Haptic Invitation of Textures: An Estimation of Human Touch Motions

Similar documents
Visual and Sensory Properties of Textures that Appeal to Human Touch

Texture recognition using force sensitive resistors

Evaluation of Five-finger Haptic Communication with Network Delay

A Pilot Study: Introduction of Time-domain Segment to Intensity-based Perception Model of High-frequency Vibration

Building a Cognitive Model of Tactile Sensations Based on Vibrotactile Stimuli

Expression of 2DOF Fingertip Traction with 1DOF Lateral Skin Stretch

Illusion of Surface Changes induced by Tactile and Visual Touch Feedback

HAND-SHAPED INTERFACE FOR INTUITIVE HUMAN- ROBOT COMMUNICATION THROUGH HAPTIC MEDIA

The Shape-Weight Illusion

Multidimensional Matching of Tactile Sensations of Materials and Vibrotactile Spectra

Tactile Vision Substitution with Tablet and Electro-Tactile Display

Salient features make a search easy

Remote Tactile Transmission with Time Delay for Robotic Master Slave Systems

Tactile Actuators Using SMA Micro-wires and the Generation of Texture Sensation from Images

REBO: A LIFE-LIKE UNIVERSAL REMOTE CONTROL

Haptic Cues: Texture as a Guide for Non-Visual Tangible Interaction.

Hiroyuki Kajimoto Satoshi Saga Masashi Konyo. Editors. Pervasive Haptics. Science, Design, and Application

VIRTUAL FIGURE PRESENTATION USING PRESSURE- SLIPPAGE-GENERATION TACTILE MOUSE

MOBAJES: Multi-user Gesture Interaction System with Wearable Mobile Device

Object Exploration Using a Three-Axis Tactile Sensing Information

2. Introduction to Computer Haptics

Advanced Analytics for Intelligent Society

For the Subjective Evaluation Items of the Pencil Still Drawing Evaluation System

Chapter 2 Introduction to Haptics 2.1 Definition of Haptics

Sensing the Texture of Surfaces by Anthropomorphic Soft Fingertips with Multi-Modal Sensors

The Integument Laboratory

License Plate Localisation based on Morphological Operations

Shape Memory Alloy Actuator Controller Design for Tactile Displays

Frictional Force (32 Points)

From Encoding Sound to Encoding Touch

Response of SAI Afferents May Play a Role in the Perception of Velvet Hand Illusion

The Impact of Unaware Perception on Bodily Interaction in Virtual Reality. Environments. Marcos Hilsenrat, Miriam Reiner

Communication Research Focused on Tactile Quality and Reality

Art of Ancient Times, Studio 1 5

Discrimination of Virtual Haptic Textures Rendered with Different Update Rates

CARBORUNDUM MEZZOTYPE dark field & reductive techniques

FORM ERROR AND HARDNESS PERFORMANCE OF ROCKWELL DIAMOND INDENTERS

A Three-Dimensional Evaluation of Body Representation Change of Human Upper Limb Focused on Sense of Ownership and Sense of Agency

UNIT 3: Textiles and Fabric # Assignment

Research & Advanced Engineering Ford Motor Company Europe

Comparison of Haptic and Non-Speech Audio Feedback

New Developments at ERICHSEN Scratch Testing

Fibratus tactile sensor using reflection image

Proceedings of the 33rd ISR (International Symposium on Robotics) October 7 11,

Techniques for Generating Sudoku Instances

Multisensory Virtual Environment for Supporting Blind Persons' Acquisition of Spatial Cognitive Mapping a Case Study

2B34 DEVELOPMENT OF A HYDRAULIC PARALLEL LINK TYPE OF FORCE DISPLAY

* STATION 1: Guess the Fiber Category *

GRADES K-5. Form Introduce form as an element of design.

E90 Project Proposal. 6 December 2006 Paul Azunre Thomas Murray David Wright

Interactive System for Origami Creation

PUBLICATIONS Journal articles, books, book chapters

Limits of a Distributed Intelligent Networked Device in the Intelligence Space. 1 Brief History of the Intelligent Space

Associated Emotion and its Expression in an Entertainment Robot QRIO

Compressibility and Crushability Reproduction through an Amorphous Haptic Interface

User s Manual SOLDERING STATION

Extraction and Recognition of Text From Digital English Comic Image Using Median Filter

TSA Tissue / Nonwovens Softness Analyzer: a new method to measure the softness of nonwovens and textiles

Haptic presentation of 3D objects in virtual reality for the visually disabled

Sensor system of a small biped entertainment robot

Enduring Understanding Actual texture is the way something feels on the surface. Using different kinds of lines can create different textures.

