AENSI Journals Journal of Applied Science and Agriculture ISSN 1816-9112 Journal home page www.aensiweb.com/jasa Effect of Chipboard Screw Sizes to the Presence of Failure by using Different Screw Insertion Techniques 1,2 Falah Abu and 1,2 Mansur Ahmad 1 Faculty of Applied Sciences, Universiti Teknologi MARA, 40450 Shah Alam, Selangor, Malaysia. 2 Core of Frontier Materials and Industry Applications, Universiti Teknologi MARA, 40450 Shah Alam, Selangor, Malaysia. A R T I C L E I N F O Article history Received 25 June 2014 Received in revised form 8 July 2014 Accepted 10 August May 2014 Available online 30 August 2014 Keywords Particleboard, Failure Modes Chipboard Screw A B S T R A C T Background Jointing of wood based product made from particleboard could be a drawback if it was not done properly. The common 4M chipboard screw tends to damage the particleboard surface. Therefore, suitable chipboard screw replacement and reliable screw insertion technique required in order to reduce number of damages. Objective The objective of this study is to determine the correct match of screw size when using different screw insertion technique. Results 3.5M chipboard screw has a less number of damage presence compared to common chipboard screw when using self-drilling insertion technique. Installer who is preferred to use self-drilling insertion technique can utilize this small chipboard screw to minimize the probability of damage occurred. Application of pilot-hole during screw fixing is suitable for all three types of chipboard screw. There is no significant difference on number of failure presence when using this technique. However, additional application of countersunk is a drawback for both 3.5M and 4M common chipboard screw. Only 5M chipboard screw provides a minor number of failures occur due to large screw head diameter. Conclusion In conclusion, different size of screw should be used when implementing different type of screw insertion technique. 2014 AENSI Publisher All rights reserved. To Cite This Article Falah Abu and Mansur Ahmad., Effect of Chipboard Screw Sizes to the Presence of Failure by using Different Screw Insertion Techniques. J. Appl. Sci. & Agric., 9(11) 33-37, 2014 INTRODUCTION Particleboard is used in mass production especially for wood product (Ericsson, 1992). Jointing wood products should be done with caution, in order to get the correct screw holding strength and to avoid the particleboard surface damages. However, damage occurrence on the particleboard surface cannot be denied (Abu, 2011). Identifying the damage presence (Abu, 2012) during screw insertion technique could help consumer or manufacturer to determine the screw withdrawal strength of the products. There are many ways to assemble wood products made from particleboard panel. Installer (the person who jointing the particleboard panel) can used dowel, screw fastener or any other techniques to attached the compartment. Preferable jointing practice by installer is screw fastener. It is because screw fastener is more reliable (Eckelman, 1974). In order to minimize possibility of damaging the particleboard surface, installer should take into account matching the correct screw sizes with the screw insertion technique. There is tendency of improper installed screw to protrude out or chip-off (Abu, 2013). Three different screw and screw insertion technique were applied. This study was done to determine the correct match of screw sizes using different screw insertion technique in reducing number of damages. MATERIALS AND METHODS An observation of screw fixing on the particleboard surface was carried out. The chipboard screw was inserted at the middle of the face surfaces of the particleboard sample. The particleboard used for the testing was P2 type, 16mm in thickness and 700±kg/m³ (BS EN 3122003). The particleboard sample is 50mm x 50mm in length and width respectively. Three screw insertion technique tested is self-drilling screw insertion technique, pilot-hole screw insertion technique and pilot-hole with countersunk (P+CSK) screw insertion technique. Any failure spots during screw fixing activities were recorded based on failure pattern studied by Abu (2012). The screw insertion technique is distinguish on application of pilot-hole and countersunk. The step of predrilling pilot-hole during screw fixing is necessary. However, most installer skips this step by directly inserting the screw without pre-drilling (make a pilot-hole). This technique is known as self-drilling screw insertion Corresponding Author Falah bin Abu, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Department of Bio-composite Technology, Faculty of Applied Sciences, UiTM Shah Alam, 40450 Shah Alam, Selangor, Malaysia. Ph (+603-55438443) E-mail falah@salam.uitm.edu.my
