Coalescers OVERVIEW There are numerous industrial applications requiring effective physical separation of two process liquids. HAT has developed a number of AlphaSEP Coalescers to handle a wide range of duties from severe fouling or viscous service through to fine polishing of clean, light liquids. Standard Types: FP Flat Plate Coalescers 50 150 m 2 /m 3 Interface Area MP Matrix Pack Coalescers 150 350 m 2 /m 3 Interface Area High Performance Types: LP Pack Coalescers 433 m 2 /m 3 Interface Area DM Dual Media Mesh Coalescers 750 m 2 /m 3 Interface Area CC Cartridge Coalescers >1000 m 2 /m 3 Interface Area DS-CD-01 Rev 3
Plate Coalescers Mixtures of immiscible liquids can generally be separated by a process of settling as a result of the density difference between the two phases. However gravitational settling becomes increasingly difficult as the droplet size of the dispersed phase decreases. The settling process can be enhanced considerably by passing the dispersion through a suitable coalescer pack. HAT s AlphaSEP FP Flat Plate Coalescer Packs are specifically designed to be used as effective coalescers in dirty liquid-liquid service where a level of phase separation is required that cannot be obtained in an empty, gravity separator. Coalescer style, face velocity and configuration will depend on the specific application. Light Phase Dispersion COALESCER PACK Heavy Phase Outlet TYPICAL ARRANGEMENT OF SEPARATOR VESSEL Liquid-liquid separator vessels are usually arranged horizontally as shown above. The coalescer pack is used to enhance the separation of liquid dispersions and consists of angled, flat metal plates with a spacing and style to suit service conditions. Generally a 45 o slope is used, but this can be increased to 60 o for particularly severe fouling service to ensure any solids fall from the plates to avoid plugging. DS-CD-01 Rev 3
Plate Coalescers Plate spacing is typically 15 25mm (giving a bulk surface area between 75 and 125 m 2 /m 3 ), standard pack length is 1000mm and the complete pack is assembled using a modular system from sub-assemblies. These sub-assemblies are designed to pass through vessel manways and be easily bolted together within the vessel. Unlike other manufacturers, HAT does not normally supply loose panel systems unless specifically requested, due to the added complexity and lower mechanical integrity. Several styles of AlphaSEP FP packs are available as illustrated below. Type FP-A This has the simplest construction, being blocks measuring 300 x 300mm face area stacked in a diamond pattern. However, the exit paths for the phases and solids are longer so this style is generally used for clean, coarse separation. Type FP-B A more advanced design of pack, again using 300 x 300mm modules, but stacked in a square pattern. This allows each row of packs to be reversed giving the characteristic fishbone pattern, which provides drainage channels for the different phases and solids. Type FP-C Our most sophisticated pack constructed from trapezoidal modules in which the plates are also provided with self-cleaning gutters ensuring that solids are deposited behind the pack rather than below it as with the other common designs. The mechanical integrity is also very high. Dispersions of droplets sized over 1000 microns tend to be very unstable and separate rapidly under gravity. Dispersions of droplets sized below 10 microns tend to be very stable and do not easily separate. Flat plate coalescers as shown above are very effective in coalescing all droplets as small as 100 microns into droplets greater than 1000 microns. DS-CD-01 Rev 3
Plate Coalescers Flat Plate Coalescers operate on the basis of Stokes Law, and are sized to ensure laminar flow between the plates. v = { g. d 2. ( 1 2 ) } / 18 μ Where: v = droplet terminal velocity, m/s g = acceleration due to gravity, m/s 2 d = droplet diameter, m 1 = bulk liquid density, kg/m 3 2 = droplet fluid density, kg/m 3 μ= viscosity of bulk liquid, kg/m.s Depending on the degree of separation required, this generally means a liquid velocity between 1.0-3.0 m/min is acceptable using standard plate spacings, to capture and coalesce the target droplet size. HAT can simulate most process conditions and / or offer advice on customer designed installations. Oil in Water Prediction Inlet and Outlet Droplet Distributions 0.00014 Relative Volume, m3/m3 0.00012 0.0001 0.00008 0.00006 0.00004 0.00002 Inlet Outlet 0 0 33 67 100 133 167 200 233 267 300 333 367 400 Droplet Size Distribution, Microns Fig 1. Typical Performance Prediction Curve DS-CD-01 Rev 3
