SECTOR SYNTHESIS OF ANTENNA ARRAY USING GENETIC ALGORITHM

Similar documents
Progress In Electromagnetics Research, PIER 36, , 2002

The Genetic Algorithm

URL: < /isape >

Chapter 5 OPTIMIZATION OF BOW TIE ANTENNA USING GENETIC ALGORITHM

Design of Microstrip Array Antenna for Wireless Communication Application

Evolutionary Optimization for the Channel Assignment Problem in Wireless Mobile Network

Application of genetic algorithm to the optimization of resonant frequency of coaxially fed rectangular microstrip antenna

Adaptive Hybrid Channel Assignment in Wireless Mobile Network via Genetic Algorithm

Sweet Spot Control of 1:2 Array Antenna using A Modified Genetic Algorithm

Antenna Array Synthesis for Suppressed Side Lobe Level Using Evolutionary Algorithms

Satellite constellation design and radio resource management using genetic algorithm

A Novel approach for Optimizing Cross Layer among Physical Layer and MAC Layer of Infrastructure Based Wireless Network using Genetic Algorithm

Adaptive Antennas. Randy L. Haupt

Multiple Signal Direction of Arrival (DoA) Estimation for a Switched-Beam System Using Neural Networks

Evolution of Sensor Suites for Complex Environments

Optimum Coordination of Overcurrent Relays: GA Approach

A Genetic Algorithm-Based Controller for Decentralized Multi-Agent Robotic Systems

IF ONE OR MORE of the antennas in a wireless communication

Genetic Algorithms for Optimal Channel. Assignments in Mobile Communications

A COMPACT TRI-BAND ANTENNA DESIGN USING BOOLEAN DIFFERENTIAL EVOLUTION ALGORITHM. Xidian University, Xi an, Shaanxi , P. R.

Simulation and Design of a Tunable Patch Antenna

NUMERICAL SIMULATION OF SELF-STRUCTURING ANTENNAS BASED ON A GENETIC ALGORITHM OPTIMIZATION SCHEME

An Optimized Performance Amplifier

Smart Home System for Energy Saving using Genetic- Fuzzy-Neural Networks Approach

Tracking System using Fixed Beamwidth Electronics Scanning Haythem H. Abdullah, Hala A. Elsadek, and Hesham Eldeeb

Slotted Multiband PIFA antenna with Slotted Ground Plane for Wireless Mobile Applications

Millimeter Wave RF Front End Design using Neuro-Genetic Algorithms

Non-Uniform Concentric Circular Antenna Array Design Using IPSO Technique for Side Lobe Reduction

Wideband Bow-Tie Slot Antennas with Tapered Tuning Stubs

GENETICALLY DERIVED FILTER CIRCUITS USING PREFERRED VALUE COMPONENTS

Title. Author(s) Itoh, Keiichi; Miyata, Katsumasa; Igarashi, Ha. Citation IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 48(2): Issue Date

AMACH Zehnder interferometer (MZI) based on the

Mutual Coupling Reduction in Two- Dimensional Array of Microstrip Antennas Using Concave Rectangular Patches

Beamforming Techniques at Both Transmitter and Receiver for Indoor Wireless Communication

Performance Analysis of Differential Evolution Algorithm based Beamforming for Smart Antenna Systems

Optimization of the performance of patch antennas using genetic algorithms

Keywords- DC motor, Genetic algorithm, Crossover, Mutation, PID controller.

Genetic Algorithm Optimization for Microstrip Patch Antenna Miniaturization

The Simulated Location Accuracy of Integrated CCGA for TDOA Radio Spectrum Monitoring System in NLOS Environment

Linear Array Geometry Synthesis Using Genetic Algorithm for Optimum Side Lobe Level and Null

Performance Enhancement for Microcell Planning Using Simple Genetic Algorithm

International Journal of Innovative Research in Computer and Communication Engineering. (An ISO 3297: 2007 Certified Organization)

A NOVEL MICROSTRIP GRID ARRAY ANTENNA WITH BOTH HIGH-GAIN AND WIDEBAND PROPER- TIES

Wire Layer Geometry Optimization using Stochastic Wire Sampling

Direction of Arrival Estimation in Smart Antenna for Marine Communication. Deepthy M Vijayan, Sreedevi K Menon /16/$31.

