THE ADAPTIVE CHANNEL ESTIMATION FOR STBC-OFDM SYSTEMS

Similar documents
Performance Evaluation of different α value for OFDM System

CCI CANCELLATION USING KF IN FADED MIMO CHANNELS

Channel estimation in space and frequency domain for MIMO-OFDM systems

Performance analysis of MISO-OFDM & MIMO-OFDM Systems

A Stable LMS Adaptive Channel Estimation Algorithm for MIMO-OFDM Systems Based on STBC Sonia Rani 1 Manish Kansal 2

Comb type Pilot arrangement based Channel Estimation for Spatial Multiplexing MIMO-OFDM Systems

Performance Evaluation of STBC MIMO Systems with Linear Precoding

Reduced Complexity of QRD-M Detection Scheme in MIMO-OFDM Systems

Wireless Communication: Concepts, Techniques, and Models. Hongwei Zhang

Implementation and Comparative analysis of Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) Signaling Rashmi Choudhary

On Comparison of DFT-Based and DCT-Based Channel Estimation for OFDM System

International Journal of Advance Engineering and Research Development. Channel Estimation for MIMO based-polar Codes

ADAPTIVITY IN MC-CDMA SYSTEMS

Orthogonal Cyclic Prefix for Time Synchronization in MIMO-OFDM

Performance Evaluation of STBC-OFDM System for Wireless Communication

IMPROVED CHANNEL ESTIMATION FOR OFDM BASED WLAN SYSTEMS. G.V.Rangaraj M.R.Raghavendra K.Giridhar

Performance Analysis of n Wireless LAN Physical Layer

Cooperative Orthogonal Space-Time-Frequency Block Codes over a MIMO-OFDM Frequency Selective Channel

4x4 Time-Domain MIMO encoder with OFDM Scheme in WIMAX Context

Improving Channel Estimation in OFDM System Using Time Domain Channel Estimation for Time Correlated Rayleigh Fading Channel Model

Comparison of MIMO OFDM System with BPSK and QPSK Modulation

Efficient Decoding for Extended Alamouti Space-Time Block code

The Optimal Employment of CSI in COFDM-Based Receivers

Cognitive Radio Transmission Based on Chip-level Space Time Block Coded MC-DS-CDMA over Fast-Fading Channel

CHAPTER 3 ADAPTIVE MODULATION TECHNIQUE WITH CFO CORRECTION FOR OFDM SYSTEMS

Diversity techniques for OFDM based WLAN systems: A comparison between hard, soft quantified and soft no quantified decision

Lecture 13. Introduction to OFDM

BER PERFORMANCE AND OPTIMUM TRAINING STRATEGY FOR UNCODED SIMO AND ALAMOUTI SPACE-TIME BLOCK CODES WITH MMSE CHANNEL ESTIMATION

Design of DFE Based MIMO Communication System for Mobile Moving with High Velocity

Study of Turbo Coded OFDM over Fading Channel

OFDM Code Division Multiplexing with Unequal Error Protection and Flexible Data Rate Adaptation

Lecture 3: Wireless Physical Layer: Modulation Techniques. Mythili Vutukuru CS 653 Spring 2014 Jan 13, Monday

Weight Tracking Method for OFDM Adaptive Array in Time Variant Fading Channel

Performance of Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing System Based on Mobile Velocity and Subcarrier

Interpolation-Based Maximum Likelihood Channel Estimation Using OFDM Pilot Symbols

Transmit Power Allocation for BER Performance Improvement in Multicarrier Systems

A novel multiple access scheme for mobile communications systems

A Simple Space-Frequency Coding Scheme with Cyclic Delay Diversity for OFDM

Performance Comparison of Channel Estimation Technique using Power Delay Profile for MIMO OFDM

PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF MIMO-SPACE TIME BLOCK CODING WITH DIFFERENT MODULATION TECHNIQUES

Performance Evaluation of OFDM System with Rayleigh, Rician and AWGN Channels

UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON

Channel Estimation in Multipath fading Environment using Combined Equalizer and Diversity Techniques

Performance and Complexity Comparison of Channel Estimation Algorithms for OFDM System

Maximum-Likelihood Co-Channel Interference Cancellation with Power Control for Cellular OFDM Networks

Differential Space-Frequency Modulation for MIMO-OFDM Systems via a. Smooth Logical Channel

