PAPR REDUCTION TECHNIQUE USING MODIFIED SLM IN OFDM SYSTEM

Similar documents
ORTHOGONAL frequency division multiplexing (OFDM)

PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF PARTIAL RANSMIT SEQUENCE USING FOR PAPR REDUCTION IN OFDM SYSTEMS

IJMIE Volume 2, Issue 4 ISSN:

A COMPARISON OF DIFFERENT PAPR REDUCTION TECHNIQUES IN OFDM USING VARIOUS MODULATIONS

II. OFDM SYSTEM MODEL

Low Complexity Partial SLM Technique for PAPR Reduction in OFDM Transmitters

Partial Transmit Sequence (PTS)-PAPR Reduction Technique in OFDM Systems with Reduced Complexity. II. PAPR problem in OFDM system

Algorithm to Improve the Performance of OFDM based WLAN Systems

Keywords: MC-CDMA, PAPR, Partial Transmit Sequence, Complementary Cumulative Distribution Function.

Peak-to-Average Power Ratio (PAPR)

A Kalman Filter Approach to Reduce ICI in OFDM Systems

MC CDMA PAPR Reduction Using Discrete Logarithmic Method

REDUCING PAPR OF OFDM BASED WIRELESS SYSTEMS USING COMPANDING WITH CONVOLUTIONAL CODES

Simplified Levenberg-Marquardt Algorithm based PAPR Reduction for OFDM System with Neural Network

Riemann Sequence based SLM with nonlinear effects of HPA

Power Reduction in OFDM systems using Tone Reservation with Customized Convex Optimization

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PURE AND APPLIED RESEARCH IN ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY

Computational Complexity Reduction of OFDM Signals by PTS with Various PAPR Conventional Methods

Reduction of peak to average power ratio (PAPR) in orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) system

An Overview of PAPR Reduction Techniques In Concerned with OFDM

Implementation and Comparative analysis of Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) Signaling Rashmi Choudhary

Performance analysis of OFDM with QPSK using AWGN and Rayleigh Fading Channel

Lekhraj Udaigiriya and Sudhir Kumar Sharma

A New PAPR Reduction in OFDM Systems Using SLM and Orthogonal Eigenvector Matrix

MODIFIED SELECTED MAPPING TECHNIQUE TO REDUCE PEAK TO AVERAGE POWER RATIO FOR OFDM SIGNALS

SCFDMA PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS FOR PAPR REDUCTION WITH DIFFERENT SUBCARRIER MAPPING USING SLM TECHNIQUE AND MODIFIED SLM TECHNIQUE

PAPR Reduction in 4G Cellular Network: A SLM-based IFDMA Uplink System

PEAK CANCELLATION CREST FACTOR REDUCTION TECHNIQUE FOR OFDM SIGNALS

PAPR Reduction in SLM Scheme using Exhaustive Search Method

OFDM Systems and PAPR Reduction Along With Channel Estimation

PAPR Reduction techniques in OFDM System Using Clipping & Filtering and Selective Mapping Methods

Reducing Intercarrier Interference in OFDM Systems by Partial Transmit Sequence and Selected Mapping

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF CLIPPING, SLM AND TWO PIECEWISE COMPANDING TECHNIQUES FOR PAPR REDUCTION IN OFDM SYSTEM

CRITERIA FOR SELECTION OF PAPR REDUCTION TECHNIQUES IN OFDM SYSTEM

Modified PTS Technique Of Its Transceiver For PAPR Reduction In OFDM System

IJREAT International Journal of Research in Engineering & Advanced Technology, Volume 1, Issue 5, Oct-Nov, 2013 ISSN:

A Novel of Low Complexity Detection in OFDM System by Combining SLM Technique and Clipping and Scaling Method Jayamol Joseph, Subin Suresh

Hybrid PTS-Clipping Scheme for PAPR Reduction in MIMO-OFDM Systems

Interleaved PC-OFDM to reduce the peak-to-average power ratio

Performance Evaluation for OFDM PAPR Reduction Methods

SIDELOBE SUPPRESSION AND PAPR REDUCTION FOR COGNITIVE RADIO MIMO-OFDM SYSTEMS USING CONVEX OPTIMIZATION TECHNIQUE

THE COMBINATION OF CLIPPING AND FILTERING WITH SELECTIVE MAPPING METHODS FOR PEAK TO AVERAGE POWER RATIO REDUCTION IN OFDM

