IJIRST International Journal for Innovative Research in Science & Technology Volume 3 Issue 06 November 2016 ISSN (online): 2349-6010 Effect of Burnishing Force on Surface Roughness and Hardness of Low Carbon Steel Spur Gear by using Diamond Gear Burnishing Chhabildas M. Gajare Research Scholar Department of Mechanical Engineering Zeal College of Engineering & Research, Narhe, Pune 411041, India Dr. U. M. Shirsat Professor Department of Mechanical Engineering Siddhant College of Engineering, Pune 412205 India Abstract Gear Burnishing is a cold working surface finishing process in which the work gear is rolled in tight mesh with hardened and highly accurate smooth gears. When contact stress between gear teeth increases the yield point stress of the material, plastic deformation occurs that reduces surface irregularities improving surface finish and induces useful residual compressive stresses. Gear burnishing if carried out properly results in improvement in metallic surface properties such as surface finish, surface hardness, wear resistance, corrosion resistance and fatigue life. The involute spur gears of AISI 1018 and AISI 1020 are burnished by diamond gear burnishing tool for fixed values of cycle time and speed without coolant. The burnishing force is varied to investigate its impact on surface roughness and surface hardness of gears. The spur gear is rolled in mesh with hard diamond coated gear at 300 rpm for 30 seconds in clockwise direction and then for another 30 sec in anticlockwise direction on standard diamond gear burnishing machine. Considerable effect of burnishing force on surface finish and micro hardness of spur gear of is observed due to burnishing. Keywords: Burnishing, Surface Roughness, Surface Hardness, Burnishing Force, Diamond Gear I. INTRODUCTION In burnishing, the contact stress or pressure between the work piece and the burnishing tool must exceed the yield point stress of the material. Good burnishing occurs when the burnishing pressure is 1.8 to 2.1 times the yield point stress of the material. Material yields when contact stress exceeds yield point stress of the material, plastic deformation occurs beyond yielding. The yield strength(s yt) of AISI 1018 is 370MPa and that of AISI 1020 is 295MPa. In the present work, the involute spur gears of AISI 1018 & AISI 1020 are burnished by diamond gear burnishing tool for fixed values of cycle time and speed without coolant. The burnishing force is varied to investigate its impact on surface roughness and surface hardness of gears. The spur gear is rolled in mesh with hard diamond coated gear at 300 rpm for 30 seconds in clockwise direction and then for another 30 sec in anticlockwise direction on standard diamond gear burnishing machine. The surface roughness is examined by using Hommel Tester T1000 and hardness tested by portable hardness tester model PHT 1840. II. MATERIAL AND EQUIPMENT The material of work gear specimen, its dimensions and the diamond gear machine setup specifications are as follows: Material Chemical Composition Table 1 Material Chemical Composition Element Carbon, C Iron, Fe Manganese, Mn Phosphorous, P Sulfur, S AISI 1018 (EN32B) 0.14-0.20 % 98.81 99.26 % 0.60 0.90 % 0.040 % 0.050% AISI 1020 (EN3A) 0.17-0.23 % 99.08 99.53 % 0.30 0.60 % 0.040 % 0.050% Spur Gear Specification Work Gear Module, m = 2 mm, Pitch Circle Diameter, d = 40 mm, Number of Teeth, T = 20, Face width, b = 10 mm All rights reserved by www.ijirst.org 100
Fig. 1: Work Gear Diamond Gear Module, m = 2 mm, Pitch Circle Diameter, d = 220 mm, Number of Teeth, T = 110, Face width, b = 24 mm Fig. 2: Diamond Gear Diamond Gear Burnishing Machine Set up Specification: Spindle Speed: 300 to 1100 rpm (Inverter Controlled) Spindle Power: 2 HP, 950 rpm Maximum force on gear: 300 kgf at 5 bar pneumatic line pressure Electrical controller: PLC Siemens S7 200 TD 200 Display Pneumatic System Festo Maximum work diameter: 200 mm Minimum work diameter: 20 mm Tilt angle: ± 15 0 Fig. 3: Gear Burnishing Set up All rights reserved by www.ijirst.org 101
