ISSN: X International Journal of Advanced Research in Electronics and Communication Engineering (IJARECE) Volume 1, Issue 3, September 2012

Similar documents
Dct Based Image Transmission Using Maximum Power Adaptation Algorithm Over Wireless Channel using Labview

Wireless Image Transmission Using Maximum Power Adaptation Algorithm

BER ANALYSIS OF MINIMUM AND MAXIMUM POWER ADAPTATION METHODS USING HAAR WAVELET IMAGE TRANSMISSION USING BPSK MODULATION

JPEG Image Transmission over Rayleigh Fading Channel with Unequal Error Protection

UNEQUAL POWER ALLOCATION FOR JPEG TRANSMISSION OVER MIMO SYSTEMS. Muhammad F. Sabir, Robert W. Heath Jr. and Alan C. Bovik

410 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON IMAGE PROCESSING, VOL. 19, NO. 2, FEBRUARY A. Background /$ IEEE

THE EFFECT of multipath fading in wireless systems can

Performance Evaluation of different α value for OFDM System

EE 382C Literature Survey. Adaptive Power Control Module in Cellular Radio System. Jianhua Gan. Abstract

MULTICARRIER communication systems are promising

Convolutional Coding Using Booth Algorithm For Application in Wireless Communication

Performance analysis of OFDM with QPSK using AWGN and Rayleigh Fading Channel

Performance Analysis of Concatenated RS-CC Codes for WiMax System using QPSK

Achievable-SIR-Based Predictive Closed-Loop Power Control in a CDMA Mobile System

Simulation Study and Performance Comparison of OFDM System with QPSK and BPSK

Transmit Power Allocation for BER Performance Improvement in Multicarrier Systems

BEING wideband, chaotic signals are well suited for

Adaptive Digital Video Transmission with STBC over Rayleigh Fading Channels

Performance Optimization of Hybrid Combination of LDPC and RS Codes Using Image Transmission System Over Fading Channels

Power-Rate-Distortion Analysis For Wireless Multimedia Networks - Part II

Power-Distortion Optimized Mode Selection for Transmission of VBR Videos in CDMA Systems

Doppler Frequency Effect on Network Throughput Using Transmit Diversity

Implementation of Different Interleaving Techniques for Performance Evaluation of CDMA System

Comparative Analysis of the BER Performance of WCDMA Using Different Spreading Code Generator

Energy Efficient JPEG 2000 Image Transmission over Point-to-Point Wireless Networks

Testing The Effective Performance Of Ofdm On Digital Video Broadcasting

Adoption of this document as basis for broadband wireless access PHY

Effects of Fading Channels on OFDM

The Impact of Imperfect One Bit Per Subcarrier Channel State Information Feedback on Adaptive OFDM Wireless Communication Systems

Relay Selection in Adaptive Buffer-Aided Space-Time Coding with TAS for Cooperative Wireless Networks

Chaos based Communication System Using Reed Solomon (RS) Coding for AWGN & Rayleigh Fading Channels

Study of Turbo Coded OFDM over Fading Channel

Performance Evaluation Of Digital Modulation Techniques In Awgn Communication Channel

THROUGHPUT AND CHANNEL CAPACITY OF MULTI-HOP VIRTUAL CELLULAR NETWORK

A High-Throughput VLSI Architecture for SC-FDMA MIMO Detectors

SIMULATIVE STUDY (LINK/SYSTEM) OF WCDMA SYSTEMS

Combined Transmitter Diversity and Multi-Level Modulation Techniques

Study of Performance Evaluation of Quasi Orthogonal Space Time Block Code MIMO-OFDM System in Rician Channel for Different Modulation Schemes

1 Introduction. Abstract

Key words: OFDM, FDM, BPSK, QPSK.

