SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE STATE LIST FOR PERMISSION TO APPEAL May 15, 2000 AMENDED May 15, 2000 STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTY TRIAL JUDGE TRIAL COURT NO. APPELLATE JUDGE/JUDGMENT NATURE OF APPEAL ACTION Pam Clark, et al Service Corporation International, et al M1998-00160-SC-R11-CV Davidson Chancery Irvin H. Kilcrease 97-2932-I Highers, J. in part, reversed in part and Denied - Application of Pam Clark & Tonya Pilote; the opinion of the Court of Appeals is designated Not for Citation Leta Hoalcraft Walter Troy Smithson M1999-01837-SC-R11-CV Williamson Circuit Russ Heldman 91068 Highers, J. Denied - Application of Walter Smithson Carl Eugene Jordan Donal Campbell M1999-00540-SC-R11-CV Davidson Chancery Irvin H. Kilcrease 98-2241-I Highers, J. in part, reversed in part, and Denied - Application of Carl Eugene Jordan Richard D. Minton, et al William R. Long M1998-00491-SC-R11-CV Davidson Chancery Ellen Hobbs Lyle 97-1985-III Cain, J. Denied - Application of Richard D. Minton and Kathleen Minton Dr. and Mrs. Wentworth S. Morris and Mary Mauricia Morris James A. Woods M1998-00977-SC-R11-CV TN Claims Commission William Baker 101452, 101807 Cain, J. and Remanded Denied - Application of Dr. and Mrs. Wentworth S. Morris and Mary Mauricia Morris Lori Ann Parr Middle Tennessee State University, et al M1999-01442-SC-R11-CV Rutherford Circuit James L. Weatherford 39762 Highers, J. affirmed and Denied - Application of Lori Ann Parr
Robert Spurlock, et al Lawrence Ray Whitley, et al M1999-01486-SC-R23-CQ U.S. District Court, Middle District Rule 23 The Court accepts certification of one question of law. 1 William H. Thompson, et al Department of Codes Administration, et al M1998-00352-SC-R11-CV Davidson Chancery Carol McCoy 98-71-II Cain, J. and Denied - Application of Country Maid Farms and William H. Thompson, Jr. June Z. Wilkinson Grant R. Wilkinson M1998-00132-SC-R11-CV Davidson Circuit Barbara N. Haynes 97C-1364 Cottrell, J. and Denied - Application of June Wilkinson James Gordon Freeman M1998-00182-SC-R11-CD Davidson Criminal Seth W. Norman 97-B-788 Woodall, J. Denied - Application of James Gordon Freeman Joseph Gieck M1998-00467-SC-R11-CD White Criminal Leon C. Burns CR261 Lafferty, J. Denied - Application of Joseph Gieck Billy Joe Greenwood M1998-00477-SC-R3-PC Overton Criminal Leon Burns 1974 Per Curiam Vacated and reinstated Denied - Application of Billy Joe Greenwood 1 The following question was certified: Does a sheriff, when acting in a law enforcement capacity, serve as a state or county official under Tennessee law? 2
Gary Thomas Moore M1997-00100-SC-R11-CD Warren Circuit Charles D. Haston F-7140 Witt, J. Denied - Application of Gary Thomas Moore Freddie Morrow M2000-00302-SC-R11-CD Robertson Circuit Robert W. Wedemeyer 9676 From trial court order granting 60 days to seek R.11 review Dismissed - Application of Freddie Morrow Joseph Oscar Price, III M1998-00209-SC-R11-CD Davidson Criminal Cheryl Blackburn 97-D-2337 Smith,J. Denied - Application of Joseph Oscar Price, III Ronald L. Davis Jack Morgan, Warden M1999-00965-SC-R11-PC Hickman Circuit Donald P. Harris 98-5072C-II Welles, J. Denied - Application of Ronald L. Davis Charles Dwight Farrar M1999-00204-CCA-R3-PC Bedford Circuit William C. Lee 7822 Williams, J. Denied - Application of Charles Dwight Farrar Charles C. Gary M1999-00136-SC-R11-PC Davidson Criminal Cheryl Blackburn 97-A-197 Peay, J. pursuant to Rule 20 Denied - Application of Charles C. Gary Marvin E. Martin M1999-00973-SC-R11-CO Lawrence 20,807 Woodall, J. Order of 11/24/99 Denied - Application of Marvin E. Martin 3
Jackie McLaney Ricky Bell, Warden, et al M1998-00187-SC-R11-PC Davidson Criminal J. Randall Wyatt, Jr. 2692 Ogle, J. Granted - Application of Jackie W. McLaney 2 Hartwell D. Price M1999-01035-CCA-R3-PC Cheatham Circuit Robert E. Burch 12361 Williams, J. Denied - Application of Hartwell D. Price David Stovall M1999-00937-SC-R3-PC Maury Criminal Jim T. Hamilton 7482 Smith, J. pursuant to Rule 20 Denied - Application of David Stovall Maurice Wilson M1999-00001-SC-R3-CD Davidson Criminal Cheryl A. Blackburn 85-W-156 Peay, J. pursuant to Rule 20 Denied - Application of Maurice Wilson Bennie F. Green, et al Betty J. Pirtle W1998-00134-SC-R11-CV Shelby Chancery Chancellor Peete 108539 Highers, J. Order dismissing appeal Denied - Application of Betty J. Pirtle Anita Joyce Owen, et al George D. Summers W1999-00718-SC-R11-CV Fayette Chancery Dewey C. Whitenton 11797 Farmer, J. Highers, J. Rule 9 Denial Denied - Application of George D. Summers 2 Oral argument will be limited to the following issues: Whether arrest while on bail for a felony offense, thus requiring consecutive sentences pursuant to TCA Section 40-20-111 and TRCrP 32(c)(3)(C), makes the judgment order running these sentences concurrent void as opposed to voidable (and thus amenable to habeas corpus relief); and if the conviction was void, whether the Court of Criminal Appeals should have the case to the trial court for appointment of counsel and a hearing. 4
