PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CHAOS BASED INTERLEAVER IN IDMA SYSTEM

Similar documents
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF IDMA SCHEME USING DIFFERENT CODING TECHNIQUES WITH RECEIVER DIVERSITY USING RANDOM INTERLEAVER

IDMA Technology and Comparison survey of Interleavers

Journal of Information Engineering and Applications ISSN (print) ISSN X (online) Vol 1, No.3, 2011

Performance of Wideband Mobile Channel with Perfect Synchronism BPSK vs QPSK DS-CDMA

Study of Turbo Coded OFDM over Fading Channel

Chaos based Communication System Using Reed Solomon (RS) Coding for AWGN & Rayleigh Fading Channels

IJEETC. InternationalJournalof. ElectricalandElectronicEngineering& Telecommunications.

PERFORMANCE AND COMPARISON OF LINEAR MULTIUSER DETECTORS IN DS-CDMA USING CHAOTIC SEQUENCE

A Simplified Downlink Transmission and Receiving Scheme for IDMA

Performance Study of MIMO-OFDM System in Rayleigh Fading Channel with QO-STB Coding Technique

USING CHAOTIC SEQUENCE IN DIRECT SEQUENCE SPREAD SPECTRUM BASED ON CODE DIVISION MULTIPLE ACCESS (DS-CDMA)

COMPARISON OF CHANNEL ESTIMATION AND EQUALIZATION TECHNIQUES FOR OFDM SYSTEMS

Implementation of Different Interleaving Techniques for Performance Evaluation of CDMA System

Performance Evaluation of different α value for OFDM System

Lecture 9: Spread Spectrum Modulation Techniques

USER SPREAD OPTICAL INTERLEAVE DIVISION MULTIPLE ACCESS SCHEME (US-OIDMA) FOR HIGH SPEED TRANSMISSION WITH ZERO DISPERSION FIBER

Performance Evaluation of STBC-OFDM System for Wireless Communication

PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF AN UPLINK MISO-CDMA SYSTEM USING MULTISTAGE MULTI-USER DETECTION SCHEME WITH V-BLAST SIGNAL DETECTION ALGORITHMS

CDMA Mobile Radio Networks

Adaptive DS/CDMA Non-Coherent Receiver using MULTIUSER DETECTION Technique

EXIT Chart Analysis for Turbo LDS-OFDM Receivers

Concert Investigation of Novel Deterministic Interleaver for OFDM-IDMA System

Performance of Turbo codec OFDM in Rayleigh fading channel for Wireless communication

A Novel Spread Spectrum System using MC-DCSK

Physical Layer: Modulation, FEC. Wireless Networks: Guevara Noubir. S2001, COM3525 Wireless Networks Lecture 3, 1

BER Analysis for MC-CDMA

Performance Analysis of Optical Code Division Multiple Access System

Cognitive Radio Transmission Based on Chip-level Space Time Block Coded MC-DS-CDMA over Fast-Fading Channel

Implementation of DSSS System using Chaotic Sequence using MATLAB and VHDL

PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF MIMO WIRELESS SYSTEM WITH ARRAY ANTENNA

Comparative Analysis of the BER Performance of WCDMA Using Different Spreading Code Generator

1. INTRODUCTION II. SPREADING USING WALSH CODE. International Journal of Advanced Networking & Applications (IJANA) ISSN:

On the performance of Turbo Codes over UWB channels at low SNR

Performance of Parallel Concatenated Convolutional Codes (PCCC) with BPSK in Nakagami Multipath M-Fading Channel

SPLIT MLSE ADAPTIVE EQUALIZATION IN SEVERELY FADED RAYLEIGH MIMO CHANNELS

OFDM Systems For Different Modulation Technique

Performance Analysis of DSSS and FHSS Techniques over AWGN Channel

IJESRT. Scientific Journal Impact Factor: (ISRA), Impact Factor: 2.114

Generation of Orthogonal Logistic Map Sequences for Application in Wireless Channel and Implementation using a Multiplierless Technique

CDMA versus IDMA for Subscriber Cell Density

Combined Transmitter Diversity and Multi-Level Modulation Techniques

Robust Frequency-Hopping System for Channels with Interference and Frequency-Selective Fading

SPREADING SEQUENCES SELECTION FOR UPLINK AND DOWNLINK MC-CDMA SYSTEMS

Wireless Communication: Concepts, Techniques, and Models. Hongwei Zhang

ADVANCED WIRELESS TECHNOLOGIES. Aditya K. Jagannatham Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur

