2013 Intellectual Property Statistics

Transcription

1 2013 Intellectual Property Statistics September 2014 Presented To:

2 2013 Intellectual Property Statistics Each year the Intellectual Property Group at FTI Consulting researches and compiles statistics on intellectual property prosecution and litigation. Please note that the underlying data used in the charts originate from either publicly available information or FTI Consulting s own databases, which are collections of publicly available information. As such, FTI Consulting does not endorse the accuracy or reliability of any of the information included therein, and reliance on such information for any purpose will be solely at your own risk. We welcome any feedback regarding the information presented in the charts. If you believe that that there are inaccuracies or omissions in any of the information contained in the charts, please contact us via at debra.resnick@fticonsulting.com. 1

3 U.S. Patent Applications Filed and Issued FY FY2013 Filed 600,000 Patents Issued Patents Filed 609, , , , , ,000 Issued 300, , , , , , s 1990s 2000s 2010s Source: United States Patent and Trademark Office Fiscal Year Ends September 30 2

4 U.S. Trademark Applications Filed and Issued FY FY ,000 Filed 450,000 Trademark Applications Issued Trademark Applications Filed 433, , ,000 Issued 300, , , , , ,000 50, s 1990s 2000s 2010s Source: United States Patent and Trademark Office Fiscal Year Ends September 30 3

5 Top Organizations Receiving U.S. Patents: ,652 3,316 2,814 2,649 2,190 2,086 1,802 1,730 1,621 1,469 1,355 1,259 6,788 3,918 3,117 2,679 2,399 2,182 1,828 1,775 1,638 1,448 1,459 1,280 1,168 Source: United States Patent and Trademark Office 4

6 Top Organizations Receiving U.S. Patents Total ,336 5,091 6,273 6,145 5,941 5,873 5,719 5,620 5,580 5,571 5,107 7,159 9,502 9,222 9,089 8,658 8,459 8,331 8,261 13,033 12,480 13,860 15,749 16, ,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 26,213 Source: United States Patent and Trademark Office 5

7 Top Countries Receiving U.S. Patents 2013 Canada 6 6,547 United States 1 133,593 Denmark Germany 3 15,498 Netherlands 12 2,253 Belgium 18 1,062 Spain U.K. 8 5,806 Switzerland 13 2,270 France 7 6,083 Italy 11 2,499 Austria 19 1, Norway Sweden 2, Israel 3,012 Finland 1,221 India 16 2, Russian Fed China 5,928 2 Japan 51,919 4 South Korea 14,548 5 Taiwan 11,071 China, Hong Kong 540 Singapore Australia 15 1,631 Source: United States Patent and Trademark Office 6

8 Top Countries Receiving U.S. Patents Rank Total Country ,920 UNITED STATES 77,501 82, , , , , ,732 JAPAN 33,682 35,501 44,814 46,139 50,677 51, ,531 GERMANY 8,915 9,000 12,363 11,920 13,835 15, ,025 SOUTH KOREA 7,549 8,762 11,671 12,262 13,233 14, ,717 TAIWAN 6,339 6,642 8,238 8,781 10,646 11, ,234 CANADA 3,393 3,655 4,852 5,012 5,775 6, ,753 FRANCE 3,163 3,140 4,450 4,531 5,386 6, ,895 UNITED KINGDOM 3,094 3,175 4,302 4,307 5,211 5, ,276 CHINA, PEOPLE S REPUBLIC 1,225 1,655 2,657 3,174 4,637 5, ,856 ISRAEL 1,166 1,404 1,819 1,981 2,474 3, ,005 ITALY 1,357 1,346 1,798 1,885 2,120 2, ,131 NETHERLANDS 1,329 1,288 1,614 1,743 1,904 2, ,692 SWITZERLAND 1,112 1,208 1,608 1,663 1,831 2, ,571 SWEDEN 1,060 1,014 1,434 1,711 2,081 2, ,336 AUSTRALIA 1,292 1,221 1,748 1,919 1,525 1, ,760 INDIA ,098 1,234 1,691 2, ,067 FINLAND , ,654 BELGIUM ,312 AUSTRIA ,885 DENMARK ,692 SINGAPORE ,856 SPAIN ,536 CHINA, HONG KONG ,222 NORWAY ,690 RUSSIAN FEDERATION K 100K 200K 300K 400K 500K 600K 700K Source: United States Patent and Trademark Office 7

