Index Modulation with PAPR and Beamforming for 5G MIMO-OFDM

Similar documents
INTERFERENCE SELF CANCELLATION IN SC-FDMA SYSTEMS -A CAMPARATIVE STUDY

IJMIE Volume 2, Issue 4 ISSN:

PROGRESSIVE CHANNEL ESTIMATION FOR ULTRA LOW LATENCY MILLIMETER WAVE COMMUNICATIONS

Study of Performance Evaluation of Quasi Orthogonal Space Time Block Code MIMO-OFDM System in Rician Channel for Different Modulation Schemes

Performance Study of MIMO-OFDM System in Rayleigh Fading Channel with QO-STB Coding Technique

Lecture LTE (4G) -Technologies used in 4G and 5G. Spread Spectrum Communications

Performance Evaluation of STBC-OFDM System for Wireless Communication

Millimeter-Wave Communication and Mobile Relaying in 5G Cellular Networks

NR Physical Layer Design: NR MIMO

MATLAB COMMUNICATION TITLES

Hybrid Index Modeling Model for Memo System with Ml Sub Detector

Investigation on Multiple Antenna Transmission Techniques in Evolved UTRA. OFDM-Based Radio Access in Downlink. Features of Evolved UTRA and UTRAN

UNIFIED DIGITAL AUDIO AND DIGITAL VIDEO BROADCASTING SYSTEM USING ORTHOGONAL FREQUENCY DIVISION MULTIPLEXING (OFDM) SYSTEM

DESIGN, IMPLEMENTATION AND OPTIMISATION OF 4X4 MIMO-OFDM TRANSMITTER FOR

CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION

A Research Concept on Bit Rate Detection using Carrier offset through Analysis of MC-CDMA SYSTEM

SPARSE CHANNEL ESTIMATION BY PILOT ALLOCATION IN MIMO-OFDM SYSTEMS

Evaluation of BER and PAPR by using Different Modulation Schemes in OFDM System

2.

CHAPTER 3 ADAPTIVE MODULATION TECHNIQUE WITH CFO CORRECTION FOR OFDM SYSTEMS

Field Experiments of 2.5 Gbit/s High-Speed Packet Transmission Using MIMO OFDM Broadband Packet Radio Access

What s Behind 5G Wireless Communications?

Technical Aspects of LTE Part I: OFDM

BER Analysis for MC-CDMA

Techniques for Mitigating the Effect of Carrier Frequency Offset in OFDM

AWGN Channel Performance Analysis of QO-STB Coded MIMO- OFDM System

OFDM AS AN ACCESS TECHNIQUE FOR NEXT GENERATION NETWORK

Lecture 13. Introduction to OFDM

2015 The MathWorks, Inc. 1

Performance Evaluation of OFDM System with Rayleigh, Rician and AWGN Channels

A Novel of Low Complexity Detection in OFDM System by Combining SLM Technique and Clipping and Scaling Method Jayamol Joseph, Subin Suresh

Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing & Measurement of its Performance

Webpage: Volume 4, Issue V, May 2016 ISSN

Clipping and Filtering Technique for reducing PAPR In OFDM

Simulative Investigations for Robust Frequency Estimation Technique in OFDM System

Implementation and Comparative analysis of Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) Signaling Rashmi Choudhary

A New PAPR Reduction in OFDM Systems Using SLM and Orthogonal Eigenvector Matrix

Carrier Frequency Offset Estimation Algorithm in the Presence of I/Q Imbalance in OFDM Systems

PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF WIMAX SYSTEM USING CONVOLUTIONAL PRODUCT CODE (CPC)

Channel Estimation for Downlink LTE System Based on LAGRANGE Polynomial Interpolation

Performance Analysis of OFDM for Different Digital Modulation Schemes using Matlab Simulation

Analysis of Interference & BER with Simulation Concept for MC-CDMA

Page 1. Overview : Wireless Networks Lecture 9: OFDM, WiMAX, LTE

Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM)

Peak-to-Average Power Ratio (PAPR)

5G NR: Key Features and Enhancements An overview of 5G NR key technical features and enhancements for massive MIMO, mmwave, etc.

Interleaved PC-OFDM to reduce the peak-to-average power ratio

University of Bristol - Explore Bristol Research. Link to publication record in Explore Bristol Research PDF-document.

