UWB Channel Modeling for Wireless Body Area Networks in Medical Applications

Similar documents
Effect of Body Motion and the Type of Antenna on the Measured UWB Channel Characteristics in Medical Applications of Wireless Body Area Networks

Impact of an Aortic Valve Implant on Body Surface UWB Propagation: A Preliminary Study

Different experimental WBAN channel models and IEEE models: comparison and effects

P-Rake Receivers in Different Measured WBAN Hospital Channels

IEEE a UWB Receivers Performance in Different Body Area Network Channels

A Review of Channel Modelling for Wireless Body Area Network in Wireless Medical Communications

Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks N

SUB-BAND ANALYSIS IN UWB RADIO CHANNEL MODELING

Ultra Wideband Indoor Radio Channel Measurements

UWB Channel Modeling

Channel Modeling ETI 085

Measurement-Based On-Body Path Loss Modelling for UWB WBAN Communications

EITN85, FREDRIK TUFVESSON, JOHAN KÅREDAL ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY. Why do we need UWB channel models?

Experimental Study of Dynamic Ultra Wideband On-Body Radio Propagation Channel for Medical Applications

This is the author s final accepted version.

Ultra Wideband Radio Propagation Measurement, Characterization and Modeling

Radio Propagation and Networks Research. Costas Constantinou School of Electronic, Electrical & Computer Engineering 10 June 2013

Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks N

Research Article Statistical Modeling of Ultrawideband Body-Centric Wireless Channels Considering Room Volume

MEASUREMENT AND MODELING OF INDOOR UWB CHANNEL AT 5 GHz

UWB Small Scale Channel Modeling and System Performance

The Measurement and Characterisation of Ultra Wide-Band (UWB) Intentionally Radiated Signals

Propagation Effects in UWB Body Area Networks

Intra-Vehicle UWB Channel Measurements and Statistical Analysis

Performance Evaluation of a UWB Channel Model with Antipodal, Orthogonal and DPSK Modulation Scheme

SUITABILITY STUDY OF DS-UWB AND UWB-FM FOR MEDICAL APPLICATIONS

IEEE P a. IEEE P Wireless Personal Area Networks. UWB Channel Characterization in Outdoor Environments

Overview. Measurement of Ultra-Wideband Wireless Channels

ANUMBER of very promising applications such as health

Radio Channels Characterization and Modeling of UWB Body Area Networks

Numerical Study on Indoor Wideband Channel Characteristics with Different Internal Wall

Channel-based Optimization of Transmit-Receive Parameters for Accurate Ranging in UWB Sensor Networks

Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks N

Performance Analysis of Ultra-Wideband Spatial MIMO Communications Systems

Millimeter Wave Small-Scale Spatial Statistics in an Urban Microcell Scenario

Channel characterisation for indoor wearable active RFID at 868 MHz

DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF MULTIBAND OFDM SYSTEM OVER ULTRA WIDE BAND CHANNELS

Antennas and Propagation for Body-Centric Wireless Communications

Ultra Wideband Channel Model for IEEE a and Performance Comparison of DBPSK/OQPSK Systems

Directional channel model for ultra-wideband indoor applications

UWB Impact on IEEE802.11b Wireless Local Area Network

60 GHz WIRELESS LINKS FOR HDTV: CHANNEL CHARACTERIZATION AND ERROR PERFORMANCE EVALUATION

International Journal of Engineering & Computer Science IJECS-IJENS Vol:13 No:03 1

Narrow- and wideband channels

AN ACCURATE ULTRA WIDEBAND (UWB) RANGING FOR PRECISION ASSET LOCATION

Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks N (WPANs)

Diversity gain measurements for body-centric communication systems

Experimental Evaluation Scheme of UWB Antenna Performance

Measurement-based characterizations of on-body channel in the human walking scenario

Research Article Experimental Characterization of a UWB Channel for Body Area Networks

DS-UWB signal generator for RAKE receiver with optimize selection of pulse width

SHORT-RANGE UWB WIRELESS LINK IN WPAN SCENARIOS. CNRS 6164, Université de Rennes 1, Rennes Cedex, France

UWB Theory, Channel, and Applications

Wideband Characterization of RF Propagation for Time-of Arrival Localization of Wireless Video Capsule Endoscope Inside Small Intestine