9 IP Cases Commenced in U.S. District Courts FY FY2013 Total 13,335 14,000 12,000 10,000 8,000 TM Trademark 6,497 3,666 6,000 4,000 Patent ,000 Copyright FY 03 FY 04 FY 05 FY 06 FY 07 FY 08 FY 09 FY 10 FY 11 FY 12 FY 13 0 Source: Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts Fiscal Year Ends September 30 8

10 Patent Cases Commenced in U.S. District Courts FY FY2013 Total 13,335 14,000 12,000 10,000 8,000 TM Trademark Patent C Copyright 6,497 5,189 4,015 2,814 3,075 3,301 2,720 2,830 2,896 2,909 2,792 FY 03 FY 04 FY 05 FY 06 FY 07 FY 08 FY 09 FY 10 FY 11 FY 12 FY 13 6,000 4,000 2,000 0 Source: Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts Fiscal Year Ends September 30 9

11 Trademark Cases Commenced in U.S. District Courts FY FY2013 Total 13,335 14,000 12,000 10,000 8,000 TM 6,000 Trademark 3,672 3,508 3,668 3,740 3,487 3,449 3,381 3,652 3,628 3,403 3,172 4,000 Patent C Copyright FY 03 FY 04 FY 05 FY 06 FY 07 FY 08 FY 09 FY 10 FY 11 FY 12 FY 13 2,000 0 Source: Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts Fiscal Year Ends September 30 10

12 Copyright Cases Commenced in U.S. District Courts FY FY2013 Total 13,335 14,000 12,000 10,000 8,000 TM Trademark Patent 2,448 3,007 5,796 4,944 4,400 3,234 2,192 2,013 2,297 3,074 3,666 6,000 4,000 2,000 Copyright FY 03 FY 04 FY 05 FY 06 FY 07 FY 08 FY 09 FY 10 FY 11 FY 12 FY 13 0 Source: Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts Fiscal Year Ends September 30 11

13 Completed Patent Cases in U.S. District Courts FY FY2013 Jury Trial Bench Trial % 55% % 53% % 55% % 62% % 58% % 59% Total 70% 60% 48% 10,084 50% 53% 42% 5,748 TM 40% 30% 29% Trademark 20% Patent C 10% 0% 14% 4% 9% 1% 2, Copyright PRE-Trial Trial POST-Trial No Court Action Before Pre-Trial During / After Pre-Trial During / After Trial Source: Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts Fiscal Year Ends September 30 12

14 Completed Trademark Case Trials in U.S. District Courts FY2008 FY2013 Jury Trial Bench Trial % 63% % 69% % 56% % 56% % 50% % 56% Total 70% 60% 64% 12,876 50% 53% TM 40% 30% 35% Trademark 20% 21% 6,470 Patent C 10% 0% 10% 2% 14% 2% 2, Copyright PRE-Trial Trial POST-Trial No Court Action Before Pre-Trial During / After Pre-Trial During / After Trial Source: Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts Fiscal Year Ends September 30 13

15 Jury Trial Bench Trial Completed Copyright Case Trials in U.S. District Courts FY FY % 60% 43% 57% 29% 71% 21% 79% 29% 71% 37% 63% Total 60% 50% 8,812 40% 5,524 TM Trademark 30% 20% Patent 10% 0% 1, Copyright PRE-Trial Trial POST-Trial No Court Action Before Pre-Trial During / After Pre-Trial During / After Trial Source: Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts Fiscal Year Ends September 30 14

16 Top Patent Damages Awards 2013* Rank Award Parties Date Court Source 1 $290.5M Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics November 2 $176.5M Tyco Healthcare Group LP et al. v. Ethicon Endosurgery Inc. 3 $173.0M ParkerVision Inc. v. Qualcomm Inc. October 4 $95.8M 5 $76.0M Syntrix Biosystems Inc. v. Illumina Inc. AstraZeneca AB et al. v. Apotex Corp. et al. N.D. California Law360 March Connecticut Law360 March 6 $70.0M Stryker Corp. v Zimmer Inc. Feb 7 $30.2M Seiijero Tomita v. Nintendo March 8 $29.0M KFx Medical Corp. v. Anthrex inc. October 9 $27.5M 10 $16.0M 11 $15.0M $0M $50M $100M $150M $200M $250M $300M Two-Way media LLC v AT&T Inc. et al DePuy Synthes Products LLC v Globus Medical Inc. Summit 6, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co. Dec M.D. Florida W.D. Washington S.D. New York W.D. Michigan S.D. New York S.D. California Patstats.org Patstats.org Law360 Law360 Patstats.org Law360 March W.D. Texas Patstats.org June Delaware Patstats.org April N.D. Texas Patstats.org *List does not take into account post-trial proceedings, rulings or settlements. 15

