CORPORATE GOVERNANCE REPORT 1. CORPORATE GOVERNANCE PHILOSOPHY The National Detergent Co. SAOG is committed to the highest standards of corporate governance in all its activities. Key elements in corporate governance such as transparency, disclosure, internal control, risk management, internal and external communications of high standards are being practiced. The Board confirms that the Company follows the principles enlisted in the CMA s Code of Corporate Governance for MSM listed Companies. The following is a report on the status and progress on the major aspects of corporate governance. 2. BOARD OF DIRECTORS Composition: The Board consists of eight members with experience in various disciplines like finance, industry, trading and general manufacturing. The present Board was reconstituted by re-election at the Annual General Meeting held on 23 rd March 2013 in accordance with the new rules and conditions for election of s prescribed for public joint stock companies. In line with the requirements spelt out under the Commercial Companies Law, the newly elected Board met separately to elect its Chairman and Vice-Chairman apart from reconstituting its Committees. Besides, the Secretary to the Board was also duly nominated. Board Meetings and Details of Board Members: During the year ended 31 December 2013, five meetings of the Board of s were held on the following dates, 24 th February, 23 rd March, 23 rd April, 18 th July and 28 th October. Name of the Redha Baqir Al Lawati Mahdi Abdul Baqi Representing Position Independent Individual Zubair Enterprises LLC Chairman Non-Executive Vice Chairman Non-Executive Anwar Ali Sultan W J Towell & Co. Non-Executive Mohammed Abdul Hussain Bhacker V Venkataraman Sadacharam Ramasamy Ali Taya Jandal Bhacker Suleiman Jaffer Co. Wilayat Holding Co. Ltd. LLC National Heaters SAOG Oman International Development and Investment Company SAOG No. of Meetings attended Mr Abdul Hussain Bhacker Al Lawati, Ex-Chairman had attended one board meeting dated 24 th Feb 2013. 1 Whether attended last AGM 4 5 2 No Non-Executive No 5 Non-Executive Non-Executive 4 Non-Executive V Sundaresan Al Habib & Co. Executive No 5 4 2
Other ships held during the year: Name of the Name of the Company Position Held Redha Baqir Al Lawati Sweets of Oman Saog Chairman Mahdi Abdul Baqi National Biscuits Industries Ltd. Saog Sweets of Oman Saog Oman Abrasives Anwar Ali Sultan Majan Glass Co. Saog Chairman Mohammed Abdul Hussain Bhacker Sweets of Oman Saog V Venkataraman Sadacharam Ramasamy Ali Taya Jandal Areej Vegetable Oils & Derivatives Saog. Muscat Finance Co. Ltd. Saog. Oman Textile Holding Company SAOG - - V Sundaresan - - Mr Redha Baqir Al Lawati, Chairman Board of s: A leading businessman with professional diploma in computer having more than 30 years of experience in a wide range of fields like trading, manufacturing, marketing and real estate. He is currently the Chairman of Board of s of M/s Sweets of Oman saog and M/s Bhacker Suleman Jaffer Co. Mr Mahdi Abdul Baqi, Vice Chairman, Board s: A graduate in commerce having more than 37 years of experience in many diversified companies in the fields of manufacturing, trading and distribution. He is currently holding the position in M/s Sweets of Oman, M/s National Biscuit Industries and M/s Oman Abrasives. Mr Mohammed Abdul Hussain Bhacker Al Lawati, : Graduate from Yarmook University, Jordan having more than 20 years of experience in the field of trading, distribution, marketing, manufacturing and real estate. He is the member of Board of s of M/s Sweets of Oman and M/s Bhacker Suleman Jaffer Co. Mr Anwar Ali Sultan, : A leading businessman in Sultanate of Oman who joined M/s W J Towell group in 1968 and became a member of the Board of s and currently holding Chairmanship and s position in many diversified companies in the field of trading, distribution, marketing, manufacturing and real estate etc. He is having more than 44 years of experience with professional diploma in Business Administration and Shipping. 2
Mr V. Venkataraman, : A Chartered Accountant and Cost Accountant from India having over 41 years of varied experience in the fields of Finance, Accounting, Internal Auditing, Taxation and Management and has held senior positions in the Omzest Group for over 25 years. He has served on the Boards of several companies in Oman and is currently Dy. Chairman and Chairman of Audit Committee in both Muscat Finance SAOG and Areej Vegetable Oils and Derivatives Co saog. Mr Sadacharam Ramasamy, : He Holds a Master's degree in Commerce and having Professional Qualification in Finance & Management Accounting. He is a rank holder in his Bachelor s and Master s Degree and carries a rich industry experience of 20 years at various levels. Prior to joining OMZEST group he worked with Tata Group for 14 years. His experience includes both manufacturing and services sector. In addition to Finance & Management Accounting, he is a specialist in Information Technology, ERP, Systems and Processes. Mr Ali Taya Jandal, : A graduate in Mechanical Engineering from University of Liverpool, UK having 10 years experience in Oil & Gas and Investment sector. 