Solving Peak Power Problems in Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing

Lowest PAPR Selection Technique from SLM and PTS with One IFFT Block in Wireless MC-CDMA Communication Systems

International Journal of Informative & Futuristic Research ISSN:

PAPR reduction performance analysis of Optimized Matrix based Phase Sequences in OFDM systems

PAPR ANALYSIS IN OFDM SYSTEMS USING PTS REDUCTION TECHNIQUE

Performance Analysis of OFDM for Different Digital Modulation Schemes using Matlab Simulation

Nonlinear Companding Transform Algorithm for Suppression of PAPR in OFDM Systems

PERFORMANCE ENHANCEMENT OF OFDM SIGNALS USING SELECTED MAPPING TECHNIQUE AND OVERVIEW OF DIFFERENT PAPR REDUCTION SCHEMES

2. PAPR IN OFDM: Let X=[XR0R,X1,XR2R,..XRMR] is data coming out of S/P. OFDM is represented in time domain by

PAPR Reduction in an OFDM system using Recursive Clipping and Filtering Technique

Iterative Clipping and Filtering Technique for PAPR Reduction in OFDM System without Encoding

Clipping and Filtering Technique for reducing PAPR In OFDM

Keywords SEFDM, OFDM, FFT, CORDIC, FPGA.

Image Transmission over OFDM System with Minimum Peak to Average Power Ratio (PAPR)

Comparative Study of PAPR Reduction Techniques

Analysis of OFDM System by Comparing Different PAPR Reduction Schemes

ORTHOGONAL frequency division multiplexing (OFDM)

PTS Technique for MIMO-OFDM Paper Reduction

A Research Concept on Bit Rate Detection using Carrier offset through Analysis of MC-CDMA SYSTEM

An Improved SLM Technique Using Discrete Cosine Transform in OFDM. S. Lih., An Improved SLM Technique Using Discrete Cosine Transform in OFDM System.

OFDM Systems For Different Modulation Technique

Comparative Study of Peak-to-Average Power Ratio Reduction Techniques for OFDM System

International Journal of Research and Review E-ISSN: ; P-ISSN:

PAPR Reduction of OFDM Using a New Phase Sequence in SLM Technique

Effects of Nonlinearity on DFT-OFDM and DWT-OFDM Systems

PAPR Reduction of OFDM System using LBC

Study of Performance Evaluation of Quasi Orthogonal Space Time Block Code MIMO-OFDM System in Rician Channel for Different Modulation Schemes

Optimization of PAPR Using HPA and Amplitude Clipping Reduction Technique

Systematic Comparison of Different PAPR Reduction Methods in OFDM Systems

Low-Complexity Architecture for PAPR Reduction in OFDM Systems with Near-Optimal Performance

Comparative Study of OFDM & MC-CDMA in WiMAX System

Performance Evaluation of PAPR Reduction with SER and BER by Modified Clipping & Filtering in 3GPP LTE Downlink

COMPARISON OF SLM & PTS TECHNIQUES FOR REDUCING PAPR IN OFDM

Lecture 3: Wireless Physical Layer: Modulation Techniques. Mythili Vutukuru CS 653 Spring 2014 Jan 13, Monday

A NON-LINEAR SCHEME FOR PMEPR REDUCTION IN MC-CDMA SYSTEM

ISSN: ISO 9001:2008 Certified International Journal of Engineering and Innovative Technology (IJEIT) Volume 4, Issue 12, June 2015

RNS SYSTEM MODEL BASED EFFECTIVE PAPR REDUCTION FRAMEWORK BASED ON TO IMPROVE SIGNAL EFFICIENCY

Volume 2, Issue 9, September 2014 International Journal of Advance Research in Computer Science and Management Studies

An Overview of PAPR Reduction Techniques in OFDM Systems

Evaluation of Optimized PAPR and BER of OFDM signal by using Clipping and Filtering Technique

Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing & Measurement of its Performance

International Journal of Innovative Research in Advanced Engineering (IJIRAE) ISSN: Issue 06, Volume 3 (June 2016)

