Calculating in floating sexagesimal place value notation, 4000 years ago

Transcription

1 Calculating in floating sexagesimal place value notation, 4000 years ago Christine Proust Laboratoire SPHère (CNRS & Université Paris-Diderot) ARITH nd Symposium on Computer Arithmetic Lyon June 22-24, 2015

2

3 François Thureau-Dangin ( ) 1938 Textes Mathématiques Babyloniens. Otto Neugebauer ( ) Mathematische Keilschrifttexte I Neugebauer & Sachs, 1945 Mathematical Cuneiform Texts.

4 School tablet from Nippur, Old Babylonian period (HS 217a, University of Jena)

5 HS 217a Multiplication table by :3 8 1:12 9 1: : : : : :6 15 2: : : : : : : a-ra x9 = 180 = 3x60 In base 60 : 3:0 But the scribes wrote: 3 This is puzzling. 20x9 is written 3 20x9 = 3 The square of 30 is written 15 30x30 = 15 The square root of 15 is written 30

6 (Sachs 1947) Is the lack of graphical systems to determine the place of the unit in the number an imperfection of the cuneiform script?

7 yes The algorithm for reciprocals according to Abraham Sachs (1947)

8 no

9 Scribal schools in Old Babylonian period (ca BCE) Scribal school in Nippur

10 The curriculum at Nippur Level Elementary Intermediate Content Metrological lists: capacities, weights, surfaces, lengths Metrological tables: capacities, weights, surfaces, lengths, heights Numerical tables: reciprocals, multiplications, squares Tables of square roots and cube roots Exercises: multiplications, reciprocals, surface and volume calculations

11 School tablet from Nippur, Old Babylonian period (Ist Ni 5376, Istanbul) A list of proverbs 1. Someone who cannot produce "a-a, from where will he achieve fluent speech? 2. A scribe who does not know Sumerian -- from where will he produce a translation? 3. The scribe skilled in counting is deficient in writing. The scribe skilled in writing is deficient in counting. 4. A chattering scribe. Its guilt is great. 5. A junior scribe is too concerned with feeding his hunger; he does not pay attention to the scribal art. 6. A disgraced scribe becomes a priest.

12 Metrological lists capacity weight School tablet from Nippur, Old Babylonian period (HS 249, University of Jena) surface length

13 Metrological lists: measurements of capacity School tablet from Nippur, Old Babylonian period (HS 1703, University of Jena) 1/3 sila 1/2 sila 2/3 sila 5/6 sila 1 sila 1 1/3 sila 1 1/2 sila 1 2/3 sila 1 5/6 sila 2 sila 3 sila 4 sila 5 sila 6 sila 7 sila 8 sila 9 sila 1 ban še 1 ban 1 sila 1 ban 2 sila 1 ban 3 sila 3 1 sila ca. 1 liter 1 ban ca. 10 liters

14 1 šusi 10 2 šusi 20 3 šusi 30 4 šusi 40 5 šusi 50 6 šusi 1 7 šusi 1:10 8 šusi 1:20 9 šusi 1:30 1/3 kuš 1:40 1/2kuš 2:30 2/3 kuš 3:20 5/6 kuš 4:10 1 kuš 5 1 1/3 kuš 6:40 1 1/2kuš 7:30 1 2/3 kuš 8:20 2 kuš 10 1 šusi = 1 finger, ca. 1.6 cm 1 kuš = 1 cubit, ca. 50 cm School tablet from Nippur, Old Babylonian period (HS 241, University of Jena)

15 Reciprocals Multiplication tables by :26: : : : :20 8 7:30 7:12 7 6: :30 4 3:45 3:20 3 2:30 2:24 2 1:40 1:30 1:20 1:15 Table of squares Numerical tables School tablet from Nippur, Old Babylonian period (Ist Ni 2733, Istanbul Museum)

16 School tablet from unknown provenance, Old Babylonian period (MS 3874, Schøyen collection, copy Friberg) Table of reciprocals :30 9 6: : : : : :13: :52: : : : : : :6: :4 56:15 1:21 44:26:40

17 The division by a number was performed by mean of the multiplication by the reciprocal of this number = 5 2 = :26:40 = 2 1:21 = 2: :30 9 6: : : : : :13: :52: : : : : : :6: :4 56:15 1:21 44:26:40

