OECD s Innovation Strategy: Key Findings and Policy Messages 2010 MIT Europe Conference, Brussels, 12 October Dirk Pilat, OECD dirk.pilat@oecd.org
Outline 1. Why innovation matters today 2. Why policies for innovation need to adapt 3. Key policy messages from the OECD Innovation Strategy 4. Some broader messages 5. Conclusions and further work 2
Slovak Republic Italy Why Innovation? Because it is already a fundamental economic investment... Czech Republic Japan (2005) Australia Spain Canada (2005) Portugal (2005) Austria Sweden France Denmark Germany Finland United States United Kingdom Investment in fixed and intangible assets as a share of GDP, 2006 % Machinery and equipment Software and databases R&D and other intellectual property products Brand equity, firm specific human capital, organisational capital 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Source: Data on intangible investment are based on COINVEST [www.coinvest.org.uk] and research papers, 2009. 3
and driver of economic growth... Contributions to labour productivity growth, 1995-2006, in % % Labour quality Physical capital deepening Multifactor productivity Intangible capital deepening 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0-1 -2 Source: Data on intangible investment are based on COINVEST [www.coinvest.org.uk] and research papers, 2009. 4
Emissions (Gt CO 2 ) that can help address global challenges such as climate change Potential contributions to CO 2 emission reductions 70 60 Baseline emissions 62 Gt CCS industry and transformation (9%) CCS power generation (10%) 50 Nuclear (6%) Renewables (21%) 40 Power generation efficiency and fuel switching (7%) 30 End use fuel switching (11%) 20 End use electricity efficiency (12%) 10 BLUE Map emissions 14 Gt WEO 2007 450 ppm case ETP2008 analysis End use fuel efficiency (24%) 0 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 Note: WEO refers to the IEA s 2007 World Energy Outlook. Source: International Energy Agency, Energy Technology Perspectives 2008: Scenarios and Strategies to 2050.
Policies for innovation are still often ill adapted to innovation today The what, how and who of innovation has changed 6
Innovation today is more than R&D... 70% New to market product innovators with and without R&D, 2004-06 (or latest) As a percentage of innovators Innovation (no R&D) In-house R&D 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 7 7
South Africa (2005) Luxembourg.. and involves a wide range of innovation strategies (manufacturing, 2004-2006, percentage of all firms) Belgium Estonia Austria Japan (2003) United Kingdom Ireland Denmark Australia (2007) Portugal Iceland (2004) Finland Netherlands Czech Republic Spain Norway Chile Korea (2008) % 80 Product or process innovation only Marketing or organisational & Product or process innovation Marketing or organisational innovation only 60 40 20 0 Source: OECD
that enables firms to reap the returns from innovation The Apple ipod = 299$ of Chinese exports to US Distribution of the value added 299 US$ 75$ profit to US (Apple) 73$ whls/retail US (Apple) 75$ to Japan (Toshiba) 60$ 400 parts from Asia 15$ 16 parts from the US 2$ assembly by China http://blogs.computerworld.com/node/5724 itunes Music Store (2003) 70% digital market share Big 5 recording companies 9
Firms today no longer innovate in isolation Then: Closed Innovation Approach: not invented here Now: Open Innovation Approach: proudly found elsewhere Innovation: Strategy independent of overall business strategy Performed in-house Internal pool of innovators Outputs: Incorporated in firm s products and services. Product revenues finance next cycles of in-house R&D Innovation: Business strategy drives targets Technology developed cooperatively or acquired Work with many innovators and users/consumers Leverage own IP Outputs: Both internalized and externalized (licensing, spin-offs, venturing)
and increasingly cooperate across borders Companies collaborating on innovation, as a percentage of all firms, 2004-2006 Source: OECD, based on CIS and national sources.
as the Internet has enabled much greater participation in innovation. 12 12
Innovation today More than science and technology also design, business models, organisational changes More than high-tech manufacturing also in services More than firms and research institutions also nongovernmental organisations, the public sector, users and consumers Involving people throughout the economy Involving supply and demand, pull and push policies. This implies that a broad approach is needed joining up a range of policies 13
1. People 3. Key dimensions of the OECD Innovation Strategy 2. Firms 3. Knowledge creation and diffusion 4. Governance 14
a) Empower people to innovate Innovation is not only driven by scientists and engineers, but depends on people in many roles: Entrepreneurs, key to idea generation and commercialisation Workers, key to workplace innovation Users and consumers, influencing the direction of innovation Global talent spreading hands-on knowledge Implies: A broad and inclusive agenda for education and training A well-functioning labour market that enables mobility and organisational change. Policies that empower and enable consumers to engage 15
Chile France Ireland Sweden Canada Israel Estonia Belgium Czech Republic Iceland (2006) Slovenia Italy United Kingdom Finland Norway New Zealand Switzerland Austria Denmark Spain Australia Japan Slovak Republic United States Portugal Germany Korea Poland Netherlands Hungary Turkey Mexico Greece 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 Human resources are a priority Science and engineering graduates at the doctoral level, 2007 As a percentage of all new degrees at the doctoral level % Science Engineering 0 Source: OECD Education Database (2010).
