SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS May 14, 2001 APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT. Koch, J. Affirmed

Transcription

1 SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS May 14, 2001 STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTY TRIAL JUDGE TRIAL COURT NO. APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT NATURE OF APPEAL ACTION Robert Lafferty and Phyllis Lafferty City of Winchester, et al M SC-R11-CV Franklin Circuit J. Curtis Smith 10,025-CV Koch, J. Denied - Application of Robert Lafferty Rick Ray Tinkham and Kathy Tinkham R. Jerome Beasley M SC-R11-CV Wilson Circuit Clara W. Byrd Cottrell, J. Reversed and Denied - Application of Rick Ray Tinkham and Kathy Tinkham Michael Brady, Jr. M SC-R11-CD Williamson Circuit Timothy L. Easter II A Denied - Application of Michael Brady, Jr. Carl David Burnette M SC-R11-CD Grundy Circuit Buddy D. Perry 3219 Woodall, J. Denied - Application of Carl David Burnette Michael Inlow M SC-R11-CD Williamson Criminal Timothy L. Easter II , II Smith, J. Denied - Application of Michael Inlow

2 Harold Wayne Shaw M SC-R11-CD Davidson Criminal Seth W. Norman 95-D-2761 Smith, J. Denied - Application of Harold Wayne Shaw Jerry W. Yancey, Jr. M SC-R11-CD Williamson Circuit Timothy L. Easter II Lafferty, J. Granted - Application of Jerry W. Yancey, Jr. 1 Gary Green M SC-R11-PC Davidson Criminal Steve R. Dozier 96-A-32 pursuant to Rule 20 Denied - Application of Gary Green Skyla Sepeda Smith M SC-R11-PC Putnam Circuit John A. Turnbull Woodall, J. pursuant to Rule 20 Denied - Application of Skyla Sepeda Smith Allied Business Brokers, Inc. Ibrahim Musa and Abed Amro W SC-R11-CV Shelby Circuit John R. McCarroll, Jr T.D. Highers, J. Reversed and Denied - Application of Abed Amro Jay R. Bennett Paul G. Summers, et al W SC-R11-CV Hardeman Circuit Jon K. Blackwood 9222 Farmers, J. Dismissed for failure to post bond Denied - Application of Jay R. Bennett 1 For oral argument, the Court is particularly interested in the following issues: In cases where the denial of pretrial diversion is appealed after trial, may the court of Criminal Appeals consider the evidence at trial when reviewing that denial of diversion; and Will the trial court s failure to follow proper procedures when determining whether the district attorney general abused his discretion warrant relief? This statement of the issue(s) for oral argument does not prevent the parties from raising additional issues pursuant to Rule 13(a), TRAP. 2

3 Emergicare Consultants, Inc. Barbara A. Woolbright W SC-R11-CV Shelby Chancery D. J. Alissandratos R.D. Highers, J. Reversed and Denied - Application of Barbara A. Woolbright Pam Hamblen Richard Davidson W SC-R11-CV Obion Circuit J. Steven Stafford Crawford, J. Reversed Denied - Application of Richard Davidson Terry Bates Lynn City of Jackson W SC-R11-CV Madison Circuit Roy B. Morgan, Jr. C Div. 1 Crawford, J. Granted - Application of Terry Bates Lynn Trau-Med of America, Inc., et al Allstate Insurance Company, et al W SC-R11-CV Shelby Circuit Robert L. Childers T.D. Crawford, J. Reversed in part, affirmed in part, and Granted - Application of Allstate Insurance Co., et al John T. Weatherford, et al Darrin Sheffield W SC-R11-CV Benton Chancery Ron E. Harmon 8960 Highers, J. Denied - Application of Darrin Sheffield Willie Wayne Boyland W SC-R11-CD Hardeman Circuit Jon K. Blackwood 6270 Woodall, J. Denied - Application of Willie Wayne Boyland John Lee Hampton W SC-R11-CD Hardeman Criminal Jon K. Blackwood 6278 Wade, J. Denied - Application of John Lee Hampton 3

4 Demario Quentez Jackson W SC-R11-PC Madison Circuit Joe C. Morris C Denied - Application of Demario Quentez Jackson Judy Martin W SC-R11-CD Carroll Circuit Charles McGinley 99 CR 1429 Denied - Application of Judy Martin Tony L. Pirtle W SC-R11-PC Hardeman Circuit Jon K. Blackwood 6092 Williams, J. pursuant to Rule 20 Denied - Application of Tony L. Pirtle Cedarius James Robertson W SC-R11-CD Madison Circuit John F. Murchison Hayes, J. and Denied - Application of Cedarius James Robertson Billy Thompson W SC-R11-CD Shelby Criminal James C. Beasley, Jr ; Hayes, J. Denied - Application of Billy Thompson; recommended that the Court of Criminal Appeals opinion be published Joseph Kenneth Tipler W SC-R11-PC Shelby Criminal Carolyn W. Blackett P Witt, J. Denied - Application of Joseph Kenneth Tipler James Robert Whitworth W SC-R11-PC Shelby Criminal James C. Beasley, Jr Glenn, J. Denied - Application of James R. Whitworth 4

