In 1954, Arnold Harberger, who would later become a stalwart of the. University of Chicago economics department, produced a very influential
|
|
- Alaina Perkins
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 X-Efficiency and Ideology In 1954, Arnold Harberger, who would later become a stalwart of the University of Chicago economics department, produced a very influential article. He began: One of the first things we learn when we begin to study price theory is that the main effects of monopoly are to misallocate resources, to reduce aggregate welfare, and to redistribute income in favor of monopolists. In the light of this fact, it is a little curious that our empirical efforts at studying monopoly have so largely concentrated on other things. [Harberger 1954, p. 77] Harberger went on to show that markets were so efficient in allocating resources that any distortions created by monopoly were bound to be inconsequential -- at most 0.1 percent of the Gross National Product (Harberger 1954). The article continues to be quite influential, perhaps in part because Harberger used a simple graph showing the effect a change on a curve showing demand falling with an increasing price. This picture shows increasing profits for the monopolist, decreasing costs of inputs, increasing prices for consumers, and a relatively small triangle, which represented, for Harberger, the social costs of monopoly. Even today, virtually any economist will immediately understand the meaning of the expression, Harberger triangle. Harberger's lesson was that nobody should worry about business becoming monopolistic: the triangles are very small, one tenth of one 1
2 percent, by his estimates. Harberger casually dismissed the effect of monopoly on the distribution of income: I have not analyzed the redistributions of income that arise when monopoly is present... I leave [questions about income distribution] to my more metaphysically inclined colleagues to decide. [Harberger 1954, p. 87] A few years later, in 1962, the future Nobel laureate, Robert Mundell, reflected about Harberger's triangles. He worried that if distortions did so little damage, "some one inevitably will draw the conclusion that economics has ceased to be important!" (Mundell 1962, p. 622). A more serious response came from Harvey Leibenstein, a respected economics professor from Harvard University. Leibenstein argued that Harberger just looked at what would happen if monopolist raised prices little bit. By restricting himself to the marginal effect of price changes, Harberger lost sight of how the reduction of competitive pressures could let business become sloppy. Not taking full advantage of productive opportunities could have major effects. In effect, Harberger was only looking at the transactions side, what economists refer to as allocative efficiency. In contrast, Leibenstein pointed to the productive side of the economy. He cited numerous studies showing how similar plants produced quite dissimilar results. He postulated that there was something missing -- a kind of economic efficiency that went beyond allocative efficiency. Leibenstein could not fit his insight into formal economic models since he could not exactly pin it down. He called it 2
3 "X-efficiency" -- an illusion to the Russian novelist, Leo Tolstoy's War and Peace, which contained the observation: "Two armies may be identical in every observable respect..., yet one army, in possession of an intangible 'X-factor,' will soundly defeat the other." (Part XIV, II). While economists were unlikely to welcome Mundell's nightmare of economists sinking into irrelevancy, the Leibenstein's dissimilar efficiencies had even more uncomfortable implications. He was suggesting that firms do not maximize, undermining one of the central assumptions of academic economics. Leibenstein was unlikely rebel. He resigned from Berkeley after being repulsed by the campus turmoil of the 1960s (Perlman and Dean 1998, pp ). He was in no way intending to openly challenge conventional economics, but he made the mistake of making things difficult for economists who want to be able to reduce everything to simple equations. At the same time, he inadvertently opened the door to questions of work, workers, and working conditions. Leibenstein's article unleashed a volley of criticism. A retrospective on his work noted: Between 1969 and 1980, the article was the third most frequently cited in the Social Science Citation Index. However the second remarkable aspect is that much of this citation derived from attempts to explain X-efficiency theory away: it was under almost constant attack from much of the mainstream of the profession over that same dozen years. [Perlman and Dean 1998, p. 141] 3
4 Leibenstein's harshest critic was none other than George Stigler, who always stood ready to bully anybody who dared to stray too far from the conventional wisdom. Leibenstein was not immune from this treatment, which came in a caustically titled article, "The Xistence of X-Efficiency" (Stigler 1976). From one perspective, Stigler's vehemence in attacking X-efficiency is puzzling. Leibenstein's point was that barriers to competition -- barriers that most economists abhor, such as monopolistic practices or regulation -- can be wasteful. Stigler himself was a constant critic of regulation. Stigler's main point was that these differential efficiencies were an illusion. The different firms were producing different mixes of products for sale and other non-marketed outputs, "including leisure and health" (Stigler 1976, p. 213). Stigler did not mean the leisure and health of the workers, but their employers. Of course, if the subjective side of work were relevant for employers, such considerations would be relevant for workers. Quickly after inadvertently opening the door to consideration of work, workers, and working conditions, Stigler tried to slam that door shut with his concluding words: Unless one is prepared to take the mighty methodological leap into the unknown that a nonmaximizing theory requires, waste is not a useful economic concept. Waste is error within the framework of modern economic analysis, and it will not become a useful concept until we have a theory of error. [Stigler 4