AWGN Channel Performance Analysis of QO-STB Coded MIMO- OFDM System

Low complexity iterative receiver for Linear Precoded OFDM

MULTIPATH fading could severely degrade the performance

ANALYSIS OF BER AND SEP OF QPSK SIGNAL FOR MULTIPLE ANENNAS

SPARSE CHANNEL ESTIMATION BY PILOT ALLOCATION IN MIMO-OFDM SYSTEMS

Channel Estimation for MIMO-OFDM Systems Based on Data Nulling Superimposed Pilots

Impact of Antenna Geometry on Adaptive Switching in MIMO Channels

Combining Orthogonal Space-Frequency Block Coding and Spatial Multiplexing in MIMO-OFDM System

Evaluation of channel estimation combined with ICI self-cancellation scheme in doubly selective fading channel

Multiple Input Multiple Output (MIMO) Operation Principles

University of Bristol - Explore Bristol Research. Peer reviewed version

VOL. 3, NO.11 Nov, 2012 ISSN Journal of Emerging Trends in Computing and Information Sciences CIS Journal. All rights reserved.

Combination of Space-Time Block Coding with MC-CDMA Technique for MIMO systems with two, three and four transmit antennas

Combined Transmitter Diversity and Multi-Level Modulation Techniques

Dynamic Subcarrier, Bit and Power Allocation in OFDMA-Based Relay Networks

Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing & Measurement of its Performance

Combined Phase Compensation and Power Allocation Scheme for OFDM Systems

Practical issue: Group definition. TSTE17 System Design, CDIO. Quadrature Amplitude Modulation (QAM) Components of a digital communication system

FREQUENCY DOMAIN POWER ADAPTATION SCHEME FOR MULTI-CARRIER SYSTEMS

ELEC E7210: Communication Theory. Lecture 11: MIMO Systems and Space-time Communications

SPLIT MLSE ADAPTIVE EQUALIZATION IN SEVERELY FADED RAYLEIGH MIMO CHANNELS

ENHANCED BANDWIDTH EFFICIENCY IN WIRELESS OFDMA SYSTEMS THROUGH ADAPTIVE SLOT ALLOCATION ALGORITHM

Analysis and Improvements of Linear Multi-user user MIMO Precoding Techniques

Amplitude and Phase Distortions in MIMO and Diversity Systems

Investigation of the Impact of Pilot Signals on the Performance of OFDMA Systems

A Multicarrier CDMA Based Low Probability of Intercept Network

Performance Study of MIMO-OFDM System in Rayleigh Fading Channel with QO-STB Coding Technique

A Hybrid Synchronization Technique for the Frequency Offset Correction in OFDM

Effects of Fading Channels on OFDM

A New Carrier Frequency Offset Estimation Algorithm for ASTC MIMO OFDM Based System

FREQUENCY RESPONSE BASED RESOURCE ALLOCATION IN OFDM SYSTEMS FOR DOWNLINK

Optimal Number of Pilots for OFDM Systems

Wireless Medium Access Control and CDMA-based Communication Lesson 16 Orthogonal Frequency Division Medium Access (OFDM)

SPACE-TIME CODING AND PROCESSING TO IMPROVE RADIO COMMUNICATION COVERAGE FROM HIGH ALTITUDE PLATFORMS (HAPs) - AN APPROACH

Comparison between Performances of Channel estimation Techniques for CP-LTE and ZP-LTE Downlink Systems

Comparison of ML and SC for ICI reduction in OFDM system

An Equalization Technique for Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing Systems in Time-Variant Multipath Channels

On Differential Modulation in Downlink Multiuser MIMO Systems

Reception for Layered STBC Architecture in WLAN Scenario

Multiuser Decorrelating Detector in MIMO CDMA Systems over Rayleigh and Rician Fading Channels

ISSN: International Journal of Advanced Research in Computer Engineering & Technology (IJARCET) Volume 1, Issue 8, October 2012

Dynamic Subchannel and Bit Allocation in Multiuser OFDM with a Priority User

Performance and Complexity Comparison of Channel Estimation Algorithms for OFDM System

Evaluation of Diversity Gain in Digital Audio Broadcasting

Iterative Channel Estimation Algorithm in Multiple Input Multiple Output Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing Systems

On the Spectral Efficiency of MIMO MC-CDMA System

Low Complexity I/Q Imbalance and Channel Estimation Techniques for MIMO OFDM Systems

2.