18 Multiplying

19 Reciprocal 17:46:40 Its reciprocal 3:22:30 ==================== 17:46:40 [9] 2:40 22:[30] 3:22:[30] A chattering scribe, his guilt is great A chattering scribe, his guilt is great ====================== 17:46:40 9 1:30*

20 Calculation of surface SPVN !.40 1/3 kuš 3 3 šu-si its side Its surface what? Its surface 13 še igi-4! gal 2 še ============== Metrological notations Ni 18 School tablet from Nippur Istanbul Museum

21 Multiplication table (SPVN) Table of surfaces SPVN surface measure Table of lengths length measures SPVN

22 School tablets from Nippur Extract of metrological table for lengths 6 šu-si 1 7 šu-si šu-si šu-si / 3 kuš / 3 kuš 3 1 šu-si / 3 kuš 3 2 šu-si 2 1 / 3 kuš 3 3 šu-si / 3 kuš 3 4 šu-si 2.20 Extract of metrological table for surfaces 1 / 3 sar 20 1 / 2 sar 30 2 / 3 sar 40 5 / 6 sar 50 1 sar / 3 sar / 2 sar / 3 sar / 6 sar 1.50 Extract of table of squares 2 times times times times times times times times times times times SPVN SPVN Metrological notations Metrological notations SPVN

23 The algorithm for reciprocal Obverse 4:26:40 Its reciprocal 13:30 ============== reverse 4:26: * 1:30 13:30 *error of the scribe: he wrote 41 instead of 40

24 :30 9 6: : : : : :13: :52: : : : : : :6: :4 56:15 1:21 44:26:40 4:26: :30 13:30 4:26:40 ends with the regular number 6:40, so 4:26:40 is "divisible" by 6:40. To divide 4:26:40 by 6:40, we must multiply 4:26:40 by the reciprocal of 6:40. The reciprocal of 6:40 is 9. The number 9 is placed in the right hand column. 4:26:40 multiplied by 9 is 40, thus, 40 is the quotient of 4:26:40 by 6:40. This quotient is placed in the left hand column. The reciprocal of 40 is 1:30. The number 1:30 is placed in the right hand olumn. To find the reciprocal of 4:26:40, one only has to multiply the reciprocals of the factors of 4:26:40, that is to say, the numbers 9 and 1:30 placed in the right hand column. This product is 13:30, the reciprocal sought.

25 :30 9 6: : : : : :13: :52: : : : : : :6: :4 56:15 1:21 44:26:40 4:26: :30 13:30 Left hand column: 4:26:40 = 6:40 40 Right hand column 9 1:30 = 13:30

26

27 CBS 1215 Obverse: 3 columns, # 1-16 Reverse: 3 columns, #16-21 Provenance: unknown Datation: OB period (ca BCE) University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia Publication: Sachs 1947, Babylonian Mathematical Texts 1 Copy Robson 2000: 14 Entries

28 CBS 1215: transliteration Obverse (columns from left to right) Reverse (columns from right to left) colonne I colonne II colonne III # #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 #7 # [36] [1.40] sic sic [2] [40] 1.30 [27] # # #11 36 sic.2 sic [30] [16] 3.4[5] [1.41.1]5 4 [6.45] 1.20 [9] 6.40 [8.53].20 [35.33].20 #12 [1].11.6.[40] [30] [5] [5] [8.5]3.[20] # [18] * [16] [6.40] [2.2]2.13.[20] # [9] [2.30] 16 3.[45] [12.3] [2] [25.18].45* [16] [6.45] [1.20] [9] [6.40] [8] [ ] [ ] #15 [9.28].53.[20] [18] [1.30] [4.16] [3.45] [16] [3.45] 14.3.[45] [2]1.5.3[7.30] [6.19.4]1.15 [4] [ ]* [16] [6.45] [1.20] [9] [6.40] [ ] 2.[ ] 9.[ ] # [46.40] [9] [ ] [1.30] 4.[16] [3.45] 16 [3.45] [14].3. [45] [ ] [ ] [2] [ ] [4] (suite sur le revers) colonne III colonne II colonne I # [30] [5] [45] 16 3.[45] 1[4.3.4] [3.4] [30] [5] * * [16] 6.45 [1.20] 9 [6.40] #19 [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] 16 [3.45] 14.[3.45] 5[ ] 1.18 sic.6.[ ] [41.15] [4] 1.[3] * [16] [25].18.45* 1[6] [6].45 1.[20] [9] [3.20] [20] # [9] [2.44] * * [40] #16 (suite) [ * 16] [ ] [9 6.40] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] #17 [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ * 16] [ * 16] [ ] 9 [6.40] [ ] [20] [20] # [3.45] 14.[3.45] 5.16.[ ] [ ] [ * 16] [ * 16] [ ] [9 6.40] 8.[53.20] 2.2[ ] [33.20] [6.40]