34 Falah bin Abu et al, 2014 technique. Installers neglect the application of pilot-hole due to time concern on completing of jointing wood products. The pilot-hole diameter and depth implementing in this study is 3 mm and 16 mm respectively. The pilot-hole diameter was essential in reducing screw-fixing damages. According to Customwood Company (2001), recommended suitable pilot-hole diameter is 2.7mm. Tradesman essential guide magazine (2011) recommended pilot-hole in the range of 2.0mm to 2.6 mm diameter. The feature of the screw is cross recess, type H Phillips (BS ISO 18912009). The chipboard screw was distinguished on its diameter size. One part of small and another one is bigger than common chipboard screw size was used in this study. The smaller chipboard screw was used to reduce the tendency of the particleboard surface to damages (Özçifçi, 2009). Application of larger screw is not allowed to minimize the edge from splitting. Recommended screw diameter should not exceeding 20% of the panel thickness. Figure 1 shows the image of three different chipboard screw used in this study. Table 1 shows the screw specification for these three types of screw. All screw has a different screw and root diameter. The length of the screw should not be exceeding the length of the screw insertion depth (Breyer et al, 2003). 4M common chipboard screw is the common screw used by installer in jointing the kitchen cabinet panel. 4M CS are specifying as 4x30 mm and are name as SF 45. The screw thread diameter is approximately 3.7 mm meanwhile the screw diameter is about 2.2mm. The 3.5M CS is specified as 3.5x30 mm. The screw thread diameter is approximately 3.2 mm meanwhile the screw diameter is about 2.0 mm. The 5M CS are specified as 5x30 mm. The screw thread diameter is approximately 4.6 mm meanwhile the screw diameter is about 2.8mm. Screw Full Image Screw Head Screw End 4M Common Chipboard Screw 3.5M Chipboard Screw 5M Chipboard Screw Fig. 1 Chipboard Screw Image. Table 1 Chipboard Screw Specifications. Screw Type Pilot-hole Pilot-hole Depth Screw Root Thread Depth 4 M Common Chipboard Screw 3 16 3.7 2.2 1.5 3.5 M Chipboard Screw 3 16 3.2 2.2 1.0 5 M Chipboard Screw 3 16 4.6 2.8 1.8 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Table 2 shows screw fixing damages detected on three-difference type of chipboard screw. Over 225 number of sample studied, 43% samples were damages compared to 57% in good condition. The percentage between good and damaged screw were discussed. ANOVA test for self-drilling, pilot-hole and P+CSK insertion technique shows in Figure 2. There is evidence to conclude that at 5% level of significance, the mean of failure occurred is similar for pilot-hole insertion technique (p-value = 0.552 > 0.05). However, the mean of failure occurred is different for self-drilling and P+CSK insertion technique. Both screw insertion technique p- values were below than 0.05 which is 0.034 and 0.000 respectively.
Number of Damages 35 Falah bin Abu et al, 2014 Common 4M chipboard screw shows a moderate number of damages in all insertion technique. 5M CS were damaged more by 47% while 3.5M CS showed few damages by 22% compared to common chipboard screw. The result was contrast in both pilot-hole and P+CSK insertion technique. 3.5M CS showed highest damages for both pilot-hole and P+CSK insertion technique by 43% and 51% respectively. The lowest damages for pilot-hole and P+CSK insertion technique is 5M CS. The screw was damaged by 21% and 4% respectively. Number of damages for self-drilling insertion technique is contrast with pilot-hole and P+CSK insertion technique. Self-drilling insertion technique shows that number of damages will increase parallel with increasing chipboard screw diameter. It means that smaller diameter of chipboard screw is better. It will reduce the particleboard fiber from swelling, protruding and damaged fiber bonding at the particleboard wide surface. However, the trend for pilot-hole and P+CSK insertion technique is decreasing downward. It is probably because of the factor of pilot-hole pre-drilling. The pilot-hole pre-drilling shows it is a reliable technique to be applied in order to reduce number of damages. Where; 3.5M Chipboard Screw 4M Chipboard Screw 5M Chipboard Screw Self-drilling Pilot-hole P+CSK Screw Insertion Technique Fig. 2 Screw Fixing Damages in Three-Difference Chipboard Screw. Table 2 ANOVA and DMRT of Screw Fixing Damages in Three-Difference Chipboard Screw. Analysis of Various Screw Self-Drilling Pilot-Hole P+CSK Lowest 3.5M CS 5M CS 5M CS Highest 5M CS 3.5M CS 3.5M CS ANOVA Sig. Diff SIMILAR Sig. Diff Good 3.5M CS All 5M CS Bad 5M CS None 4M CS / 3.5M CS ANOVA 3.5M CS A 5M CS A 5M CS A 4M CS AB 4M CS A 4M CS B 5M CS B 3.5M CS A 3.5M CS B From the screw fixing observation, all damages were segregate based on failure pattern (Abu, 