a People Advantage by increasing the supply of highly qualified S&T graduates, and a Knowledge Advantage to generate new knowledge in strategic areas that generate health, environmental, social and economic benefits. Through 2007 government economic policy Advantage Canada, innovation policy is directed at translating knowledge into commercial applications. Business led Centres of Excellence is an initiative to improve linkages between research and business communities. Through 2007 government economic policy Advantage Canada, education policy is linked to the development of a People Advantage by increasing the supply of highly qualified S&T graduates. Provides direct link between national research policy and its intended contribution to national social, environmental and economic objectives Emphasises need to translate knowledge into social, environmental, health and business applications. Emphasises need to for Canada s education system to provide more engineering and natural science graduates and post-graduates to meet needs of the knowledge economy. European Research Area Canada is not a member of the EU and is in North America, a different continent. Consequently, it is not surprising that there is little reference to ERA policies in Canada. However, to a considerable extent, the ERA objectives are generic, relevant to most advanced countries. Improving research capacity, building collaborations and increasing private sector investment in R&D are basic policy objectives in all advanced countries. The Page 4 of 42

5 Table below describes the extent to which Canada s policies align with the achievement of the 15 ERA objectives. Assessment of the national policies/measures supporting the strategic ERA objectives 1 ERA objectives Main policy changes Assessment of national strengths and weaknesses 1 Ensure an adequate supply of human resources for research and an open, attractive and competitive labour market for male and female researchers 2 Increase public support for research 3 Increase coordination and integration of research funding Canada Student Grant and Canada Graduate Scholarship Programmes receive additional funding so undergraduate and graduate students can pursue their education There are policies to attract foreign students to undergraduate and graduate programmes. Advantage Canada report links R&D policy directly to economic policy, and provides an increased focus on translation of research into applications, public well being and economic benefits. Increase in business led R&D Policies encourage Canadian researchers work cooperative with those from other countries in areas of mutual interest and complementary expertise. 4 Enhance research capacity Canada Research Chairs, Canada Industrial Research and Canada Excellence Research Chairs programmes are designed to increase research capacity by attracting world class expatriate and foreign researchers to Canadian universities. 5 Develop world-class research infrastructures (including e- The Canada Foundation for Innovation provides funding for Overall attractive conditions for training researchers. Adequate supply of science and engineering graduates. Supply is enhanced by foreign born students. Canadian trained researchers in high demand worldwide, especially in U.S. Have significant brain drain to scientifically interesting work in other countries. Some recent success in counteracting loss of trained researchers Canada ranked 13 th among R&D countries in GERD / GDP in Canada has a higher percentage of R&D funding from the public sector and lower from business compared to other OECD countries. Business R&D expenditures, already low, have been affected by the recent economic crisis. Canada works cooperatively with other countries, in many areas, research needs are specific to Canadian conditions. Canada has had some recent success in attracting world class researchers and building high quality research teams. However, Canadian trained researchers are in high demand worldwide, especially in U.S. Have significant brain drain to scientifically interesting work in other countries. Canada has recognised the need for high quality 1 Of course non-era countries do not strive to achieve ERA objectives. This part of the report is simply to allow a comparison with the activities of ERA countries on these issues Page 5 of 42

6 ERA objectives Main policy changes Assessment of national strengths and weaknesses infrastructures) and ensure access to them 6 Strengthen research institutions, including notably universities 7 Improve framework conditions for private investment in R&D 8 Promote public-private cooperation and knowledge transfer 9 Enhance knowledge circulation 10 Strengthen international cooperation in science and technology 11 Jointly design and coordinate policies across policy levels and policy areas, notably within the knowledge triangle large capital intensive S&T infrastructure and equipment needed by researchers to carry out leading research. CANARIE develops and maintains a world class high capacity optical communications network that is connected to other national and international networks. Federal gov t funding for Higher Education R&D, has doubled since 1980, and is presently 35% of all R&D. Canada has recently improved the access of SMEs to the Scientific Research and Experimental Development tax credit and has strengthened public/private partnerships and commercialisation initiatives, such as the Business Led Network of Centres of Excellence. The Business-Led Network of Centres of Excellence is on recent initiative to increase cooperation and transform knowledge to industrial application. To complement Canadian funding, partnerships with other countries are encouraged, Canada has a number of bilateral S&T Agreements with countries such as India, Japan, France, Germany and the European Union The 2007 policy document Advantage Canada emphasises the need to co-ordinate education, research and innovation policies and programmes as the means to physical, technical and e- infrastructure to support researchers and to enable them to attract international collaborations Provinces are responsible for funding education, including universities. Universities are suffering from serious underfunding of staff and infrastructure. The federal government funds university R&D primarily through NSERC and government departments. BERD levels have been a long term weakness in Canada, in spite of many attempts to change. Other structural factors impact business willingness to increase R&D spending. Weakness by the business community in the transformation of knowledge to application and innovative new and improved processes has been a long term area of concern. Canada has a number of research projects that include partnerships with other countries in areas of mutual interest and complementary capability, Canada has good access to international research through formal and informal collaborations and communication. Canada needs to improve the role of education and research, and the transfer of knowledge as key elements of innovation, quality of life and economic Page 6 of 42