Multi-Carrier Systems

Underwater communication implementation with OFDM

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PURE AND APPLIED RESEARCH IN ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY

Hybrid PTS-Clipping Scheme for PAPR Reduction in MIMO-OFDM Systems

Iterative Clipping and Filtering Technique for PAPR Reduction in OFDM System without Encoding

On the Spectral Efficiency of MIMO MC-CDMA System

MIMO I: Spatial Diversity

PAPR Reduction in SLM Scheme using Exhaustive Search Method

Multiple Antenna Processing for WiMAX

Space Time Block Coding - Spatial Modulation for Multiple-Input Multiple-Output OFDM with Index Modulation System

Image Transmission over OFDM System with Minimum Peak to Average Power Ratio (PAPR)

Filter Bank Multi-Carrier (FBMC) for Future Wireless Systems

PAPR Reduction techniques in OFDM System Using Clipping & Filtering and Selective Mapping Methods

Performance analysis of OFDM with QPSK using AWGN and Rayleigh Fading Channel

Auxiliary Beam Pair Enabled AoD Estimation for Large-scale mmwave MIMO Systems

Study of Turbo Coded OFDM over Fading Channel

[Gupta, 3(3): March, 2014] ISSN: Impact Factor: 1.852

Evaluation of Kalman Filtering Based Channel Estimation for LTE-Advanced

TECHNOLOGY : MATLAB DOMAIN : COMMUNICATION

5G new radio architecture and challenges

PAPR Reduction in 4G Cellular Network: A SLM-based IFDMA Uplink System

Performance Analysis of Cognitive Radio based WRAN over Rayleigh Fading Channel with Alamouti-STBC 2X1, 2X2&2X4 Multiplexing

5G, WLAN, and LTE Wireless Design with MATLAB

Channel Estimation by 2D-Enhanced DFT Interpolation Supporting High-speed Movement

PAPR Reduction in an OFDM system using Recursive Clipping and Filtering Technique

UNDERSTANDING LTE WITH MATLAB

Broadband OFDM-FDMA System for the Uplink of a Wireless LAN

4x4 Time-Domain MIMO encoder with OFDM Scheme in WIMAX Context

Adaptive Modulation and Coding for LTE Wireless Communication

Interference management Within 3GPP LTE advanced

Performance Comparison of Channel Estimation Technique using Power Delay Profile for MIMO OFDM

II. OFDM SYSTEM MODEL

ISSN: ISO 9001:2008 Certified International Journal of Engineering and Innovative Technology (IJEIT) Volume 4, Issue 12, June 2015

Comb type Pilot arrangement based Channel Estimation for Spatial Multiplexing MIMO-OFDM Systems

Performance Analysis of Ofdm Transceiver using Gmsk Modulation Technique

Performance Evaluation of LTE-Advanced Channel Estimation Techniques in Vehicular Environments

Performance Analysis of ICI in OFDM systems using Self-Cancellation and Extended Kalman Filtering

Performance Improvement of OFDM System using Raised Cosine Windowing with Variable FFT Sizes

PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF PARTIAL RANSMIT SEQUENCE USING FOR PAPR REDUCTION IN OFDM SYSTEMS

Background: Cellular network technology

Basic idea: divide spectrum into several 528 MHz bands.

Algorithm to Improve the Performance of OFDM based WLAN Systems

Comparison of ML and SC for ICI reduction in OFDM system

BER Performance of CRC Coded LTE System for Various Modulation Schemes and Channel Conditions

Chapter 0 Outline. NCCU Wireless Comm. Lab

Hardware implementation of Zero-force Precoded MIMO OFDM system to reduce BER

Effects of Nonlinearity on DFT-OFDM and DWT-OFDM Systems

Frequency-Domain Equalization for SC-FDE in HF Channel

Optimization of Data Allocation in Of dm System

Summary of the PhD Thesis

Volume 2, Issue 9, September 2014 International Journal of Advance Research in Computer Science and Management Studies

PAPR REDUCTION TECHNIQUE USING MODIFIED SLM IN OFDM SYSTEM

Transcription:

