Before the Federal Communications Commission Washington, DC PDF Free Download

SUMMARY In its initial comments on the Commission s Public Notices seeking updates and corrections to the list of unserved areas on the National Broadband Map ( NBM ) for Connect America Phase I incremental support, the American Cable Association ( ACA ) filed certifications from its members regarding areas (census blocks) they determined are served but that may not have been accurately described on the NBM. In these reply comments, ACA files additional documentation from its members and responds to the policy proposals set forth by the Commission and in comments of various price cap local exchange carriers ( LECs ) or their trade associations. In its comments, the Independent Telephone & Telecommunications Alliance ( ITTA ) claimed that the process for correcting the NBM set forth in the Public Notices cannot be relied upon to identify where the NBM and its underlying data are inaccurate but may be adequate enough to identify those circumstances where the NBM does not accurately reflect its underlying data. Submissions of ACA members regarding inaccuracies in the NBM were provided with specifically identified areas and certifications. As such, the proposed process will produce reliable results and the Commission should accept these as sufficient to correct the NBM. In addition to its prior submissions, ACA submits herein lists of census blocks that CenturyLink claimed in its comments are unserved, but are in fact served by ACA members. ACA agrees with CenturyLink and Windstream that the NBM should be accurate and that the Commission should establish a formal challenge process to provide an opportunity for parties to update or revise the NBM to ensure its accuracy. However, CenturyLink s proposed process is skewed in favor of incremental support recipients by effectively permitting them to declare the NBM is inaccurate and placing the burden on competitive providers to demonstrate

that their previous submissions were not correct. In contrast, Windstream recognizes that the incremental support recipient must initiate the challenge process by first submitting evidence indicating that the NBM is inaccurate, even though, as discussed below, the evidence it wants to submit falls short of being probative. ACA sets forth below a more equitable approach, which places the initial burden of proof on a provider challenging the NBM, then permits opportunities to rebut the provider s prima facie case, and enables the Commission to establish deadlines to ensure an expeditious resolution which is equitable and transparent. Further, ACA opposes the proposal of CenturyLink and USTelecom that the Commission raise the service area proxy from 4/1 Mbps to 6/1.5 Mbps because such a change would greatly expand the limited purpose of the Phase I incremental support program. ACA submits that a price cap LEC may have more than a sufficient number of lower cost locations shown on the NBM lacking broadband at speeds of 3 Mbps/768 kbps (the proxy for 4/1 Mbps service) for which it could use incremental support. Thus expanding the proxy to 6/1.5 Mbps is not necessary. Further, ACA opposes use of incremental support in partially served census blocks where competitors provide service. The Commission addressed this issue in the Second Reconsideration Order and provided targeted relief to the price cap LECs. Competitive providers are constantly expanding their networks, including to deploy broadband service to unserved locations. Therefore, the Commission should encourage this by withholding the provision of support to locations in areas where competitive providers offer service or even adjacent to these service territories. ii

Finally, ACA agrees with USTelecom that the latency and capacity performance metrics are both important and require clarification. ACA stands ready to work with USTelecom and others to craft appropriate standards. iii

TABLE OF CONTENTS I. THE COMMISSION SHOULD FIND THAT ACA MEMBERS HAVE PROVIDED SUFFICIENT DOCUMENTATION ABOUT INACCURACIES IN THE NATIONAL BROADBAND MAP... 1 II. III. IV. Page THE COMMISSION SHOULD ADOPT A FORMAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION PROCESS WITH EQUITABLE AND REASONABLE BURDENS OF PROOF... 3 ACA OPPOSES RAISING THE SERVICE AREA PROXY FOR 5/1 MBPS TO 6/1.5 MBPS... 7 ACA OPPOSES USE OF INCREMENTAL SUPPORT IN PARTIALLY SERVED CENSUS BLOCKS WHERE COMPETITORS PROVIDE SERVICE... 9 V. ACA SUPPORTS THE COMMISSION PROVIDING CLARITY ON THE SPECIFIC STANDARDS FOR DETERMINING WHETHER THE LATENCY AND CAPACITY OBLIGATIONS ARE MET... 10 VI. CONCLUSION... 11

Before the Federal Communications Commission Washington, DC 20554 In the Matter of Connect America Fund ) ) ) WC Docket No. 10-90 REPLY COMMENTS OF THE AMERICAN CABLE ASSOCIATION ON PUBLIC NOTICES DA 12-1961 AND DA 12-2001, UPDATING AND CORRECTING THE LIST OF UNSERVED AREAS ON THE NATIONAL BROADBAND MAP FOR CONNECT AMERICA PHASE I INCREMENTAL SUPPORT The American Cable Association ( ACA ) respectfully submits these reply comments in response to the Public Notices DA-12-1961 and DA 12-2001 seeking updates and corrections to the list of unserved areas on the National Broadband Map ( NBM ) for Connect America Phase I incremental support. In its initial comments, ACA filed certifications from its members regarding areas (census blocks) they determined are served but which may not have been accurately described on the NBM. 1 In these reply comments, ACA files additional documentation from its members and responds to the policy proposals set forth by the Commission and in comments of various price cap local exchange carriers ( LECs ) or their trade associations. I. THE COMMISSION SHOULD FIND THAT ACA MEMBERS HAVE PROVIDED SUFFICIENT DOCUMENTATION ABOUT INACCURACIES IN THE NATIONAL BROADBAND MAP In the Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking ( FNPRM ) on distribution of Phase I incremental support, the Commission proposed a limited challenge process to address inaccuracies with the NBM. 2 Even though comments on that proposed process are not due until 1 2 See Comments of the American Cable Association, WC Docket No. 10-90 (Jan. 9, 2013). See Connect America Fund, WC Docket No. 10-90, Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, FCC 12-138, 9-12 (rel. Nov. 19, 2012)..

January 28, 2013, the Commission issued Public Notices DA 12-1961 and DA 12-2001, which effectively initiate the proposed challenge process and request submissions about inaccuracies in the NBM. In response, the Independent Telephone & Telecommunications Alliance ( ITTA ) submitted comments objecting to the Public Notice process as providing a woefully inadequate time period to respond and submitted that the process is arbitrary and imprudent in light of the fact that the comments on the challenge process are not to be filed until weeks after the deadline for submitting evidence about inaccuracies with the NBM. 3 ITTA then claims the process cannot be relied upon to identify where the NBM and its underlying data are inaccurate but may be adequate enough to identify those circumstances where the NBM does not accurately reflect its underlying data. 4 As noted above, ACA submitted on behalf of its members evidence about inaccuracies in the NBM. It agrees with ITTA s comment that parties could have used additional time to provide evidence about areas incorrectly identified on the NBM. However, it disagrees with ITTA s comment that the Commission s review process is only reliable for identifying discrepancies between the NBM and its underlying data. Submissions of ACA members regarding inaccuracies in the NBM were provided with specifically identified areas and certifications. As such, the proposed process will produce reliable results. The Commission should accept these as sufficient to correct the NBM. In its comments, CenturyLink provides a list of census blocks that it believes the NBM 3 4 Comments of the Independent Telephone & Telecommunications Alliance, WC Docket No. 10-90 at 2 (Jan. 9, 2013). ( ITTA Comments ) Id. at 3. 2