Department of Electronic Engineering FINAL YEAR PROJECT REPORT

Spread Spectrum Techniques

Research Collection. Multi-layer coded direct sequence CDMA. Conference Paper. ETH Library

Performance comparison of convolutional and block turbo codes

Performance Analysis of n Wireless LAN Physical Layer

PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF DIRECT SEQUENCE SPREAD SPECTRUM UNDER PHASE NOISE EFFECT WITH SIMULINK SIMULATIONS

Iterative Detection and Decoding with PIC Algorithm for MIMO-OFDM Systems

Analyzing Pulse Position Modulation Time Hopping UWB in IEEE UWB Channel

Analysis of Interference & BER with Simulation Concept for MC-CDMA

Spread Spectrum (SS) is a means of transmission in which the signal occupies a

Study of Performance Evaluation of Quasi Orthogonal Space Time Block Code MIMO-OFDM System in Rician Channel for Different Modulation Schemes

Prof. P. Subbarao 1, Veeravalli Balaji 2

A MODIFIED DIRECT-SEQUENCE SPREAD SPECTRUM MODULATION SCHEME FOR BURST TRANSMISSIONS. Bart Scheers and Vincent Le Nir

A Game Theoretic Framework for Decentralized Power Allocation in IDMA Systems

Lecture 3. Direct Sequence Spread Spectrum Systems. COMM 907:Spread Spectrum Communications

Analysis of Ternary and Binary High Resolution Codes Using MATLAB

4x4 Time-Domain MIMO encoder with OFDM Scheme in WIMAX Context

2. LITERATURE REVIEW

Multirate schemes for multimedia applications in DS/CDMA Systems

ISSN: Page 320

Power Efficiency of LDPC Codes under Hard and Soft Decision QAM Modulated OFDM

Performance Evaluation of Nonlinear Equalizer based on Multilayer Perceptron for OFDM Power- Line Communication

THE OFDM-IDMA APPROACH TO WIRELESS COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS

MULTI-USER DETECTION TECHNIQUES FOR POTENTIAL 3GPP LONG TERM EVOLUTION (LTE) SCHEMES

A promising set of spreading sequences to mitigate MAI effects in MIMO STS systems

Performance Analysis of MIMO Equalization Techniques with Highly Efficient Channel Coding Schemes

SYSTEM-LEVEL PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF MMSE MIMO TURBO EQUALIZATION TECHNIQUES USING MEASUREMENT DATA

Chapter 2 Channel Equalization

Performance Comparison of ZF, LMS and RLS Algorithms for Linear Adaptive Equalizer

Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) based Uplink Multiple Access Method over AWGN and Fading Channels

On the Uplink Capacity of Cellular CDMA and TDMA over Nondispersive Channels

OFDM AS AN ACCESS TECHNIQUE FOR NEXT GENERATION NETWORK

Computational Complexity of Multiuser. Receivers in DS-CDMA Systems. Syed Rizvi. Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering

QUESTION BANK SUBJECT: DIGITAL COMMUNICATION (15EC61)

A New PAPR Reduction in OFDM Systems Using SLM and Orthogonal Eigenvector Matrix

Channel Estimation in Multipath fading Environment using Combined Equalizer and Diversity Techniques

Effects of Fading Channels on OFDM

Multiuser Decorrelating Detector in MIMO CDMA Systems over Rayleigh and Rician Fading Channels

Performance Analysis of Optimal Scheduling Based Firefly algorithm in MIMO system

Delay-Diversity in Multi-User Relay Systems with Interleave Division Multiple Access

AWGN Channel Performance Analysis of QO-STB Coded MIMO- OFDM System

A Multicarrier CDMA Based Low Probability of Intercept Network

Amplitude and Phase Distortions in MIMO and Diversity Systems

BEING wideband, chaotic signals are well suited for

Chapter 2 Direct-Sequence Systems

Notes 15: Concatenated Codes, Turbo Codes and Iterative Processing

Performance analysis of MISO-OFDM & MIMO-OFDM Systems

SPARSE CHANNEL ESTIMATION BY PILOT ALLOCATION IN MIMO-OFDM SYSTEMS

CHAPTER 2. Instructor: Mr. Abhijit Parmar Course: Mobile Computing and Wireless Communication ( )

