EU R&D Funding and Structural Funds Innvatin prmtin: tw different plicy delivery mechanisms with cmplementary bjectives First wrkshp n Research Funding and Structural Funds Swedish Permanent Representatin, Brussels, 22 June 2009 Mikel Landabas Head f Unit Regi D2 Thematic Crdinatin and Innvatin 1
EU R&D Funding and Structural Funds Innvatin prmtin: tw different plicy delivery mechanisms with cmplementary bjectives 1. The Prmtin f Innvatin in Eurpean 2. A Eurpean challenge: R&D excellence & Reginal Innvatin 3. Tw plicies with cmplementary bjectives: a histry n cllabratin in search f synergies 4. A way frward 2
3 The Prmtin f Innvatin in Eurpean : a silent (r)evlutin 1989-1993: apprximately 4% fr innvatin (2 billin ut f 50) (L. Tsipuri, IPTS Reprt N 40, 2004) Cmmunity initiatives: Science and Technlgy fr Reginal Develpment - STRIDE, TELEMATIQUE, ENVIREG, VALOREN 1994-1999: apprximately 7% fr innvatin (7,6 billin ut f 110) (L. Tsipuri, IPTS Reprt N 40, 2004) Pilt Prjects: RIS, RIS+, RTTs, RISI, RISI2, IRISI, EBN, BICs 2000-2006: apprximately 11% fr innvatin ut f 195 billin Regins in the new Ecnmy : PRAIS Reginal Prgrams f Innvative Actins 400 millin 2007-2013: apprximately 25% fr innvatin (86 billin ut f 345) Article 5 f the ERDF: innvatin as a pririty fr the Cmpetitiveness bjective -31.000 R&TD prjects identified in nly 95 ERDF Prgrams (40% f ttal budget) (Nrdregi 2009) Regins fr Ecnmic Change
4 Pririty themes in 434 Operatinal Prgrams in 271 regins 344.305.598.427 Research and technlgical develpment (R&TD), innvatin and entrepreneurship 50.046.501.271 01 R&TD activities in research centers 5.783.265.653 02 R&TD infrastructure and centers f cmpetence in a specific technlgy 9.899.436.081 03 Technlgy transfer and imprvement f cperatin netwrks (Clusters and Business Netwrks). 5.577.995.235 04 Assistance t R&TD, particularly in SMEs (including access t R&TD services in research centres) 5.573.990.437 05 Advanced supprt services fr firms and grups f firms 5.150.882.219 06 Assistance t SMEs fr the prmtin f envirnmentally-friendly prducts and prductin prcesses 2.504.554.193 07 Investment in firms directly linked t research and innvatin 9.029.635.350 09 Other measures t stimulate research and innvatin and entrepreneurship in SMEs 6.526.742.103 Infrmatin sciety 13.028.213.085 11 Infrmatin and cmmunicatin technlgies 3.597.833.221 12 Infrmatin and cmmunicatin technlgies (TEN-ICT) 523.787.206 13 Services and applicatins fr citizens (e-health, e-gvernment, e-learning, e-inclusin, etc.) 5.225.072.351 14 Services and applicatins fr SMEs (e-cmmerce, educatin and training, netwrking, etc.) 2.144.358.160 15 Other measures fr imprving access t and efficient use f ICT by SMEs 1.537.162.147 Increasing the adaptability f wrkers and firms, enterprises and entrepreneurs 14.427.929.049 62 Develpment f life-lng learning systems and strategies in firms; training and services fr emplyees... 9.752.889.678 63 Design and disseminatin f innvative and mre prductive ways f rganising wrk 1.897.998.513 64 Develpment f special services fr emplyment, training and supprt in cnnectin with restructuring f sectrs... 2.777.040.858 Imprving access t emplyment and sustainability 3.247.192.561 68 Supprt fr self-emplyment and business start-up 3.247.192.561 Imprving human capital 4.926.200.421 74 Develping human ptential in the field f research and innvatin, in particular thrugh pst-graduate studies... 4.926.200.421 Ttal fr innvatin in a brad sense 85.676.036.387
5 EUROPEAN COMMISSION
Chesin plicy helps shifting the plicy mix f public investment twards innvatin
Reginal Innvatin Perfrmance Reginal Innvatin Screbard 2006 7
% f GDP % pints f GDP EUROPEAN COMMISSION Innvatin in firms: R&D and thers R&D expenditure in the business enterprise sectr 2006 and evlutin 2000-2006 1.40 1.20 R&D Change 0.14 0.12 1.00 0.10 0.80 0.08 0.60 0.06 0.40 0.04 0.20 0.02 0.00 8 Cnvergence Transitin RCE 0.00
A Eurpean challenge: R&D excellence & Reginal Innvatin An R&D excellence-based apprach: mre mney fr basic leading edge R&D - help the best cmpete glbally the thers will fllw 30% f business expenditure n R&D and nearly half f all patent applicatins in just 10 regins Over 6.000 SMEs invlved in the VII FWP in first tw years (12,3% f all funding) The "reginal systems apprach": mre mney fr innvatin help tap underutilised ptential, SMEs in particular, wherever it exists. Over 23 millin SMEs acrss the Unin prviding up t 2/3 f all private sectr jbs (27 billin in EU Chesin funding aid) Bth glbal ecnmic grwth and scial chesin require increasing the cmpetitiveness f regins, especially where ptential is highest. The cmparative advantages that drive innvatin and investment are as much a reginal characteristic as a natinal ne. Fr regins t succeed, they must harness their wn mix f assets, skills and ideas t cmpete in a glbal market and develp unused ptential. OECD (Cnclusins f the Chair, High level Meeting, Martigny, Switzerland, July 2003) 9