AN EVOLUTIONARY ALGORITHM FOR CHANNEL ASSIGNMENT PROBLEM IN WIRELESS MOBILE NETWORKS

Optimal design of a linear antenna array using particle swarm optimization

The Application of Multi-Level Genetic Algorithms in Assembly Planning

INTEGRATED CIRCUIT CHANNEL ROUTING USING A PARETO-OPTIMAL GENETIC ALGORITHM

An overview of Broadband and Miniaturization Techniques of Microstrip Patch Antenna

Smart Grid Reconfiguration Using Genetic Algorithm and NSGA-II

[Sukumar, 5(3): July-September, 2015] ISSN: Impact Factor: 3.145

6545(Print), ISSN (Online) Volume 4, Issue 3, May - June (2013), IAEME & TECHNOLOGY (IJEET)

GA Optimization for RFID Broadband Antenna Applications. Stefanie Alki Delichatsios MAS.862 May 22, 2006

2. Simulated Based Evolutionary Heuristic Methodology

LANDSCAPE SMOOTHING OF NUMERICAL PERMUTATION SPACES IN GENETIC ALGORITHMS

G. A. Jafarabadi Department of Electronic and Telecommunication Bagher-Aloloom Research Institute Tehran, Iran

A comparison of a genetic algorithm and a depth first search algorithm applied to Japanese nonograms

Solving Sudoku with Genetic Operations that Preserve Building Blocks

Capacity Enhancement in Wireless Networks using Directional Antennas

Design and Development of an Optimized Fuzzy Proportional-Integral-Derivative Controller using Genetic Algorithm

Optimization of OFDM Systems Using Genetic Algorithm in FPGA

Adaptive Array Beamforming using LMS Algorithm

Design of a Rectangular Spiral Antenna for Wi-Fi Application

Solving Assembly Line Balancing Problem using Genetic Algorithm with Heuristics- Treated Initial Population

Keywords: Fuzzy Logic, Genetic Algorithm, Non-linear system, PI Controller.

LOG-PERIODIC DIPOLE ARRAY OPTIMIZATION. Y. C. Chung and R. Haupt

Synthesis of Dual Beam Pattern of Planar Array Antenna in a Range of Azimuth Plane Using Evolutionary Algorithm

Synthesis of Non-Uniform Amplitude equally Spaced Antenna Arrays Using PSO and DE Algorithms

Implementation of FPGA based Decision Making Engine and Genetic Algorithm (GA) for Control of Wireless Parameters

CS 441/541 Artificial Intelligence Fall, Homework 6: Genetic Algorithms. Due Monday Nov. 24.

Worst Case RLC Noise with Timing Window Constraints

DESIGN OF WIDEBAND TRIANGLE SLOT ANTENNAS WITH TUNING STUB

Load Frequency Controller Design for Interconnected Electric Power System

Genetic Algorithm Based Performance Analysis of Self Excited Induction Generator

DESIGN OF SEQUENTIALLY FED BALANCED AMPLIFYING ANTENNA FOR CIRCULAR POLARIZATION

Application of Genetic Algorithm to the Optimization of Gain of Magnetized Ferrite Microstrip Antenna

Smart Antenna of Aperiodic Array in Mobile Network

Optimization of Recloser Placement to Improve Reliability by Genetic Algorithm

A 5.8-GHz Planar Beam Tracking Antenna Using a Magic-T

Publication P IEEE. Reprinted with permission.

Optimum Design of a Probe Fed Dual Frequency Patch Antenna Using Genetic Algorithm

INTERFERENCE REJECTION OF ADAPTIVE ARRAY ANTENNAS BY USING LMS AND SMI ALGORITHMS

PID Controller Tuning using Soft Computing Methodologies for Industrial Process- A Comparative Approach

Local Search: Hill Climbing. When A* doesn t work AIMA 4.1. Review: Hill climbing on a surface of states. Review: Local search and optimization

Evolutionary Programming Optimization Technique for Solving Reactive Power Planning in Power System

Invasive Weed Optimization (IWO) Algorithm for Control of Nulls and Sidelobes in a Concentric Circular Antenna Array (CCAA)

Design of Non-Uniform Circular Arrays for Side lobe Reduction Using Real Coded Genetic Algorithm

