Frequency Extended-MUSIC Method for DOA Estimation in Indoor IR-UWB Environment

Similar documents
Direction of Arrival Algorithms for Mobile User Detection

Performance Analysis of MUSIC and MVDR DOA Estimation Algorithm

Lecture 7/8: UWB Channel. Kommunikations

Joint DOA and Array Manifold Estimation for a MIMO Array Using Two Calibrated Antennas

Smart antenna for doa using music and esprit

Bluetooth Angle Estimation for Real-Time Locationing

Chapter 4 DOA Estimation Using Adaptive Array Antenna in the 2-GHz Band

Antennas and Propagation. Chapter 5c: Array Signal Processing and Parametric Estimation Techniques

Adaptive Beamforming Applied for Signals Estimated with MUSIC Algorithm

ROOT MULTIPLE SIGNAL CLASSIFICATION SUPER RESOLUTION TECHNIQUE FOR INDOOR WLAN CHANNEL CHARACTERIZATION. Dr. Galal Nadim

Ultra-Wideband Time-of-Arrival and Angle-of- Arrival Estimation Using Transformation Between Frequency and Time Domain Signals

Approaches for Angle of Arrival Estimation. Wenguang Mao

MIMO Wireless Communications

METIS Second Training & Seminar. Smart antenna: Source localization and beamforming

SUPERRESOLUTION methods refer to techniques that

Power limits fulfilment and MUI reduction based on pulse shaping in UWB networks

JOINT TRANSMIT ARRAY INTERPOLATION AND TRANSMIT BEAMFORMING FOR SOURCE LOCALIZATION IN MIMO RADAR WITH ARBITRARY ARRAYS

DIRECTION OF ARRIVAL ESTIMATION IN WIRELESS MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS USING MINIMUM VERIANCE DISTORSIONLESS RESPONSE

Performance of Impulse-Train-Modulated Ultra- Wideband Systems

Narrow Band Interference (NBI) Mitigation Technique for TH-PPM UWB Systems in IEEE a Channel Using Wavelet Packet Transform

Cooperative Sensing for Target Estimation and Target Localization

SIGNAL MODEL AND PARAMETER ESTIMATION FOR COLOCATED MIMO RADAR

Analyzing Pulse Position Modulation Time Hopping UWB in IEEE UWB Channel

This is a repository copy of Robust DOA estimation for a mimo array using two calibrated transmit sensors.

AN ACCURATE ULTRA WIDEBAND (UWB) RANGING FOR PRECISION ASSET LOCATION

Performance of Wideband Mobile Channel with Perfect Synchronism BPSK vs QPSK DS-CDMA

Intra-Vehicle UWB MIMO Channel Capacity

Advances in Direction-of-Arrival Estimation

Indoor Positioning with UWB Beamforming

S. Ejaz and M. A. Shafiq Faculty of Electronic Engineering Ghulam Ishaq Khan Institute of Engineering Sciences and Technology Topi, N.W.F.

Applying Time-Reversal Technique for MU MIMO UWB Communication Systems

Project Report. Indoor Positioning Using UWB-IR Signals in the Presence of Dense Multipath with Path Overlapping

DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF MULTIBAND OFDM SYSTEM OVER ULTRA WIDE BAND CHANNELS

Indoor Localization based on Multipath Fingerprinting. Presented by: Evgeny Kupershtein Instructed by: Assoc. Prof. Israel Cohen and Dr.

Elham Torabi Supervisor: Dr. Robert Schober

A Blind Array Receiver for Multicarrier DS-CDMA in Fading Channels

Multipath Beamforming for UWB: Channel Unknown at the Receiver

Performance Analysis of Different Ultra Wideband Modulation Schemes in the Presence of Multipath

Index Terms Uniform Linear Array (ULA), Direction of Arrival (DOA), Multiple User Signal Classification (MUSIC), Least Mean Square (LMS).

