Sustaining the Si Revolution: From 3D Transistors to 3D Integration Tsu Jae King Liu Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences University of California, Berkeley, CA USA February 23, 2015 2015 SPIE Advanced Lithography Symposium
Impact of Moore s Law 10 11 Gordon E. Moore Investment Transistor Scaling Lower Cost/Component Higher Performance Market Growth Mobile Internet Internet of Things (IoT) # DEVICES 10 10 10 9 10 8 10 7 Mainframe Minicomputer 10 6 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030 Desktop Internet PC Source: Morgan Stanley Research YEAR 2
A Vision of the Future Ultra low power operation required! The Cloud (millions) Mobile devices (billions) The Swarm (trillions) Source: J. Rabaey, ASPDAC 2008 3
Data Center Electricity Usage Data centers accounted for ~1.4% of electricity use worldwide in 2010* Google s Finland data center uses frigid water from the Baltic Sea for cooling. http://www.wired.com/2012/01/google finland/ *J. Koomey, Growth in Data center electricity use 2005 to 2010 (Analytics Press, Oakland, CA), 2011 4
Outline The path to 3D Transistors The CMOS Power Crisis Improving Energy Efficiency Pathways to 3D Integration Summary
MOSFET Basics Metal Oxide Semiconductor (MOS) Field Effect Transistor (FET) Gate length, L G log (CURRENT) I ON I OFF 0 V T V DD GATE VOLTAGE 6
The CMOS Power Crisis Voltage scaling has not kept pace with transistor scaling! Technology Node 45 nm 32 nm 22 nm 16/14 nm Supply voltage, V DD 1.0 V 0.9 V 0.8 V 0.7 V Power density limits now constrain IC design Supply Voltage [V] 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 Gate Overdrive (V DD V T ) V DD V T 1.4 1.0.8.6.35.25.18.13.09.065 Technology Generation [μm] Source: P. Packan (Intel), IEDM Short Course, 2007 Power Density [W/cm 2 ] 10 3 10 2 Active 10 1 10 0 10-1 10-2 10-3 Passive 10-4 10-5 0.01 0.1 1 MOSFET Gate Length [μm] Source: B. Meyerson (IBM), Semi. Conf., 2005 7
POWER DENSIY [W/cm 2 ] The Advent of Multi-Core Systems Parallelism is the main technique used to improve system performance under a power density constraint. 10 4 10 3 μpchip Power Density Trend 10 2 Core 2 8086 286 P6 10 8085 386 486 Pentium 1 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 YEAR Source: S. Borkar (Intel) Normalized Energy/op 100 80 60 40 Dual core Single core Operate at a lower energy point 20 Run in parallel to recoup performance 0 10 0 10 1 10 2 10 3 10 4 1/throughput [ps/op] 8
CMOS Energy Efficiency Limit A lower limit for E/op exists due to transistor OFF state leakage. Active Energy Passive Energy E Total = αl d fcv DD2 + L d fi OFF V DD t delay t delay = L d fcv DD / (2I ON ) α : Activity Factor L d : Logic Depth f : Fanout C : Capacitance per Stage Normalized Energy/op 25 20 15 10 5 E Total E Active E Passive 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 V DD [V] B. Calhoun et al., IEEE J. Solid State Circuits, Vol. 50, pp. 1778 1786, 2005 9
E total = L d fcv DD2 [ 1 + (L d f/2α) / (I ON /I OFF ) ] Improved reducing V DD log (CURRENT) 1/S Energy Improved V T V DD GATE VOLTAGE Delay Higher I ON /I OFF lower Energy/op Steeper switching behavior is needed! 10
3-Dimensional (3D) Transistor L G Gate Drain Superior gate control higher I ON /I OFF Source Multiple fins can be connected in parallel to achieve higher current H fin W fin D. Hisamoto et al. (UC Berkeley), IEDM 1998 15nm L g FinFET GATE 20 nm DRAIN 10 nm SOURCE Y. K. Choi et al., (UC Berkeley) IEDM 2001 Intel Corp., May 2011 11
3D Transistor Technology Roadmap Year: 2012 2014 2016? Intel Technology Node 22 nm 14 nm 10 nm Year: 2015 Foundry Technology Node: 14 nm 10 nm 7 nm Gate length, L G 25 nm 20 nm 15 nm Fin width, W fin ~10 nm ~8 nm ~6 nm Equivalent oxide thickness 0.9 nm 0.85 nm 0.8 nm X SEM Images Gate Gate Si SiO 2 SiO 2 C. Auth et al. (Intel Corp.) VLSI Symp. 2012 Si SiO 2 Si S. Natarajan et al. (Intel Corp.) IEDM 2014 12
MOSFET Evolution 32/28 nm planar FinFET: 22 nm thin body beyond 10 nm nanowires (NWs)? P. Packan et al. (Intel), IEDM 2009 FD SOI: Intel Corp. K. Cheng et al. (IBM), VLSI Symp. 2011 C. Dupré et al. (CEA LETI) IEDM 2008 Gate all around FETs must comprise stacked NWs for good area efficiency. 13
MOSFET vs. Tunnel FET ENERGY BAND DIAGRAM STRUCTURE Gate N+ N+ Source Drain Thermionic Emission Source Drain E C E V P+ Source Source Gate N+ Drain Band to Band Tunneling smaller S Drain E C E V Small bandgap (e.g. Ge or SiGe) Source provides for higher I ON 14
Electro-Mechanical Switch Zero off state leakage Zero passive power consumption Abrupt switching behavior Low V DD (low active energy) Three Terminal Switch OFF State (as fabricated): Source Gate Drain ON State: F elec Drain Current (A) 10 4 10 6 10 8 10 10 10 12 10 14 I V Characteristic S 0.1mV/dec release V RL V PI Gate Voltage pull in Logic relay endurance > 10 15 cycles for hot switching below 1 Volt H. Kam et al. (UC Berkeley), IEDM 2010 15