Algorithm to Improve the Performance of OFDM based WLAN Systems

Improving Channel Estimation in OFDM System Using Time Domain Channel Estimation for Time Correlated Rayleigh Fading Channel Model

Performance Analysis of Cognitive Radio based on Cooperative Spectrum Sensing

Multirate schemes for multimedia applications in DS/CDMA Systems

Performance Comparison of Channel Estimation Technique using Power Delay Profile for MIMO OFDM

Performance of Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing System Based on Mobile Velocity and Subcarrier

IN A direct-sequence code-division multiple-access (DS-

Performance Evaluation of OFDM System with Rayleigh, Rician and AWGN Channels

ORTHOGONAL frequency division multiplexing (OFDM)

Multilevel RS/Convolutional Concatenated Coded QAM for Hybrid IBOC-AM Broadcasting

Comparison of ML and SC for ICI reduction in OFDM system

Audio and Speech Compression Using DCT and DWT Techniques

Dynamic Subchannel and Bit Allocation in Multiuser OFDM with a Priority User

Combining Orthogonal Space Time Block Codes with Adaptive Sub-group Antenna Encoding

Performance Analysis of WiMAX Physical Layer Model using Various Techniques

A Novel Spread Spectrum System using MC-DCSK

COMPARISON OF CHANNEL ESTIMATION AND EQUALIZATION TECHNIQUES FOR OFDM SYSTEMS

C th NATIONAL RADIO SCIENCE CONFERENCE (NRSC 2011) April 26 28, 2011, National Telecommunication Institute, Egypt

Distributed Power Control in Cellular and Wireless Networks - A Comparative Study

Power Reduction in OFDM systems using Tone Reservation with Customized Convex Optimization

A Research Concept on Bit Rate Detection using Carrier offset through Analysis of MC-CDMA SYSTEM


The Impact of EVA & EPA Parameters on LTE- MIMO System under Fading Environment

SPECTRUM SHARING IN CRN USING ARP PROTOCOL- ANALYSIS OF HIGH DATA RATE

International Journal of Digital Application & Contemporary research Website: (Volume 2, Issue 7, February 2014)

Hybrid throughput aware variable puncture rate coding for PHY-FEC in video processing

PEAK CANCELLATION CREST FACTOR REDUCTION TECHNIQUE FOR OFDM SIGNALS

AWGN Channel Performance Analysis of QO-STB Coded MIMO- OFDM System

Combined Rate and Power Adaptation in DS/CDMA Communications over Nakagami Fading Channels

Rekha S.M, Manoj P.B. International Journal of Engineering and Advanced Technology (IJEAT) ISSN: , Volume-2, Issue-6, August 2013

DS-UWB signal generator for RAKE receiver with optimize selection of pulse width

DYNAMIC POWER ALLOCATION SCHEME USING LOAD MATRIX TO CONTROL INTERFERENCE IN 4G MOBILE COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS

Periodic Impulsive Noise Suppression in OFDM- Based Power-Line Communications through Filtering Under Different Coding Schemes

Hybrid throughput aware variable puncture rate coding for PHY-FEC in video processing

ISSN Vol.07,Issue.01, January-2015, Pages:

MITIGATING INTERFERENCE TO GPS OPERATION USING VARIABLE FORGETTING FACTOR BASED RECURSIVE LEAST SQUARES ESTIMATION

Amplitude and Phase Distortions in MIMO and Diversity Systems

Comparative Analysis of Bit Error Rate (BER) for A-law Companded OFDM with different Digital Modulation Techniques

Adaptive DS/CDMA Non-Coherent Receiver using MULTIUSER DETECTION Technique

Performance of Wideband Mobile Channel with Perfect Synchronism BPSK vs QPSK DS-CDMA

SNR Scalability, Multiple Descriptions, and Perceptual Distortion Measures

Error Probability of Different Modulation Schemes for OFDM based WLAN standard IEEE a

SEVERAL diversity techniques have been studied and found

Performance Analysis of Maximum Likelihood Detection in a MIMO Antenna System

OFDM Code Division Multiplexing with Unequal Error Protection and Flexible Data Rate Adaptation

Image Transmission over OFDM System with Minimum Peak to Average Power Ratio (PAPR)

Cognitive Radio Transmission Based on Chip-level Space Time Block Coded MC-DS-CDMA over Fast-Fading Channel

Low Complexity Partial SLM Technique for PAPR Reduction in OFDM Transmitters

Computational Complexity Reduction of OFDM Signals by PTS with Various PAPR Conventional Methods

Effect of AWGN & Fading (Rayleigh & Rician) Channels on BER Performance of Free Space Optics (FSO) Communication Systems

A Kalman Filter Approach to Reduce ICI in OFDM Systems

Simplified Levenberg-Marquardt Algorithm based PAPR Reduction for OFDM System with Neural Network

