SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS Monday, May 10, 2004 STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTY TRIAL JUDGE TRIAL COURT NO. APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT NATURE OF APPEAL ACTION Jennifer L. Biscan, et al. vs. Franklin H. Brown, et al. M2001-02766-SC-R11-CV Davidson Circuit Carol Soloman 98C-2721 Cottrell, J. and Granted - Applications of Franklin H. Brown and Paul N. Worley. Brick Church Transmission, Inc. v. Southern Pilot Ins. Co. M2002-02778-SC-R11-CV Davidson Chancery Carol L. McCoy 02-1734-II Cain, J. and Denied - Application of Brick Church Transmission, Inc. Kevin Stanley Demers v. Karen Annette Wallace Demers M2002-01970-SC-R11-CV Robertson Circuit Ross H. Hicks 8683 Kirby, J. Denied - Application of Kevin Stanley Demers. In Re: H.N.G.; J.W.G. v. T.L.H.G. M2002-02656-SC-R11-JV Montgomery Juvenile Wayne C. Shelton 76-74 Susano, J., Case Denied - Application of T.L.H.G. William J. Reinhart, et al v. Robert T. Knight, et al M2001-02195-SC-R11-CV Rutherford Circuit James L. Weatherford 41560 Brothers, Sp. J. Reversed as to Remittitur, Jury Verdict Reinstated, and in all other Respects Denied - Application of Robert T. Knight and Glenda Knight. Denied - Application of Bob Parks. Edward Pinchon v. State of M2003-00816-SC-R11-PC Davidson Criminal J. Randall Wyatt, Jr. 98-A-307 Denied - Application of Edward Pinchon. Page 1 of 9
State of v. Benjamin Damron M2003-00588-SC-R11-CO Coffee Circuit John W. Rollins 29542 Granted - Application of the State of. State of v. William O. Ewerling M2002-02459-SC-R11-CD Davidson Criminal Carol Soloman 2001-T-567 Denied - Application of William O. Ewerling. State of v. Kevin Lamont Hutchinson M2001-03174-SC-R11-CD Montgomery Circuit Michael R. Jones 40000608 Denied - Application of Kevin Lamont. State of v. Danny Johnson M2002-02139-SC-R11-CD Sequatchie Circuit Buddy Perry 3858 Denied - Application of Danny Johnson. State of v. Michael Lafever M2003-00506-SC-R11-CD Putnam Criminal Lillie Ann Sells 01-0579 Denied - Application of Michael Lafever. State of v. Michael Renee Lee M2003-01077-SC-R11-CD Williamson Circuit Russ Heldman I-902-339-B Denied - Application of Michael Renee Lee. State of v. Treacy F. Lewis M2002-01694-SC-R11-CD Humphreys Circuit Robert E. Burch 9782 Woodall, J. Modified/ Denied - Application of Treacy F. Lewis. State of v. Melissa A. Mellinger M2002-01029-SC-R11-CD Wilson Criminal John D. Wootten, Jr. 00-1385 and 00-1386 Denied - Application of Melissa A. Mellinger. State of v. Delsie Lucille Sartain M2002-02617-SC-R11-CD Bedford Circuit Charles Lee 14954 Denied - Application of Delsie Lucille Sartain. Donald F. Walton v. State of M2002-02044-SC-R11-CO Wayne Circuit Robert L. Jones 12705 Woodall, J. Denied - Application of Donald Walton. Page 2 of 9
