How New York State Exaggerated Potential Job Creation from Shale Gas Development
|
|
- Coral Horton
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 How New York State Exaggerated Potential Job Creation from Shale Gas Development
2 About Food & Water Watch Food & Water Watch works to ensure the food, water Food & Water Watch Copyright November 2011 by Food & Water Watch.
3 How New York State Exaggerated Potential Job Creation from Shale Gas Development Executive Summary Introduction New York s shale gas job projection Shale gas development would bring few opportunities to current residents Additional failures of New York s analysis of socioeconomic impacts Conclusion
4 shales. 1 - New York State, much of which sits atop the Marcellus Shale and the Utica Shale, is at the center of this public controversy. The Cuomo administration is currently considering regulations that would allow widespread drilling and fracking for shale gas in New York. The regulations being considered are based on the state s 1,537-page environmental impact analysis, which included a socioeconomic impact analysis with job and revenue projections for several different shale gas development scenarios in the state. 2 Food & Water Watch closely examined New York s socioeconomic impact analysis and found that it does the people of New York a disservice. The New York analysis concluded that an average shale gas development scenario would bring 53,969 jobs, but only in the fine print of a footnote of the widely read factsheet is it mentioned that this is a 30-year projection. 3 Moreover, Food & Water Watch found that the analysis: counts many jobs that would be filled by outof-state workers, or by workers with shale gas industry experience who relocate to New York permanently; assumes a rapid pace of shale gas drilling and fracking under the average scenario that would result in more than 20,000 wells being drilled in just three counties of the state (Broome, Chemung and Tioga); fails to account for the negative impacts that drilling and fracking would have on employment in other industries, such as tourism and agriculture; overestimates production jobs by assuming that shale gas wells will produce for 30 years; and misapplies an economic multiplier to estimate the economic spillover effect of gas industry jobs. Based on the New York analysis, Food & Water Watch estimates that in the first year of the average shale gas development scenario, current New York residents can expect only 195 new oil and gas industry job opportunities. This would grow steadily to over 600 new jobs for current New York residents in the tenth year of development, but after this tenth year, there would be next-to-no new jobs for established New York residents. For perspective, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics estimated that 755,892 New Yorkers were unemployed in August of 2011, 4 and thus the impact of 195 new oil and gas industry jobs would be about one-fortieth of 1 percent (i.e., percent). This is far from the number of jobs that New York residents have been led to expect from shale gas development. Such minimal economic benefits do not justify the near-term and long-term public costs that would accompany drilling and fracking for shale gas. 2 Food & Water Watch
5 The oil and gas industry, 5 industry-funded academics 6 and ideological think tanks 7 have promoted shale gas development as a sure-fire job creator in difficult economic times. Proponents of shale gas development have benefited from media 8 and U.S. government 9 reports in which the supposed economic benefits have gone unquestioned. Food & Water Watch recently analyzed one industry-backed job projection and found that it overstated shale gas job creation potential in New York by a factor of 10, or about 900 percent. 10 New York s job projection follows a similar methodology and suffers from similar flaws. A topline claim in the New York socioeconomic impact analysis is that 53,969 jobs could be created assuming an average scenario of shale gas development. 11 But this is a 30-year projection. 12 It assumes that a total of 42,126 shale gas wells would be developed over 30 years, including 21,067 in just the three counties of Broome, Chemung and Tioga. 13 Close examination of this job projection shows that allowing for such extensive shale gas development in New York would actually have a minimal impact on employment in the near term, primarily because most jobs would go to employees from out-of-state. Shale gas development would not provide the broadbased economic growth that New York now needs and that the industry has promised they could deliver. Instead, shale gas development would primarily benefit the oil and gas industry while bringing significant costs to public health, public infrastructure, and the environment. The consulting company Ecology and Environment, Inc. (E&E Inc.) was hired to conduct New York s analysis of the impact that shale gas development would have on employment in the state. 14 E&E Inc. produced a report describing their methodology and findings that became, after minor revisions, Section 6.8 of the New York State Department of Conservation (NYSDEC) Revised Draft Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement (SGEIS). 15 Under New York s average development scenario, A the analysis concluded that 53,969 jobs would be created from drilling and fracking 42,126 shale gas wells over 30 years, compared to the baseline of no shale gas development. 16 New York s 30-year projection of 53,969 jobs comes from three separate projections: a projected 17,634 construction jobs from the preparing, drilling and fracking of 1,652 shale gas wells in year 30; a projected 7,161 production jobs that have accumulated over the 30 years as more and more wells are brought into production; and a projected 29,174 indirect jobs created by the economic spillover effects of construction and production jobs. 17 A 2009 study by the Marcellus Shale Education & Training Center (MSETC) on future education and training needs in Pennsylvania is the basis, in the New York study, of this distinction between jobs before production and jobs during production. 18 However, to make this distinction, MSETC uses the terms drilling phase jobs and production phase jobs, even though some of the drilling phase jobs are associated with pre-drilling activities. 19 New York s use of the term construction jobs obscures the fact that the drilling (and pre-drilling) phase of well development includes white-collar jobs, such as lawyers, lobbyists, accountants, engineers and office assistants, in addition to jobs directly associated with building access roads, constructing pipelines, clearing land and drilling and fracking. 20 A more accurate distinction is used in this report: pre-production phase jobs versus production phase jobs. It takes less than one year to prepare a well site and conduct the drilling and fracking. 21 As a consequence, the number of pre-production phase jobs increases from one year to the next only if the number of new wells developed each year increases; if the number of new wells drilled and fracked stays constant, then no new pre-production phase jobs would be created. A scenarios.