Matrix Coalescers Mixtures of immiscible liquids can generally be separated by a process of settling as a result of the density difference between the two phases. However gravitational settling becomes increasingly difficult as the droplet size of the dispersed phase decreases. The settling process can be enhanced considerably by passing the dispersion through a suitable coalescer pack. HAT s AlphaSEP MP Matrix Coalescer Packs are specifically designed to be used as effective coalescers in light fouling liquid-liquid service where a level of phase separation is required that cannot be obtained in an empty, gravity separator. Coalescer style, face velocity and configuration will depend on the specific application. The packs can also be used in gas-liquid service for foam breaking applications. Liquid-liquid matrix coalescer packs are usually arranged vertically as shown above. The pack consists of corrugated metal plates with a spacing and style to suit service conditions. Pack surface areas are typically 125 and 250 m 2 /m 3, standard pack depth is 600mm and the complete pack is assembled using a modular system from sub-assemblies. These sub-assemblies are designed to pass through vessel manways and be easily stacked together within the vessel. Most packs are supplied in stainless steel, but they are also available in exotic alloys as well as stable plastics such as PVDF. DS-CD-02 Rev 3
Matrix Coalescers Sizing Dispersions of droplets sized over 1000 microns tend to be very unstable and separate rapidly under gravity. Dispersions of droplets sized below 10 microns tend to be very stable and do not easily separate. Matrix coalescers as shown above are very effective in coalescing all droplets as small as 50 microns into droplets greater than 1000 microns. The matrix pack used for liquid-liquid coalescing is similar to that used for other applications such as structured packing in absorber and distillation towers, and to static mixing elements. It is the velocity through the pack that is critical in determining the effectiveness for each application. In liquid-liquid separation for instance, at low Reynolds numbers the dispersed liquid droplets will, due to the frequent direction changes and high surface area, bump into each other and the metal surfaces and coalesce into larger drops which easily separate. As the velocity rises however and the flow becomes more turbulent, these larger droplets will be torn apart and any dispersed liquid layer on the metal surface will be dragged from it and also broken up into a dispersion. In effect the pack becomes an effective static mixer. Depending on the degree of separation required and the characteristics of the dispersion, the liquid flux rate should typically be kept below 2 m 3 /m 2.minute for sizing these coalescer packs. Pack Model Description Applications MP-250-S MP-250-H MP-125-S MP-125-H 250 m 2 /m 3 surface area with 45 plate angle 250 m 2 /m 3 surface area with 60 plate angle 125 m 2 /m 3 surface area with 45 plate angle 125 m 2 /m 3 surface area with 60 plate angle Best performance in clean service As above, will tolerate some light fouling Lower pressure dop suits clean, viscous liquids or foam breaking As above, with light fouling DS-CD-02 Rev 3
Polypropylene Packs Mixtures of immiscible liquids can generally be separated by a process of settling as a result of the density difference between the two phases. However gravitational settling becomes increasingly difficult as the droplet size of the dispersed phase decreases. The settling process can be enhanced considerably by passing the dispersion through a suitable coalescer pack. HAT s AlphaSEP LP Polypropylene Coalescer Packs are specifically designed to be used as effective coalescers in dirty oily water service where a level of phase separation is required that cannot be obtained in a gravity or plate separator. Coalescer arrangement, face velocity and configuration will depend on the specific application. Inlet Zone Outlet Zone Sediment Collector Coalescer Pack Inlet Baffles Sediment Collector TYPICAL ARRANGEMENT OF LP COALESCER DS-CD-03 Rev 3
Polypropylene Packs Selecting the right coalescing media for the duty depends on many factors with initial consideration given to the droplet size range in the dispersion and the target separation performance. Droplet Diameter Range Media Type Performance > 1000 micron None 80 90% Removal 100 1000 micron Flat Plate Pack 90-95% Removal 50 500 micron Matrix Pack > 95% removal 20 300 micron LP High Surface Pack >99% Removal 10 100 micron Dual Media Mesh Pack > 99% Removal 5 20 micron Cartridge Coalescer > 99.9% Removal < 3 5 micron Specialist Filter N/A Performance indications for ideally designed vessel and system in a single stage The high surface area media used in HAT s LP Coalescers easily passes the EPA Method 413.2 test for removal of oil droplets 20 microns and larger. Testing at the Danish Institute of Technology confirmed that the media beats the efficiency requirements of the European Standard CEN EN 858-1 for >99.9% oil removal regardless of droplet dize. While removing oil efficiently, the LP media also shows superior resistance to plugging by sludge and iron deposits commonly found in oily water. The rounded rod design of the pack allows self cleaning. As deposits form on the polypropylene surfaces they quickly reach a critical mass that forces them to slough off the slick, vertical rods and fall into the sludge compartment below the media. The AlphaSEP LP media has a specific surface area of 433 m 2 /m 3. This can be compared with typical flat plate packs at 100 m 2 /m 3 and matrix packs of 250 m 2 /m 3. Installation Options For gravity flow systems commonly a rectangular (non-pressurised) separator design is used, whereas for pressurised systems a horizontal, cylindrical separator would be installed. In both cases the vessel is divided in to several zones: Inlet Zone Where the fluid first enters the vessel a section is allowed for fluid calming, solids settling, and flow distribution to the next zone. Inlet devices would typically include pipe or trough deflectors or cyclones to encourage maximum initial solids separation. A system of baffles would then distribute the fluid for the next separation zone. DS-CD-03 Rev 3