5 Mark and Cathalena Addaman Gwendolyn R. Lanford E SC-R11-CV Loudon Circuit Russell Simmons, Jr Swiney, J. Reversed and dismissed Denied - Application of Mark and Cathalena Addaman Thomas Fain Dalton Lynda Faye Dalton E SC-R11-CV McMinn Circuit John B. Hagler Franks, J. Modified Petition to Rehear Rule 11 Denial Denied - Application of Lynda Faye Dalton William Davidson Richard Holtzman, et al E SC-R11-CV Hamilton Criminal W. Frank Brown, III Susano, J. and Denied - Application of Richard Holtzman and Engel Stadium Local Union760 of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, et al The City of Harriman and The Harriman Utility Board E SC-R11-CV Roane Chancery Frank V. Williams, III Goddard, J. Denied - Applications of Local Union 706 of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, et al, the City of Harriman and the Harriman Utility Board, and the TN AFL-CIA Labor Council Messer Griesheim Industries, Inc., d/b/a MG Industries Cryotech of Kingsport, Inc., et al E SC-R11-CV Knox Circuit Wheeler A. Rosenbalm Susano, J. Denied - Application of Messer Griesheim Industries, Inc.; recommended that the opinion of the Court of Criminal Appeals be published. David Roberts Essex Microtel Associates II, L.P., d/b/a Microtel-Kingsport and Carmen Allen E SC-R11-CV Sullivan Circuit Richard E. Ladd C Swiney, J. Denied - Application of David Roberts 5

6 , et al Ralph E. Williams, Jr. E SC-R11-CV Hamilton Chancery W. Frank Brown, III Susano & Swiney, JJ. Dismissed Dismissed - Application of Ralph Williams Perry H. Young Hamilton County E SC-S10-CV Hamilton Circuit Franks, J. Rule 10 Denied Rule 10 Denied - Application of Perry H. Young Bruce Adams E SC-R11-CD Blount Circuit D. Kelly Thomas C-11410;C Witt, J., reversed & dismissed Denied - Application of Bruce Adams Randy Lee Bowers E SC-R11-CD Sullivan R. Jerry Beck S41,828 Williams, J. Denied - Application of Randy Lee Bowers John D. Brown E SC-R11-CD McMinn Criminal R. Steven Bebb Reversed Denied - Application of John D. Brown Nicholas Brown E SC-R11-CD Sevier Richard R. Vance 7624 Modified and Denied - Application of Nicholas Brown John Lee Dockery E SC-R11-CD Knox Richard Baumgartner Denied - Application of John Lee Dockery 6

7 John Clark Garrison E SC-R11-CD Knox Criminal Lynn Brown 45851, Williams, J. Denied - Application of John Clark Garrison Tony Allen Leonard E SC-R11-CD Sullivan Criminal R. Jerry Beck S40,612 Tipton, J. Denied - Application of Tony Allen Leonard Amos Phillips E SC-R11-CD Wade Phyllis H. Miller S41,666 Wade, J. Denied - Application of Amos Phillips Faron Douglas Pierce E SC-R11-CD Blount Circuit D. Kelly Thomas, Jr. C Wade, J. Denied - Application of Faron D. Pierce Bruce Monroe Stevenson E SC-R11-CD Bradley Criminal Carroll L. Ross M Wade, J. as modified Denied - Application of Bruce Monroe Stevenson Michael E. Christian E SC-R11-PC Sullivan Criminal R. Jerry Beck C41,052 Tipton, J. Denied - Application of Michael E. Christian Joseph Lebron Derrick E SC-R11-PC Hamilton Criminal Stephen M. Bevil Wedemeyer, J. Denied - Application of Joseph Lebron Derrick 7

8 Ronald E. Walton E SC-R11-PC Hamilton Criminal Douglas A. Meyer Williams, J. Denied - Application of Ronald E. Walton Kenneth Lee Weston E SC-R11-CO Morgan Criminal E. Eugene Eblen 8601 Denied - Application of Kenneth Lee Weston th The following Dismissals were filed the weeks of May 7th - May 11, 2001 STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTY TRIAL JUDGE TRIAL COURT NO. APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT NATURE OF APPEAL ACTION 8