Multicarrier CDMA with OFDM as Data Enhancement Technique and BER Analysis

Similar documents
BER Analysis for MC-CDMA

Analysis of Interference & BER with Simulation Concept for MC-CDMA

Multi-Carrier Systems

Cognitive Radio Transmission Based on Chip-level Space Time Block Coded MC-DS-CDMA over Fast-Fading Channel

Performance Evaluation of OFDM System with Rayleigh, Rician and AWGN Channels

A SURVEY OF LOW COMPLEXITY ESTIMATOR FOR DOWNLINK MC-CDMA SYSTEMS

Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) based Uplink Multiple Access Method over AWGN and Fading Channels

MITIGATING CARRIER FREQUENCY OFFSET USING NULL SUBCARRIERS

ORTHOGONAL frequency division multiplexing (OFDM)

Optimal Number of Pilots for OFDM Systems

Lecture 13. Introduction to OFDM

INTERFERENCE SELF CANCELLATION IN SC-FDMA SYSTEMS -A CAMPARATIVE STUDY

Keywords MCCDMA, CDMA, OFDM, Rayleigh Fading, Rician Fading.

SC - Single carrier systems One carrier carries data stream

SPARSE CHANNEL ESTIMATION BY PILOT ALLOCATION IN MIMO-OFDM SYSTEMS

Comparative Study of OFDM & MC-CDMA in WiMAX System

Copyright is owned by the Author of the thesis. Permission is given for a copy to be downloaded by an individual for the purpose of research and

Performance Comparison of OFDMA and MC-CDMA in Mimo Downlink LTE Technology

OFDM AS AN ACCESS TECHNIQUE FOR NEXT GENERATION NETWORK

Part 3. Multiple Access Methods. p. 1 ELEC6040 Mobile Radio Communications, Dept. of E.E.E., HKU

Performance analysis of FFT based and Wavelet Based SC-FDMA in Lte

EC 551 Telecommunication System Engineering. Mohamed Khedr

Implementation and Comparative analysis of Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) Signaling Rashmi Choudhary

Outline / Wireless Networks and Applications Lecture 7: Physical Layer OFDM. Frequency-Selective Radio Channel. How Do We Increase Rates?

FREQUENCY RESPONSE BASED RESOURCE ALLOCATION IN OFDM SYSTEMS FOR DOWNLINK

An Overview of Performance Evaluation of MC-CDMA System

1. INTRODUCTION II. SPREADING USING WALSH CODE. International Journal of Advanced Networking & Applications (IJANA) ISSN:

An OFDM Transmitter and Receiver using NI USRP with LabVIEW

Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM)

Bit Error Rate Performance Evaluation of Various Modulation Techniques with Forward Error Correction Coding of WiMAX

Page 1. Overview : Wireless Networks Lecture 9: OFDM, WiMAX, LTE

SPREADING SEQUENCES SELECTION FOR UPLINK AND DOWNLINK MC-CDMA SYSTEMS

Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing & Measurement of its Performance

ENHANCING BER PERFORMANCE FOR OFDM

2.

Evaluation of BER and PAPR by using Different Modulation Schemes in OFDM System

Performance Evaluation of STBC-OFDM System for Wireless Communication

Performance Evaluation of Wireless Communication System Employing DWT-OFDM using Simulink Model

Performance Analysis of OFDM for Different Digital Modulation Schemes using Matlab Simulation

Performance Analysis of Concatenated RS-CC Codes for WiMax System using QPSK

Single Carrier Ofdm Immune to Intercarrier Interference

Technical Aspects of LTE Part I: OFDM

Clipping and Filtering Technique for reducing PAPR In OFDM

PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF MC-CDMA SYSTEM USING BPSK MODULATION

Performance Enhancement of Multi User Detection for the MC-CDMA

Key words: OFDM, FDM, BPSK, QPSK.