7 ERA objectives Main policy changes Assessment of national strengths and weaknesses improve Canadian quality of life growth and economic growth. 12 Develop and sustain excellence and overall quality of research 13 Promote structural change and specialisation towards a more knowledge - intensive economy 14 Mobilise research to address major societal challenges and contribute to sustainable development 15 Build mutual trust between science and society and strengthen scientific evidence for policy making Research funding is based on quality and relevance. Science policy and funding priorities focus on building a knowledge intensive economy, particularly in areas of national strategic importance (energy, information technology, communication, the environment) Recent federal government initiatives have increased the funding in areas of strategic importance (environment, natural resources and energy, health and information and communications technologies). More specifically in energy conservation, renewable energy, reduction in GHG emissions, health and an aging population. The 2007 major economic policy Advantage Canada acknowledged scientific knowledge and expertise as key ingredients in developing applications to achieve government objectives and improve quality of life and economic wealth. There is international recognition of the quality of Canadian research. While the Canadian knowledge based economy is growing, the Canadian economy remains largely based on exploitation of natural resources (forestry, oil and gas, mining and agriculture). However, there are many innovative changes occurring in these areas of the economy related to the environment, cost savings and competitive advantage. There is a need for government regulatory and social policies to complement and support the R&D initiatives. Policy decisions involve many factors beyond science. There continues to be some disconnect between the scientific community and policy makers. Need to improve use of science based knowledge as basis for evidence based policies and decisions Page 7 of 42

8 TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary Introduction Performance of the national research and innovation system and assessment of recent policy changes Structure of the national research and innovation system and its governance Resource mobilisation Resource provision for research activities Evolution of national policy mix geared towards the national R&D investment targets Providing qualified human resources Knowledge demand Knowledge production Quality and excellence of knowledge production Policy aiming at improving the quality and excellence of knowledge production Knowledge circulation Knowledge circulation between the universities, PROs and business sectors Cross-border knowledge circulation Main societal challenges Overall assessment National policies which correspond to ERA objectives Labour market for researchers Stocks and mobility flows of researchers Providing attractive employment and working conditions Open recruitment and portability of grants Meeting the social security and supplementary pension needs of mobile researchers Enhancing the training, skills and experience of researchers Research infrastructures National Research Infrastructures roadmap Strengthening research institutions Quality of National Higher Education System Academic autonomy Academic funding Knowledge transfer Intellectual Property Policies Other policy measures aiming to promote public-private knowledge transfer Cooperation, coordination and opening up national research programmes with the EU Page 8 of 42

9 3.5.1 National participation in intergovernmental organisations and schemes Bi- and multilateral RDI agreements with EU countries Other instruments of cooperation and coordination between national R&D programmes Opening up of national R&D programmes International science and technology cooperation International cooperation (beyond EU) Mobility schemes for researchers from third countries CONCLUSIONS Effectiveness of the knowledge triangle Comparison with ERA 2020 objectives - a summary References List of Abbreviations Page 9 of 42

