Virtual Communities and Elderly Support

Similar documents
Framework Programme 7

)XWXUH FKDOOHQJHV IRU WKH WRXULVP VHFWRU

Potential areas of industrial interest relevant for cross-cutting KETs in the Electronics and Communication Systems domain

A Collaborative Services Ecosystem for Ambient Assisted Living

Methodology for Agent-Oriented Software

A CYBER PHYSICAL SYSTEMS APPROACH FOR ROBOTIC SYSTEMS DESIGN

ARTEMIS The Embedded Systems European Technology Platform

An Australian roadmap for ICT research and development for ageing? Lessons from a European Union initiative

Development and Integration of Artificial Intelligence Technologies for Innovation Acceleration

IoT governance roadmap

FP7 ICT Work Programme

A Harmonised Regulatory Framework for Supporting Single European Electronic Market: Achievements and Perspectives

Foreword The Internet of Things Threats and Opportunities of Improved Visibility

Economic and Social Council

Promoting citizen-based services through local cultural partnerships

Computer Challenges to emerge from e-science

COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION

Interoperable systems that are trusted and secure

UNITED NATIONS EDUCATIONAL, SCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL ORGANIZATION

Personal Data Protection Competency Framework for School Students. Intended to help Educators

Country Paper : Macao SAR, China

AGENTS AND AGREEMENT TECHNOLOGIES: THE NEXT GENERATION OF DISTRIBUTED SYSTEMS

Lithuania: Pramonė 4.0

What is Digital Literacy and Why is it Important?

Economic and Social Council

Ethical Framework for Elderly Care-Robots. Prof. Tom Sorell

Ambient functionality : human interfaces for the digital life

AMIMaS: Model of architecture based on Multi-Agent Systems for the development of applications and services on AmI spaces

European Charter for Access to Research Infrastructures - DRAFT

Information & Communication Technology Strategy

UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY FOR DEVELOPMENT (CSTD)

CAPACITIES. 7FRDP Specific Programme ECTRI INPUT. 14 June REPORT ECTRI number

Digital Transformation. A Game Changer. How Does the Digital Transformation Affect Informatics as a Scientific Discipline?

GROUP OF SENIOR OFFICIALS ON GLOBAL RESEARCH INFRASTRUCTURES

Research Development Request - Profile Template. European Commission

PEOPLE on Smart Cities

FP9 s ambitious aims for societal impact call for a step change in interdisciplinarity and citizen engagement.

Ageing Well in the Information Society

Towards an MDA-based development methodology 1

Position Paper. CEN-CENELEC Response to COM (2010) 546 on the Innovation Union

Distributed Robotics: Building an environment for digital cooperation. Artificial Intelligence series

Article. The Internet: A New Collection Method for the Census. by Anne-Marie Côté, Danielle Laroche

Digital transformation in the Catalan public administrations

PhD in PROGETTAZIONE ARCHITETTONICA, URBANA E DEGLI INTERNI / ARCHITECTURAL, URBAN AND INTERIOR DESIGN - 34th cycle

COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION. Brussels, 9 December 2008 (16.12) (OR. fr) 16767/08 RECH 410 COMPET 550

NATIONAL TOURISM CONFERENCE 2018

demonstrator approach real market conditions would be useful to provide a unified partner search instrument for the CIP programme

Long Term Evolution (LTE) Next-Generation Public Safety Communications. Fred Scalera

Abstract. Keywords: virtual worlds; robots; robotics; standards; communication and interaction.

High Performance Computing Systems and Scalable Networks for. Information Technology. Joint White Paper from the

Enabling ICT for. development

Scientific Data e-infrastructures in the European Capacities Programme

COLLABORATIVE NETWORKED ORGANIZATIONS. A research agenda for emerging business models

A SYSTEMIC APPROACH TO KNOWLEDGE SOCIETY FORESIGHT. THE ROMANIAN CASE

Common evaluation criteria for evaluating proposals

Media Literacy Expert Group Draft 2006

OASIS concept. Evangelos Bekiaris CERTH/HIT OASIS ISWC2011, 24 October, Bonn

The OASIS Concept. Thessaloniki, Greece

Robotics in Horizon 2020 ICT Work Programme

Analysis on Digital Radio Service Deployment in Thailand TIME Consulting, 13 December 2017