Index Modulation with PAPR and Beamforming for 5G MIMO-OFDM Ankur Vora and Kyoung-Don Kang State University of New York at Binghamton, NY, USA. {avora4, kang}@binghamton.edu Abstract Although key techniques for next-generation wireless communication have been explored separately, relatively little work has been done to investigate their potential cooperation for performance optimization. To address this problem, we propose a holistic framework for robust 5G communication based on multiple-input-multiple-output (MIMO) orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM). More specifically, we design a new framework that supports: 1) index modulation based on OFDM (OFDM M) [1]; 2) sub-band beamforming and channel estimation to achieve massive path gains by exploiting multiple antenna arrays [2]; and 3) sub-band pre-distortion for peak-to-average-power-ratio (PAPR) reduction [3] to significantly decrease the PAPR and communication errors in OFDM- IM by supporting a linear behavior of the power amplifier in the modem. The performance of the proposed framework is evaluated against the state-of-the-art, OFDM- and -spatiotemporal -ST [2] schemes. The results show that our framework reduces the bit error rate (BER), mean square error (MSE) and PAPR compared to the baselines by approximately 6 13dB, 8 13dB, and 50%, respectively. I. INTRODUCTION International Mobile Telecommunication (IMT) has set ambitious goals for year 2020 and beyond, called IMT- 2020, and announced its use-cases, such as enhanced mobile broadband (embb), massive machine type communication (mmtc) and ultra-reliable low latency communication (URLLC) [4]. To achieve these goals, robust communication between a user equipment (UE) and the base station (enodeb) is required. Although key technologies for 5G have been studied separately, relatively little work has been done to explore an overarching framework that seamlessly integrates them to significantly enhance the overall performance by creating synergy. To bridge this gap, we design robust wireless communication framework by leveraging advanced 5G techniques: 1) OFDM-; 2) sub-band beamforming and channel estimation [2] and; 3) PAPR reduction [3]. First, we apply the OFDM-IM technology [1] to significantly reduce the computational cost for inverse fast Fourier transform (IFFT) and fast Fourier transform (FFT) at a UE modem and base station, respectively. In a conventional OFDM-based modem, IFFT/FFT is the most computationally expensive operation [5], because it is designed to modulate data for full size IFFT/FFT regardless of the number of active bit streams that actually deliver data. If there are fewer data, it pads dummy data bits for full IFFT/FFT operations, wasting computational resources and energy. To address this problem, we apply a novel OFDM-IM technique [1] that can dynamically adjust the number of parallel IFFT/FFT operations considering the number of incoming bit streams. Second, we extend an effective OFDM-IM scheme [1] by applying the PAPR reduction method presented in [3] to avoid signal degradation. PAPR reduction for OFDM has gained significant attention for decades; however, much less attention has been paid to PAPR reduction for OFDM-IM. Popular PAPR reduction techniques, such as peak insertion, clipping, windowing, scrambling, block coding, and selective mapping, are mainly optimized for large amounts of data to minimize the PAPR affect [6, 7, 8, 9]. In case of mmtc and URLLC, the OFDM-IM usually deals with small amounts of data. Hence, we need an efficient PAPR technique that focuses on normalizing the power amplifier rather than tuning OFDM symbols. In this paper, we apply a novel sub-band pre-distortion PAPR reduction technique [3], which normalizes the power level of the power amplifier in the digital-to-analog-converter (DAC), for robust communication via OFDM-IM. Further, our framework supports beamforming and channel estimation to ensure a reliable communication in 5G, to support mmtc and embb use cases of IMT-2020. The channel noise, fading, multi-path effects, and delay are the main challenges in 5G and mmwave communication [10]. A plenty of work has been done to address these challenges for OFDM via beamforming and channel estimation [10, 11, 12, 13]. To the best of our knowledge, however, beamforming for OFDM-IM has not been investigated yet. Sridhar et al [2] presented a novel spatiotemporal MIMO beamforming method with channel estimation to estimate the delay, direction of arrival (DoA), velocity and fading coefficients of the desired signal path. By leveraging it to enhance OFDM-IM, we significantly decrease the BER and MSE of the system. The performance of the proposed framework is thoroughly evaluated against the existing, OFDM- and spatiotemporal (-ST) [2] schemes. Our framework reduces the BER, MSE and PAPR compared to the baselines by approximately 6 12dB, 8 13dB, and 50%, respectively. By taking a holistic approach, we significantly improve BER, MSE, and PAPR compared to the advanced OFDM- and -ST [2] schemes as well as the generic technique. The rest of this paper is organized as follows. Section II discusses the proposed system framework followed by performance evaluation in section III. The paper is concluded in Section IV.