6 Year # of new wells drilled and fracked # of producing wells New pre Note: The reason for the variability in the number of new pre-production jobs during the first 10 years is unexplained in the E&E Inc. report. Source: Ecology and Environment Inc. 2011, Table 4-7 for new jobs projected, pages 4-2 and 4-3 for wells drilled and fracked per year 4 Food & Water Watch
7 The New York job projection assumes that for the first 10 years there is constant growth in the number of new wells developed each year, from 165 new wells in the first year to 1,652 new wells in the tenth year. 22 (See Table 1.) Development is then assumed to level off for years 11 through 30 at 1,652 new wells a year. 23 This means there would not be any new pre-production phase jobs after year 10. Production jobs, in contrast, would accumulate as more wells are brought into production. The New York job projection assumes that a shale gas well will produce for 30 years, so in year 31 the first shale gas wells would be retired under the development scenario. However, while production jobs would accumulate, the pre-production phase of shale gas development requires many times more workers per well than the production phase. 24 The New York analysis, relying on the 2009 MSETC study, estimated that the pre-production phase requires the equivalent B of about 10.7 full-time workers per well. C25 In contrast, again based on the MSETC study, the New York analysis assumed that the production phase requires the equivalent of 0.17 fulltime workers per well, or about one full-time worker to manage the production of six active wells. 26 These estimates of the full-time equivalent (FTE) workforce needed per well, combined with the number of new wells developed and the number of producing wells, allowed New York to project the number of preproduction and production jobs each year under each development scenario. (See Table 1 for annual job creation under the average development scenario.) New York considers pre-production and production phase jobs as direct jobs, from which there is an economic spillover effect that creates indirect jobs. 27 The New York analysis used the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) Regional Input-Output Modeling System (RIMS II) Type I employment multiplier to project indirect job impacts under the different development scenarios. 28 Specifically, the analysis used the oil and gas industry RIMS II Type I multiplier of , estimated for the state of New York. 29 This assumption means that for each direct job created from shale gas development, an additional indirect jobs would be created (i.e., ). Thus, New York projected 29,174 indirect jobs by multiplying times the sum of the projected 17,634 construction jobs and 7,161 production jobs. 30 For reasons detailed below, however, New York s projections of direct and indirect job creation from shale gas development are deeply flawed. B C.
8 Year # of new wells drilled and fracked New phase jobs (total) jobs for transient workers jobs for permanent workers jobs to current NY residents , , , , Note: Instead of distinguishing between in-state and out-of-state workers, the New York analysis chose to describe pre-production phase workers as either transient or permanent. Although adopted in this table, this is inappropriate terminology since many out-of-state workers are permanent hires who move from site to site, while some in-state workers, such as in construction, may be temporary and/or transient workers. Source: Ecology and Environment Inc. 2011, Table Estimate of new pre-production phase jobs to current residents based on the assumption that half of new permanent pre-production phase jobs go to workers who have moved to New York for shale gas development jobs. 6 Food & Water Watch
9 residents The New York analysis noted that most pre-production jobs would go to transient, out-of-state workers in the early years of shale gas development. 31 A 2011 MSETC study estimated that 70 to 80 percent of employees were out-of-state during the early stages of Pennsylvania shale gas development. 32 According to interviews and surveys conducted by MSETC, however, the out-of-state portion of newly hired workers was percent. 33 This apparent improvement in in-state hiring may have been due in part to out-ofstate workers having established in-state residence, since in the MSETC study an employee that had lived in Pennsylvania for at least one year and had a valid PA driver s license qualified as an in-state worker. 34 This reveals a subtle but crucial problem with the way the New York job projection has been presented. Many of the pre-production jobs that New York projected as permanent employment would actually go to workers who had moved to the state to continue their oil and gas industry employment, not to current residents of New York who have been led to believe that allowing shale gas development would bring new job opportunities for them. Table 2 shows the annual pre-production phase job creation projected by New York, broken down between new jobs for transient and permanent workers. In the first year, New York assumed that only 22 percent of new pre-production phase hires would be permanent, and that the percentage of permanent new hires would steadily increase to 72 percent in year The fifth column of Table 2 lists the number of new production phase jobs for permanent workers that are projected by New York under these assumptions: 389 in the first year, an additional 466 in the second year, and so on. However, as discussed above, many of these permanent workers do not currently reside in New York they would have come from other states, most likely states that currently allow shale gas development. To illustrate this effect, Food & Water Watch assumed that half of the new permanent jobs directly associated with the pre-production phase of shale gas development were taken by employees who had moved to New York State for such work. Under this assumption, pre-production phase employment of current New York residents would only grow in the first 10 years, with 195 new jobs available in the first year increasing to 632 new jobs available in the tenth year. After year 10, based on the New York analysis, the only new permanent pre-production phase hires would be from the transitioning of the transient workforce. For perspective, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics estimated that 755,892 New Yorkers were unemployed in August Using this figure, the impact of 195 new oil and gas industry jobs would be about one-fortieth of 1 percent (i.e., percent). This is far from the number of jobs New York residents have been led to expect.