COMPARISON OF CHANNEL ESTIMATION AND EQUALIZATION TECHNIQUES FOR OFDM SYSTEMS

A Research Concept on Bit Rate Detection using Carrier offset through Analysis of MC-CDMA SYSTEM

Orthogonal Cyclic Prefix for Time Synchronization in MIMO-OFDM

OFDMA and MIMO Notes

Dynamic Spreading Code Allocation Strategy for A Downlink MC-CDMA System

Broadband OFDM-FDMA System for the Uplink of a Wireless LAN

A Comparative performance analysis of CFO Estimation in OFDM Systems for Urban, Rural and Rayleigh area using CP and Moose Technique

Performance analysis of MISO-OFDM & MIMO-OFDM Systems

Bit error rate simulation using 16 qam technique in matlab

OFDM Systems For Different Modulation Technique

OFDM system: Discrete model Spectral efficiency Characteristics. OFDM based multiple access schemes. OFDM sensitivity to synchronization errors

Performance Analysis of Ofdm Transceiver using Gmsk Modulation Technique

Performance Evaluation of Nonlinear Equalizer based on Multilayer Perceptron for OFDM Power- Line Communication

Performance Analysis of ICI in OFDM systems using Self-Cancellation and Extended Kalman Filtering

Frequency-Domain Equalization for SC-FDE in HF Channel

CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION

Study of Performance Evaluation of Quasi Orthogonal Space Time Block Code MIMO-OFDM System in Rician Channel for Different Modulation Schemes

UNIFIED DIGITAL AUDIO AND DIGITAL VIDEO BROADCASTING SYSTEM USING ORTHOGONAL FREQUENCY DIVISION MULTIPLEXING (OFDM) SYSTEM

MC CDMA PAPR Reduction Using Discrete Logarithmic Method

Chapter 2 Overview - 1 -

Performance of a Flexible Form of MC-CDMA in a Cellular System

Frequency-Domain Channel Estimation for Single- Carrier Transmission in Fast Fading Channels

CHAPTER 3 ADAPTIVE MODULATION TECHNIQUE WITH CFO CORRECTION FOR OFDM SYSTEMS

Peak to Average Power Ratio Reduction in Mc Cdma System by Using Pulse Shaping Technique

Physical Layer: Modulation, FEC. Wireless Networks: Guevara Noubir. S2001, COM3525 Wireless Networks Lecture 3, 1

Improving Channel Estimation in OFDM System Using Time Domain Channel Estimation for Time Correlated Rayleigh Fading Channel Model

Prof. P. Subbarao 1, Veeravalli Balaji 2

Multipath signal Detection in CDMA System

The Effect of Carrier Frequency Offsets on Downlink and Uplink MC-DS-CDMA

4x4 Time-Domain MIMO encoder with OFDM Scheme in WIMAX Context

Performance of Wideband Mobile Channel with Perfect Synchronism BPSK vs QPSK DS-CDMA

RADIOCOMMUNICATION SYSTEMS MULTI-CARRIER CDMA DIGITAL COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS. Prof. C. Regazzoni

Comparison of ML and SC for ICI reduction in OFDM system

Lecture 3: Wireless Physical Layer: Modulation Techniques. Mythili Vutukuru CS 653 Spring 2014 Jan 13, Monday

Interleaved spread spectrum orthogonal frequency division multiplexing for system coexistence

Simulative Investigations for Robust Frequency Estimation Technique in OFDM System

Performance Study of MIMO-OFDM System in Rayleigh Fading Channel with QO-STB Coding Technique

ISSN: Page 320

DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF MULTIBAND OFDM SYSTEM OVER ULTRA WIDE BAND CHANNELS

Mobile & Wireless Networking. Lecture 2: Wireless Transmission (2/2)

Wireless Medium Access Control and CDMA-based Communication Lesson 16 Orthogonal Frequency Division Medium Access (OFDM)

TCM-coded OFDM assisted by ANN in Wireless Channels

Performance Analysis of LTE System in term of SC-FDMA & OFDMA Monika Sehrawat 1, Priyanka Sharma 2 1 M.Tech Scholar, SPGOI Rohtak

Performance Analysis of MIMO-OFDM based IEEE n using Different Modulation Techniques

Chapter 0 Outline. NCCU Wireless Comm. Lab

Decrease Interference Using Adaptive Modulation and Coding

Performance of Coarse and Fine Timing Synchronization in OFDM Receivers

Multi-carrier Modulation and OFDM

Practical issue: Group definition. TSTE17 System Design, CDIO. Quadrature Amplitude Modulation (QAM) Components of a digital communication system

Performance of Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing System Based on Mobile Velocity and Subcarrier