II. ROBUST COMMUNICATION FRAMEWORK In this section, an overview of our proposed framework is given. Further, OFDM-IM, PAPR reduction, and beamforming and channel estimation are discussed. A. System Overview In Figure 1, the overall structure of our framework for efficient downlink communication from a base station to UEs is depicted. Our framework executes the following steps. 1) Data streams may come from one or more source to the transmitter, i.e., the base station. To distinguish them from each other, we multiply each of them with a unique pseudo-noise (PN) code. The bit splitter in Figure 1 divides these data streams into a small number of groups of a fixed size. 2) The index selector block chooses active subcarriers only. 3) The OFDM-IM modulator block modulates the active subcarriers selected by the index selector block using the mapping table stored in the corresponding mappers. Subsequently, it applies IFFT to the streams and adds a cyclic prefix (CP) to each stream to generate a subblock of symbols, similar to OFDM. 4) The PAPR reduction block pre-distorts the modulated frames in such a way that the net effect of PA becomes linear. To support beamforming, it multiplies symbols with the channel state information (CSI) matrix received from the UE. Next, it applies DAC to these streams to transmit them using an array of N T x antennas. 5) At a receiver (i.e., a UE), ADC is performed to the signal received through the antenna array with N Rx antennas and then channel estimation is applied to estimate the delay, velocity, DoA and channel coefficients. In this way, the receiver estimates the transmitted signal. 6) The OFDM-IM demodulator leverages the maximum likelyhood detector to predict and cancel potential noise in the transmitted symbol estimated by the channel estimator. Next, the OFDM-IM demodulator demaps the symbol using the mapping table stored on the receiver side, applies FFT, and removes the CP. After this step, the original data stream is recovered if it is transmitted and received with no error. B. Index Modulation The main advantage of the MIMO OFDM-IM technique [1] over OFDM is that it selects and maps only the active subcarriers out of the incoming bit streams and applies IFFT/FFT to them to avoid unnecessary computations for any inactive subcarriers. When i different bit streams arrive at the modem on the transmitter side from one or more sources as shown in Figure 1, each of these data streams is multiplied with a unique PN code to distinguish it from the others. (The PN code also aids in beamforming which is discussed in Section II-D.) The entire PN coded active data streams, (S 1,..., S i ), goes through the bit-splitter in Figure 1, which divides the incoming bits into g groups. Notably, we do not add dummy values unlike the standard OFDM. Given that, we have g = d/p groups, since there are total p bits per group. Bits Indices Subblock [0 0] {1,2} [s 1 s 2 0 0] [0 1] {2,3} [0 s 1 s 2 0] [1 0] {3,4} [0 0 s 1 s 2 ] [1 1] {1,4} [s 1 0 0 s 2 ] TABLE I: Mapping Table for OFDM-IM Let N and n represent the total number of subcarriers and the total number of sub-blocks in each subcarrier in the OFDM-IM modulator, respectively. Each bit stream is transmitted using one sub-block of a subcarrier. To place bits in a sub-block, the OFDM-IM modulator uses the symbol table as shown in Table I that modulates two bits at a time. As a simple example, 00 bits are placed in the first and second place in the subblock according to the indexes in the second column in Table I. After that, they are modulated by the OFDM-IM unit that produces symbols. Next, IFFT is performed and a CP is added, similar to conventional OFDM. C. PAPR Reduction A high PAPR is one of the major drawbacks of a multicarrier MIMO-OFDM system compared to a single carrier system, since it may decrease the spectrum and power efficiency, potentially increasing the BER and MSE. In this paper, we apply an efficient PAPR reduction method [3] to address this issue. Let S i denote the number of bit streams entering the OFDM-IM module in Figure 1, the bandwidth B of the downlink, the frequency of a sub-band that carries a subblock, and the time duration of a single frame, respectively. A key operation in PAPR reduction is shifting each frame by t at time t. Since we have already applied IFFT in the OFDM-IM module, each stream S i is transformed to the frequency domain. Thus, we time-shift the stream in the frequency domain, S i, as follows: S i (t + t) [ S i e j2πb(t+ t)] (1) After this, we up-convert j, if j is not higher than the pre-defined intermediate frequency f i : { j f i if j f i j up = (2) j otherwise Subsequently, j up is used to create a frame. Finally, all frames are combined in the binary search tree with depth log 2 N. By iteratively adding all the subframes pre-distorted as discussed above in the binary tree, we generate a linear amplitude for each stream for power amplification. Next, the base station performs DAC and transmits the signal of each bit stream to the UE that requested the data in the direction it received the CSI together with the data request from the UE via beamforming.(a description of beamforming is given in Subsection II-D.)

