Automatic Classification of Power Quality disturbances Using S-transform and MLP neural network

Similar documents
Characterization and Localization of Power Quality disturbances Based on S-transform and Fuzzy Expert System

Power Quality Disturbances Classification and Recognition Using S-transform Based Neural classifier

ELECTRIC POWER QUALITY EVENTS DETECTION AND CLASSIFICATION USING HILBERT TRANSFORM AND MLP NETWORK

Detection and Identification of PQ Disturbances Using S-Transform and Artificial Intelligent Technique

CLASSIFICATION OF POWER QUALITY DISTURBANCES USING WAVELET TRANSFORM AND S-TRANSFORM BASED ARTIFICIAL NEURAL NETWORK

Three Phase Power Quality Disturbance Classification Using S-transform

Application of Hilbert-Huang Transform in the Field of Power Quality Events Analysis Manish Kumar Saini 1 and Komal Dhamija 2 1,2

Assessment of Power Quality Events by Empirical Mode Decomposition based Neural Network

280 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 23, NO. 1, JANUARY 2008

Wavelet Transform for Classification of Voltage Sag Causes using Probabilistic Neural Network

New Windowing Technique Detection of Sags and Swells Based on Continuous S-Transform (CST)

Detection, localization, and classification of power quality disturbances using discrete wavelet transform technique

Analysis of Power Quality Disturbances using DWT and Artificial Neural Networks

Wavelet and S-transform Based Multilayer and Modular Neural Networks for Classification of Power Quality Disturbances

DETECTION AND CLASSIFICATION OF POWER QUALITY DISTURBANCE WAVEFORM USING MRA BASED MODIFIED WAVELET TRANSFROM AND NEURAL NETWORKS

Selection of Mother Wavelet for Processing of Power Quality Disturbance Signals using Energy for Wavelet Packet Decomposition

Volume 3, Number 2, 2017 Pages Jordan Journal of Electrical Engineering ISSN (Print): , ISSN (Online):

Classification of Power Quality Disturbances using Features of Signals

Keywords: Power System Computer Aided Design, Discrete Wavelet Transform, Artificial Neural Network, Multi- Resolution Analysis.

Wavelet Transform Based Islanding Characterization Method for Distributed Generation

Power Quality Monitoring of a Power System using Wavelet Transform

Detection and Localization of Power Quality Disturbances Using Space Vector Wavelet Transform: A New Three Phase Approach

Classification of Signals with Voltage Disturbance by Means of Wavelet Transform and Intelligent Computational Techniques.

Real Time Detection and Classification of Single and Multiple Power Quality Disturbance Based on Embedded S- Transform Algorithm in Labview

Time-Frequency Analysis of Non-Stationary Waveforms in Power-Quality via Synchrosqueezing Transform

IDENTIFICATION OF POWER QUALITY PROBLEMS IN IEEE BUS SYSTEM BY USING NEURAL NETWORKS

Dwt-Ann Approach to Classify Power Quality Disturbances

Detection of Power Quality Disturbances using Wavelet Transform

Characterization of Voltage Sag due to Faults and Induction Motor Starting

Detection and Classification of Power Quality Event using Discrete Wavelet Transform and Support Vector Machine

Current Harmonic Estimation in Power Transmission Lines Using Multi-layer Perceptron Learning Strategies

Development of Mathematical Models for Various PQ Signals and Its Validation for Power Quality Analysis

MULTIFUNCTION POWER QUALITY MONITORING SYSTEM

CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION

POWER QUALITY DISTURBANCE ANALYSIS USING S-TRANSFORM AND DATA MINING BASED CLASSIFIER

ASSESSMENT OF POWER QUALITY EVENTS BY HILBERT TRANSFORM BASED NEURAL NETWORK. Shyama Sundar Padhi

Pattern Recognition Techniques Applied to Electric Power Signal Processing Ghazi Bousaleh, Mohamad Darwiche, Fahed Hassoun