10 1 Introduction The main objective of the ERAWATCH International Analytical Country Reports 2010 is to characterise and assess the evolution of the national policy mixes for the non- EU countries in the perspective of the Lisbon goals and of the 2020 post-lisbon Strategy, even though they do not pursue these policies themselves. The assessment will focus on the national R&D investments targets, the efficiency and effectiveness of national policies and investments into R&D, the articulation between research, education and innovation. In doing this, the 15 objectives of the ERA 2020 are articulated. Given the latest developments, the 2010 Country Report has a stronger focus on the link between research and innovation, reflecting the increased focus of innovation in the policy agenda. The report is not aimed to cover innovation per se, but rather the 'interlinkage' between research and innovation, in terms of their wider governance and policy mix. Page 10 of 42

11 2 Performance of the national research and innovation system and assessment of recent policy changes The aim of this chapter is to assess the performance of the national research system, the 'interlinkages' between research and innovation systems, in terms of their wider governance and policy as well as the most recent changes that have occurred in national policy mixes in the perspective of the Lisbon goals. Each section identifies the main societal challenges addressed by the national research and innovation system and assesses the policy measures that address these challenges. The relevant objectives derived from ERA 2020 Vision are articulated in the assessment for comparison reasons. 2.1 Structure of the national research and innovation system and its governance This section gives the main characteristics of the structure of the national research and innovation systems, in terms of their wider governance. Canada is an economically advanced country, with the ninth largest economy in the world. Canada s natural resources sector (oil and gas production, forestry, mining) is an important contributor to the economy. International trade, especially exports of natural resources, makes up an important part of Canada s economy, and as a result, Canada is reliant on imports of Canadian goods by other countries. The population in 2010 was 34.3m, the GDP was 1,185b ($CAD1,600b), and GDP per capita 37,000 ($CAD48,000). Due to the heavy reliance on exploitation of natural resources, Canada has a relatively low level of expenditure on R&D, ranking 13 th among OECD countries. Canada had a GERD/GDP ratio of 1.86 in In particular the private sector contribution to R&D is relatively low, with a BERD of 0.9% of GDP. This is largely due to the makeup of Canada s business sector and the reliance on resource extraction. Canada is a federation with a federal government responsible for security, international relationships, trade and telecommunications. The ten provinces have primary responsibility for natural resources, education and health within their geographical area. In practice the federal government is responsible for setting and implementing research policy at the national level, even in areas of provincial jurisdiction. The provinces and territories focus on implementing research policies and delivering research programmes customised to their specific requirements. Main actors and institutions in research governance For the current federal government first elected in 2006, research policy is one element within the overall federal government plan to achieve broad, long range economic and social objectives, first articulated by the Minister of Finance in the government economic document Advantage Canada. Industry Canada is the government department responsible for developing research and innovation policy within the framework of the economic plan. The document Mobilizing Science and Technology to Canada s Advantage outlines the main elements of Canada s current research policy. Other federal departments and agencies with a large science Page 11 of 42

12 component are known as Science-Based Departments and Agencies (SBDAs) 2. SBDAs develop department / agency level research policies specific to their mandate and objectives based on the high level policies. These SBDAs share responsibility with Industry Canada for development and delivery of science policies and programmes. The Science Technology and Innovation Council is made up of representatives of business, academia and other organisations responsible for providing the government with external advice on R&D and innovation issues critical to Canada s economic development and social well-being. Figure 1: Overview of Canada s research system governance structure Canadian S&T and Innovation Governance System Prime Minister and Cabinet Science Technology and Innovation Council Industry Canada Department of Finance Science-based Departments and Agencies Universities, Colleges, Not-for-profit, Private Sector, Provinces - stakeholders advice The Prime Minister and Cabinet have the highest level of responsibility for the Canadian federal research system. While theoretically the Minister of Industry has responsibility for overall research policy, in practice, responsibility is shared with the Ministers responsible for the other SBDAs. Each Minister is responsible for interpreting the overall research policy in the context of their Departmental mandate. 2 SBDAs include: Agriculture Canada, Canada Institutes for Health Research, Environment Canada, Fisheries and Oceans, Health Canada, Natural Resources Canada, Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council, National Research Council of Canada, Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council, Statistics Canada Page 12 of 42

