NJDEP Medical Physicist s Radiographic QC Survey Registration Number:

Similar documents
Compliance Guidance for RADIOGRAPHIC QUALITY CONTROL (5 th Edition)

Practical Aspects of Medical Physics Surveys of Mammography Equipment and Facilities

Quality Control for Stereotactic Breast Biopsy. Robert J. Pizzutiello, Jr., F.A.C.M.P. Upstate Medical Physics, Inc

STEREOTACTIC BREAST BIOPSY EQUIPMENT SURVEYS

Overview of Safety Code 35

Minnesota Rules, Chapter 4732 X-ray Revision

Nuclear Associates

Surveying and QC of Stereotactic Breast Biopsy Units for ACR Accreditation

RULES OF TENNESSEE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION DIVISION OF RADIOLOGICAL HEALTH CHAPTER USE OF X-RAY APPARATUS

Quality Control of Full Field Digital Mammography Units

Beam-Restricting Devices

Acceptance Testing of a Digital Breast Tomosynthesis Unit

GE AMX 4+ Portable X-Ray

Ch. 223 VETERINARY MEDICINE CHAPTER 223. VETERINARY MEDICINE GENERAL PROVISIONS X-RAYS RADIOACTIVE MATERIAL. Authority

Nuclear Associates

REQUIREMENTS FOR LICENCE HOLDERS WITH RESPECT TO QUALITY CONTROL TESTS FOR DIAGNOSTIC X-RAY IMAGING SYSTEMS

Y11-DR Digital Radiography (DR) Image Quality

Minnesota Rules, Chapter 4732 X-ray Revision

RAD 150 RADIOLOGIC EXPOSURE TECHNIQUE II

(a) This subchapter applies to installations using analytical x-ray equipment and establishes requirements for their use.

Minnesota Rules, Chapter 4732 X-ray Revision

C-ARM FLUOROSCOPIC AND SPOT-FILM SYSTEMS

Ansur TNT Users Manual. Plug-In

Minnesota Rules, Chapter 4732 X-ray Revision

CHAPTER 6 QC Test For Fluoroscopic Equipment. Prepared by:- Kamarul Amin bin Abu Bakar School of Medical Imaging KLMUC

Teaching Digital Radiography and Fluoroscopic Radiation Protection

Digital Imaging started in the 1972 with Digital subtraction angiography Clinical digital imaging was employed from the 1980 ~ 37 years ago Amount of

Nuclear Associates

QC Testing for Computed Tomography (CT) Scanner

Learning Objectives: What s my motivation? (unknown screen actor) Workshop Overview

SUBCHAPTER 14. THERAPEUTIC INSTALLATIONS

Test Equipment for Radiology and CT Quality Control Contents

X-RAYS - NO UNAUTHORISED ENTRY

DIAGNOSTIC ACCREDITATION PROGRAM. Radiology and CT Quality Control Procedures Workbook

IChapter Number,ChapterTiiie I0400: _OJ TJse of X-Ray Apparatus! Rule Number Rule Title

Notice of Rulemaking Hearing

I. PERFORMANCE OF X-RAY PRODUCTION COMPONENTS FLUOROSCOPIC ACCEPTANCE TESTING: TEST PROCEDURES & PERFORMANCE CRITERIA

Diagnostic x-ray equipment compliance and facility survey

7/20/2014. Outline. Outline. Disclosures. Learning Objectives. SBB: Practical Aspects of ACR Accreditation, QC and ACR On Site Surveys

Multiple Choice Identify the letter of the choice that best completes the statement or answers the question.

Digital Radiography System

MXHF-1500RF is controlled by Digital key panel console that displays KV, ma and mas with APR menu programmed.

Aspire HD. Program Manual. 2nd Edition - October 2012

Assessment of Beam Alignment, Collimation and Half Value Layer of Some Selected X-Ray Machines in Plateau State, Nigeria

Safelight Fog does what to contrast and density on film?

Exposure System Selection

Dedicated Veterinary Imaging Solutions Digital, CR and Analog Imaging Solutions for any size patient and any size budget.