misidentified as served. 5 Included with these comments are certifications from ACA members Atlantic Telephone Membership Corporation (Exhibit A); Armstrong Utilities Inc. (Exhibit B); Massillon Cable TV, Inc. (Exhibit C); H&B Cable Service, Inc. (Exhibit D); Cable One, Inc. (Exhibit E); and Nittany Media, Inc. (Exhibit F) that they serve the identified census blocks listed by CenturyLink with the required broadband speeds. II. THE COMMISSION SHOULD ADOPT A FORMAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION PROCESS WITH EQUITABLE AND REASONABLE BURDENS OF PROOF The Commission s proposed challenge process involves publication of a list of census blocks shown on the NBM as eligible for support and a request for comment on whether areas are overstated as served or understated as unserved. The Commission will then evaluate the evidence submitted and where it is more probable than not that the National Broadband Map inaccurately portrays coverage, it will correct the NBM for that particular area. ACA was preparing to submit comments on the Commission s proposed challenge process during the relevant comment period of the FNPRM (by January 28, 2013). However, various parties submitted comments on the challenge process in response to the Public Notices on identifying inaccuracies in the NBM. Consequently, ACA responds herein to their comments, as well as the Commission s proposal. In its comments, CenturyLink claims that the NBM, which the Commission uses to establish eligible areas for Phase I incremental support, is inaccurate, particularly in depicting areas as being served. 6 It therefore proposes that the Commission establish an alternative formal challenge process that would apply only to locations in which Incremental Support 5 6 See Comments of CenturyLink on Areas Shown as Unserved on the National Broadband Map For Connect America Phase I Incremental Support, WC Docket No. 10-90 at Appendix B (Jan. 9, 2013) ( CenturyLink Comments ). See CenturyLink Comments at 4. 3

recipients seek to deploy broadband using funding. 7 Further, it proposes to place the burden of proof in the process on service providers claiming coverage, not on those challenging the claim, as the service provider claiming coverage is the only entity with reasonable access to the network information necessary to support such a claim. 8 Windstream, in its comments, also supports a challenge process but proposes a different scheme. It submits that there is evidence that an area is unserved by competitive providers where it has received no requests in the past two years from customers for telephone number ports that are accompanied by cancellation of the customer s Windstream broadband service. 9 It proposes that if an incremental support recipient certifies that this condition exists, it should create a presumption that the area is eligible for CAF Phase I support, and a competitive provider would have the burden of submitting evidence that it is providing broadband service in the relevant area. 10 ACA agrees with CenturyLink and Windstream that the NBM should be accurate and that the Commission should establish a formal challenge process to provide an opportunity for parties to update or revise the NBM to ensure its accuracy. However, CenturyLink s proposed process is skewed in favor of incremental support recipients by effectively permitting them to declare the NBM is inaccurate and placing the burden on competitive providers to demonstrate that their previous submissions are not correct. In contrast, Windstream recognizes that the incremental support recipient must initiate the challenge process by first submitting evidence 7 8 9 10 Id. Id., at 5. ITTA also proposes placing the burden on the competitive provider. See ITTA Comments at 4. Comments of Windstream Corporation, WC Docket No. 10-90 at 8 (Jan. 9, 2013). Windstream proposes that the competitive provider s evidence should include printouts of billing information for customers within the area or engineering analyses, with accompanying officer certification as to the veracity of the material provided. Id. at 8-9. 4

indicating that the NBM is inaccurate, even though, as discussed below, the evidence it wants to submit falls short of being probative. Last year, ACA and the National Cable & Telecommunications Association ( NCTA ) proposed the following challenge process to the Commission, which places equal burdens of proof on a provider challenging the NBM, then permits opportunities to rebut the provider s prima facie case, and enables the Commission to establish deadlines to ensure an expeditious resolution which is equitable and transparent. 11 With specific respect to challenges by incremental support recipients, ACA outlined this process. Begin with the presumption that the NBM is correct. 12 The incremental support recipient seeking to rebut that presumption should identify the portion of the census block it believes is unserved and provide evidence for that assertion. If the Commission determines that the evidence is sufficient to make a prima facie case that the NBM is inaccurate, competitive providers would then have an opportunity to rebut the incremental support recipient s showing or the findings of the NBM. 13 As mentioned above, ACA suggested following a similar process should a competitive provider challenge the accuracy of a census block on the NBM as served rather than unserved. The ACA/NCTA proposed process thus differs from that proposed by the Commission in a key respect. ACA submits that its process is more equitable than the Commission s in that a provider whose service area on the NBM is being challenged would not be required to respond 11 12 13 See Ex Parte Letter of American Cable Association and National Cable & Telecommunications Association, WC Docket Nos. 10-90 et al. (Mar. 29, 2012). This presumption is consistent with the position adopted by the Commission last year in its Second Reconsideration Order. See Connect America Fund et al., WC Docket No. 10-90 et al., Second Order on Reconsideration, 27 FCC Rcd 4648, 13 (Apr. 25, 2012) ( Second Reconsideration Order ). The process proposed by ACA/NCTA is essentially identical to that used by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration in awarding Broadband Technology Opportunities Program funding. Therefore, it is familiar, tested, and relatively straightforward to implement. 5

unless the Commission first determined that the party challenging the designation submitted sufficient evidence. This is especially important for smaller competitive providers that have limited resources to participate in proceedings. The ACA/NCTA process presumes that the state entities or non-profit organizations working at their direction that semiannually collect data on the availability, speed, and location of broadband services have a process in place that ensures the accuracy of the data they provide for the NBM. 14 Also, by presuming the NBM is accurate, the ACA/NCTA process encourages providers to participate in the regular data collection process for the NBM knowing they will not have to submit additional documentation if there is no valid challenge. ACA thus urges the Commission to modify the challenge process proposed in the FNPRM so that it conforms with the ACA/NCTA proposed process. 15 As for the question of whether Windstream s proposed evidence that an incremental support recipient has not received any customer requests to simultaneously port numbers and cancel broadband service is sufficient to require a response by a competitive provider, ACA submits that this evidence is insufficient to make a prima facie case. 16 As the Commission noted 14 15 16 See e.g., Comments of Connected Nation, Inc. on CenturyLink s Petition for Waiver, WC Docket No. 10-90 et al (July 12, 2012), in which Connected Nation discusses the requirement of the National Telecommunications and Information Administration that all State Broadband Initiative grantees verify data through a secondary source and its own process for verifying data in the states where it is the mapping grantee or contractor. ACA recognizes that the Commission has already sought submission of challenges to the NBM, and it does not believe challengers should need to re-file. Further, it is reasonable to have these particular challenges heard pursuant to the Commission s proposed regime. At the same time, ACA urges the Commission to adopt ACA/NCTA s proposed process and apply it going forward. For many reasons, Windstream s evidence is not probative. First, it excludes circumstances in which a customer of an incremental support recipient may cancel their broadband service and port their phone line, but not take both actions at the same time. Second, the evidence would not take account of instances where a customer may simultaneously cancel their broadband service and their phone line, but choose not to port their number to their new provider. Third, it does not cover the situation in which a customer only cancels their broadband service (and maintains their phone service) because their new broadband service provider does not offer phone service. It is common for Wireless Internet Service Providers ( WISPs ) to not offer phone service. Finally, 6