Fig. 1: Proposed End-to-End Framework On the other hand, the receiver needs to detect the active bit streams sent from the base station to itself and the corresponding symbols. The same mapping table used in the base station is deployed at the receivers (UEs) to de-map and extract the symbols. Each receiver uses the mapping table and maximum likelihood detector to detect the locations of the symbols in the received frame. D. Beamforming and Channel Estimation In this paper, we apply beamforming technique to provide a directional radiation pattern by changing either the amplitude or phase of the signal in the desired direction towards UE. Also, beamforming requires the receiver to perform channel estimation to find the DoA, velocity, delay and noise coefficients of the received signal to ensure the reliable decoding of the signal. Although beamforming and channel estimation have been extensively studied in the past decade, we apply an advanced technique [2], which can provide up to 15dB improvement in terms of BER over traditional MIMO systems and is scalable up to a 500 antenna array. 1) Beamforming: The base station needs to transmit a signal to one or more UE. For reliable communication, it applies beamforming towards individual UEs as discussed before. In our framework, a UE needs to send a CSI matrix w to the base station before beginning a transmission, similar to LTE. The base station transmits the signal that has an embedded unique PN code for each UE. Further, the CSI matrix w received from the UE is concatenated at the end of the signal. The receiver listens to the direction in which it initially sent the CSI and searches for the signal that has the corresponding PN code and w. 2) Channel Estimation: In multicarrier MIMO-OFDM system, a receiver has multiple receiving antennas (N rx antennas) that try to estimate the transmitted signals. An individual antenna scans for the signal with the unique PN sequence code c and w for the corresponding UE. Also, the channel estimator extracts the delay, velocity, DoA and channel fading coefficients from each antenna to extract the desired signal coming from the N T x transmitting antennas by filtering noise out. A signal is often transmitted through multiple different paths in the air and is affected by noise. Thus, we jointly estimate the delay and velocity of each path and then derive the DoA, similar to [2]. Once we have finished estimating the delay, velocity and DoA of the signal received through multiple paths, the UE combines them to find the channel coefficients using the maximum likelihood method. Finally, the OFDM-IM demodulator detects the symbols using the mapping table as discussed in Subsection II-B. The remaining steps are exactly a reverse process to that of OFDM-IM discussed in Subsection II-B. III. PERFORMANCE EVALUATION In MATLAB, the performance of the proposed framework is evaluated and compared against three state-of-the-art baselines: 1) the modulation scheme, 2) the OFDM-IM method [1] and 3) the channel estimation technique [2]. In this section, they are called, OFDM-IM and - ST, respectively. All the baselines and our approach are evaluated for four antenna array configurations: 2x2, 4x4, 6x6 and 8x8 (N T x N Rx ). In this paper, they are evaluated in terms of BER, MSE and PAPR. The BER and MSE are commonly used to ensure the reliability of a communication system. The BER measures the error rate of the bits received over a communication channel. The MSE is the average of the squared difference between the estimated and measured errors. The BER and MSE are largely affected by several factors, such as noise, synchronization error, phase offset, fading, delay, velocity and DoA. Each performance result presented in this paper is the mean of 1000 Monte Carlo simulations. 2x2 4x4 6x6 8x8 12dB 10dB 10dB 10dB OFDM-IM 6dB 8dB 8dB 8dB -ST 12dB 12dB 12dB 13dB TABLE II: BER improvement over the baselines Figure 2 shows the BER of the proposed framework and the three baselines. Table II summarizes the average

-ST [2] 0 5 5 20 25 30 35 40 (a) BER for 2*2 Antenna Array OFDM- -ST [2] (a) MSE for 2*2 Antenna Array -ST [2] (b) BER for 4*4 Antenna Array OFDM- -ST [2] (b) MSE for 4*4 Antenna Array -ST [2] (c) BER for 6*6 Antenna Array OFDM- -ST [2] (c) MSE for 6*6 Antenna Array -ST [2] 0 5 5 20 25 30 35 40 45 (d) BER for 8*8 Antenna Array Fig. 2: BER Analysis Results OFDM- -ST [2] (d) MSE for 8*8 Antenna Array Fig. 3: MSE Analysis Results