Is the Reginal Dimensin Imprtant fr Innvatin Plicy? The capacity fr develping human capital and interactins between firms, is increasingly lcalised, netwrks f bth frmal and, mainly infrmal cntacts take place mre easily at the reginal level synergies, r an innvative surplus can arise frm shared cultural, psychlgical r plitical perspectives arising frm ccupancy f a shared space r regin (Lundvall & Brras, 1997). it is able t act n lcal knwledge, part f which is tacit, cncerning the calibre f firms, the frmal and infrmal linkages between firms, the quality f the labur frce and the capacity f the institutins the mst apprpriate level at which t build scial capital (Mrgan & Nauwelaers, 1997). t the extent that prduct and prcess innvatin is based upn new ideas and that the creatin f new ideas is a scial prcess invlving discussin, then gegraphical prximity is imprtant in innvatin (Best, 1990). «La Cmmissin a dnc décidé de mettre frtement l'accent sur l'innvatin réginale dans les nuveaux prgrammes de chésin. Parce que le niveau réginal est le plus adapté pur prendre des mesures qui favrisent l'innvatin. Il a un atut majeur: la prximité des acteurs chefs d'entreprise, chercheurs, autrités lcales, institutins financières» (J.M.Barrs, 2006). 10
Tw different plicy delivery mechanisms and administrative cultures EU R&D Plicy Based n individual R&D Prjects ften f a pre-cmpetitive nature aiming at imprving leading edge basic research Awarded directly t final beneficiaries (firms, public and private R&D centers and Universities) Cmpetitive calls addressed t internatinal grupings thrugh peer review based n excellence criteria EU Based n multiannual Prgrammes aiming at increased ecnmic cmpetitivieness thrugh clse t the market cmpetitive R&D and innvatin effrts Awarded thrugh shared management t natinal and reginal public intermediaries Nn cmpetitive attributin addressed t reginal players based n strategic planning negtiatin 11
Tw plicies with cmplementary bjectives: a histry n cllabratin in search f synergies COM (1993) Chesin Plicy and RTD Plicy Synergies between Research and Technlgical Develpment Plicy and ecnmic and scial chesin plicy DG Regi Cperatin Chart with DG Enter and DG INFSO: Innvating Regins in Eurpe IRE, Eurpean Reginal Infrmatin Sciety Assciatin Eris@, RINNO. COM (1998) Reinfrcing Chesin and Cmpetitiveness thrugh Research Technlgical Develpment and Innvatin RIS+ and RITTS. COM (2001) The Reginal Dimensin f the Eurpean Research Area Regins f Knwledge Practical Guide t EU Funding pprtunities fr R&I: http://crdis.eurpa.eu/eufunding-guide/hme_en.html 12
Example f synergies between ERDF and FWP VII: Spanish ERDF Technlgy Fund Financing reginal initiatives t stimulate the participatin f reginal stakehlders in FWP VII and ther internatinal R&D prgrammes CDTI (Natinal Innvatin Prmtin Agency) funded under the Spanish OP Technlgy Fund 2007-2013 uses Structural Funds t reinfrce cperatin / cmmunicatin / crdinatin between NCP f FP7 and natinal managers f internatinal R&D prgrammes and Reginal public agents prmting, financing and stimulating R&D and Innvatin thrugh: Infrmatin Campaings Active Search f Partners Assistance in preparatin f prpsals 13
Example f cmbinatin f EU Funding: Ptsdam-Glm Science Park (Germany) (Finalist RegiStars Award 2009) ERDF: 74 millin (1997-2007) fr research infrastructure: University f Ptsdam Research institutes RTD-Framewrk Prgramme (FP5) supprt fr several jint research prjects (2000-2005) frm University and research institutes 14
AN AGENDA FOR A REFORMED COHESION POLICY: A place-based apprach t meeting Eurpean Unin challenges and expectatins Fabrizi Barca Reprt (2009) A particular case is made fr selecting Innvatin as a cre pririty. Place-based interventins, building n the strengths and taking accunt f the weaknesses f previus experience as regards chesin plicy in this area, culd cmplement plicies aimed at develping a Eurpean Research Area, by selecting in each regin a limited number f sectrs in which innvatin can mst readily ccur and a knwledge base built up. Thrugh such an apprach defined in the current plicy debate as smart specialisatin - the mst culd be made f the present diversity f industrial agglmeratins and netwrks, while their penness beynd reginal r natinal bundaries wuld be prmted 15