FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 10/04/ :10 PM INDEX NO /2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 625 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/04/2018

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 10/04/ :10 PM INDEX NO /2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 625 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/04/2018"

Joleen Boone
5 years ago
Views:

1 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK BOARD OF MANAGERS OF 147 WAVERLY PLACE CONDOMINIUM, Plaintiff, Index No /2013 (Masley, J.) KMG WAVERLY, LLC, KMGW, LLC, STIPULATION OF MARATHON WAVERLY, LLC, MARATHON DISCONTINUANCE REAL ESTATE OPPORTUNITY FUND, LLC, (WITH PREJUDICE) BURT MILLER, ERIC GRANOWSKY, STAN KLEGER, RON BERNSTEIN, BKSK ARCHITECTS, LLP, JOAN KREVLIN, GEORGE J. KULIK, P.E., P.C., and GEORGE J. KULIK, Defendants. KMG WAVERLY, LLC, et al., Third-Party Plaintiffs, -against- -against- WAVERLY CC, LLC, et al., Third-Party Defendants. IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND AGREED, by and between the undersigned attorneys for the parties to this action, that whereas no party hereto is an infant, incompetent person for whom a committee has been appointed, or conservatee, and no person not a party has an interest in the subject matter of the action, this action, including all third-party actions, be, and the same hereby is discontinued, with prejudice, and without costs to any party as against any other. This stipulation may be filed with the Clerk of the Court without further notice, may be signed in counterparts, and electronic signanwes on this stipulation shall be 1 of 8

2 originals. Dated: New York, New York Augustp2018 SCHWART7, SLADKUS REICH CYRULI SHANKS HART & ZIZMOR LLP GREENBERG ATLAS LLP Attorneys for Defendants KMG Waverly, LLC, Attorneys for Plaintiff Board of Managers of KMGW, LLC, Marathon Waverly, LLC, 147 Waverly Place Condominium Marathon Real Estate Opportunity Fund, LLC, Eric Granowsky, Stan Kleger, Ron Bernstein, and Burt Miller Jared E. Paioff Jeffrey C. Ruderman 270 Madison Avenue 420 Lexington Avenue, Suite 2320 New York, New York New York, New York (212) (212) OFFIT KURMAN, P.A. SEIGER GFELLER LAURIE LLP Attorneys for Defendant BKSK Architects, LLP Attorneys for Third-Party Defendant Lawrence Exterior Restoration Corp. Alexander Mirkin Mark D. Shifton 10 East 40th Street 100 Overlook Center, 2nd Floor New York, New York Princeton, New Jersey (212) (609) GARTNER + BLOOM P.C. RIVKIN LP Attorneys for Third-Party Defendant Vanguard Attorne fo hird-par a Def ndant Distinct Construction Dry a c. Narriman Subrati Frank Gil berli 801 Second Avenue, 1 l th Floor 926 RXR Plaza New York, New York Unicadale, New York (212) (516) of 8

3 originals. Dated: New York, New York August 2018 SCHWARTZ SLADKUS REICH CYRULI SHANKS HART & ZIZMOR LLP GREENBERG ATLAS LLP Attorneys for Defendants KMG Waverly, LLC, Attorneys for Plaintiff Board of Managers of KMGW, LLC, Marathon Waverly, LLC, 147 Waverly Place Condominium Marathon Real Estate Opportunity Fund, LLC, Eric Granow an Kleger, Ron Bernstein, and Burt dler By Jared E. Paioff Jeffrey C. Ruderman 270 Madison Avenue Lexington Avenue, Suite 2320 New York, New York New York, New York (212) (212) OFFIT KURMAN, P.A. SEIGER GFELLER LAURIE LLP Attorneys for Defendant BKSK Architects, LLP Attorneys for Third-Party Defendant Lawrence Exterior Restoration C rp. / _ Alexander Mirkin 16a D. Sh fron 10 East 40th Street 100 Overlook Center, 2nd Floor New York, New York Princeton, New Jersey (212) (609) GARTNER + BLOOM P.C. RIVKIN RADLER LLP Attorneys for Third-Party Defendant Vanguard Attorneys for Third-Party Defendant Distinct Construction Drywall Inc. Narriman Subrati Frank Giliberti 801 Second Avenue, 11th Floor 926 RXR Plaza New York, New York Uniondale, New York (212) (516) of 8