Riemann Sequence based SLM with nonlinear effects of HPA

Joint Transmitter-Receiver Adaptive Forward-Link DS-CDMA System

On the Spectral Efficiency of MIMO MC-CDMA System

A New Data Conjugate ICI Self Cancellation for OFDM System

Cross Spectral Density Analysis for Various Codes Suitable for Spread Spectrum under AWGN conditions with Error Detecting Code

DESIGN OF STBC ENCODER AND DECODER FOR 2X1 AND 2X2 MIMO SYSTEM

Transcription:

DOI: 10.1917/ijct.016.006 PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CHAOS BASED INTERLEAVER IN IDMA SYSTEM Aasheesh Shukla 1 and Vinay Kumar Deolia Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, GLA University, India E-mail: 1 aasheesh.shukla@gla.ac.in, vinaykumar.deolia@gla.ac.in Abstract Chaos are wide spread in nature, furthermore its use in the field of communication drew attention in early 90 s and recently chaos based spread spectrum (SS) communication become an interesting area of research. Based on the research; this paper presents the study of chaos theory and then leads the discussion towards the chaos based SS system. Interleave Division Multiple Access (IDMA) based spread spectrum has been considered for performance analysis. First it reviewed the role of chaos in spread spectrum communication and then discussion extends to chaos based IDMA, which is relatively a new and promising technique in this area. Simulation results verify that chaos based IDMA can achieve good BER performance as well as offers less computational complexity. Keywords: Chaos, Spread Spectrum System, CBDSS, Bifurcation, IDMA 1. INTRODUCTION In IDMA scheme, interleavers are used to distinguish the different users. This scheme is the improved version of classical CDMA scheme. IDMA inherits all the advantages of CDMA scheme especially it overcomes the major limiting factor of CDMA such as: multiple access interference (MAI) and Inter Symbol Interference (ISI). Interleavers are used to spread the information and to protect these bits from error bursts due to multipath propagation and noise sources. Hence, efficient interleaver can increase the throughput of iterative MUD receivers [1]. Interleavers should be easy to generate and not to consume large bandwidth and memory. Interleavers should also be noncolloidal in nature []. Many Interleavers were studied and proposed in the literature. Rumsey (1970) presented the study of basic interleaver design. Randomly Interleaved sequence can be the good choice of interleaver but the memory requirement in Random Interleaver (RI) is very high and this limitation motivates for further research. Pupeza et al. (006) suggested the study of Nested Interleaver (NI).The limitation of this interleaver was the extra memory requirement []. Kusume et al. (008) proposed the designing of Shifting Interleaver (SI). The bit error rate performance of this interleaver was good but not suitable for multi user detection (MUD) system [3]. M. Shukla et al. (009) presented the designing of Tree based Interleaver (TBI). This interleaver was also having the scope of improvement in memory requirement [5]. On the other hand Chaotic signals are deterministic, limited and non-periodic as well as highly sensitive to the initial condition [4]. Chaotic signals are noise like and wide-band and hence may be good candidate for interleaving sequence. Furthermore, the cross correlation property is also encouraging. Chaos-based systems are having significant advantages over traditional spread spectrum systems in terms of security and synchronization [5]. Chaos is in itself a very universal and robust phenomenon in many nonlinear systems with certain characteristics. According to chaotic dynamics these characteristics are (a) highly sensitive to initial conditions (b) wideband frequency spectrum (c) noise like behavior (d) high complexity [6]. These properties made chaos useful in communication engineering specifically for security of information. This paper meets the following objectives; firstly it provides introduction to chaos theory and its role in spread spectrum communication engineering and secondly the chaos based interleaver employed in IDMA based communication system for performance enhancement. It will also explore the new area of developments on the basis of signal processing capability. The content of the paper is organized as follows. In section, the introduction of chaos theory is discussed. Section 3, defines the IDMA system and algorithms for interleaver generation. Section 4, develops the performance analysis of chaos based IDMA schemes and finally section 5 conclude the paper.. CHAOS THEORY This could be noted that sinusoidal carriers may be a better choice in communication systems. When a sinusoidal signal is used to transmit information, the power spectral density concentrates in a narrow range of frequencies. Whereas chaotic signals, can occupy a large bandwidth, their autocorrelations and cross correlation properties are also favorable. These characteristics made chaotic signals a better choice in communication systems. Chaos-based SS systems have several properties, namely (i) Difficult to interfere with any unauthorized user; (ii) information transfer is more secure than any other communication system (iii) resistant to jamming. Chaos can be better understood with the help of difference equations. The logistic population model is very popular to understand chaos. Definition 1: The logistic map is given as: f (x n) = x n+1 = rx n (1-x n) (1) where, r is growth rate of population and an important parameter to discuss. Here parameter r is elaborated for different value ranges. For the range 0 r 4. Proposition: For the above range logistic map sends [0, 1] to itself. Proposition: For the value of r < 1, fixed and stable point is 0. For the value r > 1 it is unstable. One more point is stable i.e. x = 1 (1/r), but only for 0 < r < 3 and unstable for r > 3. Proof: If we solve the equation rx (1-x) = x, the fixed point yields x 1 = 0 and x = 1 (1/r) and from the derivative of equation i.e. f (x) = r (1- x) we get f (0) = r. Hence 0 is stable point for the specified range. Similarly second point is also stable for above said range. 1397