Increasing the Efficiency of Rake Receivers for Ultra-Wideband Applications

R ied extensively for the evaluation of different transmission

PROPAGATION OF UWB SIGNAL OVER CONVEX SURFACE MEASUREMENTS AND SIMULATIONS

Ultra Wideband Signal Impact on IEEE802.11b and Bluetooth Performances

Revision of Lecture One

Channel Modeling for UWB WBAN On-Off Body Communication Link with Finite Integration Technique

Spatial and Polarisation Correlation Characteristics for UWB Impulse Radio

Channel Models. Spring 2017 ELE 492 FUNDAMENTALS OF WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS 1

Time Domain Characteristics of Multiple UWB 2D Communication Tiles

IEEE Working Group on Mobile Broadband Wireless Access <

Narrow- and wideband channels

Range Error Analysis of TDOA Based UWB-IR Indoor Positioning System

Differential and Single Ended Elliptical Antennas for GHz Ultra Wideband Communication

Performance Analysis of Different Ultra Wideband Modulation Schemes in the Presence of Multipath

Technical Report

Path Loss Characterization of Horn-to-Horn and Textile-to-Textile On-Body mmwave Channels at 60 GHz

Intra-Vehicle UWB MIMO Channel Capacity

Lecture 7/8: UWB Channel. Kommunikations

THE EFFECTS OF NEIGHBORING BUILDINGS ON THE INDOOR WIRELESS CHANNEL AT 2.4 AND 5.8 GHz

Extraction of Antenna Gain from Path Loss Model. for In-Body Communication

Research Article Large-Scale Fading and Time Dispersion Parameters of UWB Channel in Underground Mines

FURTHER STUDY OF RAINFALL EFFECT ON VHF FORESTED RADIO-WAVE PROPAGATION WITH FOUR- LAYERED MODEL

CHANNEL MODELS, INTERFERENCE PROBLEMS AND THEIR MITIGATION, DETECTION FOR SPECTRUM MONITORING AND MIMO DIVERSITY

Impact of Metallic Furniture on UWB Channel Statistical Characteristics

Development of a Wireless Communications Planning Tool for Optimizing Indoor Coverage Areas

FADING DEPTH EVALUATION IN MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS FROM GSM TO FUTURE MOBILE BROADBAND SYSTEMS

Performance Evaluation of a MIMO-On-Body System in a Mine Environment

Performance Evaluation of a UWB Channel Model with Antipodal, Orthogonal and DPSK Modulation Scheme

Radiation Pattern Analysis of Single and Multi-Antenna Wearable Systems

38123 Povo Trento (Italy), Via Sommarive 14

Specification. Patent Pending. Description : AccuraUWB Flex Series 3~10GHz Ultra-Wide Band (UWB) Flex Antenna with 100mm 1.

UWB Double-Directional Channel Sounding

Multipath Beamforming for UWB: Channel Unknown at the Receiver

Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)

The Radio Channel. COS 463: Wireless Networks Lecture 14 Kyle Jamieson. [Parts adapted from I. Darwazeh, A. Goldsmith, T. Rappaport, P.

Ranging detection algorithm for indoor UWB channels and research activities relating to a UWB-RFID localization system

Written Exam Channel Modeling for Wireless Communications - ETIN10

RECENTLY, systems beyond 3G (B3G) have been actively

Elham Torabi Supervisor: Dr. Robert Schober

Improved Usage of Time Slots of the IEEE a UWB System Model

SHORT RANGE PROPAGATION MODEL FOR A VERY WIDEBAND DIRECTIVE CHANNEL AT 5.5 GHZ BAND

3102 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON VEHICULAR TECHNOLOGY, VOL. 58, NO. 7, SEPTEMBER /$ IEEE

Power Delay Profile Analysis and Modeling of Industrial Indoor Channels

WIRELESS COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES (16:332:546) LECTURE 5 SMALL SCALE FADING

Design of Energy Efficient Topologies for Wireless On-Body Channel

Performance of RAKE receiver over different UWB channel

Transcription:

UWB Channel Modeling for Wireless Body Area Networks in Medical Applications Attaphongse Taparugssanagorn, Carlos Pomalaza-Ráez, Ari Isola, Raffaello Tesi, Matti Hämäläinen, and Jari Iinatti Centre for Wireless Communications, University of Oulu, Finland Abstract Wireless body area networks (WBAN) are expected to be a breakthrough technology in healthcare areas such as hospital and home care, telemedicine, and physical rehabilitation. Because the human body has a complex shape consisting of different tissues it is expected that the nature of the propagation of electromagnetic signals in the case of WBAN to be very different than the one found in other environments, e.g. offices, streets, etc. There have been several previous experimental studies aimed to characterize the nature of the Ultra- Wideband (UWB) channel for the case of WBANs. In this paper we describe our contribution to expand the knowledge of the UWB channel by taking measurements in the frequency range of 3-11 GHz in realistic scenarios expected to be found in medical applications. We also present channel models that have been developed using the experimental results. Keywords: WBAN channel model, Wireless EKG, Wireless medical telemetry Introduction Future applications in the area of telecommunications are being driven by the concept of being connected or able to communicate anywhere and at anytime. This type of scenario is also envisioned in medical healthcare area. Wireless medical telemetry has been experiencing continuous developments and improvements during recent years [1]. In this application a patient s health is remotely monitored through the use of radio technology. As a result of this wireless technology patients gain more mobility and comfort by not having to be physically connected to several pieces of medical equipment. In addition to improve the quality of patient care, wireless medical telemetry has also the potential to reduce the costs by decreasing the need to have medical personal in close proximity to patients at all times. Remote monitoring of patients enables a very efficient and timely use of doctors, nurses, and specialized medical equipment. Recent advances in wireless technology have led to the development of wireless body area networks (WBAN), where a set of communicating devices are located around the human body [2]. For the case of medical applications these devices are connected to sensors that monitor vital body parameters and movements. Among the vitals that are commonly measured we have electrocardiograms (EKG), blood oxygen saturation, blood pressure, and temperature. By measuring these vitals and wirelessly transmitting them to a control node or station a WBAN allows for the continuous monitoring of the patients health status without the burden of physical wires attached to their bodies or frequent visits by medical personal. Ultra-wideband (UWB) communications is a promising technology for WBAN due to its particular characteristics [3, 4]. The monitoring of human vitals and movements requires a relatively low data rate which in the case of UWB translates into very small transmitting power requirements and longer battery life, both of which are desirable features for devices that are close to body and meant to be used for extended periods of time. To properly design and develop UWB devices that can be used in WBANs applications it is necessary to observe and model the corresponding radio propagation channel in the frequency range of 3-11 GHz. For the case of indoor and outdoor scenarios comprehensive studies of the UWB propagation channel have been performed in recent years [3, 5, 6]. It is natural to expect that the channel characteristics for those cases will be different than the ones in WBAN scenarios due to the effect of the human body with its complex shape and different tissues, each with a different permittivity. Finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) numerical analysis methods have been often used in the investigation of the UWB channel close to the human body [7]. These studies are limited to scenarios that do not take into account the effect of the antennas and other conditions that are present in most realistic scenarios, i.e., walls, furniture, etc. UWB measurements around the human body have been carried out by various researchers [8-1]. These experiments have been limited to scenarios that are highly unlikely to take place in real medical applications, e.g., the use of numerous antennas very close to the skin forming a multihop wireless network [9]. It is highly unlikely that the use of several antennas and their corresponding transceivers, close to the human body, will be approved due to potential negative effects of the radio signals not only on the human organs or tissues but on other medical implants such as pacemakers. The experimental results described in this paper correspond to conditions likely to be found and approved in the medical care field. These conditions include the use of very few (at most two or three) antennas, a slight separation between the skin and the UWB device (antenna or transceiver), the location of a UWB device on an arm (as a wristwatch), and the presence of a UWB control node or gateway a few meters from the body [3], e.g., on a wall or the ceiling as shown in Figure 1. To have a reference set of measurements that does not include the effects of walls and other components, such as furniture, the experiments were first conducted in an anechoic chamber.