DETECTION AND CLASSIFICATION OF POWER QUALITY DISTURBANCES

Alexandre A. Carniato, Ruben B. Godoy, João Onofre P. Pinto

A Novel Software Implementation Concept for Power Quality Study

Power Quality Disturbaces Clasification And Automatic Detection Using Wavelet And ANN Techniques

1. INTRODUCTION. (1.b) 2. DISCRETE WAVELET TRANSFORM

Rule-Based Expert System for PQ Disburbances Classification Using S-Transform and Support Vector Machines

Analysis of non-stationary power quality waveforms using iterative empirical mode decomposition methods and SAX algorithm

SIGNAL PROCESSING OF POWER QUALITY DISTURBANCES

CHAPTER 6 BACK PROPAGATED ARTIFICIAL NEURAL NETWORK TRAINED ARHF

TRANSIENT STABILITY ENHANCEMENT OF POWER SYSTEM USING INTELLIGENT TECHNIQUE

DSP-FPGA Based Real-Time Power Quality Disturbances Classifier J.BALAJI 1, DR.B.VENKATA PRASANTH 2

A Novel Detection and Classification Algorithm for Power Quality Disturbances using Wavelets

Decriminition between Magnetising Inrush from Interturn Fault Current in Transformer: Hilbert Transform Approach

Experimental Investigation of Power Quality Disturbances Associated with Grid Integrated Wind Energy System

Power Quality Analysis Using Modified S-Transform on ARM Processor

Power Quality Disturbance Detection and Visualization Utilizing Image Processing Methods

Techniques used for Detection of Power Quality Events a Comparative Study C. Venkatesh, Student Member, IEEE, D.V.S.S. Siva Sarma, Senior Member, IEEE

AUTOMATED CLASSIFICATION OF POWER QUALITY DISTURBANCES USING SIGNAL PROCESSING TECHNIQUES AND NEURAL NETWORKS

Generation of Mathematical Models for various PQ Signals using MATLAB

Power Quality Disturbance Detection and Classification using Artificial Neural Network based Wavelet

Recognition of Multiple PQ Issues using Modified EMD and Neural Network Classifier

MITIGATION OF POWER QUALITY DISTURBANCES USING DISCRETE WAVELET TRANSFORMS AND ACTIVE POWER FILTERS

Application of Classifier Integration Model to Disturbance Classification in Electric Signals

A Novel Fuzzy Neural Network Based Distance Relaying Scheme

Characterization of Voltage Dips due to Faults and Induction Motor Starting

By Shilpa R & Dr. P S Puttaswamy Vidya Vardhaka College of Engineering, India

Chapter 3 Spectral Analysis using Pattern Classification

Wavelet, Kalman Filter and Fuzzy-Expert Combined System for Classifying Power System Disturbances

A FUZZY EXPERT SYSTEM FOR QUANTIFYING VOLTAGE QUALITY IN ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

A DWT Approach for Detection and Classification of Transmission Line Faults

Research Article International Journal of Emerging Research in Management &Technology ISSN: (Volume-6, Issue-6)

Time-Frequency Analysis Method in the Transient Power Quality Disturbance Analysis Application

A Single Monitor Method for Voltage Sag Source Location using Hilbert Huang Transform

Keywords: Wavelet packet transform (WPT), Differential Protection, Inrush current, CT saturation.

ISSN: [Taywade* et al., 5(12): December, 2016] Impact Factor: 4.116

Application of wavelet transform to power quality (PQ) disturbance analysis

Wavelet based Power Quality Monitoring in Grid Connected Wind Energy Conversion System

FPGA Based Power Disturbances

AN ALGORITHM TO CHARACTERISE VOLTAGE SAG WITH WAVELET TRANSFORM USING

Ensemble Empirical Mode Decomposition: An adaptive method for noise reduction

[Nayak, 3(2): February, 2014] ISSN: Impact Factor: 1.852

Classification of Voltage Sag Using Multi-resolution Analysis and Support Vector Machine