in the Second Reconsideration Order, a provider may have no customers in a particular census block, even though it offers service there. 17 ACA thus believes a price cap LEC should submit additional evidence demonstrating at a minimum that a provider in the relevant area is not advertising or otherwise publicizing that it offers the requisite broadband service and is not accepting orders for service or has no facilities capable of providing service in the particular area. III. ACA OPPOSES RAISING THE SERVICE AREA PROXY FOR 5/1 MBPS TO 6/1.5 MBPS CenturyLink and the United States Telecom Association ( USTelecom ) argue that areas with broadband service of 3 Mbps/768 kbps on the NBM are not adequate to demonstrate that a provider offers 4/1 Mbps broadband service in an area. 18 Rather, they propose that the Commission use 6/1.5 Mbps as the proxy for purposes of determining areas eligible for Phase I incremental support. In addition, to limit use of support consistent with the Commission s 4/1 Mbps public interest obligation, they would require that a price cap LEC certify that it is not using Phase I incremental support to deploy to locations that are not currently engineered to meet the 4/1 Mbps standard. They base their proposal on the fact that for broadband providers like the price cap LECs, which use DSL technology, significant additional construction is required to 17 18 under existing rules, for an incremental support recipient to deploy broadband under the Phase I program to a particular location, the provider must either be offering no broadband service or broadband service at speeds no greater than 768/200 kbps. Accordingly, the carrier would either have no broadband customers, or likely very few customers if a competing provider was offering broadband service at higher speeds. Therefore, evidence that an incremental support recipient did not have any customers simultaneously cancel their broadband service and port their number may speak more to the low adoption rate of the incremental support recipients broadband service in the area than to the presence of a competitor offering higher speed broadband. Second Reconsideration Order, 13. See CenturyLink Comments at 9-10 and Comments of the United States Telecom Association, WC Docket No. 10-90 at 3-6 (Jan. 9, 2013). 7

move from providing upstream speeds of 768 kbps to 1 Mbps. By accepting this proposal, the Commission would significantly increase the number of locations eligible to be served using Phase I incremental support. ACA opposes the proposal of CenturyLink and USTelecom because it would greatly expand the limited purpose of the Phase I incremental support program an interim program designed to provide an immediate boost to broadband deployment to those areas most in need of the service, that is, without broadband service with speeds of 768/200 kbps. 19 Whether the Commission should even expand the eligible areas to include those without 4/1 Mbps service is an issue raised in the FNPRM. 20 ACA notes that neither CenturyLink nor USTelecom provide in their comments evidence of the need to expand the number of additional locations that could be served with the limited incremental support funding beyond those already part of the pool of eligible locations those without 768/200 kbps service. 21 ACA submits that a price cap LEC may have more than a sufficient number of lower cost locations shown on the NBM lacking broadband at speeds of 3 Mbps/768 kbps (the proxy for 4/1 Mbps service) for which it could use incremental support and thus expanding the proxy to 6/1.5 Mbps is not necessary. ACA will discuss this further in the comments it will file on the FNPRM on January 28, 2013. In addition, even if the Commission determines to increase the eligible areas to those without 4/1 Mbps broadband, it is not necessary to expand further. CenturyLink and USTelecom s comments are directed to the technical limitations of DSL networks. Cable 19 20 21 See e.g., Second Reconsideration Order, 20. See FNPRM, 10-12. CenturyLink and USTelecom also do not provide data on the number of additional locations that would become eligible if the Commission increased the speed threshold to 3 Mbps/768 kbps or to 6/1.5 Mbps. Such evidence would be useful to determine whether an expansion of areas is necessary for the Phase I program and would be consistent with the program s purpose. 8

networks, however, operate based on a different technology and do not have the same restrictions on upstream speeds as DSL networks. Thus, if a cable provider is portrayed on the NBM as having 3 Mbps/768 kbps broadband service, it should not be assumed that it is not providing 4/1 Mbps service. This means the effect of increasing the proxy to 6/1.5 Mbps would be to designate census blocks where cable operators provide service of 4/1 Mbps as unserved when in fact they are served. Further, the additional requirement proposed by CenturyLink and USTelecom that the price cap LEC certify that the location does not receive 4/1 Mbps broadband has a number of flaws. It does not provide competitive providers with an ability to rebut the designation, and, even if it did, it places an added burden on competitive providers to contest them. In addition, it places an added burden on the Commission to examine designations and monitor builds. It also permits price cap LECs to use incremental support to build in areas where a competitive provider may offer service to most locations and could readily expand service. Finally, the Commission has acknowledged the need for the program to adopt additional measures to ensure greater accountability. 22 However, the proposal by CenturyLink and USTelecom would create greater uncertainty and require the adoption of additional measures to ensure accountability, including verification that funds were spent properly. For all of these reasons, the Commission should reject the proposal by CenturyLink and USTelecom. IV. ACA OPPOSES USE OF INCREMENTAL SUPPORT IN PARTIALLY SERVED CENSUS BLOCKS WHERE COMPETITORS PROVIDE SERVICE CenturyLink proposes that price cap LECs be able to use incremental support to provide service to unserved locations in partially served census blocks. 23 The Commission addressed this 22 23 See FNPRM, 47. See CenturyLink Comments at 5. 9

issue in the Second Reconsideration Order and provided targeted relief to the price cap LECs by permitting them to use incremental support to build to an unserved location in a census block indicated on the NBM as served if the data underlying the Map show that a location is not served by a particular provider. 24 ACA strongly opposes any change to the Commission s current rule. Competitive providers are constantly expanding their networks, including to deploy broadband service to unserved locations. In fact, this dynamic has accelerated as wireless companies increase their cell sites and require them to be served by fiber. For instance, Mediacom has informed the Commission that these fiber builds enable them to serve locations in low density areas proximate to wireless towers with much higher speed broadband service. 25 The Commission should encourage this activity, including by withholding the provision of support to locations in areas where competitive providers offer service or even adjacent to these service territories. Providing such support will create a strong disincentive to private sector expansion. Moreover, it is a waste of scarce universal service resources. V. ACA SUPPORTS THE COMMISSION PROVIDING CLARITY ON THE SPECIFIC STANDARDS FOR DETERMINING WHETHER THE LATENCY AND CAPACITY OBLIGATIONS ARE MET USTelecom requests that the Commission address the lack of clarity about the latency and capacity performance metrics, which are part of the public interest obligations adopted in the Connect America Fund Order and therefore a part of the determination of whether an area is served or unserved. 26 ACA agrees that these performance metrics are both important and require clarification. It stands ready to work with USTelecom and others to craft appropriate standards. 24 25 26 Second Reconsideration Order, 11. See Ex Parte Presentation of Mediacom: Driving Broadband Network Investment and Deployment in Rural America, WC Docket Nos. 10-90, 05-337 (June 13, 2012). See USTelecom Comments at 9-10. 10