4 GALLO VITUCCI JOAR LLP ABRAMB, PBNSTERMAN, FENSTERMAN, AttornowfarThirdd'aryDq\ledmt EtBMAN, PORMATO, PBARARA, WOl# A KtheyAututircturalWheds Am, CARONB, ILP Attornow)br SMed-ParyDq(endent Mr hun Waris,Ltd Byr 11teplan Hohinan / Keith J. Singer 90 Broad11tmet, 12* Moor 3 Dakota Drive, Sutto New Yode, New York Lake 8uccess, Now Y By'. (646) (516) ANTHONY P. 0ALLO, P.C. AHMUTY DBMBRS & McMANUS AttormowfbyThird-PartyDepndant Asornowfor TMrd-ParyDrfëndart Zaram gar ca. ina neatrio corp. B..../ Amho P allo Deborah Del Sonio 6080 Jerlaho T)ke., 8ulte Water L68' street, Floor Commack, New York l t725 New Yorft, New York (646) RIloRDANEO SCHBRRHYLAND & HARIUB, ION0, PODERA & CORREIA PERREITI, ILP Anornow forthted1mnt-paryd ndant ANamow)he 2%ndThird-Pary AssentADirtstanof ) homer& Aaectora fjd AcornMire& ark A One 298' Battery Park Pinsa, PI, New Y' New York t0110 New Yodr, New York (212) of 8

5 ANMUTY,DEMERS & MCMANtis, PERRY, VAN SITEN, ROZANSKI A ESQB. PRIMAVARA, LP Attonsepfor Thir&Party Defenfonte, Attornsyt for Third Ird-Party Dqfandant Big Apple Chirung 11CandStarr CMA Mtchant rutruction Corp. Restorationinc. B 't Cind arreehis. F Aa 199 Water - (6th 14oar JSavaed ree 44N¼-(o O / OAO ETEcer, Gk.. ang. New York, New Yd& 1003$ New tock, New Yo (645) 336-$751 (212) OOLDBElto SBOALA LLP LAW OFPICB OFJAMES J. TOOMEY Anarnqatfor ThirdTigird-Pard Defendant Attorn efat thted TNrd-Party Defhndag Innovative Air Bulùtiong,1na. Jarunnr Associate Inc Jomph A.Oliva Robat P.7oma 711 drd Avenue, Wake Lexington AvendeJth Ploor New York. NowYo& New Yodes.New York (d46) 292-B734 (p17) LITCEFIFID CAVO, HP O'TOOLB SCRIVO FERNANDBZ WEINW AttornqaJbrThbdThird-Portø Dqfëndant, VANLEU LLC MidiroadQagra & AGuwork, km AturneysforThtedTNnt-Patyf)efersiant?& H Paintings Jac. By;... Dp) To Rebeat W 4 thrd 420 Aventua; Butla2]04 14 Village Pak Reed NeWYork.New York 1017D Cedar Giove, NJ 0 (212) (973) (I RoaQ480N BR00 C P C 7 & AltersteprprihtrdShinQartypefendant MERL agip.gy Remqua N ytfo ant att fri 87 d 95 Avenue, FL angsplans New York,Nety York 100 5Broadway, Suite 202 (212) New Ysnt. New York (212) $ of 8