SPRINGFIELD TECHNICAL COMMUNITY COLLEGE ACADEMIC AFFAIRS

C501-E029C. RADspeed. GENERAL RADIOGRAPHIC SYSTEM Automatic

COMPUTED RADIOGRAPHY CHAPTER 4 EFFECTIVE USE OF CR

The Evaluation of Collimator Alignment of Diagnostic X-ray Tube Using Computed Radiography System

Mammography is a radiographic procedure specially designed for detecting breast pathology Approximately 1 woman in 8 will develop breast cancer over

Facility, Unit and Test Equipment Data

A Practical Overview of the Clinical and Operational Impact of Computed Radiography(CR) Implementations. Shirley Weddle, RT(R)(M), CIIP, BBA

ABOVETABLE X-RAY SOURCE FLUOROSCOPIC AND SPOT-FILM SYSTEMS

MAMMOGRAPHY - HIGH LEVEL TROUBLESHOOTING

1. Carlton, Richard R., and Arlene M. Adler. Principles of Radiographic Imaging: An Art and a Science, 5th edition (2013).

Minnesota Rules, Chapter 4732 X-ray Revision PROPOSED NON-MEDICAL CABINET X-RAY SYSTEMS, 1.0

Contrast. Contrast: the difference in density on adjacent areas of a radiograph or other image receptor. Subjective. Long Scale (Low Contrast)

Digital Mammography Quality Control for the Mammographic Technologist

Minnesota Rules, Chapter 4732 X-ray Revision

Ludlum Medical Physics

Precision Performance Power

RADIATION SAFETY REQUIREMENTS FOR ANALYTICAL X-RAY EQUIPMENT

Minnesota Rules, Chapter 4732 X-ray Revision

(CR) PORTABLE CHEST EXAM Baseline Definition Worksheet

Essentials of Digital Imaging

1. Oklahoma Administrative Code (OAC) 252:410, titled Radiation Management

ARU-01CF Portable X-Ray NSN:

Exposure Indices and Target Values in Radiography: What Are They and How Can You Use Them?

Investigation of the line-pair pattern method for evaluating mammographic focal spot performance

DISC QC/QA Program for Digital Imaging Systems using the DR Radchex Plus Meter

The X-ray circuit: part II

ODYSSEY HF SERIES. ULTRA High Frequency X-Ray Technology. Precision... Performance... Power. Innovations in Digital Imaging.

X-ray Equipment in Medical Diagnosis Part A: Recommended Safety Procedures for Installation and Use

X o- System. Chiro- Systems. Chiropractic X-Ray Systems and Digital Solutions. Digital Radiography Computerized Radiography Chiropractic Systems

RADspeed Pro GENERAL RADIOGRAPHIC SYSTEM Automatic C501-E027C

By: Georgia Institute of Technology

RADspeed Pro GENERAL RADIOGRAPHIC SYSTEM Automatic C501-E027B

Nuclear Associates

X-ray Imaging. PHYS Lecture. Carlos Vinhais. Departamento de Física Instituto Superior de Engenharia do Porto

Introduction. Digital Mammography QA: Comparing the Manufacturers Recommendations. What is QC and why is it important? Review & compare QC tests

Atomscope PORTABLE VETERINARY X-RAY EQUIPMENT INSTRUCTION MANUAL. Version 1.0

Nuclear Associates

EUREKA LINEAR MC150-C. Installation Operation and Maintenance PROGENY, INC.

Redefining Ergonomics

RADIOGRAPHIC EXPOSURE

THE ART OF THE IMAGE: IDENTIFICATION AND REMEDIATION OF IMAGE ARTIFACTS IN MAMMOGRAPHY

NEXT Protocol for the Survey of Pediatric Chest Radiography

TABLE OF CONTENTS. References

FMT18 FLOOR MOUNTED SYSTEM

Step By Step Guide AP Supine Abdomen (Table bucky example) This tutorial will take you through the following steps.