The main recommendations for the Common Strategic Framework (CSF) reflect the position paper of the Austrian Council

Information Communication Technology

Development of a general purpose robot arm for use by disabled and elderly at home

Working with SMEs on projects

GALILEO Research and Development Activities. Second Call. Area 3. Statement of Work

The Role of Computer Science and Software Technology in Organizing Universities for Industry 4.0 and Beyond

AGENT BASED MANUFACTURING CAPABILITY ASSESSMENT IN THE EXTENDED ENTERPRISE USING STEP AP224 AND XML

Foresight Impact on Policy making and Lessons for New Member States and Candidate Countries Insights from the FORLEARN mutual learning process

At its meeting on 18 May 2016, the Permanent Representatives Committee noted the unanimous agreement on the above conclusions.

Research and application on the smart home based on component technologies and Internet of Things

Multi-sensory Tracking of Elders in Outdoor Environments on Ambient Assisted Living

Research strategy LUND UNIVERSITY

Committee on the Internal Market and Consumer Protection. of the Committee on the Internal Market and Consumer Protection

REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND THE COUNCIL. on the evaluation of Europeana and the way forward. {SWD(2018) 398 final}

RECOMMENDATIONS. COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION (EU) 2018/790 of 25 April 2018 on access to and preservation of scientific information

A New Platform for escience and data research into the European Ecosystem.

Ground Systems Department

NEM Strategic Research and Innovation Agenda 2018 NEM General Assembly, 30 May 2017

THE NEPTUS C4ISR FRAMEWORK: MODELS, TOOLS AND EXPERIMENTATION. Gil M. Gonçalves and João Borges Sousa {gil,

Towards Digital Ecosystems

Principles for the Networked World

Key factors in the development of digital libraries

Open Science. challenge and chance for medical librarians in Europe.

Digital Content Preliminary SWOT Analysis

Ubiquitous Home Simulation Using Augmented Reality

UNIVERSAL SERVICE PRINCIPLES IN E-COMMUNICATIONS

Сonceptual framework and toolbox for digital transformation of industry of the Eurasian Economic Union

A Survey on Smart City using IoT (Internet of Things)

Mobile Crowdsensing enabled IoT frameworks: harnessing the power and wisdom of the crowd

Operational Objectives Outcomes Indicators

Towards EU-US Collaboration on the Internet of Things (IoT) & Cyber-physical Systems (CPS)

CPE/CSC 580: Intelligent Agents

IN-DEPTH ASSESSMENT OF THE SITUATION (CONTRACT NO ENTR/2010/16, LOT 2) Task 6: Research, Development and Innovation in the Footwear Sector

Examples of Public Procurement of R&D services within EU funded Security Research actions

ASEAN: A Growth Centre in the Global Economy

GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF INTERNET GOVERNANCE

Industry 4.0: the new challenge for the Italian textile machinery industry

Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) Meeting of Experts on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (LAWS) April 2016, Geneva

CHAPTER 1 PURPOSES OF POST-SECONDARY EDUCATION

Internet of Things Paradigms as Enablers of Ambient Assisted Living Systems

Transcription:

Virtual Communities and Elderly Support Luis M. Camarinha-Matos 1 and Hamideh Afsarmanesh 2 1 New University of Lisbon, Quinta da Torre, 2825 Monte Caparica, Portugal 2 University of Amsterdam, Kruislaan 403, 1098 SJ Amsterdam, The Netherlands Abstract - This paper introduces the European IST project TeleCARE that aims to design and develop a configurable framework for virtual communities focused on supporting assistance to elderly people. The main innovative aspects introduced in the design of TeleCARE project and addressed in this paper features its tele-supervision and tele-assistance, based on the integration of multi-agent and federated information management approaches, introducing the concept of federated agency. Federated agencies comprise both stationary and mobile intelligent agents, combined with the services that are likely to be offered by the emerging ubiquitous computing and intelligent home appliances. Keywords: Intelligent agents, Tele-healthcare, Remote sensing, Federated information management. 1 Introduction There is an urgent need to develop new approaches for elderly care resorting to advanced information and communication technologies. Europe s ageing population is growing rapidly, as a considerable proportion of the total while, more significantly, the proportion of the working population who will generate the means to support the elderly is shrinking. This trend may lead to a prospect of spiralling growth in social security costs unless new ways and facilities for providing care are devised. In fact [6] during the last three decades, the number of people aged from 60 years or more has risen about 50%. Today, more than 25% of Europe s population is aged 60 years or more and this trend will continue. Within 20 years approximately a third of Europe s population will be over 60 years old, a total in excess of 100 million citizens. The percentage of people over the age of 80 is growing even more rapidly: an increase of 300% has been forecasted for the period of 1960 to 2020. Moreover, the ratio between the working and elderly population is dramatically declining. In 1995 there were almost seven adults of working age per one elderly person (aged 65 or more), by 2025 the ratio is expected to decrease to close to four. These trends present a real challenge for European social policies in the years ahead and underline the importance of developing new and more cost-effective ways of and facilities providing care and support to the elderly. Furthermore, as a group in society, the elderly face the real threat of marginalization and exclusion from the benefits of further European integration in general and indeed, the internal market in particular, if steps are not taken to provide them with the means to exercise their freedom of choice and independence. Development of adequate Internet-based infrastructures may provide the base to facilitate the establishment of collaborative virtual communities involving the elderly, care provision organizations, and relatives of the elderly at a low cost. A number of technological enablers of such solution can be identified, including: - Wide dissemination of Internet access. - Recent developments in virtual organizations and computer supported collaboration tools. - Advanced user interfaces. - The emergence of the so-called ubiquitous or pervasive computing. Nevertheless, the introduction of a new technology for the elderly care sector certainly requires the analysis of its socio-economic, ethical, and organizational impacts. In this context, the recently launched IST TeleCARE project [7] aims at design and development of a configurable framework focused on virtual communities for elderly

support. The proposed solution has to be seen as complementary to other initiatives for the integration of elderly in the society and to reduce their isolation. The TeleCARE consortium involves research organizations, technology developers, socio-economic experts, and elderly support organizations from Portugal, Spain, UK, and Netherlands. 2 Technology trends Major home appliance manufacturers are already announcing Internet-enabled systems. Networking technologies are starting to invade homes, not only to carry the conventional phone conversations signals and TV signals, but also the signals from surveillance cameras, commands for controlling lights and appliances, and multimedia information through the Internet. Various emerging technologies are competing in the sector of home networking, such as the wireless communications (e.g. Bluetooth or IEEE 802.11), use of power lines for also transporting the information, or the structured wiring for the new constructions / new residential areas [5]. Advances on mobile computing based on the new UMTS system and its integration with other technologies such as GPS, biometric identification systems, smart cards, etc. are also important contributors that will be considered for the development of the TeleCARE supporting infrastructure and services. The spread of these facilities world-wide however is a clear visible tendency of the market, and therefore facilitating the implantation of TeleCARE, when its results reach the market. There is however some uncertainty today about which one of the competing market technologies will win at the end, and when exactly the required infrastructures become generically available. Therefore, to a great extent, the TeleCARE results will be independent of the exact winning technologies, since the system is aimed at providing a highly flexible framework. Opneness is one of the main design goals for TeleCARE. In the area of virtual organizations a large amount of research efforts have been devoted to the establishment of infrastructures supporting the necessary enterprises cooperation. Some R&D efforts are also spent on supporting the cooperation of temporary consortia of autonomous enterprises and organizations that decide to join resources and skills, in order to achieve a common goal or better respond to a business opportunity. In particular, in the case of industrial enterprises and manufacturing in specific, the field of virtual enterprises is being addressed by a large number of international projects [1], [2]. The results of these projects are being employed towards the design and developments in TeleCARE. 3 The TeleCARE approach 3.1 General aspects Traditional approach to care provision has either resorted to support from the relatives, or from the elderly care centres. However, these two solutions have become increasingly inappropriate for the following reasons: (i) Shifting the burden of responsibility onto relatives is increasingly impractical, given the fact that more and more family members have to work to secure steady incomes. (ii) Provision of enough care centers is costly and invariably necessitates the relocation of the elderly people, often beyond their home communities. (iii) Many elderly people preserve enough robustness to be in their homes, a situation, which is often preferable to them, and as such, better for their welfare. Therefore, the objective of this project is to leverage the potential of information society technologies, in particular by resorting to the virtual organizations paradigm and both stationary and mobile intelligent agents, to improve the quality of life, and care, for elderly people and their families. Different classes of agents are designed to perform a large number of local and remote supervision tasks and intelligent assistance, such as sensorial data collection, alarm notification, agenda assistance, leisure activities assistance, health conditions monitoring, etc. [7]. Examples of sites and functionalities to be supported at the sites include (see Fig. 1): (i) Home Sites : To guarantee the security of elderly people living at home and help them in their daily chores (e.g. in the use of home appliances), and to provide necessary