Performance Analysis of CDMA System using Direct Sequence Spread Spectrum and Frequency Hopping Spread Spectrum Techniques

Advanced 3G & 4G Wireless Communication Prof. Aditya K. Jagannatham Department of Electrical Engineering Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur

Optimized BPSK and QAM Techniques for OFDM Systems

Performance Evaluation of different α value for OFDM System

Transcription:

National Conference on Emerging Trends in VLSI, Embedded and Communication Systems-2013 27 Multicarrier CDMA with OFDM as Data Enhancement Technique and BER Analysis P.R. Srilakshmi and B.A. Sapna Abstract--- To achieve high data rate Multi-Carrier Code Division Multiple Access (MC-CDMA) is a suitable choice for next generation wireless communication system. MCCDMA is the combination of CDMA and OFDM schemes along with receiver diversity including cyclic prefix and zero padding, resulting into getting the advantages of all of these schemes. Capacity improvement is one of the major issues in designing of wireless communication system. In wireless communication system capacity planning greatly depends on performance criteria called bit error rate (BER). This study investigates the BER performance of MCCDMA system over Rayleigh fading channel for different length of spreading code such as OVSF code. Various performance enhancements are done by using receiver diversity and rate matching is done using OVSF and cyclic prefix for N-point IFFT based OFDM implementation. Diversity used in the receiver is EGC (Equal gain Combining) and MRC (maximal ratio combining). Performance Analysis of the OFDM-CDMA for different spreading code length is carried out. E b /N o Vs BER plot for 64 point FFT based OFDM is also plotted for noise model like Rayleigh fading etc. Index Terms--- MC-CDMA, CDMA, OFDM, OVSF Code, Cyclic Prefix, Zero Padding, Receiver Diversity (MRC), BER I I. INTRODUCTION MPLEMENTATION of MC-CDMA system with W-H codes and OFDM transmission technology for enhanced data rate of 2mbps and reduction in multiple access interference receiver diversity can be implemented to reduce fading effect and provide better data rate. Wireless communication is the fastest growing segment of the communications industry. As such, it has captured the attention of the media and the imagination of the public. The first wireless networks were developed in the pre-industrial age. These systems transmitted information over line- of-sight distances using smoke signals, torch signaling, flashing mirrors etc. Early radio systems transmitted analog signals. Today most radio systems transmit digital signals composed of binary bits, where the bits are directly obtained from a data signal or by digitizing an analog signal. Wireless communication networks have become much more important than any one when cellular concept was first developed. The rapid growth in cellular telephone subscribers P.R. Srilakshmi, Electronics and Communication Engineering, R.V.S College of Engineering and Technology, Coimbatore, India. E- mail:lakshmi57@gmail.com indicates that wireless communication is a robust, viable noise and data transport mechanis m. In single carrier CDMA system, it deals with the assignment of multiple users to a shared communication source. In this system multiple access among users is made possible by assigning different users, different sets of nonoverlapping Fourier coefficients. This is achieved at the transmitter by inserting (IFFT) silent Fourier coefficients and removing them on the receiver side after the FFT. Multicarrier modulation is implemented digitally. ISI may be completely removed by MC-CDMA with OFDM transmission scheme. Cyclic prefixing (CP) is employed in order to mitigate the effects of the loss of orthogonality caused by amplitude and phase distortion introduced by the transmission channel. Although the CP is an elegant and easy solution, it leads to a loss of inefficiency in the data throughput. This gives us a reason to introduce other multicarrier modulation techniques such as FMT that do not need the use of the CP. MC-CDMA is the combination of CDMA and OFDM, therefore we can get the advantages of both the schemes. In MC-CDMA scheme each data symbol is spreaded in frequency domain and transmitted on different subcarrier which is helpful in eliminating frequency selective fading and show significant improvement in BER performance. MC-CDMA is a well developing promising technique for next generation wireless communication system. Orthogonal Variable Spreading code Factor (OVSF) is an implementation of code division multiple access where before each signal is transmitted, the signal is spread, over a wide spectrum range through the use of a users code. These codes are derived from an OVSF code tree, and each user is given a different, unique code. An OVSF code tree is a complete binary tree that reflects the construction of Hadamard matrices. In MC-CDMA, Orthogonal Variable Spreading factor codes can be used to allow multi rate communication while maintaining the orthogonality among the users with different data rate. Channel used is based on Rayleigh function. Rayleigh distribution is a continuous probability distribution. The Rayleigh Probability density function is II. A. Transmitter Model PROPOSED SYSTEM MODEL Simulation model of MC-CDMA Transmitter is shown in fig1. It consist of a modulator, CDMA Spreading using OVSF(Orthogonal Variable Spreading code Factor) codes,