Adaptive Antenna Technique for Mobile Communication

Coupling Effects of Aperture Coupled Microstrip Antenna

Using GPS to Synthesize A Large Antenna Aperture When The Elements Are Mobile

AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD FOR DIFFERENCE PATTERN FORMATION IN MONOPULSE ANTENNA

LINEAR ANTENNA ARRAY DESIGN WITH USE OF GENETIC, MEMETIC AND TABU SEARCH OPTIMIZATION ALGORITHMS

A Case Study of GP and GAs in the Design of a Control System

Effect of Loading a Horn Antenna with a Double Square Loop FSS "Filtenna System"

Determination of the PID Controller Parameters by Modified Genetic Algorithm for Improved Performance

PID Tuning Using Genetic Algorithm For DC Motor Positional Control System

Smart antenna technology

DESIGN OF PRINTED YAGI ANTENNA WITH ADDI- TIONAL DRIVEN ELEMENT FOR WLAN APPLICA- TIONS

Wide and multi-band antenna design using the genetic algorithm to create amorphous shapes using ellipses

Transcription:

2005-2008 JATIT. All rights reserved. SECTOR SYNTHESIS OF ANTENNA ARRAY USING GENETIC ALGORITHM 1 Abdelaziz A. Abdelaziz and 2 Hanan A. Kamal 1 Assoc. Prof., Department of Electrical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Misr University for Science and Technology (MUST), Cairo, Egypt 2 Asstt Prof., Department of Electrical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University, Giza, Egypt Email: abdelaziz_abdelmonem@yahoo.com, hanan_ak2003@yahoo.com ABSTRACT This paper introduces a new application of genetic algorithm (GA) in dynamic sector synthesis of antenna array for mobile base transceiver station (BTS). The basic objective is to have narrow beam widths in heavy handoff areas and wider beam widths in areas with low traffic density. By predefining the beam widths and thus the beams of each sector, optimal sectoring can be achieved using GA at different time of the day as traffic changes. The proposed algorithm consists of the simple GA with new adaptive mutation mechanism. When compared with simple GA, the proposed algorithm shows faster convergence. The results obtained are more stable and having higher fitness. Keywords: Antenna Array (AA), Sector Synthesis (SS), Genetic Algorithm (GA) 1. INTRODUCTION optimal sectoring can be achieved at different time of the day as traffic changes. Over the last few years, the number of subscribers The main objective of this work is to get the to wireless services has increased at an explosive optimal selection of the assigned sectors angles of rate. This growing demand for wireless the BTS such that the different sectors have communications services is constantly increasing properly balanced load all the time by using GA. the need for better coverage, improved capacity These sectors will be formed from different beams. and higher quality of service. These demands can Different beam angles can be obtained by be achieved by using smart antennas [1]. Smart changing the number of antenna array elements or antennas [2] are critical enabling technologies that the amplitude distribution they are fed. The first will provide high mobility in dense traffic areas. part of this work is to investigate the beam widths Smart antenna system [3], as one of the most produced using a linear array with varying number promising technologies in the cellular area, using of array elements and with different amplitude switched beam and adaptive antenna array with distributions. An example of BTS will be microstrip technology [4] are rapidly becoming an considered with options of 3 and 4 sectors. The integral part of both analog and digital cellular decision of sectors assignment depends on the networks. Using the approach of smart antenna traffic capacity which can be represented by the with switched beam antenna system [5], an measured power density received by the antennas intelligent sector synthesis of varying azimuth and of the BTS. The power measurement stage has not beam width can be established. Dynamic sectors been considered in our work but we will assume synthesis can be achieved by making the angles of two different power distributions for the assumed the sectors varying according to the traffic capacity 3 and 4 sectors with assigned hot spots. In the which varies from time to time during the day. By second part of this work, an adaptive GA is doing so, traffic load balancing can be achieved. introduced and used to solve the above problem. Another approach for load balancing is to use the This algorithm has a new adaptive mutation genetic algorithm [6, 7, 8]. The GA is a powerful mechanism which will maintain the best scheme in resource for electromagnetic optimization the solution and at the same time provides the problems [9]. Under GA control, the sector beam search space with new solution elements. The width can be varied with narrow beam widths in structure of the algorithm and a comparison heavy handoff areas (hot spots) and wider beam between the obtained results and previous work widths in areas with low traffic density. Thus, has been made. Results have proved the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm. 160