6 ANMUTY, DEMBRS & MCMANt JS, PERRY, VAN BTTEN, ROZANSKI & ESQS, PRIMAV.tRA, LLP Attorsep for Bird-f arty Defendents, Attorney for Bird frd40hy Defendant 2tig Apple Chinmey ILC and Starr CMA Mtchant astrtgation-corp. Restorat¼n inc. By L artschik 4.A %. F A 199 Water - (6th lhoor jb8roadetrwet ( O o40 srezr, Gk.. ng. NewYork, New Ydrk 1903$ New tock,.new York; (646) (212) 406,9710 OOLDBEltO SBOALA LLP LAW OPPICB dptames 1 TOOMBY AuornQr fòj Third Titird-Party Defendant.Attotnut fof uted TMrd orty Dgfendag Innouett a Air,86 ' ris, Jno. Jansonr Associates, Inc by:...- Jolgaph A..Oliva Robert7.7umo 711 Third Avenue/Bulta Lexington Avenue, fth Eloor New York, NewYork New Yods, New Yodt (d46) (917) LITCHFIELD CAVO, LLP O'TOOLBSCRIVO FERNANDBZ WHINBR 4itartage for 27ded Ththd-Pirty Dq fendant, VAN.L!EU LLC Ididwood ; oore &46Hwark ñsc, 4tewasyr for TMrd TNrd-Party Defer#nit P & H. 4Del Tom Robant W ifford ' 420 gton Avenue; Suite Village Park Road. New York, NeW York Codir 0mve, NJ (212) (973) ROBlN80N BROG HANNUMEBRBT10 PRENDBRGAST & AtteMay)by Third Sinfrd-Rarty pef ndant MBRLtN3 Afte-We nal Remgval At r TMid TNrd Parly Dqfendant.. d Abramovitz foh Hannurn 87 98' Avenue, FI, Que P4ohango Ploza New York,Nety York 1D0 55 Broadway, Staite 202 (212) Mew York, New YorEl 006 (212) of 8

7 MICHAEL A. MARKOWITZ, P.C. TRAUB LIEBERMAN STRAUS & Attorneys for Third Third-Party Defendant SHREWSBERRY LLP State of the Art Wood Flooring Corp. Attorneys for Third Third-Party Defendant T.C interior Renovation Corp. Michael Å..Markowitz T rarn K k Michael A. Markowitz, P.C. S A 7.Skyline Dñve 1553 Broad way Hawthorne, New York Hewlett, New York I 1557 (914) (516) 295-S061 CAMACHO MAURO MULHOLLAND Damato.& Lynch, LLP LLP Auorneys for Third Third-Party Defendant Attorneys)by Stilrd Third-Party Defendant Amazing Glazing, Inc Thentis ney, Inc Byr en, Mulholland Stephen F. Willig 40 Wall 40* Street; Ploor 225 Liberty Street New York, New York New York, NY (212) (23) of 8

8 MICHAEL A. MARKOWITZ, P.C. TRAUB LIEBERMAN STRAUS & Attorneys for Third Third-Party Defendant SHREWSBERRY LLP State of the Art Wood Flooring Corp. Attorñëys for Third Third-Party Defendant T.C. Interior Renovation Corp. Michael A. Markowitz Kathryn Leigh Hough Michael A. Markowitz, P.C. 7 Skyline Drive 1553 Broadway Hawthorne, New York Hewlett, New York (914) (516) CAMACHO MAURO MULHOLLAND D'Amato & Lynch, LLP LLP Attorneys for Third Third-Party Defendani Attorneys for Third Third-Party Defendant Amazing Glsing, Inc. Themis Chimney, Inc. Kathleen M. Mulholland ebhen F. Willig 40* 40 Wall Street; Floor 225 Liberty Street New York, New York New York, NY (212) (212) of 8

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/16/ :50 AM INDEX NO /2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 614 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/16/2018

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/16/ :50 AM INDEX NO /2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 614 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/16/2018 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK --------------------------------------X THE BOARD OF MANAGERS OF 147 WAVERLY PLACE CONDOMINIUM, Plaintiff, KMG WAVERLY, ~ LLC, ~ KMGW, ~ LLC, I