Rate and Power Adaptation in OFDM with Quantized Feedback

Spatial Transmit Diversity Techniques for Broadband OFDM Systems

1. Introduction. Noriyuki Maeda, Hiroyuki Kawai, Junichiro Kawamoto and Kenichi Higuchi

A Complete MIMO System Built on a Single RF Communication Ends

MULTIPLE transmit-and-receive antennas can be used

Higher Order Rotation Spreading Matrix for Block Spread OFDM

Transcription:

ISANBUL UNIVERSIY JOURNAL OF ELECRICAL & ELECRONICS ENGINEERING YEAR VOLUME NUMBER : 2005 : 5 : 1 (1333-1340) HE ADAPIVE CHANNEL ESIMAION FOR SBC-OFDM SYSEMS Berna ÖZBEK 1 Reyat YILMAZ 2 1 İzmir Institute of echnology, Electrical-Electronics Engineering, Urla, İzmir 2 Douz Eylül University, Electrical-Electronics Engineering, Buca, İzmir 1 Email: bernaozbe@iyte.edu.tr 2 Email: reyat.yilmaz@eee.deu.edu.tr ABSRAC In this paper, we propose adaptive channel estimation methods based on LMS and RLS for orthogonal SBC-OFDM systems with three transmit antennas. he performance of the proposed algorithms is obtained in the frequency selective channels using Hiperlan/2 characteristics. Keywords: Space-time bloc coded OFDM, adaptive channel estimation 1. INRODUCION In order to provide the users mobile multimedia services such as high speed mobile internet access at better quality of services, at higher data rates and higher mobility, the wireless communication systems should improve lin reliability and spectral efficiency in frequency selective fading channels [1]. Multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) communication systems that use multiple transmit and multiple receive antennas, increase the data rate without expanding the bandwidth [2], increase the diversity and improve the performance against fading channels using space-time codes. he orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) technique which transforms a frequency selective channel into parallel flat fading subchannels [3] is a potential candidate for high data rate wireless transmission. herefore, in frequency selective fading channels, MIMO codes can be combined with OFDM in the time dimension as space-time bloc coded (SBC)-OFDM [4] and SFBC- OFDM in frequency domain [5] for the next generation wireless communication systems. It is proven by the Hurwitz-Radon theorem that orthogonal SBC which can provide full diversity and full rate and can be decoded by simple linear decoder, does not exist for systems with more than two transmit antennas over complex constellations [6]. For any number of transmit antennas, the generalized design issues for SBC has been presented in [7][8]. hese orthogonal codes achieve transmission rate 1 for real constellations, transmission rate 1 for complex constellations with two transmit antennas and transmission rates 1/2 and 3/4 for complex constellations with more than two transmit antennas. For these codes, since the orthogonal structures are used, a maximum lielihood (ML) decoding becomes a linear processing at the receiver. In this paper, for orthogonal SBC systems with three transmit antennas, we use the code matrix which provides Received Date : 16.09.2004 Accepted Date: 14.01.2005

