EMD Approach to Multichannel EEG Data - The Amplitude and Phase Synchrony Analysis Technique

Similar documents
Empirical Mode Decomposition: Theory & Applications

Atmospheric Signal Processing. using Wavelets and HHT

Application of Hilbert-Huang Transform in the Field of Power Quality Events Analysis Manish Kumar Saini 1 and Komal Dhamija 2 1,2

Ensemble Empirical Mode Decomposition: An adaptive method for noise reduction

The Spatial Real and Virtual Sound Stimuli Optimization for the Auditory BCI

A Review of SSVEP Decompostion using EMD for Steering Control of a Car

KONKANI SPEECH RECOGNITION USING HILBERT-HUANG TRANSFORM

Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) of Turner Valley Airborne Gravity Data in the Foothills of Alberta, Canada

Assessment of Power Quality Events by Empirical Mode Decomposition based Neural Network

INDUCTION MOTOR MULTI-FAULT ANALYSIS BASED ON INTRINSIC MODE FUNCTIONS IN HILBERT-HUANG TRANSFORM

Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) of Turner Valley Airborne Gravity Data in the Foothills of Alberta, Canada*

Study of Phase Relationships in ECoG Signals Using Hilbert-Huang Transforms

Random and coherent noise attenuation by empirical mode decomposition Maïza Bekara, PGS, and Mirko van der Baan, University of Leeds

Motor Imagery based Brain Computer Interface (BCI) using Artificial Neural Network Classifiers

I-Hao Hsiao, Chun-Tang Chao*, and Chi-Jo Wang (2016). A HHT-Based Music Synthesizer. Intelligent Technologies and Engineering Systems, Lecture Notes

SUMMARY THEORY. VMD vs. EMD

780. Biomedical signal identification and analysis

Guan, L, Gu, F, Shao, Y, Fazenda, BM and Ball, A

Noise Reduction in Cochlear Implant using Empirical Mode Decomposition

ANALYSIS OF POWER SYSTEM LOW FREQUENCY OSCILLATION WITH EMPIRICAL MODE DECOMPOSITION

The Improved Algorithm of the EMD Decomposition Based on Cubic Spline Interpolation

BEYOND VISUAL P300 BASED BRAIN-COMPUTER INTERFACING PARADIGMS

Frequency Demodulation Analysis of Mine Reducer Vibration Signal

Hilbert-Huang Transform, its features and application to the audio signal Ing.Michal Verner

Baseline wander Removal in ECG using an efficient method of EMD in combination with wavelet

Investigation on Fault Detection for Split Torque Gearbox Using Acoustic Emission and Vibration Signals

The Application of the Hilbert-Huang Transform in Through-wall Life Detection with UWB Impulse Radar

A Brain-Computer Interface Based on Steady State Visual Evoked Potentials for Controlling a Robot

ON THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN INSTANTANEOUS FREQUENCY AND PITCH IN. 1 Introduction. Zied Mnasri 1, Hamid Amiri 1

Telemetry Vibration Signal Trend Extraction Based on Multi-scale Least Square Algorithm Feng GUO

Scientific Report. Jalal Khodaparast Ghadikolaei Iran NTNU Olav Bjarte Fosso. 01/10/2017 to 30/09/2018

Classifying the Brain's Motor Activity via Deep Learning

BCI for Comparing Eyes Activities Measured from Temporal and Occipital Lobes

Spatial Auditory BCI Paradigm based on Real and Virtual Sound Image Generation

Magnetoencephalography and Auditory Neural Representations

AdaBoost based EMD as a De-Noising Technique in Time Delay Estimation Application

NOISE CORRUPTION OF EMPIRICAL MODE DECOMPOSITION AND ITS EFFECT ON INSTANTANEOUS FREQUENCY

Method for Mode Mixing Separation in Empirical Mode Decomposition

Hilbert-Huang Transform and Its Applications in Engineering and Biomedical Signal Analysis

Beyond Blind Averaging Analyzing Event-Related Brain Dynamics

Pattern Recognition Part 2: Noise Suppression

NOVEL APPROACH FOR FINDING PITCH MARKERS IN SPEECH SIGNAL USING ENSEMBLE EMPIRICAL MODE DECOMPOSITION

ST Segment Extraction from Exercise ECG Signal Based on EMD and Wavelet Transform

