BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

Transcription

1 BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA Order Instituting Rulemaking Concerning Energy Efficiency Rolling Portfolios, Policies, Programs, Evaluation, and Related Issues. R (Filed November 14, 2013) PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY (U 39-M), SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY (U 902-M), AND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY S (U 338-E) STATEWIDE LIGHTING MARKET TRANSFORMATION REPORT STEVEN W. FRANK TESSA M.G. CARLBERG Attorneys for PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY 77 Beale Street, B30A San Francisco, CA Telephone: (415) Facsimile: (415) Tessa.Carlberg@pge.com ANNA VALDBERG JANE LEE COLE Attorneys for SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY 2244 Walnut Grove Avenue Rosemead, California Telephone: (626) Facsimile: (626) Jane.Lee.Cole@sce.com HOLLIE K. BIERMAN Attorney for SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS 555 West Fifth Street, GT-14E7 Los Angeles, CA Telephone: (858) Facsimile: (619) hbierman@semprautilities.com Dated: June 1, 2018

2 BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA Order Instituting Rulemaking Concerning Energy Efficiency Rolling Portfolios, Policies, Programs, Evaluation, and Related Issues. R (Filed November 14, 2013) PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY (U 39-M), SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY (U 902-M), AND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY S (U 338-E) STATEWIDE LIGHTING MARKET TRANSFORMATION REPORT Pursuant to Ordering Paragraph 22 subsection (c) of California Public Utilities Commission (Commission) decision D , Southern California Edison Company (SCE), hereby submits the Statewide Lighting Market Transformation Program Report dated June 1, 2018, which is attached hereto as Appendix A on behalf of itself, Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E), and San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E). 1 The report is also being served on the service list of this proceeding. 1 Pursuant to Rule 1.8(d), counsel for PG&E and SDG&E have authorized SCE to file and serve this report on their behalf

3 Respectfully submitted, ANNA VALDBERG JANE LEE COLE /s/ Jane Lee Cole By: Jane Lee Cole Attorneys for SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY 2244 Walnut Grove Avenue Post Office Box 800 Rosemead, California Telephone: (626) Facsimile: (626) Date: June 1,

4 Appendix A STATEWIDE LIGHTING MARKET TRANSFORMATION PROGRAM REPORT JUNE 1, 2018

5 2018StatewideLighting MarketTransformation AnnualReport June1,2018

6 TableofContents Introduction...3 Background...3 LightingMarketTransformationSubprogram SCE,PG&E,SDG&E...3 PrimaryLighting...4 PrimaryLightingProgram SCE...4 PrimaryLightingProgram PG&E...4 PrimaryLightingProgram SDG&E...5 OtherResidentialMultifamilyDownstreamLightingActivities...5 ResidentialMultifamilyDownstreamLightingActivitiesSCE...5 ResidentialMultifamilyDownstreamLightingActivities PG&E...5 ResidentialMultifamilyDownstreamLightingActivities SDG&E...6 NonresidentialCustomandDeemedLightingActivities...6 NonresidentialCustomandDeemedLightingProgram SCE...6 NonresidentialCustomandDeemedLightingProgram PG&E...7 NonresidentialCustomandDeemedLightingProgram SDG&E...7 MidstreamDistributorLightingProgramActivities...7 MidstreamPointofPurchase(MPOP)Program SCE...7 MidstreamDistributorLightingProgram PG&E...7 MidstreamDistributorLightingProgram SDG&E...8 LightingInnovation,DemonstrationandPilotActivities...8 NonresidentialAdvancedLightingControlSystem(ALCS)Pilot SCE...8 NonresidentialAdvancedLightingControlSystem(ALCS)ToolTrialProgram PG&E...8 EmergingTechnologyandMarketActivities SDG&E...8 LightingCodesandStandardsandQualitySpecificationActivities...9 ResidentialLightingActivities...9 NonresidentialActivities...9 ReachCodesforLocalGovernments...11 GeneralServiceLampRulemaking...11 RelevantLightingStudiesandFindingsCompletedin CaliforniaLEDPricingAnalysis,byNavigantConsultingInc.(SCE ) P age

7 ImpactEvaluationof2015UpstreamandResidentialDownstreamLightingProgramsCalifornia PublicUtilitiesCommission.ByKEMAInc.(CPU )...12 CaliforniaResidentialReplacementLampMarketStatusReport:UpstreamlightingProgramand MarketActivitiesinCaliforniathrough2015,byKEMAInc.(CPU )...13 ResidentialLightingForecastingAnalysis,byTRC(PGE )...14 EarlyEM&VofPacificGasandElectricCompany'sCommercialLEDT8Incentives,byEvergreen Economics(PGE )...14 PacificGasandElectricCompanyLightingDesignAssistanceTrialStudyFinalReport:Qualitative LightingDesignSupplySideMarketAssessment,byOpinionDynamicInc.(PGE )...15 CompilationofDatatoInformtheLEDAlampBaseline,byTRC(PGE ) NonresidentialESPICustomLightingImpactEvaluationandAppendices,byItronInc. (CPU ) NonresidentialESPIDeemedLightingImpactEvaluationandAppendices,byItronInc. (CPU ) P age

8 Introduction ThisLightingMarketTransformation(LMT)ReportisjointlysubmittedbySouthernCaliforniaEdison Company(SCE),PacificGasandElectricCompany(PG&E)andSanDiegoGasandElectricCompany (SDG&E),referencedcollectivelyinthisreportasCalifornia'sinvestorownedutilities(IOUs).TheIOUs expectthatthismaybethelastlmtreportfiling,duetoanticipatedprogramchangesfor2018and beyond. Background TheCaliforniaLongTermEnergyEfficiencyStrategicPlan(StrategicPlan)calledfortransformationof marketsforenergyconsumingequipment,includingresidentialandnonresidentiallightingapplications, tomaximizeenergyefficiencyandminimizeenergyconsumptionandgreenhousegasproduction.on September23,2010,theCaliforniaPublicUtilitiesCommission(CommissionorCPUC)publishedthe LightingChapteroftheStrategicPlan,whichoutlinedfourgoalsforreducinglightingenergy consumptionincaliforniaby60%to80%by2020.theessentialgoalofmarkettransformationisfor lightingprograminterventionstobecomenaturallyoccurringmarketpracticesandconsumerdriven dynamics,sosuchinterventionswouldnolongerbeneeded.themarkettransformationinitiativeswere designedtochangetheshapeandsizeofthesshapedmarketadoptioncurveoveragiventimehorizon. Tobesuccessful,markettransformationprogramdesignshouldfocusonprograminterventions,market andmarketactordynamics,anduserbehaviors.withthesuccessoftheious'residentialand nonresidentiallightingprogramdesigns,themarketsandendusershavequicklytransitionedfrom traditionallightsourcestoenergyefficientleds. The2017LightingMarketTransformationReportisalignedwiththefollowinglightingactivities: LightingMarketTransformationSubprogram PrimaryLightingSubprogram(residentialupstream) NonresidentialCustomandDeemedlightingactivities MidstreamLightingDistributorProgram(nonresidentialmidstream),and LightingInnovationSubprogram. LightingMarketTransformationSubprogram SCE,PG&E,SDG&E TheLightingMarketTransformationSubprogramembodiesastatewideprogramstrategythat coordinatesioueffortstopromoteefficientlightingtechnologiesandbestpracticesincalifornia.the subprogramentailsdevelopmentofinnovativedatadrivenstrategiestoadaptutilitylightingprograms totheeverchangingenergyandlightingmarketsinsupportofthestrategicplan.theprogramtracks, coordinates,andprovidescollaborationopportunitiesforutility,government,andindustrylighting markettransformationactivities,andoverseestheprogressionoflightingsolutionsacrossutility programs,suchasemergingtechnologies,lightinginnovation,primarylighting,andcodesand Standards,aswellasCommercial,IndustrialandAgriculturalincentiveprogramlightingmeasures.The programhasbeeninstrumentalindevelopinglightinginnovationprogramconcepts,trials,and 3 P age