VI. CONCLUSION In its initial comments on the Commission s Public Notices seeking updates and corrections to the list of unserved areas on the NBM for Connect America Phase I incremental support, ACA submitted on behalf of its members evidence about inaccuracies in the NBM. Submissions of ACA members regarding inaccuracies in the NBM were provided with specifically identified areas and certifications. As such, the proposed process will produce reliable results and the Commission should accept these as sufficient to correct the NBM. Further, ACA submits herein lists of census blocks that CenturyLink claimed in its comments are unserved, but are in fact served by ACA members. In addition, any changes to the Commission s rules for distribution of incremental support should be consistent with the principles set forth herein. Respectfully submitted, Matthew M. Polka President and Chief Executive Officer American Cable Association One Parkway Center Suite 212 Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15220 (412) 922-8300 Ross J. Lieberman Vice President of Government Affairs American Cable Association 2415 39th Place, NW Washington, DC 20007 (202) 494-5661 Thomas Cohen Joshua Guyan Kelley Drye & Warren LLP 3050 K Street, NW Suite 400 Washington, DC 20007 Tel. (202) 342-8518 Fax (202) 342-8451 tcohen@kelleydrye.com Counsel to the American Cable Association January 24, 2013 11

EXHIBIT A

Highlighted census blocks and descriptions were shown on the Exhibit submitted by CenturyLink. Upon comparison to our serving areas, the highlighted census blocks are either fully served or partially served by ATMC in Columbus County, NC. 1/21/2013 WSD ATMC Engineering 370479313001017 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479310002046 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001039 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004004 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479312006021 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004006 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003006 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001027 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001023 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001032 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004060 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003008 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004021 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003019 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004061 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479310003068 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479310002045 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479310003064 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313002141 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001007 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479312006019 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004033 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004001 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004028 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004023 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED

370479313004035 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004034 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004042 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001049 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003018 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003024 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004062 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004063 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004022 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479310002045 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004055 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004053 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003021 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003027 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479310002026 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479311002008 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479311003011 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001012 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001011 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313002131 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313002132 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001029 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479310002040 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003026 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004012 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004011 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004014 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003010 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003037 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003011 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED

370479310002021 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313002116 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479310003071 CTL ONLY SERVED 370479311002017 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001008 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004025 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004031 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004000 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004003 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003013 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003020 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001000 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479311002000 CTL ONLY SERVED 370479313002142 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313001044 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004051 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003029 PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003012 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313004032 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003004 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479313003002 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED 370479310002044 BOTH PARTIALLY SERVED

EXHIBIT B

A B C D E 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 Census Blocks Served by Armstrong Utilites in CenturyLink Territories that Conflict with CenturyLink's Analysis State County Tract Block 39 139 002000 3095 AUI 39 139 002000 5036 AUI 39 139 002000 4016 AUI 39 139 002700 5073 AUI 39 139 002000 5000 AUI 39 139 002000 5002 AUI 39 139 002000 5052 AUI 39 139 002700 4049 AUI 39 139 002700 5089 AUI 39 139 002000 5048 AUI 39 139 002700 4034 AUI 39 139 002000 5029 AUI 39 139 002700 3035 AUI 39 139 002000 5020 AUI 39 139 002000 3044 AUI 39 139 002700 5045 AUI 39 139 002000 2029 AUI 39 169 002000 2064 AUI 39 169 002000 1106 AUI 39 169 002000 1128 AUI 39 139 002700 5065 AUI 39 139 002000 4077 AUI 39 139 002700 5049 AUI 39 139 002000 3152 AUI 39 139 002000 1062 AUI 39 139 002700 5072 AUI 39 139 002000 5060 AUI 39 139 002700 5039 AUI 39 139 002000 3047 AUI 39 139 002700 5077 AUI 39 139 002000 3046 AUI 39 139 002000 1004 AUI 39 139 002000 1002 AUI 39 139 002000 1001 AUI 39 169 001800 3085 AUI 39 169 001800 3092 AUI 42 055 010400 4022 AUI

42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 A B C D E 42 055 010400 2123 AUI 42 055 010400 4013 AUI 42 055 010400 2074 AUI 42 055 010400 1050 AUI 42 055 010400 4014 AUI 42 055 010400 1010 AUI 42 055 010400 1059 AUI 42 055 010400 4055 AUI 39 043 040300 2020 AUI 39 043 040300 2002 AUI 39 051 040300 2056 AUI 39 051 040300 2062 AUI 39 099 812800 4005 AUI 39 169 002100 2007 AUI 39 043 040300 2069 AUI 42 001 030600 2022 AUI 42 001 030600 2007 AUI 42 001 030600 2012 AUI 42 001 030600 2066 AUI 42 001 030600 2065 AUI 42 001 030600 2078 AUI 42 055 010600 3058 AUI 42 001 030600 2079 AUI 42 055 010600 2045 AUI 42 055 011000 3018 AUI 42 061 951200 5029 AUI 42 061 951200 5045 AUI 42 061 951200 4019 AUI 42 061 951200 5064 AUI 42 061 951200 1121 AUI 42 061 951200 4030 AUI 42 061 951200 4038 AUI 42 061 951200 1112 AUI 42 061 951200 4005 AUI 42 061 951200 3027 AUI 42 061 951200 5025 AUI 42 061 951200 3012 AUI 42 061 951200 5011 AUI 42 061 951200 1081 AUI 42 061 951200 2038 AUI 42 061 951200 4075 AUI 42 061 951200 1068 AUI 42 061 951200 3044 AUI 42 061 951200 1016 AUI 42 061 951200 1013 AUI 42 061 951200 1061 AUI

88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 A B C D E 42 061 951200 4033 AUI 42 061 951200 4065 AUI 42 061 951200 5049 AUI 42 061 951200 1113 AUI 42 061 951200 4045 AUI 42 061 951200 4078 AUI 42 061 951200 2008 AUI 42 061 951200 4048 AUI 42 061 951200 4046 AUI 42 061 951200 4018 AUI 42 061 951200 1067 AUI 42 061 951200 2001 AUI 42 061 951200 3028 AUI 42 061 951200 2016 AUI 42 061 951200 4014 AUI 42 061 951200 2002 AUI 42 061 951200 1044 AUI 42 061 951200 2058 AUI 42 061 951200 1108 AUI 42 061 951200 4025 AUI 42 061 951200 2019 AUI 42 061 951200 4058 AUI 42 061 951200 4052 AUI 42 061 951200 4080 AUI 42 061 951200 3045 AUI 42 061 951200 4056 AUI 42 061 951200 1126 AUI 42 061 951200 2040 AUI 42 061 951200 3043 AUI 42 061 951200 5063 AUI 42 061 951200 1045 AUI 42 061 951200 3018 AUI 42 071 011000 2044 AUI 42 071 011000 2032 AUI 42 071 011000 1055 AUI 42 071 011000 1030 AUI 42 061 951200 2028 AUI 42 061 951200 2023 AUI 42 061 951200 2037 AUI 42 061 951200 5047 AUI 42 061 951200 2010 AUI 42 061 951200 1085 AUI 42 061 951200 2045 AUI 42 061 951200 3030 AUI 42 061 951200 2063 AUI 42 061 951200 1036 AUI