1334 full diversity gain with linear operations at the receiver side at transmission rate of 3/4 [9]. he performance of the communication systems relies on the nowledge of channel state information (CSI) at the receiver side. herefore, the efficient algorithms should be used to estimate channel parameters. Since SBC systems are designed assuming that the channel coefficients are perfectly nown at the receiver side, the estimation of channel coefficient that approaches the ideal case is very important in term of performance. In [10] and [11], adaptive channel estimation algorithms based on least mean square (LMS), recursive least square (RLS) and Kalman filtering [12] have been examined for SBC in time varying flat fading channels. In [13], the channel tracing and equalization based on LMS, RLS and Kalman filtering have been proposed for MIMO systems in time varying frequency selective channels. For MIMO-OFDM systems, the channel tracing and equalization method based on Kalman filtering has been proposed in [14] in time varying channels. In this method, tracing and equalization of MIMO channel matrix has been performed in time and frequency domain respectively to reduce computational complexity. In addition, the Kalman filter technique for pilot symbol assisted MIMO-OFDM channel tracing has been examined for the time varying channels in [15]. he comparison of time and frequency domain channel tracing algorithms based on Kalman filtering has been examined in [16] for MIMO-OFDM systems. In this paper, we propose adaptive channel estimation algorithms based on LMS and RLS in frequency domain for SBC-OFDM systems with three transmit antennas in frequency selective channels. In section 2, we will explain the SBC-OFDM system model with three transmit antennas. In section 3, we will propose the adaptive channel estimation algorithms based on LMS and RLS. Finally, in section 4, we will give the simulation results compared to perfect CSI results using Hiperlan/2 characteristics. 2. SYSEM MODEL FOR SBC-OFDM In order to obtain third order diversity gain in frequency selective fading channels, SBC with rate 3/4 for three transmit antennas are combined with OFDM as shown in Figure 1 [4]. he SBC encoder for three transmit antennas is used the G 3 code matrix presented in Equation (1). Since three symbols are transmitted using four time interval, the rate of the code is 3/4. G Figure 1: ransmitter and receiver scheme of SBC-OFDM with three transmit antenna s s s = 1 2 3 s2 s1 0 3 s3 0 s1 0 s3 s2 (1) As shown in Figure 1, the outputs of SBC X 1,X2 and X 3 are transmitted though the multipath fading channel after applying inverse fast Fourier ransform (IFF) and adding guard interval. he transmitted symbols belonging th subcarrier and three adjacent OFDM symbols X l,(3n), X 2,(3n + 1) and X 3,(3n + 2) are represented in matrix form as given in Equation (2). For = 1,2,...,K each row of the matrix is transmitted from the three antennas ( = 1,2,3) simultaneously. Antenna X (3n) X (3n + 1) X (3n + 2) (2) ime X(3n + 1) X(3n) 0 X(3n + 2) 0 X(3n) 0 X (3n+ 2) X (3n+ 1)

1335 he subcarrier channel vector between the th transmit and receive antenna for n th OFDM symbol vector are denoted by H (n) H,1 (n) H,2 (n)... H,K(n). If we assume that the channel coefficients do not change during the four OFDM symbol transmission H (4n) = H (4n+ 1) = H (4n+ 2) = H (4n+ 3),,,,, we represent the system model given in Equation (3). R (n) = H (n)x (n) + N (n) (3) where * R(n) R(4n) R(4n + 1) R(4n + 2) R(4n + 3) is the received vector for each subcarrier, [ ] X(n) = X(3n) X(3n+ 1) X(3n+ 2) is the transmitted symbols, * N (n) N (4n) N (4n + 1) N (4n + 2) N (4n + 3) is the additive white Gaussian noise vector 2 whose elements are zero mean and σ variance and H (n) is the channel transfer matrix as given in Equation (4). H H (4n) H (4n) H (4n) H (4n) H (4n) 0 = H (4n) 0 H (4n) 0 H (4n) H (4n) 1, 2, 3, 2, 1, (n) 3, 1, 3, 2, (4) Assuming the channel transfer matrix has been estimated, the reconstructed symbol vector is obtained multiplying the received vector with H H ˆ (n) which is transpose-conjugate of channel transfer matrix. ˆ ˆ H ˆ H X (n) = H (n) H (n)x (n) + H (n)n (n) (5) 3. HE PROPOSED ADAPIVE CHANNEL ESIMAION MEHOD We propose an adaptive channel estimation based on LMS and RLS algorithms in frequency domain. he channel coefficients are estimated using N p pilot OFDM symbols in training mode as is given in Figure 2. Figure 2. he adaptive filter structure After estimating the channel coefficients, the reconstructed symbols are used as pilot symbols in tracing mode to trac the channel coefficients during the transmission. he filter coefficients are adapted by using RLS algorithm which has small converge time than LMS)algorithm [12]. For each subcarrier, the channel transfer matrix of SBC-OFDM with three transmit antennas given in Equation (4) is estimated using LMS and RLS adaptation algorithms. For four time interval, the pilot OFDM symbols that belongs to th subcarrier are defined as [ ] S = X(3n) X(3n+ 1) X(3n+ 2) 4n, S4n+ 1, X (3n+ 1) X (3n) 0 S4n+ 2, X (3n+ 2) 0 X (3n) S4n+ 3, 0 X(3n + 2) X(3n + 1) (6) Using the pilot OFDM symbols in Equation (6), the adaptive algorithm is summarized as follows: LMS algorithm for n = 2,3,,Np En, = R ˆ n, Sn,H (n 1) ˆ ˆ * H(n) = H(n 1) +µ E S n, n, RLS algorithm for n = 2,3,,Np En, = Rn, Sn,H ˆ (n 1) H 1 K = PS n,( λ+ Sn,PS n,) H P = (P KSn,P )/ λ ˆ ˆ * H(n) = H(n 1) + E PS n, n, (7) (8)