IEEE P a. IEEE P Wireless Personal Area Networks. UWB Channel Characterization in Outdoor Environments

Ultra Wideband Signals and Systems in Communication Engineering

Multipath Effect on Covariance Based MIMO Radar Beampattern Design

The Feasibility of Conventional Beamforming Algorithm Based on Resolution for Internet of Things in Millimeter Wave Environment

Joint delay and direction of arrivals estimation in mobile communications

Performance Study of A Non-Blind Algorithm for Smart Antenna System

Performance Analysis of MUSIC and LMS Algorithms for Smart Antenna Systems

STAP approach for DOA estimation using microphone arrays

Combined Use of Various Passive Radar Range-Doppler Techniques and Angle of Arrival using MUSIC for the Detection of Ground Moving Objects

On the performance of Turbo Codes over UWB channels at low SNR

A Soft-Limiting Receiver Structure for Time-Hopping UWB in Multiple Access Interference

Eigenvalues and Eigenvectors in Array Antennas. Optimization of Array Antennas for High Performance. Self-introduction

Noise-robust compressed sensing method for superresolution

UWB Double-Directional Channel Sounding

Performance Analysis of Rake Receivers in IR UWB System

Channel-based Optimization of Transmit-Receive Parameters for Accurate Ranging in UWB Sensor Networks

MIMO Radar Diversity Means Superiority

Spatial Correlation Effects on Channel Estimation of UCA-MIMO Receivers

Channelized Digital Receivers for Impulse Radio

UWB Channel Modeling

Impact of Metallic Furniture on UWB Channel Statistical Characteristics

Analysis of Direction of Arrival Estimations Algorithms for Smart Antenna

Channel Modeling ETI 085

Antennas and Propagation. Chapter 6b: Path Models Rayleigh, Rician Fading, MIMO

Experimental Study on Super-resolution Techniques for High-speed UWB Radar Imaging of Human Bodies

INTERFERENCE REJECTION OF ADAPTIVE ARRAY ANTENNAS BY USING LMS AND SMI ALGORITHMS

FDM based MIMO Spatio-Temporal Channel Sounder

Waveform-Agile Sensing for Range and DoA Estimation in MIMO Radars

Space-Time Encoded Secure Chaos Communications with Transmit Beamforming

Single snapshot DOA estimation

Template Design and Propagation Gain for Multipath UWB Channels with Per-Path Frequency- Dependent Distortion.

Performance of MMSE Based MIMO Radar Waveform Design in White and Colored Noise

An improved direction of arrival (DOA) estimation algorithm and beam formation algorithm for smart antenna system in multipath environment

3D positioning scheme exploiting nano-scale IR-UWB orthogonal pulses

Advances in Radio Science

Ultra Wideband Radio Propagation Measurement, Characterization and Modeling

Design of Complex Wavelet Pulses Enabling PSK Modulation for UWB Impulse Radio Communications

The Estimation of the Directions of Arrival of the Spread-Spectrum Signals With Three Orthogonal Sensors

Study on the UWB Rader Synchronization Technology

DOA Estimation of Coherent Sources under Small Number of Snapshots

Detection of Obscured Targets: Signal Processing

THERE ARE A number of communications applications

Ultra-wideband Technology-based Ranging Platform with Real-time Signal Processing

Channel Modelling ETIN10. Directional channel models and Channel sounding

Joint TOA and DOA Estimation Compliant with IEEE a Standard

A Weighted Least Squares Algorithm for Passive Localization in Multipath Scenarios

A Novel Adaptive Method For The Blind Channel Estimation And Equalization Via Sub Space Method

HIGH accuracy centimeter level positioning is made possible

A novel ULA-based geometry for improving AOA estimation

UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING : SYSTEMS EECS 555 DIGITAL COMMUNICATION THEORY

Low-Complexity Spectral Partitioning Based MUSIC Algorithm for Automotive Radar

PERFORMANCE OF IMPULSE RADIO UWB COMMUNICATIONS BASED ON TIME REVERSAL TECHNIQUE

Performance and Complexity Comparison of Channel Estimation Algorithms for OFDM System

Direction of Arrival Estimation in Smart Antenna for Marine Communication. Deepthy M Vijayan, Sreedevi K Menon /16/$31.

