UNIVERSITI MALAYSIA PERLIS

Transcription

1 UNIVERSITI MALAYSIA PERLIS PIT 26-A CENTRE FOR GRADUATE STUDIES LAPORAN PENILAIAN TESIS PENUKARAN STATUS MSc ke PhD THESIS EVALUATION REPORT CHANGE OF STATUS MSc to PhD Nama Calon Candidate s Name Pusat Pengajian/Pusat School of/centre Ijazah / Degree Tajuk Tesis / Thesis Title Nama Panel Panel s Name PANDUAN MENGISI BORANG LAPORAN PANEL PENILAI Borang Laporan Pemeriksa Tesis ini terdiri daripada Empat (4) Bahagian iaitu: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) BAHAGIAN A : GAYA DAN PENYUSUNAN KESELURUHAN BAHAGIAN B : KOMEN BAHAGIAN C : PENERBITAN DAN ANUGERAH (JIKA ADA) BAHAGIAN D : PERAKUAN Panel adalah dipohon menilai laporan pelajar bagi menepati tahap ijazah Doktor Falsafah INSTRUCTIONS FOR COMPLETING THE EVALUATION PANEL REPORT The Thesis Examiner s Report Form consists of Four (4) Sections: (i) SECTION A : OVERALL STYLE AND ORGANISATION (ii) SECTION B : COMMENT (iii) SECTION C : PUBLICATION AND AWARD (IF ANY) (ii) SECTION D : RECOMMENDATION Panels are required to assess the student s report to meet the standard for Doctor of Philosophy UniMAP/UIT/PIT26 1

2 BAHAGIAN A / SECTION A Sila nyatakan respons anda dengan membulatkan nombor yang paling sesuai. Sila nyatakan, jika tidak releven. Please indicate your response by circling the most appropriate number. Please state not relevant, where appropriate. GAYA DAN PENYUSUNAN KESELURUHAN OVERALL STYLE AND ORGANISATION Amat tidak sesuai Not appropriate at all Amat sesuai Most appropriate 1. Dari segi kandungan, tajuk tesis adalah In terms of contents, the thesis title is Amat tidak jelas Not clear at all 2. Dari segi kejelasan penyampaian, laporan ini In terms of clarity of presentation, the report is Amat jelas Very clear UniMAP/UIT/PIT26 2

3 KEKUKUHAN LAPORAN ROBUSTNESS OF REPORT Amat tidak tepat Not accurate at all Amat tepat Most accurate 7. Istilah yang digunakan The terminology used is Amat tidak tepat Not accurate at all Amat tepat Most accurate 8. Tinjauan bacaan adalah The literature review is Amat tidak jelas Not clear at all Amat jelas Most robust 9. Objektif kajiannya Research objectives are UniMAP/UIT/PIT26 3

4 Amat tidak jelas Not clear at all Amat jelas Most robust 10. Metodologi adalah The methodology is Amat tidak mencukupi Not adequate at all 11. Data yang dikutip untuk analisis dan pengukuran The data collected for the analysis and testing are Most adequate Amat tidak mencukupi Not adequate at all Most adequate 12 Analisis kuantitatif (statistik)/kualitatif The quantitative (statistical)/qualitative analysis is UniMAP/UIT/PIT26 4

5 Amat tidak sesuai Not appropriate at all Amat sesuai Most appropriate 13. Interprestasi data/maklumat dan kesimpulan Data/information interpretation and conclusion are 14. Hubungan perbincangan dengan penemuan kajian The discussion corresponds to the result of the study Amat tidak berkaitan Did not correspond at all Amat berkaitan Corresponds very well Amat tidak mencukupi Not adequate at all Most adequate 15. Perbincangannya The discussion is UniMAP/UIT/PIT26 5

6 Amat tidak mencukupi Not adequate at all Most adequate 16. Bahan rujukan References are Amat tidak terkini Not up-to-date at all Most up-to-date 17. Kekemaskinian bahan rujukan References are Amat tidak asli Not original at all 18. Kajian adalah The research is Amat asli Very original UniMAP/UIT/PIT26 6

7 BAHAGIAN B / SECTION B KOMEN COMMENT.. UniMAP/UIT/PIT26 7

8 BAHAGIAN C / SECTION C PENERBITAN DAN ANUGERAH (JIKA ADA) PUBLICATION AND AWARD (IF ANY) BAHAGIAN D / SECTION D PERAKUAN RECOMMENDATION Sila catatkan ringkasan perakuan di bawah dengan menandakan ( )di dalam perenggan yang berkaitan : Please indicate your summary recommendation by placing a tick ( ) against the appropriate paragraph : Ringkasan Perakuan / Summary Recommendation 1. Calon diperakukan untuk menukar taraf ijazah Sarjana kepada ijazah Doktor Falsafah The candidate is recommended to change the status of Master s Degree to Doctoral degree.. 2. Calon tidak diperakukan untuk menukar taraf ijazah Sarjana kepada ijazah Doktor Falsafah. The candidate is not recommended to change the status of Master s Degree to Doctoral degree Tandatangan / Signature Tarikh/ Date UniMAP/UIT/PIT26 8