information on their daily agenda, and access to leisure activities. (ii) Care Center Sites : To provide remote care services for helping/reminding elderly people at home and monitoring their activity from specialist care centers with regard to health conditions and individual medication programmes. (iii) Family Monitoring Sites (relative s office): To provide relatives of the elderly people with the means for monitoring their condition and offering support and assistance through a remote " window", accessible from their place of work, thereby allowing relatives to remain an integral part of the care process. (iv) Leisure Sites : To provide the means ensuring that elderly people remain active, through the provision of access to leisure activities and facilitate contact between elderly people with similar areas of interest. (v) Mobile Sites : Taking advantage of the ubiquitous computing, personal assistant agents travelling on devices such as mobile phones, smart cards, etc. are considered. (vi) Virtual shop : Due to the reduced mobility of elderly people, specialized electronic commerce can be expected to develop in near future, allowing for an easy way for these people to choose and buy some goods. A cooperative virtual organization involving such diverse nodes composes the framework for virtual care communities. Within TeleCARE project, a new infrastructure supporting seamless interactions among stationary and mobile intelligent agents, with planning the error diagnosis and recovery capabilities, able to recognize and self-adapt to a diversity of environments, and to interoperate with federated information and services management environments, is being designed and developed. Intelligent interface agents resorting to multimedia services will be of invaluable importance to the project, since elderly people may present some physical and/or cultural limitations that frustrate their interaction with automatic devices such as computers, and home appliances. The elderly care domain constitutes a highly distributed, heterogeneous and autonomous environment including both stationary and mobile intelligent agents, that requires: advanced functionalities in terms of co-operative problem solving (for user-assistance, remote operation, status monitoring, and error recovery), and advanced facilities that are expected to be offered in near future by the emerging ubiquitous computing, intelligent home appliances, and dedicated appliances to assist elderly people. The most important requirements for this sector, in opinion of our end users, include the Leisure Site Support for leisure activities Has advertisement and meeting organizing agents Receives several specific leisure related agents Elderly Leisure Site Elderly Care Center Relatives Office (job) Internet Elderly Home Site Virtual shop Family Monitoring Site Supports remote helping/reminding by relatives Runs dialog agents, Sends specific helping/reminding/observation agents Home Site Where elderly live Sensors, intelligent Home appliances, Has monitoring, helping agent and agenda agents Receives agents for specific tasks Sends shopping, information request and leisure related agents Virtual Shop Support for electronic commerce trading Has advertisement agents and selling agents Receives shopping agents Mobile Site Care Centre Site Supports remote care by care organizations Has dialog agents Receives alarm and specific care requesting agents Sends specific care agents Fig. 1 Examples of sites and required functionalities in elderly care Mobile Site Support for monitoring during elderly mobility Has personal assistant agent Receives several information and reminding agents Sends shopping, information request and leisure related agents