National Conference on Emerging Trends in VLSI, Embedded and Communication Systems-2013 28 serial to parallel convertor, cyclic prefix and Zero padding, IFFT block etc. QPSK modulation is undergoing and the modulated signal is spreaded using OVSF Code which is based on OVSF code tree and is developed by using a recursive algorithm. A serial to parallel conversion is undergone and this parallel data is provided with cyclic prefix and Zero padding in order to prevent the loss of data. Inverse FFT is implemented to convert data from frequency domain to time domain.since channel used is time dependent These parallel subcarriers are orthogonal to each other and can be generated by using Inverse Fast Fourier transform (IFFT). After this cyclic prefix is used as a guard interval to minimize the effect of inter carrier interference (ICI). Now parallel to serial converter (P/S) converts parallel data into seria l data stream and transmit over channel. d 0 d k-1 B. Receiver Model r(t) Receiver Diversity FFT Remove CP & zero padding Parallel to serial conversion Input bit stream Input bit stream Modulalator Modulalator De-spreading using OVSF codes De-spreading using OVSF codes CDMA spreading using OVSF codes CDMA spreading using OVSF codes De-modulator De-modulator Output bit stream Output bit stream Ʃ Serial to parallel conversion Cyclic prefix and zero padding IFFT S(t) Fig.1: MC-CDMA Transmitter Model d 0 d k-1 Fig.2: MC-CDMA Transmitter Model Block diagram for Receiver Model of MC-CDMA is shown in the fig.2. The received signal is given by r(t)= Where η (t) is the Additive White Gaussian Noise (AWGN) with psd of N 0 /2 and α k,n is the channel phase. At receiver, convert serial data into parallel by serial to parallel converter (S/P) then remove the cyclic prefix and zero padding and take the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) of received signal. After that dispread and demodulate the users signal. The output of demodulator passes through a channel decoder. To reduce ISI, MC-CDMA system has introduced where it divide bit streams into many sub streams and pass through sub channel to reduce ISI. The multicarrier CDMA scheme is categorized mainly in to two groups. One spreads the original data stream using the given spreading code and then modulates a different subcarrier with each chip (that is, spreading operation in frequency domain) and other spreads the serial to parallel converted data streams using a given spreading code such as OVSF code and then modulates a different subcarrier with each of a data stream.