Haplug: A Haptic Plug for Dynamic VR Interactions

Designing Pseudo-Haptic Feedback Mechanisms for Communicating Weight in Decision Making Tasks

NAVIGATION OF MOBILE ROBOT USING THE PSO PARTICLE SWARM OPTIMIZATION

APPEAL DECISION. Appeal No USA. Tokyo, Japan. Tokyo, Japan. Tokyo, Japan. Tokyo, Japan

Wavelet-based Image Splicing Forgery Detection

Haptic Perception & Human Response to Vibrations

Exploring Texture Pattern Features and Relations to Kansei with 2D FFT - Wallpapers and Dashboard Leather Grain Patterns

Microsoft Scrolling Strip Prototype: Technical Description

An Open Robot Simulator Environment

Selective Stimulation to Skin Receptors by Suction Pressure Control

This is your child s KS3 graphics homework. It will take around an hour and a half in total which breaks down to 15 mins a week for 6 weeks.

A BIOMIMETIC SENSING SKIN: CHARACTERIZATION OF PIEZORESISTIVE FABRIC-BASED ELASTOMERIC SENSORS

ARTS IMPACT ARTS-INFUSED INSTITUTE LESSON PLAN (YR1-TTAL) KINDERGARTEN LESSON THREE: Lines to Touch Artist-Mentor Beverly Harding Buehler

Spatial Low Pass Filters for Pin Actuated Tactile Displays

Evaluation of Visuo-haptic Feedback in a 3D Touch Panel Interface

Differences in Fitts Law Task Performance Based on Environment Scaling

Learning to Detect Doorbell Buttons and Broken Ones on Portable Device by Haptic Exploration In An Unsupervised Way and Real-time.

Blur Estimation for Barcode Recognition in Out-of-Focus Images

Simultaneous presentation of tactile and auditory motion on the abdomen to realize the experience of being cut by a sword

An Efficient Color Image Segmentation using Edge Detection and Thresholding Methods

Collaboration in Multimodal Virtual Environments

This is a postprint of. The influence of material cues on early grasping force. Bergmann Tiest, W.M., Kappers, A.M.L.

Evaluating a Signal Control System Using a Real-time Traffic Simulator Connected to a Traffic Signal Controller

Interactive Simulation: UCF EIN5255. VR Software. Audio Output. Page 4-1

A New Connected-Component Labeling Algorithm

May Edited by: Roemi E. Fernández Héctor Montes

Comparison of ridge- and intensity-based perspiration liveness detection methods in fingerprint scanners

Changes of Impression in the Animation Characters with the Different Color and Thickness in Outlines

INNOVATIONAL FILAMENT

Apparel and Sport Fabric File Fabric Descriptions. Denim: twill weave made of single hard-twisted yarns with colored warp and

Markerless 3D Gesture-based Interaction for Handheld Augmented Reality Interfaces

The Effect of Frequency Shifting on Audio-Tactile Conversion for Enriching Musical Experience

Analysis of Spiral Curves in Traditional Cultures

Assembly Instructions: Kit #5

Muscular Torque Can Explain Biases in Haptic Length Perception: A Model Study on the Radial-Tangential Illusion

Decision Tree Analysis in Game Informatics

SAMPLE ASSESSMENT TASKS MATERIALS DESIGN AND TECHNOLOGY PRELIMINARY UNIT 3 AND UNIT 4

Vibrotactile Apparent Movement by DC Motors and Voice-coil Tactors

Analysis and Synthesis of Latin Dance Using Motion Capture Data

Transcription:

Haptic Invitation of Textures: An Estimation of Human Touch Motions Hikaru Nagano, Shogo Okamoto, and Yoji Yamada Department of Mechanical Science and Engineering, Graduate School of Engineering, Nagoya University, Japan Abstract. Some textures invite human touch motions in daily life, but studies on the methodology of designing such textures have just been initiated [1,2,3]. However, there is still no method of identifying various touch motions invited by these textures. For example, some textures are likely to invite stroking, while others are likely to invite pushing. We developed a Bayesian network model that represents the probabilistic relationships between texture-invited touch motions and properties of textures. We interpreted the constructed model and confirmed that the model is potentially useful for the estimation of human motions. Keywords: Bayesian Network, Stochastic Reasoning. 1 Introduction Some textures appeal to human touch. Examples of such textures are smooth and comfortable surfaces such as silk, elastic sponges, and finely woven cloths. Occasionally, such textures invite human touch; that is, people feel compelled to touch them. These textures are potentially useful for designing products that invite human touch motion and interfaces that stimulate human interest. Nevertheless, such textures and human responses have rarely been investigated. Nagano et al. [1,2], who investigated properties of textures that appeal to human touch, revealed that the linear combination of physical factors of textures described the degrees of haptic invitation with accuracies of 70 80%. Although glossiness and surface shape types strongly affected the haptic invitation, surface colors barely affected them. Klatzky and Peck [3] also investigated relationships between objects properties and their appeal to human touch and reported that simple objects invited human touch rather than complex objects, and that people wanted to touch moderate objects more than rough objects. Based on the continuity of these studies, the methodologies for determining the best combinations of physical factors in terms of appeal to human touch will be established. The results of past studies mentioned above will enable us to design textures and objects that appeal to human touch. However, exactly how people touch these textures is still not known. For example, hard pushing and soft stroking are just two of many touch motions. The touch motion for elastic rubber may be different from that of smooth fur. Some researchers have analyzed hand motions P. Isokoski and J. Springare (Eds.): EuroHaptics 2012, Part I, LNCS 7282, pp. 338 348, 2012. c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2012

Haptic Invitation of Textures: An Estimation of Human Touch Motions 339 of touch. For example, Lederman and Klatzky [4] investigated relationships between hand movements during haptic object exploration and desired properties of objects, such as heaviness and hardness, and Peine et al. [5] analyzed finger motions during surgical palpation. However, touch motions invited by textures have not yet been investigated. If the relationships between touch motions and properties of textures are revealed, we can design not only textures that appeal to human touch but also texture-invited touch motions. For example, we could design textures that are more likely to invite specific touch motions such as stroking or pushing. The objective of this study was to develop a stochastic model that represents the relationships between texture-invited touch motions and properties of textures. We observed such human touch motions through experiments; thereafter, we developed a Bayesian network, which enabled us to estimate the properties of textures from observed touch motions and vice versa. 2 Experiments We conducted two types of experiments. In Experiment 1, participants evaluated textures consecutively using a semantic differential (SD) method. Sensory properties of textures acquired here were used in constructing the stochastic model. In Experiment 2, participants touched textures that had a strong appeal to human touch. Human touch motions were measured using a camera and a six-axis dynamic force sensor. Features of touch motions were also applied to the stochastic model. The details of each experiment are described below: 2.1 Experiment 1: Sensory Properties of Textures Participant Five laboratory students, excluding the authors, approximately twenty years of age participated in Experiment 1. Task: Sensory Evaluation. The participants evaluated the textures using five-point scales in terms of five adjective pairs: rough-smooth, uneven-flat, hard-soft, warm-cold, and sticky-slippery, without touching them. The evaluation sheets provided both English and Japanese terms. As shown in Fig. 1a, a large white plate with an 80 mm 80 mm square window was placed on a texture so that participants could see only the surfaces and not the sides of the samples. The participants were instructed to keep their head positions fixed in order to retain the relative position between the head and textures. The textures and adjective pairs were presented to each participant in random order. Stimuli. Preliminary experiments were conducted in order to measure the degrees of affinity for various textures. For details of measurement method of degrees, refer to our articles [1,2]. The textures whose degrees of haptic invitation varied significantly depending on individuals were eliminated through experiments. This process led to the final thirty textures used in Experiments 1 and 2.