5 1976, p. 216] In short, unless economists can wrestle waste into a simple mathematical box, economists must not take such a "mighty methodological leap." Leibenstein's sin was to suggest a line of research that would require economists to look into the way that things are produced rather than confining themselves to the transactional side of the market. Four years after Leibenstein's death, Arnold Harberger gave the presidential address to the American Economic Association on the subject of economic growth. Harberger began by downplaying the marginal perspective which was the centerpiece of his 1954 article: Many, maybe even most, economists expected that increments of output would be explained by increments of inputs, but when we took our best shot we found that traditional inputs typically fell far short of explaining the observed output growth. [Harberger 1998, p. 1] Harberger gave a telling example of the sort of productive improvements that fall through the usual net of economic analysis: I recall going through a clothing plant in Central America, where the owner informed me of a 20-percent reduction in real costs, following upon his installation of background music that played as the seamstresses worked. [Harberger 1998, p. 3] Harberger suggested two different metaphors for economic growth -- yeast and mushrooms: "yeast causes bread to expand very evenly, like a balloon being filled with air, while mushrooms have the habit of popping up, almost overnight, in a fashion that is not easy to predict" (Harberger 1998, 5
6 p. 4). Harberger must have understood as clearly as Stigler that conventional economics is not particularly useful in hunting mushrooms, such as finding the kind of music that might make the seamstresses work harder. Yet, as Harberger realized, such innovations, which cannot be quantified, can be very productive. The rest of his article ignored mushrooms, retreating to a relatively conventional analysis of the yeast-like bunching of technical change within particular industries. He blamed the poor performance of the lagging industries on an inability to perceive potential cost savings together with nod to the damage done by inflation, bad regulation, and protectionism. He never showed why these problems should vary among firms. In the end, Harberger was no more prepared than Stigler to deal with work, workers, and working conditions. References Dean, J. W. and Mark Perlman "Harvey Leibenstein as a Pioneer of Our Time." The Economic Journal, 108: 446 (January): pp Harberger, Arnold C "Monopoly and Resource Allocation." American Economic Review, 44 (May): pp "A Vision of the Growth Process." American Economic Review, 88: 1 (March): pp Mundell, Robert "Book Review: L. H. Janssen, Free Trade, Protection and Customs Union." American Economic Review, Vol. 52, No. 3 (June): pp Stigler, George J "The Xistence of X-Efficiency." American Economic Review, 66: 1, pp
Thorstein Bunde Veblen
Thorstein Bunde Veblen 1857-1929 1 Thorstein Bunde Veblen The Theory of the Leisure Class (1899) Theory of the Business Enterprise (1904) The Engineers and the Price System (1921) See http://www.hetwebsite.org/het/profil
More informationTechnologists and economists both think about the future sometimes, but they each have blind spots.
The Economics of Brain Simulations By Robin Hanson, April 20, 2006. Introduction Technologists and economists both think about the future sometimes, but they each have blind spots. Technologists think
More informationInformation Societies: Towards a More Useful Concept
IV.3 Information Societies: Towards a More Useful Concept Knud Erik Skouby Information Society Plans Almost every industrialised and industrialising state has, since the mid-1990s produced one or several
More informationUsing the General Equilibrium Growth Model to Study Great Depressions: A Rejoinder to Kehoe and Prescott. Peter Temin. Abstract
Using the General Equilibrium Growth Model to Study Great Depressions: A Rejoinder to Kehoe and Prescott Peter Temin Abstract The reply by Kehoe and Prescott restates their position but does not answer
More informationBook review: Profit and gift in the digital economy
Loughborough University Institutional Repository Book review: Profit and gift in the digital economy This item was submitted to Loughborough University's Institutional Repository by the/an author. Citation:
More informationTrump s Protectionism: A Great Leap Backward. James Petras. US Presidents, European leaders and their academic spokespeople have attributed
Trump s Protectionism: A Great Leap Backward James Petras Introduction US Presidents, European leaders and their academic spokespeople have attributed China s growing market shares, trade surpluses and
More informationMeasuring Income Inequality in Farm States: Weaknesses of the Gini Coefficient
Whitepaper No. 16006 Measuring Income Inequality in Farm States: Weaknesses of the Gini Coefficient April 28, 2016 Madelyn McGlynn, Gail Werner-Robertson Fellow Faculty Mentor: Dr. Ernie Goss EXECUTIVE
More informationArtists, Engineers, and Aspects of Economic Growth in a Creative Region
MPRA Munich Personal RePEc Archive Artists, Engineers, and Aspects of Economic Growth in a Creative Region Amitrajeet Batabyal and Hamid Beladi Rochester Institute of Technology, University of Texas at
More information17.181/ SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT Theory and Policy
17.181/17.182 SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT Theory and Policy Department of Political Science Fall 2016 Professor N. Choucri 1 ` 17.181/17.182 Week 1 Introduction-Leftover Item 1. INTRODUCTION Background Early
More informationMath Matters: Why Do I Need To Know This?