Time Delay Estimation: Applications and Algorithms

A Complete MIMO System Built on a Single RF Communication Ends

ARRAY PROCESSING FOR INTERSECTING CIRCLE RETRIEVAL

Joint Viterbi Decoding and Decision Feedback Equalization for Monobit Digital Receivers

Omnidirectional Sound Source Tracking Based on Sequential Updating Histogram

Performance of Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing System Based on Mobile Velocity and Subcarrier

Waveform-Space-Time Adaptive Processing for Distributed Aperture Radars

Transcription:

American Journal of Applied Sciences Original Research Paper Frequency Extended-MUSIC Method for DOA Estimation in Indoor IR-UWB Environment Hajer Meknessi, Ferid Harrabi and Ali Gharsallah Unit of Research in High Frequency Electronic Circuits and Systems, Faculty of Mathematical, Physical and Natural Sciences of Tunis, Tunis El Manar University, Campus Universitaire Tunis-El Manar-09, Tunis, Tunisia Article history Received: 0--05 Revised: 0-04-06 Accepted: 07-04-06 Corresponding Author: Hajer Meknessi Unit of Research in High Frequency Electronic Circuits and Systems, Faculty of Mathematical, Physical and Natural Sciences of Tunis, Tunis El Manar University, Campus Universitaire Tunis-El Manar-09, Tunis, Tunisia Email: meknessih@gmail.com Abstract: In recent years, many researchers have been developed in order to ensure an accurate localization. So many techniques have been used the direction of arrival to estimate and track of IR-UWB signals. In this study, we propose a new direction of arrival estimation method for impulse radio UWB signals. This technique based on Extended-MUSIC algorithm. The proposed method has high performances in the multipath channels. Simulation results show that it has more accuracy then others high resolution algorithms, moreover, It is compared the performance corresponding to the Cramer-Rae bound (CRB). Keywords: Impulse Radio Ultra Wide Band (IR-UWB), Direction of Arrival Estimation (DOA), Extended-MUSIC, Cramer-Rae bound (CRB) Introduction Nowadays, the impulse radio ultra wideband technologies present a promising solution for the wireless data communication with the presence of many obstacles. In the literature many studies performed in this area and provide the high performances of this technology (Win and Scholtz, 998; 000; Lee et al., 00). The IR-UWB signals has many advantages: First, it s low power consumption. Second, the nature of impulse it makes to penetrate obstacles and reduce interferences. Moreover, it characterized by the high accuracy. Furthermore, the ability of the UWB pulse to resolve individual multi-path components. The IR-UWB signals has an angle resolution capabilities, it has an accurate location estimates. The DOA is important parameters in IR-UWB signal, it has been addressed in the literature (Mani and Bose, 00; 009). Many studies have discussed the performances of some super resolution techniques for DOA estimation in frequency domain (Cao and Li, 00; Zhang et al., 006; Monica and Montse, 0). In this study, a new approach for DOA estimation is proposed. This method based on Extended Music algorithm in frequency domain for indoor localization application (Harabi et al., 007; Meknessi et al., 04). This method estimate the DOAs of the IR-UWB signals, we provide the performance of our proposed algorithm in term of RMSE on comparing with others super resolution techniques and the CRB. This paper is structured as follows: Section is dedicated to describe of the signal model. Section 3 gives the main features of our proposed Frequency Extended Music method for DOA estimation and developed Music, root Music, Esprit and Matrix Pencil. In section 4, the Cramer-Rae bound for DOA estimation is derived. Some simulation results are provided in section 5. Finally, section 6 concludes the paper. These superscripts: (.)T, (.)*, (.)H and (.)- presents the matrix transpose, conjugate, hermitian and inverse operators, respectively. Signal Model In an IR-UWB system, we consider the sending signal model, it can be expressed as: N f q q = j f f j c k k= j= 0 () s () t p( t ( kn j) T ct b T δ ) where, transmission of an information symbol is typically implemented by the repetition of N f pulses of very short duration (Win and Scholtz, 998), b k {0, } is the information symbols, T f is the frame period, where a total of N c pulses are sent, N f is the number of frames 06 Hajer Meknessi, Ferid Harrabi and Ali Gharsallah. This open access article is distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY) 3.0 license.