Channel Measurement Setup and Scenarios Figure 1- Channel links in wireless medical communication: (A) the WBAN channel: (A1) the channel between the sensor or (A2) from the sensor nodes to the gateway, (B) the channel from the gateway to some other wireless network. TX RF components Vector Network Analyzer Post processing RX RF components Port 1 Port 2 S21 parameter Computer with LabVIEW 7 Figure 2- Frequency domain measurement using VNA Figure 3- Antenna positions around the body Measurements were taken on a total of five individual: three males and two females. One of the male subjects has a metallic (titanium alloy) aortic implant. It is found that for certain scenarios the characteristics of the UWB channel are distinctively different depending on the gender or the medical condition of the subject. These results highlight the importance, for medical applications, to carry out a comprehensive study of the nature of the propagation signals when they take place close the human body. The measurements obtained in this study are used to estimate the channel parameters needed to build models that can be used in WBAN medical applications. The channel measurement system used in this paper consists of an HP Agilent 872ES, a vector network analyzer (VNA), P2 BroadSpec antennas [11], 5-m long SUCOFLEX RF cables with 7.96 db loss and a control computer with Lab- VIEW 7 software. The VNA is operated in a transfer function measurement mode, where port 1 and port 2 are the transmitting and the receiving port, respectively, as seen in Figure 2. This corresponds to a S21-parameter measurement set-up, where the device under test (DUT) is a radio channel. The BroadSpec antennas are azimuthally omni-directional with the antenna radiation patterns as shown in [11]. The sweep time of the network analyzer depends on the number of frequency points within the sweep band, being automatically adjusted by the VNA. The frequency band used in the measurements is from 3. GHz to 11 GHz covering both the Industrial Scientific and Medical (ISM) frequency bands (5.725-5.875 GHz) as well as the whole frequency bands of the UWB mask allotted by the FCC (3.1-1.6 GHz). Therefore, the bandwidth B is 8 GHz. The imum number of frequency points per sweep M is 161, which can be used to calculate the imum detectable delay of the channel as Using (1) = ( M 1) B. (1) is 2 ns which corresponds to 6 m in free space distance. Here we are interested in the first 2 ns, i.e. at most 6 m away from the body. We consider two different cases: 1) when both antennas are attached to the body and 2) when there is a separation, a 1.2 cm dielectric, between the body and the antennas. The measurements setups are designed with more realistic scenarios in mind. This means that the number of antennas near the body should be small. Also, only comfortable positions on the body where to place the antennas are selected. In addition, the level of the Tx power should be small enough so that the EM emissions do not harm the human body. The UWB channel measurement experiments were first conducted in an anechoic chamber, to minimize the effect of the environment when measuring the channel around the body. Then measurements in a classroom were conducted to investigate the UWB channels in an indoor environment. The 1 st set of measurements (around the body) was taken at two different levels of the torso, at the chest level (level 1) and at the abdomen level (level 2) as illustrated in Figure 3. At each level, the Rx antenna (the rectangle in the figure) is fixed at the middle front of the torso and the Tx antenna (the circle in the figure) is placed at various positions at distances of 1 cm. We obtained results for 3 men and 2 women. The age span of the subjects is from mid 2s to mid 5s. One of three men has a titanium alloy aortic valve implant. Figure 4 shows the positions for the 2 nd set of measurements, with the Tx antenna at the middle of the chest and the Rx antenna on the right hand wrist. The 3 rd set of measurements aims to emulate the situation in a hospital room as illustrated in Figure 1. As shown in Figure 5, the subject stands 1 m away from a 2 m high pole where the Rx antenna is placed. The Tx