3/31/2011. Objectives. Emory University. Historical Development. Historical Development. Historical Development

Veterinary Science Preparatory Training for the Veterinary Assistant. Floron C. Faries, Jr., DVM, MS

X-RAY IMAGING EE 472 F2017. Prof. Yasser Mostafa Kadah

China Resources Wandong Medical Equipment Co., Ltd. High Frequency 50kW, 150kV Radiography System - HF50-R

AeroDR X60. Motorized X-ray System

DRX SERIES. Radiographic Systems. Division of Carestream

SPRINGFIELD TECHNICAL COMMUNITY COLLEGE ACADEMIC AFFAIRS

OPERATOR'S INSTRUCTIONS

Transcription:

Facility Name NJDEP ID # NJDEP Medical Physicist s Radiographic QC Survey PLEASE PRINT Facility Information Unit Information Manufacturer Model Console Model # Console serial # Tube serial # Location (room) QC Survey Information Date of QC Survey Qualified Medical Physicist Name MP Assistant in Radiography Name CERTIFICATION STATEMENT I certify that, to the best of my knowledge, the information in this document and all attached documents is true, accurate and complete. Medical Physicist Signature Date MP Assistant Signature Summary of Areas Needing Correction Date Recommendations Date of the Meeting/Conference Call Persons Attending Statement of Meeting Registrant's Receipt of Report I have received this report and I agree to correct any deficiencies in accordance with N.J.A.C. 7:28-22.8(f). Registrant or designee signature: Date If deficiencies were found, record below when corrective actions taken and by whom. Use additional sheets if needed. Revised 10/15/01 1

NOTE! Please mark all tests performed by the Certified Physicist Assistant with an (*). Item Description Pass Needs Repair N/A NJAC 7:28 Radiographic Unit Assembly Evaluation 1 Tube locks are operational. 2.5(b) 2 Unit is registered with DEP. 3.3(a) 3 Collimator is securely connected to the housing If in question, perform a diagnostic source assembly leakage test. Measurement mr in one hour. 15.3(b) 4 For certified units, an X-ray beam angulation 15.3(d)1 indicator is present and operational. 5 SID indicator is present and accurate. 15.3(d)3 6 Control panel indicates kvp, ma, time, mas. 15.3(f)2 7 Audible and visual indication of exposure for 15.3(f)3 certified unit. 8 Visual indication of exposure uncertified unit. 15.3(f)3 9 Exposure switch for stationary units can only be 15.3(f)6 activated from behind a protective barrier. 10 Protective apron(s) of > 0.25 mm Pb equivalent 15.9(a)1i is present if a person is not behind a protective barrier during exposure. 11 Gondal shielding of > 0.5 mm Pb equivalent is 15.9(a)3 present. 12 Unit has a current radiation survey. 15.10(b)1 and 2 For Multiple tube control panels ONLY 13 Permits activation of only one tube at a time. 15.3(h)1 14 Provides an indication of selected tube. 15.3(h)2 15 Only the selected tube is energized. 15.3(h)3 For Mobile or Portable units ONLY 16 Collimator or spacer fame is present to limit the 15.3(j)2 source to skin distance > 12 inches. 17 SID Indicator is present and measures SID 15.3(j)3 within 2%. 18 Exposure switch is a dead man type. 15.3(j)4 19 Exposure switch is on a cord > 6 feet long. 15.3(j)4 Revised 10/15/01 2

Item Description Pass Needs Repair Collimator Assessment For MANUAL & PBL Collimators 20 Controls open and close blades smoothly, adjustment is stepless. 21 X-ray/Light field congruence does not exceed 2% of SID. Measurements: N/A NJAC 7:28 15.3(c)1 15.3(c)1 22 Minimum field size at 39.4 inches SID < 2"X 2" Measurement: 23 Center alignment with bucky tray < 2% SID Measurement: 15.3(c)1 15.3(d)2 For PBL Collimators ONLY Applicable to both automatic and semi automatic PBL *(If PBL has been properly disabled and labeled, only perform tests for Manual Collimators) 24 X-ray production is prevented when: a Either the length or width of the x-ray field 15.3(i)2i larger than the image receptor size by >3% of the SID. b The sum of the difference in length and width of 15.3(i)2ii the x-ray field is larger than the image receptor size by >4% of the SID. c The SID for which PBL is not designed for sizing. 15.3(i)2iii 25 Override is for all SID s and image 15.3(i)4i receptor sizes. 26 A key is required to override PBL. 15.3(i)4ii 27 Key remains in place during all times that PBL 15.3(i)4iii is overridden. 28 Each key switch or key is labeled as required. 15.3(i)4iv 29 Collimator controls open and close blades 15.3(i)5 smoothly and adjustment is stepless. 30 Minimum Field size at a 39.4 inch SID <2 X 2 15.3(i)5 Measurement: 31 A change of image receptor of the same size does not cause an automatic return to PBL. 32 Any change in image receptor size or SID causes automatic return to PBL. 15.3(i)6 15.3(i)6 Revised 10/15/01 3