2005-2008 JATIT. All rights reserved. 2. BEAM WIDTH INVESTIGATION The first part of this work is to investigate the beam widths produced using a linear array with varying number of array elements and with different amplitude distributions. The number of elements used in the simulation is in the range of 3 to 12. The values are chosen such that they can represent a practical implementation. There are many famous linear array synthesis techniques have been used to produce shaped beam patterns [10]. Table 1 shows the simulated beam widths (BW) produced from a linear array elements of isotopic type with resonance frequency of 2 GHz and inter-element spacing λ/2. Simulation results are obtained using antenna design software PCAAD 4.0 [11] for the most famous amplitude distributions. Table 1: The 3-dB beam widths (BW), in degrees, for different amplitude distributions and element numbers Number of elements Cheby. Weight (1) Woodword Weight (2) Uniform Weight (3) Cosine Weight (4) Taylor Weight (5) 3 40.3 36.1 41.4 40.4 42.6 4 30 92.8 26.3 31.7 29.6 34.9 5 23.7 20.7 25.4 23.4 30.2 6 19.4 108.9 17.1 21.3 19.3 27 7 16.4 14.6 18.3 16.5 24.7 8 14.2 118.5 12.7 16 14.4 22.9 9 12.5 11.3 14.2 12.7 21.4 10 11.1 124.9 10.2 12.8 11.4 20.2 11 10.1 9.2 11.7 10.4 19.1 12 9.1 129.9 8.4 10.7 9.5 18 Binom. Weight (6) 3. SECTORS OF THE BASE TRANCEIVER STATION We will consider, as an example, the total number of elements for the BTS is 48 elements. The number of sectors may be any number and each sector may be covered by number of beams depending on the number of elements per sector and amplitude distribution (weight) of the elements as shown in Table 1. The BTS configuration will be considered with two options of 3 and 4 sectors as shown in Figure 1.The assumed sector angles of both sectors and direction of heavy and low traffic are given in Table 2. In 3-sector design, 16 elements are used per one sector with combinations of 4, 6, 8, and 12 elements to form a 16 elements array. There are a total of 5 options of array grouping for 16 elements as given in Table 3. In 4-sector design, 12 elements are used per one sector with combinations of 3, 4, 6, and 8 elements. There are a total of 6 options of array grouping for 12 elements as given in Table 3. Individual beam widths produced by the grouped elements add up to form the sector beam width. Depending on the beam width required for each 3 and 4 sector, the array elements are connected into groups of 3, 4, 6, 8, or 12 configurations accordingly with specific amplitude distribution (weight) applied. The composition of 16 and 12 elements are arranged in a linear form along the radial direction. Individual beam widths produced by the grouped elements add up to form the sector beam width required according to the assigned traffic capacity. Table 2: Assigned angles, in degrees, and direction of heavy and low traffic for the 3 and 4 sectors angle of angle of angle of angle of direction of direction of sector (1) sector (2) sector (3) sector (4) heavy traffic low traffic 3-sector 100 185 75-12 o clock 10 o clock 4-sector 40 90 190 40 12 o clock 4 o clock 161