Admiralty Suites and Inns, LLC, et al v. Shelby County,, et al W2002-02155-SC-R11-CV Shelby Chancery D.J. Alissandratos 99-0036-3 Highers, J. in Part; Reversed in Part and Denied - Application of Admiralty Suites and Inns, LLC, et al John Wayne Goodman v. City of Savannah & Savannah Board of Commissioners W2002-02898-SC-R11-CV Hardin Chancery Ron E. Harmon 5999 Kirby, J. Denied - Application of John Wayne Goodman. William Russell Hyneman v. Amy Carlene Doyle Hyneman W2002-01546-SC-R11-CV Shelby Chancery Floyd Peete, Jr. CH-01-2271-2 Kirby, J. Reversed and remanded Denied - Application of William Russell Hyneman. In Re: J.J.C., D.M.C., and S.J.B. a/k/a State of, Department of Children s Services v. John Calabretta W2002-01400-SC-R11-JV Shelby Juvenile Harold Horne M2432 Kirby, J. Reversed and Denied - Application of John Calabretta. Gwendolyn Jackson, et al v. Zodie Hamilton, et al W2000-01992-SC-R11-CV Shelby Circuit Rita Stotts 44531 T.D. Highers, J. Reversed and Denied - Application of Zodie and James Hamilton. **The opinion of the Court of Appeals is designated Not for Citation in accordance with Supreme Court Rule 4, F. James Larry Conrad, Sr. v. State of W2002-01678-SC-R11-PC James C. Beasley, Jr. P-24789 Denied - Application of James Larry Conrad, Sr. Ricky Lynn Frazier v. State of W2003-01380-SC-R11-PC Chester Circuit Roy B. Morgan, Jr. 03-4422 Wade, J. Denied - Application of Ricky Lynn Frazier. Michael P. Healy v. State of W2002-01962-SC-R11-PC Arthur T. Bennett P-26147 Denied - Application of Michael P. Healy Page 3 of 9
Jessie Hodgesf, Pro-Se v. State of W2003-01006-SC-R11-PC Lauderdale Circuit Joe H. Walker, III 5999 Order Denied Denied - Application of Jessie Hodges, Pro-Se. Richard Rehagen v. State of W2003-00894-SC-R11-PC John P. Colten, Jr. P-25212 Denied - Application of Richard Rehagen. Carl E. Ross, Pro Se v. State of W2003-01448-SC-R11-CO J.C. McLin P-26913 Rule 20 Denied - Application of Carl E. Ross. Carl E. Saine v. State of W2002-03006-SC-R11-PC W. Fred Axley P-25706 Denied - Application of Carl E. Saine. State of v. Billy M. Higgins W2003-00310-SC-R11-CD Hardin Circuit C. Creed McGinley 8064 Denied - Application of Billy M. Higgins. State of v. John Johnson W2002-01333-SC-R11-CD Joseph B. Dailey 00-5917, 00-5918 Denied - Application of John Johnson. State of v. James A. McCurry W2002-02870-SC-R11-CD Madison Circuit Roy B. Morgan, Jr. 02-119 Denied - Application of James A. McCurry. State of v. Dwight Miller W2001-03095-SC-R11-CD Haywood Circuit L.T. Lafferty 2401 Smith, J. Denied - Application of Dwight Miller. State of v. Stephen Murray Mitchell W2004-00003-SC-S10-CD Joseph B. Dailey 03-04239 Rule 10 Denied Denied - Application of Stephen Murray Mitchell. State of v. Eslie L. Morgan W2003-00172-SC-R11-CD W. Otis Higgs, Jr. 99-11102 Denied - Application of Eslie L. Morgan. Page 4 of 9