per symbol, T c is chip duration, T δ is the PPM modulation time shift, {c j } is the time hopping sequence, q is the number of paths and p(t) is the waveform of the transmitted pulse, which is the second order derivative of Gaussian function given by: p t = t t () ( ) ( 4 π / τm)exp( π / τm) Therefore, the UWB multipath channel impulse model defined as: L h( t) = αδ i ( t τl) (3) l= 0 Where: α l = The fading coefficient τ I = The propagation delay of l th path For UWB systems, the received wideband signal can be represented as the convolution of s(t) and h(t) as: x ( t) = s ( t)* h() t w ( t) (4) m q m where, w m is the additive Gaussian white noise, M is the number of element antenna array and m {, M-}. Then the received signal on the m sensor antenna equidistant spaced d can be formulated as follow: Q ( m ) dsin( θq) xm( t) = sq t wm() t q= c (5) d: is the distance between antenna elements in the array, c the speed of light and θ q direction of arrival of the qth path. After Fourier transformation to the received signal in (5), we obtain atransforming signal in the frequency domain, it can be formulated as follow: ( m ) dsin( θ ( ) sin( ) ) m d θq jπ f jπ f c c a( θq, fk) =, e,..., e Finally the covariance matrix is expressed as: T () R = E X( f ) X( f ) T (3) k k Let the number of element antenna array M be larger than the number of paths q. Then, from the formulation of received signals and additive noise is obtained as: R AS A Iσ = T E (4) where, the q*q vector S E = E[S(f k ) S(f k ) T ] is the source covariance matrix, I is the identity matrix and σ is the noise variance. DOA Estimation Algorithms Frequency Extended-MUSIC Method Frequency Extended-MUSIC is based on Extended MUSIC algorithm (Harabi et al., 007; Meknessi et al., 04). The following steps outline the procedure of estimation of the DOA using the proposed method: Perform Eigen values decomposition on R λ n, n =,..., N tr( Rˆ ) Calculate a positive scalar value as m= N Construct the new Frequency EXTENDED MUSIC function as: τ G = R ma( θ) a( θ) H (5) Extract the Eigen values of the new extended correlation matrix G τ in decreasing order: Q ( m )sin( θq) jπ f c m k = q k m k q= X ( f ) S ( f ) e W ( f ) (6) µ λ l =,..., L l l µ = λ = σ n= L,..., N n n n (6) where, X m (f), S q (f) and W m (f) are the Fourier transformation of x m (t), s q (t) and w m (t)respectively. The received signals in can be given in matrix from as: X( f ) = A( θ, f ) S( f ) W( f ) (7) Where: k k k k X( f ) = [ X ( f ), X ( f ),... X ( f )] T (8) k k k M k S( f ) = [ S( f ), S ( f ),... S ( f )] T (9) k k k M k A( θ, f ) = [ a( θ, f ), a( θ, f ),... a( θ, f )] (0) k k k q k W( f ) = [ W( f ), W ( f ),... W ( f )] T () k k k M k Calculate the function: D( θ) = N ( µ l _ λl ) l= L Music Method (7) The following steps summarize the MUSIC algorithm (Stoica and Nehorai, 989): Perform Eigenvector and Eigen value on R. Where e i is the eigenvector associated with Eigen value λ i which will organized as: λ λ... λ λ = λ... = λ = σ (8) L L L N w 373

