SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS Monday, December 22, 2003 STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER Tom Albert, et al v. Pat Frye, et al M2003-00883-SC-R11-CV Tony Baldwin v. Board of Paroles, et al M2002-01428-SC-R11-CV Patricia Conley, ind. & as Personal Representative of Estate of Martha Stinson, Deceased v. State of M2002-00813-SC-R11-CV In Re: Estate of Spencer Brown Don M. Brown v. Allene Dunnagan M2002-00141-SC-R11-CV In the matter of: A.J.H., Joseph and Jean Gonzalez v. State of Dept. Of Children s Services COUNTY TRIAL JUDGE TRIAL COURT NO. Robertson Circuit Ross H. Hicks 9571 Davidson Chancery Irvin H. Kilcrease, Jr. 01-2533-I Claims Commission W.R. Baker 20200368 Dickson Circuit Allen W. Wallace CV 1290 Davidson Juvenile Betty K. Adams 2219-68191 APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT Cantrell, P.J., M.S. Dismissed Cantrell, P.J., M.S. Highers, J. Brown, III, Sp. J. Reversed; Cause to Circuit Court Koch,P.J.,Cain,J, Cottrell,J., M.S. Denied Rule 9 NATURE OF APPEAL Rule 9 ACTION Granted - Application of Pat Frye and Vernon Frye. Denied - Application of Tony Baldwin. Granted - Application of the State of. Denied - Application of Allene Dunnagan. Granted - Application of Joseph and Jean Gonzalez Page 1 of 9
Vanessa Manning v. City of Lebanon, et al M2002-02075-SC-R11-CV Wilson Chancery Charles K. Smith 02090 Cantrell, P.J., M.S. Denied - Application of Vanessa Manning. Alan Miller, et al v. City of Murfreesboro, et al M2001-01478-SC-R11-CV Prodigy Services Corporation, Inc. v. Ruth E. Johnson, Commissioner of Revenue, State of, et al M2002-00918-SC-R11-CV Squeeky Clean Laundries, Inc. v. David E. Harvey, et al M2002-00538-SC-R11-CV State of, on Relation of the Commissioner of the Department of Transportation, for and on Behalf of the State of, et al v. Any and All Parties With an Interest in Property Identified as Tax Map 158, Parcel 34, Tax Assessor s Office, Davidson County,, et al M2002-01137-SC-R11-CV Rutherford Chancery John W. Rollins 96-CV-975 Davidson Chancery Ellen H. Lyle 98-1051-III Davidson Chancery Carol L. McCoy 99-2837-II Davidson Chancery Ellen H. Lyle 99-1278-III Cain, J. Cantrell, P.J., M.S. and Johnson, Sp. J. and Denied - Application of Alan Miller, Ken Roberts, and John Singleton. Denied - Application of Ruth E. Johnson, Commissioner of Revenue, State of, et al. Denied - Application of David E. Harvey, ind. & Campus Concepts, Inc., formerly d/b/a Harvey Washbangers. Denied - Application of Any and All Parties, et al. **The Opinion of the Court of Appeals is designated Not for Citation. Page 2 of 9
Reta J. Tompkins, et al v. Kevin W. Helton, et al M2002-01244-SC-R11-CV Putnam Circuit John A. Turnbull 00-N0374 McCoy, Sp. J. Denied - Application of Reta J. Tompkins. State of v. William E. Eakes, III M2001-01420-SC-R11-CD State of v. Ronald B. Finch M2002-01050-SC-R11-CD State of v. Robert Kern Holloway M2002-01904-SC-R11-CD State of v. Ricky Lynn Littrell M2002-01298-SC-R11-CD State of v. Timmy Ray Mooneyhan M2003-01866-SC-R9-CO State of v. William Ramsey Davidson Criminal Seth Norman 99-A-35 Davidson Criminal Cheryl Blackburn 2001-A0252 Dickson Circuit Allen Wallace CR5515 Bedford Circuit Lee Russell 1484 Bedford Circuit Wedemeyer, J. Hayes, J. Glenn, J. in Part; Vacated in Part Denied - Application of William E. Eakes, III. Denied - Application of Ronald B. Finch. Denied - Application of Robert Kern Holloway. Denied - Application of Ricky Lynn Littrell. Wedemeyer, J. Denied Rule 9 Denied Application of Timmy Ray Mooneyhan. 14,894 Warren Circuit Glenn, J. Denied - Application of William Charles D. Haston as Ramsey. M2001-02735-SC-R11-CD F-8152 Modified State of v. Kenneth Rutherford Circuit Ogle, J. Denied - Application of Kenneth Strickland J. Steve Daniel Strickland. M2002-00543-SC-R11-CD F-49297 State of v. Siphachanh Wilson Criminal Wedemeyer, J. Denied - Application of Siphachanh Page 3 of 9