134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 A B C D E 42 061 951200 2000 AUI 42 061 951200 2014 AUI 42 061 951200 1124 AUI 42 061 951200 2005 AUI 42 061 951200 5019 AUI 42 061 951200 3059 AUI 42 061 951200 2039 AUI 42 061 951200 2068 AUI 42 061 951200 3021 AUI 42 061 951200 3032 AUI 42 061 951200 2012 AUI 42 061 951200 2013 AUI 42 061 951200 2047 AUI 42 061 951200 2021 AUI 42 061 951200 2025 AUI 42 061 951200 2027 AUI 42 061 951200 2046 AUI 42 061 951200 3025 AUI 42 061 951200 2034 AUI 42 061 951200 2006 AUI 42 061 951200 2060 AUI 42 061 951200 2055 AUI 42 061 951200 2031 AUI 42 061 951200 2065 AUI 42 061 951200 1123 AUI 42 061 951200 1047 AUI 42 061 951200 1062 AUI 42 061 951200 2062 AUI 42 061 951200 3024 AUI 42 061 951200 2009 AUI 42 061 951200 5048 AUI 42 005 950400 1008 AUI 42 005 950400 1006 AUI 42 005 950400 1025 AUI 42 005 950400 1010 AUI 39 021 010100 2026 AUI 39 021 010100 2001 AUI 39 021 010100 2006 AUI 39 139 002900 2109 AUI 39 139 002900 2092 AUI 39 139 002900 2136 AUI 39 139 002900 3002 AUI 39 139 002900 3029 AUI 39 165 031200 1012 AUI 39 165 031200 1002 AUI 39 139 002900 3008 AUI

180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 A B C D E 42 001 030800 2037 AUI 42 013 011300 3061 AUI 42 013 011300 3065 AUI 42 013 011300 5012 AUI 42 013 011300 5033 AUI 42 013 011300 3085 AUI 42 013 011300 5071 AUI 42 013 011300 4001 AUI 42 013 011300 5014 AUI 42 013 011300 5041 AUI 42 013 011300 5077 AUI 42 013 011300 5002 AUI 42 013 011300 5011 AUI 42 013 011300 4002 AUI 42 013 011300 4003 AUI 42 013 011300 3017 AUI 42 013 011300 3050 AUI 42 013 011300 5080 AUI 42 027 010100 1035 AUI 42 027 010100 3007 AUI 42 027 010100 3014 AUI 42 027 010100 3023 AUI 42 027 010100 4005 AUI 42 027 010100 1046 AUI 42 027 010100 1026 AUI 42 027 010100 1047 AUI 42 027 010100 4031 AUI 42 027 010100 1054 AUI 42 027 010100 1063 AUI 42 027 010100 3004 AUI 42 027 010100 1133 AUI 42 027 010100 1145 AUI 42 027 010100 3019 AUI 42 027 010100 1121 AUI 42 027 010100 1140 AUI 42 027 010100 4023 AUI 42 027 010100 2033 AUI 42 055 010100 1037 AUI 42 055 010100 2033 AUI 42 055 010100 1020 AUI 42 055 010100 1030 AUI 42 055 010100 3036 AUI 42 055 010100 3046 AUI 42 055 010100 3154 AUI 42 055 010100 1033 AUI 42 055 010100 3129 AUI

226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 A B C D E 42 055 010100 1044 AUI 42 055 010100 1061 AUI 42 055 010100 2036 AUI 42 055 010100 3044 AUI 42 055 010100 1049 AUI 42 055 010100 2087 AUI 42 055 010100 1023 AUI 42 055 010100 3184 AUI 42 055 010100 3147 AUI 42 055 010100 3013 AUI 42 055 010100 3026 AUI 42 055 010100 3011 AUI 42 055 010100 3174 AUI 42 055 010100 1072 AUI 42 055 010100 3002 AUI 42 055 010100 2034 AUI 42 013 011300 5069 AUI 42 013 011300 5009 AUI 42 027 010100 1126 AUI 42 027 010100 3012 AUI 42 027 010100 1042 AUI 42 027 010100 1050 AUI 42 027 010100 1025 AUI 42 027 010100 3020 AUI 42 027 010100 3008 AUI 42 027 010100 1142 AUI 42 027 010100 1051 AUI 42 027 010100 3009 AUI 42 027 010100 1127 AUI 42 055 010100 1059 AUI 42 055 010100 1028 AUI 42 055 010100 3030 AUI 42 055 010100 3150 AUI 42 055 010100 1071 AUI 42 055 010100 1056 AUI 42 055 010100 1025 AUI 42 055 010100 3027 AUI 42 055 010100 2003 AUI 42 055 010100 1047 AUI 42 055 010100 3176 AUI 42 055 010100 3136 AUI 42 055 010100 3097 AUI 42 055 010100 3021 AUI 42 071 011300 1010 AUI 42 055 010100 1057 AUI 42 031 160500 1133 AUI

272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 A B C D E 42 031 160500 1136 AUI 42 031 160500 4022 AUI 42 031 160500 1128 AUI 42 031 160500 4027 AUI 39 117 965100 1008 AUI 39 117 965000 3074 AUI 39 117 965000 3095 AUI 39 117 965100 1047 AUI 39 117 965000 3122 AUI 39 117 965100 1043 AUI 39 117 965100 1060 AUI 39 117 965000 3103 AUI 39 117 965100 1030 AUI 39 117 965100 1007 AUI 39 117 965000 3097 AUI 39 117 965000 2029 AUI 39 117 965100 1016 AUI 39 117 965100 1023 AUI 39 117 965100 1057 AUI 39 117 965100 3029 AUI 42 001 030900 2003 AUI 42 001 030900 1026 AUI 42 001 030900 2020 AUI 39 169 002500 1045 AUI 39 169 003100 2005 AUI 39 169 002500 1025 AUI 39 169 002500 1050 AUI 39 169 002500 1036 AUI 42 019 910600 1006 AUI 42 019 910600 1007 AUI 42 043 024001 4017 AUI 42 043 024001 4020 AUI 42 043 024002 1064 AUI 42 043 024002 1079 AUI 42 043 024001 4001 AUI 42 043 024002 1053 AUI 42 043 024002 1065 AUI 42 043 024002 1057 AUI 42 121 201500 4043 AUI 42 121 201500 4057 AUI 42 121 201500 4066 AUI 42 121 201500 2086 AUI 42 121 201500 4020 AUI 42 121 201500 2068 AUI 42 121 201500 2061 AUI 42 121 201500 4067 AUI