Item Description Pass Needs Repair For Diaphragms or Fixed Collimator ONLY 33 SID and image receptor size is marked on each diaphragms. 34 A beam limiting device is available for all combinations of SID s and image receptor sizes used by the facility. 35 Each device limits the beam size to the size of the image receptor size. Collimator Illumination 36 Illumination is at least 15 ft candles (160 lux) when measured at 39.4 inches. Measurement: N/A NJAC 7:28 15.3(c)2 15.3(c)2 15.3(c)3 15.3(c)1i 37 Half Value Layer Measured mm Al @ kvp See Form #1 15.3(e)1 ma or mas Linearity 38 ma linearity does not exceed 10%. See Forms #5 39 mas linearity does not exceed 10%. See Forms #6 kvp Accuracy / Reproducibility 40 kvp accuracy does not exceed 10% or Mfg. Specs. See Form #2 41 kvp reproducibility does not exceed 5%. See Form #3 15.3(g)6i 15.3(g)6ii 15.3(g)4 15.3(g)5 Revised 10/15/01 4

Item Description Pass Needs Repair Timer Accuracy/ Reproducibility 42 Timer accuracy does not exceed 10% or Mfg. Specs. Test can be excluded for mas units. See Attached Form #4 43 Timer reproducibility may not exceed: 5% for certified units OR 7% for uncertified units. See Attached Form #3 45 Exposure reproducibility may not exceed: 5% for certified units OR 7% for uncertified units. See Attached Form #3 AEC Control, Reproducibility, Tracking, Density Control 46 A device is on control panel that indicates when AEC mode is selected. N/A NJAC 7:28 15.3(g)1 15.3(g)2I or 15.3(g)2ii 15.3(g)3I or 15.3(g)3ii 15.3(f)7i 47 Audible and visual indication of exposure for 15.3(f)7ii certifies units. 48 Visual indication of exposure for uncertified units. 15.3(f)7iii 49 ESE Measurement Procedure(s) Used (i.e. AP L/S pine, AP or PA Chest, AP abdomen, AP foot) According to the facility s technique chart, the following factors below were used ma mas Time 22.8a kvp SID Film-Screen speed AEC Cells Activated Density Control ESE Measurement mr 50 Are facility s techniques for this and other procedures within the normal diagnostic range? YES 9 NO 9 51 Attach a copy of the appropriate NEXT or State chart, identifying the measured ESE. Provide recommendations if appropriate. Revised 10/15/01 5

Item Description Pass Needs Repair Image Quality Evaluation (Recommendation) 52 List Procedure(s) Used (i.e. AP L/Spine, AP or PA Chest, AP abdomen, AP foot) N/A NJAC 7:28 22.8(a) Compare Phantom standards with what is visualized on the facility s radiograph Phantom Test Item Phantom Standard Facility Result 53 Noise/artifacts 54 Uniformity 55 High Contrast Resolution 56 Low Contrast Resolution 57 Low Contrast Detail 58 Background Density 59 Comments: Revised 10/15/01 6

7:28-22.4 (a)1 Item 61 QA Manual satisfies the requirements of N.J.A.C. 7:28-22.4. REQUIRED ITEM Pass Not in Manual List of identified individuals responsible for QA/QC program (a)2i QC Tests to be performed & required frequencies (See item 62) (a)2ii List of Equipment to be tested (a)2iii Acceptability limits for each test (See item 62) (a)2iv (a)2v (a)2vi (a)2vii (a)3 (a)3i (a)3ii (a)3iii (a)3iv (a)3v (a)3vi (a)3vii (a)3viii (a)3ix (a)3x (a)3xi (a)4i (a)4ii (a)5 (a)5i (a)5ii (a)5iii (a)5iv (a)6 (a)7 Comments: Description of each QC test procedure Sample forms for each QC test performed Processor Maintenance & Chemical Solutions Annual Medical Physicist s QC Survey Policies and Procedures Holding Patients and for individuals present in the room during Exposure Pregnant patients and employees Gonadal shielding Orientation Program Proper use and maintenance of equipment Employee responsibilities concerning personnel radiation Monitoring Release of films Labeling films Radiation Safety Survey Technique Chart Rules on Radiation Safety Plan for Corrective Action: after X-ray Equipment service or repair Plan for Corrective Action: after processor repair or service Record Keeping Most recent 1 year of QC tests maintained Initial Medical Physicist s QC Survey + 2 most recent Surveys Corrective Action for most recent 2 years Personnel Monitoring Reference Manuals Annual QA Program Review Not Adequate Not Current Revised 10/15/01 7