National Conference on Emerging Trends in VLSI, Embedded and Communication Systems-2013 29 Fig.2 consist of a Receiver diversity,fast Fourier Transform(FFT),removal of cyclic prefix (CP), parallel to serial convertor, CDMA de-spreading using OVSF code, de-interleaver, de-modulator. Diversity techniques that mitigate the effect of multipath fading are called micro diversity. Diversity to mitigate the effect of shadowing from buildings and objects is called macro diversity. Macro diversity is generally implemented by combining signals received by several base stations or access points. This requires coordination among the different base stations or access points. Such coordination is implemented as a part of the networking protocols in infrastructure based wireless networks. There are many ways of achieving independent fading paths in a wireless system. One method to use multiple transmit or receive antennas, also called as antenna array, where the elements of the array are separated in distance. This type of diversity is referred as space diversity. The kind of receiver diversity used here is maximal ratio combining and equal gain combining. MRC requires knowledge of the time varying SNR on each branch, which can be very difficult to measure. A simpler technique is equal gain combining, which co-phases the signals on each branch and then combines them with equal weighting,α i =e -θi. The SNR of the combiner output, assuming equal noise PSD N 0 in each branch, is given by γ =1/N 0 M ( i r i ) 2 Also the channel model used in the proposed system is Rayleigh fading channel. The simplest probabilistic model for the channel filter taps is based on the assumption that there are a large number of statistically independent reflected and scattered paths with random amplitudes in the delay window corresponding to a single tap. The phase of the i th path is 2πf c t modulo2π. The channel impulse parameter is exponentially distributed with density 1/σ i 2 exp {-x/ σ i 2 }, x 0 This model, which is called Rayleigh fading channel, is quite reasonable for scattering mechanis ms where there are many reflectors, but is adopted primarily for its simplicity in typical cellular situations with a relatively small number of reflectors. The word Rayleigh is almost universally used for this model, but the assumption is that the tap gains are circularly symmetric complex Gaussian random variables. III. SPREADING CODE FOR RATE MATCHING Spreading will convert narrowband signal to a wideband signal to suppress the self interference by multipath effect. Various types of spreading codes are studied, they are Walsh- Hadamard (W-H) code, Pseudo Noise (PN) spreading code, Gold code, Golay code are used to spread the user data. These codes can be distinguished each other from their correlation properties, orthogonality property and peak average to power ratio (PAPR). Since W-H code is orthogonal code its performance is good among the above said spreading code. To minimize the MAI each users spreading code should be orthogonal. In synchronous downlink for MAI reduction W-H code can be used. In uplink PN code is used as spreading code because due to distortion spreading codes orthogonality gets lost. Also PN sequences are provided in FHSS system. In view of correlation property Gold code is suitable option than any other codes for asynchronous transmission. W-H code and Gold code can be used in WCDMA standard. Orthogonal Variable spreading code Factor (OVSF) codes have better orthogonality than W-H codes. This OVSF codes are based on OVSF code tree which in turn depend on a recursive algorithm. In the data channelization technology, orthogonal variable spreading factor (OVSF) code can distinguish the different data tunnels and promise the orthogonality for different customer tunnels. This results in a major drawback of OVSF codes, called blocking property as in fig 4. It may have significant impact on the bandwidth utilization of systems. Different data through put are made available to same user by allocating different OVSF code under the same code tree. This is the basic rate matching principle. This process may be implemented using OVSF code tree. Different user provided with different OVSF code. C 1,1 =(1) C 4,1 =(1,1,1,1) C 8,1 =(1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) C 2,1 =(1,1) C 8,2 =(1,1,1,1,-1,-1,-1,-1) C 4,2 =(1,1,-1,-1) C 4,3 =(1,-1,1,-1) C 8,3 =(1,1,-1,-1,1,1,-1,-1) C 8,4 =(1,1,-1,-1,-1,-1,1,1) C 8,5 =(1,-1,1,-1,1,-1,1,-1) C 8,6 =(1,-1,1,-1,-1,1,-1,1) C 2,2 =(1,-1) C 8,7 =(1,-1,-1,1,1,-1,-1,1) C 4,4 =(1,-1,-1,1) SF=1 SF=2 SF=3 SF=4 Layer 0 Layer 1 Layer 2 Layer 4 C 8,8 =(1,-1,-1,1,-1,1,1,-1) Fig 3: code tree representation for OVSF code

National Conference on Emerging Trends in VLSI, Embedded and Communication Systems-2013 30 Recursive algorithm: C 1 (0) = 1 C N (i) = {C 2N (2i-1) = C 2N (2i) (C N (i),c N (i)) = (C N (i),-c N (i)) Fig :3 illustrates a family of channelization codes ranging from a spreading factor of 1(on the left hand side) to a spreading factor of 8(on right hand side).this family of channelization codes is referred to as the OVSF code tree. The creation of OVSF code tree can be defined with the following simple recursive algorithm. From fig : 3, we start at the bottom of the tree with a value of 1. This corresponds to a channelization code with a spreading factor of 1(not spread). To move to the code of length 2 chip, we create two new branches on the tree. The algorithm for deciding the codes for these new branches can be summarized as follows: 1. Moving up a branch repeat the parent node sequence twice. 2. Moving down a branch repeat the parent node sequence twice, but inverting the second sequence. From this we end up with two codes of length 2.By recursively applying this algorithm we can build four codes of length 4 and then codes of length 8. IV. SIMULATION RESULTS Proposed design of MC-CDMA transmitter and receiver as described in section II has been simulated using MATLAB Version 7.10 R2010a. It shows results for MC-CDMA with OFDM along with receiver diversity, different types of receiver diversity are tried in the system. Results shows that MC-CDMA with maximal ratio combining will provide better results than Equal gain combining.mc-cdma with spreading code as both W-H codes and OVSF codes are tried. Results shows that MC-CDMA with receiver diversity and OVSF code provide better results. Fig 9 shows Rate matching using OVSF codes. Bandwidth used is 3.84MHz and variable data rate of 480kbps and 960kbps is tried and plotted. Fig 5: MC-CDMA with OFDM and receiver diversity as maximal ratio combining with BPSK modulation Fig 6: MC-CDMA with OFDM and receiver diversity as equal gain combining with BPSK modulation Fig 7: MC-CDMA with OFDM and receiver diversity as maximal ratio combining with QPSK modulation. Fig 4: MC-CDMA with OFDM without Receiver Diversity