1336 where µ is the step size for LMS, λ is the forgotten factor for RLS and E n, is the error vector for each step. S n, pilot symbols are chosen from Equation (6) according to n value. Here, the estimated channel vector belonging to th subcarrier is defined as. 1, 2, 3, H ˆ (n) H ˆ (n) H ˆ (n) H ˆ (n) 4. SIMULAION RESULS he simulation results are obtained using Hiperlan/2 specifications as given in able 1 [17] and Channel model A characteristics which corresponds to a typical office environment and its power delay profiles are given in able 2 [18]. Classical Jaes Doppler spectrum [19] choosing the Doppler frequency 15Hz are used and Rayleigh fading statistics are assumed for all taps. herefore, each tap has a complex gain with Rayleigh amplitude and uniformly distributed phase. he Hiperlan/2 standard provides the data rate from 6Mbps to 54Mbps according to type of modulation and channel encoder. We choose QPSK modulation scheme without channel coding for simulation results. In Figure 3, the absolute value of channel transfer function is plotted versus subcarriers and OFDM frames. Notice that, the channel transfer function changes between subcarriers in single OFDM frame while the whole function changes very slowly from frame to frame due to the fact that a low Doppler frequency is chosen. In order to compare the convergence properties of LMS and RLS algorithms, we draw the instantaneous mean squared error versus number of step as shown in Figure 4 for 30dB signal-tonoise ratio (SNR) at the transmitter side. According to Figure 4, RLS algorithm has better convergence properties compared to LMS algorithm. herefore, we choose RLS algorithm by using 12 pilot OFDM symbols following 88 data OFDM symbols. Each data OFDM symbol includes 52 data symbols instead of 4 pilot and 48 data symbol as in Hiperlan/2 characteristics. hus, the reduction effect of pilot symbols in data rate is tolerated using only data symbols after pilot symbols. Again 12 OFDM symbols are used as retraining sequence after each 88 transmitted OFDM symbols in order to avoid divergence since the channel is a slowly time varying channel. able 1. Hiperlan/2 System Parameters Bandwidth 20MHz otal OFDM symbol duration Guard Interval duration Sampling time 4µ s 0.8µ s 50ns he number of used subcarrier 52 he number of data subcarrier 48 he number of pilot subcarrier 4 FF size (K) 64 he spacing of subcarrier 0.3125MHz

1337 able 2. Power delay profile for Channel Model A of Hiperlan/2 standard Path Delay (ns) Power (db) Path Delay (ns) Power (db) 1 0 0.0 10 90-7.8 2 10-0.9 11 110-4.7 3 20-1.7 12 140-7.3 4 30-2.6 13 170-9.9 5 40-3.5 14 200-12.5 6 50-4.3 15 240-13.7 7 60-5.2 16 290-18.0 8 70-6.1 17 340-22.4 9 80-6.9 18 390-26.7 Figure 3. Channel ransfer Function for Hiperlan/2 at v=50m/sec In order to compare the estimated channel coefficients with actual values, we draw the amplitude and phase values of complex channel coefficients for each antenna and for all subcarriers as illustrated in Figure 5 and Figure 6, respectively. According to curves, it can be observed that the estimated channel coefficients approach the actual values in reasonable degree. We obtain the simulation results for SBC- OFDM with three transmit and one receive antenna using Hiperlan/2 characteristics as shown in Figure 7. We compare the BER performance that are obtained assuming the channel coefficients are perfectly nown at the receiver (ideal case) with the BER performance that are obtained estimating the channel coefficients using RLS algorithm. According to results, the BER performance of the scheme with the RLS equalizer approaches to perfect CSI model with a difference of 2 db at BER=10-4. Moreover, SBC-OFDM with three transmit and one receive antenna gives approximately 8dB diversity gain at BER=10-3 compared to only OFDM case.

