BASKET, WIRE LETTER, FELLOWS 60012, OR GENERAL OR APPROVED EQUAL

Transcription

1 SALT LAKE CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT Low Bid Bid Award IFB TH1418-OS OFFICE SUPPLIES FOR DISTRICT STOREROOM Item not as specified- not accepted AFP Industries CPG DGS Educational Elgin LD Products National Sch. Suppl Office Depot EA PKG EA BASKET, WIRE LETTER, FELLOWS 60012, OR GENERAL OR Fellowes $3.48 BINDER TAB DIVIDERS, INSERTABLE, LASER/INKJET, 8-1/2 X 11, 3-HOLE PUNCHED, 8-TAB SET, MULTI COLOR, AVERY 11111, SCHOOL SMART OR BINDER, 3-RING DURABLE, CLEAR OVERLAY VIEW, 8.5" X 11", 1-1/2" DIAM, WHITE, OD , WJ W362- Tops WPP OR (DO NOT BID SCHOOL SMART BRAND) $1.34 Samsill 18557C $1.69 Kleerfax $.57 Avery 5726 $1.54 Fellowes $4.17 Source $.60 Source $2.12 Fel $4.84 Ave ci $.60 OD $ PKG CARD, INDEX, WHITE PLAIN (UNRULED), 3" x 5", 100/PKG, OXFORD 30 OR Oxford 30 $ $.59 Esselte 30 $ PKG CARD, INDEX, WHITE RULED, 3" X 5", 100/PKG, OXFORD 31 OR Oxford 31 $ $.51 Esselte 31 $ PKG CARD, INDEX, WHITE RULED, 4" X 6", 100/PKG, OXFORD 41 OR Oxford 41 $.51 (60/cs) $.85 Esselte 41 $ PKG CARD, INDEX, WHITE RULED, 5" X 8", 100/PKG, OXFORD 51 OR Oxford 51 $.86 (40/cs) $1.19 Esselte 51 $ BOX BINDER CLIPS, SMALL, 3/4", 3/8" CAPACITY, BLACK, 12/BOX, OD BX OR OIC $ $.24 OD $ BOX BINDER CLIPS, LARGE, 2", 1" CAPACITY, BLACK, 12/BOX, OD OR OIC $ $1.43 OD $ CTN CLIP, PAPER 1 REG 100/BOX, 10 BOX/CTN, OIC OR OIC $1.40 E $2.50 (25/cs) $1.69 OIC $ BOX CLIP, PAPER JUMBO 2, 100/BOX, OIC OR UNV OR 301- OIC E $.65 $ $.48 OIC $ EA DISPENSER, TAPE 1" CORE FOR 3/4" X 1296", LEONARD 900BK OR SCH SMART OR 900BK $ BK $ $1.10 c60- BKED $ EA ENVELOPE, 10" x 13" KRAFT, INTER-DEPARTMENT, QUALITY PARK 63562, COLUMBIAN CO880 OR $.13 $.1368 (100/bx; 100/ctn) $.24 ($24.21/10 0) $.40 ($33.98/10 0) BOX BOX ENVELOPE, 10 WHITE REG PLAIN WOVEN, 500/BX, QP 11126, CO125 OR ENVELOPE, 6-3/4" REG WHITE, 24, 500/BOX, WEST VACO OR QP CO125 $7.11 QP $6.37 QP $7.63 (500/ctn) QP CO125 $6.81 (2500/ctn) $ $11.06 QP 78R25 $12.87 QP $7.62 Page 1 of 6 3/27/2013

2 SALT LAKE CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT Low Bid Bid Award IFB TH1418-OS OFFICE SUPPLIES FOR DISTRICT STOREROOM Item not as specified- not accepted AFP Industries CPG DGS Educational Elgin LD Products National Sch. Suppl Office Depot BOX FASTENER, PAPER 1, 3/8", ROUND HEAD FASTENER, 100/BOX, GENERAL 1RH OR 1R- BP $.87 1RBP $.63 Gem 84C $ BOX FOLDER, MANILA LETTER SIZE, 1/2 CUT, 100/BOX, AMPAD 221 1/2 OR Oxford 752-1/2 $5.48 Triangle 1102 $4.84 Oxford 752-1/2 $ $8.13 Smead 152L $ EA PKG