9 demonstrations.lightingmarkettransformationhelpsensuretheefficientprogressionoflighting solutionsintoandoutofcustomerenergyefficiencyprograms. ThestatewideLMTsubprogramwasinstrumentalindevelopingLightingInnovationProgramconcepts, trials,anddemonstrations.thankstotheinfluxofledtechnologytothemarketandlmt'ssuccessin helpingtoensuretheefficientprogressionoflightingsolutionsintocustomereeprograms,this statewidesubprogramhasrampeddown.itremainsasaplaceholderandmayberevivedinthefuture whenmoreresearchinthelightingmarketisneeded. In2017,SCEbeganinvestigatingthepersistenceofenergysavingsderivingfromadvancedlighting controlsystems.thismayrequireinitiationofdatacollectioneffortsin2018. During2017,SDG&EcollaboratedwiththestatewideIOUlightingteamandwithstakeholdersonthe futureofthissubprogram.duetothesignificantincreaseinledproductavailabilityanddecreasein costs,theiousreassessedthesubprogrammarketstrategies.sincetherewashighdemandinthe PrimaryLightingsubprogram,theseLMTsubprogramfundswereshiftedtoPrimaryLightingtofurther providecosteffectiveproductsolutionstonewhardtoreachcustomerlocations. In2017,PG&EfinalizedthelastphaseoftheLightingActivityWorkbooktocompletetheexistingscope ofworkforthelmtsubprogram.thestatewideiouteamisintheprocessofdefiningmarket transformationactivitiesaswegoforward,basedontheprogressoftheledmarketduringthecourse of2017. PrimaryLighting TheIOUs'ResidentialLightingProgrammayincludetheupstreamPrimaryLightingsubprogramand downstreamprogramactivitiestargetingmultifamilycustomers.thissubprogramoffersupstream rebatestoparticipatingmanufacturerstoreducetheretailcostofenergyefficientlightingproducts.it introducesnewpremiumefficiencylightingproductsintothemarketandattemptstoinfluencethe futurepurchasingandinstallationbehaviorsofresidentialcustomers.theprimarylightingsubprogram isbasedonamassmarketapproachtargetedatallresidentialcustomersandpromotesonlyhigh qualitypremiumefficiencyleds. PrimaryLightingProgram SCE In2017,SCE'sPrimaryLightingProgramexpandedthevarietyofretailersandincreasedproductquality, providinggreaterenergysavingstocustomers.theprogramoptimizedsavingsandcosteffectiveness byadjustingthemeasuremixandquantitiestoadheretoworkpapervalues.thishappenedinthefirst halfoftheyear,andagainwhenthemidyearworkpaperswentintoeffect.forexample, omnidirectionalalampswerereducedbyabout80%inthesecondhalfoftheyearbecausetheir savingsandcosteffectivenessdecreasedaccordingtotheworkpapersandotheranalyses.theprogram alsocontinuedtousethemanyeffectivestrategiesofpreviousyears. PrimaryLightingProgram PG&E In2017,PG&E'sPrimaryLightingProgramprovidedtieredincentivestomanufacturersbasedonthe volumeofsalesofcecspecificationqualifiedbulbs.thetieredincentivestructureisdesignedforthree mainpurposes: 4 P age

10 1. Toensurefairness,consistency,andtransparency. 2. Byprovidingthehighestincentivesforinitialbatchesofproducts,tosecureparticipationfrom thegreatestnumberofmanufacturers,whichwillensurethatthemarketispreparedforfuture codechangesinlinewiththececspec. 3. Byhavingthelowertiersallowforcontinuedsupportforhighvolumesamongthelarge manufacturers,toensurethatratepayersarenotoverlyburdenedinachievingresourcesavings. AnincentivecapwasplacedonALampstosupportmarkettransformationandmaintainprogram savingsgoals. PrimaryLightingProgram SDG&E During2017,SDG&E'sPrimaryLightingProgramworkedwithtenmanufacturersandsupporteddozens ofdifferentmodelsorconfigurationsofresidentiallightingproducts.participatingmanufacturers establishedandmaintainedongoingrelationshipswitharearetailerstosellqualifyingproducts identifiedbyspeciallogosorsignage. SDG&E'sPrimaryLightingProgramalsocontinuedtomodifythelistofproducts,eligiblerebatelevels, andretailersparticipatingintheprogram,toaccommodatechangingbaselinerequirementsandthe increasinglyefficientspecificationsofcecleds.sdg&eworkedwithmanufacturersprovidingcec Specificationlampsandwiththeiraffiliatedretailerstoproperlypositionthesenewproductsand effectivelypromotethemtocustomers. SDG&Ealsoworkedwithmanufacturerstopromoteefficientlightinginover200hardtoreach locations,suchassmallgrocerystores,drugstores,lowincomemarkets,andresaleshops.bydoingso, SDG&Eexpandedthereachofefficientlightingintonewavenuesandreachedcustomerswhomaynot typicallypurchaseefficientequipmentorshopatlargerretaillocations.thesehardtoreachmarket locationsallowedsdg&etogreatlyincreasethenumberofcustomersservedandtoprovidedeeper marketenergysavingsviaanincreasedprimarylightingprogrambudget. OtherResidentialMultifamilyDownstreamLightingActivities InadditiontoupstreamPrimaryLightingactivity,theIOUsalsooffereddownstreamprogramservicesto supporttheresidentialmultifamilysector. ResidentialMultifamilyDownstreamLightingActivitiesSCE In2017,approximately80%ofSCE'sMultifamilyEERebate(MFEER)Program'senergysavingswere achievedthroughimplementationoflightingmeasures.asaresultofthe2018lightingdispositions, Codes&Standards(C&S),andIndustryStandardPractice(ISP),theStatewideMultifamilyprogramsare expectedtohaveminimalenergysavingsclaims.thescemfeerprogramteamwillcontinuetowork towarddiversifyingitsmeasuremixbeyondlightingmeasures. ResidentialMultifamilyDownstreamLightingActivities PG&E InadditiontothePrimaryLightingProgram,whichhastypicallybeenfocusedonmanufacturers,high productvolumes,andproductquality,pg&ehasanumberofdownstreamanddirectinstallresidential programsthataddresslightingforindividualcustomers.theseincludethemultifamilyupgrade 5 P age