following aspects: A high degree of security, privacy, and welfare considerations for the users (elderly people) is mandatory. An improvement of the costs, quality, and accessibility of the care services is necessary. The quality of life of the elderly users must be ensured by adequate support not only for professional health care, but also for their involvement on leisure and social activities. The privacy, ethical and socio-organizational issues must be considered when developing any such technical solutions. 3.2 Design perspectives TeleCARE is therefore based on a distributed system built around a set of sites specialized for specific tasks. The general architecture of the sites comprise the following components: 1. Support for mobility. Adaptive mobile agents are used as the means to simultaneously achieve high levels of flexibility and independence on the characteristics of the network. All sites support the reception, execution, and launching of mobile agents. 2. Stationary agents. The sites present some specific needs that will not change over time, which are achieved by stationary agents. 3. Coordination through tuple-spaces. A crucial aspect in the system is inter-agent communication. In TeleCARE two types of inter-agent communications can be distinguished: i) intra-site communication where some agents executing in the same site communicate with each other, and ii) inter-site communication, where agents executing at different sites communicate with each other. Tuple-spaces (the LINDA model) are being tested for inter-site communication. Collaboration between agents with different home sites can be done if one agent is sent from one home site to the other. So a mobile agent sees two tuple spaces: the tuple-space of the site where it is executing and the tuple-space of the place where it originated. 4. Interactive planning and simulation tools. Building and deploying mobile agents is a crucial aspect. Since the agents have significant adaptive skills, one can imagine a library of pre-built agents that are selected and used (possibly with small adjustment) according to some application specific criteria. However, on one hand, these agents in the library have to be built, and on the other hand the user has to be confident that the chosen agent will fulfill his/her objectives. In order to achieve these objectives, a component will be developed at the sites to play the role of an interface to help the development, adjustment, deployment, simulation and monitoring of such agents. 5. Knowledge processing capability. In order to support the planning and error recovery mechanisms, the platforms includes ruleprocessing capabilities (JESS or similar). 6. Federated database mechanisms. To support federated / distributed database management, the platform also includes a federation layer that extends the functionalities of standard database management systems. On one hand, the usage of both emerging standards and Web tools (ODMG, XML) supporting the required interoperability criteria for TeleCARE is considered. On the other hand, innovative mechanisms and facilities will be developed to support the on line definition of both the syntax and semantics of common meta-data necessary to support the collaboration and information exchange / integration among heterogeneous and autonomous sites, with diverse goals and configurations. Proper settings of information visibility and access rights of different sites involved in the virtual community, also addressed through the federated information management layer. support for mobility tuple space stationary agent mobile agent federated database mechanisms interfaces to local resources interactive planning and simulation tools Rules processor Fig. 2 General composition of the site platforms The proposed virtual community infrastructure can benefit from the experiences and results gained earlier within the virtual enterprises area and in specific from two perspectives: Establishment of cooperation agreements among the various organizations and actors involved in the elderly care. Specific aspects to

be borrowed from the virtual enterprises area: definition of access rights to information / visibility rules, coordination policies, and safe communications. Support for the formation of virtual communities of elderly, complemented by low cost teleconferencing tools integrated with the multi-agent infrastructure. 3.3 Societal issues Inclusion of technology in our lives is a difficult subject as there is always the potential risk of intrusion in our privacy. Therefore, in addition to the technological developments, TeleCARE project includes tasks to study and assess its social / organizational impacts, and economic issues, training needs, ethical aspects, etc. The privacy rights of the elderly will be completely preserved by the federated information management approach in the sense that the proprietary and confidential information about elderly and the centers involved can only be accessed by authorized users and centers. Furthermore, special focus is given to the security of interactions. As such, safe communications is an important task in the project. 4 Preliminary results A preliminary prototype focused on the adaptability of mobile agents to different environments (e.g. different home sites) was developed [3], [4]. While going through its itinerary a mobile agent has to face the heterogeneity of the environments it finds. Therefore, it is crucial that the agents have some mechanisms to cope with this heterogeneity. Also, mobile agents have to face uncertain environments that require high levels of autonomy. TeleCARE proposes the concept of adaptive mobile agents that carry high level hierarchical abstract plans enabling agents to adapt themselves to the characteristics of the local environments before execution. These high level abstract plans are annotated with monitoring and error recovery strategies that guide the agent when errors occur. The general architecture of the mobile agents is illustrated in Fig. 3. There is an important distinction between the objectives of stationary agents and mobile agents. In fact, stationary agents will be used for those tasks that may only slightly change over the life of the site, while mobile agents will be used for those tasks that are not foreseen in advance, episodic tasks, and those tasks that have high rates of change possibilities over time. For instance, stationary agents will be used in monitoring activities which may require some sort of intelligent reasoning, agenda agents (e.g., agents to guarantee the fulfilment of a pre-defined medication program), local help agents (e.g., in a home site such an agent could use intelligent interfaces to provide help to the elderly person, when using a HIFI equipment), etc. Mobile agents will be used in activities such as specific monitoring of some health parameters motivated by some alarm condition, specific help, reminding or advice to the elderly person, and support for electronic trading. mobility coordination plan representation plan adaptation execution monitoring execution supervision Mobile Agent MA HTS of MA RTS of MA tuple space stationary agents tuple space interface to local resources Home Place of MA interface to local resources current Residence Place of MA Fig. 3 General architecture of a mobile agent An interesting concept investigated in this work is that the data may not be sent from one agent to the other via a high-level protocol, as in the traditional push strategy or via mobile carrier agents, but rather through the pull strategy via the access to the agent s federated information management system (FIMS) associated to each (stationary) agent [2]. The planned architecture offers both possibilities. In the case of a pull strategy, the high-level protocol is used for coordination purposes only. The message s content then becomes shorter and leaner and the agents have access to the necessary data only when needed. Fig.4 illustrates this approach. Consider an example case where a given agent (B) processes some information and generates some results (for example r1) that is needed by another agent (A). Then B sends a message to A (represented by 1 in this Figure), communicating that certain