13 Several federal organisations have a mandate to fund research, performed mainly at universities. These include Departments such as the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council (NSERC) and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC). The Canada Foundation for Innovation (CFI) provides funding for major capital infrastructure and equipment that supports research. Some federally funded agencies, such as Sustainable Development and Research Canada (SDRC) co-fund R&D projects with industry that are at the advanced development or pilot stage and are strong candidates for commercial application. Research is carried out in business enterprises, universities, government laboratories, and a range of public, not-for-profit and private research institutes. Most research institutes receive funding from both government and business. Most other SBDAs both carry out intramural research and fund extramural research at universities and other research organisations. The governance and delivery structures have been relatively stable for many years. The role of Industry Canada, SBDAs, NSERC and SSHRC has been consistent for decades. From time to time, new agencies are created in response to government priorities and identified needs. CFI was created over a decade ago to address the need for funding major scientific infrastructure in universities and hospitals. SDRC was created a number of years ago in response to the increased focus on improving environmental sustainability. The institutional role of regions in research governance As Canada is a federation, the provinces are important actors in the areas of research and higher education. Each province is responsible for education under the Constitution, including the universities within its borders. In general, the province contributes funding towards the salary of professors and university infrastructure and the federal government funds the research and stipends for graduate students. Each province has a political governance system similar to the federal government and has departments and agencies similar to those of the federal government. Provinces develop and fund R&D and innovation policies and programmes that are focused on those areas most important to their economy. For example, Quebec, which has large aerospace and pharmaceutical sectors, has programmes and funding to support research in these areas, carried out both by business and universities. As an example, the Quebec government is contributing 51m ($70m CAD) over four years towards a 109m ($150m CAD) Ecological Airplane research project to enhance the ability of the Quebec aerospace industry to contribute to the production of ecologically friendly aircraft. In addition to supporting the development of knowledge at universities, Ontario and other provinces have Centres of Excellence and other major programmes to translate research knowledge into innovative applications and commercial products. Many provinces have a provincial research organisation that conducts research in areas related to the economic interests of the province. For example the Alberta Research Council has large programmes linked to production of oil from the oil sands and valued added forest products such as oriented strand board used as a lower cost substitute for plywood. The Alberta government, through the Alberta Energy Research Institute is also funding a number of projects associated with carbon capture and storage to reduce GHG emissions to the atmosphere. Several projects involve examining the feasibility of long term high volume CO 2 storage in deep geological formations. Most provinces co-fund research initiatives with the federal government in areas of mutual interest. For example, The National Institute for Nanotechnology in Alberta is jointly funded by the federal and Alberta governments and operates as a partnership between the National Research Page 13 of 42

14 Council of Canada and the University of Alberta. Government. British Columbia, with a large forest industry, is a major funder along with the federal government and the private sector in Forintek, Canada`s primary forest products research centre, which has its primary research facilities in British Columbia. The federal government co-also funds genomics related research with specific provinces related to their interests under a generic federal genomics program. Western Canada genomics research projects focus on agricultural products such as canola and other grains, which are major crops in the region. Main research performer groups The private sector is the larger performer of research, at 54% of GERD, with a total of 12.3b (CAD $16b 3 ). Firms in the several of the resource sectors, including forestry and fossil fuel production, perform little R&D in proportion to sales. Until recently, Nortel, one of Canada s largest IT firms, was a major R&D performer. Unfortunately, Nortel declared bankruptcy in Canada s other major IT firm, RIM, the maker of the Blackberry, continues to be among the largest private sector R&D performers The higher education sector is the next largest performer of research, accounting for about 35% of GERD, with 7.9b (CAD$10.3b) in expenditures 4 in Each province has at least one university and Ontario, the largest and most populous, has ten. Provinces also have colleges that deliver applied programmes. The public sector is the third largest research performer, accounting for about 9% of GERD or 2.0b (CAD $2.6b) in The federal government SBDAs are the largest performers of intramural research related to their mandates. For example, Natural Resources Canada conducts research on improving the efficiency of coal fired electrical power generation and renewable power generation in order to support the effective use of Canada s large coal reserves and reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Agriculture Canada conducts research on improving crop yields. 2.2 Resource mobilisation This section will assess the progress towards national R&D targets, with particular focus on private R&D and of recent policy measures and governance changes and the status of key existing measures, taking into account recent government budget data. The assessment will include also the human resources for R&D. Main assessment criteria are the degree of compliance with national targets and the coherence of policy objectives and policy instruments Resource provision for research activities Canada has no specific targets for R&D investment. While there is a general desire to increase GERD, the GERD/GDP ratio has in fact declined in recent years, from 2.1% in 2001 to 1.85% in Even though the government has attempted to increase industrial R&D investments through a very generous R&D tax credit programme, BERD/GDP remains low in Canada by international standards. From a high of 1.25% in 2001, BERD declined to 0.9% in While the government has challenged the business sector to increase its spending on R&D, the recent economic crisis has affected business spending. 3 Statistics Canada 2008 data 4 Statcan 2008 data Page 14 of 42