11 Program,theModerateIncomeDirectInstallProgram,theMobileandManufacturedHomesProgram, theenergyfitnessprogram,andtherisingsunprogram.manyoftheseprogramsserveahigh percentageofdisadvantaged,hardtoreach,orlowincomecustomers.installationoflowcost/nocost LEDmeasuresforthesecustomersyieldsimmediatesavingsandcustomersatisfaction.Thelighting measuresareoftenusedasa"gateway"tomoreextensiveinterventions,includinghvacmaintenance andductreplacementmeasures. ResidentialMultifamilyDownstreamLightingActivities SDG&E SDG&Eworkedwithathirdpartyimplementertoprovidelowcost/nocostlightingsolutionsforover 130multifamilypropertiesaroundtheSDG&Eserviceterritory.Manyofthesepropertieswerein disadvantagedcommunities,whichbenefitedfromthevariousinteriorandexteriorledretrofit combinationsofrecessedfixtures,wallmountedfixtures,commonarealighting,andotherled offerings. NonresidentialCustomandDeemedLightingActivities TheNonresidentialLightingProgrammayinvolvedeemedandcustomprojects,implementedbythe IOUsaswellasbyThirdPartyProgramimplementers. NonresidentialCustomandDeemedLightingProgram SCE ThreeSCEprogramsledSCE'snonresidentialprogramactivities:TheAgricultureDeemedIncentive Program,theSchoolEnergyEfficiencyProgram(SEEP),andtheIndustrialDeemedEnergyEfficiency Program.In2017,theseprogramsadoptedtheDesignLightsConsortium's(DLC)Technical RequirementstransitionfromVersion3.0toV4.0/4.1.Thischangeaffectedanumberofqualifying lightingproductsacrossalldownstreamledlightingmeasuresandinvolvedincreasedefficacy requirements. TheAgricultureDeemedIncentiveProgram(advertisedtocustomersas"EnergyEfficiency ExpressSolutions")offerseligibleagriculturalcustomersincentivesthatencouragecommon, standardizedeeequipmentretrofits.deemedretrofitmeasureshavefixedincentiveamounts permeasureunitandareintendedforprojectswithwelldefinedenergyanddemandsavings. TheSchoolsEnergyEfficiencyProgram(SEEP)bringsEEretrofitstopublicschooldistricts, privateschools,anduniversities.in2017,thisprogramintroducednewlightingtechnology measures,usingacostshareincentivedeliverystrategytoleverageproposition39(prop39) fundsandpositivelyimpactthesavingstoinvestmentratioofschoolsparticipatinginprop39. TheIndustrialDeemedEnergyEfficiencyProgram(advertisedtocustomersas"EnergyEfficiency ExpressSolutions")offerseligiblebusinesscustomersincentivesthatencouragecommon, standardizedeeequipmentretrofits.projectsaretypicallyidentifiedthroughutilityeeaudits, customercommunicationswithlocalscerepresentatives,scecontractors,and/orpartnerships withequipmentvendorsandtradeallies.thetopmeasuresinstalledin2017werevariable speeddrives(vsds)onpumpcontrolsandexteriorledlighting.exteriorlightingandsome pumpmeasureswereremovedfromthedownstreamprogram,effective12/31/2017,dueto CPUCdispositions,marketstudies,andindustrystandard(ISP)practicestudies. 6 P age

12 NonresidentialCustomandDeemedLightingProgram PG&E Toreinforcesupportforthemostefficaciousandinnovativeproducts,andtoimprovethecost effectivenessofitslightingofferings,pg&eupdatedtheincrementalmeasurecostsforitsledwork papersusingdatafromthecalifornialedworkpaperupdatestudy.pg&eisinvestigatingalternative calculationmethods,workingcollaborativelywiththestatewideteamandcommissionstaffforfuture workpaperupdates.pg&eisalsoworkingwiththedesignlightsconsortium(dlc)ontechnical specificationsthatencouragehigherefficacytosupportdeepersavings. NonresidentialCustomandDeemedLightingProgram SDG&E In2017,alldeemedlightingshiftedtoamidstreamdeliverychanneltomitigatethehighdemandfor lightingrebates.thechangeindeliverychannelwasalsodueinparttonumerouslightingstandard changes,asthemidstreamchannelallowsimmediateintegrationofnewrequirementsintothe program.thischannelworksdirectlythroughdistributorstobuydownthecostoflightingproducts, andtheincentiveispassedthroughtothecustomerintheformofadiscount.lightingrebateswerenot offeredintheprogramuntilthemidstreammodelwasfullydevelopedandlaunchedinaugust2017. MidstreamDistributorLightingProgramActivities TheIOUs'midstreamdistributorand/orpointofpurchaselightingprogramsofferedinnovativeprogram designconsistentwiththeintentofmarkettransformationbytargetinglightingdistributorsserving nonresidentiallightinginstallersandprojects. MidstreamPointofPurchase(MPOP)Program SCE In2017,theMidstreamPointofPurchase(MPOP)ProgramsurpasseditskWhandkWgoalsby38%and 46%,respectively.TheMPOPProgramprovidedpointofpurchaseincentivesonqualifiedLEDlighting productstoscenonresidentialcustomersthroughamidstreamdistributorchannel.thempopprogram exceededitsenergysavingsgoalsbyemployingkeystrategiesin2017togrowtheprogramanddrive results: SCEincreasedthenumberofparticipatingdistributorsintheprogramtomorethan60to expandtheprogram'sreachandtoprovidemoreoptionsforcustomerstoreceiveanincentive. SCEalsomadeprocessimprovementstokeyprocessesandeliminatedaninternalincentive allocationprocess,whichresultedindistributorsbeingabletoprovideincentivesonafirst come,firstservedbasis. Thesestrategies,alongwithproactivedistributorcommunicationandfollowup,allowedSCEtoexceed itsenergysavingsgoalsforthempopprogramin2017. MidstreamDistributorLightingProgram PG&E PG&E'sMidstreamDistributorLEDReplacementProgramgrewsmallerin2017ascomparedto2016. Withanearly50%reductioninincentivevaluesandincreasedproductspecifications(requiringENERGY STAR 2.0specificationlamps),theprogram'slampvolumedroppedtobelow150,000fromnearly 500,000in2016.Theprogramaccountedfornetenergysavingsofnearly5gWh.TheLEDscrewin lampreplacementcategoryhascontinuedtomaturerapidly,andthenewcodesandstandardsbaseline 7 P age

13 isexpectedtoresultintheretirementofalampsandsmalldiameterdirectionallampsbytheendof thesecondquarter(i.e.,june30,2018). MidstreamDistributorLightingProgram SDG&E TheSDG&EMidstreamDistributorLightingProgramwasfullydeployedinAugust2017.Themidstream channelworksdirectlythroughdistributorstobuydownthecostoflightingproducts.theincentiveis passedthroughtothecustomerintheformofadiscount.programparticipationin2017was significantlylessthanexpectedbecauseoftheprogramdeploymentdelay. LightingInnovation,DemonstrationandPilotActivities TheIOUs'LightingInnovationSubprogramevaluatesproductsorprogramapproachesthatarenewto themarketandthathavethepotentialofeventuallyenteringtheprimarylightingprogramor Commercial,IndustrialandAgriculturalprograms.LightingInnovationtrials,pilots,andstudiescollect dataonsales,installation,marketing,andotherbusinessaspectsofthelightingindustrytodetermine datadrivenrecommendationsandinfluencefutureprogramdesigns.showcasesandfieldplacement projectsareconductedwhenapplicable. NonresidentialAdvancedLightingControlSystem(ALCS)Pilot SCE In2017,SCEconcludeditsAdvancedLightingControlSystemPilotprogramwith31customersites participating.whenpossible,theimplementationteamcollectedbothpreandpostinstallationdata forenergysavingsandinstallationpractices.thegoalsofthispilotweretoassesstheeffectivenessof contractortrainingandcertificationonworkquality,andtodeterminetheeffectsoflightingcontrol systemsondeepenergysavings.giventhelimitednumberofparticipants,thispilotprogramwillreport itsfindingsusingacasestudyapproach.scehasengagedcadmusgrouptoconductthisexpostpilot assessment.afinalpilotstudyreportisexpectedbytheendofthesecondquarter,2018.sceisalso consideringthepossibilityofconductingafollowuppersistencystudytoinvestigatethedurabilityof energysavings,lightingcontrolimplementations,anduseracceptanceandsatisfaction. NonresidentialAdvancedLightingControlSystem(ALCS)ToolTrialProgram PG&E In2017,PG&EcontinuedwiththeimplementationandevaluationoftheAdvancedLightingControls (ALCS)ToolTrialProgram.TheToolisdesignedforusebylightingprofessionalsandlightingcontrol agentswhenassessingtheenergyanddemandsavingspotentialofpossiblecommerciallighting retrofits.theoverarchinggoalofthisstudyistoevaluatethetoolduringthecurrenttrialandprovide recommendationsthatwillsupportwidescaleuseofthetoolbyprogramstaffandimplementation contractors.in2017,tensiteswererecruitedtoparticipateinthetrial;sixsiteswillreceivepreand postmetering,andfoursiteswillnotbemetered.afinalreportisexpectedinthefourthquarter, EmergingTechnologyandMarketActivities SDG&E In2017,SDG&EtookanopportunitytopartnerwithPhilipstoprovide"SmartLED"PhilipsHue combo packsasapromotionwhencustomerspurchasednestthermostatsthroughtheplugloadand ApplianceProgram.Theintentwastopromotehomeautomationandsmartcontrolsthroughout houses.duringthecourseofthe2017programyear,sdg&econtinuedpresentingpopupretailevents operatedbyathirdpartyvendor.these"lightingfair"eventshaveproventobeahighlyeffective methodofreachinglargeaudienceswithspecialpromotionsthatencouragecustomerstopurchaseand 8 P age