Surface Micromachining Process Cross sectional View structural film sacrificial layer Si wafer substrate Mechanical structures can be made using conventional microfabrication techniques Structures are freed by selective removal of sacrificial layer(s) 16
4-Terminal Logic Relay Isometric View Drain A Body Gate Gate A Source Voltage applied between the gate and movable body brings the channel into contact with source & drain Dielectric layer insulates body Body Dielectric (Al 2 O 3 ) AA Cross section channel (W) Body (p+ Si 0.4 Ge 0.6 ) Insulator (Al 2 O 3 ) Source (W) Gate (W) Drain (W) R. Nathanael et al. (UC Berkeley), IEDM 2009 17
3D Integration with CMOS Advanced back end of line (BEOL) processes have multiple metal layers and air gaps can be adapted for fabrication of compact relays! Scanning Electron Micrographs D. C. Edelstein (IBM), 214th ECS Meeting, Abstract #2073, 2008 S. Natarajan et al. (Intel), IEDM 2014 18
BEOL NEM Relay D0 V DD D1 GND M5 M4 A 5 terminal switch can be implemented using 4 interconnect layers Vias are used for electrical connection and as torsional elements for lower k eff V DD V DD GND M3 GND M2 INPUT courtesy of Dr. Kimihiko Kato (UC Berkeley) Fixed actuation electrodes on opposite sides of movable structure 2 stable states (contacting D 0 or D 1 ) 19
Outline The path to 3D Transistors The CMOS Power Crisis Improving Energy Efficiency Pathways to 3D Integration Summary
3D Packaging System in Package (SiP), Package on Package (PoP), etc. Enabled by wire bonding and/or flip chip bonding Packaging based Chip Stack Die to Wafer Bonding Smaller form factor Reduced packaging cost Reduced power consumption Limited interconnection density J. J. Q. Lu et al., Future Fab International, Issue 23, 2007 21
3D Transistor Stacking Transistor layers can be embedded between interconnect layers Laser crystallized Si Polycrystalline Si Bonded Si (on oxide) Higher transistor density Heat dissipation Thermal process limitations EDA tool adaptation J. J. Q. Lu et al., Future Fab International, Issue 23, 2007 22
Moore s 1965 Paper Revisited The minimum cost point moves to a larger number of components per IC over time, as manufacturing technology advances (i.e. yield improves). The primary reason for increasing the number of components per IC was (and still is) lower cost. *Gordon E. Moore, Cramming more Components onto Integrated Circuits, Electronics, pp. 114 117, April 1965 23
3D NAND Flash Technology Poly Si is used as the semiconductor material. Lithography steps for multiple memory layers are shared. Density scaling is not driven by lithography. Aspect ratios of etched and filled features are very large (>40:1). http://www.monolithic3d.com/uploads/6/0/5/5/6055488/695394.jpg?388 24
Heterogeneous Integration Enhanced performance & functionality in a compact form factor Separate layer fabrication processes Integrated fabrication process MEM relay Metal Insulator Interconnects CMOS layer J. J. Q. Lu et al., Future Fab Int l, Issue 23, 2007 Si substrate V. Pott et al., Proc. IEEE, Vol. 98, 2010 25
DMD TM Projection Display Chip Electrostatically actuated mirrors built over CMOS circuitry Structural layers comprise Al alloys; sacrificial material is photoresist SEM image of pixel array Schematic of 2 pixels < 20 m Each mirror corresponds to a single pixel, programmed by an underlying memory cell to deflect light either into a projection lens or light absorber. Texas Instruments Inc. 26
Polymeric Relay Plan View SEM Measured I V Characteristics 10-9 10-10 V DR = 32 V V SR = 0 V I DS [A] Transparent relay fabricated with a CMOS compatible process: SU 8 photoresist as structural material Fluorinated photoresist (OSCoR 4000) as dielectric material SiO 2 as sacrificial material Can be used as a humidity sensor 10-11 10-12 10-13 10-14 RH = 60 % RH = 90 % RH < 10 % 16 20 24 28 32 V GB [V] Y. Pan et al., 28 th IEEE Int l Conf. MEMS, pp. 940 943, 2015 27
Outline The path to 3D Transistors The CMOS Power Crisis Improving Energy Efficiency Pathways to 3D Integration Summary
Summary 3D transistors and 3D integration provide for improvements in IC energy efficiency and functionality, to sustain the Si revolution. Heterogeneous Integration Investment Lower Cost/Function Lower Power Market Growth Information technology will be pervasive embedded human centered solving societal scale problems Healthcare Transportation Infrastructure maintenance & disaster response Energy Environment 29