15 Canada s R&D investments are based on the county s societal and economic challenges. Canada s economy relies heavily on exports, and the country needs to ensure a competitive marketplace so companies can compete on the world stage. For example, Canada needs to develop new technologies to reduce the costs and environmental effects of oil production from the oil sands. It is also important to maintain the competitiveness of Canada s aerospace industry through the development of new and improved technologies to increase the energy efficiency and reduce the environment footprint of Canada s next generation aircraft. Like other countries, Canada has major environmental challenges related to reduction in energy use and greenhouse gases generated by fossil fuels that contribute to global warming. With an aging population, Canada also has challenges related to the health of Canadians and minimising the costs of health care. As stated in the federal policy document, Mobilizing Science and Technology to Canada s Advantage, Science and technology are essential to building a prosperous economy and promoting a better quality of life across the country. The challenge is to translate S&T knowledge into public and private sector applications that provide socio-economic benefits. Canada s current long term policies regarding R&D activities are directly linked to the economic policy Advantage Canada, and are based on the 2007 policy document Mobilizing Science and Technology to Canada s Advantage. The goals are to utilise science and technology to create innovation applications that help improve Canada s economic competitiveness and provide solutions to environmental, health and other social challenges. The 2007 report sets out an S&T strategy to achieve these goals, built around three pillars, Entrepreneurial Advantage, Knowledge Advantage and People Advantage, described below: Canada will create an Entrepreneurial Advantage by translating knowledge into commercial applications that generate wealth and support the quality of life of Canadians. A Knowledge Advantage will be created by focusing on research in areas of national importance from a social and economic perspective. These are: environmental science and technologies; natural resources and energy; health and related life science and technologies; and information and communications technologies. In order to create a People Advantage, Canada will attract and retain the highly skilled workers necessary to foster innovation and growth. This goal will be accomplished through enhancing Canada s immigration system, fostering excellence in and access to post-secondary education, and reducing barriers to labour mobility. As articulated, Canada s science policy is vertically integrated, beginning with education and R&D to develop highly qualified personnel (HQP), leading to the development of new knowledge that will be applied to achieve economic, environmental and social objectives. There have been updates, but the broad strategy has not changed. The economic crisis has affected R&D funding in several ways. The federal government response to the crisis has been two fold. On one hand, as part of the Economic Action Plan, the focus has been to provide additional financial assistance to help the large industries most affected, such as forest products and automotive, and SMES to invest in modern innovative technologies to improve competitiveness. The government has instituted programmes to help industry develop innovative Page 15 of 42