Adaptive Fourier Decomposition Approach to ECG Denoising. Ze Wang. Bachelor of Science in Electrical and Electronics Engineering

from signals to sources asa-lab turnkey solution for ERP research

By Shilpa R & Dr. P S Puttaswamy Vidya Vardhaka College of Engineering, India

Research Article Subband DCT and EMD Based Hybrid Soft Thresholding for Speech Enhancement

EOG artifact removal from EEG using a RBF neural network

doi: /APSIPA

Theory of Telecommunications Networks

Diagnosis of root cause for oscillations in closed-loop chemical process systems

Spectro-Temporal Methods in Primary Auditory Cortex David Klein Didier Depireux Jonathan Simon Shihab Shamma

arxiv: v2 [q-bio.nc] 30 Sep 2016

FACE RECOGNITION USING NEURAL NETWORKS

Towards Estimating Selective Auditory Attention From EEG Using A Novel Time-Frequency-Synchronisation Framework

Impact of Stimulus Configuration on Steady State Visual Evoked Potentials (SSVEP) Response

Phase Synchronization of Two Tremor-Related Neurons

Signal segmentation and waveform characterization. Biosignal processing, S Autumn 2012

EasyChair Preprint. A Tactile P300 Brain-Computer Interface: Principle and Paradigm

Frequency Domain Analysis for Assessing Fluid Responsiveness by Using Instantaneous Pulse Rate Variability

Development of a New Signal Processing Diagnostic Tool for Vibration Signals Acquired in Transient Conditions

Neural Coding of Multiple Stimulus Features in Auditory Cortex

Rolling Bearing Diagnosis Based on LMD and Neural Network

Feature Extraction of ECG Signal Using HHT Algorithm

Open Access Research of Dielectric Loss Measurement with Sparse Representation

A NEW METHOD FOR FETAL ELECTROCARDIOGRAM DENOISING USING BLIND SOURCE SEPARATION AND EMPIRICAL MODE DECOMPOSITION

Bivariate Empirical Mode Decomposition

MULTI-FAULT ANALYSIS IN INDUCTION MOTORS USING MULTI-SENSOR FEATURES

Gearbox fault detection using a new denoising method based on ensemble empirical mode decomposition and FFT

PSYC696B: Analyzing Neural Time-series Data

Wavelet Transform Based Islanding Characterization Method for Distributed Generation

Multi-target SSVEP-based BCI using Multichannel SSVEP Detection

Vibration-based Fault Detection of Wind Turbine Gearbox using Empirical Mode Decomposition Method

Mode shape reconstruction of an impulse excited structure using continuous scanning laser Doppler vibrometer and empirical mode decomposition

Impact of Time Varying Angular Frequency on the Separation of Instantaneous Power Components in Stand-alone Power Systems

Evoked Potentials (EPs)

Rail Structure Analysis by Empirical Mode Decomposition and Hilbert Huang Transform

Sound Synthesis Methods

Non-Invasive EEG Based Wireless Brain Computer Interface for Safety Applications Using Embedded Systems

Detection, localization, and classification of power quality disturbances using discrete wavelet transform technique

40 Hz Event Related Auditory Potential

The effect of the viewing distance of stimulus on SSVEP response for use in Brain Computer Interfaces

ASSESSMENT OF POWER QUALITY EVENTS BY HILBERT TRANSFORM BASED NEURAL NETWORK. Shyama Sundar Padhi

Analysis and simulation of EEG Brain Signal Data using MATLAB

Tribology in Industry. Bearing Health Monitoring

The study of Interferogram denoising method Based on Empirical Mode Decomposition

A GPU-Based Real- Time Event Detection Framework for Power System Frequency Data Streams

Chaotic Circuits and Encryption

366 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON NEURAL SYSTEMS AND REHABILITATION ENGINEERING, VOL. 19, NO. 4, AUGUST 2011 II. EMPIRICAL MODE DECOMPOSITION ALGORITHM

21/01/2014. Fundamentals of the analysis of neuronal oscillations. Separating sources

A Practical VEP-Based Brain Computer Interface

A Novel Approach to Improve the Smoothening the Wind Profiler Doppler Spectra Using Empirical Mode Decomposition with Moving Average Method

New Additive Wavelet Image Fusion Algorithm for Satellite Images

Introduction to Computational Neuroscience

Seismic application of quality factor estimation using the peak frequency method and sparse time-frequency transforms