3. AUDIT COMMITTEE Composition and Meetings: The Committee was elected in 2013, comprising of three independent non-executive directors. The statutory auditors, internal auditors and the senior management personnel were invited to attend the meetings of the Committee as and when required. Besides, the Committee also met the external auditors independently on different occasions during the year. The Committee met four times during the year ended 2013 on the following dates, 20 th February, 21 st April, 18 th July and 28 th October. Name of the Member No. of meetings attended Redha Baqir Al Lawati 1 Position Chairman (BOD) Mohammed Abdul Hussain Bhacker 3 Chairman (AC) V Venkataraman 2 Member Sadacharam Ramashamy 4 Member Mahdi Abdul Baqi 1 Member 3
Role of Audit Committee: The role of the Audit Committee covers the matters specified under the Code of Corporate Governance, which includes: - Overseeing the financial reporting process and disclosure of financial information in general and with particular reference to review the annual and quarterly financial statements before submission to the Board. Reviewing any change in accounting policy and practices and any departure from International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). Reviewing the adequacy of the internal control system through the reports of the internal and external auditors. Reviewing risk management policies of the company and ensuring its adequacy. Reviewing proposed transactions with related parties for making suitable recommendation to the Board. Overseeing the internal audit function in general with particular reference to reviewing the scope of the internal audit plan for each year. Considering the choice of statutory auditors, determining their fees and terms of engagement and recommending their appointment. The Committee also holds discussions with the external and internal auditors independent of the management wherever necessary apart from serving as a channel of communication between the auditors and the Board. 4. EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE The Company has in place a duly constituted Executive Committee comprising three independent non-executive directors. The Committee met two times during the year 2013 on 21 st April and 16 th Dec. During the meeting the committee discussed new business proposal and future business expansion plan. Besides, the Committee members also discussed with the management on other occasions to review the significant market developments and major operational issues. The Committee is delegated with appropriate powers and authority for guiding the management in the smooth running of the operations of the company. Name of the Member No. of meetings Attended Position Redha Baqir Al Lawati 1 Chairman (BOD) Mohammed Abdul Hussain Bhacker 2 Chairman (EC) V Venkataraman 1 Member Sadacharam Ramasamy * 2 Member 4
5. REMUNERATION MATTERS Sitting fees amounting to RO 12,800/- are payable for meetings during the year and RO 30,000/- has been proposed as total s remuneration for the year. s name Abdul Hussain Bin Bhacker Al Lawati Redha Baqir Al Lawati Sitting fee (RO) s remuneration (RO) Total remuneration (RO) 400-400 1,600 4,500 6,100 Anwar Ali Sultan 800 3,000 3,800 Mohammed Abdul Hussain Bhacker 2,000 4,500 6,500 Mahdi Abdul Baqi 2,000 3,000 5,000 V Venkataraman 1,600 4,500 6,100 Sadacharam Ramasamy 1,600 4,500 6,100 Ali Taya Jandal 800 3,000 3,800 V Sundaresan 2,000 3,000 5,000 Total 12,800 30,000 42,800 Management Remuneration: The salary, benefits, bonus, gratuity, pension paid during the year to the top five officers is given below. Bonus/incentive/ex-gratia was paid after annual evaluation and achievement of key tasks, which were set at the beginning of each year. The service contracts are for a two-year term with a notice period of three months on either side. Details RO Salaries 129,383 Allowances and Perquisites * 78,225 Bonus/Incentive/Ex-gratia 52,675 Terminal Benefits /GOSI 9,882 Total 270,165 * Includes RO 3,850/- paid in the capacity of. 5