14 9 P age installnewledlampsintheirhomes.hostedatpopularlocationswithheavyfoottraffic(homeand gardenshows,corporateearthdayevents,etc.),customersareofferedpacksofledandbr30lamps. SDG&EalsopartneredwithFEITElectricandAmazonintheFourthQuarterof2017toofferrebatedLED productsthroughansdg&especificpageontheamazonwebsite.thisactivityisexpectedtorelaunch in2018asanadditionalofferingchannel. LightingCodesandStandardsandQualitySpecificationActivities Thefollowingsubsectionssummarizekeylightingrelatedcodesandstandardsactivitiesforboth residentialandnonresidentialprojectsandinstallations. ResidentialLightingActivities Aspartofthe2019Title24,Part6updateprocess,theStatewideBuildingStandardsAdvocacyprogram teamsupportedin2017thecontinuationandrefinementoftherequirementsinjointappendix8(ja8), whichinformsthemandatoryresidentiallightingrequirementsintitle24.althoughresidentiallighting wasnotpartoftheformalcodesandstandardsenhancementreportdevelopmentforthiscodecycle,it isimportanttocontinuetosupporttheenergysavingspotentialconnectedtotherequirementsinthe 2016iterationoftheStandards. Tosupportcompliancewiththe2016standards,thecomplianceimprovementteamofferedtools, training,andresourcesthroughenergycodeacethataresimilartowhatisdescribedinthe nonresidentiallightingsectionabove.selectedofferingsinclude: Applicationguide:ResidentialLighting FactSheets: o ResidentialLighting o ResidentialHighEfficacyLightingforManufacturers o StateRegulatedLamps o Title20LightingFAQ o OverviewTitle24,Part6"What'sNew"and"What'sChanged"factsheetsforresidential andnonresidentialprojects Training o Title24Part6EssentialsStandards&TechnologyforResidentialLighting o Title24Part6EssentialsTest,Certify&Comply:California'sHighEfficacyLighting RequirementsforResidentialApplications. AworkplantofurthersupportcompliancewithJA8iscurrentlyinprogress. NonresidentialActivities In2017,theStatewideCodesandStandards(C&S)Programpreparedforupdateofthe2019Title24, Part6standardsdevelopment.TheC&Steamheldaseriesofstakeholdermeetingstoinformand engagestakeholders,gatherinput,andrefinethemeasurelistandspecifications.theprogram supportedtheenergycommission's2019rulemakingbydeveloping40buildingcodeproposalsthat wereincludedin23codesandstandardsenhancement(case)reports. The2019CASEreportsareavailableonlineat: mostsignificantlightingactivitiesincludedatransitiontowardlightingpowerdensities(lpds)tobe

15 10 P age basedonallledlightingsystems.thisactivityrepresentsthelargestenergyusereductionmeasure, accountingfor55%oftotalsavingsacrossthe23casereports.otherlightingtopicssupportedinclude AdvancedDaylightingDesign,IndoorLightingControls,OutdoorLightingSources,andOutdoorLighting Controls.SupportwasalsoprovidedtotheEnergyCommissiononcalculatingcosteffectivenessfor proposedchangestothelightingstandardalterations. Complianceimprovementeffortstosupportimplementersofthenonresidentiallightingcomponentsof Title24,Part6includedthedesignanddeploymentofmanytools,trainingofferings,andresources. Manyresourcesareofferedthroughhttp:// Selectedexamplesinclude: TheEnergyCodeAceIndoorLightingWheelisdesignedasaquickreferencetocheckwhether anindoorlightinginstallationinvariousareasofanonresidentialbuildingmeets2016title24 requirements,withouttheneedtodiveintothestandardslanguageitself.itcoversbothnew constructionandalterations.thispopularhandheldtoolmakescomplexinformationmore accessibletothosewhomustnavigatethestandardstosupporttheirwork. Newin2017,shortapplicationguidesincludecompliancerequirementsandrecommendations forimplementingtitle24innonresidentialandresidentialnewconstruction,additions,and renovationprojects.lightingfocusedguidesincludedresidentiallightingandnonresidential LightingandElectricalPowerDistribution. EnergyCodeAcefactsheetsprovide"quickreference"summariesofkeyrequirements,forms, definitions,andresourcesforimplementingtitle24andtitle20.fornonresidentiallighting theseinclude: o NonresidentialLightingControlsforCredit o NonresidentialLightingMandatoryControls o NonresidentialDaylightingandDaylightingControls,and o OverviewTitle24"What'sNew"and"What'sChanged"factsheetsforresidentialand nonresidentialprojects. Triggersheetsaretableformatquickreferencesofferingcomponentbycomponentsummaries ofsectionsoftitle24thataretriggeredbasedonprojectscope.lightingtopicsinclude: o NonresidentialExteriorLighting,and o NonresidentialInteriorLightingAlterations. Asuiteoffreetoolshasalsobeenupdatedandimprovedforthe2016Standards: o InstallationAce :Afieldguideprovidingphotosandtexttoassistinidentifyingproper installationtechniques o NavigatorAce :AstepbystepguidetotheTitle24complianceprocess o FormsAce :Awebbasedtoolthataidsindeterminingwhichcomplianceformsare applicabletoaspecificproject,and o ReferenceAce :Atoolthathelpsnavigatethestandardsusingkeywordsearch capabilities,hyperlinkedtables,andrelatedsections. CurrentlyavailableNonresidentialLightingtrainingcoursesinclude: o 2016Title24Part6EssentialsStandards&TechnologyforNonresidentialLighting