340 H. Nagano, S. Okamoto, and Y. Yamada a) Sample displayed in Experiment 1 White plastic plate 80 mm 80 mm b) Samples displayed in Experiment 2 White plastic plate Side view Sample texture 90 mm 80 mm 20 mm 80 mm Fig. 1. Sample textures and presentation method Table 1. List of textures Group Texture Group Texture Group Texture Crumpled paper Fake alligator hide Fine woven cotton Cloth Fine Japanese paper Leather Fake suede 1 Coarse woven cotton Coarse Japanese paper Fake suede 2 Towel Towel Paper Embossed paper 1 Long hair fake fur Felt Felt Embossed paper 2 Fur Short hair fake fur Boa Fake boa Fake paper Soft fake fur Artificial grass Artificial grass Wall paper Fine woven straw Metal Woven wire mesh Straw and Walnut wood Coarse woven straw Fiber Coarse polyester fiber rush grass Cypress wood Woven rush grass Wood Chestnut wood Soft sponge Sponge Cork board Hard sponge These textures, which are listed in Table 1 and shown in Fig. 2, include a fake fur with long hair and a flat Japanese paper. The textures were 90 mm 90 mm squares. Flexible textures, such as cloths, were attached to a plastic plate with double-sided tape. Analysis: Adjective Ratings for Thirty Textures. Ratings of 1 to 5 were assigned to the five-point adjective scales measured in Experiment 1. The rating of each adjective pair was normalized within a single participant to reduce the influence of individual differences in criteria for judgment. Ratings were then averaged across all the participants. 2.2 Experiment 2: Observation of Touch Motions to Textures Participant. Another five laboratory students, excluding the authors, aged approximatelytwentyyears,participated in Experiment 2.

Haptic Invitation of Textures: An Estimation of Human Touch Motions Crumpled paper Fake paper Fine Coarse Japanese paper Japanese paper Wall paper Walnut wood Embossed paper 1 Cork board Fake alligator hide Fake suede 1 Fake suede 2 Fine woven straw Coarse woven straw Short hair fake fur Soft fake fur Soft sponge Hard sponge Felt Fake boa Fine woven cotton Artificial grass Embossed paper 2 Cypress wood Chestnut wood Coarse woven cotton Woven wire mesh Fig. 2. Thirty textures used in experiments Long hair fake fur Woven rush grass Towel Coarse polyester fiber 341

342 H. Nagano, S. Okamoto, and Y. Yamada Camera Z X Metal plate Side View Texture White plastic plate Marker Y Z Textures X Six-axis dynamic force sensor Fig. 3. Measurement of touch motions to textures Task. In Experiment 2, participants touched one texture among three textures that most strongly appealed to them. These textures were placed under the white plastic plate, as shown in Fig. 1b. If only one texture was shown in the experiments, participants were forced to touch the texture. In order to avoid this unnatural situation, three textures were shown to the participants. Participants were instructed to keep their eyes closed until they heard a beep sound, and then they were free to touch one of three textures. Stimuli. Three textures were selected through preliminary experiments that were described in Sec. 2.1. The preliminary experiments revealed the ranking of thirty textures in terms of measured degrees of haptic invitation. One of the three textures was selected from ten textures that exhibited the highest degrees of haptic invitation. Another texture was selected from the lowest ten textures, and the last was selected from the remaining ten textures. In total, ten combinations were presented to each participant in random order. Each texture was used only once, and each participant received a unique set of combinations. Measurement Method for Touch Motions. Human touch motions to textures were measured in Experiment 2. Tip positions of the index finger were measured using a camera (Playstation Eye, Sony co., Tokyo, Japan), as depicted in Fig. 3. The position was detected using a red marker fixed on the nail of the index finger. The camera resolution was 320 240 pix, which corresponded to a position resolution of 1.03 mm, and the frame rate was 30 fps. Contact forces were measured by a six-axis dynamic force sensor (MINI 2/10, BL AUTOTEC. LTD., Kobe, Japan), as shown in Fig. 3. The sensor was fixed under a metal plate on which textures were placed. Contact force was recorded at a sampling frequency of 50 Hz.