Math Matters: Why Do I Need To Know This? Bruce Kessler, Department of Mathematics Western Kentucky University Episode One 1 Introduction Hi, I m Bruce Kessler and welcome to Math Matters. This is a bold
More informationSUBSCRIBE NOW AND RECEIVE CRISIS AND LEVIATHAN* FREE!
SUBSCRIBE NOW AND RECEIVE CRISIS AND LEVIATHAN* FREE! The Independent Review does not accept pronouncements of government officials nor the conventional wisdom at face value. JOHN R. MACARTHUR, Publisher,
More informationConnections with Leading Thinkers. Academic Carlos Arruda discusses the problems that must be surmounted to boost innovation in Brazil s economy.
Connections with Leading Thinkers Academic Carlos Arruda discusses the problems that must be surmounted to boost innovation in Brazil s economy. Carlos Arruda is a professor of Innovation and Competitiveness
More informationAC : ENGINEERING ECONOMY FOR ECONOMISTS
AC 2008-2866: ENGINEERING ECONOMY FOR ECONOMISTS Peter Boerger, Engineering Economic Associates, LLC Peter Boerger is an independent consultant specializing in solving problems that incorporate both technological
More informationOesterreichische Nationalbank. Eurosystem. Workshops Proceedings of OeNB Workshops. Current Issues of Economic Growth. March 5, No.
Oesterreichische Nationalbank Eurosystem Workshops Proceedings of OeNB Workshops Current Issues of Economic Growth March 5, 2004 No. 2 Opinions expressed by the authors of studies do not necessarily reflect
More informationClass 3 - Getting Quality Clients
Class 3 - Getting Quality Clients Hi! Welcome to Class Number Three of Bookkeeper Business Launch! I want to thank you for being here. I want to thank you for your comments and your questions for the first
More informationState Content Standards for Florida
Episode 101 What Is a Biz Kid? Episode 102 What Is Money? Episode 103 How Do You Get Money? Episode 104 What Can You Do with Money? Episode 105 Money Moves Episode 106 Taking Charge of Your Financial Future
More informationRevised Course Outlines & Pattern of Examinations in the subject of Economics for BA/B.Sc. w.e.f. 1 st Annual Examinations 2018 & onwards
Annexure - 1 Revised Course Outlines & Pattern of Examinations in the subject of Economics for BA/B.Sc. w.e.f. 1 st Annual Examinations 2018 & onwards Paper A: Microeconomics &Basic Mathematical Economics
More informationThorstein Veblen, the Provisioning Process, and the Need for a Job Guarantee Program
Working Paper No. 101 November 2014 Thorstein Veblen, the Provisioning Process, and the Need for a Job Guarantee Program John F. Henry Research Scholar, Binzagr Institute for Sustainable Prosperity Adjunct
More informationThe Deception of the Eye and the Brain
PROJECT N 12 The Deception of the Eye and the Brain Elisa Lazzaroli, Abby Korter European School Luxembourg I Boulevard Konrad Adenauer, 23, 1115, Luxembourg, Luxembourg S3 EN Abstract Key words: Optical
More informationResearch of Tender Control Price in Oil and Gas Drilling Engineering Based on the Perspective of Two-Part Tariff
4th International Education, Economics, Social Science, Arts, Sports and Management Engineering Conference (IEESASM 06) Research of Tender Control Price in Oil and Gas Drilling Engineering Based on the
More informationHuman Capital and Industrial Development in Africa
AfDB Pre-TICAD7 Knowledge Event Human Capital and Industrial Development in Africa Keijiro Otsuka Professor of Development Economics, Kobe University September 26, 2018 Contents Part I: Development Paths
More informationBASED ECONOMIES. Nicholas S. Vonortas
KNOWLEDGE- BASED ECONOMIES Nicholas S. Vonortas Center for International Science and Technology Policy & Department of Economics The George Washington University CLAI June 9, 2008 Setting the Stage The
More informationUnit 1: The Economic Fundamentals Weeks How does scarcity impact the decisions individuals and societies must make?