Evaluation of BER and PAPR by using Different Modulation Schemes in OFDM System

A Novel SINR Estimation Scheme for WCDMA Receivers

MATLAB Simulation for Fixed Gain Amplify and Forward MIMO Relaying System using OSTBC under Flat Fading Rayleigh Channel

Power Control and Utility Optimization in Wireless Communication Systems

Comb type Pilot arrangement based Channel Estimation for Spatial Multiplexing MIMO-OFDM Systems

SPREADING SEQUENCES SELECTION FOR UPLINK AND DOWNLINK MC-CDMA SYSTEMS

Prof. P. Subbarao 1, Veeravalli Balaji 2

OFDM AS AN ACCESS TECHNIQUE FOR NEXT GENERATION NETWORK

Transcription:

Transmission of Images with Distance Based Power Adaptation Algorithm over Wireless Channels using Binary Phase Shift Keying Modulation M. Padmaja 1, Dr. P. Satyanarayana, K. Prasuna 3 1 Asst. Prof., ECE Dept., VR Siddhartha Engg. College, Vijayawada (A.P.), India Prof. and Head of EEE, Sri Venkateswara University College of Engg. Tirupati (A.P.), India 3 Asst. Prof., ECE Department, Vijaya Institute of Technology for Women, Vijayawada (A.P.), India Abstract-In this Paper, Power is controlled by reducing the error in the data while transmission is carried.this transmission takes place by bits. The Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm calculates the optimal transmission power assignment for each bit within the vector, taking into account all the neighboring bits. The Distancebased power allocation algorithm (DBPAA) uses the distance between reference bit and each bit to allocate transmitted power to each of its other bits. Thus, more transmitted power should be allocated to bits which are far from their corresponding bits. In order to avoid having very small transmitted powers for bits close to the reference bit, bits whose distance is less than a certain threshold value, the same transmitted power is allowed. This proposed algorithm is used to find the optimum power distribution such that the MSE is minimized subject to the constraints that the power per bit is kept constant based on distance between the bits. The above optimization is done for RMSE regardless of the average probability of bit error and the PAPR is kept below the certain bounds. Transmission of images with Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm shows better performance achieving higher gains compared to the case of Conventional power allocation while reducing the peak-to-average ratio Keywords-Maximum, Minimum, Mean Square Error, PAPR, RMSE I. INTRODUCTION One of the most important and challenging goal of current and future communication is transmission of high quality images from source to destination quickly with least error where limitation of bandwidth is a prime problem. By the advent of multimedia communications and the information superhighway has given rise to an enormous demand on high-performance communication systems. Multimedia transmission of signals over wireless links is considered as one of the prime applications of future mobile radio communication systems. However, such applications require the use of relatively high data rates (in the Mbps range) compared to voice applications. With such requirement, it is very challenging to provide acceptable quality of services as measured by the Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) due to the limitations imposed by the wireless communication channels such as fading and multipath propagation. Furthermore, the user mobility makes such a task more difficult because of the time varying nature of the channel. The main resources available to communications systems designers are power and bandwidth as well as system complexity. Thus, it is imperative to use techniques that are both power and bandwidth efficient for proper utilization of the communication [1-]. With the increasing complexity of these communication systems comes increasing complexity in the type of content being transmitted and received. The early content of plain speech/audio and basic black and white images used in early radio and television has developed into high definition audio and video streams; and with the introduction of computers into the mix even more complex content needs to be considered from images, video and audio to medical and financial data. Techniques are continuously being developed to maximize data throughput and efficiency in these wireless communication systems while endeavoring to keep data loss and error to a minimum. Power control has been an effective approach to mitigating the effect of fading channels in the quality of signal transmission over wireless channels. The system typically involves a mechanism of measuring the quality of the channel seen by the receiver and providing such information to the transmitter to adjust the amount of transmitted power. The primary purpose of power control is to maintain the acceptable E b /N o by meeting some PAPR requirements. So, it is obvious that all the transmitters should transmit with different power levels. The determination of different transmitting power levels becomes an important issue. This paper shows that the Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm is well suited for 97