Haptic Invitation of Textures: An Estimation of Human Touch Motions 343 3 Construction of Bayesian Network Model In order to estimate touch motions from the properties of textures, we constructed a model that represents relationships among them. Considering that a certain texture frequently invites stroking while another may not, the probabilistic relationships are appropriate for representing connections. In addition, the causal connections are not previously established in relationships. Therefore, we adopted a Bayesian network to represent relationships between human touch motions and sensory properties of textures. Bayesian networks enable us to estimate unobserved states of variables using observed variables. In our case, we estimated properties of textures that are likely to invite specific touch motions. First, we extracted feature variables that constituted a network from sensory properties of textures and measured touch motions. Second, a Bayesian network model was constructed using these variables as nodes. Finally, the constructed model was interpreted. 3.1 Feature Extraction The feature variables that became nodes of the Bayesian network are described, and all nodes were discrete variables. Material Type. Thirty textures were classified into thirteen groups on the basis of their materials, as shown in Table 1. As a result, the node representing material types was quantized into thirteen levels in the following manner: Material Type: Paper, wood, leather, fur, straw and rush grass, sponge, cloth, towel, felt, boa, artificial grass, metal, or fiber. Sensory Properties of Textures. We produced five nodes on the basis of adjective ratings rough-smooth, uneven-flat, hard-soft, warm-cold, and sticky-slippery, which were acquired in Experiment 1. These ratings were quantized into two levels across their averages. For example, the standardized roughsmooth rating of short-hair fake fur was -1.8 (+: rough; -: smooth), which was lower than the average 0. Therefore, the Micro Roughness node of short-hair fake fur was labeled smooth. On the other hand, the standardized hard-soft rating of walnut wood was 1.3 (+: hard; -: soft), which was higher than the average 0. Thus, the Hardness node of walnut wood was assigned the hard label. The five adjective ratings were quantized in the following manner: Macro Roughness: Flat or bulky Micro Roughness: Smooth or rough Hardness: Soft or hard Warmness: Cold or warm Friction: Sticky or slippery

344 H. Nagano, S. Okamoto, and Y. Yamada AT: Arrival Time CT: Contact Time a) An example of Z-axial force (One touch mode) AT: Arrival Time CT: Contact Time Stroking Pushing b) An example of Z-axial force (Two touch modes) FF: Frequency of Fz c) An example of force spectra Fig. 4. Examples of Z-axial force and force spectra Properties of Touch Motions. Human touch motions were measured using the camera and force sensor. From measured data, we produced eight feature variables. The ratings of each feature variable were normalized within a single participant and were then averaged across all participants. All nodes were discretized into two qualitative states across each average. Two examples of Z-axial force and an example of force spectra are presented in Figs. 4a, b, and c, respectively. An example of distribution of fingertip position in a two-dimensional space (X-Y space) is depicted in Fig. 5. The following nodes were extracted from these force and position data: Arrival Time: Short or long

Haptic Invitation of Textures: An Estimation of Human Touch Motions 345 MD: Movement Distance Fig. 5. An example of distribution of finger position As depicted in Fig. 4a, the Arrival Time node was determined from a period between the starting time of the experiment (t = 0) at which a sound cue was presented to participants and the time at which the force signal began changing. The Arrival Time node was quantized into two levels across its average of normalized values 0. For example, the normalized value of Arrival Time for coarse Japanese paper was 2.0 (+: long; -: short), which was higher than zero. Therefore, the Arrival Time node of coarse Japanese paper was assigned the long label. Contact Time: Short or long As depicted in Fig. 4a, the Contact Time node was determined as the period during which the texture was touched. The time was quantized into two levels: long and short. For example, for cypress wood, the standardized contact time of -1.2 (+:long; -:short) was assigned the short label. Average Z-axial Force: Weak or strong The Average Z-axial Force node was determined from the average Z-axial force while in contact with the textures. Maximum Z-axial Force: Weak or strong The maximum Z-axial force during contact determined the Maximum Z-axial Force node. Frequency of Z-axial Force: Low or high The Frequency of Z-axial Force node was determined from a peak frequency of force spectra, as depicted in Fig. 4c. Movement Distance: Short or long As depicted in Fig. 5, we produced a minimum rectangle area surrounding a distribution of the fingertip position. The Movement Distance node was determined from a diagonal of the area.