SPARSE CHANNEL ESTIMATION BY PILOT ALLOCATION IN MIMO-OFDM SYSTEMS

VOLD-KALMAN ORDER TRACKING FILTERING IN ROTATING MACHINERY

SIMULATING RESTING CORTICAL BACKGROUND ACTIVITY WITH FILTERED NOISE. Journal of Integrative Neuroscience 7(3):

LOCAL MULTISCALE FREQUENCY AND BANDWIDTH ESTIMATION. Hans Knutsson Carl-Fredrik Westin Gösta Granlund

Study and Analysis of Various Window Techniques Used in Removal of High Frequency Noise Associated in Electroencephalogram (EEG)

Transcription:

EMD Approach to Multichannel EEG Data - The Amplitude and Phase Synchrony Analysis Technique Tomasz M. Rutkowski 1, Danilo P. Mandic 2, Andrzej Cichocki 1, and Andrzej W. Przybyszewski 3,4 1 Laboratory for Advanced Brain Signal Processing RIKEN Brain Science Institute, Japan tomek@brain.riken.jp http://www.bsp.brain.riken.jp/ 2 Imperial College London, United Kingdom d.mandic@imperial.ac.uk http://www.commsp.ee.ic.ac.uk/ mandic/ 3 Department of Psychology, McGill University, Montreal, Canada przy@ego.psych.mcgill.ca 4 Department of Neurology, University of Massachusetts Medical School, MA, USA http://www.umassmed.edu/neurology/faculty/przybyszewski.cfm Abstract. Human brains expose the possibility to be connected directly to the intelligent computing applications in form of brain computer/ machine interfacing (BCI/BMI technologies. Neurophysiological signals and especially electroencephalogram (EEG are the forms of brain electrical activity which can be easily captured and utilized for BCI/BMI applications. Those signals are unfortunately highly contaminated by noise due to a very low level of electrophysiological signals and presence of different devices in the environment creating electromagnetic interference. In the proposed approach we first decompose each of the recorded channels, in multichannel EEG recording environment, into intrinsic mode functions (IMF which are a result of empirical mode decomposition (EMD extended to multichannel analysis in this paper. We present novel and interesting results on human mental and cognitive states estimation based on analysis of the above mentioned stimuli-related IMF components. Keywords: EEG; brain synchrony; brain signal processing; EMD application to EEG. 1 Introduction Online brain states analysis based on non-invasive monitoring techniques such us EEG have received much attention recently due to the growing interest and popularity of research related to BCI/BMI techniques, owing to the very exciting possibility of computer-aided communication with the outside world. Also a new and growing interest in neuroscience in so called steady-state potentials [1,2,3], which produce longer in time and more easy to detect within monitored EEG D.-S. Huang et al. (Eds.: ICIC 28, LNCS 226, pp. 122 129, 28. c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 28

EMD Approach to Multichannel EEG Data 123 steady responses contribute also to EEG signal processing popularity. EEG based brain stages monitoring is achieved in a non-invasive recording setup, which poses several important and difficult problems. In terms of signal processing these include the detection, estimation, interpretation and modeling of brain activities, and cross-user transparency [4].Itcomesasnosurprise,therefore, that this technology is envisaged to be at the core of future intelligent computing. Other industries which would benefit greatly from the development of online analysis and visualization of brain states include the prosthetics, entertainment, and computer games industries, where the control and navigation in a computer-aided application is achieved without resorting to using hands, or gestures (peripheral nervous system in general. Instead, the onset of planning an action recorded from the head (scalp surface, and the relevant information is decoded from this information carrier. Apart from purely signal conditioning problems, in most BCI/BMI experiments other issues such us user training and adaptation, which inevitably causes difficulties and limits in wide spread of this technology due to the lack of generality caused by cross-user differences [4]. To help mitigate some of the above mentioned issues, we propose to make use of a new and growing in interest in signal processing community technique of Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD [] which we extend to multichannel approach of parallel decomposition of single channel signals and further comparison of obtained components among channels to track coherent (synchronized activities in complex signals as EEG. In the proposed approach, we analyze responses from experiments based on a visual stimuli which were conducted with in Laboratory for Advanced Brain Signal Processing, BSI RIKEN, within the so-called Steady State Visual Evoked Potential (SSVEP mode [1,6]. Within this framework, the subjects are asked to focus their attention on simple flashing stimuli, whose frequency is known to cause a physiologically stable response traceable within EEG [6,7]. This way, the proposed multichannel and multimodal signal decomposition scheme uses the EEG captured by several electrodes, subsequently preprocessed, and transformed into informative time-frequency traces, which very accurately visualize frequency and amplitude modulations of the original signal. EEG is usually characterized as a summation of post-synaptic potentials from a very large number of neurons which create oscillatory patterns distributed and possible to record around the scalp. Those patterns in the known frequency ranges can be monitored and classified in synchrony to a stimuli given to the subjects. EMD utilizes empirical knowledge of oscillations intrinsic to a time series in order to represent them as a into superposition of components with well defined instantaneous frequencies. These components are called intrinsic mode functions (IMF. This paper is organized as follows. First the method of single channel EMD analysis of EEG signals is presented. Next multichannel EEG analysis and decomposition is discussed leading to a novel time frequency synchrony evaluation method. A new concept of multiple spatially localized amplitude and frequency oscillations related to presented stimuli in time-frequency domain is descirbed