multimedia like image and video signals, where different bits carry different amount of information. The scheme is specifically optimized for minimizing the mean square error (MSE) of the image or video signal rather than the bit error rate (BER) since it is more indicative of the image quality[3]. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. The noise used in this paper is AWGN.Section II presents the signal model. The Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm is presented in section III. Section IV presents the simulation results. Finally, conclusions are drawn in section V. II. PROBLEM FORMULATION Efficient use of the multimedia power is one of the major challenges in information devices. The controlling of power becomes even more critical with devices integrating complex video signal processing techniques with communications. Some of the key technologies that affect the power in this respect are source signal compression, channel error control coding, and radio transmission. Power consumption of base band processing should also be taken into account. On the other hand, the work on improving the power has focused on separate components such as algorithms and hardware design for specific video and channel coders [3],[4]. The need for dynamic control of transmitted power in communication systems was first encountered in the area of satellite communications. To fill this need, balancing (also called power balancing) algorithms were proposed by Aein [] and Meyerhof [3] in the early 1970's.The power balancing algorithms equalize, where possible Although Systems are stochastic; the power control problem leads to a purely deterministic Eigen value problem or a linear equation Joint optimization of source compression, channel coding, and transmission to balance the quality of service and power requirements of the multimedia has only recently attracted interest [5]. The work by Appadwedula et al. [6], considers minimization of the total energy of a wireless image transmission system. By choosing the coded source bit rate for the image coder, redundancy for the Reed Solomon (RS) coder, transmission power for the power amplifier and the number of fingers in the RAKE receiver, the total energy due to channel codec, transmission, and the RAKE receiver is optimized subject to end-to-end performance of the system. The proposed system is simulated for an indoor office environment subject to path loss and multipath. Significant energy saving is reported. In [7] and [8], by changing the accuracy of motion estimation different power and distortion levels for H.63 encoder are provided [9].The coded bits are packetized and unequally protected using RS codes and are transmitted over a code-division multipleaccess system operating over a flat fading channel. The system is a typical binary phase shift keying (BPSK) digital communication system for multimedia transmission. The signal is sampled, quantized and then coded into binary bits for transmission. The transmitted BPSK signal is represented as S(t) = k=0 M 1 i=0 w ibki g(t (km + i)t b The channel used in this paper is the additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN) channel. Modulation is the process by which signal waveforms are transformed and enabled to better withstand the channel impairments. In a BPSK system the received signal is given by (1) Y = x + n () Where x A, A and σ =N o The bit error probability is P 1 b= And the Q-function is given by Q x = A Q(x)= 1 π π σ e e x x x σ dx 1 1 1 a x + a(x + b) 0.5 (π) x e 0.5 Equation (5) is widely used in Bit error rate calculation. (3) (4) (5) 98

The Q-function can be described as a function of error function defined over [0, ) and is given by erf x = π With erf 0 = 0 and erf ( )=1 P b = Q( γ b ) x e y dy 0 (6) P s 3 πγ s e 0.5γ s P b Can be approximated from P s by P b as P b = P s (1) (13) P s = 1 [1 Q( (γ_b ))] (7) The Bit Error Rate for BPSK signaling can be calculated by an approximation of symbol error rate using nearest neighbour approximation. The Symbol error probability can be approximated by (8) P s =Q Asin π M N o = Q γ s Sin π M γ s =γ b = A N o P s Q γ s + Q γ s 3Q γ s Where the Q function is defined as: Q(x) 1 π x e x dx (9) (10) The Bit Error rate of BPSK involves two BPSK modulations on in-phase and quadrature components of the signal. The bit error probability is given by III. III. DISTANCE POWER ADAPTATION ALGORITHM (DPAA) (14) When there are N number of images and M number of bits in a multimedia system, then the powers transmitted by the bits be P = [P 1, P,.. P M ] and the respective RMSEs at the bits be RMSE = [RMSE 1, RMSE,.. RMSE M ]. Let RMSE T be the target RMSE. For a system with M bits per sample, there are M different samples to be transmitted. The probability that i th sample with a decimal value of (i) is reconstructed is given by M 1 P i = k=0 [p k ϑ(k) + (1 p k )ϑ k ] Q(z) 1 x z π e dx (11) (15) Where p k is the probability that the k th bit is in error.ϑ(k) is equal to zero if the indices of i and k are same and the value will be equal to 1 if the indices are different. The notation ϑ k ] represents the binary inversion of ϑ(k). 99