Robert Clarence Payne Leslie Shumake, et al W1999-02059-SC-R11-CV Hardeman Circuit Jon K. Blackwood 8964 Highers, J. Denied - Application of Robert Clarence Payne David Eaton W1998-00644-SC-R11-CD Shelby Criminal Chris Craft 96-12053 Wade, J. Denied - Application of David Eaton Ben Phillip Ray W1999-02008-SC-R11-CD Henry Circuit Julian Guinn 12760 Williams, J. Denied - Application of Ben Phillip Ray William Ray Rhodes W1998-01677-SC-R11-PC Henry Circuit Charles McGinley 12447 Hayes, J. Denied - Application of William Ray Rhodes, pro se Marshall A. Simon W1999-01991-SC-R11-CD Hardeman Circuit Jon Blackwood 6245 Riley, J. Denied - Application of Marshall Simon Johnny L. Smith W1998-00100-SC-R11-PC Shelby Criminal Sr. Judge Lafferty P-19479, P- 19660 Peay, J. Denied - Application of Johnny L. Smith Michael Joe Boyd W1999-01981-SC-R11-PC Shelby Criminal Carolyn W. Blackett P-5354 Hayes, J. Appeal dismissed Denied - Application of Michael Joe Boyd 5
Tom Moore, III W1998-00579-SC-R11-PC Shelby Criminal Carolyn W. Blackett P-13826 Woodall, J. Denied - Application of Tom Moore, III Joy Nelson W1999-01885-SC-R11-PC Gibson Circuit Dick Jerman, Jr. 14872-1 Glenn, J. Denied - Application of Joy Nelson Judy F. Barnett NN Ball & Roller, Inc., et al E1998-00534-WC-R3-CV Unicoi Chancery 6172 Motion for review Denied - Application of Judy F. Barnett Richard Thomas Bogan Doris Mae Bogan E1998-00060-SC-R11-CV Sullivan Chancery John S. McLellan, III 21988 Swiney, J. Granted - Application of Richard Bogan Tony Milo Crowe Wanda June Comer E1998-00285-SC-R11-CV Sullivan Circuit Richard E. Ladd C31635(L) and C31977(L) Goddard, J. and Denied - Application of Wanda Comer In Re: Estate of Fred Filyaw George Pritchett and Barbara Pritchett Harvey Lunsford, executor E1999-00396-SC-R11-CV McMinn Probate James F. Watson 42368 Swiney, J. Denied - Application of George and Barbara Pritchett Lenoir City Board of Zoning Appeals Mark Matlock d/b/a MSM Development, Inc. E1999-01787-SC-R11-CV Loudon Circuit Russell E. Simmons, Jr. 6267 Goddard, J. Denied - Application of Lenoir City Board of Zoning 6
The Oceanics Schools, Inc. Operation Sea Cruise, Inc. E1999-00646-SC-R11-CV Knox Circuit Wheeler A. Rosenbalm 3-315-95 Swiney, J. Denied - Application of The Oceanics Schools, Inc. Ella Mae Shockley Aldridge Lynn Shockley E1999-01814-SC-R11-CV Hamblen Chancery Thomas R. Frierson II 98-488 Franks, J. Denied - Application of Aldridge Lynn Shockley Westside Health and Racquet Club, Inc. Jefferson Financial Services, Inc. E1998-00412-SC-R11-CV Hamblen Chancery Thomas R. Frierson II 94-367 Susano, J. Remanded Denied - Application of Westside Health Jeffrey Dunlap E1999-00987-SC-R11-CD Knox Criminal Ray Jenkins 68024 Welles, J. Denied - Application of Jeffrey Dunlap Thomas D. Huskey In re: The Knoxville News-Sentinel E1999-02754-SC-R11-CD Knox Criminal Richard R. Baumgartner 51903 Witt, J. Rule 10 Denied - Application of Thomas Dee Huskey Eric Larez, a/k/a Easy E1998-00114-SC-R11-CD Sullivan Criminal Jerry Beck S36,003- S36,005 Glenn, J. Denied - Application of Eric Larez, a/k/a Easy Clifford Caudill E1999-01494-SC-R11-CD Campbell Criminal Shayne Sexton 5746 Smith, J. Denied - Application of James Miller 7
Gordon Scott Hobbs James Bowlen, Warden, and State of Tennessee E1999-01009-SC-R11-CD Bledsoe Criminal Thomas W. Graham 10863 Glenn, J. Denied - Application of Gordon Scott Hobbs Alicia Shayne Lovera E1999-01964-SC-R11-PC Sevier Circuit Rex H. Ogle 97-282 Hayes, J. Denied - Application of Alicia Shayne Lovera; the opinion of the Court of Criminal Appeals is designated Not for Citation James William Massengale David Mills, Warden, et al E1999-02717-SC-R11-CO Morgan Criminal E. Eugene Eblen Wade, J. Motion to recall or amend Denied - Application of James William Massengale Robert Williams E1999-00323-SC-R11-CD Hamilton Criminal Douglas A. Meyer 214328 Witt, J. Denied - Application of Robert Williams 8