Management Profiles: Mr. V. Sundaresan, Chief Executive Officer: An Engineer and a Management graduate having more than 40 years of experience in various industries. Mr. Deepak Jain, Chief Financial Officer: A Fellow Chartered Accountant and Postgraduate in Business Administration with additional qualifications of professional Law degree and diploma in Computer Programming, having more than 24 years of experience in various industries. Dr. X. Cherian, Chief Technical Officer: A Post graduate in Science and Doctorate in Chemistry having more than 23 years of experience in detergent industry. Mr. Ahmed Hussain Al Syed; Country Sales Manager, KSA: A graduate in Business Administration having experience more than 18 years in detergent industry. Mr. Nasser Mansoor Al Rawahi, Administration and HR Manager: Diploma in Business Administration having experience of more than 21 years. 6. CMA/MSM REGULATIONS The Company has generally complied with CMA/MSM regulations during the last three years and non-compliance is reported separately. 7. MEANS OF COMMUNICATION WITH SHARE HOLDERS AND INVESTORS The Company publishes quarterly results, one each in Arabic and English daily as per the CMA regulations. Soft copy as well as hard copy is being submitted to CMA to host on their site for access by shareholders. The Management Discussion and Analysis Report forms a part of the Annual Report. The Company has its own web site in which the profile as well as the results updation is done periodically. The web site address is www.ndcoman.com The dates of the Shareholders meeting held during the past two years are given below. Financial Year Date of Meeting Type of Meeting 2013 23 March 2013 EOGM 2013 23 March 2013 OGM 2012 24 March 2012 OGM Venue Hotel Grand Hayat, Muscat Hotel Grand Hayat, Muscat Hotel Grand Hayat, Muscat Time 4:30 P.M. 5:00 P.M. 5:00 P.M. 6
8. MARKET PRICE DATA The details of the high and low prices of the company s shares traded in various months during 2013, the MSM share price index and the MSM index for industry sector shares traded are given below. Month Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec High RO 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.852 0.812 0.812 Low RO MSM Share price Index MSM Index for Industry Sector Shares 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.810 0.852 0.812 0.812 5800 5976 5990 6127 6418 6338 6643 6692 6647 6674 6726 6835 7691 8189 8155 8785 9341 9199 9536 9583 9686 9910 10265 10407 9. DISTRIBUTION OF SHAREHOLDING Information on shareholders holding more than 5% is furnished in here under: 2013 (%) RO Oman International Development and Investment Company SAOG 20.9 356,170 Dr. Omar Bin Abdul Muniem Al Zawawi 19.9 339,082 Bhacker Suleiman Jaffer Company 13.7 233,822 Mr. Mohammed Abdul Hussain Bin Bhacker Al Lawati 10.0 170,882 Mr. Redha Baqir Al Lawati 8.1 137,950 Oman Arab Bank 5.1 87,000 7
10. AREAS OF NON-COMPLIANCE WITH PROVISIONS OF CORPORATE GOVERNANCE Mr Mohammed Abdul Hussain Bhacker, Audit Committee Chairman was a Non- Independent as on reporting date. This has since been rectified by electing an independent member as the Chairman of Audit Committee by the Board of s on 16 Feb 2014. Except as mentioned above, the Company has complied with the all other regulations of the CMA/MSM during 2013 and there are no penalties or strictures imposed on the company on any matter related to capital markets during the last three years. 11. PROFILE OF STATUTORY AUDITORS Ernst & Young are the statutory auditors of the Company. EY have been operating in the Sultanate of Oman since 1974 and are the largest professional services firm in the country. EY Oman, forms part of EY s EMEIA practice, with 3,628 partners and over 81,000 professionals in 462 offices throughout the EMEIA geographical area. Globally EY operates in more than 150 countries and employs 175,000 professionals. 12. AUDIT FEE TO AUDITORS Total audit fee for the annual audit and half-yearly review paid / due to auditors was RO 10,500/- (RO Ten thousand five hundred only) 13. RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS The transactions with related parties are disclosed in note 30 to the Accounts in the Annual Report. 14. COMPLIANCE WITH INTERNAL REGULATIONS AND CONTROL SYSTEM The Company understands its liability in preparing the financial statements in accordance with the applicable International Accounting Standards and the disclosure requirements of the Capital Market Authority and other applicable rules. The company has been constantly monitoring and upgrading its internal control procedures and systems in compliance with the local laws and regulations. As a part of this process, the internal controls, procedures manuals and guidelines as recommended by the Capital Market Authority have been implemented from 2003 and time to time revised incorporating latest changes in local laws. The Board, through the appointment of an external firm as internal auditor, regular involvement of Audit committee in the review process and based on the periodical reports submitted by the internal auditor, have reviewed the internal controls and procedures adopted by the Company and found them to be adequate and effective. We confirm according to our knowledge there is no material things that affect the continuation of the Company and its ability to continue its operations during the next financial year. ******* 8