Sippy Syhalath M2002-02123-SC-R11-CD State of v. Johnny Darryl Williams-Bey M2002-00950-SC-R11-CD J. O. Bond 01-1361 Davidson Criminal Cheryl Blackburn 2001-A-349 Welles, J. as Modified Sippy Syhalath. Denied - Application of the State of and Application of Johnny Darryl Williams-Bey. State of v. William L. Vaughn M2002-01879-SC-R11-CD Davidson Criminal J. Randall Wyatt, Jr. 2001-D-1990 Riley, J. Denied Application of William Vaughn. Cedrick Arnett, et al v. Domino s Pizza, L.L.C., et al W2001-02942-SC-R11-CV First State Bank of Holly Springs, Mississippi, et al v. Bill Wyssbrod, et al W2002-03016-SC-R11-CV First TN Bank National Association v. Marilyn Conway W2002-02342-SC-R11-CV Nina Sue Holland v. City of Memphis, et al W2002-01529-SC-R11-CV George H. Brown CT-001187-01 Robert L. Childers CT-002006-01 4350-01 John R. McCarroll, Jr. CT-001866-01 Shelby Chancery Floyd Peete 98-0604-2 in Part and Reversed in Part; and Crawford, P.J., W.S. Highers, J. Dismissed by Order and Denied - Application of Cedrick Arnett, et al. Denied - Application of Martin Aussenberg. Denied - Application of Marilyn Conway. Denied - Application of Nina Sue Holland. In the Matter of L.J.C., A.L.C. and Tipton Juvenile Highers, J. Denied - Application of Tabitha Page 4 of 9
J.R.C. State of Department of Children s Services v. Tabitha Stewart W2001-01799-SC-R11-CV Rodney V. Johnson v. James Gulley W2002-02537-SC-R11-CV William A. Peeler J4427 Robert A. Lanier CT-007605-01 Vacated in Part; in Part and and Stewart. Denied - Application of Rodney V. Johnson. Billy Joe Lambert, et al v. Jon Douglas Hall W2002-02511-SC-R11-CV Robert D. Pelts v. International Medical Services Corp., Hugh A. Hines, Jr., Carlton Smith, and Bernard Tibbetts W2002-00388-SC-R11-CV Lafeyette Romine, Sr. and Debra P. Romine v. Julia Fernandez, CRNA and Johnathan Isom, M.D. W2002-00703-SC-R11-CV State of, Department of Children s Services v. Portia Ann Letney Butler, et al W2003-01002-SC-R11-PT Deonnie Rodenie Boykin v. State of W2003-00066-SC-R11-CO Tyrone Cunningham v. State of W2001-02941-SC-R11-CD Shelby Chancery D.J. Alissandratos CH-00-1102-3 George H. Brown, Jr. 305315-9 T.D. McNairy Juvenile Bob Gray C-482 Obion Circuit William B. Acree 2-379 Lauderdale Circuit Joseph H. Walker, III 7059 Kirby, J. Highers, J. Crawford, P.J., W.S. Riley, J. Appeal Dismissed Denied - Petition to Rehear of Jon D. Hall. Denied - Application of Carlton Smith. Denied - Application of Julie Fernandez, CRNA, and Johnathan Isom, M.D. Denied Application of William Mark Butler. Denied - Application of Deonnie Rodenie Boykin. Denied - Application of Tyrone Cunningham. Page 5 of 9
State of v. Charlene Denise Franks W2002-02067-SC-R11-CD State of v. Bobby Holt, Jr. W2002-02443-SC-R11-CD Hardin Circuit C. Creed McGinley 7832 Hardin Circuit C. Creed McGinley 8143 Denied - Application of Charlene Denise Franks. Denied - Application of Bobby Holt, Jr. State of v. Shun D. Jones W2001-01313-SC-R11-CD State of v. Felix Bartolo Jose W2002-02532-SC-R11-CD State of v. Thomas Mitchell W2002-01781-SC-R11-CD State of v. Marcus Rogers W2002-01416-SC-R11-CD State of v. Jerry Lorenze Sandridge, et al W2002-00945-SC-R11-CD State of v. Quinten Turnage W2002-02269-SC-R11-CD Martin T. Terrell v. State of W2003-02073-SC-R11-CD Shelby Criminal Bernie Weinman 00-04543-44 Henry Circuit Julian P. Guinn 13306 Shelby Criminal Chris Craft 02-00161 Shelby Criminal Chris Craft 01-00606-07 Lauderdale Circuit Joseph H. Walker, III 7119-C Joseph B. Dailey 01-06585 Tipton Circuit Joseph H. Walker 2971 Hayes, J. Hayes, J. Woodall, J. Hayes, J. Welles, J. in Part, Reversed in Part; Wedemeyer, J. Williams, J. Denied Denied - Application of Shun D. Jones. Denied - Application of Felix Bartolo Jose. Denied - Application of Thomas Mitchell. Denied - Application of Marcus Rogers. Denied - Application of Jerry Lorenze Sandridge. Denied - Application of Quinten Turnage. Denied - Application of Martin T. Terrell. Bankers Trust Company v. Timothy Knox Chancery Franks, J. Denied - Application of Bankers Page 6 of 9