Polypropylene Packs Separation Zone This is where the bulk liquids flow through the coalescer pack and the separation is achieved. The primary factor here is to achieve the correct bulk velocity too high and the residence time will be insufficient for all the droplets to be captured, also there could be a danger of turbulent flow through the media which would undo any separation achieved. A Reynolds number around 500 achieves maximum performance, although on some systems it may be higher where the performance is less critical e.g. the discharge is not into public water. The packs may be placed across the axis of the vessel to achieve axial flow of the liquid through the media or, where a greater area is required, it may be placed along the central axis and the liquid sent in a cross flow arrangement. Axial Flow Cross Flow A sediment collection system should be placed under the coalescer pack to remove the solids occasionally. For pressurised systems where access to the pack is more complex, consideration should be given to a liquid or gas spray/sparge system to occasionally aid pack cleaning should it be necessary. Outlet Zone The outlet zone is a quiescent, settling zone where the 2 phases are physically separated by means of a skimmer device such as a weir or an overflow bucket or trough. The size and depth of the skimmer depends on the relative quantity of the light phase liquid. DS-CD-03 Rev 3
Polypropylene Packs Sizing and Performance The following curves are typical performance predictions for a pressurised oily water treatment system where the inlet oil droplet distribution is based on smaller particles than would be found in a gravity based system. Where a droplet distribution is available we can calculate more accurate performance projections. Residual ppmv Residual Oil in Water 70 60 50 40 30 0.80 sg Oil 0.85 sg Oil 0.90 sg Oil 20 10 0 0 5 10 15 20 Velocity, USgpm/ft² DS-CD-03 Rev 3
Mesh Coalescers Mixtures of immiscible liquids can generally be separated by a process of settling as a result of the density difference between the two phases. However gravitational settling becomes increasingly difficult as the droplet size of the dispersed phase decreases. The settling process can be enhanced considerably by passing the dispersion through a suitable coalescer pad. HAT s AlphaSEP DM Knitted Dual Media Mesh Pads are effective coalescers in both liquid-liquid and vapour-liquid service. Mesh pad style, face velocity and configuration will depend on the specific application. Light Phase Dispersion DM COALESCER Heavy Phase Outlet TYPICAL ARRANGEMENT OF SEPARATOR VESSEL Liquid-liquid separator vessels are usually arranged horizontally as shown above. The coalescer pack is used to enhance the separation of liquid dispersions and consists of layers of composite materials chosen to suit service conditions. Generally a metallic wire monofilament is co-knitted with a fibre material which has a surface which is preferentially wetted by the dispersed phase. For hydrocarbon in water dispersions, a thermoplastic fibre is preferred and for water in hydrocarbon dispersion a specially treated glass fibre is used. It is therefore always important to know which is the dispersed phase in the mixture. Whilst the right choice of fibre material ensures maximum collection of the dispersed droplets, the effect of the difference in surface free energies of the monofilament wire and fibre materials in close proximity promotes droplet coalescence. DS-CD-04 Rev 3
Mesh Coalescers TYPICAL DM 25 50 25 75 25 25 75 25 50 25 COALESCER PACK Spacer Rods Style "DS" Mesh (Drainage Layers) Mesh (Coalescing Layers) DM Composite Retainer Grid Support Retainer Grid Screen Dispersions of droplets sized over 1000 microns tend to be very unstable and separate rapidly under gravity. Dispersions of droplets sized below 10 microns tend to be very stable and do not easily separate. DM mesh coalescers as shown above are very effective in coalescing all droplets as small as 30 microns into droplets greater than 1000 microns. The coalescer velocity will be typically less than 1 m/min and the pad should be sized as follows:- Minimum Effective Face Area (A f ) = 1.44 * Q * { L /( H - L )} 0.5 (m 2 ) where: Q = Volumetric flowrate (m 3 /min) L = Light phase density (kg/m 3 ) H = Heavy phase density (kg/m 3 ) Generally similar principles apply to coalescer pads in vertical liquid-liquid extractor columns. A 150mm thick pad of DM composite knitted wire mesh, preferentially wetted by the dispersed phase, installed above the packed section will coalesce dispersed phase droplets hence improving phase separation and reducing entrainment. For performance predictions please refer to HAT s engineers. DS-CD-04 Rev 3