MCELROY, DEUTSCH, MULVANEY &CARPENTER, LLP ATTORNEYS A'C LAW

Transcription

1 MCELROY, DEUTSCH, MULVANEY &CARPENTER, LLP ATTORNEYS A'C LAW 1300 MOUNT KEMBLE AVENUE P.O. BOX 2075 MORRISTOWN, NEW JERSEY (973) FACSIMILE (973) JOSEPH P. LA SALA Direct dial: (973) August 18, 2017 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL and ELECTRONIC FILING Laurence V. Nassif, Esq. Simmons Hanly Conroy LLC 112 Madison Avenue New York, NY Re: NYCAL October 2017 In-Extre~zis Trial Group Wayne Peer v. A.O. Smith Water Products Co., et al. Index No.: !2017 MDMC File No.: R Dear Mr. Nassif: As you are aware, this firm represents Defendant Robertshaw Controls Company ("Robertshaw"), in the above referenced matter. Our review of the file reveals that Robertshaw was not identified as a source of plaintiffs exposure to asbestos-containing products. Therefore, in accordance with CMO Amendment Re: No Opposition Summary Judgment Motion and Order ("ivtos3iv~"), Gated December 1~, 2G01, I request that you kindly execute the enclosed IvT~S3i~i and return the original to my attention in the enclosed envelope within ten days as provided for by the July 23, 2001 amendment to the Case Management Order. Please do not hesitate to contact me should you have any questions. Thank you for your courtesies. Very truly yours, MCELROY, DEUTSCH, MULVANEY &CARPENTER, LLP,~ ~ I, ~t) ': K-t ~ f ~ ~ 1: r~ -~ /,~~ "` -ter i- f 1~ f C,~ ( ~ Joseph P. ~,a Sala JPLS/sg Enclosures cc: All Counsel on Attached Service List (via electronic filing) NEW JERSf~Y N} W YORK PENNSYLVANIA CONNECTICUT MASSACHUSETTS COLORADO DELAWARE FLORIDf~

2 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNZ~Y OF NEW YORK IN RE: NEW YORK COUNTY ASBF_,STOS LITIGATION "I~his Document Relates to: NYCAL I.A.S. Part 46 (Billings, L.) Index No.: /2017 WAYNE YFER ANll ANN PFFR 1~1(~ ~~'P~~I~~~I+~ SL11~lII~IA~~~' ~~ ~ij ~ ~~ I~ E1~1T li~~ ~'TI OIL Ali I~ ORI)EIZ WHEREFORE, Defendant Robertshaw Controls Company ("Robertshaw"), hereby I'eC1t1CStS StlIl1I11dI'y JUCigment in the above-entitled case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules Section 3212, dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against Robertshaw, with prejudice, and there being no opposition thereto. ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against Defendant Robertshaw be and the same ire hereby dismissed with prejudice and without costs. Dated: New York, New' York 2017 Laurence V. Nassif, Esq Attorneys for Plaintiffs Simmons Hanly Conroy LLC 112 Madison Avenue New York, NY loseph P. La Sala, Esq. McElroy, Deutsch, Mulvaney &Carpenter, L Attorneys for Defendant Robertshaw Controls Company 225 Liberty St., 36if' Floor New York, New York S4 ORDERED, I-Ion. Lucy Billings

3 St1PREME COURT OF TH1J STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK IN RE: NEW YORK COUNTY ASBESTOS LITIGATION This Document Relates to: ~VAYNE PEER A~NI) AN1~1 1'~EIZ NYCAL I.A.S. Part 46 (Billings, L.) Index No.: / AFFIDAVIT Off' ~~]][~~~~'E STATE OF NEW JERSEY ) COtTN"l,Y OF MORRIS ) ss: ODESSA ALFANO, being duly sworn, deposes and says: That deponent is not a party to t}zis action, is Duet- 18-years of ale and is employed at McElroy, Deutsch, Mulvaney, & Carpenter, LLP, 1300 Mount Kemble Avenue, Morristown, New.lersey Further, deponent delivered nn August ~, 2017, true copies of the No Opposition Summary Judgment Motions and Orders, via electronic filing and first class mail upon: Laurence V. Nassif, Esq Simmons Hanly Conroy LLC 112 Madison Avenue New York, NY Attorneys for Plaintiffs and by electronic filing, directed to the following: ALL DEFENSE COUNSEL of record on the attached service list being the address designated by said attorneys for that purpose. ODESSA ALFANO Sworn t~ and subscribed before me this ~ day of August, 2017 Notary lic ~9~L~~ ~CAL9~~~~'~ N(~T~1RY PU~LI~ OF i~~111/ Jr~~~Y ~y Commission Expires 04/Q7/2019