16 technologies through university / business partnerships and support for the venture capital industry. However, recently, as the economic crisis abates for Canada, and the Economic Action Plan comes to a close, the focus has been on reducing government expenditures in all areas, including R&D. Business funding of R&D has also been affected. Canada s biggest single private sector R&D spender, Nortel, went into bankruptcy during the crisis and has been wound up. Other business R&D spending also declined. Canada has a number of federal organisations that manage and distribute R&D funding. There are three agencies, Natural Science and Engineering Research Council, Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council and Canada Institute for Health Research that deliver programmes that provide funding support to carry out R&D in universities and colleges in natural sciences and engineering, social sciences and humanities and medicine and health sciences respectively. Much of the funding from these three agencies is provided for research projects on a competitive basis. The Canada Foundation for Innovation provides funding for major capital equipment and infrastructure required to carry out front line research. The science-based departments and agencies carry out and fund R&D related to their specific mandates. For example, Natural Resources Canada carries out and supports research in forestry, oil and gas production, energy and mining. In addition, there are a number of specific programmes that fund specific initiatives such as Genome Canada and National Centres of Excellence in various fields. There are also several programmes that support private sector R&D carried out to develop new and improved technologies, products and processes to improve their competitive position. The programme Strategic Aerospace and Defence Initiatives provides funding for major projects in those sectors, and the Industrial Research Assistance Program provides technical advice and financial assistance to SMEs through a network of over 200 Industrial Technology Advisors. In 2008, federal funding of R&D totalled $5.6 b, 19% of the total, divided about equally between federal departments and universities Evolution of national policy mix geared towards the national R&D investment targets One major science policy objective is for the private sector to invest more in R&D. As stated in Mobilizing Science and Technology to Canada s Advantage, ``At a time when Canada`s overall productivity gains are below those of other trading nations with whom we compete, the need to encourage greater private-sector S&T investment is a priority.`` This policy directive is intended to address a long-standing area of concern. Canada is ranked 16 th among OECD countries in 2007 in terms of BERD/GDP. In 2006 Canada s BERD/GDP ratio was 1.05% compared to the G7 average of 1.48 and the OECD average of 1.1%. Canada s BERD/GDP reached a peak in 2001 of 1.25% and has declined since then to 1.0% in During the economic crisis, business spending on R&D declined even further. This is of major concern, as business R&D is closer to the market and the development of innovative new products that improver Canada s competitive position in the knowledge economy. There are a number of reasons for this low rate of business R&D. One major reason has been the Canada/US Autopact, whereby the Canadian automotive sector carried out almost no R&D, focusing on production of models that were developed in the US. Studies also show that the majority of Canadian firms are inherently conservative and not risk takers. Page 16 of 42

17 Policy Mix towards increasing private R&D investment Stimulating greater investment in R&D performing firms: As described in the Entrepreneurial Advantage, the government has instituted a number of programmes aimed at stimulating R&D investment in private firms, with a focus on transforming knowledge into commercial products and wealth. These programmes are in support of a policy objective identified under Entrepreneurial Advantage to translate knowledge into innovative applications that help improve Canada s economic competitiveness and provide solutions to environmental, health and other social challenges. There are a number of programmes in which the government co-funds R&D projects in strategic areas that involve private sector firms working cooperatively with universities and government R&D laboratories. The Business Led Networks of Centres of Excellence (BL-NCE) initiative is an example of a recent government programme in this area. The BL-NCE provides four year funding ( ) for four major business led programmes aimed at: reducing the environmental impact of aircraft and air travel and increasing the competitiveness of Canadian aerospace firms; enhancing oil recovery; developing value-added forestry products; and creation of pharmaceutical products. Another programme, the Strategic Aerospace and Defence Initiative (SADI) provides financial support for R&D carried out within the aerospace and defence sector. Government funding for R&D in the private sector is focused to a large extent on areas that are of national strategic importance from a social, environmental and economic perspective. These include: Environmental science and technologies; Natural resources and energy; Health and related life sciences and technologies; and Information and communications technologies. The majority of these programmes also involve university and /or government R&D organisations and researchers Promoting the establishment of new indigenous R&D performing firms; The Industrial Research Assistance Program (IRAP) provides technical and financial support to help grow SMEs. Many of the firms assisted are very small start-ups with less than 10 employees, with a focus on R&D and new products. During the economic crisis ( ), IRAP received an additional 1.5 m ($Can 200 m) to help firms improve their competitive position. However this additional funding has not been continued. Stimulating firms that do not perform R&D yet: IRAP also helps firms develop R&D capability to support the development of new and improved products, and increased competitiveness.. Attracting R&D performing firms from abroad: While the government has reduced corporate tax rates and provided funding to support employee training,, there are no specific programmes to attract R&D performing firms from abroad. Increasing extramural R&D carried out in co-operation with the public sector: Most of the programmes described in the section describing ways that Canada is stimulating Page 17 of 42