BOX SINGLE HOLE PUNCH, HANDHELD, OD OR HIGHLIGHTERS, ASS'T COLOR, PKG OF 4,5, OR 6, PEN STYLE, CHISEL TIP, SHARPIE 27076, BIC BLP51W, SANFORD 24575, ZEBRA ZAZZLE OR MARKER, PERMANENT, CHISEL TIP, 12/BOX, BLACK, FABER 3000, BIC GPMM11-BK OR (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE DIXON 99007) $ $1.10 (6/set) $ $.94 Integra $.79 GPMM11B K $ $1.38 $2.85 OD $ $ $ BOX MARKER, PERMANENT, CHISEL TIP, 12/BOX, BLUE, FABER 3000, SANFORD OR APPROVED EQUAL (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE DIXON 99008) $2.86 Avery $7.07 $ $ SET MARKER, DRY ERASE, 4/SET, ASS'T COLORS, CHISEL TIP, SANFORD OR 80074, CRAYOLA , BIC DECP41-AST, ZEBRA Z-WM OR $1.73 (72/cs) $2.48; $1.99 Integra $ $ $ SET MARKER, DRY ERASE, 4/SET, BLACK, CHISEL TIP, SANFORD OR, BIC DECP41-BLACK OR $2.64 $2.69 Integra $1.46 $ $ PKG NOTE-PAD, POST IT SMALL 1-1/2" x 2", 100/PAD, 12/PKG, YELLOW, POST-IT BRAND 653YW ONLY NO SUBSTITUTE 655YW $3.30 Post it 653YW $ $ YW $ EA WHITE BOARD CLEANER, 8 OZ BTL, SANFORD EXPO OR $2.35 Genuine Joe $2.21 $1.73 $ BOX PEN, BALLPOINT, 12/BOX, BLACK MEDIUM POINT, BIC GSM11, ZEBRA Z , PAPERMATE INKJOY 100ST , OR (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE OTHER PAPERMATE S) $.97 GSM11 $ $ $ BOX BOX PEN, BALLPOINT BLUE, FINE POINT, 12/BOX, BIC GSF11, ZEBRA Z OR, (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE PAPERMATE) PEN, BALLPOINT, 12/BOX, RED MED POINT, BIC GSM11, ZEBRA Z , PAPERMATE INKJOY 100ST OR (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE OTHER PAPERMATE S) $ $.97 GSF11 $.83 GSM11 $ $ $ $2.04 Page 2 of 6 3/27/2013

3 SALT LAKE CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT Low Bid Bid Award IFB TH1418-OS OFFICE SUPPLIES FOR DISTRICT STOREROOM Item not as specified- not accepted AFP Industries CPG DGS Educational Elgin LD Products National Sch. Suppl Office Depot BOX PKG BOX EA PEN, FELT TIPPED BLACK (FLAIR TYPE) MEDIUM POINT, 12/BOX, PAPERMATE PAP OR $2.44 PENS, CLICK STYLE BALL, MED POINT 1.0MM, BLACK, 12/BOX, BIC CSM11, ZEBRA 22210, PAPERMATE INKJOY 100RT OR (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE OTHER PAPERMATE S) PROTECTORS, SHEET POLYPROPYLENE 8.5 X 11.75, W/3 HOLES, TOP LOAD, 50/BOX, SAMSILL OR $1.68 STAPLER, 6" ARM, STANDARD, ELMERS/RAPID 73602, SCHOOL SMART OR APPROVED EQUAL $ $2.83 $9.44 CSM11 $3.68 Sam $4.35; Leo $2.79 Rapid $ $13.70 $7.17 $ $ $3.01 $8.94 $3.60 OD SP10, $3.81 Esselte/Ra pid $ PKG TAPE, TRANSPARENT, 1/2" X 450" ON DISPENSER, 12/PKG, 144A OR 144A $ $ $ L TAPE, TRANSPARENT 3/4" x 2592", 3" CORE, 600 OR 6200 $ $ $3.135 ($6.27/2pk) L TAPE, MASKING 3/4" X 60 YD, HIGHLAND 2600, HIGHLAND 2307 OR /4 $ $ $ L TAPE, PERMANENT MENDING 1/2" x 1296", 1" CORE, HIGHLAND 6200 OR /2 $ $ $ L TAPE, PERMANENT MENDING 3/4" X 1296", 1" CORE, HIGHLAND 6200 OR /4 $ $ $ $ PKG CORRECTION TAPE, WITE-OUT 2/PKG, SANFORD 6624, BIC WOTAPP21 OR WOTAPP2 1 $2.58 WOTAPP2 1 $ $ $ L PAPER, ADDING MACHINE, 2-1/4" X 150' L, NCR EA, NCR OR $.87 OD $.43 TOTAL Bid Award Notes: Items 4-7 awarded overall low bid for all items & increased qtys to meet order mins; Items 10-11, 13 awarded lowest bid that we could meet order mins; Item 19-23, 26-29, 33, awarded low bid for quality desired; Item 25, could not meet order min for Pyramid, awarded next low to Southwest; Item 30 could not meet min for Pyramid, awarded next low bid; Item 39 could not meet Tops min for Pyramid, awarded next low bid. Items all or none Min order 10 cartons Index Cards min $1050; Items 7-11 all or none Page 3 of 6 3/27/2013

4 SALT LAKE CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT IFB TH1418-OS OFFICE SUPPLIES FOR DISTRICT STOREROOM Pyramid School Specialty Southwest Sch. Std. Stationery Std. Stat. Alternates Valley Mach EA PKG EA BASKET, WIRE LETTER, FELLOWS 60012, OR GENERAL OR BINDER TAB DIVIDERS, INSERTABLE, LASER/INKJET, 8-1/2 X 11, 3-HOLE PUNCHED, 8-TAB SET, MULTI COLOR, AVERY 11111, SCHOOL SMART OR BINDER, 3-RING DURABLE, CLEAR OVERLAY VIEW, 8.5" X 11", 1-1/2" DIAM, WHITE, OD , WJ W362- Tops WPP OR (DO NOT BID $1.31 SCHOOL SMART BRAND) $2.23 Avery 11111Q $ WE $1.77 Fellowes $ $.41 WJ $1.64 OIC $3.46 General $1.54 Universal $.46 (24/cs) Tops $1.294 WJ 63234WPP $1.50 Tops $ PKG CARD, INDEX, WHITE PLAIN (UNRULED), 3" x 5", 100/PKG, OXFORD 30 OR Oxford 30 $.318 Esselte 30 $ $.36 Esselte 30 $.319 Oxford 30 $ PKG CARD, INDEX, WHITE RULED, 3" X 5", 100/PKG, OXFORD 31 OR Oxford 31 $.318 Esselte 31 $ $.36 Esselte 31 $.319 Oxford 31 $ PKG CARD, INDEX, WHITE RULED, 4" X 6", 100/PKG, OXFORD 41 OR Oxford 41 $.498 (60/cs) Esselte 41 $ $.58 Esselte 41 $.499 (60/cs) Oxford 41 $ PKG CARD, INDEX, WHITE RULED, 5" X 8", 100/PKG, OXFORD 51 OR Oxford 51 $.855 (40/cs) Esselte 51 $ $.96 Esselte 51 $.858 (40/cs) Oxford 51 $ BOX BINDER CLIPS, SMALL, 3/4", 3/8" CAPACITY, BLACK, 12/BOX, OD BX OR $ $ $.19 OIC $.179 General BC- 20 $ BOX CTN BINDER CLIPS, LARGE, 2", 1" CAPACITY, BLACK, 12/BOX, OD OR CLIP, PAPER 1 REG 100/BOX, 10 BOX/CTN, OIC OR $ $ $ $1.70 ($.17/bx) $ $1.60 ($.16/ea) OIC $1.124 OIC $1.22 (25/cs) General BC- 100 $1.06 OIC $ BOX CLIP, PAPER JUMBO 2, 100/BOX, OIC OR UNV OR $ $ $.46 OIC $.36 OIC $ EA DISPENSER, TAPE 1" CORE FOR 3/4" X 1296", LEONARD 900BK OR SCH SMART OR $ QL $ $.72 OIC $2.20 (24/cs) Standard C- 38 $ EA ENVELOPE, 10" x 13" KRAFT, INTER-DEPARTMENT, QUALITY PARK 63562, COLUMBIAN CO880 OR QP $.44 ($43.76/100) $.126 (500/cs) $.126 (100/bx; 5bx/cs) BOX ENVELOPE, 10 WHITE REG PLAIN WOVEN, 500/BX, QP 11126, CO125 OR WW10ES $ $7.98 QP CO125 $6.995 (5/cs) QP CO125 $7.01 (5/cs) BOX ENVELOPE, 6-3/4" REG WHITE, 24, 500/BOX, WEST VACO OR WW634ES $ $7.50 QP $6.249 (10/cs) QP C0105 $6.26 Page 4 of 6 3/27/2013

5 SALT LAKE CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT IFB TH1418-OS OFFICE SUPPLIES FOR DISTRICT STOREROOM Pyramid School Specialty Southwest Sch. Std. Stationery Std. Stat. Alternates Valley Mach BOX FASTENER, PAPER 1, 3/8", ROUND HEAD FASTENER, 100/BOX, GENERAL 1RH OR 1RBP $ $.43 1R- BP $.51 General (10/cs) 1RH $ BOX FOLDER, MANILA LETTER SIZE, 1/2 CUT, 100/BOX, AMPAD 221 1/2 OR Oxford 752-1/2 $ $ $6.97 Esselte 752-1/2 $5.43 (5/cs) Oxford 221-1/2 $ EA SINGLE HOLE PUNCH, HANDHELD, OD OR $ QL $ $.56 OIC $.557 Standard G- 1 $ PKG BOX HIGHLIGHTERS, ASS'T COLOR, PKG OF 4,5, OR 6, PEN STYLE, CHISEL TIP, SHARPIE 27076, BIC BLP51W, SANFORD 24575, ZEBRA ZAZZLE OR MARKER, PERMANENT, CHISEL TIP, 12/BOX, BLACK, FABER 3000, BIC GPMM11-BK OR (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE DIXON 99007) Perfection 4808 $.92 (5/set) $2.47 BLRP51 $2.61 (5/pk) Sharpie $ $ $ PP $1.15 (6/cs) $ $1.12; BLP51 $1.43 $2.82 Emphasiz er $.77 Mighty Mark 425 $ BOX MARKER, PERMANENT, CHISEL TIP, 12/BOX, BLUE, FABER 3000, SANFORD OR APPROVED EQUAL (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE DIXON 99008) $2.47 Sharpie $10.94 Sharpie $ $2.35 $2.82 Mighty Mark 425 $ SET SET MARKER, DRY ERASE, 4/SET, ASS'T COLORS, CHISEL TIP, SANFORD OR 80074, CRAYOLA , BIC DECP41-AST, ZEBRA Z-WM OR MARKER, DRY ERASE, 4/SET, BLACK, CHISEL TIP, SANFORD OR, BIC DECP41-BLACK OR $1.95 $ $ $ $5.62 GDEMP41 AST $1.88 $2.46 (6/cs) DECP41 $2.27; $2.23 Dix $2.10; Dix $1.75 $ PKG NOTE-PAD, POST IT SMALL 1-1/2" x 2", 100/PAD, 12/PKG, YELLOW, POST-IT BRAND 653YW ONLY NO SUBSTITUTE 653YW $3.19 Post it 653YW $3.93 Post it $ YW $3.509 post it 653YW $ EA WHITE BOARD CLEANER, 8 OZ BTL, SANFORD EXPO OR $1.49 $ $1.92 $1.545 WB Wizard $ BOX BOX BOX PEN, BALLPOINT, 12/BOX, BLACK MEDIUM POINT, BIC GSM11, ZEBRA Z , PAPERMATE INKJOY 100ST , OR (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE OTHER PAPERMATE S) PEN, BALLPOINT BLUE, FINE POINT, 12/BOX, BIC GSF11, ZEBRA Z OR, (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE PAPERMATE) PEN, BALLPOINT, 12/BOX, RED MED POINT, BIC GSM11, ZEBRA Z , PAPERMATE INKJOY 100ST OR (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE OTHER PAPERMATE S) GSM11 $.80 GSF11 $.80 GSM11 $.80 GSM11BK $.80 GSF11BE $.80 GSM11RD $ $ $ $.64 GSM11BK $.78 GSF11BE $.78 GSM11RD $.78 GSM11 $.802 GSF11 $.802 GSM11 $.802 Page 5 of 6 3/27/2013