4 Master Service Lis# for : Peer, Wayne Case# '17 This is to certify that a copy of the following has been served upon the following: 1. Hand Delivery 2. Facsimile Transmission 3. Placing same in an envelope with postage prepaid, plainly addressed to each attorney and by depositing same in a U.S. Mailbox 4. Court E-Service this day of 2417 by: (Simmons Hanly Canroy) Representing Firms (Copies: 26) Barry McTiernan &Moore LLC Clemente Mueller PA Cullen ~ Dykman LLP CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC. 2 Rector Street, 14th Floor New York, NY 1000fi ~~ Phane: (212} ~~ F2~x: (212}6~ ~J One Touch: 165 Suzanne M. Halbardier 1NILLlAM POWELL COMPANY 5 Penn Plaza, 19th Floor New York, NY '[0001 ~~ Phone: X212) William F Mueller GOULDS PUMPS, INCORPORATED 44 Walt Street New York, NY 1U40~ ~~ Phone: {2'f2) Q ~~ Fax: {212y ~~ One Touch: 18~ Darger Errante Yavitz &Blau LL.P John J Fanning (jfanning@cullenanddykman.com} CERTAfN-TEED CORPORATION ~~ C04PER INDUSTRIES LLC ~~ HOPEMAN BROTHERS, INC. ~~ UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION 116 East 27th Street 12th Floor New York, NY ~~ Phone: (212) ~~ Fax: (212) ~~ One Touch: 166 Jessica J Beauvais ~~ Judith A Yavitz (jyavifz@deybllp.com) Flemming Zulack Williamson Zaudere~ LLP CROWN CORK &SEAL COMPANY, INC, One Liberty Plaza New York, NY ~~ Phone: {212) ~~ Fax: (212) ~~ One Touch: 210 Gordfln &Rees Scully Mansukhani, LLP Harr(s Beach PLLC Grant A Shehigian (gshehigian@fzwz.com) CARRIER CORPORATION individually and as successor-in-interest to BRYANT HEATING &COOLING SYSTEMS One BaEtery Park Plaza, 28th Floar New Yark, NY ~t00u4 ~~ Phone: (212y Virginia Squitieri COOPER INDUSTRIES LLC 'f00 Wal! Street, 23rd Floor New York, NY 'E0005 ~J Phone: (212)687-~'f00 Abbie E Fuchs (afuchs@harrisbeach.cam} ~~ Eric H Lindenman (elindenman@harrisbeach.com} SCEQ# 374$67 Case# /2017 Peer, Wayne 02!28/2017 Page 7 of 5

5 Master Service list for : Peer, Wayne Case# /2017 RepresenEing Firms (Copies: 26) Hodges Walsh & Messemer LLP K&L Gates LLP COPES-VULCAN, INC. ~~ JERGUSON GAGE &VALVE COMPANY ~~ SPIRAX SARCO, INC. 55 Church Street White Plains, NY ~~ Phone: (914f ~~ Fax: (994} ~{ One Tauch: 257 CRANE C4. George S Hodges 599 Lexington Ave New York, NY ~~ Phone: (212} E~ Fax; {212} ~~ One Touch: 167 Eric R. I. Cottle (eric.cottle@klgates.com} Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli Hanna 8~ Reber LLP Leader $ Berican LLP MarEn Goodman LlP FMC CORPORATION 120 Wall Street, 34th Floor Newyork, NY ~~ Phone: (212) ~~ Fax: (212) (~ One Touch: 212 Christopher P Hannan (channan@kjmsh.com)!mo INDUSTRIES inc. ~J WARREN PUMPS LI Third Avenue New York, NY ~C Phone: {212) ~) Fax: {212} ~~ One Touch: 196 David J Goodear! (dgoodearl@leaderberkon.cam} fndustrial HOLDINGS CORP~RATl~N f/k/a THE CARB~RUNDUM COMPANY 500 Mamaroneck Ave Suite 501 Harrison, NY j~ Phone: (212)6fi ~~ Fax: (212) ~~ One Touch. 219 Richard P Marin Maron Marvel Bradley &Anderson LLC VELAN VALVE CORPORATION 328 Newman Springs Road Red Bank, NJ ~~ Phone: ~~ Fax: Stefan G Bourn ~J Timothy Coughlan (tcoughlan@maronmarvel.com ) Marshall Dennehey Warner Coleman & Goggin PC BORGWARNER MORSE TEC LLC, as successor-by-merger to BORG-WARNER CORPORATfON 105 Maxess Road, Suife 303 Melville, NY ~~ Phone: (631) ~) Fax: {639} j~ One Touch: 180 McDermott, Will, 8 Emery, LLP Anna M DiLonardo (amdilonarda@mdwcg.com) HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC., f/kla ALLIED SIGNAL, INC. as successor-in-interest to THE BENDlX CORPORATION 340 Madison Avenue New York, NY ~~ Fax: {2't2~ ~~ Qne Touch: 183 Donald R Pugiiese SCEQ# Case# /2017 Peer, Wayne Page 2 of 5