2005-2008 JATIT. All rights reserved. Table 3: The possible combinations (options) of array grouping for 16 and 12 elements 16 elements option (1) option (2) option (3) option (4) option (5) option (6) 4 4 4 4 ---- 8 8 4 12 4 6 6 4 4 8 12 elements 12 6 6 4 8 4 4 4 3 3 6 3 3 3 3 4. STRUCTURE OF THE PROPOSED GENETIC ALGORITHM Any GA starts with a population of randomly generated solutions [12], chromosomes, and advances toward better solutions by applying genetic operators modeled on the genetic processes occurring in nature. In these algorithms we maintain a population of solutions for a given problem; this population undergoes evolution in the form of natural selection. In each generation, relatively good solutions reproduce to give offspring that replace the relatively bad solutions which die. An evaluation or fitness function plays the role of environment to distinguish between good and bad solutions. In this part an adaptive GA is introduced and used to optimize the problem of dynamic sector synthesis of antenna array. The main parts of the proposed algorithm are described below. 4.1 Population Initialization The implemented GA initializes the data members of the population and generates the first generation of chromosomes with random values. It uses the pure randomly initialization strategy which is preferable in research, because it clarifies the robustness of the algorithm. Initialization is done by randomly selecting items from the output of the "possible combination" function to represent what is called the initial population P or POP (0) where P is known as the population size. 4.2 Evaluation Function The objective is to achieve each sector angle with suitable array combinations with minimum error. Three different error functions have been used. The first one labeled as absolute error ( E a (i) ) which equals the difference between the required angle and the generated one obtained from the algorithm: E a (i ) = R ( j ) A (i ) (4-1) Where: R (j): Required angle of the sector j (the output of sectoring function) A (i): Individual I (initially the output of possible combination function) During trials, the GA was based on the above error function. It has been found that some error values were large; which makes the average fitness converges to a suboptimal solution very fast. So the second suggested error function was labeled as absolute normalized error ( E n (i) ) which equals ( E a (i) ) divided by R (j):r ( j ) A (i ) (4-2) E (i ) = n R ( j ) The solution was improved and became closer to the optimum. The third error function was proposed as the squared absolute normalized error: 2 E s = R( j) A(i) (4-3) R( j) The fitness function is inversely proportional to the error function. So, the fitness function F (i) is defined as: F (i) = 1/ (1+ E (i)), where E (i) is the selected error function. The reproduction operator method is the ''biased roulette wheel'' [6]. 4.3 Chromosome Crossover Operator The crossover operator is the element that provides the GA function that equivalent to the production of hybrids by genetics crossover in natural system. The simplest crossover operator takes bits from each parent and combines them to create child strings. The algorithm handles one type of crossover technique, one point crossover. Since our problem requires fine tuning of available values, we haven t used other crossover techniques, such as (two-point crossover). In one point crossover a random point is selected which divides each parent vector into two groups of genes. Then each child inherits one genes group 162

2005-2008 JATIT. All rights reserved. from each parent successively. The crossover probability ρ c is defined as the probability or the rate of cross-over along the population. This means that not all the selected parents are subjected to crossover process, but according to the probability test. 4.4 Mutation Operator In this work a new mutation mechanism is introduced in which the mutation probability (Pm) is adaptive with a single chromosome as follows: Pm = 0.1(1 - ). Where an adaptive parameter is varies between 0 and 1. When is very small, the mutation probability is approximately 0.1. As the value of increases, the new mutation 4.5 Population Replacement Function This function integrates all GA operators to produce new generation of individuals. It loops to generate an equal number of children to the population size. In each loop it uses the selection function twice to select two parents from the current generation, and then generates the new 5. SIMULATION RESULTS The algorithm has been tested for different GA parameters and the best combinations are: ρ = 0.9c ρ m = Adaptive probability (0 ~ 0.1) Pop-size = (50 ~ 200) Number of generations =1000 The simulation was done for the two configurations of the BTS with 3 and 4-sector shown in Figure 1. The simulation was done by using only two amplitude distributions weight-1, and weigt-2 (see Table 1) due to limitation of the computer memory size, but actual system will implemented to manipulate more than 10 weights. The results obtained using the three evaluation function, simple genetic algorithm (SGA) with constant mutation probability for the normalized and squared normalized error functions and the adaptive mutation probability algorithm (AGA) with squared normalized error. Results of the 3sector configuration with different beam widths are given in Figures 2 and 3 for the SGA with squared normalized error and AGA. Figure 4 shows the average fitness for the 3-sector verses the number of generation for the three evaluation probability value decreases. Finally, when approaches unit, the mutation probability is zero and the new solution is the old one. Experiments were conducted with different values of and we have found that the optimal value of is the average fitness of the population. At first generations, the average fitness value is low as we are far from the optimal solution. Thus, the adaptive mutation provides the search space with new solution elements. The average fitness is improved as the GA successfully moves towards a better solution. At last, the average fitness approaches the best fitness which is approximately unity and the adaptive mutation operator maintains the best solution elements. children that follow the problem constraints. By the end of this function we add the newly generated individuals to the population. When the population finishes its process of creating new individuals and then selects the best group of individuals to survive to the next generation. This strategy is called the rank replacement technique [6]. function. The solutions obtained from AGA are of higher fitness than SGA for the three sectors. Results of the 4-sector configuration with different beam widths are given in Figures 5 and 6 for the SGA with squared normalized error and AGA. Figure 7 shows the average fitness for the 4-sector verses the number of generation for the three evaluation function. The solutions obtained from AGA are of higher fitness than SGA for the four sectors. Results of both techniques (SGA and AGA) have narrow beam widths in heavy handoff areas (hot spots) and wider beam widths in areas with low traffic density. Comparison between the communication soft hand-off process. Effect of solution parameters for the 3 and 4-sector for the number of sectors on the convergence time has two different used techniques are given in Table 4 been studied. It is noted that the convergence times and 5 respectively. Total coverage angle should be are at 415, 94, and 20 generations for the 3, 4 and equal to 360 o. The coverage angle error value is 6 sectors respectively. Figure 8 shows that the required to be zero or small positive value. convergence time of the AGA technique is Negative error value means creating a dead zone, inversely proportional to the number of designed while positive error value means creating an 163