16 11 P age o 2016Title24Part6Essentials:NonresidentialStandards&TechnologyforIndoor LightingMandatoryMeasures o 2016Title24Part6Essentials:NonresidentialStandards&TechnologyforIndoor LightingPrescriptiveCompliance o Decoding2016Title24,Part6:Let'sTalkNonresidentialLighting,and o Decoding2016Forms:Let'sTalkabouttheNEWNRCCLTIE. ReachCodesforLocalGovernments Inadditiontostateandnationalbuildingcodes,theC&SProgramprovidestechnicalsupporttolocal governmentsthatwishtoadopt"reachcodes" ordinancesthatexceedstatewidetitle24minimum energyefficiencyrequirementsfornewbuildings,additions,oralterations.reachcodesupportforlocal governmentsincludes: ResearchandanalysistoestablishperformancelevelsandcosteffectivenessrelativetoTitle24 byclimatezone Draftingofmodelordinancetemplatestoencourageregionalconsistency Assistanceforcompletingandexpeditingtheapplicationprocessrequiredforapprovalbythe CEC,and Supportingimplementationonceeffective. TheReachCodes(RC)subprogramsupportslocalgovernmentsseekingtoestablishresidentialor commercialenergyconservationordinancesfornewconstructionandexistingbuildings.to improvereachcoderesourceaccessibility,thercsubprogramlaunchedthelocalenergycodes.com websitewhichcontainsallprogramstudies,aswellasmodelordinanceandresolutionlanguage whichjurisdictions'staffsmayusetofacilitatedraftingordinances. GeneralServiceLampRulemaking In2017,theApplianceStandardsAdvocacysubprogramsupportedtheadoptionofoneofthemost farreachingappliancestandardsinrecenttimes:aminimum45lumenperwattefficacystandardforall generalservicelamps(gsls)regardlessoftechnology,whichtookeffectincaliforniaforalllamps manufacturedafterjanuary1,2018.thistitle20standardeffectivelyphasesoutincandescentgeneral service"a"lamps.lifecyclesavingsareapproximately10,000gwhforgslsandanother2,000gwhfor smalldiameterdirectionallamps(sddls). TheNationalElectricManufacturerAssociation(NEMA)hadsuedforaninjunctionagainstCaliforniafor implementingthisstandardandalsoforsettinghigherstandardsforledgslsandsddls.innational ElectricManufacturerAssociation(NEMA)v.CaliforniaEnergyCommission(CEC),theUSDistrictCourt ruledinfavorofthecec,whichclearedthepathforthecectoenforcethegslstandard.asimilar standardistotakeeffectnationwidein2020.theexperienceoftheincandescentbanincaliforniawill bewatchedbyotherstatesandthefederalgovernment. Complianceimprovementeffortsin2017includedcontinuingworkthatstartedin2016,including preparingfortheeffectivedateofledreplacementlampstandards(gsls,alamps,sddls,andportable luminaires)andconductingassessmentstounderstandtheneedsofthelightingmarketforsuccessful implementationofthetitle20andtitle24lightingmeasures.

17 RelevantLightingStudiesandFindingsCompletedin2017 In2017,theCPUCandtheIOUscompletedmanyimportantstudies,including2015impactevaluation, marketcharacterization,andbaselinestudies.thesecompletedstudiesarepostedat thecpuc,andtheious.thesestudiesarecarefullyanalyzedbytheiouprogramteamsandare supportedbyresponsetorecommendations(rtr)activities.toreviewthesertrs,see CaliforniaLEDPricingAnalysis,byNavigantConsultingInc.(SCE ) Thepurposeofthisstudyistounderstandpricingtrendsinthelightemittingdiode(LED)lightingmarket andtheirimplicationsfortheious'programs.thestudywasdesignedaroundfivekeyresearch objectives: 1. CurrentLEDPricing:IdentifytherangeofcurrentpricesforDLCandENERGYSTAR qualified priorityledproducts. 2. CaliforniaIOUProgramDataandWebbasedPriceComparison:Assesstherelationship betweenonlineandcaliforniaiouprerebatedprices(providedbysceandpg&e)forhigh prioritynonresidentialledproducts,anddeterminehowthiscouldbeutilizedforforecasting purposes. 3. FactorsthatSignificantlyInfluenceLEDPrice:Conductamultiplevariableregressionto determinethecorrelationbetweenvariousproductspecificationsandprice,focusingonmetrics includinglumenoutput,efficacy,cct,cri,dimmability,dlcqualificationstatus,and manufacturer. 4. IncrementalCost:DevelopincrementalcostestimatesforpriorityLEDproductsrelativetotheir baselinetechnologies. 5. ProjectedLEDPricing:Determinehow,andatwhatrate,LEDpricerangesareanticipatedto changeasthemarketbecomesmoremature,lookingforward3yearsand5years.acrossall15 priorityproductcategories,thepriceofledproductsisexpectedtodecline39%from2017to 2022.Averagingacrossall15priorityproductcategories,theannualrateofdeclineis9%per yearfrom2017to2020,thendecreasestoanannualrateof8%from2020to2022. ImpactEvaluationof2015UpstreamandResidentialDownstreamLightingPrograms CaliforniaPublicUtilitiesCommission.ByKEMAInc.(CPU ) ThisreportpresentsanimpactevaluationoftheCaliforniaIOUs'2015upstreamandresidential downstreamlightingprograms.upstreamprogramstypicallyprovideincentivestomanufacturers(and insomecases,retailers)toencouragestockingofenergyefficienttechnologies,whiledownstream programstypicallyprovideincentivesdirectlytoutilitycustomers. GrossFindings: Exanteestimatesuseawattagereductionratio,whileexpostevaluationusesadifference betweentheaverageprogramwattageandtheaverageinstalledwattage.whereprogram lampshadloweraveragerebatedwattsinaspecificmeasuregroup(suchasledalamps), expostestimateswerehigherthanexanteestimatesandviceversa(suchashighwattage CFLs>30). 12 P age

18 SDG&E'sexanteassumptionsallocatedallupstreamlightingprogramlampstotheresidential sector.expostassumptionsallocated94%totheresidentialsectorand6%tothe nonresidentialsector. PG&E'sexanteinstallationrateforallCFLmeasuregroupswas67%andSCE'swas77%.The expostinstallationrateestimatewas95%forallious. NetFindings: BasicspiralCFLshavealowNettoGrossRatio(NTGR)forallIOUsaround30%.Grosssavings estimatesforthesemeasureswerealreadylow,sonetsavingsdroppedfurther. ThisfindingmeansthattheaveragelampdisplacedbyprogramLEDlampswasoflowerwattage thantheaverageofallinstalledlampsacrossallelectricioucustomers. CaliforniaResidentialReplacementLampMarketStatusReport:Upstreamlighting ProgramandMarketActivitiesinCaliforniathrough2015,byKEMAInc.(CPU ) ThisdocumentprovidesanupdateonCalifornia'srapidlychangingresidentialretaillampmarketasof 2015,includingsupplyanddemandsidemarketactivitiesaswellasUpstreamLightingProgram(ULP) activities. KeyFindings: 1. Atthenationallevel,theENERGYSTAR qualifiedcflmanufacturinglandscapehasdiminished whiletheledlampmanufacturinglandscapecontinuestoexpand.thistrendislikelytocontinue, giventhatforthcomingchangestotheenergystar standard(energystar 2.0)willincreasethe numberofledlampsthatqualifyandwillpotentiallyeliminatecfls.thesechangesalignedwith lampmanufacturers'outlookoncalifornialampsales:thesemanufacturersexpectcflsalesto declineandledlampsalestoincreaseoverthenextseveralyears. 2. Smallerretailchannelssuchasdiscount,drug,andgrocerymaynotsellENERGYSTAR CFLsorLED lampswithoutulpsupport.bigboxchannelsarelesslimitedintheirabilitytocontinuestocking ENERGYSTAR lamps. 3. ForlampsintheAlampreplacementcategory,thelowestcostoptionwithoutIOUdiscountsin both2014and2015wasthetraditionalincandescentalamp,followedbytheeisacompliant halogenlamp.whenioudiscountswereavailable,however,thelowestcostoptionshiftedto CFLs(basicspiralsin2014andAlampsin2015). 4. Theretailstockmixforresidentialreplacementlampscontinuestoshiftawayfrom incandescentlampsandtowardledlamps. 5. WhilethevastmajorityoflampsupplierrepresentativesclaimedthattheCECLEDlamp specificationcausednegativemarketeffectsforledlamps,somesupplierrepresentatives acknowledgedthatthespecificationpushedtechnologicaladvancementsandimprovedled lampquality.retailstockdatasuggestthatwithdiscounts,ledlampsthatmeetthecec specificationaretheleastcostledoptionavailable. 6. LampqualitywaslessofaconcernforconsumerswhohadnotpurchasedLEDlampsthanprice andlackoffamiliaritywiththetechnology.forcfls,however,qualityandperformancewere thechiefconcernsamongconsumerswhohadnotpurchasedcflsasof P age