318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 A B C D E 42 121 201500 4054 AUI 42 121 201500 4075 AUI 39 003 010300 2023 AUI 39 003 011400 1044 AUI 39 003 011400 1050 AUI 39 003 011400 1003 AUI 39 003 011400 1000 AUI 39 003 010300 2068 AUI 39 007 001301 3034 AUI 39 007 001301 4016 AUI 39 007 001301 4023 AUI 39 007 001301 4002 AUI 39 007 001301 4004 AUI 39 007 001400 3019 AUI 39 007 001301 4018 AUI 39 007 001301 4011 AUI 39 007 001301 1001 AUI 39 007 001302 1061 AUI 39 007 001302 1030 AUI 39 007 001400 3010 AUI 39 007 001400 3006 AUI 39 007 001400 3015 AUI 39 007 001400 3038 AUI 39 007 001400 3037 AUI 39 007 001400 3034 AUI 39 007 001301 2100 AUI 39 007 001301 2101 AUI 39 007 001301 2095 AUI 39 007 001301 4013 AUI 39 007 001302 1109 AUI 39 007 001302 1041 AUI 39 007 001302 1056 AUI 39 007 001302 1049 AUI 39 007 001302 1060 AUI 39 007 001302 1031 AUI 39 007 001400 3041 AUI 39 007 001302 1072 AUI 39 007 001400 3016 AUI 39 007 001400 3089 AUI 39 007 001301 4020 AUI 39 007 001301 1002 AUI 39 007 001301 2093 AUI 39 007 001301 4009 AUI 39 007 001301 2105 AUI 39 007 001302 1066 AUI 39 007 001302 1044 AUI

364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 A B C D E 39 007 001302 1050 AUI 39 007 001302 1106 AUI 39 007 001302 1079 AUI 39 007 001302 1062 AUI 39 007 001400 3004 AUI 39 007 001400 3011 AUI 39 007 001400 3013 AUI 39 007 001400 3022 AUI 39 007 001301 1004 AUI 39 007 001301 4027 AUI 39 063 001300 4092 AUI 39 063 001300 4040 AUI 39 063 001300 4056 AUI 39 063 001300 4083 AUI 39 063 001300 4041 AUI 39 099 813300 3046 AUI 39 099 813300 3029 AUI 39 099 813300 3012 AUI 39 099 812900 1025 AUI 39 099 813300 3037 AUI 39 139 001000 3045 AUI 39 149 971400 1010 AUI 39 149 971400 1013 AUI 39 149 971400 1032 AUI 39 149 971400 2044 AUI 39 149 971400 1016 AUI 39 149 971400 2010 AUI 39 149 971400 1018 AUI 39 149 971400 2017 AUI 39 149 971400 1017 AUI 39 149 971400 2046 AUI 39 161 020400 1074 AUI 39 161 020400 1004 AUI 39 165 031100 2051 AUI 39 165 031100 2025 AUI 39 165 031100 2030 AUI 39 165 031100 2024 AUI 39 165 031100 2053 AUI 39 165 031100 2031 AUI 39 165 031100 2033 AUI 39 099 813300 3038 AUI 39 099 813300 3045 AUI 39 139 001200 2068 AUI 39 139 001200 2021 AUI 39 139 001200 2071 AUI 39 165 031100 1082 AUI

410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444 445 446 447 448 449 450 451 452 453 454 455 A B C D E 39 165 031100 1104 AUI 39 165 031100 1068 AUI 39 165 031100 1080 AUI 39 165 031100 1083 AUI 39 165 031100 1112 AUI 39 165 031100 1060 AUI 39 165 031100 1066 AUI 39 165 031100 1076 AUI 39 165 031100 1074 AUI 39 165 031100 1145 AUI 39 165 031100 1111 AUI 39 165 031100 1070 AUI 39 165 031100 1081 AUI 39 165 031100 1072 AUI 39 165 031100 1067 AUI 39 169 003300 1018 AUI 39 169 003200 1069 AUI 39 169 001400 2040 AUI 39 169 000900 2003 AUI 39 169 003300 2052 AUI 39 169 000900 2004 AUI 42 001 031300 1036 AUI 42 001 031300 2040 AUI 42 001 031201 1043 AUI 42 001 031300 2030 AUI 42 001 031300 2042 AUI 42 001 031300 2051 AUI 42 001 031201 1041 AUI 42 001 031201 1056 AUI 42 001 031201 1064 AUI 42 001 031300 1042 AUI 42 001 031201 1062 AUI 42 001 031300 1035 AUI 42 001 031201 1102 AUI 42 001 031201 1079 AUI 42 001 031300 2026 AUI 42 005 950300 2010 AUI 42 005 950300 1035 AUI 42 005 950300 2052 AUI 42 005 950300 2000 AUI 42 005 950300 2040 AUI 42 005 950300 2048 AUI 42 005 950300 1024 AUI 42 005 950300 1033 AUI 42 005 950300 2017 AUI 42 005 950300 2024 AUI

456 457 458 459 460 461 462 463 464 465 466 467 468 469 470 471 472 473 474 475 476 477 478 479 480 481 482 483 484 485 486 487 488 489 490 491 492 493 494 495 496 497 498 499 500 501 A B C D E 42 005 950300 2058 AUI 42 005 950300 1021 AUI 42 005 950300 1087 AUI 42 005 950300 1032 AUI 42 005 950300 2057 AUI 42 005 950300 1030 AUI 42 013 011400 1024 AUI 42 019 910302 2030 AUI 42 019 910200 3078 AUI 42 019 910200 1068 AUI 42 019 910100 2042 AUI 42 019 910302 3086 AUI 42 019 910100 1073 AUI 42 019 910302 3016 AUI 42 019 910302 2076 AUI 42 019 910200 3063 AUI 42 019 910200 3031 AUI 42 019 910200 2073 AUI 42 019 910302 2036 AUI 42 019 910302 3052 AUI 42 019 910302 2103 AUI 42 019 910302 2082 AUI 42 019 910302 3049 AUI 42 019 910200 1008 AUI 42 019 910100 1022 AUI 42 019 910100 2062 AUI 42 019 910302 3054 AUI 42 019 910100 1005 AUI 42 019 910302 3073 AUI 42 019 911800 2011 AUI 42 019 911800 1025 AUI 42 019 910302 3036 AUI 42 019 910200 1006 AUI 42 019 910100 1038 AUI 42 019 910302 2096 AUI 42 041 012100 1019 AUI 42 055 011400 5034 AUI 42 055 011400 4024 AUI 42 055 011400 1065 AUI 42 055 010300 2029 AUI 42 055 010300 4043 AUI 42 055 010300 4052 AUI 42 055 010300 5015 AUI 42 055 012100 2005 AUI 42 055 010300 1039 AUI 42 055 011400 5004 AUI