State of v. Antray Terrill Morrow W2002-02065-SC-R11-CD Hardin Circuit C. Creed McGinley 8030 in Part; Reversed in Part, and Denied - Application of Antray Terrill Morrow. State of v. Joy Nelson W2003-00798-SC-R11-CD Gibson Circuit L.T. Lafferty 14872-1 Denied - Application of Joy Nelson. State of v. Calvin Owens W2003-00033-SC-R11-CD Joseph B. Dailey 01-06973, 74, 75, 76 Denied - Application of Calvin Owens. State of v. Trent Stark W2002-03078-SC-R11-CD J.C. McLin 01-02374 Smith, J. Denied - Application of Trent Stark. State of v. James Curtis Westbrook W2003-00163-SC-R11-CD Gibson Circuit Clayburn L. Peeples H-7159 in Part, Reversed in Part, Denied - Application of James Curtis Westbrook. State of v. Jarvis Williams and John Williams W2002-03010-SC-R11-CD Joseph Dailey 01-08323-34 Denied - Application of Jarvis Williams and John Williams. State of v. Dominic O. Woods W2003-00029-SC-R11-CD Hardin Circuit C. Creed McGinley 8171 Denied - Application of Dominic O. Woods. Taurys K. Walls v. State of W2002-01330-SC-R11-PC Arthur T. Bennett P-23193 Woodall, J. Denied - Application of Taurys K. Walls. Darrell Watkins, Pro-se v. State of W2003-00995-SC-R11-HC Joseph B. Dailey P-27095 Rule 20 Denied - Application of Darrell Watkins. Page 5 of 9
Jason M. Weiskopf v. State of W2002-01675-SC-R11-PC J.C. McLin P-25719 Woodall, J. Denied - Application of Jason M. Wesikopf. Corwyn E. Winfield v. State of W2003-00889-SC-R11-PC James C. Beasley, Jr. P-26030 Denied - Application of Corwyn E. Winfield. Eddie W. Belcher, Deceased and Sara O. Belcher, Deceased Through Their Executrix and Daughter, Beverly J. Ritchie v. State of E2003-00642-SC-R11-CV Tn Claims Commission Robert A. Fellman 101040 Susano, J. Denied - Application of Eddie W. Belcher. Combustion Federal Credit Union v. John H. Farmer E2003-00107-SC-R11-CV Hamilton Circuit Samuel H. Payne 92CV1143 Inman, Sr. J. & Appeal Dismissed Denied - Application of John H. Farmer. Effie Louise Hayes v. Roger Strutton, et al E2003-00938-SC-R11-CV Hamilton Circuit L. Marie Williams 03C-227 & Denied - Petition of Effie Louise Hayes to Rehear Denial of TRAP. Sally Keylon Henderson, Personal Representative of The Estate of Juanita W. Keylon v. Robert A. Hill E2003-01054-SC-R11-CV Roane Circuit Russell E. Simmons, Jr. 12413 Inman, Sr. J. in Part; Reversed in Part Denied - Application of the Estate of Juanita W. Keylon. Fortunee Hoffman v. Barry Lynn Hoffman E2003-00615-SC-R11-CV Hamilton Circuit W. Neil Thomas, III 95 DR 2972 Susano, J. Appeal Dismissed Denied - Application of Fortunee Hoffman. Frankie Pauline Maples v. Frank Allen Maples E2003-00722-SC-R11-CV Knox Circuit Bill Swann 54419 Inman, Sr. J. Reversed Denied - Application of Frank Allen Maples. Page 6 of 9
Shirley F. Mason, et al v. Brian J. Daley, M.D. E2003-02978-SC-S09-CV Knox Circuit Harold Wimberly 2-366-01 Goddard, P.J., E.S. Susano, J. Rule 9 Denied Rule 9 Denied - Application of Brian J. Daley, M.D. Ronald H. Peeler, et al. v. John R. Reynolds, et al. E2003-02695-SC-S09-CV Hamilton Circuit L. Marie Williams 02C1123 Franks, Susano & Swiney, JJ Denied Rule 9 Denied - Application of Harve Platig, Howard R. Allen, John R. Reynolds, Loy C. Martindale, and Rosalie F. Rivenbark. Karen Thompson Scoggins v. Larry Browder Scoggins E2002-02923-SC-R11-CV Hamilton Chancery Howell N. Peoples 98-0224 Reversed & Denied - Application of Karen Thompson Scoggins. Donna Godfrey Taylor v. Doris Holt E2003-00901-SC-R11-CV Cocke Chancery Telford Forgety, Jr. P-3803 Denied - Application of Donna Godfrey Taylor. **Pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 4(D), the Court directs the publication of the opinion of the Court of Appeals filed October 31, 2003. Rena Thompson v. Charles Hensley, et ux E2003-00456-SC-R11-CV Monroe Chancery Jerri Bryant 13632 and Denied - Application of Rena Thompson. Timothy Bickers, Thomas Carter and Gregory Hedges v. State of E2002-02887-SC-R11-PC Greene Criminal James E. Beckner 02-CR-202; 02-CR- 201;02-CR-200 Denied - Application of Timothy Bickers, Thomas Carter and Gregory Hedges. Jerry Lee Cowan v. State of E2003-00652-SC-R11-PC Blount Circuit D. Kelly Thomas, Jr. C-7085 Denied - Application of Jerry Lee Cowan. Thaddeus D. Daniel v. State of E2003-02637-SC-R11-PC Hamilton Criminal Douglas A. Meyer 246399 Tipton, J. Pursuant to Rule 20 Denied - Application of Thaddeus D. Daniel. Kenneth Robert Daniels v. Howard Carlton, Warden E2003-01063-SC-R11-PC Johnson Circuit Lynn W. Brown 4133 Tipton, J. Denied - Application of Kenneth Robert Daniels. Page 7 of 9
Thomas Eugene Graham v. State of E2003-00923-SC-R11-PC Hamilton Criminal Douglas A. Meyer 243215 Wade, J. Pursuant to Rule 20 Denied - Application of Thomas Eugene Graham. Michael J. Grant v. State of E2003-00637-SC-R11-PC Bradley Criminal R. Steven Bebb M-02-0837 Denied - Application of Michael J. Grant. Bryan Pearson v. State of E2003-02597-SC-S10-CD Knox Criminal Mary Beth Leibowitz 77694, 38234 Writ of Mandamus - Denied Denied - Rule 10 Application of Bryan Pearson for Extraordinary Appeal. Barker, J. - not participating. State of v. Elizabeth M. Clark E2002-01592- SC-R11-CD Blount Circuit D. Kelly Thomas, Jr. C-138-11 Denied - Application of Elizabeth M. Clark. State of v. Howard Duty, Jr. E2002-01772-SC-R11-CD Sullivan Criminal R. Jerry Beck S45,840 in Part & Reversed in Part Denied - Application of Howard Duty, JR. State of v. Clifford Leon Farra E2001-02235-SC-R11-CD Sullivan Circuit R. Jerry Beck S43,491 Reversed in Part and in Part Denied - Application of Clifford Leon Farra State of v. Robert Franklin, et als. E2004-00155-SC-S09-CD Sevier Circuit Richard R. Vance 9380, 9382, 9423, 9634, 9392 & 9342 Wade, J. Rule 9 Denied Denied - Application of Robert Franklin, et als. State of v. Shawn A. Hodge E2002-01794-SC-R11-CD Knox Criminal Mary B. Leibowitz 68409 Denied - Application of Shawn A. Hodge. State of v. Steve McKenzie E2002-03029-SC-R11-CD Bradley Circuit R. Steven Bebb M-01-419 Dismissed Denied - Application of Steve McKenzie. Page 8 of 9
State of v. Jaye Wesley Mitts E2002-00016-SC-R11-CD Campbell Circuit E. Shayne Sexton 10853 Reversed in Part; and for Entry of Corrected Judgement Denied - Application of Jaye Wesley Mitts. Terry Franklin Stogdill v. State of E2002-02928-SC-R11-PC Claiborne Circuit O. Duane Sloan 11,472 Denied - Application of Terry Franklin Stogdill. James E. Swiggett v. State of E2003-02212-SC-R11-PC Johnson Circuit Robert E. Cupp 4153 pursuant to Rule 20 of the Rules of the Court of Criminal Appeals Denied - Application of James E. Swiggett Page 9 of 9