is placed at the middle of the chest, which is 1.25 m high from the floor. One hundred realizations of the measured channel impulse responses are averaged for each position. We focus only on the first 2 ns of each channel impulse response, since the energy of the channel impulse responses at the human body decays rapidly. Figure 6 compares the average channel impulse responses in the 1 st set, level 1, when the antennas are directly attached to the clothes and then when there is a dielectric separation between the body and the antenna. The propagation link is significantly improved with a separation. In Figure 7, one can see that the average channel impulse response of the subject with an aortic implant drops off more quickly. A possible explanation is the scattering caused by the metallic aortic valve. The difference between the average channel impulse responses of male and female subjects is shown in Figure 8. The second peak in the female cases is due to the metal component inside their brassieres. A small effect is also due to their body structure. Figure 9 shows the average channel impulse responses for the 2 nd set of measurements (Figure 4). The average channel impulse response when the subject turns the back towards the Rx antenna in the 3 rd set of measurements has the smallest gain. A comparison of the results, when the two antennas are placed on the body, for the classroom and anechoic chamber scenarios, is shown in Figure 1. It can be clearly seen the variations in the channel characteristics depending on the presence or not of the human body. When there is a separation between the antenna and the body, the average channel impulse response tends to be the closer to the one in an empty room. Figure 4- Antenna positions for the 2 nd set of measurements 5 6 position 2 position 3 position 5 position 6 position 7 2 4 6 8 1 12 14 16 18 2 5 6 (a) Figure 5- Antenna position for the 3 rd set of measurement: (1) facing the antenna, (2) beside the antenna, and (3) with the back towards the antenna Finally, measurements were done in a classroom with the size of 7.2 5 3 m. The Rx antenna is placed on a 2-m high pole. The subject with Tx antenna on the chest stands 2.4 m away facing to the pole. The measurements were also done for sitting and sleeping person scenarios. Measurements, when both the Tx and the Rx antennas are attached on the body were also conducted to compare the results to the ones measured at the anechoic chamber. Average Channel Impulse Responses 2 4 6 8 1 12 14 16 18 2 (b) Figure 6- Average channel impulse responses for the 1 st set level 1: (a) without separation and (b) with separation 75 85 95 15 male 1 male 2 male 3 (with implant) 5 1 15 2 Figure 7- Average channel impulse responses in the 1 st set (level 1, position 2) for three male subjects. 65 75 85 95 15 male 1 male 2 female 1 female 2 5 1 15 2 Figure 8- The average channel impulse responses in the 1 st set (level 1, position 2) comparing male and female subjects.

Positions Table 1 Different positions for the 1 st set (level 1) with corresponding statistical parameters Mean L [delay bins] Mean [ns] Positions Mean L [delay bins] Mean [ns] Tx at 1 45.746 Tx at 1 with separation 85.691 Tx at 2 22.1863 Tx at 2 with separation 43.113 Tx at 3 8.4197 Tx at 3 with separation 1.1238 Tx at 6 5.3241 Tx at 4 with separation 8.8964 Tx at 7 24.2343 Tx at 5 with separation 6.9166 Tx at 8 3.841 Tx at 6 with separation 11.1623 male with implant, Tx at 2 8.2963 Tx at 7 with separation 51.771 female 1, Tx at 2 32.159 Tx at 8 with separation 83.642 female 2, Tx at 2 31.1275 4 5 6 position 1 position 2 position 3 Delay Dispersion Parameter To evaluate the delay dispersion within the channel the value of interest is the root mean square () delay spread [12]. To calculate it, all measured channel impulse responses are first truncated above the noise threshold set to four times of the noise standard deviation. The number of paths L above the noise threshold and the mean delay spreads corresponding to the 1 st set are summarized in Table 1. It can be seen that is smaller for the case with separation. 5 1 15 2 Figure 9- The average channel impulse responses in the 2 nd set 2 3 4 5 6 nobody in room body in chamber body in room body in room with separation 5 1 15 2 25 3 35 4 Figure 1- The average channel impulse responses comparing the scenarios in the chamber and in the classroom, when the Tx is at level 1 position 2 Measurements when the Rx antenna is on a pole and with different body postures, i.e., standing, sitting, and lying down in the classroom were also taken. The propagation channel of the lying down posture shows more delay (~3 ns) than the others. Small Scale Fading In contrast to narrowband systems, the number of multipath components (MPCs) that fall into each resolvable delay bin is much smaller in UWB systems. Therefore, the central limit theorem is not applicable and the amplitudes do not exhibit a Rayleigh or Rice distributions. Thus the propagation channel near human body in WBANs is very distinct than the ones found in other environments. Figure 12 illustrates that the lognormal distribution excellently fits the measured amplitude of the channel impulse responses. This is validated by the Akaike information criterion (AIC) approach [13], where the weights of the candidate models are computed and compared to each other. These results also show that there is high correlation between the delay bins. Large Scale Fading The path loss in db versus distance for the 1 st set for both cases, with and without separation is plotted in Figure 13. Contrary to the typically exponential path loss, the path loss of the 1 st set can be modeled as directly proportional to d, PL d PL γ d d X d d (2) db ( ) + ( ) +, = σ ; where d is the reference distance = 1 cm, PL is the path loss at the reference distance, γ is the slope in units of db/m,