A Fast and Accurate Fault Detection Approach in Power Transmission Lines by Modular Neural Network and Discrete Wavelet Transform

EEE508 GÜÇ SİSTEMLERİNDE SİNYAL İŞLEME

Measurement of Power Quality through Transformed Variables

Roberto Togneri (Signal Processing and Recognition Lab)

Time- Frequency Techniques for Fault Identification of Induction Motor

VIRTUAL INSTRUMENT FOR POWER QUALITY ASSESSMENT

Automatic Detection and Positioning of Power Quallity Disturbances using a Discrete Wavelet Transform

Long Range Acoustic Classification

Detection and classification of faults on 220 KV transmission line using wavelet transform and neural network

Detection and characterization of amplitude defects using Spectral Kurtosis

Data Compression of Power Quality Events Using the Slantlet Transform

CHAPTER 4 PV-UPQC BASED HARMONICS REDUCTION IN POWER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

Artificial Neural Networks approach to the voltage sag classification

Comparison of MLP and RBF neural networks for Prediction of ECG Signals

Adaptive Multi-layer Neural Network Receiver Architectures for Pattern Classification of Respective Wavelet Images

Measurement of power quality disturbances

Power quality event classification: an overview and key issues

Identification of Power Quality Issues using Kalman Filter

An Enhanced Symmetrical Fault Detection during Power Swing/Angular Instability using Park s Transformation

Review of Signal Processing Techniques for Detection of Power Quality Events

FAULT DETECTION AND CLASSIFICATION FOR ONLINE DETECTION IN DISTRIBUTED ELECTRICAL SYSTEM

Transcription:

I J C T A, 8(4), 2015, pp. 1337-1350 International Science Press Automatic Classification of Power Quality disturbances Using S-transform and MLP neural network P. Kalyana Sundaram* & R. Neela** Abstract: The paper presents an S-Transform based multilayer perceptron neural network (MLP) classifier for the identification of power quality (PQ) disturbances.the proposed method is used to extract the three input features (Standard deviation, peak value and variances) from the distorted voltage waveforms simulated using parametric equations. The features extracted through S-transform are trained by a MLP neural network for the automatic classification of PQ disturbances. MLP neural classifier has been implemented and tested for nine types of power quality disturbances. The results clearly show that the proposed method has the ability to identify and characterize PQ disturbances. The performance of the proposed technique is compared with the kalman based MLP neural network. Keywords: Power quality, Power quality disturbances, S-transform, Neural classifier, MLP neural network. Nomenclature h(t) Real signal S(t, f) Stransform f frequency t time WT(t, f) Continous wavelet transform e j2f Phase factor time variable d differential time variable W* Complex conjugate of wavelet transform W(v, f) Time frequency resolution of wavelet transform 1. INTRODUCTION In the recent years, power quality has become an important issue in the electric power system. There are various types of power quality issues in the transmission and distribution lines such as sag, swell, interruption, harmonics, sag with harmonics, swell with harmonics, flicker and notches. In order to improve power quality, the sources and causes of such disturbances must be known before the appropriate mitigating actions can be taken. The various types of power quality disturbances were detected and classified using wavelet transform analysis as illustrated in [1]. The time and frequency of multi resolution wavelet has been presented in [2] to analyze the electromagnetic * Assistant Professor, Electrical Engineering, Annamalai University ** Professor, Electrical Engineering, Annamalai University