National Conference on Emerging Trends in VLSI, Embedded and Communication Systems-2013 31 [12] Thakamichi INOUE,Deepshika GARG, Study on the OVSF code selection for the downlink MC-CDMA,IEICE Trans.commun,volE88- B,No:2,February 2007 [13] Boris D. Andreev, Edward L. Titlebaum, and Eby G. Friedman, Orthogonal Code Generator for 3G Wireless Transceivers,IEEE trans.commun,vole89-b, may 2011. Fig 8: Rate Matching using OVSF Codes V. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION The performance of the MC-CDMA system with OFDM is analyzed. The system includes receiver diversity technique which mitigates the effect of fading thus improving the BER performance. A comparison study of BER performance analysis for different receiver diversity and modulation techniques is done. System replaces W-H codes with OVSF code. Performance analysis will be better for system with receiver diversity and OVSF code. REFERENCES [1] S. Hara and R. Prasad., Overview of Multicarrier CDMA, IEEE Communications Magazine, vol. 35, pp. 126 133, Dec. 1998. [2] A.A. Patel, A.D. Patel, Matlab Implementation ofmultiuser Code division Multiple Access, Journal of Telecommunications, vol. 7, issue 2, pp. 40-45, March 2011. [3] P. Kumar, M. Ramesh, S. Chakrabarti, Performance Evaluation of Orthogonal/Scrambled-Orthogonal Overloaded DS-CDMA System, Wireless and Optical Communications Networks, pp. 1-5, June 2007. [4] A.C. Mccormick and E.A.Al.susa, (2007) Multicarrier CDMA for future generation mobile communication tells that future generations of wireless communication system IEEE Trans. Mobile comm. vol. 24, no. 5, pp. 603 619, May. [5] Ather Ravish khan, (2010) BER performance evaluation of DS-CDMA over AWGN channel using M-sequence and gold codes IEEE. Trans. no. 9, pp. 1485 1490, Sept. [6] Ignacio Berenguer, Hughes Hall, (2002) filtered multi tone modulation for broadband fixed wireless system IEEE conference paper, vol. 9 Apr. [7] Liang Liu, student member IEEE, Yong Liang Guan, member, IEEE and Dingrong Shao, (2011) Effect of carrier frequency offset on single carrier CDMA with frequency Domain Equalization IEEE Trans.vol. 20, no. 9, pp. 897 915, sep. [8] Muhammad Nasir Iqbal, (2009) Pilot Aided Rayleigh fading channel estimation using MMSE estimator for DS-CDMA system in cellular. ICCV, pp. 416 423.. [9] Muhammad Zoheb Hassan1, S.M. Shahrear Tanzil2, Tanveer Ahmed Bhuiyan3, Md. Mahmud Hassan4, S.P. Majumder, (2010) A Combined Analytical Model on the Bit Error Performance of A DS-CDMA Wireless Communication System in presence of Doppler shift, Timing Error and Frequency offset IEEE Trans. Wireless systems., vol. 17, no. 12, pp. 2301 2311, Dec [10] V.Jagan Nareen, K.Murali Krishna, K.Rajarajeshwari, (2012) performance analysis of MC-CDMA and OFDM in wireless Rayleigh channel IEEE. Trans. Dordrecht, Germany: Springer-Verlag, pp. 177 186. [11] Zhongqiang Luo, Xing Zhong Xiong, Artifical Intelligence of key Laboratory of Sichuan province, (2011) performance comparison of SC-FDMA-CDMA and OFDM-CDMA system for uplink IEEE conference paper., vol. 19, no. 6, pp. 1567 1586, Jun.