OFDM- -ST [2] (a) PAPR for 2*2 Antenna Array OFDM- -ST [2] (b) PAPR for 4*4 Antenna Array OFDM- -ST [2] (c) PAPR for 6*6 Antenna Array OFDM- -ST [2] (d) PAPR for 8*8 Antenna Array Fig. 4: PAPR Analysis Results 2x2 4x4 6x6 8x8 13dB 13dB 13dB 12dB OFDM-IM 11dB 11dB 11dB 10dB -ST 8dB 8dB 8dB 8dB TABLE III: MSE improvement over the baselines BER reduction of our approach over the baselines for each tested antenna configuration. From them, we observe that our approach significantly decreases the BER; it improves BER over, OFDM-IM and -ST by up to 12dB, 8dB and 13dB, respectively. Figure 3 plots the MSE of all the tested approaches. Also, Table III summarizes the average MSE enhancement of our approach over the baselines for each tested antenna configuration. Based on these results, we observe that our framework decreases the MSE over, OFDM-IM and -ST by up to 13dB, 11dB and 8dB, respectively. In addition, we measure the PAPR of all the tested approaches. This is important, because multicarrier systems generally have a higher PAPR than single carrier systems do. A high PAPR may degrade the overall system performance by decreasing the signal-to-quantization noise ratio (SQNR) due to the reduced efficiency of ADC and DAC. As shown in Figure 4, our approach reduces the PAPR by more than 50% (approximately 6V) for all the antenna configurations compared to, OFDM-IM and -ST. Overall, our holistic approach significantly reduces the BER, MSE and PAPR over not only but also advanced OFDM- and -ST [2]. This is because, in the proposed communication system, the index modulation considering the number of active bit streams, sub-band beamforming and channel estimation to achieve massive path gains by exploiting multiple antenna array [2], and peakto-average-power-ratio (PAPR) reduction schemes usually investigated separately cooperate with each other for robust communication and PAPR reduction. IV. CONCLUSION The upcoming 5G system requires robust communication. Although key techniques for 5G communication have been explored separately, relatively little work has been done to explore their potential cooperation for performance optimization. To address this problem, we propose a systematic approach for robust 5G communication based on MIMO OFDM by leveraging index modulation for OFDM [1], subband beamforming and channel estimation [2], and sub-band pre-distortion for PAPR reduction [3]. In addition to seamlessly integrating them, we apply beamforming and channel estimation to OFDM-IM, which has not been attempted before to our knowledge. The performance of the proposed framework is evaluated against the state-of-the-art, OFDM- and -ST [2] schemes. The results show that our framework significantly reduces the BER, MSE and PAPR compared to the baselines by approximately 6 13dB, 8 13dB, and 50%, respectively. In the future, we will continue to investigate how to enhance the robustness and reduce the PAPR further.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work was supported, in part, by NSF grant CNS- 1526932. REFERENCES [1] Ertugrul Basar. Index modulation techniques for 5G wireless networks. In: IEEE Communications Magazine. 2016. [2] Vidhya Sridhar, Thibaud Gabillard, and Athanassios Manikas. Spatiotemporal-MIMO Channel Estimator and Beamformer for 5G. In: IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications. 2016. [3] Feng Lu et al. Sub-Band Pre-Distortion for PAPR Reduction in Spectral Efficient 5G Mobile Fronthaul. In: IEEE Photonics Technology Letters. 2017. [4] ITU. Recommendation ITU-R M.2083-0 Policy on Intellectual Property Right (IPR) Series of ITU-R Recommendations. In: (). [5] Taewon Hwang et al. OFDM and Its Wireless Applications: A Survey. In: IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology. 2009. [6] C Matrakidis. Multicarrier Transmission Peak-toaverage Power Reduction Using Simple Block Code - Electronics Letters. In: vol. 34. 10. 1998, pp. 953 954. [7] Xiaojing Huang, Y. Jay Guo, and John D. Bunton. A hybrid adaptive antenna array. In: IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications. 2010. [8] Ahmed Alkhateeb et al. Channel Estimation and Hybrid Precoding for Millimeter Wave Cellular Systems. In: IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Signal Processing. 2014. [9] Omar El Ayach et al. Spatially Sparse Precoding in Millimeter Wave MIMO Systems. In: IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications. 2014. [10] Wonil Roh et al. Millimeter-wave beamforming as an enabling technology for 5G cellular communications: theoretical feasibility and prototype results. In: IEEE Communications Magazine. Vol. 52. 2. Feb. 2014, pp. 106 113. [11] Maliheh Soleimani et al. Hybrid Beamforming and DFT-Based Channel Estimation for Millimeter Wave MIMO Systems. In: 2017. ISBN: 9781538635315. [12] Min Li et al. Beamforming for Dual-Hop MIMO AF Relay Networks with Channel Estimation Error and Feedback Delay. In: IEEE Access. Vol. 5. 2017, pp. 21840 21851. [13] Devendra Singh Gurjar et al. Beamforming in Traffic- Aware Two-Way Relay Systems With Channel Estimation Error and Feedback Delay. In: IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology. Vol. 66. 2017, pp. 8807 8820.