AASHEESH SHUKLA AND VINAY KUMAR DEOLIA: PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CHAOS BASED INTERLEAVER IN IDMA SYSTEM Proposition: The logistic map has cycles for r > 3 and stable if r < 1+ 6. Proof: In cycle, logistic map has set of points such that u v [0,1] and f (u) = v and f (v) = u and hence f (u) = u and f (v) = v. Now solving the equation f (x) = r u (1-x)[1 rx(1 x)] = x yields four solutions and these solutions proves that the map forms - cycles if r > 3. Now another interesting property is yet to be discussed i.e. sensitivity on initial conditions, which is a much needed requirement for a spread spectrum system to be chaotic Definition: Let α 0 be initial condition and consider the orbit of a nearly point α 0 + θ 0 where θ 0 is very small. Let θ n is the separation in two orbits after n iterations. If θ n θ 0 e nλ, then λ is called the Liapunov exponent. A positive value of it shows dependency on initial condition. Above discussion shows that as the value of r increases, the stability coefficients of the fixed points decreases and at r = 3, a stable -cycle formed. So this value of r is popularly known as period doubling bifurcation. For higher values of r, again -cycle has also become unstable but simultaneously a stable 4-cycle started at r = 3.4494897. Sl, No Table.1. Chaotic maps used in SS system Chaotic Map Equation 1 Logistic Map X n+ 1 = AX n(1 X n) 1 mxn if 0 x Tent Map F ( ) m x = m(1 x ) if 1 n x 1 3 Baker Map 4 Henon Map 3. SYSTEM OVERVIEW ( xy, ) 0 < x < 1 Fxy (, ) = ((x 1),( y+ 1 )) 1 < x < 1 n+ 1 = 1 n + n n+ 1 = bx n X ax Y Y In IDMA system interleavers play a vital role as they are used to distinguish the data from different users. Many interleavers are suggested by researchers such as random Interleaver, orthogonal interleaver, pseudo random interleavers and tree based Interleaver etc. Although all of these interleavers ensure good interleaving performance, memory requirement is always less. But some limiting factors motivate for further research. These limiting factors are computational complexity, memory requirement for the storage of the interleaving pattern and detection at receiver. y 1 y SP Π 1 SP Π Signal mixer Rj Fading Channel ESE Π -1 Π 1 DSP SP O/P y k SP Π k Elementary Signal Estimator xk j th branch of IDMA Rx SP = Spreader DSP = De-spreader Π = Interleaver Fig.1. Bifurcation diagram In Fig.1, the entire discussions can be pictorially depicted that for r < 4 an orbit eventually converges to the stable fixed point. In Fig.1, the situation is completely different at r = 4 i.e. it may be considered as chaotic. At this value of r the stable point becomes unstable. The use of chaos into spread spectrum communication systems offers many advantages as well as several opportunities for further improvement. Random nature and the sensitivity on initial conditions of chaotic systems may help to generate large number of uncorrelated, random-like, yet deterministic and reproducible signals or sequences [7]. Many chaotic maps are available which help in the generation of chaotic sequences and these sequences can be used at the place of p-n codes and interleaving sequences. The popular chaotic maps are shown in Table.1, such as Logistic map, Tent map, Bernoulli s map, Baker Map, Henon map etc. Fig.. Transmitter and Receiver structure of iterative IDMA scheme As shown in Fig., we consider an Interleave Division Multiple Access (IDMA) system with K users. At the transmitter, a n-length input data sequence y k = [y k1, y k,... y ki,..., y kn,] of k th user is spread and encoded into chips c k = [c k1, c k,...,c kj], where j is the Chip length. Now chips are interleaved by a specific interleaving pattern (based on chaotic maps) to produce transmitted chip sequence x k = [x k1, x k,...,x kj]. For performance evaluation multipath Rayleigh fading channel is opted [1]. In receiver section, the received signal from the K th users with channel coefficient h k for k th user and for the samples of fading {ζ j} can be written as: k R = hx + ζ () j k kj j k= 1 The iterative MUD detector also consists Elementary signal Estimator (ESE) and a posteriori decoder. The output of ESE is known log likelihood ratios and defined as: 1398

