Demand inspired research in offshore wind energy systems Jos Beurskens We@Sea / ECN www.we-at at-sea.org / www.ecn.nl
This presentation We@Sea programme and experiences Update R&D top priorities based on recent developments
We@Sea Initiated by ECN and TUDelft and designed in cooperation with relevant partners from all relevant sectors (2002 2004) Bridging gap between WE sector s s optimism and the offshore sector s s skepticism Awareness needed for policy measures Create opportunities for the industry R&D topics inspired by demand
We@Sea consortium R&D Establishments ECN windenergie, TNO TU-Delft WMC BV environment, nature & safety Bureau Waardenburg / Alterra-Texel / NIOZ Greenpeace RIVO St.Noordzee University Twente wind turbine manufacturers GE wind energy Vestas NL, (NEG Micon) offshore technology Ballast Nedam Fabricom Fugro Engineers BV Genius Vos IHC GustoMSC Lloyd s Register NL Smart Tower project developers E-connection, E-concern (Evelop( Evelop) Shell Wind Energy BV wind energy technology Multiwind BV Rheden Steel Siemens energy consultants: Kema Power Ecofys energy sector Delta Nuts BV ENECO Nuon Statkraft TenneT logistics and harbour development STC financiers NIB Capital Bank
Offshore WE technology: What makes it different from land based applications? Cost breakdown External conditions (waves, salt conditions, turbulence, extreme winds, water currents, (sea) bottom morphology) Support structures Transport and assembly Commissioning Operation and maintenance/access Grid integration Nature issues & safety Specific offshore research
We@Sea s research lines and topics M 5.7 M 0.7 M 2,9 M 7.2 M 4.1 M 6,3 M 1.3 M 1.2 M 4.3 integration & scenario s In red: original budgets
We@Sea in perspective Wind contributes 16% to RE target 2020 9000 MW 7500 MW (= 45 PJ) 6000 MW OWEZ Q7 09-2008: 2000 MW offshore on land 3000 MW 1500 MW 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030 Note: The energy-unit [PJ] refers to fossil fuels being replaced.
Objectives, critical issues and We@Sea s research lines and topics Technology Grid connection Transport Installation O&M Financing PPA Scenario s Integration Ecology Spatial Planning Know Know how how transfer transfer
Topics and clusters of projects; Technology Technology Transport Assembly Commissioning Grid connection O&M EIA Legal issues Financing PPA Design tools Standards LCA, end-of of-life solutions 1. Loads (extremes) 2. Tools (frequency domain analysis) 3. Monitoring and Verification of design tools (Beatrice) 4. Materials for very large blades & fatigue characteristics 5. Control for stability Presentation 6. Flow dynamics in & around wind farms PhD PhD Presentation Multi-functionality 1. Multipurpose facilities at sea
Topics and clusters of projects; Transport, Installation, O&M Transport, Technology Transport Assembly Commissioning Grid connection O&M EIA Legal issues Financing PPA Transport, Installation O&M PhD PhD 1. Integrated Transport & Installation 1. O&M cost estimator and optimising operations (Load monitoring (optical methods), Flight leader concept) 2. Access technology Presentation Presentation Safety 1. Safety (HSE, nautical) Presentation Port development
Topics and clusters of projects; Grid connection Technology Wind farm as an electricity plant 1. Modeling Presentation Grid connection Transport Assembly Commissioning O&M Financing PPA EIA Legal issues Grid connection PhD 1. Interconnectors 2. System integration (balancing & stability) Presentation
Topics and clusters of projects; Spatial planning, Ecology Technology Transport Assembly Commissioning Grid connection O&M Site atlas Morphology PhD PhD 1. Site data for design 2. Site data for planning 3. GIS based methodology to forecast changes in marine environment 1. Sand waves and banks Financing PPA EIA Legal issues Ecological impacts & monitoring methods 1. Monitoring equipment bird migration, bird collisions, sea mammal 2. Impact studies: : grey seals, sea birds (hearing sensitivity seals) Presentation Ecological design of wind farms
Topics and clusters of projects; Financing & markets Technology Financing & markets Effects of LS offshore WE on electricity markets Effects of LS storage island Presentation Grid connection Transport Assembly Commissioning O&M Financing PPA EIA Legal issues Accidents & incidents characteristics
The deployment of WE at present 1470 MW installed 1770 MW under construction > 30,000 MW under consideration 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Source: TUDelft Offshore Engineering
The deployment of WE at presnt Shell-NUON 36 x Vestas 3MW V90 108MW 10 18 km from the coast 18 m water depth Monopiles 70 m above sea level, 30 m into seabed total investment appr. M 260 Photo: Jos Beurskens (We@Sea( We@Sea) OWEZ 1470 MW installed 1770 MW under construction E-Connection Evelop 60 Vestas 2 MW V80 120 MW 23 km from coast 19-24 m water depth mono piles total investment appr. M 380 Q7 Photo: Jos Beurskens (We@Sea( We@Sea) 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Source: TUDelft Offshore Engineering