1338 P. Kalyana Sundaram & R. Neela power system transients. Analysis of the power quality transient signals using wavelet transform has been illustrated in [3]. The short time Fourier transforms (STFT) based power frequency harmonic analyzer has been discussed in [4] for the non stationary signals. The windowed FFT which is the time windowed version of discrete Fourier transform has been applied for power quality analysis to classify a variety of disturbances in [5]. Wavelet transform along with multi-resolution signal decomposition for the classification of power quality disturbances in [6]. A combination of Fourier and wavelet transform along with fuzzy expert system has been presented in [7] for the automatic monitoring and analysis of power quality disturbances. Wavelet multi resolution analysis based neural network classifier is presented in [8] for the detection and extraction of power quality disturbances. An automated online power quality disturbances classification using wavelet based pattern recognition technique has been illustrated in [9]. Discrete STFT along with wavelet transform for the analysis of power quality disturbances in [10].The detection, localization and classification of power quality disturbances are based on S-transform and compared with wavelet multi resolution analysis has been presented in [11]. Multi resolution S-transform along with fuzzy system was discussed for the classification of power quality classification in [12]. A two dimensional representation of analyzing the various types of power quality disturbances using DWT decomposition technique has been implemented in [13]. A combination of DSP hardware system along with kalman filter for the real time detection and analysis of the power quality disturbances has been illustrated in [14]. The classification of the power quality disturbances in both single and multiple natures using S-transform and Pattern recognition techniques has been implemented in [15]. The S-transform extract important information from a disturbance signal and trained by PNN to determine the type of disturbance that caused power quality (PQ) problem to occur has been presented in [16]. An S-transform based fuzzy and Particle swarm optimization has been presented in [17] and this combines to identify the time series PQ disturbance data and also classified it. A rule based technique along with S-transform has been discussed in [18] which diagnosis the Power quality disturbance in the time-frequency nature. Probabilistic neural network method based on optimal feature selection for power quality event classification has been illustrated in [19]. The windowed Hilbert huang transform (HHT) used to analyze the non-stationary signal in power quality analysis has been discussed in [20]. An S-transform based MLP neural network classifier for analysis of power quality disturbances in which the features are extracted using S-transform and disturbances are classified using an MLP based neural network is presented in this paper. 2. PROPOSED METHOD The proposed method has two stages namely i. Feature extraction using S-transform ii. Classification stage using MLP neural network S-transform is used for extracting features such as peak value, variances and standard deviation. MLP neural network is used for classifying the power quality disturbances. A set of parametric equations generate the disturbance waveforms. 2.1. Feature Extraction Stage using S-transform The S-transform is a generalization of the Short-time Fourier transform (STFT) and an extension of the continuous wavelet transforms (CWT). The S-transform will perform multi-resolution analysis (MRA) on a time varying power signal, as its window width varies inversely with the frequency. The main function of the S-transform is a Gaussian modulation cosinusoid. The output of the S-transform is an N M matrix called the S-matrix whose rows pertain to the frequency and columns to time.

Automatic Classification of Power Quality disturbances Using S-transform 1339 A spectrogram or sonogram is a visual representation of the spectrum of frequencies. Spectrograms are usually created in one of two ways. They are approximated as a filter bank that results from a series of band pass filters, or calculated from the time signal using the short-time Fourier transform (STFT). These two methods actually form two different Time-Frequency Distributions, but are equivalent under some conditions. S-transform using spectrogram analysis provides better visual analyze of the signal. The S-transform of a signal is defined as Where S( t, f ) * h( ) w ( j2 f t, f ), e d (1) f 2 2 tf / 2 S( t, f ), e (2) a 2 The integration of S-transform over time results in the Fourier spectrum is given as H ( f ) S( t, f ) dt (3) For the gaussian window S( t, f ) dt 1 The original signal can be obtained from S-transform as (4) j 2 f h( t) S(, f ) d e df (5) The S-transform is also represent as the amplitude and phase correction of the continuous wavelet transform f j 2 f S( t, f ) e, WT ( t, f ) (6) 2 f 2 2 2 t f / 2 j 2 f Wavelet transform is given as WT ( t, f ), e, e (7) The S-transform is now expressed in time frequency resolution as S( t, f ) * j2 v H ( v, f ) w ( v, f ), e dv (8) w( v, f ) 2 2 2 2 2 v / t e (9) 2.2 Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) Neural Network A multilayer perceptron neural network is a feed-forward artificial neural network that has an input layer, output layer and one or more hidden layers. A MLP based neural network consists of multiple layers of nodes in which each layer connected to the next one fully in a directed graph. Except for the input nodes, each node is a neuron with a nonlinear activation function. MLP based neural network utilizes a supervised learning technique called back propagation for training the network. MLP based neural network architecture diagram is shown as in the figure 1. Further, MLP networks have redundant networking and are very robust, providing a mathematical flexibility. The training parameters and the structure of the MLP used in this work are shown in Table 1.