29 :30 9 6: : : : : :13: :52: : : : : : :6: :4 56:15 1:21 44:26:40 CBS 1215 #1 2: :24 28:48 1: :40 2:5 2: :24 28:48 1: :40 2:5 The factorization of 2:5 appears in the left column: 2:5 5 = 25 The factorization of the reciprocal of 2:5 appears in the right hand column: 12 2:24 = 28:48 The reciprocal of 2:5 is thus 28:48.

30 :30 9 6: : : : : :13: :52: : : : : : :6: :4 56:15 1:21 44:26:40 CBS 1215 #

31 :30 9 6: : : : : :13: :52: : : : : : :6: :4 56:15 1:21 44:26:40 CBS 1215 #20: iteration Transcription Copy [Robson 2000, p. 23] [9] [2.44] * * [40]

32 :30 9 6: : : : : :13: :52: : : : : : :6: :4 56:15 1:21 44:26:40 Transcription 5:3:24:26:40 [9] 45:30:40 1:30 1:8:16 3:45 4:16 3: :45 14:3:45 5[2:44]:3:45 1:19:6:5:37:30 11:51:54:50:37: :43:49:41:15 4 1:34:55:18: :18: :45 1:20 9 6:[40] 8:53:20 2:2:22:2:13: 20 37:55:33:20 2:31:42:13:20 5:3:24:26:40 Explanation: n 5:3:24:26:40 Factors of n factors of inv(n) 6: : : : :45 Products 14:3:45 5[2:44]:3:45 1:19:6:5:37:30 11:51:54:50:37:30 n 11:51:54:50:37: : : :20 9 6:[40] Products 8:53:20 2:22:13: 20 37:55:33:20 2:31:42:13:20 5:3:24:26:40 Left hand column: 5:3:24:26:40 = 6: Right hand column: 9 1:30 3:45 3:45 3:45 = 11:51:54:50:37:30

33 Aspects of CBS 1215: Paradigmatic examples: Calculation performed on common values (2.5 and doubles) that provide the ability to control the outputs, known in advance. The execution of the algorithm is guided by a codified layout: the layout of the numbers indicates the nature of the operation carried out and the meaning of the calculations. The implementation of the reverse algorithm illustrates the property "the reciprocal of a reciprocal of a number is this number itself."

34 Abstract numbers are not quantities, but calculation tools L algorithme d inversion selon l interprétation d Abraham Sachs (1947)

35 Plimpton 322 Columbia University, New York Old Babylonian period Provenience unknown (probably Southern Mesopotamia) 59,30 1,24,30 1 Sexagesimal number = number with finite sexagesimal development Sexagesimal rectangle = length, width and diagonal are represented by sexagesimals numbers Diagonal rule = Pythagorean rule

36 The square (takiltum) of the diagonal (from) which 1 is torn out (i.e. subtracted) and (that of) the width comes up. width diagonal Line n δ² 1 = β² δ 2 b d obv I' II' III' IV' 1 ta-k ]I- il- ti şi - li - ip - tim íb.si 8 sag íb.si 8 şi-li-ip-tim mu.bi.im 2 ša 1 in ]-na-as-sà-hu-ú-ma sag i- [il ]-lu-ú ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki 15 β b δ 1 d l l

37 The square of the diagonal (from) which 1 is torn out (i.e. subtracted) and (that of) the width comes up. I II III IV width diagonal line 1,59,0,15 1,59 2,49 n 1 1,59,0,15 1,24,30² 1 1² = 59,0,15 59,30² 1 1² + 59,0,15 59,30² = 1,59,0,15 1,24,30² 59,30 1,24,30 1,59 2,49 1 Unit rectangle Reduced rectangle