and X σ is the shadowing (large-scale). The path loss in the case with separation is smaller and has higher slope γ. Probability signal amplitude > abscissa 1.9.8.7.6.5.4.3.2.1 measured log normal fitting Empirical CDF delay bin 5 delay bin 1 delay bin 3 6 5 4 Signal amplitude [db] Figure 12- The amplitude distribution of the delay bins 1, 3, and 5 in the 1 st set (without separation) when the Tx is at level 1, position 1, and the log-normal distribution fitting Path Loss [db] 15 14 13 12 11 1 9 8 7 6 without separation with separation γ = 166.7 γ = 225. 5.1.15.2.25.3.35.4 Distance between Tx and Rx antennas [m] Figure 13- The path loss versus distance for the 1 st set with and without separation Conclusions We conducted a series of UWB WBAN measurements in the frequency range of 3-11 GHz in scenarios that are expected to be found in medical scenarios. The results highlight the importance, for medical applications, to carry out a comprehensive study of the nature of the signal propagation when they take place close the human body. It was found that for certain scenarios the UWB channel characteristics are distinctively different depending on the gender or the medical condition of the subjects. The measurements obtained in this study are used to estimate channel parameters needed to build communication systems for WBAN medical applications. Acknowledgments The authors wish to thank Hanna Saarela, Elina Hoglund, and Hanna Holopainen for their help with our measurement campaign. References [1] State-of-the-Art Telemedicine/Telehealth: An International Perspective. Mary Ann Liebert, Inc., 2 Madison Avenue, Larchmont, NY 1538. [2] Coronel P, Schott W, Schwieger K, Zimmermann E, Zasowski T, Maass H, Oppermann I, Ran M, Chevillat P. Wireless body area and sensor networks. Wireless World Research Forum (WWRF) Briefings 24. [3] Cramer RJ, Scholtz RA, Win MZ. An Evaluation of the Ultra-wideband propagation channel. IEEE Trans. Antennas Propagation 22; 5: 561-57. [4] Gezici S, Sahinoglu Z. Theoretical limits for estimation of vital signal parameters using impulse radio UWB. IEEE Communications Society subject matter experts for publication in the ICC 27 proceedings, 27. [5] Ghassemzadeh SS, Tarokh V. The ultra-wideband indoor path loss model. Tech. Rep. P82.15 2/277r1SG3a, AT&T Labs, Florham Park, NJ, USA (IEEE P82.15 SG3a contribution, June 22). [6] Kannan B. Characterization of UWB Channels: Largescale parameters for indoor and outdoor office environment. IEEE P82.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) (IEEE 82.15-4-383- -4a, July 24). [7] Fort A, Desset C, Ryckaert J, De Doncker P, Van Biesen L, Donnay S. Ultra wide-band body area channel model. IEEE International Conference ICU 25; 4: 284-2844, 16-2 May 25. [8] Alomainy A, Hao Y, Yuan Y, Liu Y. Modelling and characterisation of radio propagation from wireless implants at different frequencies. European Conference on Wireless Technology 26. [9] Zasowski T, Althaus F, Stäger M, Wittneben A, Tröster G. UWB for noninvasive wireless body area networks: channel measurements and results. IEEE Conference on Ultra Wideband Systems and Technologies (UWBST) 23. [1] Fort A, Desset C, Ryckaert J, De Doncker P, Van Biesen L, Wambacq P. Characterization of the ultra wideband body area propagation channel. International Conference ICU 26; 22-27. [11] TimeDomain Corporation, n.d., P21 Integratable Module Data Sheet, 32-95 Rev B, TimeDomain Corporation, Huntsville, AL. [12] Molisch A. Statistical properties of the delay-spread of mobile radio channels with independent Rayleighfading paths. IEEE Trans. Veh. Technol.; 45: Feb. 1996. [13] Schuster UG, Bölcskei H, Durisi G. Ultra-wideband channel modeling on the basis of information-theoretic criteria. Int. Symp. Information Theory (ISIT) 25; 97-11, Sep. 25.