Rj w E( ζ kw, ) eese ( xk ( j)) w = hk (3) var( ζ ( j)) + kw, The output of APP-DEC is called as extrinsic log likelihood ratio. Based on the iterative process, the final outcome is decided. It is already discussed that along with iterative process the effective interleaver can enhance throughput of the IDMA system. In view of that, a chaos based interleaver is proposed. Flow chart and detailed algorithm is presented in further subsections. The popular Logistic map is used for interleaver generation. X k i+1 = 0 π k = {y 0 k }, y 0 k [1,,...,M] k = 1,m = 0, i = 0 YES if m=m Generate X k i+1 i = i+1 USER X I J+1 = {} Π I Π I X I j+1 4. PERFORMANCE OF LOGISTIC MAP BASED IDMA 4.1 ERROR-RATE ANALYSIS In this section, the quality of transmission of conventional IDMA is evaluated for chaos based logistic map interleaver. Random Interleaver is also considered for bit error rate (BER) analysis of conventional IDMA system. For simplicity, BPSK modulation is considered in multipath Rayleigh fading channel. The spreading code for all users is simply a repetition code with the length S = 64. The Fig.4 shows the simulation results for data length = 56 bits. Simulation results authenticate the performance of chaos based IDMA system. This is clear in figure that the chaos based logistic map interleaver achieves similar BER performance compared to RI in case of similar and somewhat better for higher values of E b/n 0. 10-1 X k i+1 π k YES Random Interleaver Chaos based Logistic Interleaver NO 10 - π k = π k X k i+1 USER 1 m = m+1 Bit Error Rate 10-3 Fig.3. Flow Chart of Logistic Map Interleaver In Fig.3, the flow chart is proposed which describe the algorithm for first interleaver generation. For the second user the whole process is repeated with some different initial interleaver. The Foot step τ is used to modify the initial value of interleaver. Steps required for the interleaver pattern generation is described below. 3.1 ALGORITHM OF INTERLEAVER DESIGN BASED ON LOGISTIC MAP Step 1: Initialization λ > 3.58, N = Interleaver length, I = no. of users X I J = I th user: 0 < X I J < N τ = Foot step I F 0 = X 0I : the first element (Π I = F 0I ), j = 0 and n = 0 Step : Main operation a) If n < N Calculate F I J+1 = X I J+1 Now Check: If F I J+1 is in the set Π I Increment j by 1 and repeat the main operation Otherwise Π I Π I F I J+1 b) If n > N: Bit Error Rate 10-4 Datalength=56 10-5 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Eb/No 10-1 10-10 -3 10-4 Fig.4. Performance of chaos based logistic interleaver Logis tic Ma p IDMA Logis tic Ma p IDMA RI-IDMA RI-IDMA Datalength=51 Datalength=104 Datalength=51,104 10-5 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Eb/No Fig.5. Performance of chaos based IDMA at different data length In Fig.5, simulation results show the comparative BER performance of RI and logistic map based interleaver. The data length is assumed 51 and 104 bits. Number of iterations is 10 and spread length S is considered to be 64. Simulation figure 1399