124 T.M. Rutkowski et al. which let us obtain final traces of frequency and amplitude ridges. Finally examples of the analysis of the EEG signals are given and conclusions are drawn. 2 Methods We aim at looking at the level of detail (richness of information source obtainable from single experimental trial EEG signals, and compare the usefulness of a novel multichannel signal decomposition approach in this context. The utilized approach is based on multichannel extension of the EMD technique which was previously successfully applied to EEG sonification in [1,2,3]. The EMD approach rests on the identification of signal s non-stationary and non-linear features which represent different modalities of brain activity captured by the EEG data acquisition system (g.usbamp R of Guger Technologies. This novel method allowed us previosly to create slowly modulated tones representing changing brain activities among different human scalp locations where EEG electrodes were localized. In the current application we propose to look at the level of details revealed in single EEG channels decomposed separately into IMFs as discussed in detail in the next section and later compared across the multiple channels. After application of Hilbert transform to all IMFs we can track and visualize revealed oscillations of amplitude and frequency ridges. Similarity of these oscillations among channels revealed in form of pairwise correlations identify components which are synchronized or not with the onsets and offsets of the presented stimuli. The proposed approach is the completely data driven concept. All the IMFs create semi-orthogonal bases created from the original EEG signals and not introduced artificially by the method itself. 2.1 Empirical Mode Decomposition for EEG Analysis - A Single Channel Case The IMF components obtained during EMD analysis should approximately obey the requirements of (i completeness; (ii orthogonality; (iii locality; (iv adaptiveness []. To obtain an IMF it is necessary to remove local riding waves and asymmetries, which are estimated from local envelope of minima and maxima of the waveform. There are several approaches to estimate signals envelopes and we discussed them previously [3]. The Hilbert spectrum for a particular IMF allows us later to represent the EEG in amplitude - instantaneous frequency - time plane. An IMF shall satisfy the two conditions: (i in the whole data set, the number of extrema and the number of zero crossings should be equal or differ at most by one; (ii at any point of IMF the mean value of the envelope defined by the local maxima and the envelope defined by the local minima should be zero. The technique of finding IMFs corresponds thus to finding limited-band signals. It also corresponds to eliminating riding-waves from the signal, which ensures that the instantaneous frequency will not have fluctuations caused by an asymmetric wave form. IMF in each cycle is defined by the zero crossings. Every IMF involves

EMD Approach to Multichannel EEG Data 12 only one mode of oscillation, no complex riding waves are thus allowed. Notice that the IMF is not limited to be a narrow band signal, as it would be in traditional Fourier or wavelets decomposition, in fact, it can be both amplitude and frequency modulated at once, and also non-stationary or non-linear. The process of IMF extraction from a signal x(t ( sifting process [] is based on the following steps: 1. determine the local maxima and minima of the analyzed signal x(t; 2. generate the upper and lower signal envelopes by connecting those local maxima and minima respectively by the chosen interpolation method (e.g., linear, spline, cubic spline, piece-wise spline [3,]; 3. determine the local mean m(t, by averaging the upper and lower signal envelopes; 4. subtract the local mean from the data: h 1 (t =x(t m 1 (t. Ideally, h 1 (t is an IMF candidate. However, in practice, h 1 (t may still contain local asymmetric fluctuations, e.g., undershoots and overshoots; therefore, one needs to repeat the above four steps several times, resulting eventually in the first (optimized IMF. In order to obtain the second IMF, one applies the sifting process to the residue ε 1 (t =x(t IMF 1 (t, obtained by subtracting the first IMF from x(t; the third IMF is in turn extracted from the residue ε 2 (t and so on. One stops extracting IMFs when two consecutive sifting results are close to identical; the empirical mode decomposition of the signal x(t may be written as: x(t = n IMF k (t+ε n (t, (1 k=1 where n is the number of extracted IMFs, and the final residue ε n (t can either be the mean trend or a constant. The EMD is obviously complete, since (1 is an equality: the original signal can be reconstructed by adding all IMFs and the final residue. Note that the IMFs are not guaranteed to be mutually orthogonal, but in practice, they often are close to orthogonal [3]; it is also noteworthy that the IMFs are adaptive, i.e., they depend on the signal x(t as anticipated for the data driven method. 2.2 Hunang-Hilbert Spectra with Amplitude and Frequency Ridges From the obtained in previous section IMFs corresponding time frequency representations can be produced by applying the Hilbert transform to each component []. As a result of Hilbert transform application to each IMF the data can be expressed time-frequency domain as: R(t = n k=1 ( IMF k (texp i ω k (tdt, (2 where IMF k are obtained as above discussed and ω j is an instantaneous frequency. The Hilbert transform allows us to depict the variable amplitude (Figure 1(d and