1340 P. Kalyana Sundaram & R. Neela Figure 1: Architecture of MLP Neural Network Table 1 MLP architecture and training parameters Architecture The number of layers 3 The number of neuron on the layers Input: 13, hidden: 10, output: 9 The initial weights and biases Random Activation functions Tangent sigmoid Training parameters Learning rule Back-propagation Learning rate 0.75 Mean-squared error 1E 08 2.3. Back propagation learning algorithm BP has two phases: Forward pass phase: Computes the functional signal and feed forward propagation of input pattern signals through network. Backward pass phase: Computes the error signal and propagates the error backwards through network starting at output units (The error is the difference between actual and desired output values). 3. CLASSIFICATION STAGE In this stage, features extracted through the S-transform are applied as inputs to the multi-layer perception based neural network in order to classify the disturbances. MLP networks are very useful for the classification of those input signals which cannot be defined mathematically. 3.1. Flowchart of the Proposed Method The flowchart for the Classification of Power Quality disturbances is shown in below. It has three different blocks. Block-(a) Features extraction such as standard deviation, peak value and variances Block-(b) Detection and classification of the power quality disturbances

Automatic Classification of Power Quality disturbances Using S-transform 1341 Figure 2: Flowchart for the Classification of Power Quality disturbances 4. SIMULATION AND TEST RESULTS Training and Test data for various classes of disturbances using a set of parametric equations and this method of data generation offers the advantages such as a wide range of parameters can be generated in a controlled manner. signals closer to real situation can be simulated. 100 cases of each class with different parameters were generated for training and another 100 cases were generated for testing. The feature extraction of these signals has been done by S-transform. Total size of the training data set is 3*900, where 3 represents the number of features extracted for each type of disturbance and 900 represents the total number of samples at the rate of 100 samples for each one of the 9 disturbances. These input signals, when applied to the MLP neural network to get accurate classified disturbances.the various types of power quality disturbances are presented to highlight the suitability of the application of the proposed method. Pure sine wave is the normal voltage signal of at frequency 50 Hz and its waveform is as shown in the figure 3(a).The time frequency analysis of S-transform and spectrogram representation of the pure sine wave are shown in the figures 3(b) and 3(c). The standard deviation, peak value and the variances of the pure sine wave are shown in the figures 3(d) and 3(f).

1342 P. Kalyana Sundaram & R. Neela Figure 3(a) Figure 3(b) Figure 3(c) Figure 3(d) Figure 3(e) Figure 3(f) Voltage sag (or) voltage dips causes the decrease of system voltage and its waveform is as shown in the figure 4(a).The time frequency analysis of S-transform and spectrogram representation of the voltage sag are shown in the figures 4(b) and 4(c). The standard deviation, peak value and the variances of the voltage sag are shown in the figures 4(d) and 4(f). Figure 4(a) Figure 4(b)

Automatic Classification of Power Quality disturbances Using S-transform 1343 Figure 4(c) Figure 4(d) Figure 4(e) Figure 4(f) Voltage swell causes the rise of system voltage and its waveform is as shown in the figure 5(a).The time frequency analysis of S-transform representation and spectrogram of the voltage swell are shown in the figures 5(b) and 5(c). The standard deviation, peak value and the variances of the voltage swell are shown in the figures 5(d) and 5(f). Figure 5(a) Figure 5(b) Figure 5(c) Figure 5(d)

1344 P. Kalyana Sundaram & R. Neela Figure 5(e) Figure 5(f) Outages may be seen as a loss of voltage on the system for the short duration and its waveform is as shown in the figure 6(a). The time frequency analyses of S-transform representation spectrogram and of the voltage swell are shown in the figures 6(b) and 6(c). The standard deviation, peak value and the variances of the voltage swell are shown in the figures 6(d) and 6(f). Figure 6(a) Figure 6(b) Figure 6(c) Figure 6(d) Figure 6(e) Figure 6(f)