Let U s = [e e L ] and U n = [e L e N ] be the signal subspace and noise subspace, respectively Construction of the MUSIC pseudo spectrum function as: H H F( θ) = / a( θ) U U a( θ) (9) n n where, a(θ) is the steering vector. Find the values of θ that minimizes F(θ), these values are the estimated DOA. ESPRIT Method ESPRIT stands for estimation of Signal Parameters via rotational Invariance Technique. It developed by ROY and KEILATH (Keshavaraz, 05; Li and Jiang, 009; Yilmazer et al., 008). This subspace based method explores the rotational invariance property in the subspace signal created by two sub-arrays derived from original array with a translation invariance structure. The ESPRIT algorithm is summarized as follows: Perform Eigen values decomposition on R Extraction of the subspace signal Decompose the subspace into subarray E and E Estimate the matrix Ψ using the method of least squares: H ( ) Ψ = E E E E (0) H Calculate the Eigen values of Ψ The DOA is obtained from Eigenvectors of Ψ Matrix Pencil Method The Matrix PENCIL technique is based on the use of the received signal expression. It was developed in order to estimate the poles of a system (Bayat and Adve, 003). The Pencil Matrix algorithm is summarized as follows: Choose the Pencil parameter P as: N * N P () 3 3 Construction of the received signals matrix Decompose the received signals matrix into subarrays X 0 and X as: x(0) x()... x( P ) x() x()... x( P) X0 =...... x( L P ) x( L P)... x( L ) () And: x() x()... x( P) x() x(3)... x( P ) X =...... x( L P) x( L P )... x( L ) (3) Estimate the matrix Ψ MP using the method of least square: Ψ = ( X X ) X X (3) MP H H 0 0 0 The DOA is obtained from Eigenvectors of Ψ MP Root-Music ROOT-MUSIC is the polynomial copy of Multiple Signal Classification (MUSIC). This technique detected the DOA of the arriving signals on searching roots in the complex plane (Fang et al., 04). The following ROOT-MUSIC algorithm is: Perform Eigen vector and Eigen value on R. Where e i is the eigenvector associated with Eigen value λ i and: λ λ... λ λ = λ... = λ = σ (5) L L L N w Let U s = [e e L ] and U n = [e L e N ] be the signal subspace and noise subspace, respectively Construction the polynomial degree: f z f f z n ( ) = 0... fnz (6) Who s the coefficients correspond to the trace of the noise subspace matrix: Finding roots of this polynomial and display them in the complex plane with the unit circle Find the value of θ corresponding to the nearest root in the unit circle Cramer-Rao Bound The Cramér-Rao bound (CRB) is a limit mathematical on the performance of an unbiased estimator. Indeed, it s a lower bound on the error variance of any methods. In order for the analytical formulations to be valid, the following assumptions are needed (Stoica and Nehorai, 989), a general formula for the CRB on the covariance matrix of any unbiased estimate (Zhang et al., 005; He and Blum, 00): 374

Γ( α) Γ( α) = Γ Γ α j [( CRB )] ij tr ( α) ( α) αi m*( α) m( α) Re Γ ( α) αi αi (7) where, α i denotes the i component of α. (Γ(α)) independent of α and in (Fang et al., 04) m(α) Independent of α. The general formula has been presented in (Zhang et al., 005). The CRB corresponding to these parameters is (He and Blum, 00): { σ T CRB = Re[ H P ]} (8) N Where: H D*[ I A( A* A) ] D = (9) D d d k = [... ] (30) a( θ) di = / θ = θi θ K K i = (3) P = S ( f)* S ( f) (3) q q I M a (M)*(M): Sized identity matrix. Moreover, the value σ is the noise power and the operator [.] ij denotes the selection of the i, j th element of the matrix. Simulation Results We have investigated the performances of our proposed method against other algorithms in terms of accuracy and resolution. We consider an ULA antenna array with eight elements and the antenna separation is one half of the wavelength. The simulation parameters are given in Table. Three IR-UWB pulses incident on the antenna element from 30, 50 and 70 respectively, with a Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR) of 0 db and 000 snapshots. We will study the resolution of our proposed method with Root-Music, Esprit and Matrix Pencil. The obtained spectrums of Frequency Extended MUSIC and Frequency MUSIC have been illustrated in Fig.. However, those of Esprit, Root-Music and Pencil Matrix are presented in Table. As shown in Fig. and Table, Frequency Extended MUSIC, Frequency MUSIC, Esprit and Root-Music are able to detect three paths, but Matrix Pencil separate only one. Our proposed method has performed an accurate detection of DOAs. Fig.. FREQUENCY EXTENDED MUSIC and FREQUENCY MUSIC spectrograms of three DOAs estimation 375