38 δ = ½(r/s + s/r) β = ½(r/s - s/r) We have: δ 2 - β² = 1 1<r/s < 1+ 2 (<2;25) r is a regular number s is a 1-place regular number r/s is irreducible txt r /s = in descending order txt r /s = in descending order No s r r/s = α s/r = 1/ α No s r r/s = α s/r = 1/ α β List of all the values of r/s (John Britton according to Price 1964)

39 β δ δ 2 = 1+β 2 b d N o [-I'] [0'] I' II' III' IV' sag şi-li-ip-tum ta]-ki-il-ti şi-li-ip - tim íb.si 8 sag íb.si 8 şi-li-ip-tim mu.bi.im šá 1 in]-na-as-šà-hu-ú-ma sag i-[il-lu]-ú ki ki ki ki ki ki 6 obv ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki 17 lo.e ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki 26 rev ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki 37 u.e ki 38 Reconstruction of complete tablet, by John Britton

40 A B :4 1:12 1:15 1:20 1:21 1:30 1:36 1:40 1:48 2:

41 A = 1-place value regular numbers + 2-place value regular numbers until 2:5 B = 1-place value regular numbers C = {a/b, a є A and b є B} = {{1},{2},{3},{4},{5},{6},{8},{9},{10},{12},{15},{16},{18},{20},{2 4},{25},{27},{30},{32},{36},{40},{45},{48},{50},{54},{1,4},{1, 12},{1,15},{1,20},{1,21},{1,30},{1,36},{1,40},{1,48},{2,5},{2, 8},{2,15},{2,24},{2,30},{2,40},{2,42},{3,12},{3,20},{3,36},{3, 45},{4,3},{4,10},{4,16},{4,30},{4,48},{5,20},{5,24},{6,15},{6, 24},{6,40},{6,45},{7,12},{7,30},{8,6},{8,20},{9,36},{10,25},{ 10,40},{10,48},{11,15},{12,30},{12,48},{13,20},{13,30},{14, 24},{16,12},{16,40},{18,45},{19,12},{20,15},{20,50},{21,20},{21,36},{22,30},{26,40},{28,48},{31,15},{32,24},{33,20},{3 3,45},{37,30},{38,24},{40,30},{41,40},{42,40},{43,12},{53,2 0},{56,15},{57,36},{1,2,30},{1,4,48},{1,6,40},{1,7,30},{1,16, 48},{1,23,20},{1,25,20},{1,26,24},{1,33,45},{1,37,12},{1,41, 15},{1,46,40},{1,52,30},{1,55,12},{2,1,30},{2,9,36},{2,13,20 },{2,33,36},{2,36,15},{2,46,40},{2,48,45},{2,52,48},{3,7,30}, {3,14,24},{3,22,30},{3,28,20},{3,33,20},{3,50,24},{4,19,12}, {4,26,40},{4,41,15},{5,3,45},{5,12,30},{5,33,20},{5,37,30},{ 5,45,36},{6,56,40},{7,6,40},{7,40,48},{7,48,45},{8,26,15},{8,38,24},{8,53,20},{9,22,30},{10,7,30},{11,6,40},{11,31,12},{ 12,57,36},{13,53,20},{14,3,45},{15,21,36},{15,37,30},{16,5 2,30},{17,16,48},{17,46,40},{22,13,20},{23,2,24},{23,26,15 },{25,18,45},{25,55,12},{27,46,40},{28,7,30},{30,43,12},{35,33,20},{38,52,48},{42,11,15},{44,26,40},{46,52,30},{50,37,30},{55,33,20},{1,11,6,40},{1,15,56,15},{1,24,22,30},{1,28,53,20},{1,51,6,40},{1,57,11,15},{2,18,53,20},{2,22,13,20}, {2,31,52,30},{2,57,46,40},{3,42,13,20},{3,54,22,30},{4,37, 46,40},{5,55,33,20},{7,24,26,40},{11,51,6,40},{14,48,53,20 },{18,31,6,40},{23,42,13,20},{29,37,46,40},{37,2,13,20},{4 7,24,26,40},{1,32,35,33,20}} Select numbers of C between 1 and 1+ 2 (<2,25), in the lexicographic order. This list is the same as the Price s one. This list generates the first 15 entries of Plimpton 322, as well as the 23 additional entries reconstructed by Price, Britton, and others. These entries are obtained from the values n of C as follows: the diagonal is half the sum of n and its reciprocal: Column I contain the squares of these diagonals.