19 7. AwarenessofLEDlampsamongCaliforniaconsumerswasonparwithCFLsin2015(85%each). PurchaseratesforLEDlampsremainedlow,however,asdidawarenessandpurchaseratesfor EISAcomplianthalogenlamps. 8. Asidefromenergysavings,pricewastheprimarymotivatoramongCFLpurchasersin2015and expectedusefullifewastheprimarymotivatoramongledlamppurchasers. ResidentialLightingForecastingAnalysis,byTRC(PGE ) Thiswhitepaperestimatespastresidentialelectricitylightinguse(from2012to2016)andforecasts residentialelectricitylightingusefrom2017to2018underdifferentscenariosoflightingtechnology penetrations.thepurposeistoinformpg&eforecasting,andtoestimateprogressandopportunities towardsmeetingthegoalofcaliforniaassemblybill(ab)1109toreduceresidentialelectricityuseby 50%from2007to2018. Findings: ThisanalysisfindsthatCaliforniahasmadesignificantprogresstowardsmeetingitsAB1109goals. From2007to2016,residentiallightingelectricityusedeclinedby33%,oranaveragereductionof4% peryear.whilethisisanimpressiveachievement,residentiallightingelectricityusemustdeclinean additional17%inthenexttwoyears(anaverageof8.5%annually)tomeettheab1109goal.trc developedfivescenariosofpossibleresidentiallightingelectricityusefor2017to2018,byvaryingthe penetrationoftechnologies(particularlybyvaryingtheincreaseinledadoption)forlamp replacements,andearlyretirementrates. Conclusions: Overall,residentiallightingelectricityusehasdeclinedsignificantly,butCaliforniamayfallslightlyshort ofmeetingitsab1109goals.whileupcomingrequirements particularlytitle20forgsls willpush themarkettowardsgreateruptakeofhighefficacylamps,utilityincentivesandeducationcanstillplaya role,particularlyfornongsls,after2018.inaddition,utilitycodesandstandardsprogramscan continuetosupportfederalorstatestandardsthatincreasetheenergyefficiencyrequirementsof residentiallightingproducts. EarlyEM&VofPacificGasandElectricCompany'sCommercialLEDT8Incentives,by EvergreenEconomics(PGE ) PG&EcontractedwithEvergreenEconomics(Evergreen)inNovemberof2016toconductearly evaluationresearchtoinformnumerousresearchobjectivesrelatedtothedeliveryofrebateprograms forcommercialledt8(ortled)linearreplacementlamps.sincethestartof2015,pg&ehasprovided LEDT8replacementlampsexclusivelythroughitsRegionalDirectInstall(DI)programs.TheDIprograms providereducedcostorfreeledt8replacementlampstosmallcommercialcustomerstoreplacetheir existinglinearfluorescentlamps.(thediprogramsalsooffernumerousotherlightingandnonlighting measureoptions).theprimary,overarchingobjectivesofthisresearchwere: 1. TounderstandparticipatingDIcustomers'decisionsinselectingLEDT8lampoptions,and 2. ToassessparticipatingDIcustomers'overallsatisfactionwithinstalledLEDT8lamps. 14 P age

20 Basedonthefindingsofthisresearch,evaluatorsfoundthatprovidingincentivesforLEDT8sthrough otherchannelsbesidesdiprogramsisinherentlyriskierintermsofcustomersatisfactionand technologypersistence,aswellasfreeridership,thanprovidingincentivessolelythroughthedi programs.simplyput,pg&ehaslesscontrolovertheprocess.however,diignorescustomerslarger than200kw,whichissignificant.aswitchto ortheadditionof otherincentivemechanismshas thepotentialtoincreaseoverallgrosssales,duetoincreasingthenumberoftargetcustomersandthus reducingthenumbersofthetargetedlinearfluorescentlamps. PacificGasandElectricCompanyLightingDesignAssistanceTrialStudyFinalReport: QualitativeLightingDesignSupplySideMarketAssessment,byOpinionDynamicInc. (PGE ) PG&ELightingDesignAssistanceTrialbeganinSeptember2015withthegoalofpromotingthe involvementoflightingdesignpractitioners(ldps)inlightingspecificretrofitprojects.afterafullyear ofimplementation,thetrialwasnotabletoattractmuchparticipation.giventhatthetrialfaced challengesgainingparticipationwithitsinitialdesign,thestudyfocusedonhelpingpg&edetermine whatdesignmodificationsmightbeneededtosuccessfullyreachandincentivizecustomerstoconsider comprehensivelightingdesign.itisimportanttonotethatthisstudydrawsfindingsfromarelatively smallnumberofinterviews. Accordingtothestudy,theincrementalcostsofacomprehensivelightingdesignquicklyoutpacethe benefits:uptothreetimesthecostforuptoa30%increaseinenergysavings.whiletriggeringtitle24 isasignificantproportionofthatcost,changingthetrialdesigntotargetcustomerswhowerealready completingacomprehensiveretrofitandencouragethemtogoabitfurtherstillmightnotachieve enoughincrementalsavingstomaketheincentivecosteffective.thisstudyhasalsoshownthatcertain typesofldps specifically,lightingcontractorsandenergyefficiencyconsultants maybehigher opportunitypartnersthanotherldptypesforidentifyingandencouragingcustomerstocompletemore comprehensiveretrofits.finally,thetrial'sprimarymarketingstrategyhasbeentorecruitldpsand encouragethemtopromotethetrialtocustomers.however,findingssuggestthatthismaynotbean idealstrategybecauseldpsoftendonotmarkettheirservicesandareworkingwithcustomerswhoare alreadyconsideringalightingdesign,asopposedtothetrial'stargetcustomers. CompilationofDatatoInformtheLEDAlampBaseline,byTRC(PGE ) Thiswhitepaperprovidesdataandanalysistoinformlightemittingdiode(LED)Alampbaseline assumptions,tosupportcaliforniaiouledalampworkpaperupdatesfor2017andbeyond. FINDINGS:Highlightsofresultsincludethefollowing: AfterremovingLEDs,CFLscompriselessthanhalfofpurchasedoravailableAlamps,withthe CaliforniasourcesshowingthatCFLscomprise34%to45%,basedontheLightTrackersales estimate,trcestimateofalampsales,andcaliforniashelfsurveyresults. Halogenscomprisethemajorityoftheremaininglampssoldoravailable,althoughincandescent lampspersist(comprising10%to18%ofalllampssoldoravailable,whenledsareincludedin theanalysis). 15 P age