10 The average scenario assumed that 165 new wells would be drilled and fracked in the first year of development, increasing gradually to 1,652 new wells in the tenth year of development (see Table 1), after which point the annual number of new wells would stay at 1,652. For comparison, in Pennsylvania in 2010 there were 1,405 new wells developed, and 2,459 new wells have been projected for development in year New York s rapid pace of shale gas development would be concentrated in certain counties, 39 and it is far from certain that such development could be sustained for 30 years. The New York analysis assumes that 50 percent of the wells would be located in just three counties: Broome, Chemung and Tioga. 40 Under the average development scenario, the number of new wells would increase gradually until reaching 826 new wells per year in years 10 through 30 in these three counties. 41 In total, 21,067 wells would be developed in these three counties. 42 With such extensive shale gas development, significant negative impacts on other parts of the economy, such as agriculture and tourism, would likely result, but the New York analysis fails to account for such negative impacts. Although the New York analysis acknowledges that shale gas development could have negative impacts on employment in other industries, these potential negative impacts are not included in the job projections. 43 Instead, the New York analysis dismisses the significance of such negative impacts with the simple argument that Cattaraugus and Chautauqua Counties still have healthy tourism sectors despite having more than 3,900 active natural gas wells in the region. 44 But the fact that tourism and agriculture exist as industries in Chautauqua and Cattaraugus counties is not a serious argument. It is quite possible that tourism would have been greater in these counties were it not for the past and current gas drilling. Moreover, modern shale gas development is far more intensive than conventional natural gas development: much longer boreholes drilled, much more fracking fluid used, much more wastewater created and much more heavyduty truck traffic. 45 The cumulative impacts that such development would have on other parts of rural economies may be difficult to quantify, but they must not be dismissed. - In projecting production phase jobs, the New York analysis assumed that each new well produces shale gas for 30 years, and further assumed that the estimate of 0.17 FTE production phase workers per well would hold for all 30 years. 46 But this estimate, taken from the 2009 MSETC report, is based on only a few years of shale gas production in Pennsylvania. 47 This introduces significant uncertainty into New York s production phase job projection. New York assumes that production of a typical horizontal well will fall by 75 percent from year 1 to year 4, and by 90 percent by year But if production falls more rapidly than expected, then there would be fewer production phase jobs over the long term. Indeed, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is investigating whether shale gas companies have overstated the productivity of shale gas wells. 49 Rapidly changing estimates of the amount of recoverable shale gas also raise questions about future well productivity, 50 suggesting that the amount of gas that can be recovered from a given location of the shale may vary significantly from well to well. 8 Food & Water Watch
11 Finally, New York misused employment multipliers in a way that exaggerated the potential economic spillover effect from pre-production and production phase jobs. New York went on to misuse economic multipliers in a way that exaggerated the potential economic spillover effect from these jobs. Indirect jobs are those that would be created down supply chains due to demand created by pre-production and production phase jobs, i.e., from direct jobs. The New York analysis used the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) Regional Input-Output Modeling System (RIMS II) Type I employment multiplier to project indirect job impacts that would stem from preproduction and production phase jobs. 51 Specifically, the New York analysis adopted the oil and gas industry RIMS II Type I multiplier of for the state of New York. 52 Under this assumption, each direct job created from shale gas development would lead to an additional indirect jobs (i.e., ). However, input-output modeling is well suited only for analyzing the economic impact of clearly defined projects for which the interdependencies between relevant economic sectors, over the course of the project, are well understood and quantifiable. 53 For example, when a bridge is to be built, there is a record of understanding of how direct spending on the project leads to indirect spending down supply chains within the regional economy, in part because such projects are not typically new to a region. In contrast, shale gas development would be a new industry in New York. This means the estimate of indirect jobs from each direct job is highly uncertain. development in the state. Yet the New York oil and gas industry multiplier is derived from conventional oil and gas development. Shale gas development, being a fundamentally new industry for the state, would likely have less of a regional multiplier effect because of extensive out-of-state sourcing. Finally, the New York analysis implicitly assumed that all of the pre-production and production phase jobs were in the oil and gas industry when it used the oil and gas industry multiplier. But, according to the MSETC report, shale gas development challenges the traditional notion of oil and gas industry jobs, and jobs would go to a wide array of subcontractors. 55 Because the employment multiplier for the oil and gas industry is larger than it is for most other industries, New York overestimated the number of indirect jobs by using only the oil and gas industry multiplier. 56 These flaws reflect the fact that New York projected indirect job impacts using input-output models despite the explicit warning in the 2011 MSETC study, which stated, Since the analysis focuses on the specific jobs required for drilling and production without regard to formal industry sectors, it would be illogical to apply workforce or economic multipliers to it, which typically are based upon specific industry sectors (emphasis added). 57 The New York analysis ignored this logic and produced an exaggerated projection of the job creation potential of shale gas development. Another flaw is exposed by the fact that the New York analysis assumed that more than 77 percent of workers are out-of-state initially. 54 (See Table 2.) The fact that out-of-state workers hired by out-of-state companies would make up the majority of the workforce for the first 11 years of drilling suggests that there would be greater out-of-state sourcing of supplies and materials than occurs for conventional oil and gas
12 Conclusion The New York socioeconomic impact analysis, conducted by E&E Inc., fails to provide an accurate projection of the potential benefits of opening up the state to drilling and fracking for shale gas. By exaggerating the potential benefits, New York has failed to serve the public interest. In reality, current residents of New York can only expect intensive shale gas development to create several hundred new shale gas industry jobs for each of the first 10 years, followed by far fewer production jobs created for the next 20 years. Specifically, Food & Water Watch estimates that in the first year of average shale gas development, current New York residents can expect only 195 new oil and gas industry job opportunities. For perspective, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics estimated that 755,892 New Yorkers were unemployed in August 2011, 58 and thus the impact of 195 new oil and gas industry jobs would be about one-fortieth of 1 percent (i.e., percent). This is far from the 53,969 jobs that New York residents have been led to expect from opening up their state to shale gas development. The reality that allowing shale gas development is likely to only create several hundred new jobs annually for current residents of New York puts the risks of drilling and fracking for shale gas in proper perspective. Decision makers in New York should see that such minimal job gains do not justify the certain costs to public health, public infrastructure, and the environment that come with shale gas developmen Endnotes 10 Food & Water Watch
13 .
