FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/19/2011 INDEX NO /2010 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 48 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/19/2011

Transcription

1 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/19/2011 INDEX NO /2010 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 48 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/19/2011 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK 110 CENTRAL PARK souni CORPORATION, -against- Plaintiff, 112 CENTRAL P.ARK SOUTH, LLC, J.T. MAGEN & COMPANY, INC., and EPIC MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, LLC, :Defendants. 112 CENTRAL PARK SOUTH, LLC, Third Party Plaintiff, -against- COSTAS KONDYLIS & :PARTNERS, LLC, GOLDSTEIN ASSOCIA.TES, PLLC, I.M. ROBBINS, PC, LASZLO BOD.AK ENGINEER, P.C., CONVENTIONAL STONE & MARBLE CORP., ROSLYN ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES, P.C., INDUSTRIAL WINDOW CORP., DKS CONTRACTORS, INC. d/b/a DKS CONSTRUCTION, GACE CONSULTING ENGINEER.S, P.C., INNOVATIVE CARPENT.RY, NAST.ASI & ASSOCIATES, INC., CARDRONA., INC., PIERMONT IRON WORK, INC., RAEL SPRINKLER, AMERICAN SPRAY-ON CORP.,.AVA SHAPULA CONSULTING, CENTRAL ENVIRONMENTAL, and ASHLAND :PLUMBING CORP. ailsla ASHLAND DESIGN, Third Party Defendants. X INDUSTRIAI, WINDOW CORP., Fourth Party :Plaintiff, -again.st- X REPLY To CROSS-CLAIM AGAINST THIRD PARTY DEFENDANT ASHLAND PLUMBING CORP. Us/h/a ASHLAND PLUMBING CORP. anda ASHLAND DESIGN Index No.: /10 CLERKS OFFICE. Third Party Indexi No.: DEC 1 4 ititi t(y 1 VP"FlirpQMPA vk,11..t.i.1 cow DeMAYO CONSTRUCTION, INC., Fourth Party Defendant. Third Party Defendant ASHLAND PLUMBING CORP. ils/hla ASHLAND plumbing CORP. ailla ASHLAND DESIGN (hereinafter "third party defendant ASHLAND") by its r 1

2 attorneys MORRISON MAHONEY LLP as and for its REPLY TO CROSS-CLAIM AGAINST THIRD PARTY DEFENDANT ASHLAND :PLUMBING CORP, i/s/hia ASHLAND PLUMBING CORP. a/k/a ASHLAND DESIGN by defendant EPIC MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, LLC sets forth the.following: Third party. defendant ASHLAND denies the allegations contained in paragraph I of defendant EPIC MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, LIX's Cross-Claim, Third party defendant ASHLAND denies the allegations contained i.n paragraph 2 of defendant EPIC MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, LLC's Cross-Claim, 3 Third party defendant.a.shland denies the allegations contained in paragraph 3 of defendant EPIC MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, LLC's Cross-Claim. 4. Third party defendant.a.shland denies the allegations contained in paragraph 4 of defendant EPIC MECHANICAL CONTRACT-ORS, LLC's Cross-Claim. WHEREFORE, third. party defendant ASHLAND PLUMBING CORP. iisthia A.SHLAND PLUMBING CORP. aikia. ASHLAND DESIGN dernand.s judgment dismissing plaintiff's Complaint, the Verified Amended Third Party Complaint, all cross-claims herein, together with interest, costs and disbursements in the defense of this matter. Dated: New York, NeW York December 12, 2011 Yours, etc,, MORRISON MAHONEY LIP Attorneys for Third Pty. Deft. ASHLAND PLUMBING CORP. ilsil/a ASHLAND PLUMBING CORP. ailea ASHLAND DESIGN and CONVENTIONAL STONE & MARBLE CO. BY: / Sha owerson 17 Rate 4yeet, - Suite File: v 1

3 TO: BRUCE R. CONNOLLY, ESQ. RAISER & KENNIFF Attorneys for Defendant EPIC MECHANICAL 1517 Franklin Avenue ---- Suite 300 Mineola NY Fax: JOHN E. HANNUM, ESQ. HANNUM FERETIC PRENDERGAST & MERLIN, :LAX Attorneys for Defendant JT MAGEN 55 Broadway -- Suite 202 New York NY VIARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & COGGIN Attorneys for Defendant/Third Pty. Plaintiff 112 CENTRAL PARK SOUTH, LLC 425 Eagle Rock Avenue --- Suite 302 Roseland NJ SAY R. FIALKOFF, ESQ. MOSES & SINGER, LLP Attorneys for Plaintiff 110 CENTRAL P 405 Lexington Avenue New York NY K. SO "IH DOUGLAS R. HALSTROM, ESQ..L'ABBATE, BALKAN, COLAVITA & CONTINI, LLP Attorneys for Third Party Defts, GOLDSTEIN, I.M. ROBBINS GACE CONSULTING and I.M..R0I3BINS, PC 1001 Franklin Avenue Garden Czity NY CARL M. PERRI, ESQ. CLAUSEN MILLER, P.C. Attorneys for Third Party Deft. ROSLYN ENGINEERING One Chase Manhattan Plaza th Floor New York NY v I