b) Unleash innovation in firms Firms and an encouraging business environment are the key drivers of innovation: Encouraging entrepreneurship in new and existing firms Supportive framework conditions (tax climate, competitive markets, openness to trade and investment, stable macroeconomic policy, supportive regulation) Strong private funding for innovation well-functioning financial markets, including for risk capital, well-designed government support to address gaps Markets that encourage and diffuse innovation this may require government action, e.g. tax policy, regulatory reform, innovative public procurement 17
Denmark Norway United States Austria Finland Netherlands United Kingdom Belgium France Sweden Germany Spain Italy New firms are important for innovation Patenting activity of young ( <5 years) firms, 2005-07 Share of young patenting firms and share of PCT patent filings by young firms (%) % 40 Patenting firms under 5 years old Patents filed by firms under 5 years old 30 20 10 0 Source: OECD (2010), Measuring Innovation: A New Perspective, OECD, Paris. 18
United Kingdom Netherlands Sweden Italy Canada Denmark Australia Korea Portugal Switzerland Austria Norway Spain United States France Germany Japan Finland Belgium Czech Republic New Zealand Luxembourg Hungary Iceland Mexico Poland Turkey.. but barriers to entrepreneurship remain a challenge in many countries Scale from 0 to 6, from least to most restrictive, 2008 Regulatory and administrative opacity Administrative burdens on startups Barriers to competition 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 Source: OECD (2010), Measuring Innovation: A New Perspective, OECD, based on OECD, Product Market Regulation Database. 19
R&D is the main focus of public support. Direct and indirect government funding of business R&D and tax incentives for R&D, 2007 or latest available year As percentage of GDP Source: OECD (2010), Measuring Innovation: A New Perspective, OECD, Paris based on NESTI 2009 R&D tax incentives questionnaire. 20
c) Investing in knowledge and reaping its returns Innovation requires public and private investment in knowledge creation and diffusion: Excellent and effective public research A modern and reliable knowledge infrastructure, including policies to foster ICT and other general purpose technologies Well-functioning knowledge networks and markets that help generate knowledge and IP and generate value from it Strategies to foster innovation in the public sector How assets are combined is increasingly key. 21
Broadband networks are of growing importance to innovation 40 35 OECD Broadband subscribers per 100 inhabitants, by technology, June 2009 Other Fibre/LAN Cable DSL 30 25 20 OECD 15 10 5 0 Source: OECD
d) Governance is key Not one single policy but a combination of actions to strengthen supply and foster demand: policies for innovation. Need for strong political leadership and a joined strategic vision. Need for measurement and evaluation frameworks to support policy. 23
4. Some broader messages Policies for supply and demand: Policies for innovation are increasingly focused on meeting the demands of society. The objectives of innovation (growth, sustainability, health, ) are achieved through diffusion and take-up Most public policy is aimed at the creation of knowledge. Need to better join up push and pull policies: Stronger creation of knowledge and better diffusion and take-up Empowering people to create knowledge and apply knowledge Protecting IPR and creating value from IPR 24
Seizing benefits at the local level: Setting priorities and creating excellence and critical mass Strengthen and capitalise on local strengths: knowledge institutions, people, services, social factors, culture, etc. An open environment Develop a joint vision and strategy for long-term investment Bottom-up, rather than top-down approaches 25
The roles of government and business: The role of markets can be strengthened to strengthen demand: e.g. through getting prices right, regulatory reform, smart use of public procurement, consumer involvement,.. In many countries, governments still need to get more out of the way. At the same time, governments play an important role in driving innovation in the post-crisis environment 26
Long- and short-term actions: Policies for innovation are mainly focused on strengthening growth and addressing challenges over the long term But some implications in exiting from the crisis: Investment in the long-term sources of growth, such as R&D, is important, also as private investment may lag Support for new firms important, also for employment creation Not all policies require additional public investment, e.g.: Removal of barriers to innovation Fostering of markets for innovative products and for knowledge Better use of public procurement Tax reform to support innovation and green growth 27
Some tangible material from the work.. A short Ministerial paper setting out the challenges and priorities for action, including a set of policy principles An analytical report, providing evidence on the main innovation drivers and processes and policy recommendations A compendium of policy-relevant indicators that will enable countries to benchmark themselves on a range of policies and measurements In-depth thematic reports on key issues The beginnings of a policy handbook, that will enable countries to examine their own performance and system, and provide tools and examples to take action. 28 28
and tomorrow Further work will involve: Implementing and monitoring action, often at the country level Country reviews of innovation policy Moving ahead on the measurement agenda Focusing on specific questions, e.g. green growth and innovation.
For further information OECD website www.oecd.org/innovation/strategy Or contact: dirk.pilat@oecd.org 30