14 Food & Water Watch
BLM Oil and Gas Economic Impact Analysis. Approach to Facilitate Economic Impact Analysis for Oil & Gas Activities using IMPLAN
BLM Oil and Gas Economic Impact Analysis Approach to Facilitate Economic Impact Analysis for Oil & Gas Activities using IMPLAN Many people authored and contributed to this project Pinyon Environmental
More informationMedia Release October 5 th, 2010
Media Release October 5 th, 2010 PSAC STUDIES REVEAL OIL & GAS SERVICES SECTOR IS A $65 BILLION INDUSTRY (Calgary, AB) --- The Petroleum Services Association of Canada ( PSAC ) announced today the results
More informationPennsylvania's Natural Gas Industry & The Jobs It Creates
Pennsylvania's Natural Gas Industry & The Jobs It Creates PAPEN May 19, 2014 December 22, 2011 Range Resources Natural gas production company Pioneered the Marcellus Shale in 2004 More than $4 billion
More information3 Economic Development
3 Economic Development Introduction: The Economic Development Element of the Comprehensive Plan is intended to guide the climate for enterprise and commercial exchange in Buckley and reinforce the overall
More informationChapter 3 What Economies Do Macroeconomics In Context (Goodwin, et al.)
Chapter 3 What Economies Do Macroeconomics In Context (Goodwin, et al.) Chapter Overview This chapter introduces the four essential economic activities: resource maintenance, the production of goods and
More informationTHE U.S. SEMICONDUCTOR INDUSTRY:
THE U.S. SEMICONDUCTOR INDUSTRY: KEY CONTRIBUTOR TO U.S. ECONOMIC GROWTH Matti Parpala 1 August 2014 The U.S. Semiconductor Industry: Key Contributor To U.S. Economic Growth August 2014 1 INTRO The U.S.
More informationLETTER FROM THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOREWORD BY JEFFREY KRAUSE
LETTER FROM THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR Automation is increasingly becoming part of our everyday lives, from self-adjusting thermostats to cars that parallel park themselves. 18 years ago, when Automation Alley
More informationIXIA S PUBLIC ART SURVEY 2013 SUMMARY AND KEY FINDINGS. Published February 2014
IXIA S PUBLIC ART SURVEY 2013 SUMMARY AND KEY FINDINGS Published February 2014 ABOUT IXIA ixia is England s public art think tank. We promote and influence the development and implementation of public
More informationWelcoming Remarks. Energy Interdependence in the Western Hemisphere Conference. Hosted by the Global Interdependence Center.
Welcoming Remarks Energy Interdependence in the Western Hemisphere Conference Hosted by the Global Interdependence Center Philadelphia, PA November 5, 2015 Patrick T. Harker President and CEO Federal Reserve
More informationThe future of work. Nav Singh Managing Partner, Boston McKinsey & Company
The future of work Nav Singh Managing Partner, Boston Since the Industrial Revolution, innovation has fueled economic growth Estimated global GDP per capita, $ 100,000 1st Industrial Revolution 2 nd Industrial
More informationTHE LABORATORY ANIMAL BREEDERS ASSOCIATION OF GREAT BRITAIN
THE LABORATORY ANIMAL BREEDERS ASSOCIATION OF GREAT BRITAIN www.laba-uk.com Response from Laboratory Animal Breeders Association to House of Lords Inquiry into the Revision of the Directive on the Protection
More informationNEWS RELEASE FOR WIRE TRANSMISSION: 8:30 A.M. EDT, FRIDAY, APRIL 17, William Zeile: (202) BEA 09-14
NEWS RELEASE FOR WIRE TRANSMISSION: 8:30 A.M. EDT, FRIDAY, APRIL 17, 2009 William Zeile: (202) 606-9893 BEA 09-14 Summary Estimates for Multinational Companies: Employment, Sales, and Capital Expenditures
More informationHow U.S. Employment Is Changing
December 1, 211 How U.S. Employment Is Changing Stephen P. A. Brown and Hui Liu During the most recent recession, U.S. employment fell by 7,49 million jobs (5.4 percent). During the first 8 months of the
More informationInfrastructure for Systematic Innovation Enterprise
Valeri Souchkov ICG www.xtriz.com This article discusses why automation still fails to increase innovative capabilities of organizations and proposes a systematic innovation infrastructure to improve innovation
More informationCommunity & Economic Implications of Marcellus Shale Development
Community & Economic Implications of Marcellus Shale Development Kathryn J. Brasier, PhD Timothy W. Kelsey, PhD kbrasier@psu.edu tkelsey@psu.edu Dept. of Ag Econ & Rural Sociology, Penn State University
More informationTechnology and Competitiveness in Vietnam
Technology and Competitiveness in Vietnam General Statistics Office, Hanoi, Vietnam July 3 rd, 2014 Prof. Carol Newman, Trinity College Dublin Prof. Finn Tarp, University of Copenhagen and UNU-WIDER 1
More informationBook review: Profit and gift in the digital economy
Loughborough University Institutional Repository Book review: Profit and gift in the digital economy This item was submitted to Loughborough University's Institutional Repository by the/an author. Citation:
More informationTorsti Loikkanen, Principal Scientist, Research Coordinator VTT Innovation Studies
Forward Looking Activities Governing Grand Challenges Vienna, 27-28 September 2012 Support of roadmap approach in innovation policy design case examples on various levels Torsti Loikkanen, Principal Scientist,
More informationBrae Area Pre Decommissioning MARATHON BRAE. Brae Area Decommissioning Programme. June Revision 1.0
Brae Area Pre Decommissioning MARATHON BRAE Brae Area Decommissioning Programme June 2017 Revision 1.0 Why is Marathon Oil decommissioning? Decommissioning is a natural step in the life cycle of an oil
More informationAcademic Vocabulary Test 1:
Academic Vocabulary Test 1: How Well Do You Know the 1st Half of the AWL? Take this academic vocabulary test to see how well you have learned the vocabulary from the Academic Word List that has been practiced
More informationShale Gas Development in Northwest PA Where are we now? Shale Gas Impacts NATURAL GAS
Shale Gas Development in Northwest PA Where are we now? Shale Gas Impacts NATURAL GAS What s Occurring Now? Sustained depressed price of natural gas Leasing activity is at a trickle Still a lot of land