Peak to Average Power Ratio Reduction of Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing System with a Significant Low Complexity

Techniques for Mitigating the Effect of Carrier Frequency Offset in OFDM

Lecture 13. Introduction to OFDM

PAPR Reduction of OFDM Signals using Partial Transmit Sequence and Clipping Hybrid Scheme

Linear Precoding Schemes for PAPR Reduction in Mobile WiMAX OFDMA System

SPARSE CHANNEL ESTIMATION BY PILOT ALLOCATION IN MIMO-OFDM SYSTEMS

Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) based Uplink Multiple Access Method over AWGN and Fading Channels

Performance Study of MIMO-OFDM System in Rayleigh Fading Channel with QO-STB Coding Technique

Analysis of Selective Mapping PAPR Reduction Technique in OFDM System

BER Analysis for MC-CDMA

PAPR Reduction Techniques with Hybrid SLM Partial Transmit Sequence Algorithm for OFDM System

Chapter 5 OFDM. Office Hours: BKD Tuesday 14:00-16:00 Thursday 9:30-11:30

Anju 1, Amit Ahlawat 2

BER and PAPR Reduction Method for Nonlinearly Amplified OFDM Signals

Performance Analysis of OFDM System with QPSK for Wireless Communication

Performance Assessment of PAPR in OFDM System using Single Carrier - FDMA

Transcription:

PAPR REDUCTION TECHNIQUE USING MODIFIED SLM IN OFDM SYSTEM Mukul Dr. Sajjan Singh M. Tech Research Scholar, Department of ECE, Associate Professor, Department of ECE BRCM CET, Bahal, Bhiwani, India BRCM CET, Bahal, Bhiwani, India Abstract High Peak to Average Power Ratio (PAPR) is still a challenging area complex issue for OFDM system. The radio transmitter stations for covering receiving an adequate amount of transmitted power in their most wanted area has to use (HPA) High Power Amplifier. In order the High Power Amplifier to have the most output power usefulness must be designed to work lock to the saturation state. A factor which is called memory less nonlinear distortion due to the high PAPR of input signals will influence the communication channels. It can reason the out-of-b power to be kept under the precise limits if the high power amplifier doesn t work in linear region. This condition can cause unproductive amplification costly transmitters, so it is necessary to explore PAPR reduction techniques for OFDM system. For reducing PAPR many techniques have been suggested. In this paper we will propose our modified selective mapping (SLM) method for a conventional OFDM system. Keywords Peak to Average Power Ratio, High Power Amplifier, Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing, Selective mapping I. INTRODUCTION Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) has grown to a popular communication technique for high speed communication in the last decade. Being an important member of the multicarrier modulation (MC) techniques, Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM), is also called Discrete Multitone Modulation (DMT). It is based upon the principle of frequency division multiplexing (FDM) where each frequency channel is modulated with simpler modulation scheme [1]. It splits a high rate data stream into a number of lower rate streams that are transmitted at the same time over a number of orthogonal subcarriers. That the carriers are placed exactly at the nulls in the modulation spectra of each other using Orthogonality is achieved. Therefore OFDM is an advanced modulation technique which is suitable for highspeed data transmission due to its advantages in dealing with the multipath propagation problem, high data rate bwidth efficiency [2]. Although OFDM principles have been developed over several decades, its implementation for high data rate communications has only recently become popular by the reduced cost availability of suitable signal processing components which make it a competitive technology for commercial applications also. A. Peak to Average Power Ratio: It is defined as the ratio between the maximum power the average power for the envelope of a baseb complex signal s(t) i.e. 2 max s (t) PAPR{s } (t) = E s(t) 2 Also we can write this PAPR equation for the complex pass b signal s (t) as PAPR{s(t)} = max s(t) 2 E s(t) 2 B. Effect of High PAPR: The linear power amplifiers are being used in the transmitter so the Q-point has to be in the linear region. Due to the high PAPR hence the clipping of signal peaks takes place which generates in-b out-of b distortion then the Q-point moves to the saturation region [3]. Which again reduces its efficiency enhances the cost due to keep the Q-point in the linear region the dynamic range of the power amplifier should be increased. In this paper our objective should be to reduce this PAPR. II. PAPR OF AN OFDM SIGNAL Let us signify the data block of length as a vector =[ 1, 2. N-1 ] T where N is equal to the number of subcarriers (.) T denotes transpose. The duration of a data symbol m in is T. Each data symbol in modulate some of a set of subcarriers {f m,m =1,2 N-1}. The N subcarriers are selected to be orthogonal, that is,f m =mδf,where Δf=1/NT NT is the period of an OFDM data block. The complex envelope of the transmitted OFDM signals given by x(t) = 1 N 1 N m=0 m. e j2πfmt, 0 < t < NT ------ (1) The PAPR of the transmitted signal in (1) is defined as 75