Automatic Classification of Power Quality disturbances Using S-transform 1345 Harmonics are generated by the connection of non linear load to the system duration and its waveform is as shown in the figure 7(a). The time frequency analysis of S-transform representation and spectrogram of the harmonics are shown in the figures 7(b) and 7(c). The standard deviation, peak value and variances of harmonics are shown in the figures 7(d) and 7(f). Figure 7(a) Figure 7(b) Figure 7(c) Figure 7(d) Figure 7(e) Figure 7(f) Sag with harmonics is caused by the presence of a nonlinear load and its waveform is as shown in the figure 8(a). The time frequency analysis of S-transform representation and spectrogram of the harmonics are shown in Figure 8(a) Figure 8(b)

1346 P. Kalyana Sundaram & R. Neela Figure 8(c) Figure 8(d) Figure 8(e) Figure 8(f) the figures 8(b) and 8(c). The standard deviation, peak value and the variances of the harmonics are shown in the figures 8(d) and 8(f). Swell with harmonics is caused by the presence of nonlinear load and its waveform is as shown in the figure 9(a). The time frequency analysis of S-transform representation spectrogram and of the swell with harmonics is shown in the figures 9(b) and 9(c). The standard deviation, peak value and the variances of the swell with harmonics are shown in the figures 9(d) and 9(f). Figure 9(a) Figure 9(b) Figure 9(c) Figure 9(d)

Automatic Classification of Power Quality disturbances Using S-transform 1347 Figure 9(e) Figure 9(f) Flicker is caused by the continuous and rapid variation of the system load and its waveform is as shown in the figure 10(a). The time frequency analysis of S-transform representation spectrogram and of the flicker is shown in the figures 10(b) and 10(c). The standard deviation, peak value and the variances of the flicker are shown in the figures 10(d) and 10(f). Figure 10(a) Figure 10(b) Figure 10(c) Figure 10(d) Figure 10(e) Figure 10(f)

1348 P. Kalyana Sundaram & R. Neela Notch is a disturbance of the nominal power voltage waveform lasting for less than half a cycle. The disturbance is initially of opposite polarity and hence it is to be subtracted from the waveform and shown in the figure 11(a). The time frequency analysis of S-transform representation spectrogram and of the notch is shown in the figures 11(b) and 11(c). The standard deviation, peak value and variances of notch are shown in the figure 11(d) and 11(f). Figure 11(a) Figure 11(b) Figure 11(c) Figure 11(d) Figure 11(e) Figure 11(f) Table 3 Classification accuracy Sno PQ Disturbances Percentage of Accuracy Input Kalman filter based S-transform based Features MLP neural network MLP neural network 1 Voltage Sag 100 98 96 2 Voltage Swell 100 98 100 3 Outages 100 92 98 4 Harmonics 100 90 98 5 Sag with Harmonics 100 90 100 6 Swell with Harmonics 100 100 97 7 Flicker 100 100 100 8 Notch 100 98 100 Overall accuracy 95.75 98.63