17 Top Patent Damage Awards Rank Award Parties Date Court Source 1 $1.7B Centocor Inc. v. Abbott Laboratories Jun-09 E.D Texas patstsats.org 2 $1.5B Alctatel v. Microsoft Feb-07 S.D California patstsats.org 3 $1.2B Cordis v. Boston Scientific and Medtronic Oct-08 D. Delaware Law $1.17B Carnegie Mellon University v. Marvell Technology Group Ltd. Dec-12 W.D. Pennsylvania Law $1.05B Apple Inc. v. Samsung Oct-12 S.D California patstsats.org 6 $1.0B Monsanto Company et al. v. Pioneer Hi-Bred Int'l Inc Aug-12 E.D Missouri patstsats.org 7 $925.0M Polaroid v. Eastman Kodak Jul-91 E.D. Massachusetts National Law Journal 8 $625.0M Mirror World LLC v. Apple Inc. Oct-10 E.D Texas patstats.org 9 $593.0M Saffran v. Johnson & Johnson Mar-11 E.D. Texas Law $521.0M Eolas Technologies v. Microsoft Jan-04 N.D. Illinois Law $501.0M Saffran v. Boston Scientific Feb-08 E.D. Texas Law $482.0M Saffran MD. v. Johnson & Johnson Jan-11 E.D Texas patstats.org 13 $475.0M City of Hope Medical v. Genentech Apr-08 Sup. Ct. California Law $442.2M Sanofi-Aventis and Bristol-Myers Squibb v. Apotex Oct-10 S.D. New York Law $397.0M Rambus v. Hynix Semiconductor Mar-09 N.D. California Law $391.0M Versata Software v. SAP America Sep-11 E.D. Texas Law $388.0M Uniloc USA Inc. v. Microsoft Corp. et al Apr-09 Rhode Island patstats.org 18 $371.0M C.R. Bard v. W.L. Gore & Associates Apr-09 D. Arizona Law $368.2M VinetX Inc. v. Apple Inc. et al. Nov-12 E.D Texas patstats.org 20 $368.0M Alcatel-Lucent v. Microsoft Apr-08 S.D California patstats.org 21 $306.9M Hynix v. Rambus Apr-06 N.D California patstats.org 22 $290.5M Apple Inc. V. Samsung Electronics Nov-13 N.D. California Law $290.0M i4i v. Microsoft Aug-09 E.D. Texas Law $252.0M InterDigital Communications v. Nokia Jan-06 S.D. New York Law $211.5M Haworth v. Steelcase Dec-96 W.D. Michigan Wall Street Journal $0M $500M $1B $1.5B $2B 16

18 Top Patent Damage Settlements 2013 Rank Settlement Parties Date District Source 1 $1.8B Monsanto Company v. DuPont Co. Mar-13 E.D. Missouri Reuters 2 $490M Motorola Mobility Inc. et al v. Tivo Inc. Jun-13 E.D. Texas Law360 3 $240M Hyundai Electronics v. Rambus Inc. Jun-13 N.D. New York Law360 4 $12M Warner Chilcott Laboratories v. Impax Laboratories Sep-13 New Jersey Law360 5 $10M Medtronic MiniMed Inc. v. Insulet Corp. Sep-13 C.D. California Law360 $0M $500M $1B $1.5B $2B 17

19 Significant Patent Damage Settlements Rank Settlement Parties Date Source 1 $1.8B Monsanto Company v. DuPont Co. Mar-13 Law $1.7B Johnson & Johnson v. Boston Scientific Feb-10 Law $1.5B Nvidia v. Intel Jan-11 Law $1.4B Michelson v. Medtronic Apr-05 Law $1.3B Advanced Micro Devices v. Intel Corp. Nov-09 Law $1.3B Sun Microsystems v. Microsoft Apr-04 Law $1.0B Texas Instruments v. Hyundai Electronics May-99 Wall Street Journal 8 $1.0B Texas Instruments v. Samsung Electronics Nov-96 Wall Street Journal 9 $900M Rambus v. Samsung Electronics Jan-10 Law $891M Broadcom v. Qualcomm Apr-09 Law $750M Medinol v. Boston Scientific Sep-05 Law $612.5M NTP v. Research in Motion Mar-06 Law $536.0M Novell v. Microsoft Nov-04 Law $500.0M TiVo v. Dish Network and EchoStar May-11 Law $490.0M Motorola Mobility Inc. et al v. Tivo Inc. Jun-13 Law $440.0M InterTrust Technologies v. Microsoft Apr-04 Law $440.0M Northrop Grumman v. Honeywell Dec-01 Wall Street Journal 18 $400.0M Abbott Laboratories v. Medtronic Jul-09 Law $400.0M Pitney Bowes v. Hewlett-Packard Jun-01 Wall Street Journal 20 $340.0M At Home v. AT&T May-05 Law 360 $0M $500M $1B $1.5B $2B 18