Economics Teacher: Vida Unit 1: The Economic Fundamentals Weeks 1-4 Essential Questions 1. How does scarcity impact the decisions individuals and societies must make? 2. What roles do individuals and businesses
More information[Existential Risk / Opportunity] Singularity Management
[Existential Risk / Opportunity] Singularity Management Oct 2016 Contents: - Alexei Turchin's Charts of Existential Risk/Opportunity Topics - Interview with Alexei Turchin (containing an article by Turchin)
More informationInformation Technology and the New Globalization: Asia's economy today and tomorrow. Lawrence J. LAU
Information Technology and the New Globalization: Asia's economy today and tomorrow Lawrence J. LAU Ralph and Claire Landau Professor of Economics, The Chinese University of Hong Kong http://www.rieti.go.jp/en/index.html
More informationDoes Russia Need a Tom Sawyer Strategy for Economic Growth?
Does Russia Need a Tom Sawyer Strategy for Economic Growth? Although they agree about little else, Russia s current leaders and their liberal critics share one firmly-held belief: To secure high growth
More informationChapter 8. Technology and Growth
Chapter 8 Technology and Growth The proximate causes Physical capital Population growth fertility mortality Human capital Health Education Productivity Technology Efficiency International trade 2 Plan
More informationMathematical Bioeconomics and the
Mathematical Bioeconomics and the Evolution of Fisheries Economics Revisited Gordon Munro Department of Economics and Fisheries Centre, University of British Columbia; CEMARE, University of Portsmouth
More informationBUSINESS EMPLOYMENT DYNAMICS
BUSINESS EMPLOYMENT DYNAMICS First Quarter 2018 Office of Research Kurt Westby, Commissioner Andrew Condon, Director of Research WETHERSFIELD, November 7th, 2018 - (BED) data published quarterly by the
More information-opoly cash simulation
DETERMINING THE PATTERNS AND IMPACT OF NATURAL PROPERTY GROUP DEVELOPMENT IN -OPOLY TYPE GAMES THROUGH COMPUTER SIMULATION Chuck Leska, Department of Computer Science, cleska@rmc.edu, (804) 752-3158 Edward
More informationInterview with Brian Hamilton '90, Co-founder and CEO of Sageworks
Interview with Brian Hamilton '90, Co-founder and CEO of Sageworks Interview by Howie Rhee '04 You went to Sacred Heart University for your undergraduate degree. What did you study and were you involved
More informationSamuelson s Mistake. How to Correct it and Maintain Prosperity for All. c Roger E. A. Farmer. 20th October FMM Conference Presentation
Samuelson s Mistake How to Correct it and Maintain Prosperity for All c Roger E. A. Farmer FMM Conference Presentation 20th October 2016 c Roger E. A. Farmer (FMM Conference Presentation) Samuelson s Mistake
More informationUpdating to remain the same: Habitual new media [Book Review]
Loughborough University Institutional Repository Updating to remain the same: Habitual new media [Book Review] This item was submitted to Loughborough University's Institutional Repository by the/an author.