More informationA Comprehensive Statewide Study of Gambling Impacts: Implications for Public Health
A Comprehensive Statewide Study of Gambling Impacts: Implications for Public Health Rachel A. Volberg 2 nd Annual Maryland Conference on Problem Gambling June 13, 2014 Acknowledgement We would like to
More informationExecutive Summary. Introduction:
Recommendations for British Columbia s 2013 Budget AME BC s Pre-Budget Submission to the Select Standing Committee on Finance and Government Services - October 18, 2012 Introduction: Executive Summary
More informationOverview - Optimism Returns To The Oil Patch
In our recent study, we surveyed senior executives from across the oil and gas industry to determine the trends, issues and challenges for 2017 and beyond. These industry leaders weighed in on such topics
More informationChapter 8. Technology and Growth
Chapter 8 Technology and Growth The proximate causes Physical capital Population growth fertility mortality Human capital Health Education Productivity Technology Efficiency International trade 2 Plan
More informationThe Economic Contribution of Canada s R&D Intensive Enterprises Dr. H. Douglas Barber Dr. Jeffrey Crelinsten
The Economic Contribution of Canada s R&D Intensive Enterprises Dr. H. Douglas Barber Dr. Jeffrey Crelinsten March 2004 Table of Contents Page 1. Introduction 1 2. Retrospective Review of Firms by Research
More informationCanada s Engineering and Applied Science Technicians and Technologists. Assessing Their Economic Contribution
Canada s Engineering and Applied Science Technicians and Technologists. Assessing Their Economic Contribution REPORT APRIL 2016 For the exclusive use of Eric Morin, ericm@aset.ab.ca, ASET. Canada s Engineering
More informationNature-based and Eco-tourism
4. The Tourist Dollar From the Super Natural British Columbia brand to Washington s nickname as The Evergreen State, the natural beauty and resources of the Salish Sea region drive a tourism industry of
More informationWORKSHOP ON BASIC RESEARCH: POLICY RELEVANT DEFINITIONS AND MEASUREMENT ISSUES PAPER. Holmenkollen Park Hotel, Oslo, Norway October 2001
WORKSHOP ON BASIC RESEARCH: POLICY RELEVANT DEFINITIONS AND MEASUREMENT ISSUES PAPER Holmenkollen Park Hotel, Oslo, Norway 29-30 October 2001 Background 1. In their conclusions to the CSTP (Committee for
More informationMedia Literacy Expert Group Draft 2006
Page - 2 Media Literacy Expert Group Draft 2006 INTRODUCTION The media are a very powerful economic and social force. The media sector is also an accessible instrument for European citizens to better understand
More informationSoftware Production in Kyrgyzstan: Potential Source of Economic Growth
400 INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON EURASIAN ECONOMIES 2011 Software Production in Kyrgyzstan: Potential Source of Economic Growth Rahat Sabyrbekov (American University of Central Asia, Kyrgyzstan) Abstract
More informationCreative Industries: The Next Phase
Creative Industries: The Next Phase Innovation Impulses & Crossover Effects: Key Results From The New Austrian Creative Industries Report Austrian Institute for SME Research Peter Voithofer, Director Institute
More informationRACE TO THE TOP: Integrating Foresight, Evaluation, and Survey Methods
RACE TO THE TOP: Integrating Foresight, Evaluation, and Survey Methods Public Sector Foresight Network July 11, 2014 Orlando, Florida For more information, contact Jamila Kennedy, (202) 512-6833 or kennedyjj@gao.gov.
More informationSALE Intersection IH 37 & US HW 281 SITE:
Live Oak Crossing 3 3 Rivers TX OFFICE SITE FOR SALE Intersection IH 37 & US HW 281 THE EAGLE FORD SHALE: The largest single economic development in the history of the state of Texas. Ranking as the largest
More informationEconomics of Utica Shale in Ohio: Workforce Analysis
Cleveland State University EngagedScholarship@CSU Urban Publications Maxine Goodman Levin College of Urban Affairs 9-2015 Economics of Utica Shale in Ohio: Workforce Analysis Iryna Lendel Cleveland State
More informationMaking Sense of Science
Minister of Fisheries and Coastal Affairs, Lisbeth Berg- Hansen Aqua Nor, 13 August 2013 Opening Presentation at the Seminar Making Sense of Science 2 Ladies and gentlemen, distinguished guests! I am pleased
More informationTHE INTELLIGENT REFINERY
THE INTELLIGENT REFINERY DIGITAL. DISTILLED. DIGITAL REFINING SURVEY 2018 THE INTELLIGENT REFINERY SURVEY explained This deck provides highlights from the second annual Accenture Digital Refining Survey,
More informationTechnology Roadmaps as a Tool for Energy Planning and Policy Decisions
20 Energy Engmeering Vol. 0, No.4 2004 Technology Roadmaps as a Tool for Energy Planning and Policy Decisions James J. Winebrake, Ph.D. Rochester institute of Technology penetration" []. Roadmaps provide
More informationDesigning for recovery New challenges for large-scale, complex IT systems
Designing for recovery New challenges for large-scale, complex IT systems Prof. Ian Sommerville School of Computer Science St Andrews University Scotland St Andrews Small Scottish town, on the north-east
More informationINSPECTOR GENERAL U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
Unless otherwise noted all redactions are persuant to B(6) and B(7)(c) OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR REPORT OF INVESTIGATION Case Title BP Atlantis Reporting Office Energy
More informationInclusively Creative
In Bandung, Indonesia, December 5 th to 7 th 2017, over 100 representatives from the government, civil society, the private sector, think-tanks and academia, international organization as well as a number
More informationUS Productivity After the Dot Com Bust
McKinsey Global Institute US Productivity After the Dot Com Bust Diana Farrell Martin Baily Jaana Remes December 2005 McKinsey Global Institute The McKinsey Global Institute (MGI) was established in 1990
More informationMORE POWER TO THE ENERGY AND UTILITIES BUSINESS, FROM AI.