2005-2008 JATIT. All rights reserved. sectors. overlapping between beams which simplifies the Table 4: Solution parameters of the 3- sector for the two different used techniques Used technique average fitness Convergence time coverage angle error SGA 1 460 generation - 0.3 % AGA 1 415 generation + 2 % Table 5: Solution parameters of the 4- sector for the two different used techniques Used technique average fitness Convergence time coverage angle error SGA 1 125 generation + 2.2 % AGA 1 94 generation + 0.7 % 6. COCLUSION This paper has met the objectives of investigating and analyzing the method of dynamic sector synthesis of linear arrays using genetic algorithm for the purpose of load balancing among the sectors of the BTS. The designs were further oriented to different heavy and low traffic density for load balancing. Successful configurations of REFERENCES [1] R. H. Roy, An overview of smart antenna technology: The next wave in wireless communications, Proc. 1998 IEEE Aerospace Conf., vol. 3, May 1998, pp. 339 345. [2] J.C. Liberti Jr. and T.S. Rappaport: Smart Antennas for Wireless Communications, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey, 1999. [3] J. Lu and T. Ohira, Smart antennas at wireless mobile computer terminals and mobile stations, Proc. 2001 IEEE AP-S Int. Symp. USNC/URSI Nat. Radio Sci. Meeting, Boston, July 8 13, 2001. [4] Lee, H. F., and W. Chen, Advances in Microstrip and Printed Ant., New York, J. Wiley & Sons, 1997. [5] Ho, M-J., Stuber, G.L., Austin, M.D., [10] C. A. Balanis, Antenna Theory: analysis and [12] M. Gen and R. Cheng: Genetic Algorithms Design, 2nd Edition, John Wiley and Sons, and Engineering Design, John Wiley & Sons, New York. Inc. New the sectors can be achieved based on traffic changes. A proposed adaptive GA is introduced and used to solve the considered problem. It has been shown that the SGA and AGA techniques were valuable and useful in solving the problem of dynamic sector synthesis of antenna array. The solution obtained using AGA is faster in convergence and has higher fitness than SGA "Performance of Switched-Beam Smart Antennas for Cellular Radio Systems", IEEE Trans. on Vehicular Technology, Vol. 47, No. 1, pp. 10-19, February 1998 [6] Davis Lwrence, "Hand Book of Genetic Algorithm" Library of Congress Catalogy, USA, 1991. [7] David E. Goldberg: Genetic Algorithm in search, Optimization, and machine learning. Addison-Wesley Publishing company, Inc, 1989. [8] J. Jin, H. Wang, W. Zhu, and Y. Liu, Array Patterns Synthesizing Using Genetic Algorithm, PIERS Online, Vol. 2, No. 1, 6468, 2006. [9] R. S. Yahya and M. Eric: Electronic optimization by Genetic Algorithms, John Wiley, New York, 1999. York,1997. [11] D. M. Pozar, PCAAD 4: Personal Computer Aided Antenna Design, Antenna Design Associates, Leverett, MA,1999. 164

2005-2008 JATIT. All rights reserved. Figure 1: Configuration of the BTS with 3 and 4sectors Figure 2: 3-sector configuration results from the SGA technique 165

2005-2008 JATIT. All rights reserved. Figure 3: 3-sector configuration results from the AGA technique 166

2005-2008 JATIT. All rights reserved. Figure 4: Average fitness for the 3-sector vs. the number of generation for the three evaluation function Figure 5: 4-sector configuration results from the SGA technique 167

2005-2008 JATIT. All rights reserved. Figure 6: 4-sector configuration results from the AGA technique 168

2005-2008 JATIT. All rights reserved. Figure 7: Average fitness for the 4-sector vs. the number of generation for the three evaluation function Figure 8: Average fitness vs. number of generation adaptive genetic algorithm for the 3, 4 and 6 sectors 169