18 greater R&D investment in the private sector involves partnerships with university and or government researchers who contribute their own expertise. Many of the programmes are intended to transfer public sector knowledge to the private sector and transform it into economic wealth. Increasing R&D in the public sector: Government policy does not include increasing overall public sector R&D. During the period, during the economic crisis, the government instituted an Economic Action Plan that spent 38b ($CAN50b) to mitigate the economic downturn. This year, the government is reducing spending in almost all areas to return to a balanced budget from the major deficit during the last two years. These reductions are affecting spending in R&D. Innovation oriented procurement policies The federal government does not have any explicit R&D oriented procurement policies. However, the increased use of electronic communications and paperless transactions encourages the development and use of innovative electronic and wireless communication systems. The Province of Ontario does have a policy encouraging the use of renewable energy in the form of solar and wind power as a means to support an emerging green energy sector. The government is providing major subsidies to individuals and firms that install renewable power generation equipment. However, this policy is being challenges at the World Trade Organization by several other countries. Other policies that affect R&D investments As mentioned previously, the federal government has policies and programmes in place that support the development, retention and import of highly qualified personnel, an important element of successful R&D performing firms. The government has also reduced personal and corporate tax rates to encourage researchers to stay in Canada and firms to grow their Canadian operations Providing qualified human resources The supply of researchers in Canada comes from two sources. The first and largest is the Canadian University system. Students receive training at the undergraduate and graduate level from university professors. For undergraduates, the training is primarily through course work. For postgraduate students, the training is a combination of course work and participation in research projects. The second is the recruitment of researchers from abroad. Canadian trained researchers are in high demand and many are attracted to opportunities in other countries. To counteract this brain drain and attract excellent researchers, there are programmes such as the Canada Research Chairs Programme to attract and retain world-class researchers, including expatriates. The 2007 Canadian federal science policy report Mobilizing Science and Technology has a specific objective, known as People Advantage, that is aimed at increasing the supply of highly qualified science and technology graduates, including providing students with business experience to improve their job readiness. Specific initiatives include an expanded Canada Graduate Scholarship programme to support an additional 1000 graduate students and an Industrial R&D Internship programme to provide 1000 science graduate interns with business experience. The government has also introduced measures to make it easier for foreign workers to come to Canada. Page 18 of 42

19 Canada has a well educated population, with 46% of adults between the age of 25-64, having a tertiary education, compared to about half that level for the EU average. This is consistent with the high level of expenditures for higher education. In terms of S&T degrees, Canada ranks about average among OECD countries and fifth among G7 countries, with about 22% of total degrees in S&T. However, Canada ranks poorly in terms of the number of Doctoral degrees granted, being well below the OECD average and last among G7 countries. Canada had about 214,000 personnel employed in R&D in 2006, with 45% in Ontario and 30% in Quebec, the two largest and most industrialised provinces. There were about 6600 in the federal government, with the largest number, 1475 at the National Research Council of Canada. While research is a relatively attractive career after obtaining permanent employment, there are a number of impediments. One is the number of years to achieve a postgraduate degree compared to the potential for entering the workforce earlier with a good salary. This is particularly true for engineers. As a result, there is a lack of Canadian students for postgraduate studies. To compensate, foreign students are hired. In addition, there are a number of other careers that have greater salaries than research. 2.3 Knowledge demand This section focuses on structure of knowledge demand drivers and analysis of recent policy changes. The majority of Canada s economy is linked to natural resources including oil and gas production, mining, forestry and agriculture. However there are a number of strategically important industrial sectors and firms that rely on R&D and innovation. These include: Information technology and communications (many firms including RIM) Aircraft and jet engines (Bombardier, Pratt and Whitney Canada) Pharmaceuticals (several international pharmaceutical firms); Plant biochemistry and genomics (Monsanto and other international agricultural firms) Many government R&D policies and programmes respond to demand by supporting industrial R&D in these strategic areas with direct funding and co-funding of research with government agencies. The oil and gas sector is another important strategic sector with a need for innovative approaches to oil sands extraction and refinement that consumes less energy, produces less CO 2 and is more environmentally sustainable. Many government R&D policies and programmes support industrial R&D in these strategic areas with direct funding and co-funding of research with government agencies. It is important to realise that often many years of basis and early applied research are required as the foundation for commercialisation, application and widespread implementation. Resource limitations and immediate need may affect the ability to conduct research to support emerging and longer term challenges, such as development of Canada s arctic resources. Page 19 of 42