PAPR = max x(t)2 1 NT. NT 0 x(t)2 dt ---------------- (2) Estimate NP equidistant samples of (1) will be measured where P is an integer which is equal to 1 or larger than [8]. This Ptimes oversampled are represent as a vector obtained as [4] x k = x (k. T P ) = 1 N 1 N m m=0. e (j2πkm NP ), k = 0,1,, NP 1 ---------------- (3) Series { k } of the OFDM data block with (P-1) zero padding can be interpreted as the inverse discrete Fourier transform. Which corresponds to the case of P=1 that PAPR of the continuous-time OFDM signal cannot be obtained accurately by the use of the Nyquist rate sampling. The PAPR compute from the P-times oversampled time-domain signal samples is given by PAPR = max x(k)2 ------------- (4) E x(k) 2 Where E [.] denotes expectation building of the phase sequences. Though, we put a structural control on the phase sequences for the improved SLM technique describes below. Source Partition Into blocks And S/P Conversi on B1 B2 Bn Select One With Lowest PAPR III. IMPROVED SELECTED MAPPING TECHNIQUE FOR OFDM SIGNAL Fig.1 Block diagram of OFDM transmitter with the SLM technique A. SLM Technique: The SLM technique is shown in Fig. 1 the input data is partition into a data block of length N. The data block of OFDM is multiplied element by element with phase sequences B(u)= [b u,0, b u,1.b u,n-1 ], u=1,2, U, to make the phase rotated OFDM data blocks where (u)=[ u,1 u,2, u,3. u,n-1 ] T, where u,m = m.b u,m, m=0,1,2 N-1.. The unmodified OFDM data block provided that the phase sequence using U phase rotated OFDM data blocks signify the same information. OFDM data block in the set of the phase rotated OFDM data blocks to take in unmodified [5] it may set the first phase sequence B (1) as all one vector of length. Here applying the SLM technique to, (1) become N 1 x (u) (t) = 1 N m. b u,m. e j2πfmt, m=0 0 < t < NT, u = 1,2, U -------------- (5) U phase rotated OFDM data blocks by using PAPR is calculated from eqn (3) (4). One of the lowest PAPR is chosen between the phase rotated OFDM data blocks transmitted. The transmitted of information about the selected phase sequence to the receiver as side information. The reverse operation should be performed to recover the unmodified OFDM data block at the receiver side. The U operations for each OFDM data block in SLM technique needs. The smallest integer which does not exceed the number of required side information bits is [log 2 U] where [y] denotes. The phase sequences are chosen in a way such that the phase rotate OFDM data blocks are adequately different. In the conventional SLM technique, there is no constraint on the B. Modified SLM Technique for Coded OFDM Signal source Symbol Mapping Channel code Encoding Symbol mapping (p-ary) partition into Bolks Sub-carrier Arrangement S/P Convrsion Bn B1 B0 Fig.2 (a) Block Diagram of improved SLM Transmitter DFT Check symbol Y Estimation Phase sequence B using Estimation symbols B OFDM block Estimation Fig.2(b) Block Diagram of Improved SLM Receiver Select One With Lowest PAPR Phase sequence Refinement Channel code Decoding Fig. 2(a) Fig. 2(b) show the block diagram of the improved SLM transmitter receiver technique. At initial, q-ary 76