126 T.M. Rutkowski et al. 1 1 EEG signal 2 4 6 8 1..37.2.12 Hilbert Huang time frequency distribution. 26 21 782 143 12 1 8 6 4 2 1 1 2 4 6 8 1..37.2.12. 26 21 782 143 12 1 8 6 4 2 1 1 2 4 6 8 1..37.2.12. 26 21 782 143 12 1 8 6 4 2 1 1 2 4 6 8 1..37.2.12. 26 21 782 143 12 1 8 6 4 2 (a Time domain preprocessed EEG. (b Huang-Hilbert spectra...37.2.12 Frequency ridges. 26 21 782 143..37.2.12. 26 21 782 143..37.2.12. 26 21 782 143..37.2.12. 26 21 782 143 1 1 Amplitude ridges 26 21 782 143 1 1 26 21 782 143 1 1 26 21 782 143 1 1 26 21 782 143 (c Frequency ridge traces. (d Amplitude ridge traces Fig. 1. Four plots of four EEG channels in each panel recorded synchronously during SSVEP experiment. The steady-state response can be visually spotted in the range of 1 6 samples. Panel (a presents time domain EEG preprocessed plots; (b their Huang-Hilbert spectra; (c and (d the frequency and amplitude ridges in Hilbert spectra domain (solid line: first; dashed line: second; dotted line:third; dash-dotted line: fourth IMF respectively.

EMD Approach to Multichannel EEG Data 127 the instantaneous frequency (Figure 1(c in the form of very sharp and localized functions of frequency and time (in contrast to Fourier expansion, for example, where frequencies and amplitudes are fixed for its bases. Such an approach is very suitable for the non-stationary EEG analysis and common/sychronized activities within certain channels. An example of Huang-Hilbert spectrograms of four EEG channels recorded simultaneously is presented in Figure 1(b. 2.3 EMD Application to to Multichannel EEG Signals Using the above procedure in a single channel mode the EEG signals from chosen electrodes could be decomposed separately forming subsets of IMF functions, from which low frequency drifts and high frequency spikes could be further removed. The most interesting part of EEG is usually in the middle range frequencies. To analyze multichannel EEG signal sets recorded synchronously in a single experiment we propose to decompose all channels separately preventing possible oscillatory information leaking among the channels. The so obtained IMFs sets can be further EEG(Fpz EEG(F7 EEG(F8 EEG(TP7 EEG(TP8 EEG(O1 EEG(O2 2 2 4 4 2 2 4 2 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 original EEG 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 AR(TP7 AR(F8 AR(F7 AR(Fpz AR(TP8 AR(O1 AR(O2 two amplitude ridges 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 FR(TP7 FR(F8 FR(F7 FR(Fpz FR(TP8 FR(O1 FR(O2....... two frequency ridges 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 2 4 6 Fig. 2. The result showing the power of the proposed method to analyze multichannel EEG recordings. The first column shows noisy EEG signals, while the second and third columns depict only amplitude (AR and frequency (FR traces of components synchronized with the stimuli and subsequently correlated among channels (solid line for the first and dashed line for the second IMF synchronized with the stimuli.