6 z Master Service List for : Peer, Wayne Case# '19UU Representing Firms {Copies: 26) McElroy Deutsch Mulvaney 8~ Carpenter LLP McGivney & Kluger, P.C. FLOWSERVE US INC., solely as successor to EDWARD VALVES INC., ROCKWELL MANUFACTURENG COMPANY, NORDSTROM VALVES INC. and MCCANNA CORPORATION Wall Street Plaza 88 Pine Street, 24th Floor New Yark, NY ~~ Phone: (212) ~~ fax: (212) ~~ One Touch: 170 Brian Sorensen DRAVO CORPORATION ~~ FL~WSERVE CORPORATION as successor to DURIR~N inc. and DURC4 INTERNATIONAL INC. ~~ WEIR VALVES &CONTROLS USA, INC., d/b/a ATWOOD & MORRILL 80 Broad Street-23rd Floor New York, NY ~~ Phone: X212}5U ~~ Fax: {2 2) (j One Touch: 171 Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP Chauvron S. Leataud ~~ Nicole F' Wesselmann ELLIOTT COMPANY 101 Park Avenue New York, NY ~~ Phone: (292)3U ~~ Cell: (977}379-86'f3 ~~ Fax: (212) One Touch: 206 Mound Cotton Wolian & Greengrass LLP Beth ~. Hughes (beth.hughes@rnorganlewis.com} ~) Brady Edwards (beclwards@morganlewis.com} COC}PER INDUSTRfES LLC One New York Plaza New York, NY (~ Phone: X212} ~~ Fax: (2'i2} John F Parker ()parker@moundcotfan.com) ~~ Michael 7 Lynch Pascarella Divi#a Lindenbaum & Tomaszewski PLLC lngersoll-rand COMPANY 2137 Rou#e 35 Suite 290 Nolmdel, N.i ~~ Phone: (732} ~~ Fax: X732) ~E One Touch: 197 Lisa M Pascarelia (Ipascarella@pol#Iaw.com) Segal McCambridge Singer &Mahoney, L#d. Steptoe &Johnson LLP Tanenbaum Keale L.LP AURORA PUMP COMPANY ~J BWIIP INC. ~J GARDNER DENVER, INC. ~j GREENE TWEED & CO. INC. 850 Third Avenue, 11th Floor New York, NY ~) Phone: (212} ~~ Fax: (212} ~~ One Touch: 173 John M Guerriero (jguerriero@smsm.com) ~~ Katrina H Murphy ~( Nisah S Lakhani f ~ Steven R Rosenblatt METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY 1114 Avenue of the Americas Newyork, NY (~ Phone: (2'(2)506-39Q0 ~~ Fax: {2'(2) j~ One Touch: 174 Sandra E Cavazos (scavazos@step#oe.corn) ~~ Shehzad Hasan AWT AIR COMPANY INC., f/k/a RESEARCH-COTTRELL, ENC. ~~ CBS CORPORATION, a Qelaware Corporation, flic/a VIACOM INC., successor by merger to CBS CORPORATION, a Pennsylvania corporation, f/k/a WESTINGHOUSE ELEG7'RtC CORPORATfON ~J FOSTER WHEELER ENERGY CORPORATION ~~ GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY 1485 Raymond Boulevard '(6th Floor Newark, NJ Dennis E. Vega ~~ Michael A. Tanenbaum SCEC~# Case# 19Q060/2017 Peer, Wayne 02/28/2017 Page 3 of 5

7 t ~Vfasfer Service List for : Peer, Wayne Case# /2017 Representing Firms (Copies: 26} Waters McPherson M~Neill PC - RILEY POWER INC. f/k/a RfLEY STOKER CORPORATION 233 Broadway Suite 222U New York, NY 9Q279 ~~ Phone: (212) ~~ Fax: (212) ~~ one Touch: '197 Giovanni Regina Wilbraham Lawler 8 Buba AIR &LIQUID SYSTEMS C4RP~RATION, BUFFALO PUMPS 0lVISION 140 Broadway, 46th Floor New York, NY ~~ Phone: X212} '5 J~ Fax: (212) ~~ One Touch: 248 Edward J. Wilbraf~am ~~ John S Howa~h ~ Wilson Elser Moskowitr Edelman ~ Dicker LLP CARRIER CORPORATION individually and as successor-in-interest to BRYANT HEATING &COOLING SYSTEMS 150 East 42nd Street New York, NY 100'( ~~ Phone: ( (~ Fax: (2'f2) j~ One Touch: f SCEQf# Case# !2017 Peer, Wayne Q2/28l2017 Pags 4 of 5

8 Master Service List for : Peer, Wayne Registered Agents (Copies: 4) Case# !20'! 7.; C.T. Corporation System GEORGIA PACIFIC CORPORATION, individually and as successor to BESTWALL GYPSUM COMPANY 11'I 8th Avenue 93th Floor New York, NY CSC-Lawyers Incorporating Service GORMAN-RUPP COMPANY 50 West Braad Street Suite 180U Columbus, OH Registered Agent Solutions inc. ROBERTSHAW CONTROLS COMPANY 901 S 2nd Street Suite 201 Springfield, il United States Corporation Company NASH ENGINEERING COMPANY 50 Weston Street Hartford, CT SCEQ# Case# /2017 Peer, Wayne D Page 5 of 5