International Journal of Engineering Applied Sciences Technology, 2016 symbols input data is mapped then processed by a rate r=k/n code over. The data symbols check symbols are separately mapped to p-ary symbols after channel code encoding are group into blocks of length N [6]. The number of code words required to create an OFDM data block of length N is set by the projected technique that of the technique if code rate is close to 0. The larger the difference is on the contrary the higher the code rate. SER vs Eb/No for N=240 & OBO=1dB ----------- (6) After collecting M code words, the data symbols check symbols are arranged suitably among N subcarriers. N* (k/n) subcarriers are used to transmit data symbols the rest N*(nk)/n subcarriers are used for check symbols. IV. RESULTS & DISCUSSION A. Approximation of effect of Non-linearity We use MATLAB simulations to evaluate the performance of the proposed PAPR reduction technique. To approximate the effect of nonlinearity in the power amplifier in the transmitter, we implement Rapp s model for amplitude conversion. The relation between amplitude of the normalized input signal g(a) amplitude of the normalized output signal of the nonlinear power amplifier is given by 0 uncoded/unmodified 5 Fig. 3.1: Comparative SER analysis OFDM, OFDM with SLM & proposed scheme at OBO =1 db SER vs Eb/No for N=240 & OBO=3dB g(a) = A (1+A 2p ) 1/(2p) -------------- (7) 0 Where p is represent the nonlinear characteristic of the power amplifier. As p gets larger then power amplifier approaches a linear amplifier. A good approximation of a general power amplifier we choose p=3[8]. Fig. 4.1 gives the input-output relation curve. The input signal into the preferred range in the input-output relation curve when the input signal is normalized by a normalization factor to properly fit. It s back into original scale before normalization when normalized output signal is processed. The output back-off (OBO) is depends upon the amount of nonlinear distortion which is defined as OBO = P 0,max P 0,avg ------------------(8) Where P o,max is the output power at the saturation point P o,avg the power of the output signal. B. Performance analysis in terms of Fig. 3.1, 3.2, 3.3 shows SER analysis of the proposed technique, technique unmodified OFDM. Proposed scheme perform better than scheme over entire range. To quantify results take Eb/No=5db, here SER for unmodified scheme is, for it is 9* for proposed scheme it is 2*10-4. It is closely related to the value of n, k or the code rate r= k/n difference in PAPR enhancement between the improved technique the ordinary SLM technique. Here is small difference between the CCDF of 5 uncoded/unmodified Fig. 3.2: Comparative SER analysis OFDM, OFDM with SLM & proposed scheme at OBO =3 db 10-4 10-6 10-8 0 SER vs Eb/No for N=240 & OBO=5dB 2 uncoded/unmodified 4 Fig. 3.3: Comparative SER analysis OFDM, OFDM with SLM & proposed scheme at OBO =5 db 77

International Journal of Engineering Applied Sciences Technology, 2016 SER vs Eb/No for proposed scheme,n=240 OBO 1dB OBO 3dB OBO 5dB CCDF vs threshold comparison, N=240 0 5 Fig. 3.4: Comparative SER scheme for various OBO levels. Fig. 3.4 show the SER for OBO= 1dB, OBO= 3dB, OBO= 5dB respectively. Performance of system is better for larger value of OBO since the amount of nonlinear distortion is less for larger OBO. C. Performance analysis in terms of CCDF Fig. 3.5, 3.6, 3.7 plots the approximate expression for the CCDF of the unmodified OFDM, technique proposed SLM technique. Fig. 3.5 3.7 shows the CCDF of PAPR for N=120(N represent block length) Fig. 4.6 4.8 shows that for N=240. The CCDF of the unmodified OFDM signal is plotted by using with α=2.3. The CCDF of the conventional SLM technique is plotted by using with α=2.3 that of the modified SLM technique is plotted by with α=2.3 β=0.8, 0.75, 0.70 for U=8, 16, 32, respectively. CCDF vs threshold comparison, N=120 unmodified 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Fig. 3.6: Comparative analysis of OFDM, OFDM with SLM & proposed scheme in terms of CCDF, N=240 vs modified SLM, N=120 6 6.5 7 7.5 8 8.5 9 Fig. 3.7: Comparative analysis & proposed scheme in terms of CCDF, N=120 vs modified SLM, N=240 unmodified 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Fig. 3.5: Comparative analysis of OFDM, OFDM with SLM & proposed scheme in terms of CCDF, N=120 (N represent block length) 6 6.5 7 7.5 8 8.5 9 Fig. 3.8: Comparative analysis of & proposed scheme in terms of CCDF, N=240 As U increase performance improves as because with U no. of phase sequences increases, those are multiplied with incoming data sequence so no of phase rotated data sequence increases. If no of phase rotated data sequence is more among which we have to select transmit, definitely performance increase. 78