Automatic Classification of Power Quality disturbances Using S-transform 1349 5. CONCLUSION In this paper, a new technique to detect and classify the various types of Power quality disturbances using S- transform and MLP neural network. The Power quality disturbance waveforms were generated through parametric equations. By using S-Transform the input features such as standard deviation, peak value and variances were extracted and MLP based neural network has been applied for classifying the various PQ disturbances. The classification accuracy has been validated by comparing the results obtained by the proposed technique against kalman based neural classifiers and it has been concluded that the proposed method performs better than those technique. The proposed technique enables the accurate classification of all nine types of PQ disturbances. Simulation results demonstrate that the performance and accuracy of the S-transform. Neural Network is a versatile classifier that can be trained for any input combination and its application makes the suggested technique particularly suitable for classification of disturbances of varying nature. The results show that the proposed technique performs very well in detection and classification of PQ disturbances. References [1] Surya Santoso, Edward J. Powers, and W. Mack Grady, Electric power quality disturbances detection using wavelet transform analysis, IEEE Transaction, 1994. [2] David C. Robertson Octavia I. Camps, Jeffrey S. Mayer, William B. Gish, Wavelet and electromagnetic power system transients, IEEE Transaction on power delivery, Vol. 11, April 1996. [3] G.T. Heydt, A.W. Galli, Transient power quality problem analyzed using wavelets, IEEE Transaction on power delivery, Vol. 12, April 1997. [4] Paul S. Wright, Short time Fourier transforms and wigner-ville distributions applied to the calibration of power frequency harmonic analyzers, IEEE Transaction on instrumentation and measurement, Vol. 48, no.2, April 1999. [5] G.T. Heydt, P.S. Fjeld, C.C. Liu, D. Pierce, L. Tu, G. Hensley, Applications of the windowed FFT to Electric Power quality assessment, IEEE Transaction on power delivery, oct 1999. [6] A.M. Gaouda, M.R. Sultan, A.Y. Chinkani and M.M.A. Salama, Power quality detection and classification using waveletmultiresolution signal decomposition IEEE Transaction on power delivery, Vol. 14, no.4, October 1999. [7] Mladen Kezunovic, Advanced assessment of the power quality events, IEEE Transaction, 2000. [8] Surya Santoso, Edward J. Powers, W. Mack Grady, and Antony C. Parsons, Power quality disturbance waveform recognition using wavelet based neural classifier-part 1: theortical foundation, IEEE Transaction on power delivery, Vol. 15, no.1, January 2000. [9] A.M. Gaouda, S.H. Kanoun and M.M.A. Salama, On-line disturbance classification using nearest neighbor rule, Electric power systems research, 2001. [10] Francisco Jurado, Jose R. Saenz, Comparison between discrete STFT and wavelets for the analysis of power quality events, Electric power systems research, 2002. [11] P.K Dash, G.Panda and B. K. Panigrahi, Power quality analysis using S transform, IEEE Transaction on power delivery, Vol. 18, no.2, April 2003. [12] M. V. Chilukuri and P. K. Dash, Multi resolution S-transform-based fuzzy recognition system for power quality events, IEEE Transaction on power delivery, Vol. 19, no.1, January 2004. [13] Dogan gokhan ece, and Omer nezih gerek, Power quality event detection using joint 2-D-wavelet subspaces, IEEE Transaction on instrumentation and measurement, Vol. 53, no.4, August 2004. [14] Julio Barros and Enrique Perez, Automatic detection and analysis of voltage events in power systems, IEEE Transaction on instrumentation and measurement, Vol. 55, no.5, October 2006. [15] Fengzhan Zhao, Rengang Yang, Power quality disturbance recognition using S-transform, IEEE transaction on power delivery, Vol. 22, no.2, April 2007. [16] Ameen M. Gargoom, Nesimi Ertugrul, and Wen. L. Soong, Automatic Classification and Characterization of Power Quality Events, IEEE Transaction on power delivery, oct 2008. [17] H.S. Behera, P.K. Dash, B. Biswal, Power quality time series data mining using S-transform and fuzzy expert system, Applied soft computing, 2010. [18] M. Faisal, A. Mohamed, H. Shareef, A. Hussain, Power quality diagnosis using time frequency analysis and rule based techniques, 2011.

1350 P. Kalyana Sundaram & R. Neela [19] Chun-Yao Lee, Yi-Xing Shen, Optimal Feature Selection for Power-Quality Disturbances Classification, IEEE Transaction on power delivery, oct 2011. [20] Mohammad Jasa Afroni, Danny Sutanto and David Stirling, Analysis of Nonstationary Power-Quality waveforms using iterative Hilbert Huang transform and SAX algorithm,ieee Transaction on power delivery, Oct 2013.