20 2.4 Knowledge production The production of scientific and technological knowledge is the core function that a research system must fulfil. While different aspects may be included in the analysis of this function, the assessment provided in this section focuses on the following dimensions: quality of the knowledge production, the exploitability of the knowledge creation and policy measures aiming to improve the knowledge creation Quality and excellence of knowledge production The primary source of knowledge production in Canada as measured by scientific publications is through scientific research at our universities. However researchers at Canadian SBDAs also make a significant contribution to knowledge production. In 2007, Canada placed eighth among 17 nations, with 840 articles per million population. 5 This is higher than the US, UK and Germany. Canada has the largest fraction of research publications in the fields of biology, agriculture, geology, the environment and mathematics. The overall quality of Canadian research, as measured by citations, is generally good, sixth among OECD countries. The fields with the highest number of citations are clinical medicine, chemistry, and biomedical research. Canadian universities also rank quite high by international standards. In the field of natural sciences, Canada has seven universities among the top 100 in the world. However, by international standards, Canadian students do not view an S&T education as a preferred option. The number of S&T degrees as a percentage of the total number of new degrees is relatively low in Canada, 21 st among OECD countries 6. However, Canada ranks poorly in translation of knowledge into application and commercial products. For example, in terms of patenting, Canada ranks 14 th among the 17 nation comparison group. The report State of the Nation 2008, produced by the Science Technology and Innovation Council also identified development and application of knowledge by industry as a weakness for Canada Policy aiming at improving the quality and excellence of knowledge production There is no overriding national policy or initiative aimed at monitoring or improving the quality and excellence of knowledge production. There are however, periodic studies that examine the quality and amount of knowledge production in Canada compared to other countries. As described in Section 2.1, the Science Technology and Innovation Council is responsible for providing external advice and guidance on Canada s R&D and innovation policies to the federal government. In 2008 the Council produced a report entitled the State of the Nation 2008, Canada s Science, Technology and Innovation System, that provided an overview of Canada s innovation performance including world ranking in science and engineering. The government takes reports such as this into account in developing innovation policies. The government also provides annual updates to the 2007 major policy document Mobilizing Science and Technology to Canada s Advantage. These updates describe 5 Conference Board of Canada, How Canada Performs, Innovation, Scientific Articles 6 State of the Nation 2008 Science, Technology and Innovation Council Page 20 of 42

21 progress in achieving policy goals, including the quality and relevance of knowledge production and its transformation into social and economic impacts. 2.5 Knowledge circulation This section provides an assessment of the actions at national level aiming to allow an efficient flow of knowledge between different R&D actors and across borders Knowledge circulation between the universities, PROs and business sectors The 2006 report The State of Science and Technology in Canada by the Committee on the State of Science and Technology in Canada cited the difficulty of knowledge transfer from researchers in universities to innovators in industry as a long standing problem in Canada. Solutions to the problems were considered to include a need for investment in technology development and demonstration, as well as dealing with broader economic, financial and cultural issues. In Advantage Canada the 2007 economic policy statement, there is a section called Entrepreneurial Advantage that emphasises the need to translate knowledge into commercial applications that generate economic benefit and support quality of life of Canadians. Canada has always had a number of programmes to bridge academic and business interests, including several Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council funded joint university-industry initiatives. However, there has been an increased focus and funding since the present government was elected in 2007, for programmes directly linking universities and businesses. As one example, the Business Led Network of Centres of Excellence Programme (BL-NCE) introduced in 2009 provided 30.1m (CAD$40m) over 4 years to four business led initiatives to develop technology relevant to business in four areas of national interest. There is one network in each of the following areas: Heavy oil production; Environmentally friendly next generation aircraft; Pharmaceuticals; and New value-added products from the forestry sector. Each of these initiatives receives matching funding from industry and other sources, and carries out research projects selected by industry. In the aerospace network, industry is also managing and carrying out the research projects Cross-border knowledge circulation Canada participates in a number of international science initiatives, particularly in those areas with large multinational participation, such as le Centre Europeenne pour la Rechereche Nucleaire (CERN), or high cost scientific infrastructure, such as the new radio astronomical facilities (Atacama Large MM Wave Array) under construction in Chile. There is also a large multinational scientific project hosted by Canada, the Weyburne-Midale Field Trial, which is injecting CO 2 into a producing oil field, as a test the viability of sequestering CO 2 in a deep geological formation, while gaining the economic benefit of enhanced oil recovery. This multimillion dollar long term project is supported by the International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme (IEA GHG) with direct participation by the U.S. and other countries. Page 21 of 42