2012). Failure Mode 1, Mode 3 and Mode 4 did not occur. Mode 6 is the highest percentage of failure observed at 41.3%. The lowest percentage of failure mode was Mode 2 and Mode 5 observed at 0.9% respectively. Table 3 shows the highest percentage of damages for all three-screw insertion technique. Each insertion technique has different number of failure mode observed. Figure 3 to Figure 5 shows the graph of six types failure modes when using self-drilling, pilot-hole and P+CSK insertion technique. Failure Mode 6 is the highest failure type for all screw insertion technique. There was no failure occur in Mode 1, Mode 3 and Mode 4 for self-drilling insertion technique. There are only failure occur in Mode 6 for pilot-hole and P+CSK insertion technique. Self-drilling insertion technique causes variety of damages pattern compared with other two-insertion technique. It is because the presence of lamination on the particleboard wide surface. It is contrast with pilothole and P+CSK insertion technique. Both insertion technique damages are Mode 6. This failure mode happened due to the over screw or bigger countersunk. The pilot-hole and P+CSK insertion technique requires pilot-hole pre-drilling for screw fixing. The pilot-hole pre-drill prove that the clearance hole applied can reduce the stress at the particleboard wide surface. Table 3 Statistic Percentage of Chipboard Screw Failure Mode. Analysis of Various Screw Self-Drilling Pilot-Hole P+CSK Highest No. of Damages 5M CS 3.5M CS 3.5M CS Percentages (%) 43 51 47 Type of FM FM 2,5,6 FM 6 FM 6 Highest FM 6 FM 6 FM 6 None FM 1,3,4 FM 1,2,3,4,5 FM 1,2,3,4,5
Number of Damages Number of Damages Number of Damages 36 Falah bin Abu et al, 2014 Where 3.5M CS 4M CS 5M CS Fig. 3 Chipboard Screw Failure Mode Self-Drilling Insertion Technique. Where 3.5M CS 4M CS 5M CS Fig. 4 Chipboard Screw Failure Mode Pilot-Hole Insertion Technique. Where 3.5M CS 4M CS 5M CS Fig. 5 Chipboard Screw Failure Mode P+CSK Insertion Technique. 3.Conclusions This study was done in order to determine the effect of chipboard screw size and screw insertion technique to the number of failure and type of failure mode. In conclusion, both alternative chipboard screws were much
37 Falah bin Abu et al, 2014 better in reducing number of damages. Smaller diameter chipboard screw was excellence when applied with self-drilling insertion technique. However, it was worst in pilot-hole and P+CSK insertion technique. It is probably due to pilot-hole pre-drilling diameter that is standardized to be used with 4M common chipboard screw. The grip between screw thread and particleboard fiber during the screw fixing will be loosen. Therefore, 3.5M chipboard screw is suitable to be used in kitchen cabinet installation because it is much better compared with common chipboard screw. This screw is also much cheaper compared to thicker chipboard screw. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The authors would like to thanks Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM) Shah Alam and Research Management Institute (RMI) for sponsoring and funding the project under Research Intensive Faculty (RIF) grants. REFERENCES Abu, F. and M. Ahmad, 2011. Physical Properties of Particleboard Exposed to the Kitchen Environment in Selected Areas of Kuala Lumpur and Selangor, IEEE Symposium on Business, Engineering and Applications (ISBEIA), 978-1-4577-1549-5 pp 204-207. Abu, F. and M. Ahmad, 2011. Screw Fixing Damages and Screw-holding Performance in Particleboard Exposed to the Kitchen Environment in the Selected Area of Kuala Lumpur and Selangor,3rd International Symposium & Exhibition in Sustainable Energy & Environment (ISESEE), 978-1-4577-0340-9 pp 227-232. Abu, F. and M. Ahmad, 2012. Assessment on Screw Fixing Failure Mode for Kitchen Cabinet Particleboard, Advanced Materials Research Vols. 463-464 pp 577-581. Abu, F. and M. Ahmad, 2013. Assessment in Screw Fixing Damages of Particleboard Surface Difference in Screw Head and Self-drilling Features, Advanced Materials Research, 748 331-335. Breyer, D.E., K.J. Fridley, D.G. Pollock, K.E. Cobeen, 2003. Design of wood structures ASD, United States of America. Customwood- Handling and installation, Retrieve on March 29, 2011 form http//www.daiken-nz.com/ Eckelman, C.A., 1974. Which screw holds best? Furniture design and manufacturing, 46(9) 184-200. Ericsson, B., 1992. Architecture in wood, Architecture, FORLAG AB, Stockholm. Özçifçi, A., 2009. The effects of pilot hole, screw types and layer thickness on the withdrawal strength of screw in laminated veneer lumber, Materials and Design, 30 2355-2358. The European Standard, BS EN 3122003, Particleboard - Specifications. The European Standard, BS ISO 18912009, Fasteners - Terminology. The laminex group, 2001, Particleboard- the tradesman s essential guide.