21 ForAlampreplacements,LEDsgenerallyreplacedeitherCFLs(49%)orincandescentlamps (43%),withtheremainderreplacinghalogens(5%)orotherLEDs(2%). Foralllampreplacements,LEDsmoreoftenreplacedincandescentlamps(51%)followedby CFLs(30%),halogens(14%),andotherLEDs(5%). TheCaliforniaLightingandApplianceSaturationStudy(CLASS),2012,indicatedthatapproximately halfofinstalledalampswereincandescentandtheotherhalfcfls.afterremovingleds,for installedlamps,cflscompriseslightlymorethanhalf(57%)oflampsinnonresidentialbuildings. Thedatainanotherrelevantstudy,theCaliforniaCommercialSaturationStudy(CSS),wascollected in ,soitmaynotreflectthecurrentinstalledbase. CONCLUSIONS: Overall,thevariousdatasourcesindicatethatCFLsshouldcomprisenomorethanhalf(34%to51%)of theledalampbaselineforresidentialapplications,andslightlymorethanhalfofthebaselinefor nonresidentialapplications.therecentimpactevaluationof2015upstreamandresidential DownstreamLightingPrograms(DNVGL2017)foundthatapproximatelytwothirdsofLEDsare replacingfunctioninglamps.consequently,theledbaselinecouldbebasedonablendofsalesand availabilitydata(representingledsinstalledthroughreplaceonburnout),andtheinstalledlampdata (representingledsinstalledthroughearlyretirement). 2015NonresidentialESPICustomLightingImpactEvaluationandAppendices,byItron Inc.(CPU ) ThisreportdocumentstheactivitiesundertakenbytheNonresidentialDownstreamCustomLighting ImpactEvaluationofthe2015investorownedutilities'(IOU)energyefficiencyprograms.Theoverall goalofthisstudyistoaddresstheneedforexpostevaluationofcustommeasuresasoutlinedincpuc Decision concerningtheEfficiencySavingsandPerformanceIncentive(ESPI).Forthis evaluation,allnonresidentiallightingmeasuresthatarecustommeasures(i.e.,notdeemed)were considered.in2015,energysavingsfromnonresidentialdownstreamcustomlightingmeasures represented12%oftheoverallexantegrosskwhsavingsportfoliofortheprogramadministrators'(pa) energyefficiencyprograms,and8%ofoverallexantegrosskwsavings.basedonthestudygoal,the primaryresearchissuesforthisevaluationcenterarounddeterminingnetandgrossexpostimpacts: Theevaluationteamestimatedgrossrealizationrates(GRRs)thatwere84%,85%,and67%of reportedlifecyclekwhsavingsforpg&e,sce,andsdg&e,respectively. Expostnettogross(NTG)ratioswerealllessthanexanteclaimsforeachofthePAsat0.46, 0.54,and0.51forPG&E,SCE,andSDG&E,respectively. Theresultingnetlifecyclerealizationrates whichdifferfromthegrrsbecauseofdifferences betweenexpostandexantentgrs were58%,58%,and54%forpg&e,sce,andsdg&e, respectively. 2015NonresidentialESPIDeemedLightingImpactEvaluationandAppendices,byItron Inc.(CPU ) ThisreportdocumentstheactivitiesundertakenbytheNonresidentialDeemedLightingImpact Evaluationofthe2015IOUs'energyefficiencyprograms.Theoverallgoalofthisstudywastoperform 16 P age

22 animpactevaluationonspecificnonresidentialdeemedlightingmeasuresand/ormeasureparameters identifiedintheefficiencysavingsandperformanceincentive(espi)decision ScrewinanddownlightLEDswereanESPImeasureforPG&E,SCE,andSDG&E,andthe resultinglifecyclenetkwhrealizationrates(nrrs)were115%,128%,and134%,respectively. Foroccupancysensors anespimeasureforsceandsdg&e theresultingnrrswere75% and110%ofnetreportedlifecyclesavings,respectively. DelampingofexistingT12fixtureswasanESPImeasureforallthreePAsbutwasonlyrebatedby PG&EandSCE.TheresultingNRRswere104%and115%,respectively. ForLEDoutdoorarealightingandstreetlights,thestatewidelifecycleNRRswere86%and88%, respectively. 17 P age

23 BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA Order Instituting Rulemaking Concerning Energy Efficiency Rolling Portfolios, Policies, Programs, Evaluation, and Related Issues. R (Filed November 14, 2013) CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that, pursuant to the Commission s Rules of Practice and Procedure, I have this day served a true copy of PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY (U 39-M), SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY (U 902-M), AND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY S (U 338-E) STATEWIDE LIGHTING MARKET TRANSFORMATION REPORT on all parties identified on the attached service list(s) R Service was effected by one or more means indicated below: Transmitting the copies via to all parties who have provided an address. ALJ Julie A. Fitch CPUC 505 Van Ness Avenue San Francisco, CA ALJ Valerie Kao CPUC 505 Van Ness Avenue San Francisco, CA Executed June 1, 2018, at Rosemead, California. /s/ Irene Gutierrez Irene Gutierrez Legal Assistant SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY 2244 Walnut Grove Avenue Post Office Box 800 Rosemead, California 91770

24 Page 1 of 26 CPUC Home CALIFORNIA PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION Service Lists PROCEEDING: R CPUC - OIR CONCERNIN FILER: CPUC LIST NAME: LIST LAST CHANGED: MAY 22, 2018 Download the Comma-delimited File About Comma-delimited Files Back to Service Lists Index Parties ANGELA HACKER CARMELITA L. MILLER COUNTY OF SANTA BARBARA LEGAL COUNSEL THE GREENLINING INSTITUTE, CA FOR: COUNTY OF SANTA BARBARA, EMPOWER, CA FOR: THE GREENLINING INSTITUTE CHARLES CORMANY HOWARD CHOY EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR GEN. MGR., OFFICE OF SUSTAINABILITY EFFICIENCY FIRST CALIFORNIA (EF CA) COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, CA 00000, CA FOR: CALIFORNIA BUILDING PERFORMANCE FOR: SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA REGIONAL CONTRACTORS ASSOCIATION DBA EFFICIENCY ENERGY NETWORK (SCREN) FIRST CALIFORNIA (EF CA) HOWARD W. CHOY JONATHAN MCHUGH, PE GEN. MGR - OFFICE OF SUSTAINABILITY PRINCIPAL LOS ANGELES COUNTY ISD MCHUGH ENERGY CONSULTANTS INC, CA 00000, CA FOR: LOCAL GOVERNMENT SUSTAINABLE FOR: MCHUGH ENERGY CONSULTANTS, INC. ENERGY COALITION (LGSEC) [MCHUGH ENERGY] LARA ETTENSON PETER MILLER NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, CA 00000, CA 00000