L. Collins, et al E2002-02109-SC-R11-CV Coleman Properties, L.L.C. v. AFG Industries, Inc., et al E2003-01444-SC-S09-CV KBH Holdings, Inc. v. Mark A. Duncan, et al E2002-02062-SC-R11-CV McMinn County v. Ocoee Environmental Services, Inc., et al E2002-00702-SC-R11-CV Daryl R. Fansler 148680-2 Sullivan Circuit John S. McLellan, III C2591 Knox Chancery Daryl R. Fansler 149910-2 McMinn Chancery John B. Hagler 20,324 Franks, J. Susano, J. Rule 9 Denied Susano, J. & Goddard, P.J., E.S. & Rule 9 Trust Company. Denied - Application of AFG Ind., Inc., Guardian Ind. Corp & PPG Ind., Inc. Denied - Application of KBH Holdings, Inc. Denied - Application of McMinn County. State of Department of Children s Services v. DLSJ In the Matter of: CLJ, A Child Under the Age of 18 Years E2002-00241-SC-R11-JV David W. Vaughn v. Daimler Chrysler Corportion, et al E2002-02163-SC-R11-CV Brent Blye v. State of E2003-2277-SC-R9-CD Earl D. Crawford v. State of E2002-02334-SC-R11-PC Alden Joe Daniel, Jr. v. State of E2002-02838-SC-R11-PC Knox Juvenile Carey E. Garrett H3813 Sullivan Circuit Phyllis H. Miller S4636 Bradley Circuit R. Steven Bebb 89-677 Bradley Circuit Carroll L. Ross M-01-392 Franks, J. & Ogle, J. Rule 9 Denied Woodall, J. Woodall, J. Denied Application of Debra L. James. Rule 9 Denied - Petition to Rehear of David W. Vaughn and Betty Vaughn. Denied - Application of Brent Blye. Denied - Application of Earl D. Crawford. Denied - Application of Alden Joe Daniel, Jr. Page 7 of 9
Robert Linder v. State of E2003-02202-SC-S10-CD Blount Circuit D. Kelly Thomas, Jr. C-13877 Rule 10 Denied Rule 10 Denied - Application of Robert Linder. Robert Linder v. State of E2003-02200-SC-S09-CD Blount Circuit D. Kelly Thomas, Jr. C-14001 Rule 9 Denied Rule 9 Denied - Application of Robert Linder Dexter L. McMillan v. State of E2003-01039-SC-R11-PC Anthony Jerome Stokes v. State of E2002-02597-SC-R11-PC Knox Criminal Ray Jenkins 74709 Hamilton Criminal Douglas A. Meyer 211-043 Appeal Dismissed Vacated & Re- Entered; Trial Court Denied - Applicaiton of Dexter L. McMillan Granted - Application of State of. **Application of Anthony Jerome Stokes Pending Application of the State of. State of v. Michael Sammie Brown E2002-01035-SC-R11-CD State of v. Patrick Deshun Paris E202-01514-SC-CD State of v. Jimmy Wayne Perkey E2002-00772-SC-R11-CD State of v. Brandon Ray Roland E2002-00927-SC-R11-CD State of v. Scott E. Snow E2002-00034-SC-R11-CD Morgan Circuit James B. Scott, Jr. 8613 Hamilton Criminal Rebecca J. Stern 224116, 224232 Knox Criminal Ray Jenkins 72968 Rhea Circuit J. Curtis Smith 15293 Roane Circuit Jerry Smith/12338 Williams, J. Williams, J. Smith, J. Woodall, J. Smith, J. Denied - Application of Michael Sammie Brown. Denied - Application of Patrick Deshun Paris. Denied - Application of Jimmy Wayne Perkey. Denied - Application of Brandon Ray Roland. Denied - Application of Scott E. Snow Page 8 of 9
State of v. Lee Ann Wolfe, et al. E2002-00776-SC-R11-CD Tommy Joe Walker v. State of E2002-02431-SC-R11-PC Hawkins Circuit James E. Beckner 7967B & 7967C Knox Criminal Richard R. Baumgartner 69441 Wedemeyer, J. Denied - Application of Lee Ann Wolfe Denied - Application of Tommy Joe Walker. Page 9 of 9