MORE POWER TO THE ENERGY AND UTILITIES BUSINESS, FROM AI www.infosys.com/aimaturity The current utility business model is under pressure from multiple fronts customers, prices, competitors, regulators,
More information1 NOTE: This paper reports the results of research and analysis
Race and Hispanic Origin Data: A Comparison of Results From the Census 2000 Supplementary Survey and Census 2000 Claudette E. Bennett and Deborah H. Griffin, U. S. Census Bureau Claudette E. Bennett, U.S.
More informationfree library of philadelphia STRATEGIC PLAN
free library of philadelphia STRATEGIC PLAN 2012 2017 Building on the Past, Changing for the Future The Free Library has been a haven and a launching pad for the people of Philadelphia from school-age
More informationThe Contribution of the Social Sciences to the Energy Challenge
Hearings: Subcommittee on Research & Science Education September 25, 2007 The Contribution of the Social Sciences to the Energy Challenge U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES COMMITTEE ON SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
More informationAN EMERGING FRAMEWORK FOR OCCIDENTAL-ORIENTAL INFORMATION SOCIETY LAW
AN EMERGING FRAMEWORK FOR OCCIDENTAL-ORIENTAL INFORMATION SOCIETY LAW Thomas S. E. Hilton, Utah State University, Hilton@cc.USU.edu Qingshan Zhou, Peking University Jeffrey J. Johnson, Utah State University
More informationMeasurement for Generation and Dissemination of Knowledge a case study for India, by Mr. Ashish Kumar, former DG of CSO of Government of India
Measurement for Generation and Dissemination of Knowledge a case study for India, by Mr. Ashish Kumar, former DG of CSO of Government of India This article represents the essential of the first step of
More informationGovernor Paterson breaks ground on GlobalFoundaries' Fab 2 project
Governor Paterson breaks ground on GlobalFoundaries' Fab 2 project August 21, 2009 - Front Section Governor David Paterson, GlobalFoundries U.S. Inc., Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) and senior state officials
More informationHigher Education for Science, Technology and Innovation. Accelerating Africa s Aspirations. Communique. Kigali, Rwanda.
Higher Education for Science, Technology and Innovation Accelerating Africa s Aspirations Communique Kigali, Rwanda March 13, 2014 We, the Governments here represented Ethiopia, Mozambique, Rwanda, Senegal,
More informationPost-Disaster Engineering & Construction. by Bob Prieto
Post-Disaster Engineering & Construction by Bob Prieto As the nation faces the challenges of rebuilding in Puerto Rico after the devastation of Hurricane Maria, it is important to understand that post-disaster
More informationChapter IV SUMMARY OF MAJOR FEATURES OF SEVERAL FOREIGN APPROACHES TO TECHNOLOGY POLICY
Chapter IV SUMMARY OF MAJOR FEATURES OF SEVERAL FOREIGN APPROACHES TO TECHNOLOGY POLICY Chapter IV SUMMARY OF MAJOR FEATURES OF SEVERAL FOREIGN APPROACHES TO TECHNOLOGY POLICY Foreign experience can offer
More informationENGINEERS, TECHNICIANS, ICT EXPERTS
TECHNICAL SERVICES ENGINEERS, TECHNICIANS, ICT EXPERTS Small, swift and agile, Switzerland can be at the forefront of change, and is embracing this opportunity. KLAUS MEIER Chief Information Officer Skyguide
More informationDIGITALIZING EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES STATE-OF-THE-ART TO THE ART-OF-THE-POSSIBLE: OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES FOR CANADA
DIGITALIZING EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES STATE-OF-THE-ART TO THE ART-OF-THE-POSSIBLE: OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES FOR CANADA For background information see https://munkschool.utoronto.ca/ipl/files/2017/11/ipl-white-paper-2017-4.pdf
More informationResponse to Ofcom s Consultation on Administrative Incentive Pricing
Response to Ofcom s Consultation on Administrative Incentive Pricing Background 1. The RadioCentre formed in July 2006 from the merger of the Radio Advertising Bureau (RAB) and the Commercial Radio Companies
More informationBeta Testing For New Ways of Sitting
Technology Beta Testing For New Ways of Sitting Gesture is based on Steelcase's global research study and the insights it yielded about how people work in a rapidly changing business environment. STEELCASE,
More informationRole of Knowledge Economics as a Driving Force in Global World
American International Journal of Research in Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences Available online at http://www.iasir.net ISSN (Print): 2328-3734, ISSN (Online): 2328-3696, ISSN (CD-ROM): 2328-3688 AIJRHASS
More informationSamson to lay off 70 workers in Tulsa
Samson to lay off 70 workers in Tulsa BY ROD WALTON World Staff Writer Wednesday, December 12, 2012 12/12/2012 7:30:21 AM Samson Resources Co. is laying off at least 100 people this month, including 70
More information1997 Annual Surveys of Journalism & Mass Communication Survey of Enrollments Survey of Graduates
1997 Annual Surveys of Journalism & Mass Communication Survey of Enrollments Survey of Graduates Sponsors: AEJMC, ASJMC Council of Affiliates of AEJMC The Freedom Forum National Association of Broadcasters
More informationIndustrial Revolutions
INDUSTRY 4.0 Digitalization for Productivity and Growth The Future of Productivity and Growth in Manufacturing Industries Industry 4.0 in Turkey as an Imperative for Global Competitiveness: An Emerging
More informationBLM S LAND USE PLANNING PROCESS AND PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES STEP-BY-STEP
