SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS Grants & Denials List Monday, March 27, 2006 GRANTS STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTY TRIAL JUDGE TRIAL COURT NO. APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT NATURE OF APPEAL ACTION Nashville David Clark v. Lowe s Home Centers, et al. M2004-02972-WC-R3-CV Jackson Circuit James O. Bond 00-118-KK-180 Granted - This case is transferred to the entire Supreme Court for Review. Set for oral argument June term in Nashville. *Filed March 22, 2006* Knoxville None Jackson Page 1 of 8
None SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS Monday, March 27, 2006 DENIALS STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTY TRIAL JUDGE TRIAL COURT NO. APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT NATURE OF APPEAL ACTION Nashville W. Michael Byrd v. Mary Etta Byrd M2003-02203-SC-R11-CV Davidson Circuit Muriel Robinson 89D-1655 Clement, J Mod. In Part and Denied - Motion to rehear application denial of Mary Etta Byrd Leonardo v. Catalano v. State of M2005-0070-SC-R11-PC Steve Dozier 2001-A-453 Denied - Application of Leonard V. Catalano. Steven Paul Deskins v. State of M2004-02638-R11-PC Steve R. Dozier 2001-B-909 Denied - Application of Steven Paul Deskins Page 2 of 8
Grand Hotel, L.P. v. Terry W. Cardin and Cheryl K. Cardin M2004-00996-SC-R11-CV Marion Chancery Jeffrey F. Stewart 6317 and Denied - Application of Terry W. Cardin and Cheryl K. Cardin. Kerry Hibdon v. George J. Grabowski, et al. M2004-01050-SC-R11-CV Warren Circuit John A, Turnbull 904 in part, Reversed in part, Denied - Application of George Grabowski, Fagan Pace, Ben Pennington, Ronnie Reels and Larry Talley Eric Todd Jackson v. Ken Goble M2004-02562-SC-R11-CV Montgomery Circuit Ross H. Hicks 50400219 Cain, J Cottrell, J Clement, J Dismissed Denied - Application of Eric Todd Jackson. Eli J. Landry, Jr. v. State of Tennesse M2004-3066-SC-R11-PC Cheryl Blackburn 2000-B-838 Denied - Application of Eli J. Landry, Jr.. Roketa Mason, et al. v. Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County, TN M2003-03108-SC-R11-CV Davidson Circuit Hamilton V. Gayden, Jr. 03C-234 Clement, J Vacated and Denied - Application of Roketa Mason Jimmy M. Millican v. State of M2004-02252-SC-R11-PC J. Randall Wyatt, Jr. 2000-T-181 Hayes, J Denied - Application of Jimmy M. Millican. Johnny Dee Roberts v. State of M2005-00215-SC-R11-PC Cheryl Blackburn 2001-C-1812 Witt, J Denied - Application of Johnny Dee Roberts. Mike Settle v. State of M2005-00411-SC-R11-HC Davidson Circuit Barbara Haynes 04C-3661 Witt, J Denied - Application of Michael Settle. Page 3 of 8
State of v. Wanda G. Ayers M2004-02153-SC-R11-CD Montgomery Circuit John H. Gassaway 40200170 Wade, J Reversed and Denied - Application of Wanda G. Ayers. State of v. Charles Baldwin M2005-00546-SC-R11-CD Cheryl Blackburn 2003-A-148; 2003-A-344 Denied - Application of Charles Baldwin. State of v. Norman L. Follis M2006-00128-SC-S10-CD Steve R. Dozier GS-201158 Wedemeyer, J. Denied Denied - Application of Norman J. Follis. State of v. James Allen Gooch, Jr. M2006-00186-SC-S10-CD Sumner Circuit Jane W. Wheatcraft CR538-2005 Wedemeyer, J. Denied Rule 10 Denied - Application of James Allen Gooch. State of v. Deon Larkins M2004-02415-SC-R11-CD J. Randall Wyatt, Jr. 2003-C-1895 Denied - Application of Deon Larkins. State of v. Homer Alson Maddin, III M2004-02298-SC-R11-CD Steve R. Dozier 2003-A-393 Denied - Application of Homer Alson Maddin, III. State of v. Basil Marceaux M2004-02739-SC-R11-CD Van Buren Circuit Larry B. Stanley 1787M Wedemeyer, J Rule 10 - Denied - Application of Basil Marceaux State of v. Jerome Mayo M2004-03061-SC-R11-CD Montgomery Circuit Michael Jones 40300086 Welles, J in Part, Reversed in Part, Denied - Application of Jerome Mayo. Page 4 of 8