346 H. Nagano, S. Okamoto, and Y. Yamada Average Hand Velocity: Slow or fast We calculated fingertip velocities from time series data of the fingertip position. The Average Hand Velocity node was determined from the average fingertip velocity while in contact with the textures. Maximum Hand Velocity: Slow or fast The maximum fingertip velocity while in contact with each texture determined the Maximum Hand Velocity node. Mode of Touching Textures Touch Mode: Soft touch, stroke, push, or scrub We produced the Touch Mode node in order to quantize the modes of touch into four levels. This node was determined from combinations of the Maximum Z-axial Force and Movement Distance nodes. If the Maximum Z-axial Force node was strong and the Movement Distance node was long, we determined that the Touch Mode node was scrub. Similarly, we determined three modes of touching: push (Maximum Z-axial Force: strong, Movement Distance: short), stroke (Maximum Z-axial Force: weak,movement Distance: long), and soft touch (Maximum Z-axial Force: weak, Movement Distance: short). Change in Touch Mode: Not changed or changed As depicted in Fig. 4b, the touch mode changed during exploration for some textures andparticipants. We produced thechange in Touch Mode node in order to differentiate examples in which a touch mode changed from those in which the mode did not change. This node was quantized into two levels by the majority mode. 3.2 Structure Learning We developed a Bayesian network model using the measured data in Experiments 1 and 2. For learning the network model, K2 algorithm and Bayesian information criteria were used. The constructed network is presented in Fig. 6. 3.3 Interpretation of Structure We briefly interpreted the constructed network on the basis of some examples. The network that obtained the evidence of stroke touch mode estimated the probability of the Friction node. The probability of the Friction node being slippery was 0.75. The examples of corresponding textures are the short-hair fake fur and felt, which are likely to invite the stroking motion with weak Maximum Z-axial Force and long Movement Distance. The network that obtained the Touch Mode node of scrub estimated that the probability of the Micro Roughness being rough was 0.88. The corresponding textures, such as coarse woven straw, are likely to invite the scrubbing motion with strong Maximum Z-axial Force and long Movement Distance.

Haptic Invitation of Textures: An Estimation of Human Touch Motions 347 Material Type Macro Roughness Friction Micro Roughness Hardness Warmness Properties of Textures Arrival Time Movement Distance Maximum Z-axial Force Frequency of Z-axial Force Change in Touch Mode Maximum Hand Velocity Touch Mode Average Hand Velocity Touch Motions Contact Time Average Z-axial Force Fig. 6. Bayesian network model The network that obtained the Frequency of Z-axial Force node of high estimated that the probability of the Macro Roughness being flat was 0.70. The walnut wood and fake suede 1 are examples of corresponding textures, which are likely to invite the high Frequency of Z-axial Force. The network that obtained the Maximum Hand Velocity node of fast estimated that the probability of the Macro Roughness being flat was 0.69. The corresponding textures, such as cypress wood and artificial grass, are likely to invite the fast Maximum Hand Velocity. When the network obtained the Hardness node of soft and the Warmness node of cold, the probability of the Touch Mode being a soft touch mode was estimated to be 0.57. The crumpled paper is an example of a corresponding texture. The above estimations suggested that the network is potentially useful for designing textures that invite specific human touch motions. However, a detailed validation of the networks is the next challenge. In this constructed network, the Material Type node was isolated perhaps because the even textures belonging to the same material category are very different. For example, although the crumpled paper and embossed paper 2 are both in the paper category, their four sensory property nodes excluding the Micro Roughness node were very different. Further, the Contact Time and Average Z- axial Force nodes were not connected with the other nodes. These nodes have the potential to connect with the nodes we did not use in this study. 4 Conclusion We investigated the stochastic relationships between touch motions and the properties of thirty textures that invite human touch. The sensory properties of

348 H. Nagano, S. Okamoto, and Y. Yamada textures were measured through sensory evaluation, and the features of human touch motions were determined from experiments in which participants freely touched the textures they felt compelled to touch. The Bayesian network model was constructed using these features. A brief interpretation suggested that the network is potentially useful for designing textures that invite specific human touch motions, such as a stroke or push. A re-construction of networks with a sufficient number of data and a detailed validation of the networks are the next challenges. References 1. Nagano, H., Okamoto, S., Yamada, Y.: Physical and sensory factors of textures that appeal to human touch. In: Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Human System Interactions, pp. 324 329 (2011) 2. Nagano, H., Okamoto, S., Yamada, Y.: What appeals to human touch? effects of tactual factors and predictability of textures on affinity to textures. In: Proceedings of the IEEE 2011 World Haptics Conference, pp. 203 208 (2011) 3. Klatzky, R.L., Peck, J.: Please touch: Object properties that invite touch. IEEE Transactions on Haptics (to appear, 2012) 4. Lederman, S.J., Klatzky, R.L.: Hand movements: A window into haptic object recognition. Cognitive Psychology 19, 342 368 (1987) 5. Peine, W.J., Wellman, P.S., Howe, R.D.: Temporal bandwidth requirements for tactile shape displays. In: Proceedings of the IMECE Haptics Symposium, pp. 107 113 (1997)