BLM ACTION CENTER www.blmactioncenter.org BLM S LAND USE PLANNING PROCESS AND PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES STEP-BY-STEP Planning What you, the public, can do the Public to Submit Pre-Planning During
More informationDreamCatcher Agile Studio: Product Brochure
DreamCatcher Agile Studio: Product Brochure Why build a requirements-centric Agile Suite? As we look at the value chain of the SDLC process, as shown in the figure below, the most value is created in the
More informationTechnology transfer industry shows gains
Technology transfer industry shows gains in patents filed and granted, university-created startups and commercial products; slippage in federal research funding cited Highlights of AUTM s Canadian Licensing
More informationABORIGINAL CANADIANS AND THEIR SUPPORT FOR THE MINING INDUSTRY: THE REALITY, CHALLENGES AND SOLUTIONS
November 17, 2014 ABORIGINAL CANADIANS AND THEIR SUPPORT FOR THE MINING INDUSTRY: THE REALITY, CHALLENGES AND SOLUTIONS 1 PREPARE TO BE NOTICED ABORIGINAL CANADIANS AND THEIR SUPPORT FOR THE MINING INDUSTRY:
More informationMeasuring Romania s Creative Economy
2011 2nd International Conference on Business, Economics and Tourism Management IPEDR vol.24 (2011) (2011) IACSIT Press, Singapore Measuring Romania s Creative Economy Ana Bobircă 1, Alina Drăghici 2+
More informationEIF: Financing SMEs, creating & measuring meaningful impact
EIF: Financing SMEs, creating & measuring meaningful impact Helmut Kraemer-Eis, Head of Research & Market Analysis, Chief Economist European Investment Fund, EIF Rome Investment Forum 15th December 2017
More informationSustainable development
Guillaume Henry Joël Ruet Matthieu Wemaëre Sustainable development & INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY Access to technologies in developing countries introduction Innovation concerning emerging economies is as much
More informationB.B.S./M.B.S. Industrial Technology
Blue Marble University B.B.S./M.B.S. Industrial Technology Curriculum and Course Descriptions (4 Year Program) This is a combined Bachelor of Business Science (BBS) and Master of Business Science (MBS)
More informationTransferring knowledge from operations to the design and optimization of work systems: bridging the offshore/onshore gap
Transferring knowledge from operations to the design and optimization of work systems: bridging the offshore/onshore gap Carolina Conceição, Anna Rose Jensen, Ole Broberg DTU Management Engineering, Technical
More informationLowndes County by the Numbers
Lowndes County by the Numbers How Do We Compare With Peer and Aspirant Communities? 2011 Report DRAFT 05/06/2011 Insert a collage of blended pictures from around Valdosta This report has been prepared
More informationBASED ECONOMIES. Nicholas S. Vonortas
KNOWLEDGE- BASED ECONOMIES Nicholas S. Vonortas Center for International Science and Technology Policy & Department of Economics The George Washington University CLAI June 9, 2008 Setting the Stage The
More informationThe Critical Path. Positioning Maryland as an Innovation Leader in the Global Construction Industry
Positioning Maryland as an Innovation Leader in the Global Construction Industry For Downloads: 1.Executive Summary 2.Full Report Scan this QR code. To Join the MCCEI Mailing List: Send your email address
More informationSEMICONDUCTOR INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION FACTBOOK
Factbook 2014 SEMICONDUCTOR INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION FACTBOOK INTRODUCTION The data included in the 2014 SIA Factbook helps demonstrate the strength and promise of the U.S. semiconductor industry and why it
More informationHaldimand County 2018 Community Profile
Labour Force Key Indicators Haldimand County is home to a labour force of more than 27,000 persons. As illustrated in Table 12, the labour force participation and employment rates are above that of Ontario.
More informationComparative study of SME development in Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan. Lyubov Tsoy CWRD intern Supervisor Dai Chai Song
Comparative study of SME development in Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan Lyubov Tsoy CWRD intern Supervisor Dai Chai Song 1. Background 2. SME development trends (1991-2013) 3. Factors that caused differences
More informationWhy is US Productivity Growth So Slow? Possible Explanations Possible Policy Responses
Why is US Productivity Growth So Slow? Possible Explanations Possible Policy Responses Presentation to Nomura Foundation Conference Martin Neil Baily and Nicholas Montalbano What is productivity and why
More informationGlobal Position Paper on Fishery Rights-Based Management
Light tower Tatjana Gerling/WWF International Global Position Paper on Fishery Rights-Based Management WWF believes that appropriate, clear and enforceable fishing entitlements and responsibilities are
More informationNorth Fork Alternative Plan Executive Summary
North Fork Alternative Plan Executive Summary The North Fork Alternative Plan (NFAP) is a resource-based set of recommendations provided to the U.S. Bureau of Land Management (BLM) as guidance regarding
More informationFebruary 4, 2004 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PROCEDURAL HISTORY. Mark Helmueller, Hearings Examiner
February 4, 2004 OIL AND GAS DOCKET NO. 01-0236356 APPLICATION OF L.O. OIL AND GAS, L.L.C., TO CONSIDER AN EXCEPTION TO STATEWIDE RULE 21 TO ALLOW PRODUCTION BY SWABBING, BAILING, OR JETTING OF WELL NO.