42 MS 3971 #3 (Friberg 2007, 252-3) b c d e In order for you to see five diagonals: 1,4 (is) the igi, and the igibi [ ] The 2nd (example). 1,40 the igi, 36 the igibi. 1,40 and 36 heap, 2,16 it gives. ½ of 2,16 break, 1,8 it gives. 1,8 square, 1,17,4 it gives. 1 from 1,17,4 tear off, 17,4 it gives. 17,4 makes 32 equalsided. 32, the width, it gives. The 3rd. 1,30 the igi, 40 the igibi. 1,30 and 40 heap, 2,10 it gives. ½ of 2,10 break, 1,5 it gives. 1,5 square, 1,10,25. 1 from 1,10,25 tear off, 10,25 it gives. 10,25 makes <25 equalsided>. 25, the 3rd width. The 4th. 1,20 the igi, 45 the igibi. 1,30 and 45 heap, 2,5 it gives. ½ of 2,5 break, 1,2,30 it gives. 1,2,30 square, 1,5,6,15. 1 from the length tear off, 5,6,15 it gives. 5,6,15 makes 17,30 equalsided. 17,30, the width of the 4th diagonal. The 5th. 1,12 the igi, 50 the igibi. 1,12 and 50 heap, 2,2 it gives. ½ of 2,2 break, 1,1. 1,1 square, 1,2,1. 1 from 1,2,1 tear off, 2,1 it gives. 2,1 makes 11equalsided. 11, the 5th width. 5 diagonals.

43 3b The 2nd (example). 1,40 the igi, 36 the igibi. 1,40 and 36 heap, 2,16 it gives. ½ of 2,16 break, 1,8 it gives. 1,8 square, 1,17,4 it gives. 1 from 1,17,4 tear off, 17,4 it gives. 17,4 makes 32 equalsided. 32, the width, it gives. u ,40 1 Configuration of gnomon Configuration of diagonal rule

44 β δ δ 2 = 1+β 2 b d N o [-I'] [0'] I' II' III' IV' sag şi-li-ip-tum ta]-ki-il-ti şi-li-ip - tim íb.si 8 sag íb.si 8 şi-li-ip-tim mu.bi.im šá 1 in]-na-as-šà-hu-ú-ma sag i-[il-lu]-ú ki ki ki ki ki ki 6 obv ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki 17 lo.e ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki 26 rev ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki ki 37 u.e ki In order for you to see five diagonals: 3 1,4 (is) the igi, and the igibi [ ] 3b 1 3c 1 3d 1 3e 1 The 2nd (example). 1,40 the igi, 36 the igibi. 2 1,40 and 36 heap, 2,16 it gives. 3 ½ of 2,16 break, 1,8 it gives. 4 1,8 square, 1,17,4 it gives. 5 1 from 1,17,4 tear off, 6 17,4 it gives. 17,4 makes 32 equalsided. 7 32, the width, it gives. The 3rd. 1,30 the igi, 40 the igibi. 2 1,30 and 40 heap, 2,10 it gives. 3 ½ of 2,10 break, 1,5 it gives. 4 1,5 square, 1,10,25. 1 from 1,10,25 tear off, 10,25 it gives. 5 10,25 makes <25 equalsided>. 25, the 3rd width. The 4th. 1,20 the igi, 45 the igibi. 1,30 and 45 2 heap, 2,5 it gives. ½ of 2,5 br eak, 1,2,30 it 3 gives. 4 1,2,30 square, 1,5,6, from the length tear off, 5,6,15 it gives. 6 5,6,15 makes 17,30 equalsided. 17,30, the width of the 4th diagonal. The 5th. 1,12 the igi, 50 the igibi. 2 1,12 and 50 heap, 2,2 it gives. ½ of 2,2 break, 1,1. 3 1,1 square, 1,2, from 1,2,1 tear off, 2,1 it gives. 5 2,1 makes 11equalsided. 11, the 5th width. Plimpton diagonals.

45