III. EFFECT OF BURNISHING FORCE ON SURFACE ROUGHNESS AND HARDNESS Specified spur gears are burnished using diamond gear burnishing tool for different values of burnishing forces. The surface roughness and hardness of burnished gear are recorded precisely. Following tables and graphs shows that there is considerable variation in surface roughness and hardness with burnishing force. Table 1 Variation of surface roughness with burnishing force for AISI 1018 Surface Roughness (µm) 1.829 1.816 1.516 1.050 0.886 1.129 1.229 1.334 Table 2 Variation of surface hardness with burnishing force for AISI 1018 Surface Hardness (HRB) 68 70 71 73 75 74 72 71 Table 3 Variation of surface roughness with burnishing force for AISI 1020 Surface Roughness (µm) 1.952 1.821 1.609 0.906 0.996 1.139 1.474 1.501 Table 4 Variation of surface hardness with burnishing force for AISI 1020 Surface Hardness (HRB) 63 64 67 72 71 69 69 68 Fig. 4: Effect of Burnishing Force on Surface Roughness for AISI 1018 Fig. 5: Effect of Burnishing Force on Surface Hardness for AISI 1018 All rights reserved by www.ijirst.org 102
Fig. 6: Effect of Burnishing Force on Surface Roughness for AISI 1020 Fig. 7: Effect of Burnishing Force on Surface Hardness for AISI 1020 IV. CONCLUSION The impact of burnishing force on surface roughness and hardness of spur gears of materials AISI 1018 and AISI 1020 are investigated. The burnishing force greatly affects the roughness and hardness of gears. The hardness increases and roughness decreases with burnishing force up to certain value (40Kgf for AISI 1018, 35Kgf for AISI 1020). Beyond this value of force decrease in hardness and increase in roughness is observed. It is found that the roughness value (Ra) reduces maximum by 51.55% for AISI 1018 and 53.59% for AISI 1020. The surface hardness is increased maximum by 10.29% for AISI 1018 and 14.28% for AISI 1020 material. REFERENCES [1] R. L. Murthy and B. Kotiveerachari (1981, July), Burnishing of Metallic Surfaces A Review, Precision Engineering, Elsevier, Volume 3, Issue 2, pp 172-179 [2] Wit Grzesik (2012), Functional Properties of Hardened Steel Parts generated by Turning & Ball Burnishing Operations, Published in Advances in Manufacturing Science & Technology, Volume 36, No. 04 [3] A. M. Hassan, A. M. Maqableh (2000), The effects of initial burnishing parameters on non-ferrous components, Journal of Material Processing Technology, Elsevier, 102 [4] Malleswara Rao J. N., Chenna Reddy, Rama Rao (2011), The effect of roller burnishing on surface hardness & surface roughness of mild steel specimens, International Journal of Applied Engineering & Research, Vol. 1, No.4 [5] American Gear Manufacturers Association, ANSI/AGMA 2101-D04, Fundamental Rating Factors and Calculation Methods for Involute Spur and Helical Gear Teeth, Alexandria VA, AGMA, 2004 [6] A. R. Hassan (2009), Contact stress analysis of spur gear teeth pair, World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology, International Journal of Mechanical, Aerospace, Industrial, Mechatronic and Manufacturing Engineering, Vol. 3, No.10 [7] Boresi A. P. and Schmidt R. J., Advanced Mechanics of Marerials, Sixth Edition, John Wiley and Sons (ASIA), 2003, pp. 589-624 [8] Suresh Dhimal et. al. (2008, May), Machining behavior of AISI 1018 steel during turning, Journal of Scientific & Industrial Research, Vol. 67 All rights reserved by www.ijirst.org 103
[9] M. Raja Roy, S. Phani Kumar, D. S. Sai Ravi Kiran, Contact pressure analysis of spur gear using FEA, International Journal of Advanced Engineering Applications, Vol.7, Issue 3, 2014 [10] T. Morimoto (1992), Effect of lubricant fluid on burnishing process using a rotating ball tool Tribology International, Vol. 22, Issue 2 [11] M. P. Grover, Fundamentals of Modern Manufacturing, Materials, Processes & Systems, John Wiley & Sons, 4th edition, 2010 [12] P Ravindra Babu, K Ankamma, T Siva Prasad, A V S Raju & N Eswara Prasad (2012 Aug), Optimization of burnishing parameters and determination of select surface characteristics in engineering materials Sadhana, Indian Academy of Sciences, Vol. 37, Part 4 All rights reserved by www.ijirst.org 104