AASHEESH SHUKLA AND VINAY KUMAR DEOLIA: PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF CHAOS BASED INTERLEAVER IN IDMA SYSTEM concludes that the performance of chaos based IDMA have nearly same performance compared to RI-IDMA. 4. COMPUTATIONAL COMPLEXITY Other than BER analysis, Computational complexity is also the important parameter to decide the quality of communication. Here, complexity means that number of cycles required for the generation of spreading codes and interleaver matrix in terms of users. In this section, complexity is calculated for chaos based logistic map interleaver and for other popular algorithms used for interleaver generation. The Table. shows that the computational complexity increases with the number of user k for orthogonal, Nested and Tree based interleaver (TBI). It means complexity is dependent on users for all mentioned schemes except logistic map interleaver. In fact, the complexity is O(1) which means that computational complexity of logistic map interleaver is independent from the number of users [6]. Table.. Computational complexity of interleaver generation of different algorithms No. of Users OI Nested Interleaver TBI Logistic map Interleaver 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 4 4 1 16 16 16 4 1 50 50 50 5 1 4.3 CORRELATION ANALYSIS The low value of correlation among interleavers is very important criterion and provides a way to reduce the value of multiple access interference (MAI). Pupeza et al. [] proposed the correlation values for random interleaver, pseudo random and orthogonal interleaver. Akbil et al. [6] extended the discussions and also include the correlation values for chaos based interleavers. Here the correlation values for 5 users of random interleavers and chaos based interleavers are presented in Table.3 and Table.4 respectively [][6]. Table.3. Peak correlation values for Random Interleaver Row/ Column 1 3 4 5 1 16384 1814 174 1708 1674 18 16384 1765 1797 1701 3 180 1786 16384 1766 1740 4 1813 1783 176 16384 1769 5 1743 177 1758 1765 16384 Table.4. Peak correlation values for Logistic map Interleaver Row/ Column 1 3 4 5 1 16384 187 1694 1698 1660 1574 16384 1790 1460 195 3 170 190 16384 171 1656 4 150 163 1594 16384 1730 5 180 1490 1864 1578 16384 5. CONCLUSIONS In this paper, the performance of chaos based interleave division multiple access has been examined. Simulation results show that the use of chaos based interleaver in IDMA scheme enhances the bit error rate performance of IDMA system. The computational complexity of the generating algorithm is also independent from users. Correlation values of chaos based interleaver are nearly same as compared to random interleaver and hence good resistance to MAI. Chaos based interleaver also offers other advantages such as less requirement of memory and small implementation complexity Future work may involve the improvements in logistic map such that the logistic map can be modified to make it less Ergodic, so that IDMA based on Logistic map can be more suitable for secure communication. REFERENCES [1] Li Ping, Linhai Liu, K.Y. Wu and W.K. Leung, Interleave- Division Multiple-Access, Proceedings of IEEE Conference on Communications, pp. 869-873, 004. [] Ioachim Pupeza, Aleksandar Kavcic and Li Ping, Efficient Generation of Interleavers for IDMA, Proceedings of IEEE Conference on Communications, pp. 1508-1513, 006. [3] Akihiko Kitada and Yoshihito Ogasawara, On a Property Specific to the Tent Map, Chaos, Solutions and Fractals, Vol. 9, No. 5, pp. 156-158, 006. [4] Zhang Chenghai and Hu Jianhao, The shifting Interleaver Design based on PN Sequence for IDMA Systems, Proceedings of Conference on Future Generation Communication and Networking, pp. 1-6, 007. [5] M. Shukla, V.K. Srivastava and S. Tiwari, Analysis and Design of Optimum Interleaver for Iterative Receivers in IDMA Scheme, Wireless Communications and Mobile Computing, Vol. 9, No. 10, pp. 131-1317, 009. [6] Shu Ming Tseng, IDMA Based on Deterministic Interleavers, International Journal of Communications Network and System Sciences, Vol. 3, No. 1, pp. 94-97, 010. [7] Brahim Akbil, Guillaume Ferre and Driss Aboutajdine, The NLM Interleaver Design for IDMA system, Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Complex System, pp. 1-5, 01. 1400

[8] M. Eisencraft et al., Chaos based Communication Systems in Non-Ideal Channels, Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation, Vol. 17, No. 1, pp. 4707-4718, 01. [9] Francisco J. Escribano, Alexandre Wagemakers and Miguel A.F. Sanjuan, Chaos-based Turbo Systems in Fading Channels, IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems I: Regular Papers, Vol. 61, No., pp. 530-541, 014. [10] Sangeetha Manoharan and Vidhyacharan Bhaskar, PN Codes Versus Chaotic Codes: Performance Comparison in a Gaussian Approximated Wideband CDMA System over Weibull Fading Channels, Journal of the Franklin Institute, Vol. 351, No. 6, pp. 3378-3404, 014. 1401