With N performance degrades. As N represent block length, if element in block increase, more be the chances of error would be there. With romness performance improves, romness is nothing but probability, if it is more closer to one, means we are very much sure of something, result would be better in that case too. D. Contribution of this paper: This paper proposes an efficient technique which has the potential to reduce PAPR significantly over scheme present in literature without affecting spectral efficiency of the system. Also its implementation complexity is less. It works well with arbitrary number of subcarriers for any type of baseb modulation used. TABLE 1.1 OVERALL ANALYSES OF DIFFERENT TECHNIQUES: Name schemes Amplitude clipping of Name of parameters Signal Distortion Power Increase rate Loss Computational Complexity Transmitter processing Yes No No Amplitude clipping (SLM) No No Yes M IFFTs,WM 1 complex vector sums (SLM MODIFIED) Above table 1.1 shows the parameters used in different PAPR reduction techniques. As shown in the table there is signal distortion in the amplitude clipping technique for the PAPR reduction. Due to the signal distortion in the amplitude clipping method desired information should not be reach to the receiver. The conventional SLM technique data rate loss increased so to overcome these losses we used modified SLM technique. TABLE 1.2 COMPARISONS BETWEEN PAPR REDUCTION TECHNIQUES: Reduction Techniques Receiver processing none Side information extraction, inverse PTS No No NO U IFFTs Side information extraction, inverse SLM PAPR at CCDF of PAPR(dB) Modified SLM 7.1 SLM 9 PTS 8.93 Table 1.2 shows the comparison of peak average power ratio between conventional SLM modified SLM i.e proposed technique. Conventional PAPR for the SLM technique is 9 db at CCDF 11.1 db at CCDF. Proposed or modified SLM technique shows the 7.1 db PAPR at CCDF.By obtaining low PAPR power consumption in the system reduced data rate also enhanced in the modified SLM based technique. V. CONCLUSION The performance difference b/w the improved technique the conventional (Selective Mapping) SLM technique is due to the fact that, in the improved technique, the phase sequences have a drawback on their structure thus the improvement of PAPR provided by the improved technique is not so much as the that from the conventional selective mapping method. In OFDM show the performance of Modified SLM that introduced the better PAPR reduction of 7.1dB can be achieved for suitable low power consumption communication system. The above achievements show the less power consumption of mobile terminal which is more suitable for next generation broadb wireless communication OFDM downlink system. VI. REFERENCES [1] B.S. Krongold, K. Ramchadran, D.L Jones, Computationally Efficient Optimal Power Allocation Algorithms for Multicarrier Communication Systems, IEEE Transaction Communication, Vol.48, no.1, pp.23-27, Jan. 2000. [2] L.J. Cimini, Jr.B. Daneshrad, N.R Sollenberger, Clustered OFDM with Transmitter Diversity Coding, in proceeding of IEEE Global Tele. Communications. Conf., pp. 703-707, 1996. [3] P. H. Moose, A Technique for Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing Frequency Offset correction, IEEE Transaction. Communication, Vol. 42, no.10, pp. 2908 2914, 1994. [4] Gaurav Sikri Rajni A Comparison of Different PAPR Reduction Techniques In OFDM Using Various Modulations International Journal of Mobile Network Communications & Telematics (IJMNCT), Vol.2, No.4, August, 2012. [5] Misha Arora1, Er. Parvinder Singh Reduction of Papr In OFDM Using Cross Grid Approach Of SLM Clipping International Journal of Advanced Research in Computer Communication Engineering, Vol. 2, Issue 10, October 2013. [6] Monika Phulia O.P. Sahu Peak-to-Average Power Ratio (PAPR) Reduction of OFDM Signals Using a Modified PTS Technique International Journal of Electronic Electrical Engineering, Volume 7, pp. 79-84, No. 2014. 79