6 SALT LAKE CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT IFB TH1418-OS OFFICE SUPPLIES FOR DISTRICT STOREROOM Pyramid School Specialty Southwest Sch. Std. Stationery Std. Stat. Alternates Valley Mach BOX PKG BOX PEN, FELT TIPPED BLACK (FLAIR TYPE) MEDIUM POINT, 12/BOX, PAPERMATE PAP OR PENS, CLICK STYLE BALL, MED POINT 1.0MM, BLACK, 12/BOX, BIC CSM11, ZEBRA 22210, PAPERMATE INKJOY 100RT OR (PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE OTHER PAPERMATE S) PROTECTORS, SHEET POLYPROPYLENE 8.5 X 11.75, W/3 HOLES, TOP LOAD, 50/BOX, SAMSILL OR 52 $7.55 $ $1.62 $9.66 CSM11BK $3.73 Avery $ $ $ $1.64 $8.365 $8.52 $2.28 Premier $1.626 Premier nonglare clear $1.47 $ EA PKG L L L L PKG L STAPLER, 6" ARM, STANDARD, ELMERS/RAPID 73602, SCHOOL SMART OR APPROVED EQUAL TAPE, TRANSPARENT, 1/2" X 450" ON DISPENSER, 12/PKG, 144A OR TAPE, TRANSPARENT 3/4" x 2592", 3" CORE, 600 OR TAPE, MASKING 3/4" X 60 YD, HIGHLAND 2600, HIGHLAND 2307 OR TAPE, PERMANENT MENDING 1/2" x 1296", 1" CORE, HIGHLAND 6200 OR TAPE, PERMANENT MENDING 3/4" X 1296", 1" CORE, HIGHLAND 6200 OR CORRECTION TAPE, WITE-OUT 2/PKG, SANFORD 6624, BIC WOTAPP21 OR PAPER, ADDING MACHINE, 2-1/4" X 150' L, NCR EA, NCR OR TOTAL $ A $ $ $ $ $ $ $ x12 96 $.87 WOTAPP21 $2.34 WOTAPP2 1 $2.18 Tops 7280 $ $ $15.72 ($1.31/ea) $ $ $ $ $.91 PM Comp $ $1.72 Mend All $ $1.57; Mend all $ /4 $ $.481; Mend All $ $.669; Mend All $.625 WOTAPP2 1 $2.27 Universal $.395 (12/pk) Standard 220 $ A $7.06 Tapemate 23-C $ $3.24 $.724 Edge 83 by $ $ $.668 WOTAPP21 $2.37 Tops 7280 $.46 Bid Award Notes: Items 4-7 awarded overall low bid for all items & increased qtys to meet order mins; Items 10-11, 13 awarded lowest bid that we could meet order mins; Item 19-23, 26-29, 33, awarded low bid for quality desired; Item 25, could not meet order min for Pyramid, awarded next low to Southwest; Item 30 could not meet min for Pyramid, awarded next low bid; Item 39 could not meet Tops min for Pyramid, awarded next low bid. Tops/Cardin al $800; Oxford $1100; $600; / $1000; / $500; $750 Item 39 $50 min; $700; Esselte $1000; QP 9 cases; $1100; OIC Ampad/Oxf $700; ord $1050; $1530; QP 9 cases; StatusP/Me $750; ndall $580; /Highlan $750 d $500 Page 6 of 6 3/27/2013