More informationLowndes County by the Numbers
Lowndes County by the Numbers How Do We Compare With Peer and Aspirant Communities? 2015 Report This report has been prepared for the Valdosta-Lowndes County Chamber of Commerce by the Center for Business
More informationINTELLECTUAL PROPERTY (IP) SME SCOREBOARD 2016
www.euipo.europa.eu INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY (IP) SME SCOREBOARD 2016 Executive Summary JUNE 2016 www.euipo.europa.eu INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY (IP) SME SCOREBOARD 2016 Commissioned to GfK Belgium by the European
More informationINTELLECTUAL PROPERTY (IP) SME SCOREBOARD 2016
www.euipo.europa.eu INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY (IP) SME SCOREBOARD 2016 Executive Summary JUNE 2016 www.euipo.europa.eu INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY (IP) SME SCOREBOARD 2016 Commissioned to GfK Belgium by the European
More informationIII. THE REGIONAL FRAMEWORK
THE SAN DIEGO REGIONAL ECONOMY III. THE REGIONAL FRAMEWORK The San Diego region, comprised solely of San Diego County, is one of California s most dynamic regions. The efforts of the University within
More informationNorth York Moors National Park Authority
Item 13 North York Moors National Park Authority 1 October 2018 Government Consultations on: i) Permitted Development rights for Shale Gas Exploration; ii) Inclusion of Shale Gas Production Projects in
More informationFocusing Software Education on Engineering
Introduction Focusing Software Education on Engineering John C. Knight Department of Computer Science University of Virginia We must decide we want to be engineers not blacksmiths. Peter Amey, Praxis Critical
More informationMr Hans Hoogervorst International Accounting Standards Board 1 st Floor 30 Cannon Street London EC4M 6XH. MV/288 Mark Vaessen.
Tel +44 (0)20 7694 8871 15 Canada Square mark.vaessen@kpmgifrg.com London E14 5GL United Kingdom Mr Hans Hoogervorst International Accounting Standards Board 1 st Floor 30 Cannon Street London EC4M 6XH
More informationOfficial Journal of the European Union L 21/15 COMMISSION
25.1.2005 Official Journal of the European Union L 21/15 COMMISSION COMMISSION DECISION of 17 January 2005 on the harmonisation of the 24 GHz range radio spectrum band for the time-limited use by automotive
More informationImpact of international cooperation and science and innovation strategies on S&T output: a comparative study of India and China
Impact of international cooperation and science and innovation strategies on S&T output: a comparative study of India and China S. A. Hasan, Amit Rohilla and Rajesh Luthra* India and China have made sizeable
More informationGovernment, an Actor in Innovation
Towards a Québec Innovation Policy Government, an Actor in Innovation Science and Technology in Public Administration Advisory report of the Conseil de la science et de la technologie Summary Governments
More informationResource Management Act 1991 ( Act ) KAWARAU JET SERVICES HOLDINGS LIMITED. Appellant QUEENSTOWN LAKES DISTRICT COUNCIL.
IN THE ENVIRONMENT COURT AT CHRISTCHURCH ENV-2018-CHC-0000 UNDER THE IN THE MATTER OF Resource Management Act 1991 ( Act ) An appeal under Schedule 1, Clause 14(1), of the Act BETWEEN KAWARAU JET SERVICES
More informationAdopted March 17, 2009 (Ordinance 09-15)
ECONOMIC ELEMENT of the PINELLAS COUNTY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN Prepared By: The Pinellas County Planning Department as staff to the LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY for THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF PINELLAS COUNTY,
More informationWHEN NATIONS NEED TO GO BEYOND OIL GULF STATES PUT NEW EMPHASIS ON GROWING LOCAL INDUSTRIES
WHEN NATIONS NEED TO GO BEYOND OIL GULF STATES PUT NEW EMPHASIS ON GROWING LOCAL INDUSTRIES Bruno Sousa Volker Weber Saji Sam 1 There s a certain symbolism in the role South Korea has taken on in helping
More information101 Sources of Spillover: An Analysis of Unclaimed Savings at the Portfolio Level
101 Sources of Spillover: An Analysis of Unclaimed Savings at the Portfolio Level Author: Antje Flanders, Opinion Dynamics Corporation, Waltham, MA ABSTRACT This paper presents methodologies and lessons
More informationINNOVATION : STATE OF PLAY MINING INDUSTRY SURVEY 2017
INNOVATION : STATE OF PLAY MINING INDUSTRY SURVEY 2017 SUMMARY INSIGHTS The 3rd biennial survey of more than 800 global mining leaders reveals the impact of a rapidly changing international marketplace
More informationThe University of the Future - as Education for Sustainable Development Hub
AIESEC International 1 The University of the Future - as Education for Sustainable Development Hub Summary Initiated by Denys Oleksandrovych Shpotia e-mail: denis.shpotya@gmail.com Rio+20 Preparation Events
More informationShale Gas Innovation & Commercialization Center (SGICC)
Shale Gas Innovation & Commercialization Center (SGICC) Established Spring of 2011 by the Ben Franklin Technology Partners of Central & Northern PA Goals & Objectives: Discover, encourage and support translational
More information121 W. Fireweed Lane, Suite L Street, NW Anchorage, Alaska Washington, DC Phone: (907) Phone: (202)
Alaska Oil and Gas Association American Petroleum Institute 121 W. Fireweed Lane, Suite 207 1220 L Street, NW Anchorage, Alaska 99503-2035 Washington, DC 20005 Phone: (907) 272-1481 Phone: (202)682-8000
More informationINTERNET AND SOCIETY: A PRELIMINARY REPORT
IT&SOCIETY, VOLUME 1, ISSUE 1, SUMMER 2002, PP. 275-283 INTERNET AND SOCIETY: A PRELIMINARY REPORT NORMAN H. NIE LUTZ ERBRING ABSTRACT (Data Available) The revolution in information technology (IT) has
More informationDMSMS Management: After Years of Evolution, There s Still Room for Improvement
DMSMS Management: After Years of Evolution, There s Still Room for Improvement By Jay Mandelbaum, Tina M. Patterson, Robin Brown, and William F. Conroy dsp.dla.mil 13 Which of the following two statements
More informationLately, though, the development of Ohio shale gas means the company is seeing rapid growth close to home.
Well-positioned The Columbus [Oh.] Dispatch February 10, 2013, pg. 1D By Dan Gearino Dateline: Mount Verson, Ohio For decades, Ariel Corp. had a long-distance relationship with the natural-gas industry,
More information