State of v. Bobby James Mosley, Jr. M2004-02788-SC- R11-CD Marshall Circuit Charles Lee 15575 Wade, J Denied - Application of Bobby James Mosley State of v. Cecil Moss M2005-00279-SC-R11-CO Dickson Circuit Robert E. Burch CR131; CR132 Tipton, J Dismissed Denied - Application of Cecil Moss. State of v. Lonnie Lee Owens M2005-00362-SC-R11-CD Franklin Circuit Buddy Perry 15356 Welles, J Reversed in Part, Sent. Modified Denied - Application of Lonnie Lee Owens. State of v. Young Bak Song M2004-02885-SC-R11-CD Steve R. Dozier 2003-C-1792 Denied - Application of Young Bak Song. State of v. Michael Weigart M2006-00484-SC-R8-CD Lawrence Circuit Stella L. Hargrove 25103 Rule 8 Denied - Motion for Review of Michael Weigart. Knoxville City - County Federal Credit Union v. Suzanne E. Linboe E2005-00577-SC-R11-CV Monroe Circuit Lawrence H. Puckett V04389P Swiney, J Denied - Application of Suzanne E. Linboe. Terry Penny v. State of E2004-01735-SC-R11-PC Hamilton Criminal Douglas Meyer 130199, 248876 Denied - Application of Terry Penny Robert Allen Roysden v. State of E2005-00113-SC-R11-PC Roane Circuit E. Eugene Eblen 12367-B Denied - Application of Robert Allen Roysden Page 5 of 8
State of v. James D. Black E2004-02449-SC-R11-CD Sullivan Criminal Phyllis Miller S47, 058 Denied - Application of James D. Black State of v. Jamie Brown E2004-02717-SC-R11-CD Knox Criminal Richard Baumgartner 77031 Denied - Application of Jamie Brown Stae of v. Terry Boyd Collins E2004-01677-SC-R11-CD Sullivan Circuit Phyllis Miller S45,529 Witt, J Denied - Application of Terry Boyd Collins **The opinion of the Court of Appeals is designated Not for Citation in accordance with Supreme Court Rule 4, F. State of v. Teresa C. Graves E2004-02620-SC-R11-CD Loudon Circuit E. Eugene Eblen 10100, Resentencing Denied - Application of Teresa C. Graves **The opinion of the Court of Appeals is designated Not for Citation in accordance with Supreme Court Rule 4, F. State of v. William A. Hawkins E2004-01761-SC-R11-CD Sullivan Circuit Phyllis Milller S46, 562 and Denied - Application of William A. Hawkins State of v. Kisa Durbin Howard E2005-00112-SC-R11-CD Bradley Circuit Carroll Ross M-03-669 Denied - Application of Lisa Durbin Howard State of v. Angie Delene Jackson E2004-01755-SC-R11-CD Greene Circuit James E. Beckner 03CR063 in part, Reversed in part and Denied - Application of Angie Delene Jackson Page 6 of 8
State of v. Donald Luke Seiber, Alias E2004-01794-SC-R11-CD Knox Criminal Ray Jenkins 73049 Denied - Application of Donald Luke Seiber State of v. Patricia Ann Starkey, Alias E2004-02696-SC-R11-CD Knox Criminal Richard Baumgartner 76046 Dismissed Denied - Application of Patricia Ann Starkey Jackson Arrow Electronics v. Adecco Employment Services, Inc. W2004-02595-SC-R11-CV Shelby Circuit John R. McCarroll, Jr. CT-002241-03 Denied - Application of Arrow Electronics Lamarr Fletcher v. Shelby County Public Defenders Office W2005-01737-SC-R11-CV Shelby Chancery Kay S. Robilio 98-0694-1 Kirby, J Dismissed Denied - Application of Lamarr Fletcher. ** Defendant s motion to enjoin the petitioner also denied** Charles Goode v. State of W2004-01577-SC-R11-PC Shelby County Criminal Arthur T. Bennett P-26257 Denied - Application of Charles Goode Mark Grimes v. Stephen Dotson, Warden W2005-00862-SC-R11-HC Hardeman County Circuit Joe H. Walker, III R.D. 05-02-0023 McLin, J pursuant to Rule 20 Denied - Application of Mark Grimes Andre Matthews v. Shelby County Government W2005-00470-SC-R11-CV Shelby Chancery Arnold Goldin 110180-2 Denied - Application of Andre Matthews James Emmett Moses, Jr. v. State of W2005-01071-SC-R11-HC Hardeman Circuit Joe H. Walker 05-02-0026 Witt, J Denied - Application of James Emmett Moses, Jr. Page 7 of 8
Fredrick Sledge v. State of W2004-02357-SC-R11-PC Shelby Criminal Bernie Weinman P-27638 Denied - Application of Fredrick Sledge Terrance B. Smith v. State of W2004-02366-SC-R11-PC Tipton County Circuit Joseph H. Walker 3593 Hayes, J Denied - Application of Terrance B. Smith State of v. Stanley Phillip Chapman W2004-02404-SC-R11-CD Tipton County Joseph H. Walker 4717 Denied - Application of Stanley Phillip Chapman Patrick Stewart v. State of W2005-01843-SC-R11-HC Lauderdale County Joe H. Walker 5967 pursuant to Rule 20 Denied - Application of Patrick Stewart Rodney Wilson, et al v. Gerald W. Pickens W2004-02966-SC-R11-CV Shelby Circuit John R. McCarroll, Jr. 301614 Farmer, J Reversed and Denied - Application of Rodney Wilson and wife, Robbie Wilson Page 8 of 8