Item 62 Review all QC tests for compliance with the minimum frequencies and standards as per N.J.A.C. 7:28-22.5 Required Item Equipment Warm Up Processor Quality Control If manual processing, the timetemperature method is used. Laser Film Printer Quality Control Darkroom Cleanliness Processor Maintenance and Chemical Solutions Facility s Equipment Visual Checklist Film and Chemical Shelf Life Light Field/X-ray Field Alignment Repeat Analysis Artifact Evaluation Analysis of Fixer Retention Darkroom Fog Cassette Integrity/Screen Cleanliness Lead Aprons, Gloves, Gonadal and Thyroid Shield Integrity Check Annual Medical Physicist QC Survey Annual QA Program Review QC tests are performed using acceptable procedures. Corrective action was taken in accordance with N.J.A.C. 7:28-22.5. Records of all applicable QC tests and corrective action are maintained in accordance with N.J.A.C. 7:28-22.5. Comments: Required Frequency Daily Daily Weekly Weekly 2 months Quarterly Quarterly Quarterly Semiannual Semiannual Semiannual Semiannual Annual Annual Annual Annual Pass Not Performed Not Performed at Required Frequency Does Not Meet Standard N/A Revised 10/15/01 8

Form #1 Half-Value Layer (HVL) Minimum of three (3) measurements: One measurement for zero mm Al, one measurement before actual HVL and one measurement near actual HVL. kvp Set = ms Set = ma Set = mas Set = mm Al. kvp Measured mr Measured 0 mm Al mm Al @ kvp Revised 10/15/01 9

Form #2 kvp Accuracy Provide measurements in diagnostic range for minimum of six (6) different kvp settings. Exceptions are: Single purpose units, such as dedicated Chest units, which may use a limited kvp range. ma Set = ms Set = mas Set= kvp Set kvp Measured % kvp Error mr Measured Passed Needs Repair % Accuracy = ( measured value set value) x 100 set value Revised 10/15/01 10

Form # 3 Reproducibility For kvp, Time, and Exposure Record measurements for kvp, ms or mas, and mr for a minimum of four (4) exposures. ma Set = ms Set = mas Set = kvp Set kvp Measured ms or mas Measured mr Measured Mean Coefficient of variation C = X s = X 1 n i= 1 (X i X) n 1 2 1/ 2 Where: s = estimated standard deviation of population X = mean value of observations in sample X i = ith observation in sample n = number of observations in sample Reproducibility For: Passed Needs Repair kvp Time or mas Exposure Revised 10/15/01 11

Form # 4 Timer Accuracy Minimum of four (4) measurements in diagnostic range. Exclude timer accuracy measurements for mas units. kvp Set = ma Set = ms Set ms Measured % ms Error mr Measured Passed Needs Repair % Accuracy = ( measured value set value) x 100 set value Revised 10/15/01 12

Procedure for Determining Linearity of X-Ray Tube Current (ma) Selector Units 1. Determine the ma settings most commonly used by the facility. If only one ma setting is used by facility, linearity need not be tested. 2. Using the lowest ma setting in 1 above and the next consecutive clinically used ma setting, make a minimum of 3 but no more than 10 exposures at each setting. The difference between these settings should not be greater than a factor of 2 (ex. between 100 ma and 200 ma NOT 100 ma and 300mA). These settings may include any 2 focal spot sizes except where 1 is equal to or less than 0.45 mm and the other is greater than 0.45 mm. (Source: 21 CFR Part 1020.31(c)3) Note: if the focal spot sizes are not known, it is recommended that both settings be from the same focal spot size. The same exposure time and kvp setting are used for all exposures. 3. For each exposure, record on form #5 (below), all applicable exposure settings, the kvp measured and mr measured. Calculate and record the mr/mas for each exposure. 4. For each ma setting, calculate and record the average mr/mas. Average is calculated within a single ma setting not between all ma settings tested. You need only test linearity between ma settings used clinically by facility. 5. Using the average mr/mas calculated in 4 above and the following formula, calculate and record linearity between consecutive ma settings (ex. between 100 ma and 200 ma; between 200mA and 300mA): x 1 -x 2 < 0.10 (x 1 + x 2 ) Where x 1 and x 2 are the average mr/mas values obtained at each of the 2 ma settings. 6. Determine compliance and check the appropriate box. According to N.J.A.C. 7:28-15.3(g)6, the average mr/mas obtained at any 2 ma settings shall not differ by more than 0.10 times their sum. It is recommended that at least one linearity test be performed for each focal spot size that is used by the facility. If for example only the large focal spot is used, the small focal spot does not need to be tested. For x-ray units where multiple ma settings are used, it is recommended that linearity be determined using a series of 4 different ma settings. Revised 10/15/01 13