Fig.. FREQUENCY EXTEDED MUSIC and FREQUENCY MUSIC spectrograms of two neighbor DOAs estimation Fig. 3. MSE for four paths located at 0, 0, 40 and 80 versus number of sensors In order to investigate the performances of our approach in terms of resolution, we consider two rays of UWB arriving signals with directions of arrival are 40 and 43, respectively, with respect of the same simulation condition. The spectrums of Frequency Extended MUSIC and Frequency MUSIC are plotted in Fig., while the result simulation of Esprit and Root-Music methods are illustrated in Table 3. Figure and Table 3 show that our method, ESPRIT and the root-music algorithms are able to detect and separate these two paths. However we can note that the Frequency Music method shows only one peak. So, it can be pointed out that the obtained results prove the high resolution of Frequency Extended Music. Morover, it can be separate these two neighboring paths scenario in this condition simulation. 376

Fig. 4. MSE for two paths located at 0 and 50 versus SNRs for FREQUENCY EXTENDED MUSIC, FREQUENCY MUSIC and the CRB Table. Simulation parameters Parameters Value Measurements 0 Duration of DS-UWB signals ns UWB pulse duration ns Frequency sampling interval.45 GHz Table. DOAs estimation by root-music, esprit and matrix pencil True Root- PENCIL DOA DOA ESPRIT MUSIC MATRIX DOA 30 30.0458 30.07 9.093 DOA 50 50.053 50.033 4.8538 DOA 3 70 69.8457 69.869 6.834 Table 3. DOA estimation by esprit and root-music DOA True DOA ESPRIT Root-MUSIC DOA 40 40.4 40.0866 DOA 43 43.45 43.637 To illustrate the performance of our proposed approach, we simulate the Mean Square Error (MSE) is defined as following: MSE = ( ) nbr nbr ˆ θ θ (33) i= where, ˆ θis the estimated direction of arrival for i th measurements. In the next simulation we use four paths of UWB signal localized at 0, 0, 40 and 80 respectively, we have simulated the MSE of DOA estimation of our proposed approach with Frequency Music method, it has evaluated for different number of sensors levels with a Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR) of 5 db and 000 snapshots. Figure 3 illustrates the MSE of FREQUENCY EXTENDED MUSIC AND FREQUENCY MUSIC methods for four paths located at 0, 0, 40 and 80 versus number of sensors. As shown above, we can notice that the number of sensor has an influence on the estimation quality; as well, our method is the most efficient. It is clearly evident that performance of the FREQUENCY EXTENED MUSIC is better than FREQUENCY MUSIC at low SNR with less number of sensors. The hight performance of our prposed method has been studied via a comparaison with the CRB, so the last simulation, have been carried out with estiming two paths at, 0 and 50 with 000 snapshots. The MSE of the FREQUENCY EXTENDED MUSIC, FREQUENCY MUSIC and CRB is evaluatet in different SNR as we show at Fig. 4. Indeed, the capacity of our proposed approach is proved in the simulation results. In contrast, FREQUENCY EXTENDED MUSIC estimates seem to be less sensitive in the multipath channel, when it compared with FREQUENCY MUSIC and CRB. Thus, we conclude that our proposed techniques have better performance than others methods. It is less biased and has better resolution on comparing to FREQUENCY MUSIC for ULA array processing in IR-UWB systems. Conclusion In this study, a frequency domain DOA estimation method for direction of arrival estimation in IR-UWB channels based on extended Music algorithm is proposed. Simulation results shows that our new 377

