2002 IEEE International Frequency Control Symposium and PDA Exhibition A NEW HIGH STABILITY DOCXO. STATISTICS OF THE RESULTS OF FREQUENCY STABILITY MEASUREMENTS. By S.V.Anastasiev, A.A.Volkov, Y.L.Vorokhovsky, Morion, Inc, Phone: 7-812-350-9565; Fax: 7-812-350-7290; St.Petersburg, Russia SUMMARY Recently the significant increase of demand for Ultra Stable Quartz Oscillators has been evidenced. Such oscillators are used for many applications including CDMA, GPS/GLONASS, etc. The following major requirements are usually applied for these oscillators: frequency stability vs. Temperature changes of+/ (1..2)*10-10; long term stability of+/-(1..2)*10-8 /year; short term stability of <5*10-12 for time intervals of 1 through 100 seconds. As the world experience shows, very tight combinations of requirements can be met in Double Oven crystal oscillator (DOCXO). However, development, production and measurement of such DOCXOs is a quite technically complicated task. In the R&D laboratory of the Morion, Inc. the design of DOCXO was made with parameters satisfying the above mentioned requirements. Also the process of serial production of such DOCXOs has been worked out. The major parameters ofmv89 type DOCXO: Nominal frequency: 4.096; 5.0; 8.192; 10.0 MHz Frequency stability in operating temperature range of -20.. +70 C: Aging per day: Short-term stability for 1.. 100 s: <5*10-12 Output level: ' >0 dbm into 50 Ohms load; Power consumption: <3.5 W (steady state@ 25 C); Dimensions: 2"*2"*1.5" (50.8*50.8*38mm). ±I.O* 1 o- 10 ; ±1.5* 1 o- 10 ; ±2.0* 1 o- 10 ; ±I.O* 1 o- 10 ; The design ofdocxo is based on previous designs ofmorion's precision oscillators and takes into account the modernizing of existing technology. A new DOCXO has two modifications: MV89A with standard frequencies 8.192, 10 MHz and MV89B- 4.096 and 5.0 MHz. MV89A differs from MV89B by presence of frequency doubler. High quality SC-cut crystals in cold weld package HC40 are used in both modifications. Long term stability of
most of these crystals is enough to meet the specification requirements in serial production. DOCXO consists of three main parts: - inner oven with a crystal, oscillator circuitry and VCO; - outer oven with a thermocontroller of inner oven and reference voltage regulator; - base plate with a thermocontroller of outer oven and buffer amplifier. This structure is mounted in hermetically sealed metal case with standard pinout. MAIN CHARACTERISTICS OF FREQUENCY STABILITY Temperature stability. Frequency stability in ambient temperature range depends on stability of an average temperature of crystal and stability of temperature gradients in the crystal blank. In double oven structure it is possible to achieve the stability of crystal temperature approximately 0.01 C. Calculated temperature gradients are about 0.1 C. It is important to maintain the temperature of oscillator circuit constant to avoid frequency deviation caused by changing of components characteristics. Achieved frequency stability in ambient temperature range - 40 C + 75 C for MV89 is shown in Fig.l. 634
OCXO MV89-IOMHz.~e0076 df. pph!---~------~-----------, 08 04 -il4 - - - - -0 8 ' -40-20 20 40 60 I."C' T "C Freauencv. MHz De _ppb I ma -40 9.999 999 992 278-0.008 900 712 50-20 9 999 999 992 207-0.016 000 5&2.00-10 9 999 999 992 120-0 024 700 524.60 0 ~ 'J99 9'N 992 U5 5-0 031 200 465 30 ~5 l; t}(j'j QQI.j 99:! ](l7 0 O<Xl 000 )18 90 45 9 999 99CJ 9()2 286-0 00~ {(10 103 85 60 9 999 999 992 2110-0.016 700 120 8& 70 9 999 999 992 34 7-0.1102 000 _.MJi_ 75 9 999 999 992 521 0.015 4<Xl 46.14 Checkomnt tvoe Value L1m11 I iotofr -20:6011 0.031 200 <loob + IIDtoFl-40 7511 0.046 600 <I nob < I iotofi-20 70 : 0.03 I 200 -loob I llotofi-10:7011 0.03_1_200 lwb Fig.l. Statistical data shows that 70% of total quantity produced meet ±2*10-10 in temperature range -40 C + +75 C 90% meet ±2*10-10 in temperature range - l0 C + +70 C. And about 85% meet ±1 *10-10 vs. temperature -10 + +70 C. 635
Long term stability. Fig.2 shows typical frequency vs. time characteristic ofmv89. df, ppba OCXOMV89 ~-""""" 0610312002 16 01 N!! 4992 01.'031":!00:! 13:~1 t, days df, ppb J 0.000 4 - --... -... 2 0.181 3 0.329 4 0.447 5 0.515 7 0.643 2 8 0.769 9 0.655 10 0.622...,..._ 0 - _, - :... _:... II 0.796 - - 12 0.869 13 0.892 _,... - -, -, 0 14 0.941 - IS 1.035 2.. -4...... 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 t, days SWtday: 14/02n002 15:11, 15 days total; Ref meas. 9.999 996 435 236MHz Ageing: 0.095356ppb/day total, 0.080798ppb/day (last 10) Long term stability after 30 days of operation (forecast): 0.0149762 ppb per day 1.21775 ppb per year Forecast fonnula:o.ol +0.48Ln(t/2.JO+l) Fig.2. Long term stability mainly defined by the quality of crystal. More than 80% of crystals used in MV89 meet ±2*10-10 /day and 70% meet ±1 *10-10 /day Those DOCXO reliably have according long term stability in 1st year ~ ±2 * 1 o- 8 and ~ ±1 *10-8 They may be reliably delivered for very tight requirements like~ ±5* 1 o- 8 for 10 years of operation. 636
Short term stability. Fig.3 shows typical Allan variance characteristic of MV89. 01 Mar 2002111:24:37 10-10 Allan Deviation ay(~) 10-11 10-12 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 Ch A: 10.0 MHz 1.1 Vpp Instantaneous Phase Averaging Time 't, seconds Ch B: 10.0 MHz 0.8 Vpp B/A:Single DDS Fig.3. Statistical data shows that 90% of total quantity meet Allan variance for average time interval 1s-2*10-12 los- 3.5*10-12 100s- 5.5*10-12 637
Phase noise. Fig.4 shows the typical phase noise plot ofmv89a 10 MHz. tiu89.4942 ~~3/2002 EUROPTEST L< f') c:ibc/hz r f=-3.0db tina: ~5h~~On -90 -~00 -.uo ~ -~ -.120 ~~~~., -~30 n~ -~40 -~:so -~60 ~~k ll... l"~ ~l~ j,1 ' I"' ~~... I'H r" _/L I' '"' Ia rr U:Hz.lo»u 101~Hz ~011HZ Fig.4. Statistical data: more than 98% of total quantity of MV89A units meet phase nmse at offset 1 Hz -100 dbc 10Hz -130 dbc 100Hz -145dBc 1000Hz -150 dbc CONCLUSION The introduced DOCXO is being produced at Morion, Inc. Now our R&D department is working out a new DOCXO with a reduced height and low power consumption. 638