1338 Figure 4. he mean squared error Figure 5. Amplitude values of estimated and actual channel coefficients for each transmit antenna for all subcarriers

1339 Figure 6. Phase values of estimated and actual channel coefficients for each transmit antenna for all subcarriers Figure 7. he BER performance for SBC-OFDM system with three transmit and one receive antenna for Hiperlan/2 5. CONCLUSION In this paper, we have proposed adaptive channel estimation based on LMS and RLS algorithms in frequency domain. We have shown that the BER results that are obtained using proposed RLS algorithm approach the BER results assuming the channel coefficients are perfectly nown at thee transmitter side with a reasonable degree. REFERENCES [1] Stuber, G., Broadband MIMO-OFDM Wireless Communications, IEEE ransaction on Signal Processing, Vol: 92, pp. 271-294, 2004. [2] Foschini, G.F., and Gans, M. J., On limits of wireless communications in a fading

1340 environment when using multiple antennas, Wireless Personal Communications, Vol.6, pp.311-335, 1998. [3] Cimini, L. J., Analysis and simulation of a digital mobile channel using orthogonal frequency multiplexing, IEEE ransaction on Communication, Vol.33, pp. 665-675, 1995. [4] Lee, K.F., Williams, O.B., Space-ime Coded ransmitter Diversity echnique for Frequency Selective Fading Channels, Proc. IEEE Sensor Array and Multichannel Signal Processing Worshop, pp.149-152, March 2000. [5] Bolcsei, H. and Paulraj, A. J., Spacefrequency coded broadband {OFDM} systems, Proceedings of IEEE WCNC, Vol.1, pp.1-6, 2000. [6] aroh, V., Jafarhani, H., Calderband, A. R., Space-time bloc coding for wireless communications: performance results, IEEE J. Select. Areas Comm., Vol.17, No.3, pp.451-460, March 1999. [7] Alamouti, S. M., A simple transmitter diversity scheme for wireless communications, IEEE J. Select. Areas Commun., c.16, no.8, s.1451-1458, 1998. [8] aroh, V., Jafarhani, H., Calderban, A. R., Space-ime Bloc Codes from Orthogonal Designs, IEEE rans. on Information heory, Vol.45, No.5, July 1999. [9] Hochwald, B. M., Marzetta,. L. and Papadias, C. B., A ransmitter diversity scheme for wideband CDMA systems based on spacetime spreading, IEEE Journal on Selected Areas on Communication, Vol.19, No.5, pp.48-60, 2002. [10] Liu Z., Ma, X. Giannais, G.B., Spacetime coding and Kalman filtering for time selective fading channels, IEEE ransaction on Communications, Vol.50, pp.183-186, 2002. [11] Enescu, M., Koivunen V., ime-varying Channel racing for Space-ime Bloc Coding, IEEE Semi-annual Vehicular echnology Conference, VC Spring, May 6-9 2002. [12] Hayın,S., Adaptive Filter heory, 4th Edition, Prentice Hall, 2002. [13] Komninais, C. Fragouli, C., Sayed, A. H., Wesel, R. D., Multi-input Multi-output Fading channel tracing and equalization using Kalman estimation, IEEE Journal Selected Areas on Communications, Vol.20, pp. 1211-1226, 2002. [14] Roman,., Enescu, M., Koivunen, V., ime domain method for tracing dispersive channels in MIMO-OFDM systems, Proceeding of ICASSP, pp. 393-396, 2003. [15] Schafhuber, D., Matz, G., Hlawatsch, F., Kalman tracing of time varying channels in wireless MIMO-OFDM systems, Proceeding of ASILOMAR, pp. 1261-1265, 2003 [16] Z. Cheng and D. Dahlhaus, ime versus frequency domain channel tracing using Kalman filtering for OFDM systems with antenna array, Proceeding of VC-Spring, pp. 651-655, 2003. [17] ESI Broadband Radio Access Networs, Hiperlan/2 echnical Spec, Physical Layer. [18] ESI Normalization Committee, "Channel Models for Hiperlan/2 in Different Indoor Scenarios", France, 1998. [19] Pop, M.F., Beaulieu, N.C. Limitation of Sum-of-Sinusoids Fading Channel Simulators, IEEE rans. On Communications, Vol.49, No.4, 2001.