More informationArte Numérica -- Serviços Informáticos, Lda
Dear Sir or Madam: "Arte Numérica -- Serviços Informáticos, Lda" is a small Portuguese company which provides services and custom solutions in several computing fields (including, but not limited to, web
More informationThe relationship between Gold Raid Team and World of Warcraft s Economy On Chinese. Servers. Han Li. WRIT 1133 class. University of Denver
1 The relationship between Gold Raid Team and World of Warcraft s Economy On Chinese Servers Han Li WRIT 1133 class University of Denver 1 2 Background Introduction NCTY was the operator of WoW in China,
More informationClaiming compensation after an accident at work. A guide to help you and your family get the most from your claim
Claiming compensation after an accident at work A guide to help you and your family get the most from your claim INTRODUCTION Though health and safety standards have improved over the years, accidents
More informationFinancial Goal Setting Workbook
Financial Goal Setting Workbook How To Set Financial Goals That Actually Make You Happy From The Ways To Wealth By: R.J. Weiss CFP Introduction Life moves pretty fast. If you don t stop and look around
More informationAn Uneven Planet. Globalization, Capital, & Inequality in the 21 st Century
An Uneven Planet Globalization, Capital, & Inequality in the 21 st Century Today s Discussion Brief Review Globalization The Problem of Inequality Picketty & the Politics of Redistribution Brief Review
More informationHow U.S. Employment Is Changing
December 1, 211 How U.S. Employment Is Changing Stephen P. A. Brown and Hui Liu During the most recent recession, U.S. employment fell by 7,49 million jobs (5.4 percent). During the first 8 months of the
More informationChapter 30: Game Theory
Chapter 30: Game Theory 30.1: Introduction We have now covered the two extremes perfect competition and monopoly/monopsony. In the first of these all agents are so small (or think that they are so small)
More informationIs Real Estate the Right Career for You?
Is Real Estate the Right Career for You? Introduction: Real estate can be an exciting, highly profitable career if you have the right combination of skills, traits, a strong work ethic, a commitment to
More informationHow economists apply the methods of science. Two simple models the circular flow and the production possibilities frontier.
CHPATER 2 Thinking Like an Economist LEARNING OBJECTIVES: How economists apply the methods of science. Two simple models the circular flow and the production possibilities frontier. The difference between
More informationINTRODUCTION. The 2015 Brookings Blum Roundtable was convened to explore how digital technologies might disrupt global development.
INTRODUCTION The 2015 Brookings Blum Roundtable was convened to explore how digital technologies might disrupt global development. Our intention was to imagine a world 10 years from now where digital technologies
More informationDr Fiona McSweeney and Dr Dave Williams Dublin Institute of Technology
Dr Fiona McSweeney and Dr Dave Williams Dublin Institute of Technology Literature suggests that the transition to practice has not being investigated with social care practitioners. Asking students about
More informationOptimum Population Size
Optimum Population Size Not too big, not too small, but just right Econ/Demog c175 Lecture 2 Spring 2018 1 Our agenda What do we mean by the optimum? Two specific examples from Sauvy: economic optimum
More informationLesson II Seeing Budgeting Clearly
1 Lesson II Seeing Budgeting Clearly Anybody recall any characteristics of a marketing economy? Can anybody recall any characteristics of a marketing economy? Andrea? [ responds, The individuals like determine
More informationGift Basket Business Development Series From Gift Basket Network Construct Your Business with a One-page Business Plan
Gift Basket Business Development Series From Gift Basket Network Construct Your Business with a One-page Business Plan Joyce Reid The One Page Business Plan Only you know yourself and your business so
More informationUnionization, Innovation, and Licensing. Abstract
Unionization Innovation and Licensing Arijit Mukherjee School of Business and Economics Loughborough University UK. Leonard F.S. Wang Department of Applied Economics National University of Kaohsiung and
More informationThe Seeds That Seymour Sowed. Mitchel Resnick Professor of Learning Research MIT Media Lab
The Seeds That Seymour Sowed Mitchel Resnick Professor of Learning Research MIT Media Lab In writing about Seymour Papert, I want to look forward, not backwards. How can we make sure that Seymour s ideas
More informationand R&D Strategies in Creative Service Industries: Online Games in Korea
RR2007olicyesearcheportInnovation Characteristics and R&D Strategies in Creative Service Industries: Online Games in Korea Choi, Ji-Sun DECEMBER, 2007 Science and Technology Policy Institute P Summary
More informationCompetition Policy and Sector-Specific Regulation for Network Industries. November 2004
1 Martin Hellwig Max Planck Institute for Research on Collective Goods Bonn Competition Policy and Sector-Specific Regulation for Network Industries November 2004 1. Introduction: Changing Paradigms of
More information12 Themes of the New Economy
DIGITAL ECONOMY! In this new economy, digital networking and communication infrastructures provide a global platform over which people and organizations devise strategies, interact, communicate, collaborate
More informationHigh School Program Standards Map. Physical Science. Georgia Performance Content Standards by Lesson. Page 1 of 10 SMART GRID SMART ENERGY
Heat and Your Air and Your POWER CHOICES Physical Science SPS1. Students will investigate our current understanding of the atom. SPS1a. Eamine the structure of the atom in terms of - proton, electron,
More informationBehaviors That Revolve Around Working Effectively with Others Behaviors That Revolve Around Work Quality
Behaviors That Revolve Around Working Effectively with Others 1. Give me an example that would show that you ve been able to develop and maintain productive relations with others, thought there were differing
More informationPrivate Equity and Long Run Investments: The Case of Innovation. Josh Lerner, Morten Sorensen, and Per Stromberg
Private Equity and Long Run Investments: The Case of Innovation Josh Lerner, Morten Sorensen, and Per Stromberg Motivation We study changes in R&D and innovation for companies involved in buyout transactions.