128 T.M. Rutkowski et al. compared as in case of four EEG signals presented in Figure 1(a which are further EMD decomposed and visualized in form of Huang-Hilbert spectrograms [] as in Figure 1(b. The traces of amplitude and frequency modulations ridges [8] obtained from Hilbert transformation of separately processed IMFs and further plotted together are presented in Figures 1(d and 1(c respectively. Ridges are the continues traces within spectrograms of frequency and amplitude oscillations as first introduced in [8]. The areas of steady-state stimulation can be easily spotted in amplitude traces of a single IMF on all channels in Figure 1(d and subsequently in form of stable frequency ridge during stimulation with very strong oscillations before and after the stimuli in all channels as in Figure 1(c. The combined result of analysis of seven EEG channels from locations around the human head during similar SSVEP stimuli BCI/BMI paradigm is shown also in Figure 2. There are seven time domain EEG traces plotted with only two amplitude (AR and frequency (FR ridges of the only components showing synchrony with the stimuli. Those components were chosen based on cross-channel correlation of IMFs showing again that the proposed multichannel EMD analysis is useful for spotting steady-state responses from noisy EEG based on amplitude and frequency modulations synchrony. 3 Conclusions A new approach to extend a single channel EMD approach to EEG signals analysis with steady-state responses perfectly suited for further BCI/BMI application is presented. We propose to decompose EEG signals separately to obtain sets of IMF components. The proposed analysis of multichannel Hilbert-Huang domain frequency and amplitude ridges together with their subsequent correlation among channels during the steady-state stimuli presentation revealed a possibility to identify different brain states related to the stimuli. This allows us to detect from a very noisy and single trial EEG signals the time slots when stimuli was presented to the subjects. Such approach is perfectly suited to steady-state stimuli based BCI/BMI applications where online markers of users changes of attention to different external stimuli is sought. Acknowledgements. This work was supported in part by JSPS and Royal Society under the Japan-UK Research Cooperative Program, 27 & 28. References 1. Rutkowski, T.M., Vialatte, F., Cichocki, A., Mandic, D., Barros, A.K.: Auditory Feedback for Brain Computer Interface Management - An EEG Data Sonification Approach. In: Gabrys, B., Howlett, R.J., Jain, L.C. (eds. KES 26. LNCS (LNAI, vol. 423, pp. 1232 1239. Springer, Heidelberg (26 2. Rutkowski, T.M., Cichocki, A., Ralescu, A.L., Mandic, D.P.: Emotional States Estimation from Multichannel EEG Maps. In: Wang, R., Gu, F., Shen, E. (eds. Advances in Cognitive Neurodynamics ICCN 27 - Proceedings of the International Conference on Cognitive Neurodynamics. Neuroscience, Springer, Heidelberg (in press, 28

EMD Approach to Multichannel EEG Data 129 3. Rutkowski, T.M., Cichocki, A., Mandic, D.P.: EMDsonic - An Empirical Mode Decomposition Based Brain Signal Activity Sonification Approach. Information Technology: Transmission, Processing and Storage. In: Signal Processing Techniques for Knowledge Extraction and Information Fusion, February 28, pp. 261 274. Springer, Heidelberg (28 4. Wolpaw, J.R., Birbaumer, N., McFarland, D.J., Pfurtscheller, G., Vaughan, T.M.: Brain-computer Interfaces for Communication and Control. Clinical Neurophysiology 113, 767 791 (22. Huang, N., Shen, Z., Long, S., Wu, M., Shih, H., Zheng, Q., Yen, N.C., Tung, C., Liu, H.: The Empirical Mode Decomposition and the Hilbert Spectrum for Nonlinear and Non-stationary Time Series Analysis. In: Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, March 1998, vol. 44, pp. 93 99 (1998 6. Kelly, S.P., Lalor, E.C., Finucane, C., McDarby, G., Reilly, R.B.: Visual Spatial Attention Control in an Independent Brain-computer Interface. IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 2(9, 188 196 (2 7. Niedermeyer, E., Da Silva, F.L. (eds.: Electroencephalography: Basic Principles, Clinical Applications, and Related Fields, th edn. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins (24 8. Przybyszewski, A.W., Rutkowski, T.M.: Processing of the Incomplete Representation of The Visual World. In: Hryniewicz, O., Kacpryzk, J., Koronacki, J., Wierzchon, S. (eds. Issues in Intelligent Systems Paradigms. Problemy Wspolczesnej Nauki - Teoria i Zastosowania - Informatyka, pp. 22 23. Akademicka Oficyna Wydawnicza EXIT, Warsaw, Poland (2