information (r1) is available in its local database (that can be accessed through its export schema). Please notice that the access rights for the shared data among the nodes is dynamically and bilaterally configured, according to the roles and the needs of every node and enforced through the agents export schemas. This control message sent from B to A informs A that now this updated data item is available and can be accessed by A, through its own import schema. Once this message is received at A, (represented by 1 ), whenever it wishes A can retrieve this updated information. Such an access goes as follows: Agent_A queries this information from its own integrated schema in FIMS-A (represented by 2 ) requesting r1; an automatic access will occur from FIMS_A to FIMS_B (represented by 3 ) using the federated mechanisms for information access that receives and returns this authorized information from Node B (represented by 4 ). This information is in turn returned to Agent_A for its internal processing (represented by 5 ). Integrated 2 schema Imported schema Node A Node_ Agent_ A 5 FIMS_A Internet 1 3 4 Node B Node _ Agent_B FIMS_B Fig. 4 Exchange of data in a pull strategy export schema The possibility of configuring, on a bilateral basis, the specific common syntax and semantics of the exchanged data, as well as the access rights to the data owned by agents for every other agent in the community, represents the important functionality addressed in TeleCARE. This functionality in turn supports the adequate levels of data integration and information exchange while preserving the autonomy required by each site in a virtual elderly community environment, which constitutes another advantage regarding the traditional MAS approaches. Next developments are more focused on the virtual organization / virtual community facets, exploring the operating principles and needed functionality. 5 Conclusions The convergence of a number of technologies such as multi-agent systems, federated information management, safe communications, hypermedia interfaces, rich sensorial environments, increased intelligence of home appliances, and collaborative virtual environments, represents an important enabling factor for the design and development of virtual elderly support community environments. Although these technological factors open opportunities for new approaches to elderly care, as demonstrated by preliminary research results, this process has to be complemented by a careful analysis of the socio-economic impacts and ethical issues. Acknowledgements. This work was funded in part by the IST program of the European Commission. The authors thank the contribution of the TeleCARE consortium. References: 1. Camarinha-Matos, L.M.; Afsarmanesh, H. - Infrastructures for Virtual Enterprises, Kluwer Academic Publishers, ISBN 0-7923- 8639-6, Oct. 1999. 2. Camarinha-Matos, L.M.; Afsarmanesh, H.; Rabelo, R. - E-Business and Virtual Enterprises, Kluwer Academic Publishers, ISBN 0-7923-7205-0, Oct 2000. 3. Camarinha-Matos, L.M.; Vieira, W. - Intelligent mobile agents in elderly care, Journal of Robotics and Autonomous Systems (Elsevier), Vol. 27, N. 1-2, April 1999, ISSN 0921-8890, pp. 59-75. 4. Camarinha-Matos, L.M.; Vieira, W.; Castolo, O. - Mobile agents approach to virtual laboratories, Proceedings of IFAC Symposium on Artificial Intelligence in Real- Time Control, Budapest, 2-4 Oct 2000. 5. Dutta-Roy, A. Networks for homes, IEEE Spectrum, Vol. 36, N. 12, Dec 1999. 6. Saranummi, N.; Kivisaari, S.; Sarkikoski, T.; Graafmans, J. Ageing & Technology State of the art, Report for the European Commission, Institute for Prospective Studies, Seville, Spain, Nov. 1996. 7. Telecare Consortium - A Multi-Agent Tele- Supervision System for Elderly Care, Description of work, Jan 2001.