Optimaliseren van Impact door Alfa- en Gammawetenschappen

Transcription

1 Optimaliseren van Impact door Alfa- en Gammawetenschappen Aantonen en stimuleren van Societal Impact in synergie met andere wetenschappen Wifi: CongresAlfaGamma Wachtwoord: Impact2016 Welkom op het congres

2 Optimaliseren van Impact door Alfa- en Gammawetenschappen Louise Gunning-Schepers Voorzitter Nationale Wetenschapsagenda

3

4 Dutch National Research Agenda Policy paper Minister of Education, Culture and Science: Wetenschapsvisie 2025 called for a national research agenda: International excellence in science Create synergy between disciplines and partners Impact can be for science, for society or for economic growth

5 Impact starts with participation Partners in the field of research and innovation KNAW, MKB-Nederland, NFU, NWO, TO2, VNO-NCW, VH, VSNU Joint ownership in a Steering committee Independent chairs: Beatrice de Graaf & Alexander Rinnooy Kan Second phase: Louise Gunning

6 Participation of the public in setting the agenda questions asked Meetings of general public and researchers Curiosity and strengths Roles in the innovation process and joining forces

7

8 25 workshops No money in the near future Great participation and enthousiasm New partners in gamechangers

9

10

11

12 Routes defined by questions Link the questions to feasible gamechangers A consortium: research institutions, private and public partners PPS versus Public-Public partnership A joint, multidisciplinary researchprogramme Find a link to other research agenda s, institutional or international

13 Investing in impact More impact from science is possible but only with additional investments 1 Billion euro s a year Invest half in collaboration for more impact, gamechangers as inspiration But invest the other half in the next generation, through talent tracks and infrastructure Full spectrum of research and innovation

14 The process Questions from society Jury s of scientists Unexpected meetings and coalitions Great involvement of ministries Studiegroep Duurzame Groei Greatest gamechanger the Coalition

15

16 Optimaliseren van Impact door Alfa- en Gammawetenschappen René Penning de Vries Boegbeeld ICT voor de Topsectoren

17 René Penning de Vries Boegbeeld ICT 8 dec 2016 how to create impact in / with alpha and social sciences? Science Works congres Universiteit van TIlburg 17

18 From a holistic view. p. Dance (2) Matisse,

19 ..into fragmentation p. Blue Nude II Matisse,

20 Convergence, a new Paradigm p. A new approach to foster innovative care and cure concepts. bio, molecular and cellular science Genomics The Third Revolution: Convergence of Life Sciences, Physical Sciences and Engineering MIT

21 e.g. Future of Health (2016) p. The Future of Health (2016) Regenerative medicin, cancer detection, Drug delivering nano devices. 21

22 Convergence: changes in the system. p. NIH (2015): 97% funding into Biomedical researcher System change required: Connected funding agencies Adjusted peer-review process Educate, expand, support next generation convergence researchers 22

23 ..in the meantime in NL

24 and yes, we need each other! How to responsibly and ethically design new products? How to responsibly use and apply technology in new products? How to land new technologies and products in society? 24

25 ICT is key to all Topsectoren Topsector and ICT p. X p. Biobased Economy Nanotechnology ICT 25 12

26 Commit2Data p. 1 Big Data: Cross-functional demand inspired knowledge generation Governance and Funding not yet Convergence grade 26

27 Commit2Data WoW p. 1 Topsector Scope: ICT and Topsectors Common Roadmap Definition NWO Calls to trigger PPS Peer review Project driven, private funding ~20-40% Generic ICT 27

28 Commit2Data p. 28

29 BlockChain: BC3 p. 2 Digital Trust Blockchain Scope: Industry, society, governments ICT, MBA, regulation, legal, taxation, accountancy Today: Technology driven and that is not good enough. 29

30 BC3 WoW p. 2 Government; Industry; Societal institute Scope defined by multi disciplenairy, strategic partners Common LT Vision and Roadmap Competence driven Alignment to Field Labs Partner fee for 50/50 funding long term Generic ICT; Law; regulation; ethics 30

31 with in Impact IN ICT vs. impact WITH ICT? p. Topsector Impact with ICT i Impact In ICT with in ICT / DIgitization 31

32 Commit2Data vs BLockchain p. C2D BC3 Scope: KIA ICT and Topsector Common Roadmap Definition Project driven NWO Calls as trigger moment Private funding ~20-40% Scope defined by wide range of strategic partners LT Vision and Roadmap Competence driven Alignment to Field Labs Partner fee for 50/50 funding 32

33 Conclusion Convergence creates impact Science management and instruments need to support Engage (in BC3!) 33

34 Optimaliseren van Impact door Alfa- en Gammawetenschappen Johannes Klumpers Head of Science Advice Mechanism unit, European Commission

35 Optimaliseren van Impact door Alfa- en Gammawetenschappen Roger Kain Vice-President (Research), British Academy

36 Measuring the societal impact of humanities and social science research: UK Research Excellence Framework Professor Roger Kain FBA, Vice-President (Research), The British Academy

37 The British Academy Fellowship Funding Body Forum

38 Impact REF2014 definition of Impact Societal rather than academic Why was Impact included in 2014?

39 Measuring Impact Pilot exercise pre REF 2014 Case study approach Underpinning quality of research Impact Template

40 REF2014 Impact Case Studies some headlines Interdisciplinary /multidisciplinary 80% Diversity of impact Diversity of origin International

41 REF2014 HSS Impact outcomes Average percentage of research activity judged to meet the standard for world-leading excellence (4*) Main Panel A - Medicine & Life Sciences 60.9 Main Panel B - Physical Sciences 37.8 Main Panel C - Social Sciences 39.1 Main Panel D - Arts and Humanities 36.7 Social Work and Social Policy (43.8% - 4*) Classics (41.4% - 4*)

42 Digital Science case study analysis Word cloud of most frequent words from the Details of the impact (Section 4) of the case studies

43 REF 2021 independent review chaired by Lord Stern Highlights of British Academy response: Definition impact toxic in HSS? Linking back to a body of work not a single piece of research Need to retain narrative approach peer review not metrics

44 Lord Stern Review of REF Building on success and learning from experience Two changes for Impact - university as well as department level - broader definition.