4 ANDREW M. LAURI, ESQ. CASCONE & -KIX:EITEL LLP Attorneys for INNOVATIVE CARPENTRY 1399 Franklin Avenue Suite 302 Garden City NY GREGORY J. SPAUN, ESQ. WELRY BRADY & GREENBLA.TT, LLP Attorneys for Third Party Defendant/Fourth Party. PlaintifT INDUSTRIAL WINDOW 11 Martine Avenue White Plains NY AHMUTY DEMERS & Mc:MANUS Attorneys for Fourth Party Defendant DeMAY0 CONSTRUCTION 200 I.U. Willets Road.A.lbertson. 'NY WHITE FLEISCHNER & FINO, LIP Attorneys for Third Party :Defendant RAEL AUTOMATIC SPRINKLER 61 Broadway - 8th Floor New York :NY GOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP Attorneys for Third Party Defendant AVA SHYPULA 200 Old Country Road -- Suite 21() Mineola NY DI :(S CONTRAC17ORS, INC. d/b/a DKS Corporation 130 West 30 th Street 13 th Floor New York NY LA.SZLO BODAK ENGINEERING, P.C. 45 West 36 th Street - ri Floor New York :NY COSTAS KONDYLIS & PARTNERS, LLC c/o Kond.ylis Architecture, P.C. 115 Fifth Avenue New 'York NY '717vi

5 AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL state OF NEW YORK ) ss.. COUNTY OF NEW YORK ) Ne v York. Kim Cuomo Biondi, having been duly sworn, says: That she is n.ot a party to the within action, is over the age of 18, and resides in Brooklyn., That on the 13 th day of December, 2011 she served th.e within REPLY TO CROSS- CLAIM AGALNST THIRD PARTY DEF ENDANT ASHLAND PLUMBING CORP, i/s/hia ASHLAND PLUMBING CORP. a/k/a.ashland DESIGN upon: See attached rider by depositing a true copy of same in a postage-paid, properly addressed., wrapper and plac:ing it under the exclusive care of the United States Postal Service via First Class Mail. Sworn to before me this 13 th day of December, 2011 Kim Cuomo Bioncli Notary Public v]

6 BRUCE R. CONNOLLY, ESQ. RAISER. & KENNIFF Attorneys for Defendant EPIC MEC:HANICAL 1517 Franklin Avenue Suite 300 Mineola NY : Fax: 5: RIDER JOHN E. HANNUM, ESQ. HANNUM FERETIC PRENDERGAST & MERLIN, LLC Attorneys for Defendant JT MAGEN 55 Broadway Suite 202 New York NY MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGEN Attorneys for DefendantiThird Pty. Plaintiff 112 CENTRAL PARK SOUTH, LLC 425 Eagle Rock Avenue Suite 302 Roseland Nj JAY R. FIALKOFF, ESQ. MOSES & SINGER, LLP Attorneys for Plaintiff 110 CENTRAL PARK SOU 405 Lexington Avenue New York NY DOUGLAS R. HALSTROM, ESQ. L'ABBATE, BALKAN, COLAVITA & CONFINE, LLP Attorneys for 'Third Party Dens. GOLDSTEIN, I.M. ROBBINS GACE CONSULTING and FM. ROBBINS, PC 1001 Franklin Avenue Garden City NY CARL Ni. : PERRI, ESQ. CLA.USEN MILLER, P.C. :Attorneys for Third Party Deft. ROSLYN.ENGINEER1NG One Chase Manhattan Plaza 39 th Floor New York NY v1

7 ANDREW :M. LAURI, ESQ. CASCONE & KLUEPFEL, LLP Attorneys for INNOVATIVE CARPENTRY 1399 Franklin Avenue Suite 302 Garden City NY GREGORY. J. SPAUN, ESQ. WELBY.BRADY & GREENBLATT, LLP.Attorneys for Third Party Defendant/Fourth Party Plaintiff INDUSTRIAL WINDOW 11 Martine Avenue White Plain.s NY AHM.UTY DEMERS & McMANUS Attorneys for Fourth Party Defendant DeMAY0 CONSTRUCTION 200 I.U. Willets Road Albertson NY WHITE FLEISCHNER & FINO, LLP Attorneys for Third Party Defendant :RAU AUTOMATIC SPRINKLER 61 Broadway 8 th Floor New York NY GOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP Attorneys for Third Party Defendant AVA. SHYPULA d Country Road - Suite 210 Mineola. NY idks CONTRACTORS, INC. dibia DKS Corporation 130 West 30 th Street 13' 11 Floor New York. NY LASZLO BODAK ENGINEERING, P.C. 45 West 36' 1' Street 31'1Floor New York NY COSTAS KONDYLIS & :PARTNERS, LLC do Kondylis.Architecture, P.C Fifth Avenue New York NY vt