The MSE for the above case is calculated as else MSE = 1 M 1 M 1 P i k=0 p (j) = k(dbb (j)/r) n end (16) The MSE for other bits can be obtained following a similar procedure and the average MSE can be calculated by averaging over all possible bits and hence equation (7) will be average MSE. The Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) is obtained by taking the square root of (7) [15-18].The probability of the k th bit to be in error for the AWGN case is given by PE k = Q( E b N o k ) Initialize power step size to P. For i = 1 to iterations Define two bits, R is recipient power and C is contributing power, For j = 1 to bits Compute RMSE. Update power of all the bits using (17) In these systems, the MSE level is satisfied at each bit. Once the bit allocation is carried out, the power control takes a role of controlling the error caused by bits. On one hand, this algorithm must be reduced to minimize the interference at other bits, and, on the other hand, it must be sufficient for data communication [3-4]. ALGORITHM: Where P i n+1 =Power allocated in the n+1 state (18) (19) Initialize number of iterations Initialize number of bits Initialize dmin, R, k, n, d bb P i n = Power allocated in the n state RMSE i n =Root mean square error of ith bit in n th iteration RMSE T =Target Root Mean Square Error for i = 1 to iterations Calculate the maximum power of each bit. Initialize power vector to all ones Initialize PAPR max Repeat the same procedure (8) and (9) above but with the Contributor bit C incremented by one until all least significant bits are used. For j = 1 to bits if d bb dmin Calculate the maximum MSE and Plot Energy per Bit versus RMSE, BER and PSNR. p (j) = k (dmin/ R) n 100

IV. NUMERICAL RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS Fig.1 shows the Original image. Image transmission over AWGN is considered with M = 8 bpp for Conventional and Distance power adaptation methods. The improvement in performance obtained by the Conventional power adaptation method is affected by the Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm and the value are shown in Tabular forms as Table 1 and Table.Better Performance is observed in Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm(DPAA) compared with Conventional Power Adaptation Algorithm(CPAA) as shown in Fig.3 Fig. shows the received image using Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm. Ihe image proves that better Performance is observed in Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm compared with Conventional Power Adaptation Algorithm as the power adapted is maximum. Fig.3, Fig.4 and Fig.5 shows the plots of RMSE, PSNR and BER performance of Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm. Ihe plot proves that better Performance is observed in Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm compared with Conventional Power Adaptation Algorithm as the power is maximum. Fig.6 shows the plots of BER performance of BPSK modulation using Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm. Both Conventional power Adaptation Algorithm and Distance Power Adaptation Algorithms show better BER performance in image transmission using DPAA rather than CPAA. Fig. Images obtained in transmission over AWGN Using Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm Fig.3 Plot showing PSNR over AWGN using Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm and Conventional power Adaptation Algorithm Fig. 1 Original Image 101