More informationFrequency analysis put into practice
Technically, guitar strings, audio amplifiers, filters or rotating shafts are one and the same, namely signal sources. These contain substantial information. The content is decoded during the oscilloscopic
More informationNetwork Economics and the Future of Electric Power. Lynne Kiesling Northwestern University IRLE May 2010
Network Economics and the Future of Electric Power Lynne Kiesling Northwestern University IRLE May 2010 Game plan Overview/refresher on natural monopoly theory as the economic foundation of regulation
More informationMeasuring Income Inequality in Farm States: Weaknesses of The Gini Coefficient
Whitepaper No. 16006 Measuring Income Inequality in Farm States: Weaknesses of The Gini Coefficient April 28, 2016 Madelyn McGlynn, Gail Werner-Robertson Fellow Faculty Mentor: Dr. Ernest Goss Executive
More informationI. INTRODUCTION A. CAPITALIZING ON BASIC RESEARCH
I. INTRODUCTION For more than 50 years, the Department of Defense (DoD) has relied on its Basic Research Program to maintain U.S. military technological superiority. This objective has been realized primarily
More informationNEW ASSOCIATION IN BIO-S-POLYMER PROCESS
NEW ASSOCIATION IN BIO-S-POLYMER PROCESS Long Flory School of Business, Virginia Commonwealth University Snead Hall, 31 W. Main Street, Richmond, VA 23284 ABSTRACT Small firms generally do not use designed
More informationThe Vocation and Career Map
The Vocation and Career Map The Vocation and Career Map shows geographic areas where you are more likely to attract good employment and business opportunities into your life. Areas on the map that are
More informationThe Circle of Frustration. Why is it so difficult?
Alex Vorobieff Transform Your Company Introduction The Circle of Frustration Start at the (Real) Beginning Unclogging the Sewer Bringing Clarity to Chaos The Process Plot Your Course The Circle of Frustration
More informationA Ragged Freak. I m glad of that. I don t want to be ignorant. I didn t use to care, but I do now. I want
Katona 1 Emily Katona Professor Ings English 333 September 25, 2009 A Ragged Freak I m glad of that. I don t want to be ignorant. I didn t use to care, but I do now. I want to grow up spectable (Alger
More informationConstant returns to scale and economic theories of value
MPRA Munich Personal RePEc Archive Constant returns to scale and economic theories of value Nadeem Naqvi American University in Bulgaria 2007 Online at http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/5306/ MPRA Paper No.
More informationOptimum Population Size
Optimum Population Size Not too big, not too small, but just right Econ/Demog c175 Prof. Josh Goldstein Lecture 2 (version 1.1) Spring 2019 1 Our agenda What do we mean by the optimum? Two specific examples
More informationCircular economy Reducing negative symptoms or increasing positive synergy? It depends on ontology and epistemology
Circular economy Reducing negative symptoms or increasing positive synergy? It depends on ontology and epistemology For the special track on ecological management Word count: 1345 Amsale Temesgen, Vivi
More informationGeneral aspects of the technological approach to international trade
General aspects of the technological approach to international trade Innovation and Trade Shumpeter: the entrepreneur-innovator has a key role in the introduction of new goods and technology in the economy
More informationUA11/1 Architecture, Like a Jigsaw Puzzle; Frank Cain Remembers WKU
Western Kentucky University TopSCHOLAR WKU Archives Records WKU Archives 3-16-1994 UA11/1 Architecture, Like a Jigsaw Puzzle; Frank Cain Remembers WKU Karen Moss Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.wku.edu/dlsc_ua_records
More informationINTERNET AND SOCIETY: A PRELIMINARY REPORT
IT&SOCIETY, VOLUME 1, ISSUE 1, SUMMER 2002, PP. 275-283 INTERNET AND SOCIETY: A PRELIMINARY REPORT NORMAN H. NIE LUTZ ERBRING ABSTRACT (Data Available) The revolution in information technology (IT) has
More information2010 Alabama Course of Study for Social Studies - Economics & Common Core Standards for Literacy in History/Social Studies