Form # 5 ma linearity Take between 3 and 10 readings at each ma setting and use to calculate the average mr/mas. This average is calculated within a single ma setting not between all ma settings tested. You need only test linearity between ma settings used clinically by facility. If only one ma setting is used by facility, linearity need not be tested. kvp set time set ma set Calculate mas Focal spot (circle) kvp Measured mr Measured Calculate mr/mas Average mr/mas* L S L S L S L S *Use this number in form below to determine if ma between consecutive settings is linear. Compare linearity between consecutive ma settings (ex. between 200 ma and 300 ma) Where x 1 and x 2 are the average mr/mas values obtained at each of the 2 ma settings. List ma stations being compared Calculate linearity x 1 -x 2 < 0.10 (x 1 + x 2 ) Pass Needs Repair Revised 10/15/01 14

Procedure for Determining Linearity of X-Ray Current-Exposure Time Product (mas) Selector Units 1. Determine the mas settings most commonly used by the facility. 2. Using the lowest mas setting in #1 above and the next consecutive clinically used mas setting, make a minimum of 3 but no more than 10 exposures at each setting. The difference between these settings should not be greater than a factor of 2 (ex. between 10 mas and 20 mas NOT 10 mas and 30 mas). These settings may include any 2 focal spot sizes except where 1 is equal to or less than 0.45 mm and the other is greater than 0.45 mm. (Source: 21 CFR Part 1020.31(c)3) Note: if the focal spot sizes are not known, it is recommended that both settings be from the same focal spot size. The same kvp setting is used for all exposures. 3. For each exposure, record on form 6 (below) all applicable exposure settings, the kvp measured and mr measured. Calculate and record the mr/mas for each exposure. 4. For each mas setting, calculate and record the average mr/mas. Average is calculated within a single mas setting not between all mas settings tested. You need only test linearity between mas settings used clinically by facility. 5. Using the average mr/mas calculated in 4 above and the following formula, calculate and record linearity between consecutive mas settings (ex. between 10 mas and 20 mas; between 20 mas and 30 mas): x 1 -x 2 < 0.10 (x 1 + x 2 ) Where x 1 and x 2 are the average mr/mas values obtained at each of the 2 mas settings. 6. Determine compliance and check the appropriate box. According to N.J.A.C. 7:28-15.3(g)6, the average mr/mas obtained at any 2 mas settings shall not differ by more than 0.10 times their sum. It is recommended that at least one linearity test be performed for each focal spot size that is used by the facility and when the focal spot size is known or selectable. If for example only the large focal spot is used, the small focal spot does not need to be tested. For x-ray units, where multiple mas settings are used, it is recommended that linearity be determined using a series of 4 different mas settings. Revised 10/15/01 15

Form 6 mas Linearity Take between 3 and 10 readings at each mas setting and use to calculate the average mr/mas. This average is calculated within a single mas setting not between all mas settings tested. You need only test linearity between mas settings used clinically by facility. If only one mas setting is used by facility, linearity need not be tested. kvp set mas set Focal spot (circle) kvp Measured mr Measured Calculate mr/mas Average mr/mas* L S L S L S L S *Use this number in table below to determine if mas between consecutive settings is linear. Linearity between consecutive mas settings (ex. between 20 mas and 30 mas). Where x 1 and x 2 are the average mr/mas values obtained at each of the 2 mas settings. List mas stations being compared Calculate linearity x 1 -x 2 < 0.10 (x 1 + x 2 ) Pass Needs Repair Revised 10/15/01 16