502 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 511 512 513 514 515 516 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 525 526 527 528 529 530 531 532 533 534 535 536 537 538 539 540 541 542 543 544 545 546 547 A B C D E 42 055 011400 5017 AUI 42 055 011400 1049 AUI 42 055 010300 1067 AUI 42 055 011400 5021 AUI 42 055 011400 2009 AUI 42 055 010300 4053 AUI 42 055 011400 4020 AUI 42 055 011400 4032 AUI 42 055 012100 2012 AUI 42 055 010300 1049 AUI 42 055 010500 2046 AUI 42 055 012100 1048 AUI 42 055 010500 1082 AUI 42 055 011400 1050 AUI 42 055 012100 1039 AUI 42 001 031201 1075 AUI 42 005 950300 1096 AUI 42 005 950300 1027 AUI 42 005 950300 2054 AUI 42 019 910302 3017 AUI 42 019 910302 2033 AUI 42 019 910302 2071 AUI 42 019 910302 3030 AUI 42 019 910302 3020 AUI 42 019 910302 3051 AUI 42 019 910302 2075 AUI 42 019 910301 1014 AUI 42 055 010300 1038 AUI 42 055 010300 1046 AUI 42 055 010300 1054 AUI 42 055 010300 1021 AUI 42 055 012100 2006 AUI 42 055 010300 1052 AUI 42 055 010300 1053 AUI 42 055 010300 1045 AUI 42 055 011400 5025 AUI 42 055 012100 2024 AUI 42 055 011400 1058 AUI 42 055 011400 5020 AUI 42 055 011400 5023 AUI 42 055 012100 2000 AUI 42 055 010300 5036 AUI 42 055 010500 1064 AUI 42 055 010300 4054 AUI 42 055 012100 1021 AUI 42 055 010300 1026 AUI

548 549 550 551 552 553 554 555 556 557 558 559 560 561 562 563 564 565 566 567 568 569 570 571 572 573 574 575 576 577 578 579 580 581 582 583 584 585 586 587 588 589 590 591 592 593 A B C D E 42 055 010300 1058 AUI 42 055 010300 4041 AUI 42 055 010500 1007 AUI 42 055 010500 2049 AUI 42 055 012100 1033 AUI 42 055 010500 2093 AUI 42 055 010300 4031 AUI 42 055 012100 2011 AUI 42 071 011400 2050 AUI 42 071 011400 2000 AUI 42 085 033100 2044 AUI 42 085 033100 3059 AUI 42 085 032601 6056 AUI 42 085 032800 4080 AUI 42 085 033100 1070 AUI 42 085 032601 6058 AUI 42 085 032800 4036 AUI 42 085 032601 6061 AUI 42 085 033100 3060 AUI 42 085 033100 3057 AUI 42 085 032601 6064 AUI 42 085 032601 6066 AUI 42 085 032601 6046 AUI 42 085 033100 2052 AUI 42 085 033100 1089 AUI 42 085 032601 6035 AUI 42 085 032601 6076 AUI 42 085 033100 3058 AUI 42 085 032601 6065 AUI 42 099 030601 1044 AUI 42 099 030601 2072 AUI 42 099 030601 2027 AUI 42 099 030601 2094 AUI 42 099 030601 1021 AUI 42 099 030601 3006 AUI 42 099 030601 2104 AUI 42 099 030601 2168 AUI 42 099 030601 2124 AUI 42 099 030601 2167 AUI 42 099 030601 1062 AUI 42 099 030601 1096 AUI 42 099 030601 3004 AUI 42 099 030601 2054 AUI 42 099 030601 2121 AUI 42 099 030601 2093 AUI 42 099 030601 1064 AUI

594 595 596 597 598 599 600 601 602 603 604 605 606 607 608 609 610 611 612 613 614 615 616 617 618 619 620 621 622 623 624 625 626 627 628 629 630 631 632 633 634 635 636 637 638 639 A B C D E 42 099 030601 1073 AUI 42 099 030601 2025 AUI 42 099 030601 1072 AUI 42 099 030601 1045 AUI 42 099 030601 1031 AUI 42 099 030601 1066 AUI 42 099 030601 1070 AUI 42 099 030601 2090 AUI 42 099 030601 2075 AUI 42 099 030601 2127 AUI 42 099 030601 2061 AUI 42 099 030601 2109 AUI 42 099 030601 2034 AUI 42 099 030601 2041 AUI 42 099 030601 1026 AUI 42 099 030601 2137 AUI 42 099 030601 1040 AUI 42 099 030601 1006 AUI 42 099 030601 1014 AUI 42 099 030601 1087 AUI 42 099 030601 2116 AUI 42 099 030601 2158 AUI 42 099 030601 1074 AUI 42 099 030601 1007 AUI 42 099 030601 2156 AUI 42 099 030601 2013 AUI 42 099 030601 2068 AUI 42 099 030601 2076 AUI 42 099 030601 2139 AUI 42 055 010300 1008 AUI 42 055 010300 1055 AUI 42 055 010300 1056 AUI 42 099 030601 2141 AUI 42 099 030601 2107 AUI 42 099 030601 2111 AUI 42 099 030601 1068 AUI 42 099 030601 3015 AUI 42 099 030601 1050 AUI 42 099 030601 1039 AUI 42 099 030601 1013 AUI 42 099 030601 3018 AUI 42 099 030601 3021 AUI 42 099 030601 2123 AUI 42 099 030601 2117 AUI 42 099 030601 2143 AUI 42 099 030601 2110 AUI

640 641 642 643 644 645 646 647 648 649 650 651 652 653 654 655 656 657 658 659 660 661 662 663 664 665 666 667 668 669 670 671 672 673 674 675 676 677 678 679 680 681 682 683 684 685 A B C D E 42 099 030601 1100 AUI 42 099 030601 1083 AUI 42 099 030601 1041 AUI 42 099 030601 1037 AUI 42 099 030601 2105 AUI 42 099 030601 2052 AUI 42 099 030601 1042 AUI 42 099 030601 1077 AUI 42 099 030601 3020 AUI 42 099 030601 1015 AUI 42 099 030601 2125 AUI 42 099 030601 1058 AUI 42 099 030601 1082 AUI 42 099 030601 2170 AUI 42 099 030601 2131 AUI 42 099 030601 3014 AUI 42 099 030601 2055 AUI 42 099 030601 3017 AUI 39 003 011500 1120 AUI 39 003 011500 2045 AUI 39 003 011500 2066 AUI 42 001 030700 3007 AUI 42 001 030700 1030 AUI 42 001 030700 1058 AUI 42 001 030700 2018 AUI 42 001 030700 1081 AUI 42 013 011500 3052 AUI 42 013 011600 3041 AUI 42 013 011600 2066 AUI 42 013 011600 2060 AUI 42 013 011600 3038 AUI 42 013 011500 4027 AUI 42 013 011600 3007 AUI 42 013 011600 2059 AUI 42 013 011600 2057 AUI 42 013 011600 1018 AUI 42 013 011500 3056 AUI 42 013 011600 3051 AUI 42 013 011600 2058 AUI 42 013 011600 2028 AUI 42 013 011600 1012 AUI 42 013 011500 3059 AUI 42 013 011600 1062 AUI 42 013 011500 3019 AUI 42 013 011600 3006 AUI 42 013 011600 2025 AUI