approach has high performances in terms of accuracy and resolution. It characterized by an efficient and reliable estimation. Our method improves the DOA estimation of IR-UWB signals in dense environment. So, it has been compared with others like Music, Esprit and root Music. Our Frequency Extended ensures an accurate estimation at low SNR with less number of sensors in multipath environment. Acknowledgement We are grateful to the Unit of Research in High Frequency Electronic Circuits and Systems who supported us in the preparation of this work. Funding Information We have no support or funding to report. Author s Contributions Hajer Meknessi: Conception, design and writing of computer programs for Frequency Extended-MUSIC Method for DOA Estimation in Indoor IR-UWB Environment. Ferid Harrabi: coordination of the realization of this work. Ali Gharsallah: organization of the plan of this study. Ethics This work is new and presents unpublished material. All authors have examined and agreed the manuscript. We confirm that no ethical issues concerned. References Bayat, K. and R.S. Adve, 003. Joint TOA/DOA wireless position location using matrix pencil. Wireless Commun. Network., : 63-635. DOI: 0.09/VETECF.004.4047 Cao, F. and M. Li, 00. Frequency domain DOA estimation and tracking of UWB signals. Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Wireless Communications Networking and Mobile Computing, Sept. 3-5, IEEE Xplore Press, Chengdu, pp: -4. DOI: 0.09/WICOM.00.56008 Fang, W., Z. Xiao and W. Fer, 04. Root-MUSIC based joint TOA and DOA estimation in IR-UWB. J. Commun. DOI: 0.3969/j.issn.000-436x.04.0.08 Harabi, F., H. Changuel and A. Gharsallah, 007. A new estimation of direction of arrival algorithm with a special antenna shape. Smart Mater, Struct. J., 6: 595-599. DOI: 0.088/0964-76/6/6/063 He, Q. and R.S. Blum, 00. Cramér-Rao bound for MIMO radar target localization with phase errors. IEEE Signal Process. Lett., : 83-86. DOI: 0.09/LSP.009.03994 Keshavaraz, H., 05. Weighted signal-subspace direction-finding of ultra-wideband sources. Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Wireless and Mobile Computing, Networking and Communications, Aug. -4, IEEE Xplore Press, pp: 3-9. DOI: 0.09/WIMOB.005.58 Lee, J.Y., R.A. Scholtz and L. Fellow, 00. Ranging in a dense multipath environment using an UWB radio link. IEEE J. Selec. Areas Commun., 0: 677-683. DOI: 0.09/JSAC.00.805060 Li, X. and H. Jiang, 009. Lunar rover positioning based on TOA estimation for UWB signal using unitary- ESPRIT. Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Electronic Measurement and Instruments, Aug. 6-9, IEEE Xplore Press, Beijing, pp: -646--650. DOI: 0.09/ICEMI.009.574474 Mani, V.V. and R. Bose, 009. Direction of arrival estimation of multiple UWB signals. Wireless Pers. Commun., 57: 77-89. DOI: 0.007/s77-009-9857- Mani, V.V. and R. Bose, 00. Direction of arrival estimation and beamforming of multiple coherent UWB signals. Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Communications, May 3-7, IEEE Xplore Press, Cape Town, pp: -5. DOI: 0.09/ICC.00.550034 Meknessi, H., F. Harabi and A. Gharsallah, 04. Frequency domain Extended-MUSIC algorithm for TOA estimation in indoor UWB radio impulse channels. Int. J. Comput. Applic., 07: 0-4. DOI: 0.50/939-009 Monica, N. and N. Montse, 0. Frequency domain joint TOA and DOA estimation in IR-UWB. IEEE Trans. Wireless Commun., 0: 374-384. DOI: 0.09/TWC.0.075.090933 Stoica, P. and A. Nehorai, 989. MUSIC, maximum likelihood and Cramer-Rao bound. IEEE Trans. Acoust., Speech, Signal Process., 37: 70-74. DOI: 0.09/9.7564 Win, M.Z. and R.A. Scholtz, 998. On the robustness of ultra-wide bandwidth signals in dense multipath environments. IEEE Commun. Lett., : 5-53. DOI: 0.09/434.66080 Win, M.Z. and R.A. Scholtz, 000. Ultra-wide bandwidth time-hopping spread-spectrum impulse radio for wireless multiple-access communications. IEEE Trans. Wireless Commun., 48: 679-69. DOI: 0.09/6.84335 378

Yilmazer, N., A. Seckin and T. Sarkar, 008. Multiple snapshot direct data domain approach and ESPRIT method for direction of arrival estimation. Digital Signal Process., 8: 56-567. DOI: 0.06/j.dsp.007.07.004 Zhang, J., R.A. Kennedy and T.D. Abhayapala, 005. Cramér-rao lower bounds for the synchronization of UWB signals. EURASIP J. Applied Signal Process., 005: 46-438. DOI: 0.55/ASP.005.46 Zhang, W., T.D. Abhayapala and J. Zhang, 006. UWB spatia-frequency channel characterization. Proceedings of the IEEE 63rd Vehicular Technology Conference, May 7-0, IEEE Xplore Press, Melbourne, Vic., pp: 73-736. DOI: 0.09/VETECS.006.683365 379