Fig.4 Plot showing RMSE over AWGN using Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm and Conventional power Adaptation Algorithm Fig.5 Plot showing BER over AWGN using Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm and Conventional power Adaptation Algorithm V. REFERENCES [1] S. Appadwedula, M. Goel, N. R. Shanbhag, D. L. Jones, and K. Ramchandran, Total system energy minimization for wireless image trans Mission, J. VLSI Signal Processing Syst., vol. 7, no. 1/, pp. 99 117,Feb. 001. [] Q. Zhang, Z. Ji, W. Zhu, and Y. Q. Zhang, Power-minimized bit allo-cation for video communication over wireless channels, IEEE Trans.Circuits Syst. Video Technol., vol. 6, pp. 398 410, June 00. [3] Z. Ji, Q. Zhang, W. Zhu, and Y. Q. Zhang, Joint power control and sourcechannel coding for video communication over wireless Networks, in Proc. IEEE Vehicular Technology Conf., Oct. 001, pp.1658 166 [4] Physical layer standard for cdma000 spread spectrum System, 3GPP C.S000 Version 3.0, June 15, 001, www.3gpp.org. [5]Technical specification group radio access network:physical layer general specification, 3GPP, Release 6,December 003, www.3gpp.org. [6]Qian Zhang, Zhu Ji, Wenwu Zhu and Ya-Qin Zhang, Power-Minimized Bit Allocation for Video Communication Over Wireless Channels, IEEE Transactions on circuits and systems for Video Technology, vol. 1, no. 6, pp.398 410, June 00 [7] S. L. Kim, Z. Rosberg, and J. Zander, Combined power control and transmission rate selection in cellular networks, in Proc. IEEE VTC 99, vol. 3, 1999, pp. 1653 1657. [8] ETSI EN 300 744 V1.5.1 (004-11), Digital Video Broadcasting (DVB);Framing structure, channel coding and modulation for digital Terrestrial television. [9] T. S. Rappaport, Wireless Communications: Principles and Practice Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall,00. [10] A. Bin Sediq and M. El-Tarhuni, MMSE Power Allocation for Image and Video Transmission over Wireless Channels, Accepted to appear in the 16th IEEE International Symposium on Personal, Indoor and Mobile Radio Communications (PIMRC 05), Berlin, Germany, 005. [11] J. Proakis, Digital Communications, 4th ed., McGraw-Hill,001. [1] Talukder, K.H. and Harada, K., A Scheme of Wavelet Based Compression of D Image, Proc. IMECS, Hong Kong, pp. 531-536, June 006. [13] Ahmed, N., Natarajan, T., and Rao, K. R., Discrete Cosine Transform, IEEE Trans. Computers, vol. C-3, Jan. 1974, pp. 90-93. [14] Power-Distortion Optimization and Delay Constraint scheme for Layered Video Transmission,QIN Xiao-fang, SUI Dong, ZHANG Xin,008 [15] Power and distortion optimization for pervasive video coding,yongfang Liang, Ishfaq Ahmad,IEEE Transactions on MSEcuits and Systems for Video Technology, Volume 19 Issue 10, October 009 [16] Joint Source-Channel Distortion Modelling for MPEG-4 Video, Muhammad Farooq Sabir, 009. [17] Rate Distortion Performance for Joint Source Channel Coding of JPEG Image Over AWGN Channel, Prof. Jigisha N. Patel, Dr Suprava Patnaik, Ms.Vaibhavi P. Lineswala,011 [18] Transmission Distortion Analysis for Real-Time Video Encoding and Streaming Over Wireless Networks,Zhihai He,and Hongkai Xiong, October 11, 004, Information Transmission Over Fading Channels, Sayantan Choudhury and Jerry D. Gibson,007. [19] Unequal Error Protection for SPIHT Coded Image Transmission over Erroneous Wireless Channels,Md. Abdul Kader, Farid Ghani and R. Badlishah Ahmed, Nov 011. 10

Table I: RMSE, PSNR, BER values of Image Transmission using Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm Table II: RMSE, PSNR, BER values of Image Transmission using Conventional Power Adaptation Algorithm Distance Power Adaptation Algorithm(DPAA) E b /N 0 RMSE PSNR BER db 0 0.499 55.4973 0.1848 0.5 0.4141 55.81 0.1715 1 0.398 56.1669 0.1584 1.5 0.3815 56.5357 0.1455 0.3635 56.9548 0.131.5 0.3455 57.3966 0.1193 3 0.364 57.890 0.1065 3.5 0.307 58.4164 0.0944 4 0.86 59.038 0.0818 4.5 0.639 59.7366 0.0696 5 0.409 60.578 0.058 5.5 0.151 61.513 0.0463 6 0.186 6.766 0.0347 6.5 0.1547 64.3744 0.039 7 0.1 66.5787 0.0144 7.5 0.0854 69.5353 0.0073 8 0.0508 74.0539 0.006 8.5 0.09 80.983 0.0005 9 0.0066 91.743 0 9.5 0 Inf 0 Conventional Power Adaptation Algorithm(CPAA) E b /N 0 db RMSE PSNR BER 0 0.4953 54.673 0.453 0.5 0.4951 54.796 0.45 1 0.4947 54.643 0.447 1.5 0.4945 54.688 0.446 0.494 54.553 0.44.5 0.4951 54.71 0.451 3 0.4945 54.839 0.445 3.5 0.4957 54.757 0.457 4 0.4946 54.941 0.446 4.5 0.495 54.673 0.45 5 0.4958 54.779 0.458 5.5 0.4948 54.757 0.448 6 0.4948 54.758 0.448 6.5 0.4944 54.697 0.444 7 0.495 54.699 0.45 7.5 0.4953 54.77 0.453 8 0.495 54.641 0.45 8.5 0.4946 54.897 0.447 9 0.4946 54.758 0.446 9.5 0.494 54.687 0.44 103