Acceleration of offshore activities EWEA S S three wind power scenarios (in GW) Source: EWEA
Acceleration of offshore activities EU: M 500
Acceleration of offshore activities 10 Installed offshore wind powe GW We@Sea; Jos Beurskens 7,5 6 5 2,5 0,928 0,228 2010 2015 2020 2025 Physical and ecological reference measurements Sufficient dedicated vessels available Harbour facilities on land Harbour-at-sea Offshore electricity gris with multiple feed in points Large scale storage operational Dedicated offshore wind turbine proven and operational No shortage of specialised personnel Laws and regulations in place ( financial incentives (>10 years), EIA s, etc.. Management centre
R&D Top priorities, both public and private Based on: We@Sea experiences European TPWind Consultations of 1. Wind turbine manufacturers 2. Offshore contractors, designers, operators 3. Project designers 4. Financiers 5. Governmental authorities
Wind power technology Update of industrial needs Verification of designs and design tools (monitoring data needed!!!) Integration of design tools with offshore industry s methods Dedicated offshore concepts (Stepwise) testing of new concepts under full offshore conditions Onshore commissioning methods Decommissioning (end of life) solutions
Future concepts; some aspects Very large turbines & High speed rotors & down wind (acoustic noise and visual impact is no issue (2-bladed? 1-bladed?)) Photo: Jos Beurskens Photo: Jos Beurskens
Update of industrial needs Offshore operations (transport, installation, commissioning, O&M) Vessel capacity; designs, standardisation of docking interfaces? Integration of design tools with wind turbine industry s methods Commissioning methods/standards Series or batch wise production of foundations O&M optimisation (reliability, access, condition monitoring, logistics) Operational data feed back needed!!!!!!!!!
......................... Optimisation O&M 12 miles zone heliport haven We@Sea Jos Beurskens Various options for interventions at sea, depending of the type of activity..............................................
Optimisation O&M Fuel consumption per service mission Docking performance Jos Beurskens Service round trip time Photo: Chris Westra (We&Sea We&Sea) Photo: Jos Beurskens (We@Sea We@Sea) Access technology Cost optimum Standardisation? Photo: RePower
Transport and installation GustoMSC Ballast Nedam
Optimisation O&M Access technology Optical fibres in blades Data logger in hub Strain, Loads, Spectra, etc. 1) Failure behaviour and maintainability 2) Characterisation of access and hoisting systems 3) Characterisation of weather conditions - wind - waves - lightning - visibility Wind speed, Pitch angle Power PC for control and alarm Corrective Maintenance (Probabilistic Model) Preventive Maintenance Fibre Optic Blade Monitoring Results - High availability - Low price per kwh Optimisation Additional results Waiting time Cost drivers Recommendations for improvement Flight leader concept From: Braam, Rademakers. ECN
Update of industrial needs Grid connection Offshore grid (European concept, modular, use interconnectors) Electrical architecture high capacity (> 1000 MW) connectors suited for multi feed in connection Market design (Who plans? Who pays? Who builds?)
Offshore WE grid Offshore grid based on interconnectors x x x Source: Airtricity
Update of industrial needs Ecology, Spatial planning Cumulative effects (+ & -) (birds, sea mammals, fish) Methods & Monitoring. (International exchange of data!!!!!!) Ship safety Harmonisation of Spatial Planning between North Sea states Optimise EIA requirements and procedures (lean and efficient) Monitoring methods and interpretation of data Nature friendly design methods wind farms
Nature issues & safety Environmental Aspects from Strategic Environmental Assessments USA D Geology, seabed sediments, and sediment transport Marine and coastal processes Cables and pipelines Seabed contamination Military activities and radar Water quality Disposal areas Protected sites and species Shipping and navigation Benthic ecology Tourism and recreation Fish and shellfish Noise Marine birds Electromagnetic fields Marine mammals Seascape and viewshed Coastal fisheries Onshore grid connection Historic places and structures Decommissioning NL Source: Bonnie Ram
Automatic monitoring Chris Westra Birds (migration, collisions) Development of environmental effects monitoring equipment Bird collision detection ECN Birds flight detection radar TNO Marine mammals (sound during installation and operation) TNO
Thank you for your attention! www.we-at at-sea.org