20 Top Copyright/Trademarks/Trade Secrets Damages Awards 2013* Rank Award Parties Date Court Source 1 $273.0M The National Football League v. Sunmei et al July S.D. New York Law360 2 $80.0M Disney Enterprises inc. v Hotfile Corp December S.D. Florida Law360 3 $35.0M 4 $22.7M Fendi Adele SRL v. Ashley Reed Trading Inc. Relco LLC v. Custom Fabricating & Repair, Inc. April Second Circuit Law360 November Kandiyohi County District court UNH Law Blogs 5 $6.0M Coach Inc. v. Swap Shop Inc. December S.D. Florida Law360 6 $3.6M 7 $3.5M BeautyBank inc. v Kumar Ramani Ageless Fantasy LLC QS Wholesale Inc. v. World Marketing Inc. October S.D. New York Law360 July C.D. California Law360 8 $3.0M Facebook Inc. v Power Ventures inc. September N.D. California Law360 9 $2.8M Gabrel Tech Corp. v. Qualcomm Inc. February S.D. California Lexology $0M $75M $150M $225M $300M *List does not take into account post-trial proceedings, rulings or settlements. 19

21 Significant Awards from Copyrights/Trademarks/Trade Secrets Cases* Rank Award / Settlement Parties Date IP Source 1 $2.3B Pacesetter v. Nervicon Jun-11 Trade Secret Law $920.0M DuPont v. Kolon Industries Sep-11 Trade Secret Law $626.2M EchoStar Satellite v. Global Technologies Nov-10 Copyright Law $610.0M Yahoo v. XYZ Companies Dec-11 Trademark Law $525.0M Seagate Technology v. Western Digital Nov-11 Trade Secret Law $495.7M Cadence Design Systems v. Avant Nov-02 Trade Secret Wall Street Jrnl 7 $465.0M Lexar Media Inc, v. Toshiba Corp. Mar-05 Trade Secret Law $310.0M MGA Entertainment v. Mattel Aug-11 Trade Secret Law $306.0M Oracle v. SAP Aug-12 Copyright ip-holdings.com 10 $304.6M Adidas America v. Payless Shoesource May-08 Trademark Law $300.0M Farouk Systems v. Eyou International Oct-10 Trademark Law $290.2M Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing v. SMIC Nov-09 Trade Secret China Daily 13 $273.0M The National Foodball League v. Sunmei Jul-13 Trademark Law $240.0M All Pro Sports Camps v. Walt Disney Aug-00 Trade Secret National Law Jrnl 15 $214.0M EchoStar Satellite v. Viewtech Apr-11 Copyright Law $192.0M Mannsfeld v. Ineos Phenol Jan-09 Trade Secret Law $180.0M Burberry PLC et al. v. John Doe 1 et al May-12 Trademark Law $173.0M Philip Morris v. Otamedia Mar-05 Trademark Law $164.0M Tony Burch v. Yong Sheng International Jun-11 Trademark Law $140.7M DSC Communications v. Next Level Comm. Nov-97 Trade Secret Reuters 21 $136.2M Atlantic Recording v. Media Group Oct-03 Copyright National Law Jrnl 22 $134.0M USA Power LLC v Pacific Corp. May-02 Trade Secret blogs.orrick.com 23 $121.7M EchoStar Satellite v. Panarex Nov-10 Copyright Law $118.3M Bancorp Services v. Hartford Life Mar-02 Trade Secret National Law Jrnl 25 $117.0M Qwest Communications v. OneQwest Dec-02 Trademark Recorder $0.0B $0.5B $1.0B $1.5B $2.0B $2.5B 20 *List does not take into account post-trial proceedings and rulings.

22