Appointment of External Auditors This paper is for: Recommendation: Decision The Governing Body is asked to note the report and agree that a specialised Audit Panel be set up for the selection of the CCG s external auditors from 2017/18 For further information or for any enquiries relating to this report please contact: Rebecca Gibson, Senior Finance Manager Date: 23 rd Reporting Officer: Rebecca Gibson Agenda Item: 37/16 Lead Director: Reg Middleton Version: 001 Report Summary: This report informs the Governing Body of the requirement for the CCG to procure external audit services from 2017/18. It explains the introduction of the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014 and outlines the role of auditor panels in the procurement process. FOI status: This paper is disclosable under the FOI Act Strategic objectives links: Board Assurance Framework links: Identified risks & risk management actions: E Sustainable finances F Robust governance Should the CCG fail to appoint an external auditor, the legislation provides for the Secretary of State for Health or NHS England to either appoint an auditor for the CCG, or direct the CCG to appoint a named auditor. The CCG would then lose the ability to negotiate contract values. Resource implications: Legal implications including equality and diversity assessment The creation of an audit panel is expected to incur additional cost, which may be shared across CCGs The CCG would not be compliant with the law if it fails to appoint an external auditor
Report history: Appendices Next steps: None N/A Subject to Governing Body decision, establishment of Audit Panel. Any recommendation from Audit panel will be brought before the Governing Body in due course.
1. INTRODUCTION This paper updates the Governing Body on the position regarding the external audit contract, following the abolition of the Audit Commission, and the role of auditor panels in procuring a new contract. 2. BACKGROUND As the Governing Body will be aware, the CCG is required to produce a set of financial statements each year, and to have these externally audited. The external auditors also make an annual assessment as to whether the organisation has achieved value for money in its operation. Since 1990, the responsibility for auditing the NHS lay with the Audit Commission. The Commission appointed the external auditor for each NHS body - either its in-house audit staff, or a private sector company. The NHS organisation tended to have little influence over who was appointed as the external auditor. However, when foundation trusts were established, they were allowed to appoint their own external auditors. The CCG s current auditors, KPMG LLP, were appointed as the auditors of the CCG with effect from 1 April 2015, following PricewaterhouseCoopers who had fulfilled this role since the inception of the CCG. In 2010, the government proposed the abolition of the Audit Commission, and the establishment of a new framework for the audit of public sector bodies as part of the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014. This mainly involved the transfer of the Commission s functions to various other organisations, the transfer of its in-house audit staff to private companies, and allowing public sector bodies to appoint their own external auditor. The Audit Commission closed on 1 April 2015. 3. CURRENT EXTERNAL AUDIT CONTRACT Although the Audit Commission closed on 1 April 2015, existing audit service contracts will remain in place up until 2016/17. From 2017/18 onwards, the CCG will appoint their own auditors and directly manage the resulting contract and the relationship. The Department of Health has decided that all NHS bodies will have to procure their external audit service from this date. 4. AUDITOR PANELS The 2014 Act details that the CCG must appoint an external auditor to audit the annual accounts by 31 December of the preceding year. As the new approach begins in 2017/18,
this means an appointment must be made by 31 December 2016. The appointment can be for longer than a year, but there must be a new appointment process at least once every 5 years. The existing external auditor can be re-appointed for further terms. The external audit firm must be eligible for appointment in line with the requirements of the Financial Reporting Council. Two or more external auditors can be appointed to audit the accounts in such cases, the auditors may act jointly or separately. The Act specifies that all local public bodies covered by the legislation (including CCGs) must have auditor panels to advise on the selection, appointment and removal of external auditors, and on maintaining an independent relationship with them. The only exception to this would be if a body decided to make the appointment via a collective procurement, such as through a sector-led body. There are no current proposals for any such body in the NHS sector. The auditor panel must advise on the selection and appointment of the external auditor, as well as the maintenance of an independent relationship with that auditor. This includes dealing with possible conflicts of interest. The auditor panel will have a role in establishing and monitoring the CCG s policy on the awarding of non-audit services for example, if nonaudit services are awarded to the external audit provider, how will the panel ensure that the auditors independence is maintained? Similarly, if members of the auditor panel are ex-employees of a potential external audit provider being considered for appointment, it is vital that an interest is declared. The member should then exclude him/herself from that decision. The CCG must consult and take account of the auditor panel s advice on the selection and appointment of the external auditor. The advice given by the panel must be published and, should the CCG not follow that advice, the reasons for not doing so must also be published. In order to take a decision, the auditor panel will need to be quorate. For this to be the case independent members must be in the majority AND there must be at least 2 independent members present or 50% of the auditor panel s total membership, whichever is the highest. Since appointments for 2017/18 must be made by the end of 2016, the CCG s auditor panel needs to be in place soon in order that it can fulfil its responsibilities. The CCG s Governing Body should decide how it appoints its auditor panel. The panel must be either: - A specially established panel OR - An existing committee, sub-committee or panel provided it agrees to comply with the provisions applying to auditor panels.
The auditor panel should have its own terms of reference, which are agreed by the Governing Body. Should it be decided that the Audit Committee also forms the auditor panel then the Committee terms of reference would need to be updated to reflect its additional responsibilities. The auditor panel must have at least three members, including a Chair who is an independent non-executive member of the CCG s Governing Body. The majority of the panel s members must also be independent and non-executive members of the Governing Body. The auditor panel is an advisory body only, advising on the selection and appointment of external auditors. Responsibility for the actual procurement and appointment of the auditors remains with the CCG s Governing Body. It is also important to recognise that quite apart from the auditor panel s role normal procurement rules (as set out in the SFIs) must be followed and ultimately, the Governing Body makes the decision about the membership and chair of the panel. Independent, in relation to membership of an auditor panel, means that the member or prospective member is not in circumstances, and does not have relationships, which are likely to affect, or could affect his or her judgement in discharging his or her duties as a member of the panel. The Chair of the auditor panel will be required to provide a report to the Governing Body about the activities and decisions of the panel. If the panel is the Audit Committee, the report must be separate to the minutes of that committee. This makes it clear that the auditor panel is fulfilling a distinctive and important role. It is expected that further guidance on the procurement of external audit services will be provided by the Department of Health in early 2016. 5. PROPOSAL At the Audit Committee meeting on 12 January 2016, the options of either using the existing Audit Committee or a specially established panel were discussed and it was agreed that the recommendation to the Governing Body should be for a specially established audit panel to be set up. In addition it was agreed that West Kent CCG should support a collaborative approach across the Kent and Medway CCGs. It should be noted that if a single auditor panel approach on behalf of two or more organisations is followed, auditor panel members would need to meet the independence criteria for all the organisations involved and be confirmed by each of the organisations Governing Bodies.
6. RECOMMENDATION The Governing Body is asked to note the contents of this report. The Governing Body is asked to accept the recommendation from the Audit Committee that a specially established panel be set up either on behalf of West Kent CCG only or to represent all Kent and Medway CCGs, depending on whether there is sufficient interest from the Kent and Medway CCGs.