Two Correlations Economics Alabama Edition 2015 To the 2010 Alabama Course of Study for Social Studies - Economics & Common Core Standards for Literacy in History/Social Studies Table of Contents Alabama
More informationThe invention of new machines in Great Britain led to the beginning of the Industrial
Chapter 12: The North The industrial revolution The invention of new machines in Great Britain led to the beginning of the Industrial Revolution: a period of rapid growth in using machines for manufacturing
More informationThe Finding Respect and Ending Stigma around HIV (FRESH) Study Intervention Post-Workshop Survey Community Participants
The Finding Respect and Ending Stigma around HIV (FRESH) Study Intervention Post-Workshop Survey Community Participants Date: / / Study ID Number: Thank you for participating in this study. Please fill
More informationSome Thoughts on Changing Comparative Advantage
Some Thoughts on Changing Comparative Advantage Gerard K. Boon Introduction In the next two decades the pace of automation in the industrialised countries will increase significantly as a consequence of
More informationGLAMURS Green Lifestyles, Alternative Models and Upscaling Regional Sustainability. Case Study Exchange
Acta Univ. Sapientiae, Social Analysis, 5, 1 (2015) 113 118 GLAMURS Green Lifestyles, Alternative Models and Upscaling Regional Sustainability. Case Study Exchange Adela FOFIU Babeş Bolyai University,
More informationDoes economics need a scientific revolution?
Does economics need a scientific revolution? Ivan O. Kitov, IDG RAS Abstract Economics does not need a scientific revolution. Economics needs accurate measurements according to high standards of natural
More informationTren ds i n Nuclear Security Assessm ents
2 Tren ds i n Nuclear Security Assessm ents The l ast deca de of the twentieth century was one of enormous change in the security of the United States and the world. The torrent of changes in Eastern Europe,
More informationCPET 575 Management Of Technology. Patterns of Industrial Innovation
CPET 575 Management Of Technology Lecture on Reading II-1 Patterns of Industrial Innovation, William J. Abernathy and James M. Utterback Source: MIT Technology Review, 1978 Paul I-Hai Lin, Professor http://www.etcs.ipfw.edu/~lin
More informationTHE EVOLUTION OF TECHNOLOGY DIFFUSION AND THE GREAT DIVERGENCE
2014 BROOKINGS BLUM ROUNDTABLE SESSION III: LEAP-FROGGING TECHNOLOGIES FRIDAY, AUGUST 8, 10:50 A.M. 12:20 P.M. THE EVOLUTION OF TECHNOLOGY DIFFUSION AND THE GREAT DIVERGENCE Diego Comin Harvard University
More informationThe Economics of Leisure and Recreation
The Economics of Leisure and Recreation STUDIES IN PLANNING AND CONTROL General Editors B. T. Bayliss, B.Sc.(Econ.), Ph.D. Director, Centre for European Industrial Studies University of Bath and G. M.
More informationMay 10, 2016, NSF-Census Research Network, Census Bureau. Research supported by NSF grant SES
A 2016 View of 2020 Census Quality, Costs, Benefits Bruce D. Spencer Department of Statistics and Institute for Policy Research Northwestern University May 10, 2016, NSF-Census Research Network, Census
More informationResource Allocation and Decision Analysis (ECON 8010) Spring 2014 Foundations of Game Theory
Resource Allocation and Decision Analysis (ECON 8) Spring 4 Foundations of Game Theory Reading: Game Theory (ECON 8 Coursepak, Page 95) Definitions and Concepts: Game Theory study of decision making settings
More informationRailroads and Rise of Big Business. Age. Transcontinental Railroad. Term coined by
Railroads and Rise of Big Business Age Term coined by Refers to last quarter of the 19th century Looked glitzy, but not pure Transcontinental Railroad Central Pacific and Union Pacific Railroads met at
More informationLEGAL TRANSFORMATION STUDY
LEGAL TRANSFORMATION STUDY EXECUTIVE SUMMARY YOUR 2020 VISION OF THE FUTURE Legal Transformation Study 1 Fast Forward The year is 2020. Imagine where you will be and what you will be doing. Perhaps in
More informationEcon 911 Midterm Exam. Greg Dow February 27, Please answer all questions (they have equal weight).