25 Page 2 of 26 FOR: NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL (NRDC) FOR: NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL (NRDC) SEPHRA A. NINOW DONALD GILLIGAN ASSOC. DIR - REGULATORY AFFAIRS PRESIDENT CENTER FOR SUSTAINABLE ENERGY NATI'L ASSN. OF ENERGY SVC. COMPANIES 1615 M STREET, NW, CA WASHINGTON, DC FOR: CENTER FOR SUSTAINABLE ENERGY FOR: NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF ENERGY SERVICE COMPANIES (NAESCO) GREG MERRITT ROB FALKE CREE, INC. PRESIDENT 4600 SILICON DRIVE NATIONAL COMFORT INSTITUTE DURHAM, NC PO BOX 147 FOR: CREE, INC. AVON LAKE, OH FOR: NATIONAL COMFORT INSTITUTE KRISTIN ANDERSON JOHN WALSH PRESIDENT PRESIDENT OCCAM'S ENERGY CONSULTING, INC. GREENFAN, INC W 65TH STREET, SUITE BEAR CLAW LANE MINNEAPOLIS, MN BOZEMAN, MT FOR: APPLIANCE RECYCLING CENTERS OF FOR: GREENFAN, INC. AMERICA, INC. (ARCA) JUSTIN SEGALL JOHNNY PONG FOUNDER & EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT SENIOR COUNSEL SIMPLE ENERGY SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS COMPANY 1215 SPRUCE ST., STE WEST FIFTH STREET SUITE 1400 BOULDER, CO LOS ANGELES, CA FOR: SIMPLE ENERGY FOR: SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS COMPANY PAUL THOMAS DANIEL W. DOUGLASS SYZERGY, INC. ATTORNEY 4000 LONG BEACH BLVD., STE. 206 DOUGLASS & LIDDELL LONG BEACH, CA PARK GRANADA, SUITE 209 FOR: SYZERGY, INC. CALABASAS, CA FOR: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA; NEST LABS, INC. DANIEL W. DOUGLASS JANE LEE COLE ATTORNEY SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY DOUGLASS & LIDDELL 2244 WALNUT GROVE AVE PARK GRANADA, STE. 209 ROSEMEAD, CA CALABASAS, CA FOR: SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY FOR: NEST LABS, INC. JULIE WILEY FREDERICK M. ORTLIEB SPECIAL COUNSEL DEPUTY CITY ATTORNEY SAN DIEGO ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENTS CITY OF SAN DIEGO 401 B STREET, SUITE THIRD AVENUE, SUITE 1100 SAN DIEGO, CA SAN DIEGO, CA FOR: SAN DIEGO ASSOCIATION OF FOR: CITY OF SAN DIEGO GOVERNMENTS (SANDAG)

26 Page 3 of 26 THOMAS R. BRILL GEORGE ODERO SR COUNSEL & DIRECTOR ENERGYWISE ENG'RING & TECH. CONSULTING SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 3298 GOVERNOR DRIVE, STE CENTURTY PARK CT., CP32E SAN DIEGO, CA SAN DIEGO, CA FOR: ENERGYWISE ENGINEERING AND FOR: SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY TECHNICAL CONSULTING (EETC) ALEJANDRA TELLEZ TREVOR KEITH MGMT ANALYST, COUNTY EXEC OFFICE COUNTY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO COUNTY OF VENTURA 976 OSOS STREET 800 S. VICTORIA AVENUE, L-1940 SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA VENTURA, CA FOR: COUNTY OF SAN LUIS OBISPO FOR: THE COUNTY OF VENTURA MONA TIERNEY-LLOYD COURTNEY KALASHIAN SR. DIR., WESTERN REGULATORY AFFAIRS CP-CHAIR, RHTR ENERNOC, INC. SAN JOAQUIN VALLEY CLEAN ENERGY ORG. PO BOX NORTH FIRST STREET, SUITE 140 CAYUCOS, CA FRESNO, CA FOR: ENERNOC, INC. FOR: SAN JOAQUIN VALLEY CLEAN ENERGY ORGANIZATION (SJVCEO) ELISABETH B. RUSSELL STEVE SCHMIDT SPECIAL PROJECTS DIRECTOR HOME ENERGY ANALYTICS ASSOCIATION OF MONTEREY BAY AREA GOV'TS BYRD LN SILVER CLOUD COURT LOS ALTOS, CA MONTEREY, CA FOR: HOME ENERGY ANALYTICS (HEA) FOR: ASSOCIATION OF MONTEREY BAY AREA GOVERNMENTS (AMBAG) ABHAY GUPTA JORDANA CAMMARATA CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER FIRSTFUEL SOFTWARE BIDGELY, INC. ONE EMBARCADERO CENTER, SUITE SOUTH SUNNYVALE AVENUE, STE. 205 SAN FRANCISCO, CA SUNNYVALE, CA FOR: FIRSTFUEL SOFTWARE FOR: BIDGELY, INC. CHRISTOPHER CLAY JEANNE M. SOLE DEPUTY CITY ATTORNEY LEGAL DIVISION CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO ROOM DR. CARLTON B. GOODLETT PLACE, RM VAN NESS AVENUE SAN FRANCISCO, CA SAN FRANCISCO, CA FOR: CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO FOR: ORA HAYLEY GOODSON IVAN JIMENEZ STAFF ATTORNEY LEGAL FELLOW THE UTILITY REFORM NETWORK BRIGHTLINE DEFENSE PROJECT 785 MARKET ST., STE A HOWARD STREET SAN FRANCISCO, CA SAN FRANCISCO, CA FOR: THE UTILITY REFORM NETWORK (TURN) FOR: BRIGHTLINE DEFENSE PROJECT ANNETTE BEITEL ROSS NAKASONE

27 Page 4 of 26 CALIFORNIA TECHNICAL FORUM STAFF CALIF. POLICY ORGANIZER 2298 FULTON ST. BLUEGREEN ALLIANCE SAN FRANCISCO, CA MONTGOMERY ST., STE FOR: CALIOFRNIA TECHNICAL FORUM STAFF SAN FRANCISCO, CA (CAL TF) FOR: BLUEGREEN ALLIANCE DAN SUYEYASU EVELYN KAHL DIR ATTORNEY CODECYCLE LLC BUCHALTER, A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION 55 NEW MONTGOMERY, STE SECOND STREET, SUITE 1700 SAN FRANCISCO, CA SAN FRANCISCO, CA FOR: CODECYCLE LLC FOR: ENERGY PRODUCERS & USERS COALITION (EPUC) LARISSA KOEHLER NORA E. SHERIFF SENIOR ATTORNEY ATTORNEY ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND BUCHALTER, A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION 123 MISSION STREET, 28TH FLOOR 55 SECOND STREET, SUITE 1700 SAN FRANCISCO, CA SAN FRANCISCO, CA FOR: ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND FOR: CALIFORNIA LARGE ENERGY CONSUMERS ASSOCIATION (CLECA) TESSA CARLBERG F. JACKSON STODDARD COUNSEL ATTORNEY PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS, LLP 77 BEALE STREET, B30A ONE MARKET, SPEAR STREET TOWER SAN FRANCISCO, CA SAN FRANCISCO, CA FOR: PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY FOR: NEXANT, INC. MATTHEW O'KEEFE BRIAN CRAGG OPOWER ATTORNEY 680 FOLSOM ST., 3RD FL. GOODIN, MACBRIDE, SQUERI, DAY & LAMPREY SAN FRANCISCO, CA SANSOME STREET, SUITE 900 FOR: OPOWER SAN FRANCISCO, CA FOR: INDEPENDENT ENERGY PRODUCERS ASSOCIATION (IEPA) VIDHYA PRABHAKARAN BARBARA QUITTNER ATTORNEY PROGRAM ADMINISTRATION DAVIS WRIGHT TREMAINE LLP SYNERGY COMPANIES 505 MONTGOMERY STREET, SUITE SATELLITE STREET SAN FRANCISCO, CA HAYWARD, CA FOR: CLEARESULT CONSULTING INC. FOR: SYNERGY COMPANIES BARBARA QUITTNER ROBERT FRIED PROGRAM ADMNISTRATION ATKINSON, ANDELSON, LOYA, RUUD & ROMO SYNERGY COMPANIES 5075 HOPYARD ROAD, STE SATELLITE STREET PLEASANTON, CA HAYWARD, CA FOR: INSTITUTE OF HEARING AND AIR FOR: ENERGY EFFICIENCY INC. (EEI) CONDITIONING INDUSTRIES, INC. (IHACI) GERALD LAHR JERRY LAHR ENERGY PROGRAMS MGR. PROGRAM MANAGER ASSOCIATION OF BAY AREA GOVERNMENTS ABAG POWER 101 8TH ST. 101 EIGHT STREET