686 687 688 689 690 691 692 693 694 695 696 697 698 699 700 701 702 703 704 705 706 707 708 709 710 711 712 713 714 715 716 717 718 719 720 721 722 723 724 725 726 727 728 729 730 731 A B C D E 42 013 011600 2032 AUI 42 013 011600 1064 AUI 42 013 011600 2052 AUI 42 013 011600 2056 AUI 42 013 011600 1019 AUI 42 013 011600 1030 AUI 42 013 011600 1014 AUI 42 013 011500 3021 AUI 42 013 011500 3085 AUI 42 013 011600 3047 AUI 42 013 011600 3026 AUI 42 013 011600 3003 AUI 42 013 011600 3001 AUI 42 013 011600 1003 AUI 42 013 011600 2043 AUI 42 013 011600 1055 AUI 42 013 011600 1066 AUI 42 013 011500 2028 AUI 42 019 911300 2071 AUI 42 019 911000 1000 AUI 42 019 911300 2057 AUI 42 019 911000 1019 AUI 42 019 911300 2061 AUI 42 019 911300 2070 AUI 42 019 911300 2062 AUI 42 019 911300 2056 AUI 42 019 911300 2050 AUI 42 041 011700 3025 AUI 42 041 011700 3089 AUI 42 041 011700 3092 AUI 42 041 011700 3098 AUI 42 041 011700 3095 AUI 42 041 011700 3013 AUI 42 055 011700 1017 AUI 42 055 011600 1128 AUI 42 055 011600 1119 AUI 42 055 011600 1121 AUI 42 055 011700 2080 AUI 42 055 011700 2060 AUI 42 055 011500 3051 AUI 42 055 011500 6000 AUI 42 055 011500 4045 AUI 42 055 011600 1067 AUI 42 055 011600 1056 AUI 42 055 011600 1023 AUI 42 055 011600 1093 AUI

732 733 734 735 736 737 738 739 740 741 742 743 744 745 746 747 748 749 750 751 752 753 754 755 756 757 758 759 760 761 762 763 764 765 766 767 768 769 770 771 772 773 774 775 776 777 A B C D E 42 055 011500 3005 AUI 42 055 010900 1050 AUI 42 055 010900 2028 AUI 42 055 011600 1005 AUI 42 055 011600 1024 AUI 42 055 011700 4059 AUI 42 055 011600 2128 AUI 42 055 011600 2129 AUI 42 055 011600 2007 AUI 42 055 011500 3045 AUI 42 055 011500 3069 AUI 42 055 011500 2027 AUI 42 055 010900 1046 AUI 42 055 011500 3020 AUI 42 055 011700 2049 AUI 42 055 011100 2030 AUI 42 055 011500 4033 AUI 42 055 011500 3038 AUI 42 055 011600 2085 AUI 42 055 010900 1023 AUI 42 055 011600 1022 AUI 42 055 011600 1020 AUI 42 055 011600 1113 AUI 42 055 011600 1014 AUI 42 055 011600 1114 AUI 42 055 011600 1007 AUI 42 055 011600 3022 AUI 42 055 011700 2003 AUI 42 055 011600 2097 AUI 42 055 011500 2039 AUI 42 055 011500 3001 AUI 42 055 011800 1016 AUI 42 013 011600 1060 AUI 42 013 011600 1080 AUI 42 013 011600 1076 AUI 42 013 011600 1069 AUI 42 013 011500 3057 AUI 42 013 011600 2050 AUI 42 013 011600 3042 AUI 42 013 011600 1038 AUI 42 013 011600 1059 AUI 42 013 011600 2021 AUI 42 013 011600 1074 AUI 42 013 011600 1070 AUI 42 013 011600 2031 AUI 42 013 011600 1058 AUI

778 779 780 781 782 783 784 785 786 787 788 789 790 791 792 793 794 795 796 797 798 799 800 801 802 803 804 805 806 807 808 809 810 811 812 813 814 815 816 817 818 819 820 821 822 823 A B C D E 42 019 911300 3004 AUI 42 019 911300 2072 AUI 42 019 911300 3001 AUI 42 019 911300 2075 AUI 42 055 011500 3023 AUI 42 055 011500 1044 AUI 42 055 011500 1005 AUI 42 055 011500 2073 AUI 42 055 011500 3044 AUI 42 055 011700 2024 AUI 42 055 011500 1010 AUI 42 055 011500 2020 AUI 42 055 011800 2009 AUI 42 055 011600 1001 AUI 42 055 011600 1144 AUI 42 055 011500 3058 AUI 42 055 011700 2055 AUI 42 055 011500 3049 AUI 42 055 011500 4036 AUI 42 055 011600 1040 AUI 42 055 011600 1062 AUI 42 055 011100 2013 AUI 42 055 011600 2101 AUI 42 055 011600 1096 AUI 42 055 011600 2095 AUI 42 055 011600 1122 AUI 42 055 011600 2054 AUI 42 055 011600 2124 AUI 42 071 011100 4027 AUI 42 071 011100 4061 AUI 42 071 010900 4044 AUI 42 071 011100 4037 AUI 42 071 011100 4063 AUI 42 071 011100 4062 AUI 42 071 010900 2054 AUI 42 071 011100 2024 AUI 42 071 010900 3027 AUI 42 071 011100 4036 AUI 42 071 010900 4008 AUI 42 071 010900 3017 AUI 42 071 010900 3030 AUI 42 071 010900 4018 AUI 42 071 011100 4003 AUI 42 071 011100 3001 AUI 42 071 011100 4035 AUI 42 071 011100 4043 AUI

824 825 826 827 828 829 830 831 832 833 834 835 A B C D E 42 071 011100 4044 AUI 42 071 011100 3053 AUI 42 071 011100 4011 AUI 42 071 011100 4111 AUI 42 071 011100 4034 AUI 42 055 011500 3025 AUI 42 055 011500 3028 AUI 42 055 011500 3031 AUI 42 055 011500 3060 AUI 42 071 011100 4050 AUI 42 071 011100 4047 AUI 42 071 011100 4051 AUI

EXHIBIT C

January 22, 2013 Marlene H. Dortch Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, S.W. Washington, DC 20554 Re: Comment on Areas Shown as Unserved on the National Broadband Map; WC Docket No. 10-90 Dear Ms. Dortch: Massillon Cable TV, Inc. hereby submits a list of census blocks that are identified as unserved in the Centurylink filing, but that are in fact served by Massillon Cable TV, Inc. with cable broadband at speeds of 20 Mbps downstream and 1.5 Mbps upstream. Census Block MCTV 391690008004049 Fully served 391690008004046 Fully served 391690008004011 Fully served 391690008004007 Partially Served 391690008004006 Fully served 391690008001026 Fully served 391690005004010 Fully served 391690005004009 Fully served 391690005004007 Fully served 391690005004006 Fully served 391690005004003 Fully served Sincerely, Robert Gessner President Phone: 330-833-5509 Email: rbgessner@massilloncabletv.com Fax: 330-833-7522

EXHIBIT D

EXHIBIT E

EXHIBIT F