Econ 911 Midterm Exam Greg Dow February 27, 2013 Please answer all questions (they have equal weight). 1. Consider the Upper Paleolithic economy and the modern Canadian economy. What are the main ways
More informationR&D in WorldScan. Paul Veenendaal
R&D in WorldScan Paul Veenendaal Outline WorldScan characteristics How is R&D modelled? Spillover estimates and their implications Extension: R&D workers are difficult to attract Lisbon agenda targets
More informationThis file was downloaded from BI Open Archive, the institutional repository at BI Norwegian Business School
This file was downloaded from BI Open Archive, the institutional repository at BI Norwegian Business School http://brage.bibsys.no/bi. It contains the accepted and peer reviewed manuscript to the article
More information14.54 International Trade Lecture 2: The Basics
14.54 International Trade Lecture 2: The Basics 14.54 Week 2 Fall 2016 14.54 (Week 2) The Basics Fall 2016 1 / 36 Today s Plan 1 2 What Does the World Economy Look Like? 1 2 What does the world trade?
More informationMessages from the Millennials. Results from Accenture s High Performance IT Research in the Netherlands
Messages from the Millennials Results from Accenture s High Performance IT Research in the Netherlands Contents Executive summary...2 Key findings...3 Implications for CIOs...9 About this study...10 1
More informationAfter putting your best work and thoughts and
How to Read and Respond to a Journal Rejection Letter After putting your best work and thoughts and efforts into a manuscript and sending it off for publication, the day of decision arrives. As you open
More informationGETTING TO KNOW GP:!! AN OVERVIEW! * * *!
GETTING TO KNOW GP:!! AN OVERVIEW! * * *! PowerPoint Credits: RESEARCH & DESIGN Jill Pavich, NBCT RESOURCES Cambridge International Examinations CIE MATERIALS Sample Test handout PART 1: The GP Exam u
More informationQUANTITATIVE ASSESSMENT OF INSTITUTIONAL INVENTION CYCLE
QUANTITATIVE ASSESSMENT OF INSTITUTIONAL INVENTION CYCLE Maxim Vlasov Svetlana Panikarova Abstract In the present paper, the authors empirically identify institutional cycles of inventions in industrial
More informationCharissa Quade. CookWithAShoe.com
Charissa Quade CookWithAShoe.com Like many people, Charissa Quade was once a person who hated budgeting because it made her feel like a failure with money. She realized the opposite is true. Budgeting
More informationThe Future of Intangibles
The Future of Intangibles Prof. Hannu Piekkola University of Vaasa Finland Safe and Ethical Cyberspace, digital assets and risks: How to assess the intangible impacts of a growing phenomenon? UNESCO, June
More informationLearning Outcomes 2. Key Concepts 2. Misconceptions and Teaching Challenges 3. Vocabulary 4. Lesson and Content Overview 5
UNIT 9 GUIDE Table of Contents Learning Outcomes 2 Key Concepts 2 Misconceptions and Teaching Challenges 3 Vocabulary 4 Lesson and Content Overview 5 BIG HISTORY PROJECT / UNIT 9 GUIDE 1 Unit 9 Acceleration
More informationFoundations for Functions
Activity: Spaghetti Regression Activity 1 TEKS: Overview: Background: A.2. Foundations for functions. The student uses the properties and attributes of functions. The student is expected to: (D) collect
More informationGauging the likelihood for acceptance of a paper submitted to the Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
Gauging the likelihood for acceptance of a paper submitted to the Journal of the Acoustical Society of America Allan D. Pierce Acoustical Society of America! May 17, 2012! Hong Kong! To write or not to
More informationHow new is the new VCE Economics Study Design?
A TEACHER S GUIDE Implementing the new VCE Economics Study Design with the Economics Down Under series From January 2017, teachers will be working with an exciting and new VCE Economics Study Design for
More informationBig Businesses, Technology, and Labor Unions. Unit 6 SSUSH11
Big Businesses, Technology, and Labor Unions Unit 6 SSUSH11 Following the Civil War and Reconstruction Cities like Atlanta, Georgia and Dallas, Texas become significant railroad hubs and manufacturing
More informationObjectives ECONOMIC GROWTH CHAPTER
9 ECONOMIC GROWTH CHAPTER Objectives After studying this chapter, you will able to Describe the long-term growth trends in the United States and other countries and regions Identify the main sources of
More informationTactics at Different Forms of Scoring
Tactics at Different Forms of Scoring By Brian Senior To the club player, bridge is bridge, and most play the same way whatever the form of scoring. The tournament player may not be fully conversant with
More information